Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Tirthankar Ghosh, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This set of four appeals arises from prosecutions under Sections 489B and 489C of the Indian Penal Code, 1860. The appeals were heard together because the court had to examine the interpretation of the phrase "otherwise traffics in" in Section 489B vis-à-vis "possession" in Section 489C.

Briefly as to each appeal (facts taken from the opinion):

  • CRA 123/2019 with CRA 37 of 2019 (Suti PS case no. 431/17, dated 08.08.2017): Secret information led police to intercept three persons on 08.08.2017. Searches allegedly recovered counterfeit Indian currency notes (FICN) from each: 46 notes (Rs.2,000) from Anikul Islam; 30 notes (Rs.2,000) from Rafikul Islam; 24 notes (Rs.2,000) from Maharom Mandal. Trial court convicted all three under Sections 489B and 489C and sentenced them accordingly. Appellants challenged applicability of Sections 489B/489C and raised identification and expert-evidence issues.
  • CRA 189 of 2017 (Kaliachak PS case no. 365/14, dated 17.05.2014): Appellant, a CISF personnel posted at NTPC Farakka, was intercepted on a state highway and 100 FICN of Rs.500 denomination were seized. The trial court acquitted on Section 489B but convicted on Section 489C and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment and fine. The appellant contested application of Section 489B and relied on precedents to differentiate the State's authorities.
  • CRA 702 of 2018 (Raghunathganj PS case no. 744/15, dated 06.08.2015): From the appellant 49 notes of Rs.500 denomination were seized; expert (Ext.5) described them as "high quality counterfeit Indian currency". The opinion notes that the 2012 amendment to UAPA introduced "high quality counterfeit" as a concept relevant to terrorist acts, and asked whether any presumption for trafficking arises in such situations.
  • Other procedural posture: Each appeal involved contested questions about whether possession alone (or possession of a large volume / high-quality FICN / possession by security personnel) justifies treating the act as "trafficking" under Section 489B, and whether statutory or evidentiary presumptions apply.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the aid of a "presumption" is available when FICN is seized from the possession of an individual.
  2. If quantity/volume of FICN is a ground for a "presumption", what would be the cut-off number for presuming that possession was for the purpose of "otherwise traffics in"?
  3. When a substantial number of FICN are recovered from a security personnel (Police, CISF, Defence Forces, etc.), can it be presumed that the ingredients of "otherwise traffics in" under Section 489B IPC are automatically attracted?
  4. Does seizure from an individual of High Quality Counterfeit Notes (as per UAPA, 1967 / Third Schedule) opined by an expert automatically attract Section 489B IPC?

Arguments of the Parties

Arguments advanced on behalf of the State

  • The State relied principally on Division Bench authorities (specifically Jubeda Chitrakar v. State of West Bengal and Habibur Rahaman v. State of West Bengal) that have interpreted possession of a large volume of FICN, without explanation, as constituting "trafficking" or active transportation amounting to an offence under Section 489B. Extracts quoted show those courts found that large concealed or public carriage of FICN + failure to explain = trafficking.
  • The State emphasized similar principles in related authorities construing the object of Section 489B as to prevent circulation of forged notes, and thus treating certain forms of possession or movement as tantamount to trafficking.

