ORDER
P.M. Jagtap, Accountant Member - These two appeals -one field by the assessee being ITA No.394/Hyd/2014 and the other filed by the Department, being ITA No.373/Hyd/2014- are cross appeals, which are directed against the order of the learned CIT(A) VI, Hyderabad dated 15.11.2013.
2. The relevant facts of the case giving rise to this appeal are as follows: The assessee is an individual. As per the information received by the Assessing Officer, the assessee had entered into a sale agreement for land admeasuring 3,964 sq. yards in Survey No.28 of Rasoolpura, Secunderabad to M/s. Sri Vinayaka Constructions of Bapuji Nagar for value of Rs.25 lakhs. It also came to the knowledge of the Assessing Officer that the value of the said property, as adopted for the purposes of stamp duty was Rs.3,99,65,000. Since no return of income for the year under consideration was filed by the assessee declaring capital gains arising from the said transaction, a notice under S.148 was issued by the Assessing Officer to the assessee on 7.1.2011, which remained uncomplied with. Subsequently, notices under S.142 were issued by the Assessing Officer, in response to which the assessee appeared on 5.12.2011 for hearing before the Assessing Officer. During the course of hearing, the assessee was called upon by the Assessing Officer to explain why capital gain arising from the transfer of property at Survey no.28 Rasoolpura, Secunderabad should not be assessed in her hands by adopting the market value of Rs.3,99,65,000. In reply, it was stated by the assessee that she is not aware of the said transaction and that she has not received any consideration out of the said transaction. The assessee however could not produce any evidence such as confirmation from buyers etc., to substantiate her claim and filed only some copies of encumbrance certificates. She also accepted that the signature appearing on the sale deed was her own signatures. Keeping in view this averment made by the assessee as well as her failure to produce any evidence to support and substantiate her claim of denial of transaction, the Assessing Officer brought to tax long term capital gain of Rs.3,88,11,476 in the hands of the assessee for the year under consideration, after reducing the indexed cost of acquisition of Rs.11,53,524 from the sale consideration of Rs.3,99,65,000 adopted by him under S.50C of the Act, in the assessment completed under S.143(3) read with S.147, vide order dated 30.12.2011.
3. Against the order passed by the Assessing Officer under S.143(3), an appeal was preferred by the assessee before the learned CIT(A), challenging the addition made on account of long term capital gains. During the course of appellate proceedings before the learned CIT(A), it was contended by the assessee that the purported sale transaction appearing in the sale deed was a bogus transaction, as the assessee was induced by her sister to sign the said sale deed. It was submitted that the assessee was staying at the relevant time with her elder sister and since she was under the absolute control of the said sister, she was obliged to sign certain documents and also to provide her identity card. It was contended that the relevant transaction, thus, was entirely a bogus transaction wherein the name of the assessee was utilised as one party and at no point of time, the consideration referred to in the sale deed was actually received by the assessee. It was also contended that the assessee, at no point of time, was the owner of the property stated to be sold as per the sale deed and having not received even a single rupee out of the transaction, no capital gain arising from the said transaction could be brought to tax in the hands of the assessee. In support of the various contentions raised, additional documentary evidence was filed by the assessee before the learned CIT(A).
