Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    JITENDRA THAKUR AND 18 ORS v. THE UNION OF INDIA AND 8 ORS

    Page No.# 1/11

    GAHC010043452021

    THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT

    (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

    Case No. : WP(C)/1681/2021

    JITENDRA THAKUR AND 18 ORS

    S/O. HRIDAYA THAKUR

    VILL. MILAN NAGAR

    P.O. AND P.S. GHILAMARA

    DIST. LAKHIMPUR

    ASSAM

    PIN-787053.

    2: PABITRA KONCH

    S/O. LT. DIBAKAR KONCH

    VILL. GOPALPUR

    P.O. AND P.S. GHILAMARA

    DIST. LAKHIMPUR

    ASSAM

    PIN-787053. ROLL NO.5107000900.

    3: UJJAL CHIRING

    S/O. DEVAKANTA CHIRING

    VILL. DHENUKHANA CHIRING

    P.O. BATAMARI

    P.S. GHILAMARA

    DIST. LAKHIMPUR

    ASSAM

    PIN-787053

    ROLL. NO.5102002132.

    4: PRANAB ROY

    S/O. JITENDRA NATH ROY

    VILL. HAKARTUP

    P.O. UDALGURI

    P.S. PATACHARKUCHI

    1

    DIST. BARPETA

    ASSAM

    PIN-781325

    ROLL. NO.5105010896.

    5: DHANANJOY NEUPANE

    S/O. TIL BAHADUR NEUPANE

    VILL. NO.3 RAYANG BALIJAN

    P.O. JONAI

    P.S. JONAI

    DIST. DHEMAJI

    ASSAM

    PIN-787060

    ROLL. NO.5105054431.

    6: LAL BAHADUR CHETRY

    S/O. RAM BAHADUR CHETRY

    VILL. DOLAGAON

    P.O. KHAGRABARI

    P.S. DHALIGAON

    DIST. CHIRANG

    ASSAM. PIN-783380

    ROLL NO.5105077872.

    7: PARAMANANDRA SARKAR

    S/O. DIGAM SARKAR

    VILL. KHARIGA DALAIGAON PT.II

    P.O. AND P.S. BONGAIGAON

    DIST. BONGAIGAON

    ASSAM

    PIN-783380

    ROLL NO.5105004792.

    8: ANUJ KUMAR SAH

    S/O. RAJKISHOR SAH

    VILL. GANDHIPATH

    RAJALI ROAD

    P.O. AND P.S. TINSUKIA

    DIST. TINSUKIA

    ASSAM

    PIN-786125

    ROLL. NO.5102001571.

    9: DEEPJYOTI CHUTIA

    S/O. NUMAL CHUTIA

    VILL. TULSHIBARI

    P.O. AND P.S. GOGAMUKH

    2

    DIST. DHEMAJI

    ASSAM. PIN-787034

    ROLL. NO.5107000254.

    10: HIRAMAN CHAUHAN

    S/O. RAMBHAVAN CHAUHAN

    VILL. KALAMSHING TISSOGAON

    P.O. SHYAMPATHAR

    P.S. BAKALIGHAT

    DIST. KARBIANGLONG

    ASSAM

    PIN-782482

    ROLL. NO.5105004329.

    11: BIKASH YADAV

    S/O. BIJOY SHANKAR YADAV

    VILL. TINGRAI BONGALIGAON

    P.O. AND P.S. MAKUM

    DIST. TINSUKIA

    ASSAM

    PIN-786170

    ROLL. NO.5102003810.

    12: SONTACH YADAV

    S/O. LALSAHEB YADAV

    VILL. CHANDMARI BONGALIGAON

    P.O. AND P.S. MAKUM

    DIST. TINSUKIA

    ASSAM

    PIN-786170

    ROLL. NO.5102004621.

    13: KRISHNA NATH

    S/O. MIMI NATH

    VILL. TULSHIBARI

    P.O. AND P.S. GOGAMUKH

    DIST. DHEMAJI

    ASSAM

    PIN-787034

    ROLL. NO.5107001280.

    14: RAJESH YADAV

    S/O. RADHESHYAM YADAV

    VILL. 11 NO. BAMUNGAON

    P.O. GABHERBHATI

    P.S. PHILDOBHARI

    DIST. TINSUKIA

    ASSAM

    3

    PIN-786160

    ROLL. NO.5102005303.

    15: KALYANJYOTI BORUAH

    S/O. SUBHAN BORUAH

    VILL. RAIDONGIA

    P.O. AND P.S. GHILAMARA

    DIST. LAKHIMPUR

    ASSAM

    PIN-787053

    ROLL. NO.5107002650

    16: RAJU MONI BORA

    S/O. KALIKANTA BORA

    VILL. DAYANGIALGAON

    P.O. JAGIBHAKATGAON

    P.S. JAGIROAD

    DIST. MORIGAON

    ASSAM

    PIN-782411

    ROLL NO. 5107003703.

