Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (S.G. Chattopadhyay, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal was filed by the insurer (National Insurance Company Ltd.) challenging the award dated 20.04.2019 passed by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (No. 5), West Tripura, Agartala in T.S.(MAC) 120 of 2017.

The claim petition arose from a road traffic accident on 19.05.2017 in which Ashutosh Das, a permanent employee of Tripura Jute Mills Limited, sustained grievous injuries and died in the early hours of 20.05.2017. He left behind his wife, three sons and three daughters. The claimants (wife, 3 sons and 3 daughters) filed a claim seeking Rs. 25 lakhs. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 27,76,160 with 9% simple interest from the date of registration of the claim (05.07.2017), along with directions regarding investment of certain shares and timelines for deposit by the insurer.

The insurer appealed, limiting its grounds to three issues concerning (a) the appropriate deduction for personal and living expenses when assessing loss of dependency; (b) addition for future prospects; and (c) deduction for income tax.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Tribunal erred in applying a 1/5 deduction for personal and living expenses (under Sarla Verma) when the insurer contends that only the wife was a dependent and therefore a 1/3 deduction should apply.
  2. Whether the Tribunal erred in adding 15% to the deceased's income towards future prospects where the insurer contends no such addition should have been made because the deceased allegedly exceeded 60 years of age (invoking Pranay Sethi).
  3. Whether the Tribunal should have deducted income tax (10%) from the deceased's salary while assessing actual income for the purpose of computing loss of dependency.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Insurer's) Arguments

  • The deduction for personal and living expenses should have been 1/3 (wife only dependent) rather than 1/5, because the other children (3 sons and 3 daughters) were not dependent: the daughters were married and the sons were earning/adult (survival certificate showed sons were above 30, eldest 37).
  • The Tribunal wrongly added 15% as future prospect because the deceased was above 60 years of age and, according to the insurer's reading of Pranay Sethi, no future prospect addition applies when the deceased is over 60.
  • The Tribunal ought to have deducted 10% for income tax when assessing the annual income of the deceased, because the deceased was a salaried person and taxable income should be assessed net of tax.
  • Only minor children are entitled to parental consortium; married sons and daughters are not entitled to consortium, relying on Somwati and Magma (and related authority).

