Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2022 DHC 1805
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 409/420/120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 91 of Cr.P.C.
  • Section 173(8) Cr.P.C.
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 173(8) of Cr.P.C.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2022 DHC 1805
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 409/420/120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860
  • Section 91 of Cr.P.C.
  • Section 173(8) Cr.P.C.
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • Section 173(8) of Cr.P.C.
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Bail Application No. 679/2022 (Krishnan Subramanian) — High Court of Delhi

Factual and Procedural Background

Source: Judgment dated 10 May 2022 by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Chandra Dhari Singh

This is an application under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 by Krishnan Subramanian (the applicant) seeking regular bail in FIR No.50/2019 registered at Police Station EOW Mandir Marg for offences punishable under Sections 409, 420 and 120B of the Indian Penal Code.

The FIR was lodged by M/s Religare Finvest Limited (RFL — new management) against several persons including promoter-directors and senior executives of the Religare group. The allegation is that the promoters/directors disbursed loans to related or non‑financial entities which defaulted, causing large losses to RFL; the Reserve Bank of India had pointed out discrepancies such as related‑party lending and inter‑linked routing of funds.

The prosecution filed a chargesheet dated 6 January 2020 (first chargesheet). The applicant was not arraigned in that initial chargesheet. Subsequent supplementary chargesheets were filed: a first supplementary chargesheet concerning co-accused Maninder Singh on 20 January 2021, and a second supplementary chargesheet (relevant to the applicant) on 15 December 2021. The applicant was arrested on 8 December 2021.

Prior bail developments include regular bail granted to co-accused Maninder Singh (order dated 5 May 2021) and to Anil Saxena (order dated 17 June 2020) by Coordinate Benches of this Court; challenges to those orders were dismissed or not interfered with by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the applicant, arrested on 8 December 2021, should be granted regular bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C. in FIR No.50/2019 based on the factual and evidentiary matrix before the Court.
  2. Whether the continued custodial detention of the applicant was necessary when the prosecution's case—according to the applicant and the record—largely rests on documentary evidence and the chargesheet(s) had been filed.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant contended that the alleged "round‑tripping" and disbursement of dubious loans predominantly took place between 2008 and 2016 — a period when he was not associated with REL/RFL (he joined RFL on 14 November 2017).
  • During his limited tenure as Group CFO, he worked under the Board's directions and did not hold a key management role that would make him responsible for the earlier transactions; he resigned (14 November 2018; effective 11 March 2019 after RBI clearances).
  • He cooperated with investigation (responded to Section 91 notice, provided information) and was not called again until his arrest on 8 December 2021; the applicant says no reasons were given for the arrest.
  • The applicant argued that the charge(s) had crystallized (main chargesheet and a prior supplementary chargesheet were already on record) and that the evidence is documentary in nature and already seized, so there is no risk of tampering or need for custodial interrogation.
  • It was contended there is no prima facie case against him comparable to the gravity of allegations against certain co-accused; other co‑accused (Anil Saxena, Maninder Singh) have already been granted bail and their bail orders survived challenges.
  • The applicant offered to abide by all bail conditions, undertake not to tamper with evidence or influence witnesses, and asserted strong community ties and clean antecedents.
  • Several precedents were relied upon by the applicant in support of bail (listed in the precedents section below).