Arguments advanced on behalf of the Appellants

  • The appellants contended Sections 489B and 489C were inapplicable in the respective facts of their cases and pressed that mere possession is insufficient: the prosecution must prove mens rea (knowledge or reason to believe the notes are counterfeit) to sustain conviction under Section 489B or 489C. They relied upon a set of precedents (including Umashankar, M. Mammutti, Jiban Sasmal, Sarvesh Pathak @ Kallu, Md. Morful Haque, Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia, Md. Tousif and others) that emphasize the mens rea requirement and that possession alone does not constitute trafficking.
  • Specific factual/contention points (CRA 123/37): failures of witnesses to recollect or identify accused, alleged deficiencies/incompleteness in the expert's deposition and report (PW10 / Ext.27 described as cryptic/sketchy), and the claim that ingredients of the offences were not proved beyond reasonable doubt.
  • The appellants sought to distinguish Jubeda Chitrakar and Habibur Rahaman on grounds that (a) earlier High Court and Supreme Court decisions of equal strength were not considered in those decisions; (b) charges did not allege concealed/dormant possession or active transportation; and (c) some authorities cited by the State were inapposite or misapplied (e.g., Parakh Foods Ltd. was a PFA context).
  • The appellant in CRA 189 (security personnel) argued his employment/status and the particular facts of seizure made automatic inference of trafficking inappropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court (as recorded in the opinion)
Jiban Sasmal v. The State Of West Bengal (1987 SCC OnLine Cal 114) Possession alone is insufficient for conviction under Section 489C; prosecution must prove intention to use as genuine. Cited by appellants; Court noted it as authority supporting the proposition that mere possession does not establish mens rea or trafficking.
Sarvesh Pathak @ Kallu v. State of West Bengal (2014 SCC OnLine Cal 18497) To make out an offence under Section 489B there must be material to show notes were actually used or trafficked (a transaction); mere possession may attract only Section 489C. Relied upon by appellants to argue possession ≠ trafficking; Court considered it among authorities showing a restrictive interpretation of "traffics in".
Chhotelal Thakur v. Union of India Discusses limits on reliance upon confessional/statements taken under statutory schemes (here Customs Act) and weakness of such evidence; emphasizes care in using such statements as sole foundation of guilt. Relied upon by parties; Court quoted it for the proposition that confessional statements under other statutes cannot be sole basis for conviction and for issues of corroboration.
Hoda Sk. v. State Of West Bengal Analyses the meaning of "otherwise traffics in" within object of Section 489B; refers to definition of "traffic" and emphasizes acts that would lead to circulation of counterfeit notes. Relied upon by appellants; Court treated it as an authority that sets out a purposive approach to Section 489B and a broad meaning of trafficking but in context of debate over scope.
Umashankar v. State of Chhattisgarh ((2001) 9 SCC 642) Affirms that mens rea ("knowing or having reason to believe") is essential for Sections 489B and 489C; mere possession without mens rea is insufficient; protections for unwary possessors. Relied upon by appellants; Court recorded it as a leading Supreme Court authority emphasizing mens rea and cited it in support of referring conflicting views to a Larger Bench.
M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka ((1979) 4 SCC 723) Holds that mere possession of counterfeit notes does not automatically justify presumption of knowledge; where nature of notes is not proved, conviction cannot be sustained. Relied upon by appellants; Court noted this precedent for the proposition that no presumption of mens rea may be drawn from mere possession absent proof of note-character or specific questioning.
Md. Morful Haque v. The State Of West Bengal (2017 SCC OnLine Cal 3380) Reiterates that mens rea is essential for Sections 489B/489C; possession or intention to use is insufficient without proof of knowledge. Relied upon by appellants; Court recorded it among authorities supporting the mens rea requirement.
Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia v. State Of Maharashtra (2018 SCC OnLine Bom 2969) Applies the principles in M. Mammutti and Umashankar to quash proceedings where prosecution failed to show knowledge of counterfeit nature; stressed that proceedings would be abuse if continued. Relied upon by appellants; Court noted it as a supporting High Court authority consistent with restrictive view on possession-based inferences.
Jubeda Chitrakar v. State of West Bengal (2019 SCC OnLine Cal 8924) Found that large concealed possession/transportation of FICN and failure to explain possession amounted to "active transportation" and trafficking under Section 489B; emphasized Section 106 (burden on person with special knowledge) where accused gave no explanation. Cited by the State; Court quoted the judgment and treated it as a contrasting authority that supports an expansive reading of "otherwise traffics in".
Habibur Rahaman v. State of West Bengal (CRA 277 of 2016) Held that carrying a large volume of FICN in a public place with no explanation establishes knowing trafficking; used to support convictions under Section 489B. Cited by the State; Court quoted and recorded it as another authority supporting the proposition that quantity + lack of explanation = trafficking.
Parakh Foods Ltd. v. State of Andhra Pradesh ((2008) 4 SCC 584) Decision in an unrelated statutory context (Prevention of Food Adulteration Act) relied upon by a bench in forming an analogy for "traffics". Mentioned in submissions: appellants argued that Parakh Foods was inaptly relied upon in Jubeda Chitrakar to interpret "traffics in". Court recorded this point of distinction by appellants.
Md. Tousif v. State of West Bengal (CRA 163/2019) Sets out that failure of prosecution to produce minimum evidence undermines application of Jubeda Chitrakar; emphasizes that factual differences can render Jubeda inapplicable. Relied upon by appellants to distinguish the Jubeda line; Court recorded it as authority showing factual limits to expansive inferences from possession.
K. Hasim v. State of Tamil Nadu ((2005) 1 SCC 237) Interprets object of Section 489B as stopping circulation of forged notes; informs meaning of "otherwise traffics in". Quoted in the opinion (via Hoda Sk. extract) as an authority showing purposive construction of Section 489B; Court noted its relevance in construing trafficking.
Noor Aga (2008) 16 SCC 417 Addresses the limited evidentiary value of statements under statutory schemes (customs) and cautions against over-reliance on such confessional statements. Quoted via Chhotelal Thakur to show limits on using statutory confessional statements as sole foundation; Court applied this principle in assessing evidentiary sufficiency questions.
Ponusamy v. State (1997 SCC (Cri) 217) Holds that silence of accused without explanation can be a telling circumstance and may weigh against him where FICN are found and no explanation is offered. Referred to by the Court as an authority where silence and lack of explanation supported conviction; used in contrast to authorities requiring mens rea.
Madan Raj Bhandari v. State of Rajasthan ((1969) 2 SCC 385 : AIR 1970 SC 436) Illustrates procedural concern that charging under a particular section (e.g., s.109) when the accused should have been charged under another may prejudice the accused. Cited within the Jiban Sasmal discussion to show procedural limits on convicting for different inchoate offences; Court recorded it as relevant to charging/pleading concerns.
Md. Mukhtarul / Md. Muktarul Islam @ Suman v. State of West Bengal (2014) 2 Cal LT 260 Affirms mens rea requirement; notes that no presumption as to mens rea can be drawn and factual conduct may be inconsistent with knowledge of forgery. Relied upon by appellants; Court recorded it as another authority consistent with the line that mens rea is essential and presumption is not automatic.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in a structured manner:

  1. Consolidation and comparative approach: Recognized the four appeals raise a common interpretive question: whether and when "possession" under Section 489C can be treated as "otherwise traffics in" under Section 489B.
  2. Fact-sensitive inquiry: The court laid out the material facts of each case (numbers of FICN seized; circumstances of seizure; identity/status of accused — including a CISF personnel in one appeal; and expert opinion in one appeal that notes were "high quality counterfeit").
  3. Survey of authorities: The court extensively reviewed divergent authorities. It recorded two distinct lines of decisions:
    • One line (exemplified by Jubeda Chitrakar, Habibur Rahaman, Ponusamy) treats unexplained possession of large volumes of FICN (particularly in a public place or concealed manner) as tantamount to trafficking, sometimes invoking Section 106/Evidence Act burdens where accused give no explanation.
    • The other line (exemplified by Umashankar, M. Mammutti, Jiban Sasmal and others) stresses that mens rea ("knowing or having reason to believe") is essential, and mere possession without proof of knowledge or other incriminating conduct is insufficient to sustain conviction under Sections 489B/489C.
  4. Specific evidentiary concerns: The court noted factual/contention points raised by appellants in particular appeals — e.g., non-identification by witnesses, unhelpful/exiguous expert testimony (PW10/Ext.27 described as cryptic), and failures to prove ingredients beyond reasonable doubt — and considered how these interact with the doctrinal dispute.
  5. Identified conflict and need for authoritative resolution: Observing that courts have taken inconsistent views on whether and when possession equates to trafficking, and given the practical implications (including cases involving security personnel and "high quality counterfeit" as defined under UAPA), the court concluded the issues are of sufficient importance and conflict to require reference to a Larger Bench.
  6. Formulated discrete questions: To assist the Larger Bench, the court framed four specific issues (see Legal Issues Presented) focused on presumptions, quantitative thresholds, special status of security personnel, and effect of expert opining high-quality counterfeit.
  7. Administrative disposition: The court directed that records of the identified appeals be placed before the Chief Justice for constitution of a Larger Bench to determine those questions and gave routine directions about acting on the server copy and providing certified copies on compliance with formalities.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The Court ordered that the records of CRA 37 of 2019 with CRA 123 of 2019; CRA 189 of 2017; and CRA 702 of 2018 be placed before the Chief Justice, Calcutta High Court for constitution of a Larger Bench to decide the identified issues concerning the interpretation of "otherwise traffics in" in Section 489B IPC and its relation to "possession" under Section 489C IPC.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The appeals are not finally decided on the merits by this Bench on the central interpretive questions; instead, they are referred for determination by a Larger Bench. Parties must act on the server copy of this judgment as the operative record and may obtain certified copies in the usual course.
  • No new substantive precedent was laid down by this Bench on the core question; rather, the Bench recognized conflicting precedents and sought resolution by a Larger Bench. The opinion expressly identifies and records the conflict in authorities and frames questions for authoritative resolution.
  • Practical legal questions flagged for the Larger Bench include the availability and scope of presumptions from possession, whether volume triggers a legal cut-off for inference of trafficking, the treatment of security personnel found with FICN, and the legal effect of expert opinions that seized notes qualify as "high quality counterfeit" under UAPA.