Respondents' (Claimants') Arguments

  • The Tribunal recorded that the insurer did not deny, before the Tribunal, that the claimants were dependent family members; the insurer cannot take the contrary position on appeal.
  • The deceased's age was recorded as 59 in the Tribunal on the basis of claimants' documentary evidence, and he was a government/pensionable service employee; therefore the 15% addition for future prospect was justified under Pranay Sethi.
  • On deduction of income tax, the respondent contends the deceased's income was only from salary and there was no case that employer failed to deduct TDS. Absent evidence such as the Last Pay Certificate (LPC), the presumption (as explained in Vimal Kanwar) is that tax has been deducted by the employer; insurer must produce evidence to the contrary to procure a tax deduction in assessment.
  • The sons, though married, were asserted by claimants to be non-earning or not in gainful employment and largely dependent on the deceased; insurer did not prove otherwise, so they should be treated as dependent for purposes of calculating loss of dependency. The daughters were married and not dependents for this purpose, though they remain legal representatives entitled to a share of compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation, (2009) 6 SCC 121 Method for deduction for personal and living expenses in assessing loss of dependency based on number of dependents; and that actual income less income tax is the starting point for compensation. The Tribunal initially relied on Sarla Verma to deduct 1/5 because the Tribunal considered the number of dependents to exceed six. The Court analysed the dependents under Sarla Verma and adjusted the deduction to 1/4 based on factual findings about which members were dependents.
National Insurance Company v. Pranay Sethi, (2017) 16 SCC 680 Guidance on adding a percentage for future prospects to income; also paragraph 59.8 used for heads of non-pecuniary compensation (loss of estate, funeral expenses, wife's consortium etc.). The Court applied Pranay Sethi to uphold a 15% addition for future prospects because the deceased was a permanent salaried employee (and was found to be 59 years old). The Court also applied paragraph 59.8 to award Rs. 70,000 for loss of estate, funeral expenses and wife's loss of consortium.
Vimal Kanwar v. Kishore Dan, (2013) 7 SCC 476 Where annual income is in taxable range, actual salary should be read as actual salary less tax; in case of salaried persons, presumption is employer deducts TDS and objector must produce LPC or evidence to show TDS was not deducted. The Court relied on Vimal Kanwar to hold that the insurer's contention for deduction of income tax was unsustainable because the deceased's income was not in taxable range and because insurer produced no LPC or other evidence to show employer failed to deduct TDS.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Somwati, (2020) 2 TLR SC 162 Discusses consortium and refers to the explanation of parental/filial consortium in Magma/Nanu Ram. The Court cited Somwati (which refers to Magma) in rejecting consortium claims by married sons and daughters and in explaining the scope of parental/filial consortium as addressed in the cited authorities.
Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram, (2018) 18 SCC 130 Explains the concept of consortium (parental and filial) and the nature of damages for loss of consortium. The Court relied on the explanation of parental/filial consortium to conclude that parental consortium is for loss of parental aid, protection, affection etc., typically relevant to minor children, and therefore declined to grant consortium to the married adult children in this case.
Manjuri Bera (Smt.) v. Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., (2007) 10 SCC 643 Even if there is no loss of dependency, legal representatives are entitled to compensation not less than liability under Section 140 of Motor Vehicles Act. The Court referred to Manjuri Bera to note that legal representatives are entitled to compensation even in absence of dependency; applied in context to ensure appropriate compensation to legal representatives (while distinguishing dependency status of sons/daughters).
National Insurance Company Limited v. Birender, (2020) 11 SCC 356 Confirming that liability to pay compensation under MV Act does not cease because of absence of dependency; factual considerations may still warrant compensation. The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that legal representatives can be compensated even if not strictly dependent, and used factual analysis to determine whether the sons were dependent in this case.
United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur, AIR 2020 SC 3076 Addressed parental consortium and awarded amounts to children (in that case the children were minors) for parental consortium. The Court relied on United India to explain parental consortium (applicable to children, particularly minors) and to justify refusing parental consortium to the married adult children in the present matter.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed the insurer's three limited grounds sequentially and applied governing precedents and the record evidence. The analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. Deduction for personal and living expenses:
    • The Tribunal had applied a 1/5 deduction under Sarla Verma because it had considered the number of dependents to exceed six. The insurer contended only the wife was a dependent, which would attract 1/3 deduction under Sarla Verma.
    • The Court examined documentary evidence (survival certificate) and the record on whether the sons and daughters were dependent. It accepted the respondents' factual claim that the three daughters were married and living in their matrimonial homes (thus not dependents for this purpose), but it also accepted claimants' case that the three sons were not gainfully employed and were largely dependent on the deceased.
    • Because the insurer failed to prove the contrary (for example, by showing the sons were earning), the Court concluded that three sons plus the wife were dependents—four dependents in total—and therefore a 1/4 deduction for personal and living expenses was appropriate.
  2. Addition for future prospects:
    • The insurer argued no 15% addition should have been made because the deceased allegedly exceeded 60 years of age. The Court noted the Tribunal had recorded the deceased's age as 59 based on documentary evidence submitted by the claimants.
    • Because the deceased was a permanent salaried employee and was recorded as 59, the Court applied the principle in Pranay Sethi and upheld the Tribunal's addition of 15% for future prospects.
  3. Deduction for income tax:
    • The insurer contended the Tribunal should have deducted income tax to arrive at the actual salary. The Court referred to Vimal Kanwar which explains that where income is from salary, there is a presumption that the employer deducted TDS under Section 192(1), and an objector must produce evidence (such as LPC) to show employer failed to deduct TDS.
    • The Court found that the deceased's income was not in the taxable range as per the Income Tax Act in the present record and that the insurer had not produced LPC or other evidence to rebut the presumption of TDS deduction. Thus, the insurer's contention lacked merit and no deduction for tax was made.
  4. Consortium and entitlement:
    • The Court considered the question of parental/filial consortium, relying on Magma and United India (as explained via Somwati). Those authorities describe parental consortium as relevant to loss of parental aid, protection and guidance, often in cases of minor children.
    • Because the sons and daughters were married (and daughters were living separately), the Court found they could not derive benefit under the parental consortium concept; the Tribunal did not err in declining consortium to the married children. The wife alone was awarded consortium damages.
  5. Recalculation and remedial directions:
    • Applying the above findings (1/4 deduction, 15% future prospect, no income-tax deduction), the Court recalculated loss of dependency and additional heads: loss of dependency/relevant computation produced specified figures in the judgment (detailed below), added Rs. 70,000 for estate/funeral/wife's consortium as per paragraph 59.8 of Pranay Sethi, and arrived at the modified total.
    • The Court retained the Tribunal's rate of interest (9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition until payment) and directed the insurer to deposit the modified award amount in the Tribunal within six weeks. Amounts already paid, if any, were to be set off.

