Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal is filed by the Revenue under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 challenging the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, C Bench, Bangalore dated 19.06.2015 relating to the assessment year 2008-09. The appeal arises from the Tribunal's decision allowing the assessee's claims for deduction under Section 35D of the Act and treating foreign exchange gains arising from Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCBs) as capital gains and hence not taxable. The Assessing Officer initially accepted the claims, but the Commissioner of Income Tax exercised revisional powers under Section 263, holding the claims erroneous and prejudicial to the Revenue's interest due to lack of evidence. The Tribunal reversed this decision, holding that FCCBs are debt instruments and that exchange fluctuations on such liabilities are capital in nature. The Revenue is aggrieved and has preferred this appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in holding that Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCBs) are debentures and considering them as part of capital employed for allowing deduction under Section 35D of the Income Tax Act, 1961?
  2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in treating the foreign exchange gain as a gain on capital account and hence allowing it as not taxable?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi V/s. Woodward Governor of India [P.] Ltd., (2009) 312 ITR 254 (SC) Recognition that exchange fluctuations on foreign currency liabilities related to acquisition of industrial undertakings affect capital account and should be adjusted accordingly under Section 43A. The Court relied on this precedent to affirm that exchange gains or losses arising from restatement of FCCBs are capital in nature and not taxable as revenue gains.
Commissioner of Income-tax V/s. Enam Securities [P.] Ltd., (2012) 345 ITR 64 (Bom.) Distinction between bonds, debentures, and preference shares; bonds and debentures are debt instruments representing loans. The Court used this case to support the classification of FCCBs as debentures (debt instruments) rather than equity, relevant for allowing deductions under Section 35D.
R.D. Goyal and Another V/s. Reliance Industries Ltd., (2003) 1 SCC 81 Debentures are instruments acknowledging debt and carrying interest, distinct from shares; definition under Companies Act 1956. The Court applied this principle to confirm that FCCBs are debt instruments acknowledging liability and interest, not shares.
Noorie Manure Mill, Sambhal Vs. Commissioner Trade Tax, U.P., (2007) 10 SCC 478 In absence of statutory definition, terms must be interpreted in common parlance. The Court used this principle to interpret the term "debenture" in its ordinary commercial sense, including bonds like FCCBs.
Director of Income-tax V/s. Shree Visheshwar Nath Memorial Public Charitable Trust, (2010) 194 Taxman 280 (Delhi) Interpretation of the term 'debenture' in context of tax exemption provisions; bonds included within debentures in common parlance. The Court relied on this to reject a restrictive interpretation of 'debenture' excluding bonds, supporting FCCBs classification as debentures.
Commissioner of Income-tax-III Chennai V/s. PVP Ventures Ltd., (2012) 211 Taxman 554 (Mad.) FCCBs are debt instruments and thus treated as debentures under the Companies Act. The Court cited this judgment, upheld by the Supreme Court, to support the finding that FCCBs are debentures and that exchange fluctuations on them are capital in nature.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the nature of Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCBs) in light of definitions from the Companies Act, 1956, and relevant regulatory schemes. It held that FCCBs are debt instruments akin to debentures, as they represent funds raised repayable after a certain period and carry interest obligations. The Court noted that fluctuations in foreign exchange rates affecting the liability on FCCBs should be treated as adjustments to the capital account rather than revenue gains or losses. This interpretation aligns with Section 43A of the Income Tax Act, which mandates adjustments in the cost of assets due to exchange rate changes. The Court relied on authoritative precedents to reinforce that the gain or loss arising from currency fluctuations on such debt instruments is capital in nature and not taxable as income. Consequently, the Tribunal's decision to allow deductions under Section 35D and to treat foreign exchange gains as non-taxable capital gains was upheld. The Court found no fault with the Tribunal's reasoning and dismissed the Revenue's appeal.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED

The Court dismissed the Revenue's appeal, thereby affirming the Tribunal's findings that FCCBs are debentures for the purpose of Section 35D deductions and that foreign exchange gains arising from their restatement are capital gains and not taxable. The direct effect is in favor of the assessee, allowing the claimed deductions and non-taxation of such exchange gains. No new precedent beyond the application of established principles was set by this decision.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    PR COMMISSIONER OF v. M/S SUBEX LTD

    This appeal is filed by the Revenue under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [Act for short] challenging the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, C Bench, Bangalore ['Tribunal' for short] dated 19.06.2015 passed in ITA No.689/Bang/2014 relating to the assessment year 2008-09.

    2. The appeal was admitted by this Court to consider the following substantial questions of law:

    1. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in holding that foreign currency convertible bonds [FCCBs] are debentures and considered it to be part of capital employed for allowing deduction under Section 35D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 [for short, the Act]?

    2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was justified in treating the foreign exchange gain as a gain on capital account and hence allowing it as not taxable?

