AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-clause (c) of clause (1A) and item (b) if sub-clause (iii) of clause (14) of Section 2 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961)
  • SECTION 260 A INCOME TAX ACT 1961
  • SECTION 2 INCOME TAX ACT
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income Tax Act
  • provision of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (43
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(b) in the Act,
  • Clause (a) of Section 2(14)(iii)
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(b).
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(a).
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • sub-clause (c) of clause (1A) and item (b) if sub-clause (iii) of clause (14) of Section 2 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961)
  • SECTION 260 A INCOME TAX ACT 1961
  • SECTION 2 INCOME TAX ACT
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income Tax Act
  • provision of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (43
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(b) in the Act,
  • Clause (a) of Section 2(14)(iii)
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(b).
  • Section 2(14)(iii)(a).
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion — Adarsh Kumar Goel, J. (Oral)

This summary is prepared strictly from the text of the provided opinion. No information has been added or inferred beyond that text.

Factual and Procedural Background

This consolidated order disposes of ITAs No. 276 of 2004, 54 of 2005 and 448 of 2009 because the learned counsel for the revenue stated that facts and law in the appeals are common; the facts are taken from ITA No. 276 of 2004.

ITA No. 276 of 2004 was preferred by the revenue under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 against the order dated 19 April 2004 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench 'B' in ITA No. 135.Chandi/2001 for the assessment year 1997-1998. The revenue framed two substantial questions of law (quoted in the opinion).

The factual core is that the assessee sold agricultural land and the revenue sought to tax capital gain on the ground that the agricultural land fell within the definition of "capital asset" under Section 2(14) of the Act. The land was situated in the State of Punjab but fell within the specified distance from the municipal limits of Panchkula (a municipality in the State of Haryana) as per the notification dated 6 January 1994 under Section 2(14)(iii)(b). The CIT(A) deleted the addition holding that because the land was in Punjab and Panchkula municipality was in Haryana, the land could not be treated as a capital asset by reference to a municipality located in a different State; the Tribunal upheld that view. The court heard learned counsel for the parties and delivered the order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the ITA was right in law in holding that impugned agricultural land does not come within the definition "Capital Asset" as defined u/s. 2(14) of the Income Tax Act because the land in question is situated in the State of Punjab and beyond 8 kilometers of Municipal limits of Rajpura even when the impugned land is also situated within a distance of 5 kilometers of the Municipal limits of Panchkula, District Ambala (Haryana)?
  2. Whether expression “from the local limits of any municipality” used in Section 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income Tax Act denotes “any municipality or municipality of the district in which the land is situated?”

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments

  • The definition for determining whether land is agricultural (and thus excluded) or urban (and thus a capital asset) depends on whether the land is within or within the requisite distance from a municipality; the location of the municipality (even if outside the State in which the land is situated) is relevant to that determination.
  • In the present case the land is in Punjab but falls within the requisite distance from Panchkula municipality; even if Panchkula is outside Punjab, the land should nonetheless be treated as urban land covered by Section 2(14).
  • Any other interpretation — i.e., giving effect only to municipalities within the same State as the land — would defeat the object of the statutory provisions.