Holding and Implications

Holding (core ruling): The appeal is allowed in part: the impugned award dated 20.04.2019 is modified in the respects indicated by the Court's calculations and directions.

Specific Consequences and Directions:

  • The Court recalculated compensation and held that the claimants are entitled to a total sum of Rs. 26,07,034 as compensation (which comprises the recalculated loss of dependency and Rs. 70,000 under heads of loss of estate, funeral expenses and wife's consortium in terms of paragraph 59.8 of Pranay Sethi).
  • The Tribunal's award of interest at 9% per annum from the date of filing of the claim petition remains unchanged.
  • The appellant insurer was directed to deposit the modified amount with the Tribunal within six weeks. Any amount already paid shall be deducted from the award.
  • The appeal is disposed of; pending applications, if any, are disposed of as well.

Implication regarding precedent: The Court applied existing Supreme Court authorities (Sarla Verma, Pranay Sethi, Vimal Kanwar, Magma, Manjuri Bera, National Insurance v. Birender, United India) to the facts; no new legal principle or precedent was created by this decision—the Court applied established ratios to the record evidence to modify the quantum and distribution of the award.

    National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pratibha Das

    S.G. Chattopadhyay, J.:— By means of filing this appeal, the insurance company has challenged the award dated 20.04.2019 passed by MAC Tribunal (No-5) West Tripura, Agartala in T.S.(MAC) 120 of 2017.

    2. The claim petition arose out of the death of Ashutosh Das, a permanent employee of Tripura Jute Mills Limited, who died in a road traffic accident at Agartala on 19/05/2017 leaving behind his wife, 03 sons and 03 daughters.

    3. Prayers made by the appellant insurer in the memo of appeal are as under:

    “Under the circumstances stated above, it is most humbly prayed that Your Lordship would be kind enough to:

    (a) Admit the appeal;

    (b) Call for the record of T.S.(MAC) 120 of 2017 from the then Ld. Member, Sri. S. Bhattacharjee, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Court No. 5, West Tripura District, Agartala;

    (c) Issue Notice upon the respondents.

    After hearing both the parties Hon'ble Court would be pleased enough after setting aside the impugned Award dated 20.04.2019 kindly modify the direction of the impugned Award to the effect 1st ly, that number of dependent on the income of the deceased be one(1) instead of seven (7) and thus 1/3rd instead of 1/5th of the monthly income be deducted as personal expenses, 2nd ly 10% of the monthly salary would be deducted as income tax in order to assess actual monthly income of the deceased and 3rd ly, no amount as future prospect would be added with the monthly income since the deceased was above 60 years of age at the time of death.