Respondent's (State's) Arguments

  • The State opposed bail, asserting a specific assigned role to the applicant in relation to certain loans and the handling/release of property documents relating to three borrower companies (Best, Vitova and Devera) that were initially secured loans worth about Rs.115 crores collectively.
  • It is alleged the applicant authorized or caused release of property documents (Asola land) and replacement of securities by share pledge arrangements (share pledge agreement dated 10 January 2018), without proper authority or board resolutions.
  • The State asserted that the mortgaged properties had been exchanged by borrowers (exchange deed dated 18 July 2017) and loans were not repaid; loans were later converted from secured to unsecured — facts which the State says indicate a conspiracy to defraud RFL.
  • The State submitted that given the sensitive nature and large sums involved there is a real risk of absconding, and that on bail the applicant could influence witnesses or tamper with evidence given his position and connections as Group CFO.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sanjay Chandra vs CBI, 2012 (1) SCC 14 This judgment was relied upon by the applicant (the opinion does not set out the specific rule from this case in the text of the judgment). Cited by the applicant; the Court's reasons do not record a specific reliance or detailed application of this case in the decision.
D.K. Shivkumar vs Enforcement Directorate, 2019 (264) DLT 586 Relied upon by the applicant; the text does not reproduce the principle relied upon. Cited by the applicant; the Court did not expressly rely on or analyze the decision in its reasoning as recorded.
P. Chidambaram vs Enforcement Directorate, 2019 SCC Online SC 1549 Relied upon by the applicant; the specific principle from this decision is not set out in the judgment text. Cited by the applicant; the Court's reasoning does not record a direct application of this authority.
P. Chidambaram vs CBI, 2019 SCC Online SC 1380 Relied upon by the applicant to support the contention that further investigation is not a ground for custodial detention where the case is documentary and the investigation has crystallized (as asserted by counsel). Cited by the applicant; while the Court noted the citation, its decision is framed on the facts and other authorities rather than a specific step‑by‑step application of this judgment in the text.
Shivani Rajiv Saxena vs Enforcement Directorate (Delhi High Court), Bail Application No. 2164/2017, dated 15 Dec 2017 Relied upon by the applicant (no specific excerpt of principle reproduced in the judgment text). Cited by the applicant; the Court's reasoning does not indicate separate, explicit reliance on this decision in reaching its conclusion.
Laxman Irappa Hatti vs State of Maharashtra, 2004 (4) Mh. L.J. 415 Observed by that High Court that filing of a chargesheet would entitle an applicant to be considered for bail as the investigation stands crystallized (this observation is recorded in the present judgment). Recognized as a supporting authority relied upon by the applicant; the Court referred to the crystallization point in its reasoning when noting that chargesheet(s) had been filed and materials collected.
Vaman Narain Ghiya vs State of Rajasthan, (2009) 2 SCC 281 The judgment articulates the balancing principle: personal liberty is fundamental but must be balanced with the investigational rights of the police; law of bail requires a balance between presumption of innocence and public interest/security. (Portions are quoted in the judgment.) The Court expressly relied on and quoted this authority to underscore the guiding principles of bail jurisprudence — balancing liberty and investigational needs — and applied those principles in the analysis.
Ketan Suresh Pawar & Anr vs Yuvraj Sudeepan Sawant & Anr., (2020) 16 SCC 752 The judgment is cited for the proposition that where a chargesheet has been filed and co-accused have been enlarged on bail, a High Court may consider grant of bail to other accused; the decision contains discussion on custody prior to trial and availability of accused. The Court cited and relied on this decision in its reasoning, noting the similarity that co-accused had been enlarged on bail and that the accused in custody had been available for custody prior to bail — factors influencing the present order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying well‑settled factors to be considered on bail applications (as recited in the judgment): (i) nature and gravity of accusation and materials relied upon; (ii) reasonable apprehension of tampering with witnesses or threat to witnesses; (iii) possibility of securing presence at trial / risk of absconding; (iv) character and standing of accused; and (v) larger public interest.

The Court relied on and quoted Vaman Narain Ghiya to emphasise the balancing exercise between personal liberty and investigational rights. It also referred to Ketan Suresh Pawar to note that when a chargesheet has been filed and co-accused have been enlarged on bail, the High Court may properly consider bail for another accused in appropriate circumstances.

Applying these principles to the facts on record, the Court noted:

  • Chargesheet(s) had been filed: main chargesheet (6 January 2020), a first supplementary chargesheet (20 January 2021) and a second supplementary chargesheet (15 December 2021) were on record.
  • The materials collected by the investigating authorities were said to be documentary in nature and, according to the record and submissions, were in the custody of the prosecution (seized), reducing the risk that the applicant could tamper with or destroy evidence.
  • Co‑accused (Maninder Singh and Anil Saxena) had already been enlarged on bail by Coordinate Benches of this Court and those bail orders were not disturbed by the Supreme Court; this fact was treated as relevant evidence of parity and comparative gravity.
  • The Court accepted the applicant's representations about his residential ties (permanent resident of Delhi), clean antecedents and willingness to comply with conditions as mitigating factors against the risk of absconding.
  • The applicant had been in custody since 8 December 2021 and there was no material demonstrating that his custodial interrogation was necessary for further investigation.

