Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 78 of 1990, u/s 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) S.C./S.T. Act
  • Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act,
  • Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.
  • Sections 147, 148, 435, 436/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.(20)
  • Sections 147, 148, 302/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.(18)
  • Sections 147, 148, 302/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 427, 295, 307 I.P.C., P. S.
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 307, 427 and 295 I.P.C.
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 427, 295, 307 I.P.C.,
  • provision of Section 437-A Cr.P.C.5.
  • Sections 435, 436/149 I.P.C.(19)
  • Section 161 Cr.P.C.(80)
  • Ram, section 302 I.P.C.
  • Section 161 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 149 I.P.C.,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • 78 of 1990, u/s 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) S.C./S.T. Act
  • Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act,
  • Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.
  • Sections 147, 148, 435, 436/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.(20)
  • Sections 147, 148, 302/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.(18)
  • Sections 147, 148, 302/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 427, 295, 307 I.P.C., P. S.
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 307, 427 and 295 I.P.C.
  • Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 427, 295, 307 I.P.C.,
  • provision of Section 437-A Cr.P.C.5.
  • Sections 435, 436/149 I.P.C.(19)
  • Section 161 Cr.P.C.(80)
  • Ram, section 302 I.P.C.
  • Section 161 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 313 Cr.P.C.
  • Section 149 I.P.C.,
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion arises out of long-pending criminal litigation originating from an incident said to have occurred on 11.3.1990 in village Rudayan (then P.S. Sasni, district Aligarh / Hathras). A written report was lodged by P.W.16 Harishankar alleging mass violence, arson and attacks on members of the Jatav community, and a criminal case (Case Crime No. 78 of 1990) was registered under a multitude of IPC sections and the S.C./S.T. Act. A charred dead body of one Data Ram (deceased) was recovered and Section 302 I.P.C. was added.

Investigations were conducted by multiple officers; charge-sheets were filed and the case was committed to the Sessions Court. Trial in S.T. No. 311 of 1999 (State v. Rajendra) and related matters resulted in convictions of various accused under different combinations of charges (including offences under Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 IPC and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act). A death sentence passed against Kunwarpal Singh resulted in a reference (Reference No. 03 of 2017) to this Court.

Multiple appeals and an application for leave to appeal under Section 372 Cr.P.C. were before this Court (Capital Case No. 1368 of 2017 and connected Criminal Appeal Nos. 1289, 1296, 1302, 1370, 1371, 1440, 1473, 1473 and Criminal Misc. Application No. 284 of 2017). Arguments concluded on 10.04.2019, and this Court made an operative order allowing the principal appeals, setting aside the convictions, acquitting appellants and dismissing the reference and the leave application.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the convictions recorded by the trial court (including the death sentence in the capital case) could be sustained in view of the quality and reliability of the prosecution evidence, particularly the testimony of the sole eyewitness P.W.2 (Shanti Devi).
  2. Whether the prosecution had established the case against the various appellants beyond reasonable doubt given contradictions, omissions, hostile witnesses and failures to produce material witnesses (e.g., Brij Bala, Rahim Baksh, Narsi).
  3. Whether Reference No. 03 of 2017 (confirmation of death sentence) and Criminal Misc. Application u/s 372 Cr.P.C. No. 284 of 2017 (leave to appeal) deserved to be allowed or dismissed in light of the record and trial-court findings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The trial court erred in convicting appellants (including Kunwarpal Singh, Jogendra and Babu Singh) primarily on the testimony of P.W.2 Shanti Devi, who was contended to be wholly unreliable, untrustworthy and highly interested, without adequate corroboration.
  • P.W.1 (Chhatrapal Singh) and P.W.16 (Harishankar) had not witnessed the occurrence; P.W.1's testimony was largely hearsay as he stated his mother had told him events, and his Section 161 statement was recorded after an inordinate delay without explanation.
  • The account given by P.W.2 in court differed materially from her statement to the investigating officer and from the F.I.R.; crucial facts such as how the dead body was identified and who informed police about P.W.2's whereabouts were missing.
  • Medical evidence did not corroborate P.W.2's version (she alleged three gunshots; post-mortem showed only one firearm entry wound), undermining her claim of being an eye-witness.
  • No motive or overt act was shown against certain accused (for example Babu Singh); conviction by invoking Section 149 IPC was improper where evidence indicated only a few active perpetrators.
  • The prosecution withheld material witnesses (Brij Bala, Rahim Baksh, Narsi) without adequate explanation; adverse inference should follow.
  • For the second set of appellants, counsel submitted that glaring contradictions, material improvements and admitted enmity between communities rendered prosecution witnesses unreliable and convictions unsustainable.
  • In the leave application under Section 372 Cr.P.C., the applicant contended that the trial judge's acquittal was vitiated by non-consideration of material evidence (this is the applicant's contention; the Court reviewed and rejected it).

State / Respondent's Arguments (as presented in the opinion)

  • The prosecution maintained that P.W.2 Shanti Devi's testimony was consistent, cogent and clinching; it correctly described the occurrence and was, according to the State, corroborated by medical evidence.
  • The discrepancies and contradictions pointed out by defence were described by the State as trivial and not going to the core of the case; P.W.2's imperfect recall was attributed to her being an illiterate woman who suffered traumatic shock.
  • For the second set of appeals the State urged that convictions and sentences did not suffer legal infirmity and should be sustained.
  • In relation to the leave application (Section 372), the State relied on the trial judge's record and hostile witness declarations to defend the acquittal and opposed granting leave to appeal.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a detailed evaluation of the prosecution evidence, structured roughly as follows:

  1. Assessment of the written report and initial investigation: The written report (FIR) lodged by P.W.16 Harishankar was examined and the Court noted that the informant was not an eyewitness and that certain specific allegations (for example, murder of Data Ram and throwing his body into a 'Laha') were absent from the FIR.
  2. Evaluation of the key prosecution witnesses:
    • P.W.2 (Shanti Devi) — the principal eyewitness whose court testimony formed the backbone of the prosecution case — was scrutinised in detail. The Court found material contradictions between her trial testimony and her earlier statements (including Section 161 Cr.P.C. statements) and the FIR. Specific concerns included: (a) inconsistencies about where she was during the occurrence and whether she stayed in the village or had fled to Jasrana/Bilkhaura; (b) her failure to report the incident promptly or to explain why no FIR was lodged by her or by her alleged informant Raja Ram; (c) differences in description of weapons and the manner of assault; and (d) claims that she had remained unconscious and other details that were not recorded at investigation.
    • The Court observed that post-mortem contradicted P.W.2's repeated assertion that three shots hit Data Ram — the post-mortem reported only one firearm entry wound and extensive burns. This medical-ocular mismatch was held to go to the heart of reliability of the ocular account.
    • P.W.1 (Chhatrapal Singh) was held to have given hearsay evidence derived from P.W.2; his Section 161 statement timing and admissions undermined his independent reliability.
    • Other fact witnesses (P.W.3–P.W.13, P.W.15, P.W.16) were appraised. Several were declared hostile or did not support the prosecution in material respects; many witnesses either failed to identify accused reliably or made improvements in evidence not present in their earlier statements.
  3. Failure to produce material witnesses and adverse inference: The Court remarked upon the prosecution's failure to examine obvious and material witnesses (notably Brij Bala, Rahim Baksh, Narsi) who, according to P.W.2, were present near the scene and could have corroborated her testimony or at least confirmed her presence there. The Court drew an adverse inference that had these witnesses been produced they would not have supported the prosecution.
  4. Hostile witnesses and improvements: Several witnesses who initially allegedly supported the prosecution, when examined in Court, disowned previous statements and were declared hostile. The prosecution also failed to call the investigating officer who recorded their Section 161 statements (a witness who could have potentially proved prior statements), which the Court considered significant.
  5. Inconsistencies between FIR and later accounts: The Court emphasized that the FIR did not mention the specific sequence later described by P.W.2 (shooting and throwing Data Ram into Laha) and did not explain how or by whom the charred body was identified; these omissions weakened the prosecution narrative.
  6. Presence of police and cross-versions: Multiple statements indicated that police were present during the disturbances. The Court found it difficult to reconcile large-scale devastation occurring in the presence of police without explanation. Also, evidence showed that the 'Nauhra' (a structure) of some accused was burnt and cross-FIRs existed, indicating inter-community enmity and alternative explanations for the violence, which undermined the prosecution's claim of clean hands.
  7. Application of law on solitary eyewitness: The Court applied established prudential considerations — while a conviction can rest on solitary witness testimony if that witness is wholly reliable, where the sole witness is not wholly dependable the Court must seek corroboration. The Court concluded that P.W.2 was not wholly reliable and her testimony lacked corroboration from other evidence (including medical evidence).
  8. Conclusion on proof beyond reasonable doubt: Considering contradictions, omissions, hostile witnesses, failure to produce material witnesses, discrepancies with medical evidence and the absence of motive or explanation for singling out the deceased, the Court concluded that prosecution had not proved the charges beyond reasonable doubt against multiple appellants.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

  • The Court allowed Capital Case No. 1368 of 2017 and connected Criminal Appeal Nos. 1289 of 2017, 1296 of 2017, 1302 of 2017, 1370 of 2017, 1371 of 2017, 1440 of 2017, 1473 of 2017 and set aside the impugned judgment and order dated 15.02.2017 (S.T. No. 311 of 1999, State v. Rajendra).
  • The appellants were acquitted of all charges framed against them in those matters. The Court ordered that all appellants who were in jail shall be released forthwith unless wanted in any other case, subject to compliance with the mandatory provisions of Section 437-A Cr.P.C.
  • Reference No. 03 of 2017 and Criminal Misc. Application u/s 372 Cr.P.C. No. 284 of 2017 were dismissed.
  • There was no order as to costs.

