AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 138 of the Act (year not specified)
  • The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (Sections 19, 20, and 21)
  • Section 143-A of the NI Act
  • Section 138 of the NI Act, 1881
  • Section 144 of the Act
  • Chapter XVII of the NI Act, 1881
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 138 of the Act (year not specified)
  • The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 (Sections 19, 20, and 21)
  • Section 143-A of the NI Act
  • Section 138 of the NI Act, 1881
  • Section 144 of the Act
  • Chapter XVII of the NI Act, 1881
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition before the Court stemmed from the dishonour of two cheques dated 27-1-2005 for a total amount of Rs 1,70,000. Although Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 (NI Act) contemplates a summary trial to be concluded within six months, the matter remained pending for nearly 15 years, traversing all judicial tiers up to the Supreme Court. Citing this illustrative delay and the systemic problem of over 35 lakh pending Section 138 cases, the Court decided to broaden the scope of the matter. It ordered that the case be registered separately as a Suo Motu Writ Petition (Criminal) titled “Expeditious trial of cases under Section 138 of the NI Act, 1881.”

Legal Issues Presented

  1. How can courts, law-enforcement agencies, banks and other stakeholders ensure the expeditious disposal of Section 138 NI Act cases in alignment with statutory mandates and prior Supreme Court directions?
  2. What systemic mechanisms—such as improved service of process, use of technology, pre-litigation ADR, and specialised courts—should be implemented to reduce the existing backlog and prevent future delays?
  3. Should aspects of Section 138 offences, especially those involving small amounts, be considered for decriminalisation and relegated to civil jurisdiction?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Indian Bank Assn. v. Union of India (2014) 5 SCC 590 Mandates for summary trial, timely recording of complainant’s evidence, completion of trial within six months, day-to-day hearing, and pragmatic issuance of summons. The Court relied on these directives to highlight existing statutory and judicial requirements for speedy trials and to underscore the need for realistic service of summons, including email and police assistance.
Meters & Instruments (P) Ltd. v. Kanchan Mehta (2018) 1 SCC 560 Use of technology (email, online filing), requirement for banks to share email IDs of accused, and observations on potential online disposal of certain Section 138 cases. Formed the basis for suggesting technological solutions, information-sharing by banks, and consideration of online adjudication to ease court congestion.
K.N. Govindan Kutty Menon v. C.D. Shaji (2012) 2 SCC 51 Lok Adalat award in a Section 138 matter is deemed a civil court decree, executable without further litigation. Cited to support the proposal for pre-litigation settlement of cheque-bounce disputes through the Legal Services Authorities Act mechanisms.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court traced the legislative intent of criminalising cheque dishonour—to uphold banking credibility and provide swift compensation—and contrasted it with the present reality of massive backlog. It identified the principal cause of delay as the failure to secure the accused’s presence, noting that over half of pending cases languish for this reason.

Building on statutory provisions (Sections 62, 66, 67, 72, 82 and 83 CrPC; Section 144 NI Act) and prior Supreme Court directions, the Court proposed a multi-pronged strategy:

  • Adopt diversified modes of service—speed post, courier, police, email, and territorial court assistance—and hold negligent officers accountable.
  • Require banks to furnish email IDs, mobile numbers, and permanent addresses of account-holders to complainants and police; RBI to frame enabling guidelines and explore redesigning cheque pro forma to include such information and purpose of payment.
  • Develop software-based tracking of summons and explore electronic transfer of interim compensation or fines directly from the accused’s bank account.
  • Invoke coercive measures, including attachment under Section 83 CrPC, to compel appearance and recover amounts due.
  • Promote pre-litigation settlement through Lok Adalats under the Legal Services Authorities Act to reduce docket burden, supported by the precedent that such awards have the force of civil decrees.
  • Encourage High Courts to establish exclusive Section 138 courts in high-pendency jurisdictions and to consider online or video-conferenced proceedings where feasible.

The Court emphasised that these measures require coordination among banks, police, legal services authorities, and judiciary, necessitating broader consultation.

Holding and Implications

The Court ordered registration of the matter as a Suo Motu Writ Petition (Criminal) captioned “Expeditious trial of cases under Section 138 of the NI Act, 1881,” appointed two Amici Curiae, issued notices to the Union of India, all High Courts, State and UT Police Chiefs, National Legal Services Authority, Reserve Bank of India, and Indian Banks’ Association, and listed the case for 16-4-2020.

Implications: The order initiates a systemic review aimed at reforming the handling of cheque-dishonour prosecutions nationwide. Although no immediate substantive relief was granted to the litigants, the proceedings could lead to new procedural frameworks, technological integration, and policy guidelines affecting all future Section 138 cases. No new legal precedent on merits was set at this stage; the impact will depend on subsequent directions in the suo motu proceedings.

