Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1071
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Act, 1960
  • Section 23 of the Act, 1960
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Act (year not specified)
  • Section 10(3)(e) of the Act, 1960
  • Section 14(1)(b) of the Act
  • Sections 10(3)(a)(iii) and 14(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2019 INSC 1071
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Act, 1960
  • Section 23 of the Act, 1960
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Act (year not specified)
  • Section 10(3)(e) of the Act, 1960
  • Section 14(1)(b) of the Act
  • Sections 10(3)(a)(iii) and 14(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The landlord, claiming ownership of non-residential premises acquired under a partition deed dated 24-02-1997, filed Rent Control Original Petition No. 43/2004 before the Principal District Munsif/Rent Controller, Vellore, under Sections 10(3)(a)(iii) and 14(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960. He sought eviction of the tenant, who had been occupying the premises for a monthly rent of Rs 600, asserting a bona fide need to start a garment shop and to carry out alterations, including possible demolition and reconstruction.

The Rent Controller allowed the petition on 19-01-2011, granting the tenant two months to vacate. The tenant’s statutory appeal under Section 23 of the Act was dismissed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority in 2013, thereby affirming the eviction order. The tenant then filed a Civil Revision Petition before the High Court of Judicature at Madras, which on 06-03-2017 reversed the concurrent findings and dismissed the eviction claim, holding that the landlord had not proved bona fide requirement. The landlord appealed to the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the landlord proved a bona fide requirement for own use under Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960, warranting the tenant’s eviction.
  2. Whether the High Court, while exercising revisional jurisdiction, exceeded its limited scope by re-appreciating evidence instead of examining the findings of the Rent Controller and Appellate Authority for perversity.
  3. Whether failure to produce an approved building plan and evidence of financial capacity is fatal when eviction is sought for both bona fide use and possible demolition/reconstruction.

Arguments of the Parties

Landlord's Arguments

  • He is the lawful owner of the premises under the partition deed dated 24-02-1997.
  • He requires the premises bona fide to establish a garment shop; alterations or reconstruction are necessary for such use.
  • The tenant’s denial of ownership and jural relationship is unfounded because rent was being paid to the landlord.
  • The tenant will not suffer hardship as he possesses two other business premises.

Tenant's Arguments

  • Denied the landlord’s ownership and the existence of a landlord-tenant relationship.
  • Alleged that the eviction petition was motivated solely by a desire to extract higher rent, not by bona fide need.
  • Contended that the landlord failed to produce an approved building plan or proof of financial capacity for reconstruction.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gaya Prasad v. Pradeep Srivastava, (2001) 2 SCC 604 The crucial date for assessing the landlord’s bona fide requirement is the date of filing the eviction petition; delay in court proceedings should not penalise the landlord. Reiterated to reject the High Court’s view that need must persist until final adjudication; confirmed that requirement shown in 2004 petition sufficed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first outlined the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction, emphasising that the High Court should intervene only where findings are perverse. It found that the High Court had engaged in a fresh appreciation of evidence, effectively acting as an appellate court, which is impermissible.

On merits, the Court noted that:

  • The Rent Controller correctly accepted the landlord’s ownership based on the partition deed and the fact that rent had been paid.
  • The need to run a garment shop constituted a genuine requirement; although the landlord also mentioned demolition and reconstruction, the primary need could be met even with mere alterations.
  • Section 14(1)(b) requirements (plan and financial capacity) were not decisive because eviction was additionally sought under Section 10(3)(a)(iii) for bona fide own use.
  • The tenant’s admission in cross-examination that he possessed two other business premises undermined his plea of hardship.
  • The High Court’s insistence that bona fide need must subsist up to the date of final adjudication contradicted the principle affirmed in Gaya Prasad.

Consequently, the Court held that the concurrent findings of the Rent Controller and Appellate Authority were sound and free from perversity, and the High Court’s order required annulment.

Holding and Implications

ORDER: The Supreme Court set aside the High Court’s judgment dated 06-03-2017 and restored the eviction order of the Rent Controller dated 19-01-2011. The tenant is permitted to remain in possession until 31-01-2021, subject to filing an undertaking within four weeks to vacate peacefully, pay rent without default, and refrain from creating third-party rights or damaging the property.

Implications: The decision reinforces the limited scope of revisional jurisdiction under the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act and underscores that bona fide requirement is assessed as on the date of the eviction petition. No new legal precedent was created, but existing principles were reaffirmed, offering guidance on landlord-tenant disputes under the Act.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    D. Sasi Kumar (S) v. Soundararajan (S).

    A.S. Bopanna, J.:— Leave granted.