Implications (direct and broader, as reflected in the opinion):

  • Direct effect on the parties: Convictions and sentences imposed by the trial court in the named cases were set aside and appellants acquitted; those in custody were to be released subject to statutory conditions.
  • Reference and leave applications: The Court refused to confirm the death sentence (Reference No. 3) and dismissed the leave application under Section 372 Cr.P.C., indicating that the trial court's acquittal in the cross-case was not vitiated.
  • On precedent and broader legal principle: The Court applied established prudential rules about reliance on sole eyewitness testimony — affirming that a solitary witness may support conviction only if wholly reliable, and that lack of corroboration and material contradictions warrant acquittal. The opinion did not purport to set out a novel legal precedent beyond applying these principles to the facts of the case.

Notes: This summary is limited to the information contained in the provided opinion. No external sources or precedents not mentioned in the opinion were used to construct this summary.

    Kunwar Pal Singh v. State Of U.P . .

    1. The arguments of this case concluded on 10.04.2019. We then passed the following order:—

    Heard Sri. Satish Trivedi, Senior Advocate assisted by Sri. Ajay Kumar Pandey and Sri. Ravi Prakash Singh, learned counsel for the appellants in Capital Case No. 1368 of 2017 along with connected Criminal Appeal No. 1370 of 2017 and 1371 of 2017, Sri. Ajay Kumar Pathak learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1473 of 2017, Sri. A.B.L. Gour, Senior Advocate assisted by Sri. Saurabh Gour, learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1289 of 2017, Sri. Hemendra Pratap Singh, learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal Nos. 1440 of 2017 and 1296 of 2017, Sri. G.S. Hajela, learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 1302 of 2017 and Sri. Ravi Prakash Singh, learned counsel for the appellant in Criminal Misc. Application u/s 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave to Appeal) No. 284 of 2017 and Sri. J.K. Upadhyay, learned A.G.A. appearing for the State-respondent assisted by Sri. Awadhesh Kumar Shukla, State Law Officer.

    2. We are making the operative order here and now and will give reasons later.

    3. The Capital Case No. 1368 of 2017 along with connected Criminal Appeal Nos. 1289 of 2017, 1296 of 2017, 1302 of 2017, 1370 of 2017, 1371 of 2017, 1440 of 2017, 1473 of 2017 are allowed. The impugned judgment and order dated 15.02.2017 passed by learned Additional Session Judge, Court No. 3, Hathras in S.T. No. 311 of 1999 (State v. Rajendra) arising out of Case Crime No. 78 of 1990, under Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act, P.S. Sasni, District Hathras are hereby set aside.

    4. The appellants are acquitted of all the charges framed against them. All the appellants are in jail. They shall be released forthwith unless they are wanted in any other case subject to their complying with the mandatory requirements of provision of Section 437-A Cr.P.C.

    5. However, Reference No. 03 of 2017 and Criminal Misc. Application u/s 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave to Appeal) No. 284 of 2017 are dismissed.

    6. There shall be however no order as to costs.

    7. Here are the reasons:—

    (1) Briefly stated the facts of this case are that P.W. 16 Harishankar gave a written report at police station Sasni, sub-district Hathras, district Aligarh on 11.3.1990 at about 18:15 hours in respect of an incident which had allegedly taken place on the same day at about 4 P.M. in village Rudayan, Ward no. 1 alleging therein that he belonged to Jatav community and was a resident of village Rudayan. On the date of occurrence the festival of holi was being celebrated in the village. At about 4 P.M. Udayveer Singh had gone to the house of Sonpal who also belonged to his caste to smear him with colours and when after playing holi with him he was returning to his house he met Kunwar Pal Singh, Rajendra Singh, Jagendra Singh sons of Bhagwan Singh, Shyam Veer Singh son of Bhoori Singh, Prem Singh son of Pop Singh Jat, Banwari son of Sadhu, caste kadere and Insafi Khan son of Fateh Khan who came out from the ‘Nouhre’ of Kunwar Pal Singh and after catching hold of Udayveer Singh started beating him. Udayveer Singh somehow escaped from their clutches and started running towards his house followed by the aforesaid persons who were joined in their chase by Umesh Kumar son of Shahshi Pal, Vijendra Singh son of Soran Singh, Manoka son of Sadhu, Gulab Singh son of Gulla, Kahar, Nanak Chandra son of Kanhaiya Lal Kahar, Harishchandra son of Chandrapal Khatik, Mahendra Singh son of Radheylal, Raju son of Brahmdutta, Dinesh son of Mathura Prasad, Shambhu son of Shivshankar, Santosh son of Shivshankar Sharma, Rajeev @ Chhotey son of Narayan, Hari, Hariom Pandit, nephew of Lala, Komal Prasad, Mukesh Kumar, Bhola son of Rishi Kumar, Nempal Bhatiya son of Khyaliram, Bijuwa son of Ram Singh Jat, Udayveer Singh son of Pop Singh, Daryav Singh son of Popo Singh Jat, Purshottam son of Ramsahai all residents of village Rudayan, Sahab Singh Pradhan Bikhlaura Khurd, Netrapal son of Udayveer Jat, Brijveer Bikhlaura Khurd, Shyam Singh son of Shiv Singh Bikhlaura Khurd, Pappe son of Mathura Prasad, Pappu son of Mishri Lal, Vashisht, Nannu, Dinesh son of Rajkumar (Pathak), Premchandra son of Gangasharan, Mahesh and Vishnu sons of Gendalal, Nathuram son fo Sunehri Lal, Sunil son of Ramkesh, Dinesh son of Roopkishore, Rajanlal Advocate, Narayannahri Mishra son of Ramgopal, Kamruddin Pradhan village Bheeka Nagla, police station Sasni, district Aligarh and several other persons Narayan Singh village Bilkhaura, Resham Singh Bikhlaura Khurd, Girraj Kishore Bikhlaura Khurd and Mathura Prasad Pradhan Member Leader and Ravendra Pathak Ex-Chief armed with their licenced and unlicenced guns, lathi, ballam, pharsa etc. The aforesaid persons entered into his locality exhorting each other and surrounded therein from the side of boundary wall of the house of Kunwar Pal Singh. The miscreants who were also carrying torches in their hands started setting their houses ablaze. They also desecrated the statue of Indira Gandhi and started hurling stones and firing at the persons belonging to the Jatav caste who became helpless and started running helter skelter shouting for help while shots were being fired at them. They endeavoured to douse the fire but the fire was so fierce that they had to run towards the fields to save their lives chased by the accused. They saw their sisters and daughters being beaten and within no time not only they had burnt all the houses in the locality belonging to the Harijans but even their harvested crops kept in the farmyards and their tubewells were set on fire. Data Ram (deceased), his wife and his daughter were forcibly dragged out from their house. Such atrocities had been committed by them on the Harijans in the past also and they would continue to indulge in same activities in future also. The accused were openly threatening that they would not let the Harijans live in the village. On account of the atrocities committed on the Harijans by the accused, cries of sorrow could be heard throughout the village. While they hid themselves to save their lives abandoning their houses, the same were looted and plundered by the accused. The extent of damages caused to the houses of Harijans and details of looted property could be ascertained only after the same were assessed by the affected persons on returning to their homes.

    (2) In the written report it was also stated that apart from the persons named in the written report there were several other persons who had participated in the incidents of looting and arson who could be identified by face. While the incident was being committed the police had also arrived at the place of occurrence.

    (3) On the basis of the written report of the occurrence, case crime no. 78 of 1990, u/s 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295, 364 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) S.C./S.T. Act was registered at P.S. Sasni, district-Aligarh against Kunwarpal Singh, Rajendra Singh, Jagendra Singh, Shyamveer Singh, Prem Singh, Banwari, Insafi Khan, Umesh Kumar, Vijendra Singh, Manoka, Gulab Singh @ Gulla, Nanak Chandra all resident of village Rudayan, P.S. Sasni and several other persons. Chek F.I.R. Ext. Ka1 and the relevant G.D. entry vide rapat no. 35 time 17:15 hours date 23.3.1990 and vide rapat no. 43 time 19:00 hours date 14.3.1990.

    (4) It appears that after a charred dead body was recovered from the field of Data Ram which was identified as that of Data Ram, section 302 I.P.C. was also added.

    (5) The first investigating officer of the case reached the place where the charred dead body of Data Ram was lying and after collecting ash from the places near the tubewell and under the Mango tree he prepared the recovery memo on 12.3.1990. He also collected plain and bloodstained soil from the field of Data Ram and prepared it's recovery memo Ext. Ka13. He then proceeded to collect burnt ash from the 55 burnt houses belonging to the Harijans which were allegedly burnt by the accused during the occurrence and prepared a composite recovery memo. The recovery memo indicates that the ash collected from the houses which were allegedly burnt in the incident was not kept separately but was packed and sealed in a simple piece of cloth on the spot. He also inspected the place from where the dead body of Data Ram was allegedly recovered and prepared it's site plan. He also inspected each of the fifty five houses which were burnt in the occurrence and prepared separate site plan of each house.

    (6) The inquest on the body of deceased-Data Ram was conducted on 11.3.1990. The inquest report and other connected documents namely challan lash, letter addressed to C.M.O., photo nash, letter addressed to R.I., letter for postmortem examination were prepared on the spot. Thereafter, the dead body of Data Ram was sealed by the investigating officer and dispatched to the mortuary for postmortem examination. The postmortem on the body of Data Ram was conducted on 12.3.1990 at about 3:30 P.M. The postmortem report of the deceased was admitted by the defence during the trial and hence it's formal proof was dispensed with. The postmortem report of the deceased indicates following antemortem injuries:

    (i) Gunshot wound of entry on his back rt. side 6 cm below from angle of scapula size 2 × 2 cm × cavity deep.

    (ii) Gunshot wound on the front of chest rt. side in mid auxiliary line, 8 cm below from rt. nipple ……………..

    (iii) 100% burn injury of 2 to 3 degree present all over the body vessels and charred at both hip bone & line of redness & ventricle places also present.