On the other hand, while the State raised specific allegations concerning the handling and release of property documents and the conversion of loans from secured to unsecured (including allegations of unauthorized release of security and use of share pledges), the Court found on the balance of the recorded material that documentary evidence was available and seized, and that the risk of tampering or influencing witnesses did not justify continued custodial detention.

Taking the totality of these circumstances — chargesheeting, documentary nature of evidence, seized materials, parity with co‑accused enlarged on bail, lack of current necessity for custodial interrogation, residency and antecedents of the applicant — the Court concluded that the statutory and jurisprudential factors favoured grant of bail.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The bail application is allowed and stands disposed of; the applicant is directed to be released on bail subject to specified conditions.

Direct Consequences and Conditions:

  • The applicant shall furnish a personal bond of Rs.1,00,000 (Rupees One Lakh) with two sureties, each for a like amount, to the satisfaction of the Jail Superintendent/Trial Court.
  • Conditions imposed (as enumerated in the judgment):
    • (a) The applicant shall not leave India without prior permission of the Court concerned.
    • (b) He shall surrender his passport, if any, before the Trial Court.
    • (c) He shall appear before the Court concerned as and when required.
    • (d) He shall not directly or indirectly make any inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case.
    • (e) He shall provide his mobile number(s) and keep them operational at all times.
    • (f) He shall commit no offence whatsoever during the period he is on bail.
    • (g) In case of change of residential address and/or mobile number, the same shall be intimated to the Court concerned by way of an affidavit.

The application and any pending applications stand disposed of. The Court specifically recorded that any observations touching the merits in this judgment are for the limited purpose of deciding the bail petition and shall not be treated as final observations in the trial proceedings. A copy of the judgment was directed to be sent to the Jail Superintendent for compliance and to be uploaded on the Court website.

Broader implications: The judgment applies established bail principles to the facts — it does not purport to lay down new legal precedent; the decision addresses release of this particular accused on bail under the circumstances set out in the record (chargesheeted case, documentary evidence, co-accused on bail, and lack of custodial necessity).

End of summary. This HTML summary is based exclusively on the contents of the provided judgment and does not add or infer material beyond the opinion's text.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Krishnan Subramanian v. State (Nct Of Delhi)

    BAIL APPLN. 679/2022 Page 1 of 14

    * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

    % Reserved on: 1st April 2022 Pronounced on: 10th May 2022

    + BAIL APPLN. 679/2022 KRISHNAN SUBRAMANIAN ..... Applicant Through: Mr. Tanveer Ahmed Mir, Mr. Saud Khan, Mr. Prabhav Ralle and Mr. Kartik Venu, Advocates

    versus

    STATE OF NCT OF DELHI ..... Respondent Through: Mr. Avi Singh, ASC for State with Mr. Karan Dhalla and Ms. Mizba Dhebar, Advocates and Insp. Manoj Kumar, P.S. EOW.

    Mr. Mohit Mathur, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Sandeep D. Das, Mr.

    Shashwat Sarin and Mr. Harsh

    Gautam, Advocates for the

    complainant.

    CORAM:

    HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA DHARI SINGH

    J U D G M E N T

    CHANDRA DHARI SINGH, J.

    1. The instant bail application under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 has been filed on behalf of the applicant seeking regular bail in FIR bearing No. 50/2019 registered at Police Station EOW Mandir Marg for offences punishable under Sections 409/420/120B of the Indian Penal Code, 1860.

    1

    2. Status report filed by the State is taken on record.

    3. The brief facts of the case are that the aforesaid FIR was lodged by M/s. Religare Finvest Limited (hereinafter "RFL" - New Management) with Police Station EOW Mandir Marg against Malvinder Mohan Singh, Shivinder Mohan Singh, the then Promoters/Directors, Sunil Godhwani, the then Chairman-cum-Managing Director and N.K. Ghoshal. It is alleged that the aforesaid persons having absolute control on REL, and its subsidiaries have put „RFL" in poor financial condition by disbursing loans to entities, having no financial standings. These entities willfully defaulted in repayments and caused wrongful loss to „RFL" to the huge money. The Reserve Bank of India (hereinafter "RBI") has pointed out some discrepancies in its analysis viz. the top borrowers of „RFL", under Corporate Loan Book (CLB) portfolio were related entities; there was inter linkage between the borrowers as funds were routed from one borrower to another; and the loan amounts ultimately were coming to the group companies of „RFL".