Administrative directions recorded in the opinion: parties to act on server copy; urgent Xerox certified copy to be provided on compliance with formalities.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    RIPON SK v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL

    Tirthankar Ghosh, J.:— The four appeals relate to cases registered under the provisions of Section 489B and 489C of the Penal Code, 1860. In course of hearing of these appeals the interpretation of the term ‘otherwise traffics in’ used in Section 489B of IPC vis-a-vis the word ‘possession’ used in Section 489C of IPC fell for consideration and as such all the four appeals were taken up together. The facts of each appeal are briefly set out initially and thereafter the issues raised by the appellants and the State have been considered.

    In Re : CRA 123/2019 with CRA 37 of 2019.

    2. The facts of the case relate to Suti Police Station case no. 431/17 dated 08.08.2017 under Sections 489B/489C of the Penal Code, 1860 which was initiated on the basis of a complaint lodged with the Officer-in-charge, Suti Police Station by Ram Prasad Haldar, Inspector of Police attached to the same police station. It has been alleged that on 08.08.2017 at 15.45 hrs., a secret information was received that three persons are loitering at Chander More at the side of NH 34 for exchanging huge amount of forged currency notes. The said information was diarized and a team was formed which arrived at about 16.15 hrs. The three persons were intercepted and were searched. On search from the three persons fake Indian currency notes were recovered which were as follows:

    i) From the possession of Anikul Islam - 46 number of fake Indian currency of Rs. 2,000/- denomination,

    ii) From the possession of Rafikul Islam - 30 number of fake Indian currency of Rs. 2,000/- denomination,

    iii) From the possession of Maharom Mandal - 24 number of fake Indian currency of Rs. 2,000/- denomination were recovered.

    3. The learned trial Court on completion of investigation of the case and after hearing the final argument was pleased to convict the three appellants under Section 489B/489C of the Penal Code, 1860 and sentenced them to suffer five years rigorous imprisonment and fine of Rs. 10,000/- in default rigorous imprisonment for 6 months for the offence under Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 and rigorous imprisonment for three years and fine of Rs. 5,000/- in default rigorous imprisonment for three months for the offence under Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860.

    4. Mr. Sourav Chatterjee learned Advocate appeared for the appellant in CRA 37 of 2019 and Mr. Tapan Dutta Gupta learned Advocate appeared for the appellants in CRA 123 of 2019. Both the learned Advocates contended in the same tune regarding the non-applicability of the provisions of Section 489B and 489C of the Penal Code, 1860.

    5. Mr. Chatterjee learned advocate filed written notes of argument in order to buttress the contention of the State (which will be dealt with later) relating to the applicability of Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 and drew the attention of the Court to the following factual circumstances:

    (a) The complainant, Sub-Inspector of police Ram Prasad Halder during his examination-in-chief could not recollect the name of the 2 independent witness available at the time of recovery.

    (b) The two independent witnesses of search and seizure being the prosecution witness no. 4 and 5 could not recollect the name of the accused and also could not identify the appellant in Court.

    (c) The Expert (PW10) who examined the FICN and produced his report being Ext.27 during trial, in his deposition was completely silent regarding what was examined by him, the nature and extent of examination and the process followed in respect thereof. The opinion of the Expert is cryptic, sketchy and as such unreliable. (d) The ingredients of the offence punishable under Section 489B and 489C of the Penal Code, 1860 were not proved beyond reasonable doubt.

    6. The precedents in support of acquittal relied upon by the appellants are:

    • Jiban Sasmal v. The State Of West Bengal, 1987 SCC OnLine Cal 114;

    • Sarvesh Pathak @ Kallu v. Sate of West Bengal, 2014 SCC OnLine Cal 18497;

    • Chhotelal Thakur v. Union Of India 2149;

    • Hoda Sk. v. State Of West Bengal 1478;

    • Umashankar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2001) 9 SCC 642;

    • M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka ., (1979) 4 SCC 723;

    • Md. Morful Haque v. The State Of West Bengal, 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 3380;

    • Sanskrit Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia v. State Of Maharashtra, 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 2969.

    7. Learned Advocate also contested the decisions cited on behalf of the State of West Bengal being Jubeda Chitrakar v. State of West Bengal reported in 2019 SCC OnLine Cal 8924 and Habibur Rahaman v. State of West Bengal an unreported judgment which was delivered on 24.02.2022 in CRA 277 of 2016. The arguments advanced for distinguishing the judgments relied upon by the State would be dealt with subsequently.

    In Re : CRA 189 of 2017

    8. The present appeal arose out of judgment and order of conviction dated 30.01.2017 passed by the learned Additional District & Sessions Judge, 4 Court, Malda in connection with the Sessions Trial No. 55(11)14 wherein the appellant was convicted only under Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860.

    9. The genesis of the case relates to Kaliachak Police Station case no. 365/14 dated 17.05.2014 under Section 489B/489C of the Penal Code, 1860. The case was registered pursuant to a complaint lodged with the Inspector-in-charge Kaliachak Police Station by ASI Ram Chandra Saha of the said police station. The peculiarity of this case is that the appellant/accused is a CISF Police personnel posted at NTPC Ltd. Farakka, district Murshidabad. The complainant alleged that on 17.05.14 at about 15.45 hrs. he received an information that a person was coming towards Kaliachak, Chowrangee from Silampur and was carrying good amount of fake Indian currency notes. The information was diarized and after being informed to the Inspector-in-charge, a team of police personnel were formed and the seizure was carried out at 17.45 hrs. and from the appellant 100 number of fake Indian currency notes of Rs. 500/- denomination were seized. The place of seizure was a State Highway.

    10. In this case the learned trial Court on an appreciation of the materials placed by the prosecution was pleased to acquit the accused/appellant under the charges of Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860, however, he was convicted under Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860 and sentenced to suffer rigorous imprisonment for five years and to a fine of Rs. 5,000/- in default rigorous imprisonment for six months.

    11. Mr. Sabyasachi Banerjee learned Advocate appearing for the appellant submitted that there is no scope for applicability of the Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 in the instant case as prayed for the by the State for issuance of rule as the learned trial Court acquitted the appellant under Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860. However, while contesting the issues relating to Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 learned Advocate relied upon the following precedents for distinguishing the two Division Bench judgments (referred to earlier) and relied upon by the State.