    Cause of death was stated to be shock and hemorrhage as a result of ante mortem gunshot and burn injuries.

    (7) The investigation of the case was transferred to P.W. 18 Dayaram Dwivedi who at that point of time was posted as S.H.O. police station Sasni, district Aligarh. He started the investigation on 17.3.1990 and during the course of investigation he recorded the statements of Pooran Chandra, Smt. Shanti Devi and on 20.3.1990 Sonpal, Bheekam Singh, Gulab. The investigation of the case was transferred from local police to CBCID by order dated 24.3.1990 passed by S.S.P. Aligarh.

    (8) P.W. 14 V.S. Sirohi, the third investigating officer of the case after completing the investigation filed chargesheet on 8.4.1995 against Umashankar, Rajendra, Gulab, Dinesh, Santosh, Mukesh, Daryab Singh, Purshottam, Anil, Mahesh, Nathuram, Dinesh, Rajanlal, Narayan Hari Ravindra and against Umashankar, Vishnu, Mahesh, Hariom, Jitendra and on 18.9.1995 against Mathura Prasad, Mahendra, Kunwarpal, Vijenra, Harichandra, Mahendra, Umendra, Ashok Banwari, Insaf Ali on 21.10.1995.

    (9) Since the offences mentioned in the chargesheet were triable exclusively by the Court of Sessions, C.J.M. Aligarh committed the case for the trial of the accused to the Court of Sessions Judge Aligarh where case crime no. 78 of 1990 was registered as S.T. No. 311 of 1999 (State v. Rajendra) made over for trial from there to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 3, Hathras/Special Judge (S.C./S.T.) Act who on the basis of the material on record and after affording opportunity of hearing to the prosecution as well as the accused framed charge under Sections 147, 148, 149, 435, 436, 395, 397, 427, 307, 302, 295 I.P.C. and Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act. The accused abjured the charge and claimed trial.

    (10) The prosecution in order to establish the charges framed against the accused examined as many as 18 witnesses out of whom P.W. 1 to P.W. 13 and P.W. 16 were examined as witnesses of various facts while P.W. 14 V.S. Sirohi, the third investigating officer of the case who had completed the investigation and filed chargesheet against the accused, P.W. 18 Dayaram Dwivedi, second investigating officer of the case and P.W. 17 Dr. Gyan S. Sharma who had examined the injuries of the two injured namely Umesh Chandra and Narsi who had allegedly received injuries in the occurrence and prepared their injury reports which have been brought on record as Ext. Ka 34 to Ext. Ka36 were produced as formal witnesses. The injury reports of the injured (i) Umesh Chandra and (ii) Narsi indicate following injuries on their persons:

    Text in Vernacular

    (11) After the closure of the recording of the prosecution evidence, the accused were examined under Section 313 Cr.P.C. All the accused denied the prosecution case as concocted and alleged false implication due to village party bandi and enmity. Appellant-Anil @ Pappey in criminal appeal no. 1289 of 2017 in addition stated that he was not present at the place of occurrence at the time of the incident as he was employed in Delhi while appellant-Babu Singh @ Vijendra in criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017 stated that the persons belonging to the informant's side had set the house of his brother Rajendra ablaze and he was busy trying to douze the fire and had not participated in the occurrence. The defence neither adduced any documentary evidence nor examined any witness in defence.

    (12) Learned Additional Sessions Judge Court No. 3, Hathras after considering the submissions advanced before him by the learned counsel for the parties and scrutinizing the evidence on record convicted the appellants under the aforesaid offences and awarded above mentioned sentences by the impugned judgment and order. However, co-accused Dinesh, Rajanlal, Insaf Ali, Purshottam, Vishnu, Mahesh, Jeetu @ Jitendra, Harishchandra, Umesh, Mahendra Kumar Vashishth @ Mahesh were acquitted of all the charges.

    (13) Reference made by the Additional Sessions Judge Court No. 3, Hathras to this Court for confirmation of death sentence passed by him against Kunwarpal Singh, appellant in capital case no. 1368 of 2017 which was registered as reference no. 3 of 2017 before this Court and connected with these bunch of appeals by order dated 15.2.2017 is also being considered with these appeals.

    (14) Hence these appeals.

    (15) These appeals as well as the application seeking leave to appeal which have been preferred by the different appellants can be broadly divided into three sets.

    (16) The first set comprises of capital case no. 1368 of 2017 (Kunwar Pal Singh v. State) and criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017 (Babu Singh @ Vijendra and another).

    (17) In these two appeals, appellants-Kunwar Pal Singh, Babu Singh @ Vijendra and Jogendra @ Jogendra Singh have been convicted under Sections 147, 148, 302/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.

    (18) The appellants in the aforesaid appeals have not been convicted under Sections 435, 436/149 I.P.C.

    (19) The second set comprises of criminal appeal nos. 1371 of 2017, 1473 of 2017, 1289 of 2017, 1440 of 2017, 1296 of 2017 and 1302 of 2017 which have been preferred by appellants-Rajendra, Hariom, Anil @ Pappey, Santosh, Shambhoo, Dinesh Darji, Mukesh, Anil @ Bhola, Umashankar who have been convicted and sentenced under Sections 147, 148, 435, 436/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act.

    (20) The third set comprises Criminal Misc. Application (Leave to Appeal) u/S 372 Cr.P.C. No. 284 of 2017 which has been filed by Rajendra Singh, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1371 of 2017 against the judgment and order dated 14.7.2017 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 5, Hathras in S.T. No. 153 of 2010 (State v. Niranjan Singh) arising out of Case Crime No. 78-B of 1990, under Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 427, 295, 307 I.P.C., P.S. Sasani, District Hathras by which he has acquitted opposite party nos. 2 to 5 from all the charges.

    (21) We first proceed to decide capital case no. 1368 of 2017 and criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017.

    (22) Sri. Satish Trivedi, learned Senior counsel appearing for the appellants in the aforesaid appeals has submitted that the trial court patently erred in convicting the appellants-Kunwarpal Singh, Jogendra and Babu Singh in the aforesaid appeals under Sections 147, 148, 302/149 I.P.C. read with Section 3(2)(5) SC/ST Act on the basis of the testimony of wholly unreliable, untrustworthy and highly interested witness P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, the wife of the deceased-Datam Ram without seeking corroboration from any other evidence on record.

    (23) He next submitted that as far as the two witnesses namely P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh and P.W. 16 Harishankar who were also examined by the prosecution during the trial to establish the charge framed against the appellants are concerned, it is indisputed that none of them had witnessed the occurrence. The facts deposed by P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, son of the deceased were as per his own evidence, conveyed to him by his mother, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi after she had been brought to village Rudayan with the help of police from the house of her brother-in-law (Bahnoi), Raja Ram in village Jasrana on the night of the occurrence. Moreover the statement of P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh under Section 161 Cr.P.C. was recorded after more than 22 days of the occurrence without any satisfactory explanation for the inordinate delay. As far as P.W. 16 Harishankar is concerned, he in the F.I.R. qua deceased-Data Ram and P.W. 2 Shanti Devi had stated that the rioters had dragged deceased-Data Ram, his wife, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi and their daughter-Brij Bala from their house and taken them away somewhere but the eye-witness account of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi does not contain any such statement.

    (24) He further submitted that the medical evidence on record does not corroborate the manner of assault on deceased-Data Ram as narrated by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her statement recorded before the trial court which totally belies her claim of being the eye-witness of the occurrence. He also submitted that the admitted case of the prosecution qua deceased-Data Ram is that he was shot by appellant-Jogendra thrice and all the three shot had hit him and thereafter appellant-Kunwarpal Singh had thrown him into “Laha”. The incident was witnessed by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi alone and as per her own evidence after her husband had been thrown into Laha she had fled to village Bilkhaura and from there she had gone to her brother-in-law's house in village Jasrana and she had been brought back to her village Rudayan by the police but there is no link evidence on record proving when and by whom the dead body of Data Ram was recovered and identified and brought to the village and kept under the neem tree. There is further no evidence on record indicating how the police came to know that P.W. 2 Shanti Devi was in Jasrana. From the evidence of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi herself, it is established that P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh was neither present at the time and place of occurrence nor she had informed him about her fleeing to Jasrana.

    (25) The aforesaid loopholes and lack of link evidence give rise to a very strong suspicious that the entire prosecution story qua deceased-Data Ram is concocted and false.

    (26) He next submitted that as far as Babu Singh, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017 is concerned, neither any motive nor any overt act of any kind has been attributed to him and his conviction recorded by the trial court by invoking Section 149 I.P.C., although the evidence on record indicates that only three persons had allegedly participated in committing the murder of Data Ram, is per se illegal.

    (27) He lastly submitted that such being the state of evidence, neither the recorded conviction of the appellants nor the sentences awarded to them can be sustained and are liable to be set aside.

    (28) Rebutting the submissions made by Sri. Satish Trivedi, learned counsel for the appellants in capital case no. 1368 of 2017 and criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017 Sri. J.K. Upadhyay, learned A.G.A. appearing for the State submitted that the prosecution case stands fully proved from the consistent and clinching testimony of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, the sole eye-witness of the occurrence who has given correct and cogent description of the occurrence which finds full corroboration from the medical evidence on record. The contradictions and the discrepancies in the testimony of P.W. Shanti Devi and the inconsistency in the medical evidence and the ocular version pointed out by the learned counsel for the appellants are of trivial nature which do not go to the core of the prosecution case rendering it unreliable. The discrepancy between her evidence given by her before the trial court and the medical evidence on record with regard to the manner of assault is absolutely natural considering the fact that she is an illiterate lady who had seen her husband being shot and thrown into Laha in her presence.

    (29) The factum of deceased-Data Ram being shot by Jogendra, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017 and later thrown by Kunwarpal Singh, appellant in capital case no. 1368 of 2017 into Laha stands fully proved from her evidence.

    (30) Both the appeals lacks merit and are liable to be dismissed.