    For this act of kindness the applicant shall ever pray.”

    4. The insurer has, thus, assailed the impugned award raising the following issues:

    i) Since the claimants other than the wife of the deceased were not dependent family members of the deceased, 1/5 deduction from the income of the deceased for personal and living expenses made by the Tribunal for the purpose of assessing loss of dependency was erroneous. Wife of the deceased being his only dependent family member, there would be 1/3 deduction as per the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121

    ii) Addition of 15% of the actual salary to the income of the deceased towards future prospect was erroneous because the deceased was above 60 years of age and as per the decision of the Apex Court in the case of National Insurance Company v. Pranay Sethi reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680, there would be no such deduction where the deceased exceeded 60 years of age.

    iii) Tribunal should have assessed his annual income after deducting 10% of the income for income tax.

    5. In view of the limited grounds of appeal, this court will not go into other issues save and except the issues raised by the insurer appellant.

    6. Factual background of the case is that on 18/05/2017, the deceased after visiting his ailing daughter-in-law in Asha nursing home at Palace compound, Agartala was returning home at around 8.30 p.m. On his way, he was hit by the offending motor bike carrying registration No. TR-01-0568. As a result, he sustained grievous injuries. Despite treatment in AGMC and GBP Hospital at Agartala, he succumbed to his injuries at around 2.30 a.m. on the following day.

    7. His wife, 3 sons and 3 daughters being claimants filed a claim petition at the MAC Tribunal (No. 5), West Tripura Judicial District at Agartala claiming compensation to the tune of Rs. 25 lakhs. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the Tribunal framed issues and recorded the evidence adduced by the parties and determined the compensation payble to the claimant at Rs. 27,76,160/- with 9% annual interest on the said amount w.e.f. the date of filing of the claim petition till payment and passed the following order:

    “ORDER

    17. In the result, claim is awarded in following terms:—

    (i) Claimant petitioners are entitled to get the award of Rs. 27,76,160/- (Twenty Seven Lacs Seventy Six thousand one hundred sixty) only with 9% Simple interest per annum from the date of registration of claim i.e. w.e.f. 05.07.2017 till realization from Noticee, the National Insurance Company Ltd. having their Divisional Office at Agartala;

    (ii) Claimant petitioner No. 1 Smt. Pratibha Das being the widow of deceased is exclusively entitled to get the amount awarded under the head of consortium with interest and the rest part of amount be equally divided among all the claimant petitioners;

    (iii) 75% of the total share of claimant petitioner No. 1 Smt. Pratibha Das be invested by purchasing FD certificate from any Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5 years and no loan or advance or pre-mature withdrawal shall be allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal. However, she shall have liberty to withdraw the monthly interest therefrom. Rest part of her share be directly transferred to her individual bank account;

    (iv) 50 % of the share of award of each other claimant petitioners No. 2 to 7 shall also be invested by purchasing FD Certificate from any Nationalized Bank at least for the next 5 years for better interest of their future and no loan or advance or premature withdrawal shall be allowed without prior sanction of this Tribunal. However, they shall have liberty to withdraw the monthly interest therefrom. Rest part of their share shall directly be transferred to their individual bank account;

    (v) Noticee i.e. the National Insurance Company Ltd. shall, within 30 days of the date of announcing the award by this Tribunal, deposit the entire amount awarded in favour of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura, Agartala”.

    8. As noted, the appellant insurer has challenged this award raising 3 grounds which have been mentioned above.

    9. In so far as the deduction for personal and living expenses is concerned, the Tribunal has deducted 1/5 of the income of the deceased as per judgment of the Supreme Court in Sarla Verma (supra) since the number of dependent family members exceeded 6(six). According to the appellant it would be 1/3 since none other than the claimant wife of the deceased was actually a dependent family member of the deceased.