    2. The appellant herein was the petitioner before the Principal District Munsif/Rent Controller in the petition seeking eviction of the respondent therein. The said proceedings resulted in an appeal filed by the appellant herein before the Rent Control Appellate Authority (sub-Court) which upheld the decision of the Rent Controller. Against the said concurrent orders the respondent herein approached the High Court of Judicature at Madras in the Civil Revision Petition. The High Court reversed the concurrent decisions, which is assailed by the appellant herein. Since the rank assigned to the parties is different in the various proceedings, for the sake of convenience and clarity the appellant herein who was the original petitioner before the Rent Control Court would be referred to as the ‘landlord’, while the respondent therein would be referred to as the ‘tenant’.

    3. The brief facts are that the landlord contending to be the owner of the petition schedule premises had filed the petition under Sections 10(3)(a)(iii) and 14(1)(b) of the Tamil Nadu Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1960 (‘Act’, 1960’ for short) seeking for an order to direct the tenant to vacate and deliver the peaceful possession of the petition schedule property to the landlord. The manner in which the landlord had become the owner of the property based on a partition deed dated 24.02.1997 was referred. The tenant was in occupation of the premises for non-residential purpose on a monthly rental of Rs. 600/-. The landlord contended that the premises is bonafide required by him for setting up a garment shop and in that regard had further contended that since the premises requires alterations to be made in that regard, the landlord also intended to demolish the existing structure and put up a construction suitable for his purpose. The tenant had appeared and opposed the said petition by filing his objection statement, denying the entire case of the landlord including his claim to ownership over the property as well as the jural relationship. It was contended that the intention of the landlord is only to secure higher rent and as such the claim cannot be considered as a bonafide requirement.

    4. The Rent Control Court on having taken note of the rival contentions had framed two points for its consideration. The entire consideration revolved on the claim made by the landlord for own use and occupation as also the alternate premises available to the tenant. In order to establish the claim, the landlord examined himself as PW-1 and marked the documents at Exhibits P1 to P5. The tenant, on the other hand, examined three witnesses and relied upon the documents at Exhibits R1 to R9. The Court of the Rent Controller on analysing the documents and the evidence of the parties arrived at the conclusion that the claim as put forth by the landlord is established and accordingly on allowing the petition had directed eviction of the tenant by granting two months time to vacate.

    5. The tenant claiming to be aggrieved was before the Appellate Authority in the statutory appeal provided under Section 23 of the Act, 1960. The Appellate Authority having adverted to the contentions has reappreciated the oral as well as the documentary evidence. In that background making detailed reference to the legal position from the decisions cited before it had upheld the order dated 19.01.2011 passed by the Rent Control Court and had dismissed the appeal. Against such concurrent orders the tenant approached the High Court in the Civil Revision Petition. The High Court once again referring to the evidence and the conclusion reached by the courts below had differed from the same and accordingly allowed the petition by holding that the bonafide requirement as claimed by the landlord had not been proved. It is in that view the landlord claiming to be aggrieved is before this Court in this appeal.

    6. Heard Shri R. Balasubramanium, learned senior counsel appearing for the landlord and Shri R. Gopalakrishnan, learned counsel for the tenant and perused the appeal papers.

    7. At the outset it is to be taken note that the Civil Revision Petition before the High Court is not to be considered as in the nature of an appeal. The scope of consideration is only to take note as to whether there is any perversity in the satisfaction recorded by the original Court, namely, the Rent Controller and in that light as to whether the Appellate Authority under the statute has considered the aspect in the background of the evidence to arrive at the conclusion to its satisfaction. The reappreciation of the evidence in the Civil Revision Petition to indicate that another view is possible would not arise. To that extent, a perusal of the impugned order indicates that the High Court in fact has proceeded as if the entire evidence required reappreciation by it. In that background what is necessary to be taken note at this juncture is as to whether the Rent Controller has considered the matter in its correct perspective by satisfying himself of the bonafide claim, as required under Section 10(3)(e) of the Act, 1960 and the hardship if any to the tenant as contemplated under the proviso thereto.

    8. In the instant case what is necessary to be taken note is that the tenant despite being in possession and knowing the ownership of the property and also paying the rent, has sought to urge a contention denying the jural relationship. The said aspect has been taken note by the Rent Controller and taking into consideration the partition deed dated 24.02.1997 and further taking into account the fact that the rent was being paid, has answered the said issue in favour of the landlord. Insofar as the requirement of the premises by the landlord the evidence as tendered has been taken note. In that regard the claim put forth is that the landlord intends to run a garment shop for which the premises is required and he also intends to demolish and reconstruct. It is no doubt true that in an appropriate case when eviction is sought under Section 14(1)(b) of the Act, in proof thereof the approved plan for construction and financial capacity to construct is to be established. However, in the instant facts it is noticed that the eviction sought is not just for demolition and construction but is also for the bonafide use to set up a garment shop. The landlord, in that direction had also contended that the shop would require alteration and, in that view, he has decided to demolish and reconstruct. When that be the case even if not demolished and reconstructed the requirement of the premises is to run a garment shop even if it be by altering the premises to that extent. In that circumstance the eviction was also sought under Section 10(3)(a)(iii) of the Act, 1960.

