Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 158, 185 and 57 of the M.P. Trusts Act, 1951
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sec. 158, 185 and 57 of the M.P. Trusts Act, 1951
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (S.C. Sharma, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ appeal challenges the judgment dated 31-10-2018 in W.P. No. 3428/2017 (Sagar Bai v. State of M.P.). The core facts are:

  • Several parcels of agricultural land at Gram Bawal Nai, Tehsil Javad, District Neemuch were recorded in the revenue records in the name of the deity "Lord Shri Girdharnath Ji" (the temple) with specific survey numbers and areas set out in the record.
  • Respondent No.4 (Mohini Kunwar), recorded as Manager in the revenue record, filed a civil suit for declaration of title and permanent injunction after her name was deleted from the revenue record as Manager and the Collector's name was mutated; the Collector was proposing auction.
  • Despite the land being recorded in the name of the deity, respondent No.4 executed sale deeds of temple land in favour of respondent Nos.1–3 on dates in 2003–2004. The Gram Panchayat passed a resolution on 7-6-2004 to mutate the names of respondent Nos.1–3 in the revenue record.
  • A complaint resulted in the Sub Divisional Officer (SDO) cancelling the Gram Panchayat resolution by order dated 23-2-2011 and granting liberty to the appellant to challenge the sale deeds. Successive administrative appeals were dismissed for want of maintainability; a Second Appeal and a revision to the Board of Revenue were also dismissed.
  • Respondent Nos.1–4 filed a writ petition under Articles 226/227; the Single Judge allowed the writ petition, concluding the temples were private property of respondent No.4, that respondent No.4 could execute the sale deeds, and that mutation in favour of respondent Nos.1–3 was valid.
  • The Division Bench (this Court) examined the revenue records and precedent and concluded the properties were dedicated to the deity (a juristic person), the deity is a "perpetual minor," the Manager cannot be the title holder nor sell the property, and accordingly set aside the Single Judge's order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether land recorded in the name of a deity (temple) vests in the deity as a juristic person such that the Manager cannot be treated as the title-holder with competence to execute valid sale deeds.
  2. Whether a sale deed executed by a Manager of temple property and subsequent mutation based on that sale can be upheld where revenue records show the title in the deity's name.
  3. Whether the Single Judge's conclusion that the temples were private property of respondent No.4 and that mutation pursuant to the Gram Panchayat resolution was valid should be sustained in light of revenue records and relevant precedent.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Bijoy Krishna Mishra v. Chittaranjan Das Bera, 2016 SCC OnLine Cal 4476 Expressed a view similar to the proposition that property dedicated to a deity cannot be disposed of as if privately owned. The Court noted this case takes a similar view and relied on the consistency of judicial approach in supporting the conclusion that the manager cannot override the deity's title.
A.A. Gopalkrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board, (2007) 7 SCC 482 (also cited as (2008) 1 MP LJ 235) The properties of deities, temples and Devaswom Boards require protection; the deity's properties are vulnerable to usurpation by managers and must be safeguarded; courts have a duty to protect such properties (paragraph 10 quoted). The Court expressly relied on paragraph 10 of this judgment to hold that, given the deity is a "perpetual minor" whose rights require protection, the sale could not lawfully have taken place and the mutation was bad in law.
Kailash Chand v. Board of Revenue for Rajasthan Ajmer, 2008 SCC OnLine Raj 839 Reached a similar conclusion on the protection of temple/deity property and limitations on managers/trustees disposing of such property. The Court cited this Division Bench decision as another instance where the same legal position has been adopted, supporting the conclusion reached in the present case.
State of M.P. v. Pujari Utthan Avam Kalyan Samiti, (2017) 3 MP LJ 377 Held that a Pujari (priest) mutated in the revenue record remains a Manager and does not become the title-holder; the deity remains the title-holder. The Court referred to this Division Bench decision to reinforce that the manager/pujari cannot be treated as the title-holder and thus cannot validly alienate deity-owned property.
Gayaprasad v. State of M.P., 2009 RN 347 After considering sections of the M.P. Trusts Act, held that the Pujari cannot claim Bhumiswami or tenant rights; the deity (juristic person) can hold property and trustees/managers cannot claim title. The Court relied on this authority to emphasize that once revenue records show the deity as title-holder, the manager has no right to dispose of the property; this supported setting aside the Single Judge's affirmation of the sale and mutation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from the established facts in the revenue records and a review of relevant authority:

  1. The revenue record unambiguously showed the disputed land as recorded in the name of the deity "Mandir Shri Girdharnath Ji" with respondent No.4 identified as the Manager; it was not recorded in the name of respondent No.4 or her ancestors.
  2. Because the property was dedicated to the deity, the deity is treated as a juristic person (a perpetual minor in legal character), and the legal title vests in the deity, not in the Manager.
  3. Given that legal position, the Manager (respondent No.4) lacked the competence to alienate the property by executing sale deeds in favour of respondent Nos.1–3; such alienations are inconsistent with the status of deity-owned property.
  4. The Court relied principally on A.A. Gopalkrishnan (para.10 quoted) to underscore the obligation to protect properties of deities from usurpation and on other cited authorities (Bijoy Krishna Mishra, Kailash Chand, State of M.P. v. Pujari Utthan Avam Kalyan Samiti, Gayaprasad) which reached like conclusions regarding the non-disposability of dedicated temple property by managers/pujaris.
  5. Applying those principles to the factual matrix — sale deeds executed by the Manager, subsequent Gram Panchayat resolution to mutate revenue records, and the Single Judge's contrary conclusion that the temples were private property — the Court concluded the Single Judge erred in affirming the sale/mutation.
  6. The Court observed that the administrative orders cancelling the Gram Panchayat resolution (SDO and later authorities) and the Board of Revenue's order setting aside the resolution were valid; the Single Judge's order affirming the mutation and sale was therefore set aside.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Writ Appeal is allowed and disposed of. The Division Bench set aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge that had affirmed the sale and mutation of the temple property.

Implications and direct consequences (as stated by the Court):

  • The Court declared that the property recorded in the name of the deity is vested in the deity as a juristic person; the Manager (respondent No.4) is not the title-holder and lacked the competence to execute sale deeds over deity-owned land.
  • The sale deeds executed by respondent No.4 and the subsequent Gram Panchayat resolution to mutate names in revenue records were invalid in law; the Single Judge's order affirming that sale and mutation was set aside.
  • The Division Bench affirmed the validity of the administrative orders (SDO and Board of Revenue) that set aside the Gram Panchayat resolution (i.e., they were "certainly valid orders" as per the opinion).
  • No new legal principle was asserted beyond applying established authorities: the decision applies existing precedent to the facts and does not purport to create new law beyond those holdings.

Disposition recorded in the opinion: "Appeal allowed."

    Surendra Singh v. Sagarbai

    S.C. Sharma, J.:— The appellant before this Court has filed this Writ Appeal being aggrieved by the judgment dated 31-10-2018 passed in W.P. No. 3428/2017, Sagar Bai v. State of M.P. [2018 MPLJ Online 48].

    2. Facts of the case reveal that the respondents before this Court were claiming themselves to be the owners of Temples and the land appurtenant thereto. The agricultural land situated at Gram Bawal Nai, Tehsil Javad, District Neemuch was recorded in the revenue record in the name of Lord Shri Girdharnath Ji. The details of the land attached to the temples and recorded in the name of deity are as under:

    Survey No. Area in Hectares 423/1 0.575 115 0.177 116 0.355 117 0.329 118/1 0.052 118/2 0.052 120 0.533 121 1.859