    4. Mr. Tanveer Ahmed Mir, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the applicant submitted that as per the allegations made in the complaint and crystallized in the charge-sheet, the promoter-directors were involved in round tripping of some loans right from the year 2008 onwards and it is a matter of admitted position that the aforesaid round tripping predominantly took place between the period from 2008 to 2016, during which period the applicant was neither a part of „REL" nor a part of „RFL". It is further submitted that „RFL" was a 100% subsidiary of „REL" and therefore, a common balance sheet was being filed. The applicant throughout his

    2

    limited tenure as Group CFO of „RFL", worked strictly under the guidance and directions of the Board of Directors. It is vehemently submitted that the applicant at no point of time held a key role so far as management of affairs of „REL" or „RFL" is concerned. The applicant sought to resign from RFL/REL on 14thNovember 2018 and the resignation attained force on 11th March 2019 after obtaining the requisite clearances from the RBI.

    5. Learned counsel for the applicant further submitted that during the course of further investigation one Maninder Singh who was working as Chief Business Officer of „REL" as well as held vital post in „RFL", was arrested by the investigating authorities on 27thOctober 2020 on the allegation that he had aided and abetted and being an accessory/criminal conspirator with the main beneficiaries i.e. Shivinder Mohan Singh and Malvinder Mohan Singh and thereby had caused loss of more than Rs. 1500 Crores to „RFL". The allegation against him was that he was a member of Risk Management Committee (hereinafter "RMC") and about 13 dubious loans were granted to related parties without any documentation/collateral securities, whereas the co-accused Maninder Singh had a huge responsibility in refusing to permit/sanction or support the grant of such loans, being a member of the „RMC".

    6. The investigating agencies conducted detailed investigation and consequently filed a chargesheet dated 6thJanuary 2020, before the CMM, Saket, District Court, New Delhi. It was submitted that on account of fact that no evidence surfaced to the detriment of the applicant during the aforesaid investigation as comprehensively conducted by Economic

    3

    Offences Wing (hereinafter "EOW"), therefore, the applicant was neither arraigned nor charge sheeted by the respondent.

    7. The supplementary chargesheet under Section 173(8) of Cr.P.C. was filed by the Investigating Authorities qua the co-accused Maninder Singh on 20thJanuary 2021. The said co-accused applied for grant of bail in Bail Application No. 3952/2020 and the Co-ordinate Bench of this Court had granted regular bail to him vide judgment dated 5thMay 2021. The said judgment was challenged before the Hon"ble Supreme Court by the complainant by way of filing SLP (Crl.) No. 12290/2021, which was dismissed in limine vide judgment and order dated 12thJuly 2021.

    8. Learned counsel further submitted that the applicant was served a notice under Section 91 of Cr.P.C. by the investigating authorities, in response to which he appeared and supplied the requisite information as well and joined investigation to the satisfaction of the investigating authorities. In consequence whereof, the applicant was asked to go back to his home and was never called upon to join investigation again at any point of time. It is further submitted that on 8thDecember 2021, officers from the „EOW", Delhi Police came to the residence of the applicant at around 8:30 AM, and the applicant was forcefully taken to the offices of „EOW" at Mandir Marg and in the evening, the arrest memo was handed over to him. No reasons whatsoever were provided to the applicant as to why he was arrested.

    9. It is further submitted that the second supplementary charge-sheet under Section 173(8) of Cr.P.C. was filed by the investigating authorities on

    4

    15thDecember 2021 i.e. within a period of 6 days from the arrest of the applicant which would manifestly indicate and demonstrate that the supplementary charge-sheet qua the applicant was already ready and finalized and thereafter the applicant was arrested. It is argued that when the applicant was arrested, admittedly his custody was not needed, and he was arrested only for the purpose of giving him a taste of punishment before he was actually convicted.