    9. Since the tenant was running a metal shop, the fact that the premises was suitable for running a garment shop cannot be in dispute. That apart what is also to be kept in view is, apart from the bonafide requirement of the landlord the consideration relating to hardship of the tenant, even if kept in view, in the instant case the Rent Controller has referred to the cross examination of the tenant who was examined as RW-1 wherein he has admitted that he has two buildings as business places in addition to the business being run in the petition schedule premises. Though he states that one floor is used as a godown and the other is in the name of his wife, the fact remains that he is running the business in the other shop for the benefit of his family. In that circumstance when the need of the landlord was weighed in the background of the fact that the tenant had another premises wherein he is carrying on the business the Rent Controller as a statutory authority under the Act was of the opinion that the evidence available on record would be sufficient and recorded the satisfaction as provided under Section 10(3)(e) of the Act, 1960 and arrived at the conclusion that the landlord requires the premises for his bonafide occupation. Such conclusion while being taken note by the Appellate Authority has also received a similar consideration. In that light the nature of findings as recorded by the High Court is not appropriate in the facts and circumstance of the present case.

    10. It is no doubt true that as observed by the High Court the plan for construction and the financial capacity to construct has not been placed as evidence. However, as already indicated above, the nature of the requirement as stated by the landlord would be for running a garment shop which in any event could be run in the premises as it exists with minor alterations though the desire of the landlord is also to demolish and reconstruct. Therefore, in that circumstance the mere non-production of the approved plan or the documents to indicate financial capacity at this juncture cannot be held fatal in the instant facts. That apart as indicated above, the need of the landlord while being examined has been weighed in the background of the fact that the tenant owns two other premises and no hardship will be caused. Though the High Court has in that regard also recorded that no documentary evidence is placed, the fact of possession of alternate premises has been admitted by the tenant in his cross examination. There can be no better proof than admission.

    11. Further the High Court has also erroneously arrived at the conclusion that the bonafide occupation as sought should be not only on the date of the petition but it should continue to be there on the date of final adjudication of rights. Firstly, there is no material on record to indicate that the need as pleaded at the time of filing the petition does not subsist at this point. Even otherwise such conclusion cannot be reached, when it cannot be lost sight that the very judicial process consumes a long period and because of the delay in the process if the benefit is declined it would only encourage the tenants to protract the litigation so as to defeat the right. In the instant case it is noticed that the petition filed by the landlord is of the year 2004 which was disposed of by the Rent Controller only in the year 2011. The appeal was thereafter disposed of by the Appellate Authority in the year 2013. The High Court had itself taken time to dispose of the Revision Petition, only on 06.03.2017. The entire delay cannot be attributed to the landlord and deny the relief. If as on the date of filing the petition the requirement subsists and it is proved, the same would be sufficient irrespective of the time lapse in the judicial process coming to an end. This Court in the case of Gaya Prasad v. Pradeep Srivastava, (2001) 2 SCC 604 has held that the landlord should not be penalised for the slowness of the legal system and the crucial date for deciding the bonafide requirement of landlord is the date of application for eviction, which we hereby reiterate.

    12. Therefore, in the present facts the bonafide requirement as claimed by the landlord stands established. The learned counsel for the tenant as an alternative submission had sought for sufficient time to vacate and handover the vacant possession if the tenant was required to vacate the premises, which also needs to be addressed in the order.

    13. In the result the order dated 06.03.2017 passed by the High Court in CRP (NPD) No. 3754/2013 and MP No. 1/2013 is set aside. The order dated 19.01.2011 passed by the Principal District Munsif/Rent Controller, Vellore, Vellore District in Rent Control Original Petition No. 43/2004 is restored. Taking into consideration all aspects, the tenant is granted time till 31.01.2021 to vacate and handover vacant possession of the premises to the landlord subject to the undertaking being filed in four weeks, wherein it be undertaken to voluntarily vacate and handover possession on or before 31.01.2021, without creating any third-party rights or damage to the property. The rents shall also be paid without default.

    14. Accordingly, the appeals are allowed with no order as to costs. All pending applications shall stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    D. Sasi Kumar (S) v. Soundararajan (S).
    (Sep 23, 2019)