    12. The precedents so relied upon are:

    • M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka ., (1979) 4 SCC 723;

    • Umashankar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2001) 9 SCC 642;

    • Md. Morful Haque v. The State Of West Bengal, 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 3380;

    • Habibur Rahaman v. State of West Bengal in CRA 277 of 2016;

    • Hoda Sk. v. State Of West Bengal 1478;

    • Md. Muktarul Islam @ Suman v. State of West Bengal;

    • Md. Tousif v. State of West Bengal in CRA 163/2019;

    • Chhotelal Thakur v. Union Of India 2149.

    In Re : CRA 702 of 2018

    13. This appeal has been preferred against judgment and order of conviction dated 06.12.2018 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 1 Court, Jangipur, Murshidabad in Sessions Trial No. 03(01)2016 arising out of Sessions Case no. 286/2015 wherein the appellant was convicted under Section 489B/489C of the Penal Code, 1860. The genesis of the case relates to Raghunathganj Police Station case no. 744/15 dated 06.08.2015 under Section 489B/489C of the Penal Code, 1860. The said case was registered on the basis of a complaint by Sourav Mojumdar, SI of police of Raghunathganj police station where he alleged that from the appellant 49 number of fake Indian currency notes of Rs. 500/- denomination were seized at Jangipur Bridge near Jangipur side staircase. The police team had to chase and intercept the appellant and the fake currency were recovered from his left side trouser pocket. The learned trial Court was pleased to convict the appellant/accused at the end of the trial and sentenced him to suffer rigorous imprisonment of five years and fine of Rs. 20,000/- in default simple imprisonment for one year for the offence under Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 and rigorous imprisonment for three years for the offence under Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860.

    14. Although, the conviction was under Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 for different reason but Ext.5 which is the report prepared by the Expert of BRBNM Pvt. Ltd. Salboni which reflects that the fake Indian currency notes which were seized from the appellant were described to be ‘high quality counterfeit Indian currency’. Section 15 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 defines terrorist acts. Sub-section (1)(a)(iiia) of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 is set out as follows:

    “S.15. Terrorist act.- (1) Whoever does any act with intent to threaten or likely to threaten the unity, integrity, security [economic security] or sovereignty of India or with intent to strike terror or likely to strike terror in the people or any section of the people in India or in any foreign country,-

    (ii) …..

    (iii) …..

    (iiia) damage to, the monetary stability of India by way of production or smuggling or circulation of high quality counterfeit Indian paper currency, coin or of any other material;

    (iv) …..

    (b) ……..

    commits a terrorist act.

    Explanation- For the purpose of this sub-section, -

    (b) “high quality counterfeit Indian currency’ means the counterfeit currency as may be declared after examination by an authorised or notified forensic authority that such currency imitates or compromises with the key security features as specified in the Third Schedule.”

    15. For convenience the ‘Third Schedule is set out as follows:

    “[THE THIRD SCHEDULE

    [See clause (b) of Explanation to section 15(1)]

    SECURITY FEATURES TO DEFINE HIGH QUALITY COUNTERFEIT

    INDIAN CURRENCY NOTES

    Watermark(s), Security thread and any one of the following features:

    (a) Latent image;

    (b) See through registration;

    (c) Print quality sharpness;

    (d) Raised effect’

    (e) Fluorescent characteristics;

    (f) Substrate quality;

    (g) Paper taggant;

    (h) Colour shift effect in OVI;

    (i) Colour shift effect in security thread.]”

    16. The amendments were incorporated by the 2012 Amendment Act. The present case was registered on 6 August, 2015, naturally the question arose whether there should be any presumption in the present case for trafficking.

    Submissions on behalf of the State:

    17. On behalf of the State Mr. Partha Pratim Das learned advocate appearing in CRA 123 of 2019 and CRA 37 of 2019 at the very inception drew the attention of this Court to two judgments of Division Bench relating to the term ‘trafficking’, its interpretation as used in Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860.

    18. Learned advocate drew the attention of this Court to Jubeda Chitrakar v. State of West Bengal reported in 2019 SCC OnLine Cal 8924 and relied upon paragraph 15 which is set out as follows:

    “15. Adverting to the material evidence on record and the findings of the court below, it can be seen that the raid, interception and recovery were on the basis of secret information, the reception of which, and the modality of the raid and recovery have been noticed by us. 500 pieces of 100 rupees denomination FICN, 7 pieces of 1000 rupees denomination FICN and 9 pieces of 500 rupees denomination FICN wrapped in a newspaper and kept in a polly bag were recovered from Mokaram Mondal (one of the accused). Sunil Pramanick (one of the appellants) was also searched and 27 pieces of 500 rupees denomination FICN were recovered. Jubeda Chitrakar (one of the appellants) whose house was also raided led to recovery of 20 pieces of 500 rupees denomination FICN and 5 pieces of 1000 rupees denomination FICN. Thereupon, Jubeda was arrested. Again search and seizure was conducted leading to recovery of FICN from different other accused persons who are not amongst the appellants. They were also convicted. The appellants did not offer any explanation when questioned under Section 313 Cr.P.C. regarding the possession of FICN. Nor was any evidence adduced in defense to explain the possession of FICN. Section 106 of the Evidence Act enjoins that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person, the burden of proving the fact is upon him. In terms of Section 106 of the Evidence Act the burden of proof of facts within the knowledge of the appellants regarding the nature of possession of FICN was not discharged. Hence, the possession of such large quantity of FICN in concealed manner is not dormant possession but active transportation amounting to trafficking. It amounts to commission of offences punishable under Section 489B of the IPC. The possession of FICN of such quantity is trafficking, and, therefore, falling under the incriminating activity which made the accused/appellants offenders punishable under Section 489B as well, apart from the liability for committing offences punishable under Section 489C. For the aforesaid reasons the conviction of the appellants under Sections 489B as well as 489C stands. We approve the findings of the court below on the issue that the accused persons are liable to be convicted under Sections 489B and 489C of the IPC. Accordingly, we affirm the finding of guilt and the conviction of the appellants by the court below.”