    3. In this appeal, the focus is on two items deducted from the profit as per the profit and loss account viz., [1] Exchange gain on Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds [FCCBs] reinstatement of Rs.60,75,80,000/- [2] Deduction under Section 35D of the Act amounting to Rs.11,36,59,330/-.

    4. The returns for the assessment year 2008-09 was taken up for scrutiny. The Assessing Officer passed an order of assessment under section 143[3] of the Act for the assessment year 2008-09 accepting the claim of the assessee for deduction under Section 35D of the Act on the aforesaid two claims. The CIT in exercise of his powers under Section 263 of the Act exercised the revisional powers on the ground that allowing the aforesaid two claims made by the assessee was erroneous and prejudicial to the interest of the Revenue and held that no evidence was placed to support the claim. In the absence of evidence, the assessees claim was rejected. On appeal preferred by the assessee before the Tribunal, the same has been reversed holding that FCCBs are instruments issued to investors for raising funds which is repayable after certain period. It is the debt instrument. The increase or decrease in liability on account of fluctuation in foreign exchange as on the date of the balance sheet would increase or decrease the liability of the assessee and such liability would be on capital account. Therefore, the gain or loss would be on capital account and not taxable. Thus, the Tribunal allowed the appeal answering in favour of the assessee. Being aggrieved, the Revenue has preferred this appeal.

    5. In terms of Section 2[12] of the Companies Act, 1956, debenture includes debenture stock, bonds and any other securities of a company, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company or not.

    6. As per Regulation 2[g] of Foreign Exchange Management [Transfer or Issue of any Foreign Security] Regulations, 2004, Foreign Currency Convertible Bond [FCCB] means a bond issued by an Indian company expressed in foreign currency, and the principal and interest in respect of which is payable in foreign currency.

    7. Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds as per Regulation 2[b] of Issue of Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds and Ordinary Shares [Through Depository Receipt Mechanism] Scheme, 1993 Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds means bonds issued in accordance with this scheme and subscribed by a non-resident in foreign currency and convertible into ordinary shares of the issuing company in any manner, either in whole, or in part, on the basis of any equity related warrants attached to debt instruments.

    8. The Commissioner exercising the powers under Section 263 having observed that the assessee on one hand states that any exchange gain/loss arising on account of restatement of liability with respect to the funds sourced for investments would have to be adjusted in accordance with Section 43A of the Act, on the other hand, states that an amount of Rs.1,929,600,000/- being foreign currency loss was added back in its return of income. The same being contradictory and in the absence of full evidence, the claim of the assessee could not be verified. Thus, the Assessing officer was directed to examine the same and to bring the gain to tax accordingly. The arguments of the learned counsel for the assessee that the loss was not created because it was capital under Section 43A and as such it has been added back being foreign currency loss has some force.

    9. At this juncture, it would be apt to refer to paras 38 and 39 of the order of the Tribunal wherein it is held that the factual position that the exchange fluctuation is owing to restatement of FCCBs is not disputed, the admitted position is that FCCBs were issued for purpose of acquisition of new industrial undertaking and was therefore in that context, reference was made to the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Commissioner of Income-tax, Delhi V/s. Woodward Governor of India [P.] Ltd., [(2009) 312 ITR 254 (SC)] wherein, the Hon'ble Apex Court has held thus:

    10. As stated above, on facts in the case of M/s Woodward Governor India P. Ltd., the Department has disallowed the deduction/debit to the P&L account made by the assessee in the sum of Rs. 29,49,088.00 being unrealized loss due to foreign exchange fluctuation. At the very outset, it may be stated that there is no dispute that in the previous years whenever the dollar rate stood reduced, the Department had taxed the gains which accrued to the assessee on the basis of accrual and it is only in the year in question when the dollar rate stood increased, resulting in loss that the Department has disallowed the deduction/debit. This fact is important. It indicates the double standards adopted by the Department.

    10. Analyzing Section 43A [Un-amended] held that what triggers the adjustment in the actual cost of the assets, in terms of un-amended Section 43A is the change in the rate of exchange subsequent to the acquisition of asset in foreign currency. The Section mandates that any time there is change in the rate of exchange, the same may be given effect to, by way of adjustment of the carrying cost of the fixed assets acquired in foreign currency. Thus, it has been observed that increase or decrease in liability in the repayment of foreign loan should be taken into account to modify the figure of actual cost in the year in which the increase or decrease in liability arises on account fluctuation in the rate of exchange. Thus, the adjustments in the actual cost are to be made irrespective of the date of actual payment in foreign currency made by the assessee. The clarification issued by the Ministry of Finance dated 04.01.1967 is also considered, which inter alia reads as under: "2. The Government agrees that for the purposes of the calculation of depreciation allowance, the cost of capital assets imported before the date of devaluation should be written off to the extent of the full amount of the additional rupee liability incurred on account of devaluation and not what is actually paid from year to year. The proposed legal provision in the matter is intended to be framed on this basis."