    (31) We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the material brought on record.

    (32) Record shows that the written report of the occurrence which had allegedly taken place on 11.3.1990 in village Rudayan was lodged by P.W. 16 Harishankar who is admittedly not the eye-witness of the occurrence, at police station Sasni, district Aligarh on the same day at 18:50 hours.

    (33) A perusal of the written report of the occurrence indicates that on the date of occurrence holi festival was being celebrated in the village, one Udayveer Jatav by caste while returning from the house of Sonpal who also belonged to his caste after playing holi with him was accosted by Kunwarpal Singh, appellant in capital case no. 1368 of 2017, Rajendra Singh, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1371 of 2017, Jogendra @ Jogendra Singh A2 in criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017, Shyamveer Singh, Prem Singh, Banwari Lal and Insafi Khan who suddenly came out from the ‘Nouhre’ of Kunwarpal Singh and they after catching hold of Udayveer Singh started beating him. Udayveer Singh somehow managed to escape and started running towards his village followed by the aforesaid persons who were joined in their chase by Umesh Kumar son of Shahshi Pal, Vijendra Singh son of Soran Singh, Manoka son of Sadhu, Gulab Singh son of Gulla, Kahar, Nanak Chandra son of Kanhaiya Lal Kahar, Harishchandra son of Chandrapal Khatik, Mahendra Singh son of Radheylal, Raju son of Brahmdutta, Dinesh son of Mathura Prasad, Shambhu son of Shivshankar, Santosh son of Shivshankar Sharma, Rajeev @ Chhotey son of Narayan, Hari, Hariom Pandit, nephew of Lala, Komal Prasad, Mukesh Kumar, Bhola son of Rishi Kumar, Nempal Bhatiya son of Khyaliram, Bijuwa son of Ram Singh Jat, Udayveer Singh son of Pop Singh, Daryav Singh son of Popo Singh Jat, Purshottam son of Ramsahai resident of village Rudayan, Sahab Singh Pradhan Bikhlaura Khurd, Netrapal son of Udayveer Jat, Brijveer Bikhlaura Khurd, Shyam Singh son of Shiv Singh Bikhlaura Khurd, Pappe son of Mathura Prasad, Pappu son of Mishri Lal, Vashisht, Nannu, Dinesh son of Rajkumar (Pathak), Premchandra son of Gangasharan, Mahesh and Vishnu sons of Gendalal, Nathuram son fo Sunehri Lal, Sunil son of Ramkesh, Dinesh son of Roopkishore, Rajanlal Advocate, Narayannahri Mishra son of Ramgopal, Kamruddin Pradhan village Bheeka Nagla, police station Sasni, district Aligarh and other persons Narayan Singh village Bilkhaura, Resham Singh Bikhlaura Khurd, Girraj Kishore Bikhlaura Khurd and Mathura Prasad Pradhan Member Leader and Ravendra Pathak Ex-Chief armed with their licenced and unlicenced guns, lathi, ballam, pharsa etc. The aforesaid persons entered into his locality exhorting each other and surrounded their locality from the side of boundary wall of the house of Kunwar Pal Singh. The miscreants who were also carrying torches in their hands started setting their houses ablaze. They also desecrated the statue of Indira Gandhi and started hurling stones and firing at the persons belonging to the Jatav caste who became helpless and started running helter and skelter shouting for help while shots were being fired at them. They endeavoured to douse the fire but the fire was so fierce that they had to run towards the fields to save their lives followed by the accused. They saw their sisters and daughters being beaten and within no time not only they had burnt all the houses of Harijan locality. Even their harvested crops kept in the farmyards and their tubewells were set on fire. Data Ram (deceased), his wife and his daughter were forcibly dragged from their house. Such atrocities had been committed by them on the Harijans in the past also and they would continue to indulge in such activities in future also. The accused were openly threatening that they would not let the Harijans live in the village. On account of the atrocities committed on the Harijans by the accused, cries of sorrow could be heard throughout the village. As they hid themselves to save their lives abandoning their houses which were looted by the accused. The extent of damages caused to the houses of Harijans and details of looted property could be ascertained only after the same was assessed by the affected persons on returning to their homes.

    (34) The prosecution in order to prove the charge framed against Kunwarpal Singh, appellant in capital case no. 1368 of 2017, Babu Singh @ Vijendra and Jogendra @ Jogendra Singh, appellants in criminal appeal no. 1370 of 2017, primarily placed reliance upon the evidence of P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh and P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, son and wife of the deceased-Data Ram respectively, P.W. 15 Soorajpal, witness of recoveries, P.W. 16 (informant) Harishankar and P.W. 18 Dayaram Dwivedi, I.O. of the case.

    (35) P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, son of the deceased and P.W. 2 Shanti Devi on page 27 of the paper book in his examination-in-chief has categorically deposed that her mother had told him in the evening that at about 5 P.M. accused-Jogendra, Kunwarpal Singh, Babu Singh @ Vijendra, Banwari Lal, Manoka, Komal Prasad, Dinesh Kumar etc. whom his mother knew and of whom Jogendra was armed with katta and rest of the accused were carrying lathi-danda first had beaten his father and thereafter Jogendra Singh had fired at him 2-3 times and then his father was thrown by them into Laha of 35 bighas alive and set ablaze by Kunwarpal Singh. On page 33 of the paper book, he admitted in his cross-examination that his mother had returned to the village after the police had brought the dead body of his father. In his cross-examination on page 29 of the paper book, he admitted that he had not gone to the place where his father had been murdered on 11.3.1990 and on page 30 of the paper book he further stated that his statement under Section 161 Cr.P.C. was recorded by the investigating officer after 10-12 days of the incident in which he stated that he had neither seen his father being murdered nor he had gone to the place of the incident on 11.3.1990. There is nothing in his evidence which may show that he had provided the address of Raja Ram of Jasrana to the police and his mother had been brought from Jasrana to her village by the police. Thus whatever he deposed before the court qua the incident was hearse.

    (36) Nothing turns upon the evidence of P.W. 15 Soorajpal who was produced by the prosecution to prove Ext. Ka32 and Ext. Ka33, the recovery memo of ash, plain and bloodstained earth from the place of occurrence from the field of Data Ram where he was shot dead and burnt. However, he in his cross-examination deposed that he did not remember the day and date on which ash, plain simple earth was recovered, his signatures were obtained.

    (37) P.W. 16 Harishankar who is the informant of the case in his evidence tendered before the trial court supported the prosecution case as spelt out by him in the F.I.R. and also deposed that accused-Kunwar Pal Singh, Rajendra, Jogendra, Banwari, Manoj and Mulla @ Gulab had after setting the houses of Harijans in the village on fire had gone to the field of his brother-Data Ram and caused his death by throwing him in burning fire, although the aforesaid fact was conspicuous by its absence in the written report of the incident. He in his cross-examination on page 107 of the paper book admitted that he had not seen the incident which had taken place in the field of Data Ram. On page 110 of the paper book, he further admitted that he had no personal knowledge about the persons who had participated in the occurrence and whatever he had stated in the F.I.R. was communicated to him by other people. On page 109 of the paper book, he stated that he was not aware whether on the date of occurrence, ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra, Jogendra Singh and Kunwar Pal Singh was set on fire or not. However in the same page he admitted that appellant-Rajendra Singh and others had filed a criminal case against Sonpal and others alleging that their ‘Nauhar’ had been set on fire by Sonpal and others which was pending before the trial Court.

    (38) P.W. 18 who at the relevant point of time was posted as S.H.O.P.S. Sasni was entrusted with the investigation of the case on 17.3.1990 stated before the trial court that he started the investigation on 17.3.1990 and recorded the statements of Pooranchand, Smt. Shanti Devi on 19.3.1990 while the statement of witnesses Sonpal, Bheekam Singh, Gulab @ Mulla were recorded on 20.3.1990 and 223.1990 respectively. On 24.3.1990, the investigation of the case was transferred to CBCID under the orders of S.S.P. He also stated that he had not recorded the statement of Smt. Shanti Devi before 19.3.1990 and she in her statement made before him had not disclosed the time at which she had gone to her field. She had also not told to him about the exact place where she was cutting grass at the time of the incident but she had told him that she was cutting grass at a place which was adjacent to the grove of Harishankar. He admitted having not recorded the statements of either Rahim Baksh or Narsi. He had also stated that although Shanti Devi had told her that gunshot was fired but she had not told him that the accused had fired thrice. He also stated that P.W. 2 Shanti Devi had not stated before him that if she had raised cries for help the accused would have killed her also. She had neither told him that on the date of incident she had remained unconscious for 10-15 minutes nor that she had become unconscious at all. She had also not told him that after she had gone to Jasrana, she had told about the incident to anyone. She had also not told him that she had not gone to the police station Sasni on account of being a lady.

    (39) We now proceed to evaluate the evidence of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, the solitary eye-witness of the murder of Data Ram allegedly committed by appellants, Kunwarpal Singh, Babu Singh @ Vijendra and Jogendra @ Jogendra Singh.

    (40) P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her statement recorded before the trial court deposed that her name was Shanti Devi and she was aged about 50 years and resident of Rudayan, police station Sasna, district Aligarh. About 19-20 years before on the day of holi she, her husband and her daughter-Brij Bala had gone from their house to their tubewell. She had left her son-Chhatrapal Singh in her house. They had left their house and had gone to tubewell because they did not want to participate in holi revelry. Her husband had gone to sleep at the tubewell. Strong breeze was blowing. In order to avoid damage to their standing crops she had not switched on the tubewell. While he and Brijbala were cutting grass Raheem Baksh told her that when he was sleeping he had heard a lot of noise coming from the side of the village. While Raheem Baksh was talking to her she saw about 30-40 persons coming towards her from the side of the village, some of whom went towards the house of Netrapal and Narsi while others came to the tubewell. After beating Narsi, his tubewell and hut were set ablaze by them, Kunwarpar Singh, Jogendra, Babu Ji, Banwari, Manoka, Komal etc. who were previously known to her beat her husband. Amongst them Jogendra was carrying a katta with him while others were armed with ‘lathi-danda’. Jogendra had shot her husband thrice. P.W. 2 Shanti Devi and her daughter-Brijbala ran away due to fear towards Ganda Nala. The aforesaid persons had set on fire her ‘Burjiyan’, ‘Moonj’ and four mango trees. She had seen the entire incident while lying on the ground. Her daughter was also lying on the ground but she had not seen seen anything. She had witnessed the whole occurrence and after the mob had gone she went away from the place of occurrence.