    17: BIPUL KUMAR NATH

    S/O. LT. KRISHNA KANTA NATH

    VILL. HATIBAT

    P.O. NAGABANDA

    P.S. MIKIRBHETA

    DIST. MORIGAON

    ASSAM

    PIN-782106

    ROLL NO.5105070156.

    18: BIPLOB GOGOI

    S/O. TANKESWAR GOGOI

    VILL. LAWKUTH

    P.O. BATAMARI

    P.S. GHILAMARA

    DIST. LAKHIMPUR

    ASSAM

    PIN-787053

    ROLL NO.5105006881.

    19: RIKI RANJAN GOGOI

    S/O. AMBESWAR GOGOI

    VILL. LAWKUTH

    P.O. BATAMARI

    P.S. GHILAMARA

    DIST. LAKHIMPUR

    4

    ASSAM

    PIN-787053

    ROLL NO.5107008214.

    VERSUS

    THE UNION OF INDIA AND 8 ORS

    REP. BY THE SECRETARY OF MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS

    GOVT. OF INDIA

    NEW DELHI-01.

    2:THE STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION

    REP. BY THE CHAIRMAN

    BLOCK NO.12 CGO COMPLEX LODHI ROAD

    NEW DELHI

    03.

    3:THE REGIONAL DIRECTOR

    STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION

    GUWAHATI

    ASSAM

    HOUSE FED COMPLEX

    DISPUR

    GHY.-06.

    4:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL

    BORDER SECURITY FORCE

    BLOCK NO.10 CGO COMPLEX LODHI ROAD

    NEW DELHI

    03.

    5:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL

    SASHATRA SEEMA BALL

    5-6

    VIVEKANANDA MARG

    EAST BLOCK

    R.K. PURAM

    NEW DELHI

    22.

    6:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL

    CENTRAL RESERVE POLICE FORCE

    CGO COMPLEX LODHI ROAD

    NEW DELHI

    03.

    7:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL

    INDO TIBETAN BORDER POLICE

    5

    BLOCK NO. IV

    CGO COMPLEX LODHI ROAD

    NEW DELHI

    03.

    8:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL

    CENTRAL INDUSTRIAL SECURITY FORCE

    BLOCK NO.13 CGO COMPLEX LODHI ROAD

    NEW DELHI

    03.

    9:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL

    ASSAM RIFLES

    NONGRIMMAW

    LAITUMUKHRAH

    GORALINE

    SHILLONG

    MEGHALAYA

    11.

    ------------

    Advocate for : MR. R MAZUMDAR Advocate for : ASSTT.S.G.I. appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND 8 ORS

    BEFORE

    HON'BLE MR JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY

    For the petitioner : Mr. R. Mazumdar. Advocate.

    For the Respondents : Mr. S. K. Medhi.

    CGC.

    Date of Hearing : 07.06.2022 Date of Judgement : 07.06.2022

    JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)

    Heard Mr. R. Mazumdar learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. S. K. Medhi, learned CGC appearing for the Union of India.

    6

    2. Mr. R. Mazumdar, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner No. 2 wants to withdraw his name from this writ petition with a liberty to file afresh if so advised. Prayer is allowed. Accordingly, Registry to correct the same including in the CIS system.

    3. It is needless to say that the present decision shall not be applicable to the writ petitioner No. 2 as the said writ petitioner has withdrawn his name from the present writ petition with a liberty to approach this Court afresh

    4. The petitioners participated in a selection process for recruitment of Constable (GD) in Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), NIA & SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles. Such selection process was initiated by Staff Selection Commission by its advertisement dated 21.07.2018. The petitioners belongs to ST categories and from North Eastern Region, more particularly from Assam.

    5. The petitioners are aggrieved by non-inclusion of their names in the select list dtd.21.01.2021, published by the Staff Selection Commission.

    6. The selection test included Physical Standard Tests (PST), Physical Efficiency Test (PET), Written Examination. The grievance raised by the petitioners are that though they successfully came out in all segments without availing any individual and additional relaxation granted the selection process, their candidature had been rejected on the ground that they had taken benefit of relaxed standard as provided to SC/ST and OBC candidates.

    7. The background fact of the litigation can be summarized as under:

    (i) The Staff Selection Commission by Employment Notice dated 21.07.2018 sought application from intending illegible candidates for filling up 54953 numbers of vacancies for the post

    7

    of Constables (G.D) in Central Armed Police Forces (CAPFs), NIA & SSF and Rifleman (GD) in Assam Rifles (AR).