    10. To strengthen his arguments, learned counsel for the applicant has relied upon several judgments of Hon"ble Supreme Court and High Court as under:-

    a) Sanjay Chandra vs CBI 2012 (1) SCC 14,

    b) D.K. Shivkumar vs Enforcement Directorate 2019 (264) DLT

    586,

    c) P. Chidambaram vs Enforcement Directorate 2019 SCC Online SC 1549,

    d) P. Chidambaram vs CBI 2019 SCC Online SC 1380.

    e) Shivani Rajiv Saxena vs Enforcement Directorate, passed by this Court in Bail Application No. 2164 of 2017 dated 15th December 2017.

    11. Learned counsel also relied upon and judgment passed by the High Court of Bombay in Laxman Irappa Hatti vs State of Maharashtra 2004

    (4) Mh. L.J. 415, wherein it is observed that filing of chargesheet would entitle the applicant for grant of bail as the investigation stands crystallized.

    5

    12. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that further investigation, which otherwise is not contended by the prosecution, cannot be a ground for continued incarceration and the same has been negated by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India on a number of occasions. He has relied upon the judgment of Hon"ble Supreme Court in P. Chidambaram vs CBI 2019 SCC Online SC 1380. Learned counsel submitted that the applicant was arrested on 8thDecember 2021, when the main charge sheet and the first supplementary charge sheet had already been filed and investigation stood crystallized. There is no denial of the fact that entire investigation is in the domain of "documentary evidence" which obviously has not been touched or tampered with since 2008. There is no propensity on the part of the applicant, therefore, to tamper with any kind of evidence which has been placed on record or which is in the domain of further investigation. It is an admitted position that EOW had already seized all the documents, including digital and electronic evidence. Therefore, the applicant cannot tamper with any such evidence.

    13. Learned counsel argued that it is a matter of admitted position that the entire criminal activity of giving dubious loans or unjustified loans by „RFL" has taken place within the period of 2008 to 2016 during which period, the applicant was nowhere concerned either with „REL" or „RFL", in as much as he joined „RFL" only on 14thNovember 2017. Therefore, the applicant is not at all responsible for such grant of loan. It is also submitted that the main accused Anil Saxena has already been enlarged on bail vide order dated 17thJune 2020 by the Coordinate Bench of this Court and the same bail order was challenged in the Hon"ble Supreme Court which has

    6

    been confirmed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. It is also submitted that the co-accused Maninder Singh, who is accused of being responsible for fraudulent loans to the tune of more than Rs. 1500 Crores has already been granted bail vide order dated 5thMay 2021 by the Coordinate Bench of this Court, and the said order was also challenged before the Hon"ble Supreme Court and Hon"ble Supreme Court had dismissed the aforesaid SLP vide order dated 12thJuly 2021.

    14. Learned counsel submitted that there is no prima facie case made out against the applicant. It is vehemently submitted that as regards the parameters of gravity and seriousness of offence, the case against the applicant is on a lower pedestal when compared to co-accused Anil Saxena and Maninder Singh, who had already been enlarged on bail by the Coordinate Bench of this Court and the bail orders have been confirmed by the Hon"ble Supreme Court. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that that the applicant has a permanent abode, he is a family man and shall not abscond or flee from justice if granted bail. On instructions, it is submitted that applicant shall abide by all conditions imposed by this Court while granting bail. The applicant further undertakes not to influence any witness or tamper with any evidence or take any such step which might be detrimental to the fair investigation of the present matter. The applicant has clean antecedents and has no criminal case against him except the instant FIR. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, it is prayed that the applicant be released on bail.

    15. Per Contra, Mr. Avi Singh learned ASC for the State vehemently opposed the instant bail application and submitted that specific role has

    7

    been assigned to the applicant in the instant case. It was alleged that three companies namely Best, Vitova and Devera were initially granted secured loans (i.e. part of 19 loans, which are investigated in this case) worth Rs. 115 crores collectively and property documents of agricultural land parcel situated in Asola were kept with the complainant company as security against the said loans. It is further submitted that later, during enquiry, it was found that land parcels were exchanged by the borrower companies without permissions and knowledge of complainant-company. The property documents which were kept with complainant-company as security were released to the alleged borrower by accused person and a share pledge agreement dated 10thJanuary 2018 with RHC and Elive under which shares of Elive were pledged and trademark certificates with respect to Religare Brand were deposited with „RFL", who was the then group CEO of complainant company was under the control of accused persons, at that time.