4. The documentary evidence filed by the assessee before him for the first time was forwarded by the learned CIT(A) to the Assessing Officer to cause necessary enquiries. As per the directions of the learned CIT(A), necessary enquiries were conducted by the Assessing Officer and a remand report was submitted by him to the learned CIT(A) giving his comments on verification of the additional documentary evidence filed by the assessee. The said remand report was confronted by the learned CIT(A) to the assessee and after taking into consideration the counter comments offered by the assessee on the remand report, other submissions made by the assessee and the comments offered by the Assessing Officer in the remand report as well as the material available on record, the learned CIT(A), held for the following reasons given in paragraph 4.9 of his impugned order, that the assessee was holding rights over the property transferred to the extent of 60% and capital gains arising from transfer of such rights was chargeable to tax in her hands as capital gains:—
"4.9 On the other hand, the consistent submissions of the appellant was that she was not the owner of the property, except holding to certain constructed part of the land located at Survey No.28, Rasoolpura, and was paying electrical charges for the property with such electric connection in her name, and the said facts do not entitle her to the ownership of the property admeasuring 3964 sq. yards, which was shown to have been sold vide the sale deed dated 03.04.2008, for a total consideration of Rs.25,00,000 out of which Rs.10,00,000 was received in cash by Mrs. D. Sriatha Kamakshi, W/o. Srinivas Rao, as against Rs.15,00,000 DD issued in her name, which were also fraudulently encashed by appellant's sister Mrs. Vijaya Lakshmi, by opening a bank account by impersonation. Thus, as per the appellant, she was forced to sign on the documents, related to a property to which she was never a owner, except to hold the constructed area which was under occupation of her family and no consideration was received by her. Even on facts, it was proved that, 40% of the consideration was received by Mrs. Srilatha Kamakshi, proving that the appellant is not the owner or title for total of the property under reference, as such establishing that the act of considering the entire sale proceeds in the hands of appellant is not correct. The Assessing Officer also acknowledge the facts in this regard. Regarding the ownership of the land/property under reference, the appellant could establish that she was never under full control of the property except to hold the constructed area, by virtue of their residence/stay there, and the said right was also shown to have taken away by the decision of courts, in favour of their real owner, which was Cantonment Board, as per the submissions of the appellant. All the facts/information brought on record indicate that the legal battle regarding the rights over the property are still under way, with the actual ownership shown to have been ordered to be vested with the Cantonment Board. However, it is also a fact that the vendee of the property, who bought the said property/right over the property from the appellant as well as Srilatha Kamakshi, is still under possession of the said property, as per the information brought on record. Under the circumstances, it is reasonable to hold that the appellant, as a signatory to the sale deed under reference, can be presumed to be the vendor of the rights over the property, with her share restricted to 60% of the sale proceeds, notwithstanding the fact that such proceeds received through demand drafts shown to have been encashed by her sister Mrs. Vijaya Lakshmi. Since, the end user of the consideration is not an issue or basis for determining the accrual or arising of capital, in sale of property, the capital gains held to have accrued/arisen in the hands of the appellant to the extent of her share in right."
5. The action of the Assessing Officer in working out the capital gains chargeable to tax in the hands of the assessee by adopting the value of Rs.3,99,65,000 taken for the stamp duty purposes by invoking the provisions of Ss.50C, however, was not upheld by the learned CIT(A) for the following reasons given in paragraph 4.10 of his order:—
'4.10 The next issue comes into picture is the quantum of sale consideration. The Assessing Officer in assessment order presumed to have referred to the provisions of sec.50C of the Act, for adopting the value of the property under reference, at fair market value, for arriving at the sale value of Rs.3,99,65,000/-. In this regard, it is relevant to refer to the provisions of Sec.50C of the Income-tax Act, which read as under:
"(1) Where the consideration received or accruing as a result of the transfer by an assessee of a capital asset, being land or building or both, is less than the value adopted (or assessed or assessable) by any authority of State Government (hereafter in this section referred to as the "stamp valuation authority") for the purpose of payment of stamp duty in respect of such transfer, the value so adopted (or assessed or assessable) shall, for the purposes of section 48, be deemed to be the full value of the consideration received or accruing as a result of such transfer.
(2) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-section (1), where—
(a)
the assessee claims before any Assessing Officer that the value adopted (or assessed or assessable) by the stamp valuation authority under sub-section (1) exceeds the fair market value of the property as on the date of transfer;
(b)
the value so adopted (or assessed or assessable ) by the stamp valuation authority under sub-section (1) has not been disputed in any appeal or revision or no reference has been made before any other authority, court or the High Court,
The Assessing Officer may refer the valuation of the capital asset to a Valuation Officer and where any such reference is made, the provisions of sub-sections (2), (3) (4), (5) and (6) of section16A, clause (i) of sub-section (1) and sub-sections (6) and (7) of section 23A, sub-section (5) of section 24, section 34AA, section 35 and section 37 of the Wealth-tax Act, 1957 (27 of 1957) shall, with necessary modifications, apply in relation to such reference as they apply in relation to a reference made by the Assessing Officer under sub-section (1) of section 16A of the Act."