    19. Learned advocate also drew the attention of this Court to Habibur Rahaman v. State of West Bengal in CRA 277 of 2016 and emphasis was made on internal page 8 of the said judgment which is set out as follows:

    “Lastly, it is argued ingredients of offence under section 489B IPC have not been proved. Prosecution evidence clearly shows that the appellant and the co-accused was apprehended in front of a tailor shop while carry counterfeit currency notes totaling to Rs. 10 lakhs. When the appellant was found carrying a large volume of FICNs in a public place and he is unable to give any explanation for the said possession, one can safely held the appellant was knowingly trafficking in counterfeit currency notes. Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 makes selling, buying, receiving or trafficking in counterfeit currency notes culpable. In this regard, it may be apposite to refer to the charge framed against the appellant under section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 which reads as follows:— “that you on 4.11.2014 at township More on NH 34, under Baisnabnagar PS Dist Malda attempted to use/traffic forged or counterfeit Indian currency notes of Rs. 9,76,000/- of denomination of Rs. 1,000/- each (976 pieces) and Rs. 24,000/- of denomination of Rs. 500/- each (48 pieces) and totalling Rs. 10,00,000/- knowing the same to be counterfeit and as per seizure list dated 4.11.2014, a copy of which was served to you, knowing the same to be forged or counterfeit.” Plain reading of the aforesaid charge shows the prosecution had put the appellant on notice that he was being accused of “attempt to sell/trafficking” in counterfeit notes. As discussed above, evidence on record unequivocally shows the appellant and co-accused were apprehended while carrying a large volume of counterfeit notes in a public place. Thus, transportation of counterfeit notes by the appellant is clearly established.”

    Submissions on behalf of the appellants in respect of the issue raised by the State:

    20. Mr. Sourav Chatterjee learned advocate appearing for the appellant in CRA 37 of 2019 and Mr. Sabyasachi Banerjee learned advocate appearing in CRA 189 of 2017 resisted the contentions advanced by the State. Both the learned advocates strenuously argued for rebutting the version of the State and distinguished the two judgments regarding the interpretation of ‘trafficking’ or ‘otherwise traffics in’.

    21. Mr. Sourav Chatterjee learned advocate appearing for the appellant in CRA 37 of 2019 argued that the decision of Jubeda Chitrakar (supra) cited by the State is distinguishable for the reason that the existing decision of Benches of equal strength passed by this Hon'ble Court as well as the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Umashankar (supra) were not considered while delivering such decision. Moreover, no charge was framed against the appellant to the effect that the possession of large quantity of FICN was in a concealed manner and was not dormant possession to show active transportation which amounted to trafficking. Further the meaning and purport of the expression ‘traffics’ so arrived at was by referring to Parakh Foods Ltd. v. State of Andhra Pradesh reported in (2008) 4 SCC 584, which is a decision relating to Prevention of Food Adulteration Act. Learned advocate also distinguished the case of Habibur Rahaman v. State of West Bengal (supra) by submitting that the earlier judgments of this Hon'ble High Court as well as the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Umashankar (supra) and M. Mammutti (supra) were never considered.

    22. Mr. Sabyasachi Banerjee learned Advocate appearing for the appellant in CRA 189 of 2017 distinguished the judgments of Jubeda Chitrakar (supra) by referring to CRA 163 of 2019 in Md. Tousif v. State of West Bengal wherein it was held that as the prosecution failed to produce the minimum evidence in support of the charge, the fact and circumstances of the case completely differed and as such the precedent laid down in Jubeda Chitrakar (supra) was not acceptable. The judgment in Habibur Rahaman's case (supra) was distinguished by the learned advocate for the appellant by referring to Umashankar (supra) and it was submitted that the Court while delivering the said judgment did not take into consideration the requisite mens rea and gave undue importance to the charge of trafficking in counterfeit notes against the appellant and upheld his conviction.

    23. Both the learned advocates for the appellants relied upon the following judgments for advancing their contentions in respect of the acquittal as well as the in-applicability of Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860. Relevant paragraphs so relied upon in respect of each of the judgments are accordingly dealt with.

    24. Attention of the Court was drawn to paragraph 9 of Jiban Sasmal v. The State Of West Bengal, 1987 SCC OnLine Cal 114

    “9. Although it is in evidence led on behalf of the prosecution that five currency notes were recovered from the possession of the present app ellant but mere possession of those counterfeit currency notes will not be sufficient to uphold the charge framed against the appellant under s. 489C and, as such, the conviction thereunder cannot be sustained in as much as from a plain reading of the said Section, it is clear that m ere possession of any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank not es, knowing or having reason to believe the same to be so will not be sufficient inasmuch as the Section itself provides that possession occup ied with intention to use the same as genuine is required to be satisfied before a conviction can be upheld under s. 489C. In the charge fram ed against the appellant under the said section, it has been stated tha t under s. 489C, he had in his possession five currency notes of ten rupee denomination, full particulars whereof had been given, together with the charge that he intended to use the same as genuine, whereas from an analysis of the evidence led for and on behalf of the prosecution, it is clear that it does not support such charge inasmuch as all the five counterfeit currency notes were no doubt found in his possession but there is no evidence that he intended to use the same as genuine.

    15. In the facts and circumstances of the present case, it appears that the conviction of the appellant, Jiban Sasmal, cannot be upheld both under ss. 489B and 489C of the Penal Code, 1860. It is true that under s. 116 of the Penal Code, 1860 abetment of offence is punishable with imprisonment even if the offence is not committed. But, in view of the fact that the appellant, Jiban Sasmal, has been charged under s. 109 of the Penal Code, 1860 and not under s. 116 of the said Code, he cannot be held guilty in the present case. In the judgment in the case of Madan Raj Bhandari v. State of Rajasthan, reported in (1969) 2 SCC 385 : AIR 1970 SC 436. It was held that the accused was charged under s. 314 read with s. 109, Penal Code, 1860 and be was notified that he would only be tried for an offence of having abetted and throughout the trial the accused was asked to defend himself against the charge on which he was tried. The conviction for abetting was held not to be proper on the ground that the accused was likely to have been prejudiced by such charge. In the facts and circumstances of this case, when the accused-appellant was only found in possession of the five counterfeit currency notes but no evidence having been led on behalf of the prosecution that he was intending to use the same as genuine, this Court is not inclined to convict the appellant under s. 116, Penal Code, 1860.”

    25. Reliance was placed on the following passage of Sarvesh Pathak @ Kallu v. Sate of West Bengal, 2014 SCC OnLine Cal 18497:

    “Therefore, if anybody possesses fake currency notes intending to use the same as genuine, he will only be liable for an offence under section 489C IPC and in order to make out an offence punishable under section 489B IPC, there must be some material to show that those fake notes were actually used or trafficked meaning thereby there was a transaction involving those forged notes.”

    26. Reference was made to the following paragraphs of Chhotelal Thakur v. Union Of India 2149:

    “26. On the other hand as the view expressed in the case of Noor Aga, (2008) 16 SCC 417, has been approved by the larger bench it would be apposite to take into account the following paragraphs:—

    “83. There is another aspect of the matter which cannot also be lost sight of. A search and seizure or an arrest made for the purpose of proceeding against a person under the Act cannot be different only because in one case the authority was appointed under the Customs Act and in the other under another Act. What is relevant is the purpose for which such arrest or search and seizure is made and investigation is carried out. The law applicable in this behalf must be certain and uniform.