    10. I have Heard Mr. A.K. Deb, learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the respondent.

    11. Counsel appearing for the appellant submits that at the time when the claim petition was filed at the Tribunal, each of the 03 daughters of the deceased were married and the claimant sons of the deceased were also adult and they were independent earning members of the family. Mr. A.K. Deb, learned counsel representing the insurance company having relied on the survival certificate [Exbt.5] has contended that the survival certificate would show that each of his 03 sons were above 30 years of age when their father died and the eldest son was 37 years old and it would also appear from the impugned award of the Tribunal that each of the daughters were also married when their father died in the accident. According to learned counsel, despite these facts being placed on record, the married daughters and sons of the deceased were considered as dependent family members of the deceased against law and loss of dependency was determined by the Tribunal on the basis of such erroneous finding. Learned counsel has, therefore, urges this court to re-assess the loss of dependency after deducting the personal and living expenses of the deceased in terms of the method laid down by the Apex Court in the case of Sarla Verma (supra).

    12. It has also been contended by Mr. A.K. Deb, learned counsel of the appellant that the deceased was a salaried person and as such the income he used to earn was taxable and despite his income being taxable, the Tribunal did not make any deduction for income tax at the time of determination of his income which is grossly erroneous.

    13. It is also contended by learned counsel of the appellant that the deceased had grown up children at the time of when he died and the eldest son of the deceased was 37 years old as per the survival certificate [Exbt.5]. Therefore, claim of the petitioner that deceased was 59 years old at the time of his death is unacceptable.

    14. According to Mr. Deb, learned counsel, the deceased crossed 60 years of age when he died and therefore, 15% increase in his income by Tribunal for future prospect was incorrect and illegal.

    15. With regard to the submission of the counsel of the respondents that the respondent sons and daughters of the deceased were also entitled to consortium, it is argued by Mr. Deb, learned counsel of the appellant that only minor children can be entitled to damages for loss of consortium at the rate determined by the Apex Court in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra). According to learned counsel, married sons and daughters of the deceased are not entitled to consortium.

    16. In support of his contention, Mr. Deb has relied on the decision of the Apex Court in New India Assurance Company Ltd. v. Somwati reported in (2020) 2 TLR SC 162 wherein the Apex Court in paragraph 31 referred to its decision in the case of Magma General Insurance company Ltd. v. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130 in which the concept of consortium was explained as follows:

    “31. The next judgment which needs to be noted is Magma General Insurance Company Limited v. Nanu Ram alias Chuhru Ram, (2018) 18 SCC 130, the concept of consortium was explained in paragraphs 21, 22 and 23 which are as follows:—

    ….21.2. Parental consortium is granted to the child upon the premature death of a parent, for loss of “parental aid, protection, affection, society, discipline, guidance and training”….

    17. It is, therefore, contended by Mr. Deb, learned counsel that no question of granting any parental consortium arises in the case.

    18. On the premises aforesaid, learned counsel urges the court for modification of the award of the Tribunal.

    19. Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel appearing for the respondents opposes the submission of the counsel of the appellant with regard to deduction for personal and living expenses and submits that the Tribunal has categorically observed in paragraph 12 of the award that the appellant did not deny the claim of the respondents at the Tribunal that they were dependent family members of the deceased. According to Mr. Bhattacharje, learned counsel, now in the appeal they cannot take the plea that deduction made by the Tribunal for personal and living expenses were incorrect because the claimants were not dependent family members of the deceased.

    20. With regard to the contention of the appellant that the deceased exceeded the age of 60 years and therefore, 15% increase in his income for future prospect made by the Tribunal was incorrect, it is submitted by learned counsel of the respondents that age of the deceased was recorded as 59 by the Tribunal on the basis of documentary evidence submitted by the claimants. Moreover, he was in Government service at the time of his death. Therefore, such contention of the appellant is not at all justifiable.