    3. The respondent in the present appeal, (respondent No. 4) who was the petitioner before the learned Single Judge, has filed a Civil Suit seeking declaration of title and permanent injunction with regard to the disputed temples/land attached to it. The necessity arose to file a Civil Suit only because the name of the petitioner/respondent No. 4 was deleted from the revenue record as a Manager and the name of the Collector was mutated in place of respondent No. 4. The Collector was going to auction the land attached to the temple and in those circumstances a necessity arose to file a Civil Suit. The relevant paragraphs in the plaint preferred by the respondent No. 4 against the State Government, are as under:

    4. By a judgment dated 3-4-1991, the trial Court has granted a decree for declaration and permanent injunction and paragraph 28 of the judgment dated 3-4-1991 reads as under:

    5. Thereafter a First Appeal was preferred against the judgment dated 3-4-1991 by the respondent Collector/State and the First Appeal was also dismissed on 23-12-1997, meaning thereby, in place of Collector, Mandsaur, the name of plaintiff/respondent No. 4/petitioner was to be mutated. The revenue record, in the present case, categorically reveals that the land in question is in the name of deity and Column No. 2 of the Revenue Record, which was annexed as Annexure P/1 with the Writ Petition, categorically mentions the owner of the land/title holder of the land as Mandir Shri Girdharnath Ji, through Manager Mohini Kunwar. Thus, undisputedly, the property was in the name of deity.

    6. In spite of the fact that the property was in the name of deity, the respondent No. 4 before this Court - Mohini Kunwar has executed a sale deed of agricultural land exclusively belonging to the temple to respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 on 31-3-2004, 5-5-2004 and 10-11-2003.

    7. The Gram Panchayat passed a resolution on 7-6-2004 for mutating the name of respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 in the revenue records. Mutation of name the revenue record is always done by the Tehsildar and there is a prescribed procedure provided under the M.P. Land Revenue Code, 1959 and in those circumstances a complaint was made before the Sub Divisional Officer and the Sub Divisional Officer by order dated 23-2-2011 has cancelled the resolution passed by the Gram Panchayat and liberty was also granted to the present appellant to take appropriate action in accordance with law for challenging the sale deed.

    8. An appeal was preferred against the order passed by the Sub Divisional Officer and the appellate authority by order dated 3-8-2011 has dismissed the appeal for want of maintainability.

    9. Thereafter a Second Appeal was preferred against the order dated 3-8-2011 and the same was also dismissed by the Addl. Commissioner, Ujjain Division, Ujjain by order dated 23-4-2011. The respondent Nos. 1 to 4 thereafter preferred a revision before the Board of Revenue and the Board of Revenue ha also dismissed by revision by order dated 8-2-2017. The respondent Nos. 1 to 4 thereafter filed a Writ Petition under Article 226/227 of the Constitution of India and the learned Single Judge has allowed the Writ Petition. The learned Single Judge has arrived at a conclusion that the temples in question were the private property of respondent No. 4 and there is a difference between private temples and the temples open for public. It has also been observed that the authorities have wrongly concluded that the suit property is deity's property and, therefore, the mutation done on the basis of sale deed executed by respondent No. 4 was in order. The learned Single Judge has arrived at a conclusion that respondent No. 4 was competent to execute sale deed in favour of respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 an respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 are entitled to get their name mutated in the revenual records, pursuant to the resolution passed by the Gram Panchayat dated 7-6-2004.

    10. In the present case, the undisputed facts as established from the record makes it very clear that the temples in question and the lands attached to the temple were recorded in the revenue records in the name of Mandir Shri Girdharnath Ji and respondent No. 4 is the Manager. It is not a case where the land is recorded in the name of respondent No. 4 or her ancestors showing existence of a temple. The property in question was dedicated to the deity and the deity is perpetual minor and by no stretch of imagination, the property could have been sold by sale deed as the deity is the title holder of the property.