    Makwana Mangaldas Tulsidas v. State Of Gujarat And Another

    Order

    1. This petition relates to dishonour of two cheques on 27-1-2005, for a total amount of Rs 1,70,000, tried and contested over a period of 15 years up till this Court. A matter which is supposed to be disposed of summarily by the trial court in six months, it took seven years for this case to be disposed of at the trial court level. A dispute of such nature has remained pending for 15 years in various courts, taking judicial time and space up to this Court.

    2. Dishonour of cheque, which originally gave cause of action to file a civil suit, was criminalised in the year 1988, with the insertion of Chapter XVII in the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. Cheque dishonour, followed by default in payment after a demand notice, became punishable under Section 138 with imprisonment or fine which may extend to twice the amount of the cheque or both.

    3. The legislative intent behind the abovementioned amendment was to ensure faith in the efficacy of banking operations and credibility in transacting business on cheques. It was to provide a strong criminal remedy in order to deter the high incidence of dishonour of cheques and ensure compensation to the complainant. Subsequent amendments in the Act and the pronouncements of this Court reflect that it was always perceived that these cases would be disposed of speedily so as to preserve the object of criminalisation of the act.

    4. Despite many changes brought through legislative amendments and various decisions of this Court mandating speedy trial and disposal of these cases, the trial courts are filled with large number of pendency of these cases. A recent study of the pending cases, reflects pendency of more than 35 lakh, which constitutes more than 15 per cent of the total criminal cases pending in the District Courts. Further, there is a steady increase in the docket burden.

    5. A plain reading of Chapter XVII of the NI Act, 1881 and the judgments of this Court in Indian Bank Assn. v. Union of India (2014) 5 SCC 590 and Meters & Instruments (P) Ltd. v. Kanchan Mehta (2018) 1 SCC 560 would show the following mandates with regard to the expeditious trial of cases of this nature:

    (a) The trial of cases relating to Section 138 of the Act must be with nature of summary trial unless reasons call for summons trial, which is always exceptional.
    (b) The evidence of the complainant must be conducted within three months of assigning the case.
    (c) Endeavour must be made to conclude the trial within six months from the date of filing of the complaint.
    (d) The trial, as far as practicable, must be held on a day-to-day basis unless reasons exist to do otherwise.

    Though, these mandates exist, they cannot operate in vacuum without addressing the factors attributable to the long delay of disposal of cases, urging holistic consideration.

    6. One of the major factors, for high pendency is delay in ensuring the presence of the accused before the court for trial. As per recent study, more than half of the pending cases i.e. more than 18 lakh cases, are pending due to absence of accused.

    7. This Court in Indian Bank Assn. (2014) 5 SCC 590, has held that Magistrate should adopt a pragmatic and realistic approach while issuing process to ensure the presence of the accused. The direction was passed as follows :

    “23.2. The MM/JM should adopt a pragmatic and realistic approach while issuing summons. Summons must be properly addressed and sent by post as well as by email address got from the complainant. The court, in appropriate cases, may take the assistance of the police or the nearby court to serve notice on the accused. For notice of appearance, a short date be fixed. If the summons is received back unserved, immediate follow-up action be taken.”

    8. Taking effect from Section 144 of the Act, Sections 62, 66 and 67 CrPC and directions of this Court, the Magistrate may opt for one or many of the methods of service of summons, including service through speed post or the courier services, police officer or any other person, email or through a court having territorial jurisdiction.

    9. Despite service of summons issued through aforesaid mediums, the problem of non-execution of further process persists. While summons may be issued through aforementioned modes, bailable warrants and non-bailable warrants are to be executed through police as per Section 72 CrPC. Many a time, police as serving agency, does not give heed to the process issued in private complaints. Courts also remain ambivalent of this fact, requiring the complainant to pay unjustified process fee, repeatedly and avoid to take action against negligent police officers. The coercive methods to secure the presence of accused viz. attachment indicated in Sections 82 and 83 CrPC, are seldom resorted.

    10. Having regard to the prevailing state of affairs, we find that there is a need to evolve a system of service/execution of process issued by the court and ensuring the presence of the accused, with the concerted efforts of all the stakeholders like the complainant, police and banks. One step in such direction was taken by this Court in Meters & Instruments (P) Ltd. (2018) 1 SCC 560, where it had directed the banks to give the details of email of the accused to the payee/complainant for service through email. It was held :

    “20. In every complaint under Section 138 of the Act, it may be desirable that the complainant gives his bank account number and if possible email ID of the accused. If email ID is available with the Bank where the accused has an account, such Bank, on being required, should furnish such email ID to the payee of the cheque.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    11. Banks, being important stakeholders in cases of this nature, it is their responsibility to provide requisite details and facilitate an expeditious trial mandated by law. An information sharing mechanism may be developed where the banks share all the requisite details available of the accused, who is the account holder, with the complainant and the police for the purpose of execution of process. This may include a requirement to print relevant information viz. the email id, registered mobile number and permanent address of the account holder, on the cheque or dishonour memo informing the holder about the dishonour. Reserve Bank of India, being the regulatory body may also evolve guidelines for banks to facilitate requisite information for the trial of these cases and such other matters as may be required. A separate software-based mechanism may be developed to track and ensure the service of process on the accused in cases relating to an offence under Section 138 of the NI Act.