    (41) Jogendra had fired at her husband-Kunwarpal Singh had then dragged him upto the Laha and after throwing him into the ‘Laha’ he had set him ablaze. She and Brijbala fled to Bilkhaura from where they went to the house of Raja Ram in Jasrana and narrated the entire incident to him. Police came to the house of Raja Ram at about 9 P.M. and took her back to her village in the police jeep. On reaching her house she saw the charred dead body of her husband lying under the peepal tree. Thakurs’ of village had constructed a temple and Sonpal had built his house near the temple and had opened a door of his house towards the temple which was not appreciated by the Thakurs. Animosity which had developed between the Harijans and Jatavs was the cause of the incident.

    (42) On page 42 of the paper book, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her cross-examination stated that she was not present in her village. Much emphasis has been laid by the learned counsel for the appellants on the aforesaid part of her testimony to establish that she was not present in the village on the date of the incident and hence it was not possible for her to have witnessed the occurrence.

    (43) On page 44 of the paper book, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her cross-examination further deposed that the miscreants had beaten her husband-Data Ram with lathi-danda causing head injury to him. Blood was oozing out from the arms and legs of Data Ram. He was dragged and thrown into Laha after being shot and then set on fire. Data Ram was attacked with lathi and danda at the place which was at a distance of about 4-5 feet from the Laha. After receiving lathi blows, Data Ram had fallen on the ground and thereafter Jogendra had fired three shots at him.

    (44) The entire incident which had taken place at about 5 P.M. had lasted for about 10 minutes. Brijbala who was lying on the ground while she was watching the incident after hiding herself. The distance between the place of occurrence and the place from where she had seen the incident was about 100 paces in the west of the Laha near the farmyard. No one else was present at the crime scene from whom she could have asked for help so she kept lying there watching the incident. She had remained unconscious for about 10-15 minutes after the occurrence but Brijbala was conscious throughout and after regaining consciousness she got up and started walking and reached Jasrana. She further admitted that after the miscreants had left the place of occurrence she had not made any effort to go to the place where her husband was lying to find out his condition rather she had gone straight to Bilkhaura from the place where she was hiding.

    (45) She on reaching Jasrana had narrated the entire incident but on account of her being a lady she could not go to police station Jasrana. She also stated on page 47 of the paper book that she had told about the occurrence to the darogaji of police station Sasni who had recorded her statement twice. Her first statement was recorded by him at Jasrana. Her second statement was recorded by the investigating officer in her house after two or three days of the occurrence. In her first statement she had told the investigating officer that immediately after the occurrence she and her daughter-Brijbala had gone to the house of Mahipal Jatav in Bilkhaura from the place where they were hiding but he had asked them to leave his house.

    (46) P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her cross-examination on page 48 of the paper book stated that she had no knowledge who had told the police that she was in the house of Raja Ram in Jasrana on the night of the occurrence and who had provided the police with the address of Raja Ram.

    (47) Upon being contradicted with her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. in which she had stated that the accused were armed with pharsa, ballam and bhala whereas she in her statement recorded during the trial had deposed that the accused were carrying lathi and danda, she expressed her ignorance why the aforesaid fact had been recorded in her statement by the investigating officer. The statement of fact made by her in her evidence recorded before the trial court that appellant-Kunwarpal Singh had dragged her husband and thrown him into Laha and set him ablaze, was conspicuous by its absence in her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and upon being confronted with the aforesaid statement, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi on page 56 of the paper book reiterated that she had disclosed the aforesaid fact to the investigating officer but she was not aware why the said fact was not recorded by him in her statement.

    (48) However, the investigating officer of the case, P.W. 18 Dayaram Dwivedi upon being confronted with the aforesaid portion of the testimony of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi on page 124 of the paper book, deposed that witness P.W. 2 Shanti had not stated before him that Kunwarpal Singh had dragged Data Ram's Body into Laha and after throwing him into Laha he had set him ablaze. She had merely made sweeping allegations against all the accused including Kunwarpal Singh that they had dragged her husband's body into Laha in which harvested crops was stored and after throwing him into Laha they had set him ablaze. P.W. 2 Shanti devi had not disclosed to him the place from where she had witnessed the occurrence. She had also not told him that the place from where she had seen the occurrence was at a distance of about 100 paces from the crime scene.

    (49) On page 52 of the paper book P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her cross-examination reiterated twice that all the three shots fired by Jogendra had hit her husband causing firearm injuries on his chest. She was again confronted by the defence counsel with her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. in which she had not stated that she had left her son P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh in her house on the date of incident and the aforesaid fact was deposed by her for the first time before the Court on legal advice, she stated that it appears that investigating officer had not questioned her about her son.

    (50) On page 56 of the paper book, she deposed that on reaching Jasrana she had narrated the entire occurrence to Raja Ram but the aforesaid fact was not stated by her in her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. at the house of Raja Ram at 9 P.M.

    (51) The fact deposed by her in her examination-in-chief that she had left her house on the date of occurrence at 11 A.M. does not find mention in her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. On page 51 of the paper book. A suggestion was given to her that she had gone to Jasrana before the occurrence and she had not seen the incident and that she had given false evidence due to enmity between the two communities but she denied the same. On page 58 of the paper book she again denied the suggestion given to her that no such incident as narrated by her in her evidence had taken place and that she had not seen the incident as she had gone to her sister's house in Jasrana on the date of incident in the morning much before the occurrence had taken place and that she had given false evidence against the accused under the pressure of of her brothers-in-law Hari Shankar and Sonpal.

    (52) Another very important circumstance which puts a big question mark against her claim of being the eye-witness of the occurrence is that no explanation is coming forth from her vis-a-vis if after she had fled from the place of incident and had gone to the house of his brother-in-law Raja Ram in Jasrana via Bilkhaura and had narrated the entire occurrence to her brother-in-law Raja Ram as deposed by her in her evidence before the trial court, although admittedly the aforesaid fact was not disclosed by her to the investigating officer in her statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. then why no first information report of the incident was lodged by her or by Raja Ram. If she had actually seen the incident and narrated the entire occurrence to her brother-in-law Raja Ram in Jasrana then an F.I.R. of the incident is not only would have certainly been lodged promptly either by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi or by Raja Ram. The aforesaid contradictions, discrepancies and omissions on the part of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi clearly belies her claim of being present in the village and witnessed the occurrence and the defence version that infact she had left the village on the date of incident in the morning and had gone to her sister's house in Jasrana with her daughter-Brij Bala and possibly her son also and after the incident had taken place, she was brought back to her village by the police and the possibility of the version of the incident given by her in her deposition before the trial court being tutored cannot be ruled out.

    (53) After having very carefully scanned the statement of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, we find that there are material contradictions in her statement recorded before the trial court and that recorded during the investigation, to which we have already adverted to and dealt with in detail belie her claim of being the eye-witness of the occurrence. Her failure in not going to the place where her husband had been shot dead and thrown into Laha and set ablaze by the accused after they had gone for the purpose of inquiring about the condition of her husband and instead her fleeing from the place of occurrence with her daughter-Brij Bala on foot to her sister's house in Bilkhaura and not reporting the matter to the police station Jasrana, although Jasrana fell on the way to Bilkhaura or even at police station Bilkhaura, in case she had actually witnessed the occurrence, appears to be totally opposed to normal human conduct under such circumstances. Moreover the medical evidence on record does not corroborate the manner of assault on deceased-Data Ram as narrated by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi. P.W. 2 Shanti Devi has in her evidence tendered during the trial consistently deposed that her husband had been shot by appellant-Jogendra thrice. However the postmortem report of the deceased indicates that he had received only one firearm wound of entry. There are several loose ends and material loopholes in the prosecution story which have been left unexplained. The prosecution case is very specific that apart from P.W. 2 Shanti Devi no other villager had witnessed the occurrence. P.W. 2 Shanti Devi had deposed that although her daughter-Brij Bala was also present with her at the time of the incident but she had not witnessed the occurrence. The prosecution case further is that immediately after the occurrence, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi had fled to the house of her sister in Bilkhaura with her daughter-Brij Bala. Now there is no evidence on record indicating as to how the police came to know about the charred dead body lying in the Laha was that of Data Ram and who identified the charred dead body as that of Data Ram. Further there is no evidence on record showing how the police came to know about P.W. 2 Shanti Devi being in her sister's house in Jasrana from where the police had brought her to her village on a police jeep.

    (54) The above inconsistencies in the prosecution case thus give rise to a very strong inference that the prosecution has not come up with clean hands and the true genesis of the incident has been suppressed. There are too many loose threads in the prosecution case and material contradictions in the evidence of sole eye-witness-P.W. 2 Shanti Devi which go to the core of the prosecution story rendering it unreliable.

    (55) It is noteworthy that in the F.I.R. there are no mention that the appellants had committed the murder of Data Ram in his field and thrown his dead body into ‘Laha’. The written report of the incident merely contains vague and sweeping allegations against all the persons nominated as accused in the written report that they had caught hold of deceased-Data Ram, his wife, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi and his daughter-Brij Bala and had taken them away somewhere. The aforesaid allegations in the written report run counter to the facts stated by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her examination-in-chief.

    (56) The F.I.R. does not contain any recital that the appellants after taking away the deceased-Data Ram, his wife and his daughter with them had shot Data Ram and had thereafter thrown him into Laha.