    11. The arguments advanced on behalf of the Revenue on long term borrowing is not relevant where the question is whether FCCB convertible bonds are debentures or not. The relevant portion of the annual report extract of the assessee-company relating to the assessment year 2008-09 would also throw some light on this issue. Other terms and conditions governing the bonds are shown as under: - 10 -

    [a] Conversion of the bonds into equity shares at the option of the bond holders at any time after 18th April 2007

    12. In the case of Commissioner of Income-tax-

    4 V/s. Enam Securities [P.] Ltd., [(2012) 345 ITR 64 (Bom.)], Honble High Court of Bombay has held that there is a clear distinction between the bonds and debentures on the one hand, and preference share capital on the other. It has been observed that a bond includes any instrument whereby a person obliges himself to pay money to another on the condition that the obligation shall be void if a specified act is performed, or is not performed, as the case may be [P.Ramanatha Aiyars Advanced Law Lexicon 3rd Edition 2005 Page 565 Debt]. Securities typically are regarded as consisting of notes, debentures and bonds. Technically, a debenture is an unsecured corporate obligation while a bond is secured by a lien or mortgage on corporate property. However, in - 11 - commercial parlance, the expression bond is often used indiscriminately to cover both bonds and debentures. Bonds are in essence interest bearing instruments which represent a loan.

    13. In the case of R.D. Goyal and Another V/s. Reliance Industries Ltd., [(2003) 1 SCC 81], the Hon'ble Apex Court observed that a debenture, as ordinarily understood, in our considered view, would not come within the purview of definition of goods as it is simply an instrument of acknowledgement of debt by the company whereby it undertakes to pay the amount covered by it and till then it undertakes further to pay interest thereon to the debenture-holders. In terms of section 2(46) of the Companies Act, 1956, debenture is a share in the share capital of a company which in turn would mean that it would represent contribution of the share-holder towards the share capital of the company. On the other hand, a debenture is an instrument of - 12 - debt executed by the company acknowledging its receipt to repay the same at a specified rate and also carrying an interest.

    14. In the case of Director of Income-tax V/s. Shree Visheshwar Nath Memorial Public Ch. Trust [(2010) 194 taxman 280 (Delhi)], the Honble High Court of Delhi has held thus:

    6. For the purposes of Section 13 (1) (d) of the Act, Mr. Sabharwal, learned counsel appearing for the Department, however, has sought to give an altogether different twist to the argument. His submission was that for the limited purpose, i.e. in the context of Section

    11 (5) of the Act, the meaning to be assigned to the expression debenture; has to be restricted viz. exclude bond. In support of this submission, he referred to sub Section (5) of Section 11 which specifically deals with the investment in certain specific kinds of bonds. He, thus, argued that only those forms and modes of investments as prescribed under sub - 13 - Section (5) of Section 11 of the Act, would be entitled for exemption for the purposes of Section 11 and the investment in other forms of bonds, by necessary implication of inference had to be excluded from the exemption list. Sub Section 5 of Section 11 deals with the investment in bonds of financial corporation, State Government or Central Government. No doubt, specific provision is made in respect of investment in these particular kinds of bonds, however, that would not mean that when we deal with the investment in debentures, which also clarifies for exemption, we have to give restrictive meaning to the term debenture more particularly when this term is not defined under the Act. It is a trite principle of interpretation that in the absence of any definition given to a particular term in a statute, the meaning which is to be given to the said term is the meaning which is understood in common parlance. The Supreme Court in the case of Noorie Manure Mill, Sambhal Vs. Commissioner, Trade Tax, U.P. (2007), 10 SCC 478 observed as under:- - 14 - "In absence of any definition of the term in the statute, the meaning there of as understood in common parlance for the purpose of imposition of tax should be assigned" Even as per new Gem dictionary, the term debenture includes bond of a company or a corporation.

    15. Thus, in the light of these judgments and in terms of the Companies Act, 1956 debenture includes debenture shares and the bonds being interest bearing instruments which represent a loan, FCCB bonds, the instruments issued to investors for raising funds which is repayable after certain period is nothing but a debt instrument. This view is supported by the judgment of the High Court of Madras in case of Commissioner of Income-tax-III Chennai V/s. PVP Ventures Ltd., [(2012) 211 Taxman 554 (Mad.)] confirmed by the Honble Apex Court by dismissing the SLP [C] C.C.2512/2014 filed by the Revenue. For the reasons - 15 - aforesaid, the finding of the Tribunal that the increase or decrease in liability on account of fluctuation in foreign exchange as on the date of the balance sheet would increase or decrease the liability of the assessee and such liability would be on capital account as such, the gain or loss would be on capital account and not taxable cannot be faulted with. Hence, the challenge made by the Revenue on this issue is answered against the Revenue and in favour of the assessee. For the foregoing reasons, the questions of law raised by the Revenue are answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. In the result, appeal stands dismissed. Sd/- JUDGE Sd/- JUDGE

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    PR COMMISSIONER OF v. M/S SUBEX LTD
    (Oct 1, 2021)