    (ii) The scheme of Examination, under Clause 9 (III) provides for required Physical standard. The said clause shows that for the General, SC & OBC candidates, the minimum height for male candidate is 170 cm and female candidate is 157 cm. In case of ST candidates, the same is declared to be 162.5 cm for male and 150 cm for female. A separate standard was provided for some States, including the State of Assam, which is 165 cm for male and 155 cm for female. The measurement of chest, a relaxed standard of 75.5 CM was provided for candidates belonging to some States, including State of Assam.

    (iii) Clause -10, which is the General Instructions and are required to be complied with by the candidates during the examinations. Clause 10 (xiii) provides that those SC, ST, OBC and Ex-Serviceman candidates, who are selected on their own merit without relaxed standards, along with candidates belonging to other communities, will not be adjusted against the reserved category vacancies and such candidate will be accommodated against the unreserved vacancies as per their position in the overall Merit List.

    (iv) Clause -10 (xiv) provides that those SC, ST, OBC and Ex- Serviceman candidates, who qualifies on the basis of relaxation i.e., age limit etc. are to be adjusted against the reserved vacancy.

    8

    8. The petitioners claims that they secured more marks than their respective General category candidates. However, they have been refused appointments on the ground that as they belong to reserved categories and availed relaxed standards, they cannot be appointed against vacancies meant for the General category candidates.

    9. As per the advertisement, separate standard in respect of northeastern regional candidates and SC/ST and OBC candidates were given. On the basis of such relaxed standard, the petitioners participated in the selection process.

    10. It is no more res integra that the state and its instrumentalities are within its jurisdiction and competence to prescribe relaxed standard for reserved category candidates, including on the basis of region. The relaxed standard in question as provided, are in respect of eligibility/qualifying standard, such as minimum measurement in heigh and chest. These are the eligibility criterias/qualifying standard without which, a candidate is not qualified to participate in the other tests such as computer Proficiency Test, Physical Test, Written Examination etc. And the marks are awarded on the basis of performance in the said tests and not on the basis of the qualifying standards. Therefore, the final determination of rank in the select list is based on the marks obtained in the tests and not on the basis of relaxed qualifying standard. Thus, participating in the aforesaid tests and obtaining the marks don't have any nexus with the relaxed standard, which is a general relaxation for all ST/SC candidates and candidate from North Eastern State.

    11. There is no dispute that the petitioners herein had scored higher marks then last General Category Candidates. The relaxation in standard was

    9

    general relaxation and not individual relaxation like date of birth. The petitioners herein competed with the General Category Candidates in the examination securing more marks then the General Category candidates.

    12. No concession was given in respect of marks in selection tests to the categories in question by giving relaxed qualifying standard in respect of height/Chest. Such relaxation had only enabled them to participate in the examination as special category candidates and they competed with general category candidates and secured more marks than last general category candidates. Therefore, the reserved category candidates, who obtained more marks than that of the last general category candidate secured, need to be considered against vacancy meant for general category candidates inasmuch as same is provided in the advertisement itself under clause 10 (iii).

    13. In a similar factual background, the Delhi High Court in Hemant Pokhriyal Vs- Staff Selection Commission and Ors. in WP(C) No. 4982/2021 and decided on 1stOctober, 2021, held that relaxation given in height or chest are available to candidates from a specific region, where the candidate belong to reserved or un-reserved category, cannot lead categorization of the candidates exclusively for SC, ST and OBC, ignoring their meritorious position amongst other category candidates. This Court is in Total agreement with such view of the Delhi High Court.

    14. The present petitioners, appeared in the same region with relaxed standard and faced the same selection process with other categories. Therefore, the relaxation in qualifying standards for their categories shall not disentitle them for consideration against reserved category vacancies, if

    10

    they have secured more marks then the General Category candidates.

    15. The learned counsel for respondent Union India has fairly submitted that they have already implemented the judgment of the Delhi High Court in

    Hemant Pokhrial (Supra).

    16. In the aforesaid backdrop, this writ petition is allowed. As posts were kept vacant under interim orders of this Court, it is directed that the respondent authorities should accommodate the petitioners, against those vacancies. While doing so, the respondent authority will verify the case of the petitioners herein and their marks and if they have obtained marks above the cut off mark of last general category candidates, as discussed herein above, they will be accommodated against those posts. The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of six weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order to be furnished by the petitioners.

    17. With the above decision, observation, reasons and direction, this writ petition is allowed. Parties to bear their own cost.

    JUDGE

    Comparing Assistant

    11

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    JITENDRA THAKUR AND 18 ORS v. THE UNION OF INDIA AND 8 ORS
    (Jun 7, 2022)