Thus, as could be seen, the reference to sec.50C is not absolute, but subject to certain conditions, which is stipulated in sub-section 2 of Sec.50C. In this case, it is a fact that the property under reference is not clear titled and many claims are there over it. Further, there is no ownership to the appellant or her family members, as per the encumbrance certificates or the affidavit filed by father of the appellant. What the appellant transferred, vide the sale deed dated 03.04.2008, appears to be only the limited rights over the property, which is also under dispute. Under the circumstances, it is neither clearly indicated, nor justified to make a reference to sec.50C, for adopting the market value of the property. Where the property's value is considered to be lower than the market value, there was a requirement on the part of the Assessing Officer to assess the actual value of the property or right in the property, as appears to be a fact in this case, by referring the said property to valuation. Judicial decisions support this view. Having failed to establish the reasonable value/rate of the property under reference, I am of the considered opinion that Assessing Officer is directed to accept the value adopted in the sale deed under reference. Alternatively, the Assessing Officer was having all the avenues to explore the possibility of valuation of said property, by ascertaining the correct ownership of the said property under reference. However, the AO chosen to go by apparent information as originated from the sale deed, without appreciating the facts associated with the said transaction. Hence, it is reasonable to hold that based on the fact that the verifiable information indicate that the property under reference does not have the value as referred to the SRO and in absence of the same the value as indicated in sale deed, is directed to be adopted. Further, the shares of the appellant in the said transaction is held to be confined to 60%. Accordingly, the Assessing Officer is directed to compute the taxable capital gains, on the above lines, after allowing the proportionate cost of acquisition. This ground of appeal is treated as partly allowed.'
6. Accordingly, the Assessing Officer was directed by the learned CIT(A) to compute the capital gains chargeable to tax in the hands of the assessee by taking her share at 60% of the total sale consideration of Rs.25 lakhs. Aggrieved by the same, the assessee and Revenue both are in appeals before the Tribunal on the following grounds:—
Grounds in Assessee's Appeal:
"(1)
The learned Commissioner of Income-tax(Appeals) VI/Hyderabad erred in restricting the ownership in the property to 60% share, when the Appellant is not at all the owner of the property.
(2)
The learned Commissioner of Income-tax(Appeals) VI/Hyd should have held the Appellant, as not the owner of the property.
(3)
Any other ground or modification of the grounds already filed with the permission of the Honourable ITAT."
Grounds in Revenue's appeal :
"(1)
The Hon'ble Commissioner of Income-tax(Appeals) appears to have erred in facts and in law while directing that the Assessing Officer should adopt the value as mentioned in the sale deed and not the value adopted by the SRO, merely because there is some dispute about the ownership of the land in question.
(2)
The Hon'ble Commissioner of Income-tax(Appeals) appears to have erred in law by directing the AO to adopt the value of the sale deed in a situation where there is no onus cast on the Assessing Officer to record a finding that the assessee received more consideration than what has been shown in the sale deed.
(3)
The Hon'ble CIT(A) appears to have erred in facts by overlooking that the assessee-individual did not claim before the Assessing Officer that the value adopted by the Stamp Valuation Authority was more than the FMV of the said property."