    16. It is submitted that after receiving the said complaint, investigation was done, and applicant herein was asked to join the investigation. He replied that property related documents of Asola land was handled by operation team. The mails provided by complainant-company revealed that property documents were released on the instructions of applicant herein, for which, he was not authorised. Further, it was found that properties mortgaged with complainant company were already exchanged vide exchange deed dated 18thJuly 2017 by the alleged borrower and the loan amount was never paid by them to the complainant company. Accused could not produce any board resolution, in his favour, vide which he was

    8

    authorised to get the documents of properties viz., Best Health Management Pvt. Ltd., M/s. Vitova Realtors Pvt. Ltd. and M/s. Devera Developers Pvt. Ltd., released and replaced them through Elive Shares vide share pledge agreement dated 10thJanuary 2018. The said three loans were initially sanctioned as secure loans but later on, they were converted into unsecured loans. So, those facts indicated conspiracy of accused in question with the said promoters and SPA was executed solely with intention to defraud „RFL" by asking it to release the property related documents as security. It was done without any knowledge of complainant-company.

    17. Learned ASC submitted that given the sensitive nature of the matter and the large sums of money involved, there is a strong possibility of the applicant absconding and not facing trial. Further if released on bail, he can influence the witnesses and tamper with evidence since he, as the Group CFO, had wide ranging connections and standing with the employees of the Religare Group. It is vehemently submitted that the applicant is not entitled to any relief by this Court and the instant application is liable to be dismissed.

    18. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    19. I have perused the FIR, chargesheet dated 6thJanuary 2020, copy of first supplementary chargesheet under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. dated 20th January 2021, copy of second supplementary chargesheet under Section 173(8) Cr.P.C. dated 15thDecember 2021, bail order of the co-accused Anil Saxena dated 17thJune 2020 passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court, order dated 17thJuly 2020 passed by the Hon"ble Supreme Court in SLP

    9

    (CRL.) Diary No. 13106/2020 challenging the bail order of Anil Saxena, bail order of co-accused Maninder Singh granted by Co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 5thMay 2021 and order of Hon"ble Supreme Court dated 12thJuly 2021 challenging the bail order of Maninder Singh in SLP (CRL.) Diary No.12290/2021.

    20. The jurisdiction to grant bail must be exercised on the basis of the well-settled principles having regard to the facts and circumstances of each case. The following factors are to be taken into consideration while considering an application for bail:-

    (i) the nature of accusation and the severity of the punishment in the case of conviction and the nature of the materials relied upon by the prosecution;

    (ii) reasonable apprehension of tampering with the witnesses or apprehension of threat to the complainant or the witnesses;

    (iii) reasonable possibility of securing the presence of the accused at the time of trial or the likelihood of his absconding;

    (iv) character, behaviour and standing of the accused and the circumstances which are peculiar to the accused; and

    (v) larger interest of the public or the State and similar other considerations.

    21. In the case of Vaman Narain Ghiya vs. State of Rajasthan, (2009) 2 SCC 281, the Hon"ble Supreme Court held as under:-

    10

    "7. Personal liberty is fundamental and can be circumscribed only by some process sanctioned by law. Liberty of a citizen is undoubtedly important but this is to balance with the security of the community. A balance is required to be maintained between the personal liberty of the accused and the investigational right of the police. It must result in minimum interference with the personal liberty of the accused and the right of the police to investigate the case. It has to dovetail two conflicting demands, namely, on one hand, the requirements of the society for being shielded from the hazards of being exposed to the mis- adventures of a person alleged to have committed a crime; and on the other, the fundamental cannon of criminal jurisprudence, viz, the presumption of innocence of an accused till he is found guilty. Liberty exists in proportion to wholesome restrain, the more restraint on others to keep off from us, the more liberty we have (See A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras AIR

    1950 SC 1000).

    8. The law of bail, like any other branch of law, has its own philosophy, and occupies an important place in the administration of justice and the concept of bail emerges from the conflict between the police power to restrict liberty of a man who is alleged to have committed a crime, and presumption of innocence in favour of the alleged criminal. An accused is not detained in custody with the object of punishing him on the assumption of his guilt."

