AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Mumbai .

    Raju, Member (Technical):— This appeal has been filed by M/s. Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. The appellant had filed a claim of refund in respect of supply of Low Sulphur High Flash High Speed (LSHFHS) Diesel to Indian Navy. They claimed exemption under Notification No. 64/95-CE dated 16/03/1995.

    2. Ld. Counsel for the appellant argued that they had purchased LSHFHS from M/s. BPCL on payment of duty and stored in their warehouse at Wadala. Out of the said quantity stored in their warehouse, they supplied a part to Indian Navy and claimed benefit of Notification No. 64/95-CE dated 06/03/95 by filing the refund claims. The said refund claim was rejected by the original adjudicating authority relying on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Leader Engineering Works - 2007 (212) ELT 168 (SC). The matter was adjudicated before the Commissioner (Appeals) who held that the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Leader Engineering Works has no relevance and allowed the appeal with consequential relief. The Assistant Commissioner sanctioned the part refund amount and rejected the balance on the ground that it is not possible to distinguish whether the duty amount paid by BPCL has been paid/passed on by the appellant. The matter was agitated before the Commissioner (Appeals). The Commissioner (Appeals) rejected their appeal on the ground that it is not clear that who was borne the incidence of duty of the said amount.

    3. Ld. Counsel argued that they have not recovered any duty amount from the Indian Navy as is apparent from the invoice issued by the appellant to the Indian Navy. He pointed out that the appellant had claimed refund only in respect of the duty paid LSHFHS supplied to the Indian Navy. He argued that in the first adjudication, the refund was rejected solely following the ratio of the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Leader Engineering Works and the Commissioner (Appeals) has held that the said ratio cannot be applied to the instant case. It is not open to Revenue to introduce fresh ground for rejection. He argued that no appeal has been filed against the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) granting them consequential relief. He further argued that they have submitted following the evidence before the Commissioner (Appeals) in support of their claim that they have borne the incidence of duty:

    “Letter dated 26/09/2006 addressed by Assistant Commissioner, Chembur-I Div. to BPCL stating that Appellant's should have claimed refund of Rs. 1,42,59,155/-

    ii) Certificate from BPCL stating that the duty amount of Rs. 1,2,13,104/- was paid by appellants to BPCL in respect of invoices dated 21/09/2005, 27/09/2005 and 18/10/2005.

    iii) BPCL's letter dated 14/03/2007 addressed to Asst. Commr. Chembur-I Div. stating that they have received the duty settlement signed from Appellants vide Joint Certificate dated 14/03/2007 in respect of three invoices dated 21/09/2005, 27/09/2005 and 18/10/2005

    iv) BPCL's letter dated 26/03/2007 addressed to Asst. Commr., Chembur-I Division, stating that they are withdrawing their Refund Claim of Rs. 1,42,59,155/- filed on 18/09/2006.

    v) Order-in-original No. BNMS/Refund/61-R/CH-I/2006-07 dated 26/03/2007 passed by Asst. Commissioner in case of BPCL, thereby rejecting the refund of Rs. 1,42,59,155/- as withdrawn by BPCL.

    4. Ld. AR relies on the impugned order.

    5. We have gone through the Rival submissions. We find that in original proceedings the only ground for rejection of refund claim was the ratio of the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Leader Engineering Works (supra). The said ground of rejection has been set aside by the Commissioner (Appeals) and the said order of the Commissioner (Appeals) has not been challenged by the Revenue. The Commissioner (Appeals) had allowed consequential relief and in the said proceedings of granting consequential relief, lower authority have raised the issue regarding who was borne the burden of duty paid. In this regard, the appellants have relied on the letter of the BPCL by the Assistant Commissioner of Central Excise, Chembur, where he has stated that the appellant should have claimed the refund as the goods were supplied from the IOCL installation. They have also relied on the certificate issued by the BPCL where it has been stated that the transaction payment between BPCL and IOC in respect of said disputed refund have been settled in fully and final. They have also referred on the letter addressed to Assistant Commissioner, Chembur, wherein they have informed that duty amount between the IOC and BPCL in respect of said amount has been settled.

    5.1 In view of the so much evidence it cannot be said that burden of duty was not passed on to IOCL. The IOCL could therefore, claim refund of the same, since the order of the Commissioner (Appeals) directing grant of consequential relief has not been challenged.

    6. In these circumstances, we do not find any merit in the impugned order denying the refund. The appeal is consequently allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise, Mumbai .
    (Jan 11, 2018)