7. We have heard the arguments of both the sides and also perused the relevant material on record. In support of the issue raised in the assessee's appeal, the learned counsel for the assessee has mainly reiterated before us the submissions made before the learned CIT(A). He has contended that the assessee was never the owner of the property and since the consideration mentioned in the sale deed had never reached her, the capital gains arising from the transaction as recorded in the relevant agreement is not chargeable to tax in the hands of the assessee. He has also taken us through the relevant documentary evince placed in the paper book to support and substantiate the case of the assessee that she was not the owner of the property and it was her sister, who induced her to sign the relevant agreement without making her fully aware of the contents thereof. It is however, observed that this documentary evidence relied upon by the learned counsel for the assessee in support of the assessee' case has also been considered and analysed by the learned CIT(A) in the light of the remand report submitted by the Assessing Officer and comments offered by the assessee thereon, before coming to the conclusion that the assessee, even though was not the absolute owner of the property transferred, was holding certain rights over the said property, which constituted a capital asset within the meaning of S.2(14) of the Act. We have also perused the relevant documents placed on record before us in the paper book filed by the assessee and find from a perusal of the relevant agreement referred to as 'Agreement of Sale-cum-General Power of Attorney with Possession' placed at pages 51 to 63 of the paper-book that the same was entered into by the assessee jointly with Smt. D. Shrilatha Kamakshi, as Vendors/Principals, with M/s. Sri Vinayaka Constructions as Purchasers/Attorney Holders. The said agreement was not only signed by the assessee, but she personally presented herself before the concerned Government authority for registration, after duly establishing her identity on the basis of Identity Card issued by the Election Commission of India. In the said agreement, assessee styled herself as the owners of the property having acquired the same from her father Shri D.Durga Prasad. It was also stated in the agreement that she had constructed a shed with AC-sheet roofing and got the same assessed under the Cantonment Board Act. It was further stated that she was paying taxes regularly in respect of the said property to the concerned authorities and was in continuous and uninterrupted possession of the same, since several years, exercising all rights of ownership.
8. It is no doubt true that other documentary evidence produced by the assessee was sufficient to indicate that the property was encumbered and the assessee could not be said to be the absolute owner of the said property. At the same time, it is also true that the said documentary evidence read with the agreement entered into by the assessee with M/s. Sri Vinayaka Constructions is sufficient to show that the assessee was holding certain rights in the property and the same constituting capital asset were transferred by the assessee by agreement dated 3rd April, 2008 to M/s. Sri Vinayaka Constructions for consideration giving rise to capital gains chargeable to tax in her hands to the extent of 60%, as rightly held by the learned CIT(A). We therefore, find no infirmity in the impugned order of the learned CIT(A) holding the assessee to be the owner of certain rights in the property to the extent of 60% and accordingly directing the Assessing Officer to compute the capital gains arising from transfer of the said rights in the hands of the assessee. Accordingly, the impugned order of the learned CIT(A) on this issue is upheld, and the appeal of the assessee is dismissed.
9. As regards the issue involved in the appeal of the Revenue, relating to the applicability of the provisions of S.50C in the case of the assessee, it is observed that the market value of the property for stamp duty purpose was determined by the concerned authority at Rs.3,99,55,000 and accordingly the stamp duty thereon was also duly paid, while registering the relevant agreement. The value adopted for the purpose of payment of stamp duty thus was not disputed by the relevant parties, including the assessee. The learned CIT(A), however, held that the assessee was not the owner of the property and since she had only limited rights over the property, which was also encumbered, the market value of the property as taken for the purpose of payment of stamp duty could not be adopted as the sale consideration by applying the provisions of S.50C. We have already concurred with the learned CIT(A) while deciding the issue involved in the appeal of the assessee that the assessee was not the absolute owner of the property, and what the assessee held was only certain limited rights over the said property. It, therefore, follows that the capital asset held by the assessee itself was neither the land nor the building as envisaged in sub-section (1) of S.50C, and while computing the capital gains arising from transfer of such asset, the value adopted by any authority of State Government for the purpose of payment of stamp duty cannot be taken as full value of consideration by applying the provisions of S.50C, as rightly held by the learned CIT(A). We, therefore, uphold the impugned order of the learned CIT(A) on this issue as well, and dismiss the appeal filed by the Revenue.
10. In the result, the appeal of the assessee as well as that of the Revenue are dismissed.
SUNIL