Assessee's Arguments

  • If the land is within the requisite distance of a municipality situated in another State, it will not be covered by Section 2(14) unless it is within or within the requisite distance of a municipality of the same State where the land is situated.
  • Under Article 243Q, municipalities are to be constituted in every State, so the concept of a State-specific municipality cannot be ignored.
  • Panchkula municipality was constituted on 25 January 2001; for the relevant year it was a Notified Area Committee, which the assessee contends is at par with municipality under Section 2(14)(iii)(a).
  • Referring to the Finance Minister's speech while introducing the Finance Bill 1970, the assessee argued that the word "such municipality" in Section 2(14)(iii)(b) refers back to "municipality" in clause (a) and therefore municipality must be State-specific; ignoring the word "such" would render it redundant.
  • The assessee relied on authorities establishing the principle that no word of a statute should be treated as redundant or superfluous; the opinion cites the following cases relied upon by the assessee: J.K. Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh (AIR 1964 SC 1170), Union of India v. Hansoli Devi ((2002) 7 SCC 273, AIR 2002 SC 3240), and Sankar Ram and Co. v. Kasi Naicker ((2003) 11 SCC 699, AIR 2003 SC 4156).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
J.K. Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh, AIR 1964 SC 1170 Illustration of the principle that words in a statute should not be treated as redundant or superfluous. The court observed that the judgments relied upon to submit that all words of a statute should be assigned meaning do not support the assessee's contention; in other words, this precedent did not assist the assessee's position in the present case.
Union of India v. Hansoli Devi, (2002) 7 SCC 273; AIR 2002 SC 3240 Authority cited for the settled principle that words in a statute should be given meaning and not be treated as redundant. The court held that this authority did not support the assessee's contention that the word "such" required a State-specific reading of "municipality" for Section 2(14).
Sankar Ram and Co. v. Kasi Naicker, (2003) 11 SCC 699; AIR 2003 SC 4156 Authority cited for the same statutory interpretation principle (no redundancy of words). The court concluded that reliance on this judgment did not assist the assessee; the precedent did not mandate the interpretation urged by the assessee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the text of Section 2(14) of the Income Tax Act and the Central Government notification dated 6 January 1994 specifying areas to be treated as urban for the purposes of Section 2(14)(iii)(b). The statutory provision (quoted in the opinion) excludes from "capital asset" agricultural land in India not being land situate—

(a) in any area comprised within the jurisdiction of a municipality or cantonment board having population of not less than ten thousand, or

(b) in any area within such distance, not being more than eight kilometers, from the local limits of any municipality or cantonment board referred to in item (a), as the Central Government may specify by notification.

The notification's Schedule (as reproduced in the opinion) lists Panchkula (District Ambala, Haryana) with "Areas up to a distance of 5 kms. from the municipal limits in all directions" and lists Rajpura (Punjab) with specified areas and distances including up to 8 kms on one road.

From a perusal of these provisions the court concluded that the statutory scheme intends to treat as "capital asset" agricultural land that is comprised within a municipality or within the specified distance from the local limits of a municipality or other local bodies as specified in the notification. It was undisputed that the land in question is within the specified distance from Panchkula municipality (which falls in Haryana) while the land itself is in Punjab.

The court reasoned that the concept of a municipality as a unit of State, or the fact that a State has no jurisdiction beyond its territory, has no relevance for the narrow question of whether particular land is a "capital asset" for the purpose of taxing capital gains under Section 2(14). If land is adjacent to a municipality and is urban land covered under Section 2(14), the court held that it remains urban land even if the municipality and the land fall in different States; excluding such land from the definition would defeat the purpose of the statutory scheme.

The court further observed that the judgments cited by the assessee for the proposition that all words in a statute must be assigned meaning do not, in fact, support the assessee's contention that a State-specific reading is required. The court also considered the extract from the Finance Minister's speech quoted by the assessee and held that the speech does not lead to the alternative interpretation advanced by the assessee.

On this basis the court answered the substantial questions of law in favour of the revenue and against the assessee.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court answered the substantial questions in favour of the revenue and against the assessee and accordingly allowed the appeals and set aside the impugned orders.

Direct consequences for the parties (as expressed in the opinion):

  • The appeals by the revenue were allowed.
  • The impugned orders (i.e., the Tribunal / lower authority rulings that had treated the land as not within the definition of "capital asset") were set aside.
  • By the court's reasoning, the land in question is to be treated as urban land for the purpose of the definition of "capital asset" under the statutory provision as interpreted in this judgment (the opinion states this conclusion explicitly).

Broader implications: The court held that the State boundary/location of the municipality (i.e., whether the municipality is in the same State as the land) is not relevant to the determination under Section 2(14); however, the opinion does not frame or state that it is laying down a new binding precedent beyond the resolution of these appeals.


Order notes: The order was delivered orally by Adarsh Kumar Goel, J.; a photocopy of the order was directed to be placed on the file of each connected case.

    Commissioner Of Income Tax, Chandigarh v. Smt. Anjana Sehgal .

    Adarsh Kumar Goel, J. (Oral):— This order will dispose of ITAs No. 276 of 2004, 54 of 2005 and 448 of 2009 as it is stated by the learned counsel for the revenue that facts and law involved in these appeals are common. However, the facts or taken from ITA No. 276 of 2004.