    (57) The F.I.R. is also totally silent on the point how, when and by whom the dead body of Data Ram was recovered.

    (58) It is not the case of the prosecution that P.W. 2 Shanti Devi had informed either the police or any villager about the murder of her husband.

    (59) We have very carefully examined the evidence of the first investigating officer of the case and P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, the son of the deceased but there is nothing in their evidence which may indicate that who told the police that P.W. 2 Shanti devi was in Jasrana, that when and by whom charred dead body of Data Ram was discovered and that who identified the charred dead body as that of Data Ram.

    (60) The prosecution has further been unable to come up with any explanation why Data Ram alone was chosen by the appellants for committing his murder. Although if the prosecution story as spelt out in the F.I.R. is accepted to be true then at the time of the incident large number of people were firing with their firearms at the victims who were running helter and skelter and whose houses had been burnt by the accused but none had received any firearm injury. The two persons Umesh Chandra and Narsi who had allegedly received injuries in the incident, their injury reports Ext. Ka34 and Ext. Ka36 do not indicate any firearm wound or gunshot injury on their person.

    (61) The prosecution has thus failed to come up with with any motive for the accused-appellants for singling out Data Ram for committing his murder in a brutal manner.

    (62) It is true that the law is settled that a conviction can be based upon the evidence of a solitary witness provided that such witnesses appears to be a wholly reliable witnesses. In case the sole witness produced during the trial appears to be totally dependable, in that case the Court can record a conviction without seeking corroboration from the evidence of any other witness but where the solitary witness is not wholly reliable, then the rule of prudence demands that the Court should look for corroboration from other evidence. In the instant case, we have already found that P.W. 2 Shanti Devi is not at all a reliable witness and in our opinion it would not be safe at all to maintain the recorded conviction of the appellants on the basis of the testimony of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi which does not find corroboration from any other evidence including medical evidence on record.

    (63) There is yet another very interesting aspect of the matter. No explanation is coming forth from the side of the prosecution for its omission to examine Brij Bala, the daughter of the deceased who as per the evidence of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi was present with her at the place where she was hiding and from where she had witnessed the incident. She would have been the best witness at least to corroborate the testimony of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi or at least to prove the presence of P.W. 2 Shanti devi at the place of incident. Similarly the prosecution has failed to come up with any plausible reason for not examining Rahim Baksh who was present at the tubewell of the deceased as deposed by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in her examination-in-chief when P.W. 2 Shanti Devi had seen 30-40 persons coming from the side of the village towards her. Even Narsi who had his house near the tubewell of Data Ram and as deposed by P.W. 2 Shanti Devi before the Court he was beaten up by the mob and his house burnt by the appellants and the other co. accused and whose injury reports had been brought on record by the prosecution during the trial as Ext. Ka34 was not produced as witnesses. It is not the case of the prosecution that Brij Bala, Narsi and Rahim Baksh had been won over by the accused and they would not have supported the prosecution story if they were produced during the trial.

    (64) Thus, under the circumstances of the case, the failure of the prosecution to examine Brij Bala, Narsi and Rahim Baksh who very material witnesses of the case compels us to draw an adverse inference against the prosecution that in case Brij Bala and Rahim Baksh had been produced during the trial, they would not have supported the prosecution case. The aforesaid three persons would have been the best witness who would have corroborated the claim of P.W. 2 Shanti Devi of her being the eye-witness of the occurrence.

    (65) Thus, in view of the foregoing discussion, we do not find it safe to confirm the recorded conviction of the appellants-Kunwarpal Singh, Babu Singh @ Vijendra, Jogendra @ Jogendra Singh recorded by the trial court on the basis of the evidence of all the three witnesses, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi in our opinion is not a wholly reliable witness. Although it evinces from her evidence recorded during the trial that at the time of the occurrence at least three persons, Rahim Baksh, Narsi and her daughter-Brij Bala were present at the place of incident who had been deliberately withheld by the prosecution.

    (66) Now coming to the second set of appeals preferred by Rajendra, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1371 of 2017, Hariom, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1473 of 2017, Anil @ Pappey, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1289 of 2017, Santosh, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1440 of 2017, Shambhoo and Dinesh, appellants in criminal appeal no. 1296 of 2017 and Mukesh, Anil Kumar and Umashankar, appellants in criminal appeal no. 1302 of 2017. We find that the prosecution in order to establish the charges framed against the aforesaid appellants had examined, P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, P.W. 3 Chokhe Lal, P.W. 4 Zalim Singh, P.W. 5 Mahesh, P.W. 6 Son Pal, P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar, P.W. 8 Ram Kumari, P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra, P.W. 10 Shankar Lal, P.W. 11 Veerpal, P.W. 12 Saudan Singh, P.W. 13 Gulab Singh, P.W. 15 Soorajpal and P.W. 16 Harishankar, the informant of the case were examined as witnesses of fact while P.W. 14 V.S. Sirohi, the second investigating officer of the case who had competed the investigation and filed charge sheets, P.W. 17 Dr. Gyan S. Sharma, who had examined the injuries of Umesh Chandra son of Shishu Pal Singh and Narsi son of Bhagwan Singh and prepared their injury reports and proved the same as Ext. Ka34 to Ext. Ka36, P.W. 18 Dayaram Dwivedi, second investigating officer of the case were produced as formal witnesses.

    (67) Learned counsel for the appellants have submitted that considering the glaring contradictions, material improvements and irreconcilable discrepancies in the statements of the witnesses of fact produced by the prosecution during the trial who had supported the prosecution case and also in view of admitted enmity between the prosecution witnesses and the appellants, the conviction of the appellants recorded by the trial court on the basis of the testimonies of such witnesses cannot be sustained. The inconsistencies in their statements with regard to the identity and number of the accused who had allegedly participated in committing the offences, belie their claim of being the eye-witnesses of the occurrence.

    (68) He next submitted that the failure of the prosecution to furnish any explanation for the burning of the house of Rajendra, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1371 of 2017 clearly indicates that the true genesis of the occurrence had been suppressed and the prosecution had not approached with clean hands. Although there is cross version of the occurrence indicating that the true prosecution side had also burnt the houses of some of the accused-appellants. Such being the state of evidence, neither the recorded conviction of the appellants nor the sentences awarded to them can be sustained and is liable to be set aside.

    (69) Per contra Sri. J.K. Upadhyay, learned A.G.A. appearing for the State-respondent has made his submissions in support of the impugned judgment and order and submitted that neither the recorded conviction of the appellants nor the sentences awarded to them suffer from any illegality or infirmity requiring any interference by this Court. This appeal lacks merit and is liable to be dismissed.

    (70) Having heard the learned counsel for the parties present and perused the entire lower court record, we find that the prosecution in order to prove the charges framed against appellants-Rajendra, Hariom, Anil @ Pappey, Santosh, Shankar Lal, Dinesh, Mukesh, Anil Kumar and Umashankar and the other accused had examined as many as 15 witnesses of fact namely P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, P.W. 2 Shanti Devi, P.W. 3 Chokhe Lal, P.W. 4 Zalim Singh, P.W. 5 Mahesh, P.W. 6 Son Pal, P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar, P.W. 8 Ram Kumari, P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra, P.W. 10 Shankar Lal, P.W. 11 Veerpal, P.W. 12 Saudan Singh, P.W. 13 Gulab Singh, P.W. 15 Soorajpal and P.W. 16 Harishankar. Out of the aforesaid fact witnesses, P.W. 3 Chokhe Lal, P.W. 4 Zalim Singh, P.W. 5 Mahesh, P.W. 6 Sonpal and P.W. 13 Gulab Singh had failed to support the prosecution case as spelt out in the F.I.R. and were declared hostile. Upon being contradicted with their statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. by the DGC (Criminal) in which they had allegedly supported the prosecution case, they in their cross-examination conducted by him with the permission of the Court denied having made any such statement to the investigating officer. It is noteworthy that the prosecution had failed to examine the investigating officer who had recorded the statements of P.W. 3 Chokhe Lal, P.W. 4 Zalim Singh, P.W. 5 Mahesh, P.W. 6 Sonpal and P.W. 13 Gulab Singh under Section 161 Cr.P.C. as he would have been the best witness to prove that the aforesaid hostile witnesses had supported the prosecution case during investigation and they had not deposed true and correct facts before the Court.

    (71) As far as P.W. 15 Soorajpal and P.W. 16 Harishankar, the informant of the case are concerned, nothing turns on their evidence as admittedly they were not the eye-witnesses of the occurrence.

    (72) We have already dealt with the evidence of P.W. 15 Soorajpal and P.W. 16 Harishankar hereinabove.

    (73) P.W. 14 V.S. Sirohi, the third investigating officer of the case in his evidence tendered before the trial court has merely narrated the steps taken by him during the investigation and prepared and proved the charge-sheets filed by him against all the appellants after completing the investigation as Ext. Ka31 and Ext. Ka32.

    (74) We are now left with the evidence of P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar, P.W. 8 Ram Kumari, P.W. 10 Shankar Lal, P.W. 11 Veerpal and P.W. 12 Saudan Singh against the appellants.

    (75) P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh in his examination-in-chief nominated Gulab Singh @ Mulla alone as the accused who had set his house ablaze. He did not take the name of any other appellant. Gulab Singh died during the trial and the trial stood abated qua Gulab Singh.