    22. In the case of Ketan Suresh Pawar & Anr vs. Yuvraj Sudeepan Sawant & Anr. (2020) 16 SCC 752, the Hon"ble Supreme Court held as under:-

    "In that background considering that the charge sheet had been filed and the other coaccused have been enlarged on bail, the High Court has considered it appropriate to grant the bail in favour of the respondent No. 1 herein. Though the learned counsel for the petitioner herein contends that the allegations against the respondent No. 1 is of a serious nature, the present

    11

    SLP(Crl) No.4158/2019 custody being prior to trial the same cannot be treated as one after conviction so as to deny the bail based only on the allegation though in appropriate cases the same is also to be kept in perspective. The allegations in any event would be gone into in the trial. Even if a supplementary charge sheet is required to be filed, the respondent No. 1 was available in custody from the date of his arrest till the grant of bail. That apart, the State/Investigating Agency has not made any grievance by challenging the order, contending that his custody is required for interrogation. Even if he is on bail, he shall certainly make himself available. In addition, it is seen that the respondent No. 1 was released on bail as far back as on 13.02.2019 and there is no material on record to indicate that as on today any of the conditions imposed while granting bail has been violated. Needless to mention that if the respondent No.1 violates the bail conditions, it will be open for the petitioner herein to approach the High Court in that regard."

    23. In the instant case, it is an admitted case that co-accused Maninder Singh was enlarged on bail by the Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 5thMay 2021. The said bail order was challenged before the Hon"ble Supreme Court by way of filing SLP (CRL.) Diary No. 12290/2021. The Hon"ble Supreme Court vide order dated 12thJuly 2021 confirmed the bail order dated 5thMay 2021 and dismissed the SLP. The co-accused Anil Saxena was also enlarged on bail by the Coordinate Bench of this Court vide order dated 17thJune 2020 in Bail Application No. 1074/2020. The said order was also challenged before the Hon"ble Supreme Court by way of filing SLP (CRL) Diary No. 13106/2020. The Hon"ble Supreme Court vide order dated 17thJuly 2020 did not interfere with the bail order of co-accused Anil Saxena.

    12

    24. A perusal of record shows that chargesheet has already been filed, all materials have been collected by the investigating authorities and the evidence against the applicant is documentary in nature. In the considered opinion of this Court, the applicant is neither a flight risk, nor can there be any propensity on his part to tamper with any evidence or influence any witness inasmuch as the entire domain of evidence is documentary in nature, which exists as it is from the year 2008 onwards, unhindered, and untampered. The applicant is a permanent resident of Delhi and has clean antecedents. He has been languishing in jail since 8thDecember 2021. In that background considering the chargesheet, first supplementary chargesheet and second supplementary chargesheet as well as the fact that other co-accused persons having been enlarged on bail by the Coordinate Bench which stand confirmed by the Hon"ble Supreme Court; and the facts and circumstances and discussion as aforesaid, this Court is inclined to allow the instant bail application seeking regular bail.

    25. It is accordingly directed that the applicant be released on bail on his furnishing personal bond in the sum of Rs. 1 Lac with two sureties each of the like amount to the satisfaction of the Jail Superintendent/Trial Court subject to the conditions as follow:-

    (a) he shall under no circumstances leave India without prior permission of the Court concerned;

    (b) he shall surrender his passport, if any, before the Trial Court;

    (c) he shall appear before the Court concerned as and when required;

    13

    (d) he shall not directly or indirectly make any inducement, threat or promise to any person acquainted with the facts of the case;

    (e) he shall provide his mobile number(s) and keep it operational at all times;

    (f) he shall commit no offence whatsoever during the period he is on bail; and

    (g) in case of change of residential address and/or mobile number, the same shall be intimated to the Court concerned by way of an affidavit.

    26. Accordingly, the bail application stands disposed of. Pending application, if any, also stands disposed of.

    27. It is made clear that any observations touching merits of the case are purely for the purpose of deciding the instant petition and shall not be construed as an expression of final observation in the proceedings before Trial Court.

    28. Copy of this judgment be sent to Jail Superintendent for compliance.

    29. The judgment be uploaded on the website forthwith.

    (CHANDRA DHARI SINGH)

    JUDGE

    MAY 10, 2022

    Aj/@dityak.

    14

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishnan Subramanian v. State (Nct Of Delhi)
    (May 10, 2022)