    84. Even otherwise Section 138B of the 1962 Act must be read as a provision containing certain important features, namely:

    (a) There should be in the first instance statement made and signed by a person before a competent customs official.

    (b) It must have been made during the course of enquiry and proceedings under the Customs Act.

    Only when these things are established, would a statement made by an accused become relevant in a prosecution under the Act. Only then, it can be used for the purpose of proving the truth of the facts contained therein. It deals with another category of case which provides for a further clarification. Clause (a) of sub-section (1) of Section 138B deals with one type of persons and clause (b) deals with another. The Legislature might have in mind its experience that sometimes witnesses do not support the prosecution case, as for example panch witnesses, and only in such an event an additional opportunity is afforded to the prosecution to criticize the said witness and to invite a finding from the court not to rely on the assurance of the court on the basis of the statement recorded by the Customs Department and for that purpose it is envisaged that a person may be such whose statement was recorded, but while he was examined before the court, it arrived at an opinion that his statement should be admitted in evidence in the interest of justice which was evidently to make that situation and to confirm the witness who is the author of such statement, but does not support the prosecution although he made a statement in terms of Section 108 of the Customs Act. We are not concerned with such category of witnesses. The confessional statement of an accused, therefore, cannot be made use of in any manner under Section 138B of the Customs Act. Even otherwise such an evidence is considered to be of weak nature.”

    27. On an appreciation of the settled position of law, keeping in mind the background of the present case which is presently an appeal against conviction for commission of offence under Section 489B and 489C of the IPC, the following issue emerge that whether the confessional statement of the accused persons can be made foundation of their guilt. Needless to state that it is only in the statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act of the three appellants it is found that one Rahul @ Ikram @Ikramul of village-Mojumpur, P.O.- Harchi, P.S.- Kaliachak, District-Malda was the person who obtained the notes from Bangladesh and handed over the same in presence of Chhotelal to Umesh Sha and Maya Devi.

    28. Throughout the evidence there is no corroboration by any prosecution witness in respect of such evidence and there is neither any other documentary evidence to substantiate the same. Further no materials relating to such fact was brought in evidence by the prosecution and surprisingly the petition of complaint also did not implicate the said Rahul @ Ikram @ Ikramul as an accused. The prosecution case is silent whether in course of investigation any process was issued or any attempt was made to apprehend the said Rahul. Additionally the seizures were effected at the office of the revenue authorities and thereafter the statements under Section 108 of the Customs Act were recorded. Relying upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Noor Aga (supra) this court is of the opinion that the confessional statements so recorded under Section 108 of the Customs Act solely cannot be a foundation for arriving at the conclusion of guilt of the accused appellants.”

    27. The appellants also relied upon Hoda Sk. v. State Of West Bengal 1478 for advancing their arguments in respect of non-applicability of S.489B of IPC. Reliance was placed upon the following paragraphs:

    “14. Analysis of the aforesaid section shows whoever sells, buys or receives from any other person or otherwise traffics in or uses as genuine any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes with the knowledge or reasonable belief that the said notes are forged or counterfeit is said to have committed the offence. Hence, sale, purchase or receipt from any person, or otherwise trafficking in counterfeit currency notes as genuine is a sine qua non of such offence. There is no evidence that the appellants had sold, received or used any counterfeit notes. However, it has been argued on behalf of the prosecution that the appellant was “otherwise trafficking in” counterfeit notes by knowingly transporting a large volume of forged currency notes in a bag through a public road and had reached the ferry ghat when they were apprehended. Hence, he had committed the offence under section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860.

    15. What would the expression “otherwise traffics in” mean in the context of aforesaid offence?

    16. In K. Hasim v. State of Tamil Nadu, (2005) 1 SCC 237 : AIR 2005 SC 128, the Apex Court interpreted the object of section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 as follows:—

    “42. Similarly Section 489B relates to using as genuine forged or counterfeited currency notes or bank notes. The object of Legislature in enacting this section is to stop the circulation of forged notes by punishing all persons who knowing or having reason to believe the same to be forged do any act which could lead to their circulation.”

    17. Expression “otherwise traffics in” when interpreted in the light of the aforesaid object would include any act undertaken by the accused which would lead to circulation of notes.

    18. In Black's Law Dictionary, 10th edition, p. 1725, the word ‘traffic’ is defined as follows:—

    “traffic-1. Commerce; trade; the sale or exchange of such things as merchandise, bills, and money. 2. The passing or exchange of goods of commodities from one person to another for an equivalent in goods or money. 3. People or things being transported along a route. 4. The passing to and fro of people, animals, vehicles, and vesels along a transportation route.”

    28. The appellants also relied upon Umashankar v. State of Chhattisgarh, (2001) 9 SCC 642, attention was drawn to the following paragraphs:

    “7. Sections 489-A to 489-E deal with various economic offences in re spect of forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes. The object of the legislature in enacting these provisions is not only to protect the e conomy of the country but also to provide adequate protection to curre ncy notes and banknotes. The currency notes are, in spite of growing accustomedness to the credit card system, still the backbone of the co mmercial transactions by the multitudes in our country. But these provisions are not meant to punish unwary possessors or users.

    8. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mensrea of offences under Sections 489-B and 489-C is “knowing or having reason to believe the currency notes or banknotes are forged or counterfeit”. Without the aforementioned mensrea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes, is not enough to constitute offence under Section 489-B IPC. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency notes or banknotes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489-C in the absence of the mensrea, noted above. No material is brought on record by the prose cution to show that the appellant had the requisite mensrea. The High Court, however, completely missed this aspect. The learned trial Judge on the basis of the evidence of PW 2, PW 4 and PW 7 that they were able to make out that the currency note alleged to have been given to PW 4 was fake, “presumed” such a mensrea. On the date of the incident the appellant was said to be an eighteen-year-old student. On the facts of this case the presumption drawn by the trial court is not warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not shown that any specific question with regard to the currency notes being fake or counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of the Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts, we have no option but to hold that the charges framed under Sections 489-B and 489-C are not proved. We, therefore, set aside the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant under Sections 489-B and 489-C IPC and acquit him of the said charges (see: M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka . [(1979) 4 SCC 723 : 1980 SCC (Cri) 170 : AIR 1979 SC 1705]).”