    21. With regard to the claim of the appellant for deduction of income tax for assessment of the income of the deceased it is submitted by Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel of the respondents that the deceased was a salaried employee in Tripura Jute Mills Limited. Further submission of learned counsel is that it is no case of the appellant that the deceased had income from other source other than his income from salary. In this situation objection of the appellant is not entertainable unless by producing evidence such as LPC (Last Pay Certificate) of the deceased, the appellant can establish that income of the deceased was within taxable range and employer of the deceased failed to deduct TDS from his salary. In support of his contention, Mr. Bhattacharjee, relied on the decision of the Apex Court in Vimal Kanwar v. Kishore Dan reported in (2013) 7 SCC 476 wherein the Apex Court vide paragraph 23 of the judgment has held as follows:

    “23. In Sarla Verma (Supra), this Court held:

    “20. Generally the actual income of the deceased less income tax should be the starting point for calculating the compensation.”

    This Court further observed that:

    “24…….Where the annual income is in taxable range, the word ‘actual salary' should be read as “actual salary less tax”.

    Therefore, it is clear that if the annual income comes within the taxable range income tax is required to be deducted for determination of the actual salary. But while deducting income-tax from salary, it is necessary to notice the nature of the income of the victim. If the victim is receiving income chargeable under the head “salaries” one should keep in mind that under Section 192(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 any person responsible for paying any income chargeable under the head “salaries” shall at the time of payment, deduct income-tax on estimated income of the employee from “salaries” for that financial year. Such deduction is commonly known as tax deducted at source (‘TDS' for short). When the employer fails in default to deduct the TDS from employee salary, as it is his duty to deduct the TDS, then the penalty for non-deduction of TDS is prescribed under Section 201(1A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. Therefore, in case the income of the victim is only from “salary”, the presumption would be that the employer under Section 192(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 has deducted the tax at source from the employee's salary. In case if an objection is raised by any party, the objector is required to prove by producing evidence such as LPC to suggest that the employer failed to deduct the TDS from the salary of the employee. However, there can be cases where the victim is not a salaried person i.e. his income is from sources other than salary, and the annual income falls within taxable range, in such cases, if any objection as to deduction of tax is made by a party then the claimant is required to prove that the victim has already paid income tax and no further tax has to be deducted from the income.”

    22. It is therefore, submitted by Mr. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel that contention of the appellant with regard to deduction of income tax for determination of the income of the deceased is unsustainable.

    23. It is true that as per the survival certificate [Exbt.5], the deceased was survived by his wife, 3 sons and 3 married daughters. Counsel for the appellant has submitted that the sons being earning members of the family and the daughters being married, they would not be considered as dependent family members of the deceased. Therefore, 1/5 deduction made by the Tribunal towards personal and living expenses for determination of loss of dependency was incorrect. Wife of the deceased being the only dependent member, deduction for personal and living expenses in the given context would be 1/3.

    24. Since the deceased was 59 years at the time of his death in the accident, the Tribunal by the impugned award made the addition of 15% for future prospect for assessment of his income. There is no wrong in the finding of the Tribunal because the deceased had a permanent job and as per the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Pranay Sethi (supra) in such situation the deduction should be 15%.

    25. In the case of Manjuri Bera(Smt.) v. Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. reported in (2007) 10 SCC 643, the Apex Court held that even if there is no loss of dependency, the claimant even he or she is the legal representative will be entitled to compensation, the quantum of which shall not be less than the liability flowing from Section 140 of the Motor Vehicles Act. In National Insurance Company Limited v. Birender reported in (2020) 11 SCC 356, the Apex Court having made reference to Manjuri Bera (supra) held that liability to pay compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act does not cease because of absence of dependency of the legal representatives. Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act provides, inter alia, that an application for compensation where death has resulted from the accident may be made by all or any of the legal representatives of the deceased. In the said case of National Insurance Company Limited (supra), the appellant insurance company contended that the respondents were not entitled to compensation for loss of dependency as they were major and earning. In the context of the case, the Apex Court held that though they were major and married sons of the deceased, they had a very meager income who were largely dependent on the earning of their deceased mother. Situated thus, the Apex Court granted adequate compensation to them.