    (2) ITA No. 276 of 2004 has been preferred by the revenue under Section 260 A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) against order dated 19th April, 2004 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Chandigarh Bench ‘B’, Chandigarh in ITA No. 135.Chandi/2001, for the assessment year 1997-1998, claiming substantial questions of law:—

    “(i) Whether the ITA was right in law in holding that impugned agricultural land does not come within the definition “Capital Asset” as defined u/s. 2(14) of the Income Tax Act because the land in question is situated in the State of Punjab and beyond 8 kilometers of Municipal limits of Rajpura even when the impugned land is also situtated within a distance of 5 kilometers of the Municipal limits of Panchkula, District Ambala (Haryana)?

    (ii) Whether expression “from the local limits of any municipality” used in Section 2(14)(iii)(b) of the Income Tax Act denotes “any municipality or municipality of the district in which the land is situated?”

    (3) The assessee sold agricultural land and was sought to be taxed for the capital gain on the ground that agricultural land in question was covered by the definition of ‘Capital assest’ under Section 2(14) of the Act. The land was situated within 8 kilometers of the municipal limits of Panchkula and was thus covered by the notification dated 6th January, 1994 contemplated under Section 2(14)(iii)(b). On appeal, the CIT(A) deleted addition holding that the land in question was in the State of Punjab while Panchkula municipality was in the State of Haryana and even if the land was within the specified distance of municipality in the State of Haryana, the same could not be treated to be capital asset when the land was not in that State. The Tribunal upheld the said view.

    (4) We have heard learned counsel for the parties.

    (5) Learned counsel for the revenue submits that the definition for the purpose of land being included in agricultural land or otherwise and thus being capital asset or otherwise has consider whether the location of the land is within a municipality or within requisite distance of the municipality so that the urban land is treated as capital asset and is not excluded therefrom. In the present case, the land falls within the State of Punjab and is within the requisite distance from a specified municipality. Even if such municipality is out side the State of Punjab, land nonetheless remains urban. Any other interpretation will defeat the object of the provisions.

    (6) Learned counsel for the assessee on the other hand submits that if the land was within the requisite distance from a specified municipality of any other State, the same will not be covered unless it was within or within the requisite distance from the municipality of the State. It was submitted that under Article 243Q municipalities are to be constituted in every State and thus the concept of State specific municipality cannot be ignored. It was also submitted that municipality of Panchkula was constituted on 25th January, 2001 and for the relevant year the same was Notified Area Committee which is at par with the municipality under Section 2(14)(iii)(a). Referring to the speech of the Finance Minister while introducing Finance Bill, 1970, interpreting Section 2(14)(iii)(b) in the Act, it was stated that the word ‘such municipality’ referred to the expression ‘municipality’ to be found in Clause (a) of Section 2(14)(iii) it was submitted that municipality had to be State specific. If the expression ‘such’ is to be ignored the same be against the settled principle that no word should be treated to be redundant or superfluous as held in J.K Cotton Spinning and Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of Uttar Pradesh () AIR 1964 SC 1170, Union of India v. Hansoli Devi () (2002) 7 SCC 273 , AIR 2002 SC 3240, and Sankar Ram and Co. v. Kasi Naicker () (2003) 11 SCC 699 , AIR 2003 SC 4156.

    (7) To appreciate the controversy, it will be appropriate to refer relevant provisions of Section 2(14) of the Act:—

    “2(14) “Capital asset” means property of any kind held by an assessee, whether or not connected with his business or profession, but does not include—

    (i) xxxxxxxx

    (ii) xxxxxxxx

    (iii) agricultural land in India, not being land situate—

    (a) in any area which is comprised within the jurisdiction of a municipality (whether known as a municipality, municipal corporation, notified area committee, town area committee, town committee, or by any other name) or a cantonment board and which has a population of not less than ten thousand according to the last preceding census of which the relevant figures have been published before the first day of the previous year; or

    (b) in any area within such distance, not being more than eight kilometers, from the local limits of any municipality or cantonment board referred to in item (a), as the Central Government may, having regard to the extent of, and scope for, urbanization of that area and other relevant considerations, specified in this behalf by notification in the Official Gazette”.