    (76) P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar in his statement recorded before the trial Court stated that appellants-Jogendra, Rajendra, Kunwar Pal Singh and non-appellants-Banwari, Mulla @ Gulab Singh and Raju etc. had come to his house on the date of incident on 11.3.1990 at about 4 P.M. He was in his house with his wife, Kamlesh, mother-Ram Kumari, sister-in-law-Vidya Devi, brother-Umashankar and children while they were taking their lunch, he heard sounds of voices exhorting to kill and burn and when he came out of his house he saw a mob which included appellants-Jogendra, Rajendra and Kunwar Pal Singh and non-appellants-Banwari, Mulla @ Gulab and Raja etc. Appellants-Rajendra and Jogendra had abused his mother and had beaten her and his other family members and after locking them inside their house, they had sprinkled kerosene oil and set his house ablaze, although his mother had requested them with folded hands to let them go but they did not show any mercy to her. He managed to save his family by demolishing the rear wall of his house. On page 117 of the paper book he in his cross-examination stated that he was facing trial in a case on the charge of having set on fire ‘Nauhra’ of Rajendra and others on the date of occurrence in which his father was also an accused. On the same page, he further admitted that on the date of incident, the police had arrived in the village at about 4:30 P.M. On page 117 of the paper book, he stated that he had not got any member of his family or himself medically examined. He further stated that he did not appreciate the act of Rajendra lodging a cross F.I.R. against him.

    (77) P.W. 8 Ram Kumari corroborated the evidence of her son P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar but she did not name non-appellants-Banwari, Mulla @ Gulab Singh and Raju also as accused, although P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar had nominated them also as accused who had set his house ablaze. She had stated that she could recognize Kunwarpal Singh, Jogendra and Rajendra only as most of the assailants had their faces smeared with colours. P.W. 8 Ram Kumari also admitted in her cross-examination that on the date of incident, ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra, Kunwar Pal Singh and Jogendra had been burnt.

    (78) Thus, from the perusal of the evidence of P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar and P.W. 8 Ram Kumari, it transpires that appellant-Rajendra had lodged a cross F.I.R. of the occurrence alleging therein that his house had been set ablaze by P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar, his father-P.W. 6 Sonpal and others and hence the possibility of P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar and P.W. 8 Ram Kumari falsely implicating Rajendra, Kunwar Pal Singh and Jogendra in this case due to enmity cannot be ruled out.

    (79) P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra stated before the trial court that on the date of incident Dinesh, Premchand, Karuwa, Nahna, Umashankar, Ram Dev, Anil Kumar, Mukesh and Pappu came to his house and after threatening to kill them they with the help of other persons had set his house ablaze after P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra and his family members had come out of the same. In his cross-examination on page 78 of the paper book, he admitted that Dinesh, Hariom, Prem Chandra had set the ‘Nauhra’ of Rajendra, Jogendra and Kunwar Pal Singh on fire. He further admitted in his cross-examination that the miscreants were carrying torches, cans filled with kerosene oil and cow dung cakes and they were setting the houses ablaze by dipping cow dungs into the kerosene oil and they throwing the same on the roofs of the houses. The aforesaid fact was conspicuous by its absence in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. and when he was contradicted with the same he stated that he had told the aforesaid fact to the investigating officer but he had no explanation why he had not recorded the same in his statement. He also admitted in his cross-examination that although the accused had threatened to kill him and his family members but when they came out of their house they had not stopped them and after he had come out of his house, the above named accused had entered into his house and set it ablaze. When he was contradicted with his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. in which the aforesaid fact was conspicuous by its absence, he deposed that he had told the said fact to the investigating officer. He had no explanation why the aforesaid fact did not find mention in his statement recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C.

    (80) From the perusal of the statement of P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra, it transpires that he had not nominated appellants-Rajendra, Hariom, Jogendra Singh as accused, although P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar and P.W. 8 Ram Kumari had named them as accused. It further follows from the facts stated by him in his statement recorded before the trial court that he made material improvements in his evidence tendered during the trial by stating the facts which were not mentioned in his statements recorded under Section 161 Cr.P.C. to suit the prosecution. Thus, P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra does not appears to be a reliable witness at all.

    (81) P.W. 10 Shankar Lal stated before the trial court that accused-appellants-Rajendra, Kunwar Pal Singh and Jogendra etc. had constructed a temple on the land belonging to the Jatavs in his village. Sonpal Singh had opened the door of his house towards the temple. However due to pressure exerted on him by the Thakurs of the village, he had closed the door of his house due to which relations between Thakurs and Jatavs had become inimical. On the date of incident while holi festival was being celebrated at about 3-4 P.M., the appellants-Kunwar Pal Singh, Rajendra, Jogendra, Santosh, Hariom, non-appellants-Devesh, Kaluwa, Nahna came with about 50-60 other persons and after dividing themselves into several groups, appellants-Hariom, Santosh, Dinesh, non-appellants, Kaluwa and Devesh had set his house on fire. They were armed with lathi and danda. Apart from beating them they had also fired shots. There is no evidence on record showing that he or his family members had got their injuries examined. He further stated that he had fled from his house with his children and on returning to his house he had found his house had been plundered and his household articles burnt. He also stated that a report of the incident was lodged by him at the police station after 10-16 days of the occurrence. He in his cross-examination denied that ‘Nauhra’ of the appellants-Kunwar Pal Singh, Rajendera and Jogendra had also been set on fire on the date of the incident. He also stated that he had no knowledge whether appellant-Rajendra had lodged a first information report against his uncles-Sonpal, Chokhe Lal and Khachermal with regard to the burning of his ‘Nauhra’.

    (82) P.W. 11 Veerpal stated before the trial court that on the date of incident at about 3 P.M., appellants-Dinesh Darji, Hariom, Shambhoo and non-appellant Premchandra along with 8-10 other persons whom he could not recognize as their faces were smeared with colour had thrown brickbats at his house on which he got scared and ran away. Upon returning, he found thatched roof of several houses of the locality had been burnt. Some household articles were missing. In his cross-examination, he stated that he was not aware about the identity of the persons who had burnt the houses. He further stated in his evidence that some persons had set ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra and Kunwarpal Singh ablaze. Thus, it is evident from the statement of P.W. 11 Veerpal that he had not seen the persons who had burnt his house. Thus, nothing turns upon his evidence against the appellants.

    (83) P.W. 12 Saudan Singh stated before the trial court that on the date of incident at about 3:30 P.M., appellants-Dinesh Darji, Hariom and non-appellants-Premchandra and Sunil came to his house with 10-15 persons whom he could not recognize as their faces were smeared with colour. They had burnt the thatched roof of his house as well as the thatched roofs of the house of his son. In his cross-examination, he admitted that apart from Dinesh Darji, 10-15 other persons whose faces were smeared with colour had burnt his house. Upon seeing the mob, he had not run away when the thatched roof of his house was ablaze. The police was also present in the village. He had requested the S.O. with folded hands. He also admitted that on the date of incident, ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra and Kunwar Pal Singh had been set on fire. He also stated that the investigating officer had not recorded his statement during the investigation. Thus, it is proved from the evidence of P.W. 12 Saudan Singh that the facts deposed by him before the trial court were stated by him for the first time as he had admitted that the investigating officer had not recorded his statement during the investigation and considering the fact that he has named only appellants-Dinesh Darji and Hariom as the perpetrators of the crime and has failed to depose against the other appellants, we do not find him a reliable witness.

    (84) A persual of the statement of P.W. 7 to P.W. 12, it evinces that none of them have stated that all the appellants namely Rajendra, Hariom, Anil @ Pappey, Santosh, Raja, Dinesh, Mukesh, Anil @ Bhola and Umashankar had participated in the occurrence. It has also come in their evidence that at the time when the houses of Harijans were being allegedly burnt, the miscreants had smeared their faces with colour and the witnesses could not recognize them. It also follows from their statements that the relations between the Jatavs and the Thakurs of the villages were inimical on account of the fact that the Thakurs had constructed a temple on the land of P.W. 6 Sonpal who had opened the door of his house facing the temple but he had closed the same on account of the pressure exerted on him by the Thakurs of the village. It is also established from the evidence on record that on the date of incident, ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra, Jogendra and Kunwar Pal Singh was also burnt with regard to which a cross F.I.R. was lodged by appellant-Rajendra against P.W. 6 Sonpal, uncle of P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh and his father-P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar.

    (85) Upon a further careful scrutiny of the statements of P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar, P.W. 8 Ram Kumari, P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra, P.W. 10 Shankar Lal, P.W. 11 Veerpal and P.W. 12 Saudan Singh, we find that there is a glaring discrepancy in their statements with regard to the number of accused-appellants who had set their houses ablaze while P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh nominated P.W. 13 Gulab Singh alone. P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar nominated appellants-Jogendra, Rajendra and Kunwarpal Singh and non-appellants, Banwari, Mulla @ Gulab, Raja and other unknown persons as accused, his mother-P.W. 8 Ram Kumari did not name non-appellants Banwari, Mulla @ Gulab and Raja also as accused. P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra while nominating Dinesh, Premchand, Karuwa, Nahna, Umashankar, Ramdev, Anil Kumar, Mukesh as the persons who had torched his house failed to name appellants-Rajendra, Hariom and Jogendra Singh as accused. P.W. 10 Shankar Lal again nominated appellants-Rajendra, Kunwarpal Singh, Jogendra, Santosh and Hariom and non-appellants Devesh, Karuwa who according to him had beaten him with lathi and danda and fired shots in the air and had plundered his household articles in his absence. P.W. 11 Veerpal nominated appellants-Dinesh Darji, Hariom, Shambhoo and non-appellants Premchand along with 8-10 other persons who could not be recognized by the witness but did not attribute any overt act to them. P.W. 12 Saudan Singh named Dinesh Darji, Premchand, Hariom and Sunil as the persons who had burnt his house as well as the house of his son. It has also come in their evidence as already noted by us hereinabove that the members of the mob which was torching the houses belonging to the Jatavs in the locality and plundering their houses had their faces smeared with colour. It is highly improbable that if the incident had taken place while the festival of holi was being celebrated why the appellants alone decided not to put colour on their faces and expose themselves to the danger of being recognized and identified as the persons who had committed the offences with a large number of other unknown persons. It is proved to the hilt from the statements of the prosecution witnesses that there was enmity between the Jatavs and the Thakurs of the village due to the fact that the Thakurs had not appreciated the act of P.W. 6 Sonpal of opening the door of his house towards the temple which they had allegedly constructed on the land of P.W. 6 Sonpal but on account of the threat and pressure of the Thakurs, he had closed the same. It is also established from the evidence of the prosecution witnesses that on the date of incident ‘Nauhar’ of appellants-Rajendra, Jogendra and Kunwarpal Singh had also been burnt with regard to which a cross F.I.R. was lodged by appellant-Rajendra against P.W. 6 Sonpal, uncle of P.W. 1 Chhatrapal Singh, his father and P.W. 7 Ashok Kumar. The prosecution has failed to come up with any explanation for the burning of ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra, Jogendra and Kunwarpal Singh in the same occurrence. There is no mention in the F.I.R. of the occurrence which was lodged by P.W. 16 Harishankar about the ‘Nauhra’ of appellants-Rajendra, Jogendra and Kunwarpal Singh also having been burnt in the same incident. It is also proved from the evidence of P.W. 16 Harishankar and P.W. 12 Saudan Singh that even before the lodging of the F.I.R. while the occurrence was taking place the police had arrived at the crime scene and hence the possibility of the written report being prepared and scribed after the due deliberations and consultations between the police and P.W. 16 Harishankar containing a false and concocted prosecution story falsely implicating the appellants cannot be ruled out.