    26. In the present context counsel appearing for the claimants has submitted that none of the sons of the deceased were in gainful employment and they were largely dependent on the income of their father who used to live together in a joint mess. The appellant could not prove the contrary by adducing evidence. In these circumstances, the 3 sons, though married, should be treated as the dependent family members of the deceased. In respect of the daughters, there is no denial of the fact that all the 03 daughters were married at the time of death of their father. Each of them was living in their respective matrimonial home. Therefore, though they were entitled to claim compensation for the death of their father as his legal representatives, they cannot be considered as dependent family members of the deceased for the purpose of deduction towards personal and living expenses.

    27. In view of what is discussed above, the dependent family members would be 4 in this case and there should be 1/4 deduction towards personal and living expenses instead of 1/5 deduction.

    28. As regards the contention of the counsel of the appellant for deduction of income tax, in view of the ratio decided by the Apex Court in Vimal Kanwar (supra) and in view of the fact that income of the deceased was not in the taxable range as per the Income Tax Act, 1961, submission of the counsel of the appellant made in this regard lacks merit.

    29. With regard to payment of consortium, it was contended by the counsel of the respondent that the trial court should have granted parental consortium in this case. Counsel relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in Magma General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Nanu Ram reported in (2018) 18 SCC 130 and Apex Court's decision in United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Satinder Kaur reported in AIR 2020 SC 3076. In the case of Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. (supra) deceased was a bachelor. Father, brother and sisters filed the claim petition. The Apex Court granted 40,000/- to each of the claimant brother and sister for loss of filial consortium. In the case of United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (supra), the Apex Court granted 40,000/- to each of the children of the deceased for loss of parental consortium. Each of the children in that case were minor and the Apex Court observed that parental consortium is granted to the child upon the premature death of a parent for loss of parental aid, protection, affection, society, discipline, guidance and training. In the case in hand, the sons and daughters of the deceased were all married when the deceased died in the accident. Situated thus, respondents cannot derive any benefit from the judgments cited above. The Tribunal did not commit any error in declining to grant consortium to the claimant sons and daughters of the deceased.

    30. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the amount payable towards compensation will have to be recalculated. Accordingly, after recalculation, the impugned award is modified as under:

    31. Loss of dependency due to loss of income is calculated at Rs. 29,41,488[(Rs. 27,236/- × 12 × 9)+(15% future prospect)−(1/4 deduction for personal and living expenses)] = Rs. 25,37,034/- in addition, the claimants would be entitled to a sum of Rs. 70,000/-[(Loss of estate : Rs. 15,000/-+funeral expenses Rs. 15,000/-+ wife's loss of consortium Rs. 40,000/-)] in terms of the mandate in paragraph 59.8 of Pranay Sethi (supra). Thus a total sum of Rs. 26,07,034/- (Rupees Twenty-Six Lakhs Seven Thousand and Thirty-four) is payable to the claimants as compensation. The rate of interest awarded by the Tribunal will remain unchanged which will be paid from the date of filing of the claim petition at the tribunal till payment. The claimants will have equal share of the compensation except the amount granted to the wife of the deceased for loss of consortium. Amount already paid, if any, shall be deducted from the amount awarded hereunder.

    32. In view of the above observation and directions, the impugned award dated 20/04/2019 in T.S.(MAC) 120 of 2017 passed by the Member, MACT(5) West Tripura, Agartala titled as Smt. Pratibha Das v. Prakash Debbarma, stands modified to the extent as indicated above. Appellant insurer is directed to pay the said amount of compensation to the claimant respondents within a period of 6 weeks by depositing the same at the Tribunal.

    33. In terms of the above, present appeal is disposed of.

    34. Pending application(s), if any, also stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Pratibha Das
    (Apr 23, 2021)