    (iv) xxxxxxxx

    (v) xxxxxxxx

    (vi) xxxxxxxx

    The notification dated 6th January, 1994 issued by the Central Government is as under:—

    “Now, Therefore, in exercise of the powers conferred by item (B) of clause (ii) of the proviso to sub-clause (c) of clause (1A) and item (b) if sub-clause (iii) of clause (14) of Section 2 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961) and in supersession of the notification of the Government of India in the erstwhile Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue and insurance) No. S077(E) dated 6th March, 1973 the Central Government having regard to the extent of and scope for urbanization of the areas concerned and other relevant considerations, hereby specifies the areas shown in column (4) of the Schedule hereto annexed and falling outside the local limits of Municipality or Cantonment Boards, as the case may be shown in the corresponding entry in column (3) thereof and against the State or Union Territory shown in column (2) thereof for the purposes of the above-mentioned provision of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (43 of 1961).

    SCHEDULE

    Sr. No. State or Union Territory Name of the Name of the Municipality or Cantonment Board falling in the State/Union Territory mentioned under column (2) Details of areas falling outside the local limits of Municipality of Cantonment Board etc. under column (3). 1 2 3 4 9. HARYANA 44. Panchkuala (Distt. Ambala) Areas up to a distance of 5 kms. from the municipal limits in all directions xx xx xxx xxx
    18. PUNJAB 35. Rajpura Areas falling within— (i) 1 Km. on either side of Rajpura-Sirhind Road up to a distance of 3 Kms. from the municipal limits on that road. (ii) 1 Km. on either side of Rajpura-Banaur Road up to a distance of Kms. from the municipal limits on that road. (iii) 1 Km. on either side of Rajpura-Ambala Road up to a distance of 4 Kms. from the municipal limits on that road. (iv) 1 Km. on either side of Rajpura-Ghanour Road up to a distance of 4 Kms. from the municipal limits on that road. (v) 1 Km. on either side of Rajpura-Patiala Road up to a distance of 8 Kms. from the municipal limits of Rajpura.

    (8) A perusal of the above provisions makes it clear that what it intended to be covered in term ‘Capital Asset’ is agricultural land comprised within the jurisdiction of a municipality and within the specified distance from the local limits of municipality or other local bodies mentioned therein as specified in the notification. It is undisputed that the land in question is within the specified distance from Panchkula municipality which falls in the State of Haryana while land is in the State of Punjab. Thus land is urban land for the purpose of definition of ‘capital asset’ under Section 29(14). Concept of municipality as a unit of State or the fact that a State has no jurisdiction to make law beyond its territory have no relevance for the purpose of determining whether particular land was ‘capital asset’ or not for the purpose of taxing capital gain. If the land is adjacent to a municipality and is urban land covered under Section 2(14), even if municipality and the land fall in different States, the land will continue to be urban land. If such land is excluded from the definition of ‘capital asset’, purpose of statutory scheme will not be achieved.

    (9) The judgments relied upon to submit that all words of a statute should be assigned meaning do not support the contention of the assessee, including the land in dispute in ‘capital asset’ does not ignore any word in the definition as assumed by learned counsel. Speech of Finance Minister also does not help the assessee. The relevant extract thereof is as under:—

    “Sub-clause (a) seeks to amend clause (14) of section 2 of the Income Tax Act which defines the term “capital asset”. The amendment seeks to bring within the term “capital asset” agricultural land situated within the limits of any municipality (whether known as a municipality, municipal corporation notified area committee, town area committee, town committee or by any other name) or a cantonment Board having a population of 10,000 or more according to the last census for which the figures have been published before the first day of the previous year. Further, agricultural land situated in areas lying within a distance not exceeding 8 kilometers from the local limits of such municipalities or cantonment boards will also be covered by the amended definition of “capital asset”, if such areas are, having regard to the extent of and scope for their urbanization and other relevant considerations, notified by the Central Government in this behalf. The effect of the proposed amendment will be that capital gains arirsing from the transfer of agricultural land situated in municipal or other urban areas or notified adjoining areas will be liable to income-tax for the assessment year 1970-1971 and subsequent years.”

    (10) We are unable to accept that the above speech leads to any other interpretation. Accordingly, we answer substantial questions in favour of the revenue and against the assessee.

    (11) Accordinghly, the appeals are allowed, The impugned orders are set aside.

    (12) A photocopy of this order be placed on the file of each connected case.

    M. Jain

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Income Tax, Chandigarh v. Smt. Anjana Sehgal .
    (Mar 1, 2011)