    29. Appellants also relied upon M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka ., (1979) 4 SCC 723, to strengthen their arguments for culpability and complicity in respect of counterfeit currency. Reference was made to the following paragraph:

    “S. Murtaza Fazal Ali, J.- The appellant has been convicted in this appeal under Sections 489-B and 489-C and has been sentenced to RI for one year and to RI for six months respectively and fine of Rs. 500. The sentences have been directed to run concurrently. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant has stated that it is true that the appellant was found in possession of a counterfeit two rupee note and the accused handed over the note to a friend to purchase a ticket for a circus show. The booking clerk on seeing the note got suspicious. He immediately informed the Sub-Inspector of Police and on search of the Appellant 99 two rupee notes were recovered. The appellant in his statement under Section 342 stated that two days ago he sold three quintals of tamarind fruits to a person whom he did not know and that person gave him a sum of Rs. 390. These currency notes have been given to him by the purchaser. He also said that he did not know that these currency notes were counterfeit and he came to know of it for the first time when he was interrogated by the police. There is no evidence of any witness to show that the counterfeit notes were of such a nature or description that a mere look at them would convince any person of average intelligence that it was a counterfeit note. Nor was any such question put to the accused under Section 342 CrPC. The High Court has affirmed the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge on the ground that in his statement under Section 342 made before the committing Court the accused has made a statement different from that made in the Sessions Court and therefore the appellant had reason to believe that notes in his possession were counterfeit notes. Here the High Court is not correct because even in the statement before the committing Court in Ex. P-13 which appears at p. 154 of the paper-book, the appellant has stuck to the same statement which he made before the Sessions Court that he had sold three quintals of tamarind fruits and from the purchaser he received a sum of Rs. 390 in two rupee notes. We are not able to find any inconsistency between the answer given by the accused in his statement under Section 342 before the Sessions Judge and that before the Committing Court specially on the point that the appellant had the knowledge or reason to believe that the notes were counterfeit. Mr. Nettar submitted that once the appellant is found in possession of counterfeit notes, he must be presumed to know that the notes are counterfeit. If the notes were of such a nature that mere look at them would convince anybody that it was counterfeit such a presumption could reasonably be drawn. But the difficulty is that the prosecution has not put any specific question to the appellant in order to find out whether the accused knew that the notes were of such a nature. No such evidence has been led by the prosecution to prove the nature of the notes also. In these circumstances, it is impossible for us to sustain the conviction of the appellant. For these reasons, therefore, the appeal is allowed, conviction and sentences passed on the appellant are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charges framed against him.”

    30. Appellants also relied upon paragraph 24 of Md. Morful Haque v. The State Of West Bengal, 2017 SCC OnLine Cal 3380, which is set out as follows:

    24. From the above provisions of law it was evident that without mensrea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit notes or bank notes is not enough to constitute offence under section 489B IPC. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes is not sufficient to make out a case under section 489C IPC in the absence of mensrea. Criminality of mind and/intention must be there to constitute the offence under those sections but on critical analysis of the evidence of the prosecution witnesses on record we do not find any such evidence to the effect that the appellant had the requisite mensrea.

    31. Appellants also relied upon the judgment of the Bombay High Court in Sanskrit Sanskriti Jayantilal Salia v. State Of Maharashtra, 2018 SCC OnLine Bom 2969 and referred to the following paragraphs:

    “15. The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka . 2 has observed thus:

    “Mr. Neitar submitted that once the appellant is found in possession of counterfeit notes, he must be presumed to know that the notes ate counterfeit. If the notes were of such a nature that mere look at them would convince anybody that it was counterfeit such a presumption could reasonable be drawn. But the difficulty is that the prosecution has not put any specific question to the appellant in order to find out whether the accused knew that the notes were of such a nature. No such evidence has been led by the prosecution to prove the nature of the notes also, In these circumstances, it is impossible for us to sustain the conviction of the appellant. For these reasons, therefore, the appeal is allowed, conviction and sentences passed on the appellant are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted of the charges framed against him.” The Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Umashankar v. State of Chattisgrah (supra) has observed thus:

    “7. Sections 489-A to 489-E deal with various economic offences in respect of forged or counterfeit currency-note or bank-notes. The object of Legislature in enacting these provisions is not only to protect the economy of the country but also to provide adequate protection to currency-notes and bank-notes. The currency-notes are, inspite of growing accustomedness to the credit cards system, still the backbone of the commercial transactions by multitudes in our country. But these provisions are not meant to punish unwary possessors or users.

    8. A perusal of the provisions, extracted above, shows that mensrea of offences under Sections 489B and 489C is, “knowing or having reason to believe the currency-notes or bank-notes are forged or counterfeit”. Without the afore-mentioned mensrea selling, buying or receiving from another person or otherwise trafficking in or using as genuine forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes, is not enough to constitute offence under Section 489B of I.P.C. So also possessing or even intending to use any forged or counterfeit currency-notes or bank-notes is not sufficient to make out a case under Section 489C in the absence of the mensrea, noted above. No material is brought on record by the prosecution to show that the appellant had the requisite mensrea. The High Court, however, completely missed this aspect The learned trial judge on the basis of the evidence of P.W. 2, P.W. 4 and P.W. 7 that they were able to make out that currency note alleged to have been given to P.W. 4, was fake “presumed” such a mensrea. On the date of the incident the appellant was said to be 18 years old student. On the facts of this case the presumption drawn by the trial court is not warranted under Section 4 of the Evidence Act. Further it is also not shown that any specific question with regard to the currency-noted being fake on counterfeit was put to the appellant in his examination under Section 313 of Criminal Procedure Code. On these facts we have no option but to hold that the charges framed under Sections 489B and 489C are not proved. We, therefore, set aside the conviction and sentence passed on the appellant under Sections 489B and 489C of I.P.C. and acquit him of the said charges [see: M. Mammutti v. State Of Karnataka .].”

    16. In light of aforesaid authoritative pronouncements wherein has been categorically held that mere possession of the counterfeit notes is not punishable under law and it must be established by prosecution that possession was with a knowledge that the said currency notes are fake or counterfeit. In such circumstances, in absence of any evidence brought on record by the prosecution as a part of charge-sheet to demonstrate that possession of the Petitioner of the alleged currency notes which were deposited by her in the bank on 19th December, 2016 was with a knowledge that the same were counterfeit, Petitioner cannot tried for an offence under Section 489(B) in absence of any material to attribute such a knowledge on her part.

    17. Continuation of the proceedings against the Petitioner would be nothing but would amount to abuse of process of law and in such circumstances we are of the opinion that this is a fit case where we should exercise our inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 of Code of Criminal Procedure and in any contingency even on culmination of a trial, the charge leveled against the Petitioner cannot be proved and would result into an acquittal. In such circumstances, we are inclined to invoke our inherent power and we allow the Writ Petition and quash and set aside the Sessions Case No. 699 of 2017, pending before the Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay, Mumbai, arising out of CR No. 22 of 2017 registered with Parksite Police Station, Vikhroli, Mumbai, for the offence punishable under Section 489(B) of IPC.”