    11. A similar view has been taken by the Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court in the case of Bijoy Krishna Mishra v. Chittaranjan Das Bera, reported in 2016 SCC OnLine Cal 4476. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of A.A. Gopalkrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board, reported in (2008) 1 MP LJ 235 : (2007) 7 SCC 482 in paragraph 10 has held as under:

    10. The properties of deities, temples and Devaswom Boards, require to be protected and safeguarded by their Trustees/Archaks/Sebaits/employees. Instances are many where persons entrusted with the duty of managing and safeguarding the properties of temples, deities and Devaswom Boards have usurped and misappropriated such properties by setting up false claims of ownership or tenancy, or adverse possession. This is possible only with the passive or active collusion of the concerned authorities. Such acts of ‘fences eating the crops’ should be dealt with sternly. The Government, members or trustees of Boards/Trusts, and devotees should be vigilant to prevent any such usurpation or encroachment. It is also the duty of Courts to protect and safeguard the properties of religious and charitable institutions from wrongful claims or misappropriation.

    12. In the light of the aforesaid judgment, as the deity is a perpetual minor and rights of the deity are to be protected by the Courts, no sale of land could have taken place in the manner and method it has been done and, therefore, the subsequent resolution passed by the Gram Panchayat for mutation of name is bad in law.

    13. The Division Bench of Rajasthan High Court in the case of Kailash Chand v. Board of Revenue for Rajasthan Ajmer, reported in 2008 SCC OnLine Raj 839 has taken a similar view.

    14. The Division Bench of this Court in the case of State of M.P. v. Pujari Utthan Avam Kalyan Samiti, reported in (2017) 3 MP LJ 377 has taken a similar view. It has been held in the aforesaid that the name of the Pujari mutated in the revenue record, cannot be replaced by the Collector, however, the fact remains that the Pujari will continue to be a Manager, he does not become the title holder and it is the deity who is the title holder of the property.

    15. In another case decided by this Court i.e., Gayaprasad v. State of M.P., reported in 2009 RN 347, this Court after taking into account Sec. 158, 185 and 57 of the M.P. Trusts Act, 1951 has held that the Pujari cannot claim right of Bhumiswami or even right of a tenant and the deity being a juristic person can hold the same. It has been further stated that in respect of the property owned by the deity, it being a religious property, no right can be claimed by the Trustee or the Manager. Thus, in short, once it is an established fact that the title holder of the property is a deity, as in the present case, which is established from the revenue record (Annexure P/1) filed with the Writ Petition. The respondent No. 4 is simply a Manager and not the title holder. The title holder is Mandir Shri Girdharnath Ji (the deity) and, therefore, this Court is of the considered opinion that the order passed by the revenue authorities does not warrant any interference and the order passed by the learned Single Judge deserves to be set aside.

    16. It is a well settled proposition of law that dedicated property vests in the idol as a juristic person. When a property is given absolutely by a pious Hindu for worship of an idol, the property vests in the idol itself as a juristic person. There are various judgments delivered from time to time on this issue. The Hindu idol is a juridical subject and the pious idea that it embodies is given the status of a legal person and is deemed capable in law for holding property in the same way as a natural person. It has a juridical status, with the power of suing and being sued. Its interest are attended to by the person who has the deity in his charge and who is in law its Manager, with all the powers which would, in such circumstances, on analogy, be given to the Manager of the estate of an infant heir and, therefore, once the property has been given to a temple, which is known as debutter or endowment in favour of the established idol, the question of its disposal by the Manager is illegal. Once the property is dedicated to the deity which is a juristic person holding the title, cannot be sold by the Manager, as has been done in the present case and, therefore, the order of the Board of Revenue by which the resolution of the Gram Panchayat has been set aside in respect of the mutation, are certainly valid orders and, therefore, the order passed by the learned Single Judge which affirms the sale and mutation of the property belonging to the deity, deserves to be set aside and is accordingly hereby set aside.

    17. The Writ Appeal stands allowed and disposed of.

    Appeal allowed

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Surendra Singh v. Sagarbai
    (Jul 3, 2019)