    (86) Another very startling aspect of the matter is that although none of the prosecution witnesses have deposed about the complicity of Anil @ Pappey, appellant in criminal appeal no. 1289 of 2017 but it appears that he has been convicted by the learned trial judge illegally by placing reliance on the evidence of P.W. 9 Suresh Chandra who on page 78 of the paper book had deposed about the participation Anil Kumar, A2 in criminal appeal no. 1302 of 2017.

    (87) Since it has come in the evidence of two prosecution witnesses that the police was present in the village at the time when the accused-appellants were allegedly indulging in act of violence and arson. No explanation is coming forth from the side of the prosecution as to how the accused-appellants could set ablaze the houses of the members of the Jatavs community in the village in the presence of the police. It is difficult for us to believe that devastation of such magnitude could be caused by the accused-appellants in the presence of the police in the village including the S.H.O. of the police.

    (88) The cumulative effect of the aforesaid omission, inconsistencies and loopholes in the prosecution case compels us to hold that the true genesis of the incident has been suppressed and the prosecution has not come with clean hands and under the facts and circumstances of the case, the possibility of appellants-Rajendra, Hariom, Anil @ Pappey, Santosh, Shambhoo, Dinesh Darji, Mukesh, Anil @ Bhola, Umashankar having been falsely implicated in the present case cannot be ruled out. Although the offence had been committed by the persons who had camoflash themselves by smearing their faces with colour whom the witnesses were unable to recognize and the appellants were falsely implicated in the present case after due deliberations and consultations with the police. It has come in the evidence of P.W. 12 Saudan Singh that when the houses of the Jatav were being burnt, the S.H.O. were present in the village and he had requested to him with folded hands to stop the genocide.

    (89) Thus, upon a wholesome consideration of the facts of the case, attending circumstances and the nature of the evidence on record, we do not find that the prosecution has been able to prove its case against the accused-appellants beyond all reasonable doubt and they are entitled to benefit of doubt. Hence neither the recorded conviction of the appellants nor the sentences awarded to them can be sustained and are liable to be set aside.

    (90) Now coming to the third set namely Criminal Misc. Application u/S 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave to Appeal) No. 284 of 2017 which has been filed by appellant-Rajendra Singh seeking leave to file an appeal against the judgment and order dated 14.7.2017 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 5, Hathras in cross case namely S.T. No. 153 of 2010 (State v. Niranjan Singh) arising out of Case Crime No. 78-B of 1990, under Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 427, 295, 307 I.P.C., P. S. Sasani, District Hathras by which he has acquitted opposite party nos. 2 to 5 from all the charges.

    (91) Briefly stated the facts of this case are that the informant-Rajendra Singh gave a written report at P.S. Sasani, District Hathras on 7.3.1990 stating therein that the accused-Sonpal resident of village Rudayan in connivance with several other villagers had demolished the temple constructed on public land. Upon the information of the incident given by the Chief of the village to the police station, the police force arrived at the crime scene on which Sonpal fled. A written compromise was arrived at between the parties in which it was agreed that the temple shall be re-constructed and Sonpal shall not open his door towards it. The compromise was signed by Village Chief and Sub Village Chief, Surajpal etc. The police inspector returned to the police station with the written compromise. Thereafter, the temple was reconstructed on 9.3.1990 Sonpal and several members belonging to the Jatav caste damaged the wall of the temple at two places with the object of removing the doors of the temple. The villagers including those belonging to the Jatav caste tried to remonstrate with Sonpal but he along with Niranjan, ramesh, Chandrapal, Indrapal, Bhagwandas, Satish, Sonpal, Bhajanlal, Laxmi etc. refused to relent. On noticing that the situation was getting out of control, Village Chief and Sub Village Chief Sri. Ravendra Pathak somehow succeeded in persuading the parties to enter into compromise and it was again agreed that one door of the temple shall be removed.

    (92) On 11.3.1990 at about 4 P.M., when they went to the temple to celebrate holi, singing holi songs, they saw Sonpal, Bhawan Singh, Chokhey, Ashok, Netrapal, Zalim, Jagdish, Man Singh, Shishupal, Durga, Gulab, Chandrapal, Khajani, Pappu, Phool Singh, Babu etc. coming towards the temple hurling abuses at them and started throwing stones at them. In order to save themselves, they started running helter and skelter. Phool Singh, Babu, Chokhey, Sonpal and several other persons set their houses on fire and fired shots in the air. Some members of the Jatav community set their own houses also on fire. Someone gave information of the occurrence to the police on which police force arrived at 5:30 P.M. Informant's Nauhra and all the items kept by him in his agricultural field were burnt. The informant had suffered a loss of Rs. 3000/-

    (93) On the basis of the written complaint lodged by the informant, case crime no. 78-B of 1990 was registered on 12.03.1990 against all the accused.

    (94) The investigating officer after completing the investigation filed charge-sheet against Sonpal, Mitthu, Khacche, Chokhey, Ashok, Netrapal, Zalim, Jagdish, Kehri Singh, Khajan, Vimlesh, Man Singh, Shishu Pal, Durga, Chandrapal, Gulab, Khajani Pappu, Phool Singh, Lalu, Ramesh, Radheyshyam, Niranjan, Satish, Gramsingh and Indrapal.

    (95) Since the offences mentioned in the charge-sheet were triable exclusively by the Court of Sessions Judge, C.J.M. Hathras committed the accused for trial to the Court of Sessions Judge, Hathras where case crime no. 78-B of 1990 was registered as S.T. No. 153 of 2010 (State v. Niranjan Singh) and made over for trial from there to the Court of Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 5, Hathras who on the basis of the material on record framed charge under Sections 147, 148, 436, 323/149, 307, 427 and 295 I.P.C. The accused abjured the charge and claimed trial.

    (96) The prosecution in order to prove its case against the accused examined P.W. 1 Insaf Ali, P.W. 2 V.S. Sirohi, P.W. 3 Rajendra Singh (informant) and P.W. 4 Dayaram Dwivedi as witnesses.

    (97) The prosecution also adduced documentary evidence consisting of photo copy of the chek F.I.R., photo copy of the written report of the incident, charge-sheet Ext. Ka1, site plans of the place of occurrence Ext. Ka2, Ext. Ka3 and Ext Ka5, recovery memo of the ash recovered from the place of incident Ext. Ka4.

    (98) The accused in their statements recorded under Section 313 Cr.P.C. denied the prosecution case as false and alleged false implication.

    (99) Learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 5, Hathras after considering the submissions advanced before him by the learned counsel for the parties and scrutinizing the evidence on record, acquitted the opposite party nos. 2 to 5 by the impugned judgment and order.

    (100) Hence this application.

    (101) It is contended by the learned counsel for the applicant that the finding of the acquittal recorded by the learned trial judge is vitiated by non consideration of the material evidence on record. The impugned judgment and order which is per se illegal and is liable to be set aside.

    (102) Having heard the learned counsel for the applicant and perused the entire lower court record very carefully, we find that the two witnesses of fact examined during the trial were declared hostile after they failed to support the prosecution case regarding the complicity of the opposite parties.

    (103) The learned trial judge after considering the evidence on record, came to the conclusion that the prosecution has miserably failed to establish the charges framed against the opposite party nos. 2 to 5 and proceeded to acquit them after giving benefit of doubt to them.

    (104) We have very carefully perused the impugned judgment and order as well as the entire lower court record including the statements of the witnesses recorded during the trial and we do not find that the learned trial judge committed any illegality or legal infirmity in acquitting the opposite party nos. 2 to 5. Both the eye-witnesses of the occurrence had failed to support the prosecution case during the trial and were declared hostile. The finding of acquittal recorded by the learned trial court is supported by cogent reasons and relevant considerations. Learned counsel for the appellants has failed to demonstrate that the finding of acquittal recorded by the trial court is vitiated by non-consideration of any relevant material or is perverse. The application for leave to appeal is liable to be rejected. (105) We accordingly refuse to grant leave to the applicant-Rajendra Singh to file appeal against the impugned judgment and order.

    (106) These are the reasons upon which we had allowed Capital Case No. 1368 of 2017 along with connected Criminal Appeal Nos. 1289 of 2017, 1296 of 2017, 1302 of 2017, 1370 of 2017, 1371 of 2017, 1440 of 2017, 1473 of 2017 and dismissed Reference No. 3 of 2017 and Criminal Misc. Application u/s 372 Cr.P.C. (Leave to Appeal) No. 284 of 2017.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kunwar Pal Singh v. State Of U.P . .
    (Apr 10, 2019)