    32. Appellants submitted that the concept of mensrea was admitted in Md. Mukhtarul Islam @ Suman v. State of West Bengal, (2014) 2 Cal LT 260 and relied upon the following paragraphs:

    “13. Section 489B of the IPC speaks about the use of forged or counterfeit notes or bank notes as genuine with knowledge or having reason to believe the same to be forged or counterfeit. Similarly, 489C is attracted when a person is in possession of forged or counterfeit currency notes or bank notes having the knowledge or a reason to believe that they are forged or counterfeit. No presumption can be drawn about the mensrea of the accused as held in M. Mammutti (supra) and Umashanker (supra). In fact, the conduct of the accused is to the contrary. Had the accused the knowledge or any reason to believe that the currency notes were forged or counterfeit he would not have continued sitting in the bank till the police arrived there.”

    33. The manner of application of the provisions of Section 489B and Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860 was referred in Md. Tousif v. State of West Bengal in CRA 163/2019 and attention was drawn to the following passage:

    “In other words, if the prosecution is able to prove search, seizure, raid and recovery of FICN by adducing credible evidence in support of the prosecution case, the judicial precedents to the fact that illegal possession of huge quantity of FICN does not only attract Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860 but the offence under Section 489B is also held to be proved…..

    …. Therefore, the prosecution has failed to prove the basic ingredients of offence under Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860 and accordingly, the charge under Section 489B also fails. This Court further fails to understand as to why and how a charge under Section 120B of the Penal Code, 1860 was framed in the absence of any material of criminal conspiracy against the accused. The allegation that the accused wanted to hand over FICN to two other persons is not sufficient, there must be certain prima facie evidence to frame charge under Section 120B of the Penal Code, 1860 against the accused. The prosecution failed to produce the minimum evidence in support of the said charge.”

    34. I have considered the judgments relied upon by the appellants as well as that of the State and I find that the word ‘possession’ used in Section 489C of the Penal Code, 1860 has been given an extended meaning and interpreted to be equivalent to the term ‘otherwise traffics in’ used in Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860. One of the interpretations given is regarding volume of seized Fake Indian Currency Notes.

    35. Obviously, the issue arises that whether the attending circumstances are to be considered in a case of possession, in interpreting the phrase ‘otherwise traffics in’, in the background of the facts relating to the four appeals. In CRA 37 of 2019 with CRA 123 of 2019, 100 FICN of Rs. 2,000/- denomination were recovered from the three appellants. In CRA 189 of 2017 the recovery from the possession of the appellant was 100 numbers of Fake Indian Currency Notes of Rs. 500/- denomination but the appellant happens to be a CISF personnel. In CRA 702 of 2018, 49 number of Fake Indian Currency Notes of Rs. 500/- denomination were seized from the appellant but the opinion of the Expert was high quality counterfeit notes as specified in the third schedule of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 and it's Amendment Act, 2012.

    36. In the decision of Jubeda Chitrakar (supra) while interpreting the term ‘otherwise traffics in’ as appearing in Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860, the Court framed issue in relation to the factum of possession. Relevant part of paragraph 9 of the said judgment is set out as follows:

    “The question that would, however, arise for decision is as to whether possession of any forged or counterfeit currency note is sufficient to inculpate the accused for offence punishable under Section 489B….”

    37. In CRA 277 of 2016 Habibur Rahaman (supra) the relevant facts areset out as follows:

    “….Upon search, eight bundles of currency notes suspected to be fake in denomination of Rs. 1000/- (each bundle containing 800 pieces) valued at 8 lakhs wrapped in a coffee colour cloth bag was recovered from the appellant, Habibur Rahaman and two bundles of fake Indian currency notes in denomination of Rs. 1,000/- and Rs. 500/- (one bundle containing 176 pieces and another containing 48 pieces respectively) valued at Rs. 2 lakhs was recovered from his nephew, Nasiruddin Sheikh, who was a juvenile at the time of occurrence….”

    38. And the interpretation made by the Court at inner page 8 of the said judgment is set out as follows:

    “….When the appellant was found carrying a large volume of FICNs in a public place and he is unable to give any explanation for the said possession, one can safely held the appellant was knowingly trafficking in counterfeit currency notes….”

    39. Apart from the aforesaid two judgments in Ponusamy v. State reported in 1997 SCC (Cri) 217, the Hon'ble Supreme Court was pleased to hold as follows:

    “The verdict of the three courts below is similar in convicting and keeping maintained the convictions of the appellant under Sections 489-B and 420 of the Penal Code, 1860. The case of the prosecution against the appellant is that he had purchased paddy from a peasant on payment of 130 forged currency notes of Rs. 100 denomination. On the arrest of the appellant, further forged currency notes were alleged to have been found in his possession for which he had to face a trial separately. All the same, the appellant had no explanation to offer as to wherefrom had he obtained those forged currency notes. Silence on the part of the appellant in such circumstances would by itself be a telling circumstance which would weigh against him in the consideration of the prosecution evidence led against him. In these circumstances, we are of the view that the convictions recorded deserve no alteration and equally there is no scope for reduction of sentence. Maintaining the convictions and sentences of the appellant, we dismiss this appeal.”

    40. Thus the term ‘possession’ in some of the judgments have been interpreted to have an extended meaning equivalent to ‘otherwise traffics in’ while a set of judgments have refused such an interpretation. In view of such conflicting decisions referred to above as has been pointed out by the learned Advocates appearing for the State as well as the appellants, I am of the opinion that the following issues arise for reference to be decided by a Larger Bench:

    1) Whether the aid of ‘presumption’ is available when the seizure of FICN is effected from the possession of an individual?

    2) If quantity/volume of FICN is a ground of ‘presumption’, what would be the cut off number for presuming that the ‘possession’ was for the purpose of ‘otherwise traffics in’?

    3) When substantial number of FICN are recovered from the possession of a security personnel associated with the Government i.e. Police, CISF, Defence Forces etc. can it be presumed that the ingredients of the term ‘otherwise traffics in’ used in Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860 is automatically attracted?

    4) Do seizure from the possession of an individual of High Quality Counterfeit Notes (as referred to in the provisions of UAPA, 1967), opined by an Expert automatically attract the provisions of Section 489B of the Penal Code, 1860?

    41. Accordingly, records of CRA 37 of 2019 with CRA 123 of 2019; CRA 189 of 2017 and CRA 702 of 2018 be placed before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice, High Court at Calcutta for constitution of a Larger Bench for deciding the issues.

    42. All parties shall act on the server copy of this judgment duly downloaded from the official website of this Court.

    43. Urgent Xerox certified photocopy of this judgment, if applied for, be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite formalities.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    RIPON SK v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL
    (Aug 29, 2022)