    12. With ensuring the credibility of cheques, it is equally important that cheques are not allowed to be misused giving cause to frivolous litigation. Reserve Bank of India may consider developing a new pro forma of cheques so as to include the purpose of payment, along with other information mentioned above to facilitate adjudication of real issues.

    13. Further, a mechanism may be developed to ensure the presence of the accused even by way of coercive measure, if required, taking effect from Section 83 CrPC which allows attachment of property, including movable property. A similar coordinated effort may be evolved to recover interim compensation under Section 143-A of the NI Act as well as fine or compensation to be recovered as per Section 421 CrPC. The bank may facilitate mechanism for transferring requisite funds from the bank account of the accused to the account of the holder in due course, as may be directed by the court.

    14. With ever growing institution of NI cases, there is a need of developing a mechanism for pre-litigation settlement in these cases. The Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 provides for a statutory mechanism for disposal of cases by Lok Adalat at pre-litigation stage under Sections 19 and 20 of the Act. Further, Section 21 of the Act, recognises an award passed by Lok Adalats as a decree of a civil court and gives it a finality. This Court in K.N. Govindan Kutty Menon v. C.D. Shaji (2012) 2 SCC 51 has held that :

    “26. (4) Even if a matter is referred by a criminal court under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 and by virtue of the deeming provisions, the award passed by the Lok Adalat based on a compromise has to be treated as a decree capable of execution by a civil court.”

    15. The effect of the above legal proposition is that an award passed at the pre-litigation stage or pre-cognizance stage shall have an effect of a civil decree. The National Legal Services Authority, being the responsible authority in this regard, may evolve a scheme for settlement of dispute relating to cheque bounce at pre-litigation i.e. before filing of the private complaint. This measure of pre-litigation ADR process can go a long way in settling the cases before they come to court, thereby reducing docket burden.

    16. The High Courts, in addition to the above, may also consider setting up of exclusive courts to deal with matters relating to Section 138, especially in establishments where the pendency is above a standard figure. Special norms for assessment of the work of exclusive courts may also be formulated giving additional weightage to disposal of case within the time-frame as per legal requirement.

    17. This Court in Meters & Instruments (P) Ltd. (2018) 1 SCC 560, observed the following :

    “17. … Use of modern technology needs to be considered not only for paperless courts but also to reduce overcrowding of courts. There appears to be need to consider categories of cases which can be partly or entirely concluded “online” without physical presence of the parties by simplifying procedures where seriously disputed questions are not required to be adjudicated. Traffic challans may perhaps be one such category. At least some number of Section 138 cases can be decided online. If complaint with affidavits and documents can be filed online, process issued online and the accused pays the specified amount online, it may obviate the need for personal appearance of the complainant or the accused. Only if the accused contests, need for appearance of parties may arise which may be through counsel and wherever viable, videoconferencing can be used. Personal appearances can be dispensed with on suitable self-operating conditions. This is a matter to be considered by the High Courts and wherever viable, appropriate directions can be issued.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    In view of the above, the status of directions issued or measures adopted by the High Courts may be assessed and a best suited mechanism in this direction may be considered.

    18. In Meters & Instruments (P) Ltd. (2018) 1 SCC 560, this Court had also observed that the nature of offence under Section 138 primarily relates to a civil wrong. While criminalising of dishonour of cheques took place in the year 1988 taking into account the magnitude of economic transactions today, decriminalisation of dishonour of cheque of a small amount may also be considered, leaving it to be dealt with under civil jurisdiction.

    19. These are some indicative aspects in addition to what may come on board after hearing the relevant duty-holders. To work out mechanism for expeditious and just adjudication of cases relating to dishonour of cheques, fulfilling the mandate of law and reduce high pendency, various duty-holders like banks, police and Legal Services Authorities may be required to take measures and prepare schemes. Thus, we find it necessary to hear them for evolving a concerted, coordinated mechanism for expeditious adjudication of these cases as per the legal mandate.

    20. Let the matter be registered separately as Suo Motu Writ Petition (Criminal) with the caption “Expeditious trial of cases under Section 138 of the NI Act, 1881”.

    21. We request Shri Sidharth Luthra, Senior Advocate to assist the Court as Amicus Curiae. We also appoint Shri K. Parameshwar, Advocate as Amicus Curiae to assist him in the matter.

    22. Issue notice to the Union of India through Law Secretary, Registrar General of all the High Courts, the Director General of Police of all the States and Union Territories, Member Secretary of the National Legal Services Authority, Reserve Bank of India and Indian Banks' Association, Mumbai as the representatives of banking institutions.

    23. List both the matters on 16-4-2020.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Makwana Mangaldas Tulsidas v. State Of Gujarat And Another
    (Mar 5, 2020)