Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • UNDER SECTIONS 19 READ WITH SECTIONS 11(1), 11(4) AND SECTION 11B OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA ACT, 1992 READ WITH REGULATIONS 10 OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA
  • provisions of SEBI Act, 1992 (SEBI Act) read with SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015
  • Section 19 read with Sections 11(1),11(4)(d)and Section 11B of the SEBI Act read with Regulation 10
  • Section 11(1) read with 11(4)(d) and Section 11B of the SEBI Act read with Regulation 10
  • provisions of Sections 12A(d) & (e) of the SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(1) / 3(2) & 4(1)
  • Section 12A (d) & (e) of SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(1) and 4(1)
  • Section 12A (d) & (e) of SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(2) and 4(1)
  • Regulation 2(1)(g) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. Order
  • Sections 11(1), 11(4) and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992
  • SECTION 186 COMPANIES ACT 2013
  • COMPANIES ACT 2013
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • UNDER SECTIONS 19 READ WITH SECTIONS 11(1), 11(4) AND SECTION 11B OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA ACT, 1992 READ WITH REGULATIONS 10 OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA
  • provisions of SEBI Act, 1992 (SEBI Act) read with SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015
  • Section 19 read with Sections 11(1),11(4)(d)and Section 11B of the SEBI Act read with Regulation 10
  • Section 11(1) read with 11(4)(d) and Section 11B of the SEBI Act read with Regulation 10
  • provisions of Sections 12A(d) & (e) of the SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(1) / 3(2) & 4(1)
  • Section 12A (d) & (e) of SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(1) and 4(1)
  • Section 12A (d) & (e) of SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(2) and 4(1)
  • Regulation 2(1)(g) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. Order
  • Sections 11(1), 11(4) and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992
  • SECTION 186 COMPANIES ACT 2013
  • COMPANIES ACT 2013
  • COMPANIES ACT 1956
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the SEBI Order: Indiabulls Ventures Limited — Pia Johnson & Mehul Johnson (May 24, 2019)

Factual and Procedural Background

SEBI conducted an investigation into suspected insider trading in the scrip of Indiabulls Ventures Limited (IVL) for the period 1 January 2017 to 3 November 2017 to determine whether certain entities traded on the basis of unpublished price sensitive information (UPSI) in contravention of the SEBI Act, 1992 and the SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015.

The investigation focused on transactions and corporate events relating to the proposed sale of India Land and Properties Limited (ILPL), an indirect subsidiary of IVL, and related investments/loans by Indiabulls Infrastructure Limited (IIL). SEBI examined IVL corporate announcements, board and shareholder approvals, meeting chronology and trading data around the announcement that IDSL (a WOS of IVL) signed a definitive agreement to sell 100% of ILPL to IIL for Rs.685 crores (announced on BSE on 14 March 2017 at 23:05 and on NSE on 15 March 2017 at 08:53).

Based on the investigation and definitions in the Insider Trading Regulations, SEBI identified the period 24 January 2017 to 14 March 2017 as the UPSI period and identified Pia Johnson (a non-executive director and member of the IVL management committee) and Mehul Johnson (her husband) as insiders who traded during that UPSI period.

SEBI concluded there was a prima facie case of insider trading and initiated quasi-judicial proceedings. To prevent diversion of alleged unlawful gains, SEBI issued an ad-interim ex-parte order impounding alleged unlawful gains and directed other interim restrictive measures, and required show-cause replies within 30 days.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the information relating to identification of the buyer, finalisation of consideration and signing of a definitive agreement for sale of ILPL to IIL constituted unpublished price sensitive information (UPSI) under Regulation 2(1)(n) of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015.
  2. Whether Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson were insiders/connected persons as per Regulation 2(1)(d) and Regulation 2(1)(g) and thus prohibited from trading while in possession of UPSI.
  3. Whether Pia Johnson communicated the UPSI to Mehul Johnson (and whether Mehul procured UPSI from Pia) and both traded in the scrip of IVL during the UPSI period in violation of Regulation 3(1)/3(2) and 4(1) of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 and Section 12A(d) & (e) of the SEBI Act, 1992.
  4. Whether interim relief in the form of impoundment of alleged wrongful gains, freezing/debit restrictions on bank and demat accounts, creation of escrow accounts and directions for inventory and disclosure of assets is necessary and appropriate under Sections 19 read with 11(1), 11(4)(d) and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992 read with Regulation 10 of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Order sets out SEBI's step-by-step reasoning based on the investigation findings and statutory/regulatory definitions:

  • Identification of the corporate event and price impact: SEBI reviewed IVL announcements regarding the sale of ILPL and tabulated the market price and volume movement around announcements (June 2016, July 2016 and particularly March 2017). The March 14–15, 2017 announcements had a marked positive impact on the scrip's opening and closing prices.
  • Legal definition of UPSI: SEBI relied on Regulation 2(1)(n) of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 which defines unpublished price sensitive information and lists illustrative matters (including mergers, disposals, investments etc.) that ordinarily give rise to UPSI.
  • Determination of UPSI and its origin: SEBI considered chronology and documentary/material events — board approvals (IDSL and IVL), EGM notices and approvals, management committee authorization, meetings between key executives (notably 24 January 2017 meeting between Divyesh Shah and Gurbans Singh), IIL board/EGM decisions (March 1, 2017 enabling authorisation under Section 186) and subsequent discussions — and concluded that the origin point of the UPSI was 24 January 2017 (when the loan proposal against securities was first requested), with the UPSI period running from 24 January 2017 to 14 March 2017 (date of announcement on BSE).
  • Identification of insiders and connected persons: SEBI applied Regulation 2(1)(d) (definition of connected person) and Regulation 2(1)(g) (definition of insider). It noted that Pia Johnson was a Non-Executive Director and a member of the IVL Management Committee authorised to sanction sale of ILPL and thus was reasonably expected to have access to UPSI; accordingly, she was treated as a connected person and insider. Mehul Johnson, being Pia Johnson's husband and sharing address, bank account and broker details, was deemed an immediate relative and therefore a connected person under Regulation 2(1)(d)(ii)(a) read with Regulation 2(1)(f); he was treated as an insider as well.
  • Trading analysis and concentration: SEBI tabulated trading by Pia and Mehul across pre-UPSI, UPSI and post-UPSI periods. During the UPSI period, Pia bought 505,000 shares and Mehul bought 338,970 shares. SEBI compared each individual's trading to gross market trading and showed high concentration during the UPSI period (Pia: 93.93% concentration during UPSI; Mehul: 63.93%).
  • Prima facie conclusion on insider trading and communication of UPSI: On the basis of familial relationship, timing and pattern of trades during the UPSI period, SEBI concluded there was a prima facie case that both Pia and Mehul traded while in possession of UPSI. SEBI also found a prima facie case that Pia communicated UPSI to her husband Mehul, who then traded.
  • Calculation of wrongful gains and interest: SEBI computed wrongful gains by taking (closing price on the next day of announcement — average buy price) multiplied by number of shares bought during the UPSI period. Using the closing price of Rs.41.95 (closing on 15 March 2017) SEBI calculated wrongful gains of Rs.35,10,739.00 for Pia and Rs.33,98,498.50 for Mehul (total Rs.69,09,237.50). SEBI then applied simple interest at 12% per annum from 15 March 2017 to 21 May 2019 to compute interest amounts and a total alleged amount of Rs.87,21,918.55 (gains plus interest).
  • Necessity for interim measures: SEBI reasoned that with initiation of quasi-judicial proceedings there was a risk of diversion of alleged unlawful gains, which would defeat effective implementation of disgorgement directions if passed after adjudication. Consequently, SEBI considered interim impoundment and restrictive measures necessary and the balance of convenience to be in SEBI's favour.
  • Legal basis for directions: SEBI invoked powers under Section 19 read with Sections 11(1), 11(4)(d) and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992 and Regulation 10 of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 to issue an ad-interim ex-parte order for impounding alleged profits and imposing related directions.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: SEBI issued an ad-interim ex-parte order impounding the alleged unlawful gains of Rs. 87,21,918.55 (aggregate of alleged gains Rs.69,09,237.50 plus interest Rs.18,12,681.05) jointly and severally from the following persons:

  • Pia Johnson (PAN: AGVPJ6093M)
  • Mehul Johnson (PAN: ABBPJ3414H)

The order contains the following operative directions and immediate consequences for the named persons:

  • Banks are directed not to permit any debits from the bank accounts of the named persons without SEBI's permission; depositories are directed not to permit debits from their demat accounts without SEBI's permission. Credits may be allowed. Banks may debit amounts in excess of the impounded amount or as necessary to comply with the Order.
  • The named persons are directed not to dispose of or alienate any assets/properties/securities until the impounded amount is credited to an interest-bearing escrow account created in a nationalised bank in the name of the respective persons/entities, which shall have a lien in favour of SEBI and monies shall not be released without SEBI's permission.
  • The named persons must, within 7 days of the Order, provide a full inventory of their assets/properties and details of all bank accounts, demat accounts, holdings and details of companies in which they hold substantial or controlling interest.
  • The findings in the Order are prima facie and based on the investigation; they constitute allegations for the purpose of a show-cause notice. The persons are required to show cause within 30 days from receipt of the Order why further directions (including disgorgement, market access prohibitions and other penalties under Sections 11(1), 11(4) and 11B) should not be issued.
  • The Order is to be effective immediately and remain in force until further Orders; it will be served on stock exchanges, depositories, registrar and transfer agents and banks for compliance.

Implications: The direct effect is the impoundment and restrictive measures described above against Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson and initiation of show-cause proceedings. The Order does not state or purport to create any binding precedent; it records prima facie findings and reserves final adjudication following show-cause and any hearing.

Note: This summary is strictly confined to the information contained in the provided SEBI opinion. No information has been added or inferred beyond what appears in the text of the Order.

    Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited

    UNDER SECTIONS 19 READ WITH SECTIONS 11(1), 11(4) AND SECTION 11B OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA ACT, 1992 READ WITH REGULATIONS 10 OF THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA (PROHIBITION OF INSIDER TRADING) REGULATIONS, 2015 IN THE MATTER OF INDIABULLS VENTURES LIMITED. IN RESPECT OF ENTITY PAN

    1. PIA JOHNSON AGVPJ6093M

    2. MEHUL JOHNSON ABBPJ3414H BACKGROUND

    1. Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) had conducted an investigation into suspected insider trading activities of certain entities in the scrip of Indiabulls Ventures Limited (IVL / the company) for the period January 01, 2017 to November 03, 2017 (Investigation Period) to ascertain whether or not the suspected entities had traded in the aforesaid scrip on the basis of unpublished price sensitive information (UPSI), in contravention of the provisions of SEBI Act, 1992 (SEBI Act) read with SEBI (Prohibition of Insider Trading) Regulations, 2015 (Insider Trading Regulations, 2015).

    2. IVL was incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956 on June 09, 1995. The Registered Office of the company is at M-62 & 63, First Floor, Connaught Place, New Delhi 110001, India. The equity shares of IVL are listed on the National Stock Exchange of India Limited (NSE) and BSE Limited (BSE) and its Global Depository Receipts (GDRs) are listed on the Luxembourg Stock Exchange.

    3. The Promoters of IVL during the Investigation Period were as under TABLE I [SOURCE: BSE WEBSITE] Name Sameer Gehlaut Zelkova Builders Private Limited Orthia Constructions Private Limited Orthia Properties Private Limited Inuus Developers Private Limited Inuus Properties Private Limited Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 2 of 13

    4. The Board of Directors of IVL during the Investigation Period was as under TABLE II [SOURCE: IVLs reply dated August 10, 2018] Name Designation Divyesh B. Shah Whole-time Director & CEO Aishwarya Katoch Independent Director Brig. Labh Singh Sitara Independent Director Prem Prakash Mirdha Independent Director Amiteshwar Choudhary Whole-time Director Pia Johnson Non-Executive Director Sameer Gehlaut Non-Executive Chairman Gagan Banga Non-Executive Director Ajit Kumar Mittal Non-Executive Director Pinank Jayant Shah Executive Director Vijayalakshmi Rajaram Iyer Independent Director Shyam Lal Bansal Independent Director Alok Kumar Misra Independent Director

    5. The shareholding pattern of IVL for various Quarters prior to, during and subsequent to the Investigation Period is provided below TABLE III [SOURCE: BSE WEBSITE] Category of shareholder Dec-16 Mar-17 Jun-17 Sep-17 Dec-17 No. of shares % of Share Capital No. of Shares % of Share Capital No. of Shares % of Share Capital No. of Shares % of Share Capital No. of Shares % of Share Capital Promoters 98,448,802 33.56 123,098,802 38.45 152,748,802 34.53 152,748,802 34.53 152,748,802 34.53 Public Shareholding 194,907,123 66.44 197,047,641 61.55 289,581,723 65.47 289,581,723 65.47 289,581,723 65.47 Shares underlying DRs (C) 60,477 0.00 60,477 0.00 60,477 0.00 60,477 0.00 60,477 0.00 Total Share capital (A+B+C) 293,416,402 100.00 320,206,920 100.00 442,391,002 100.00 442,391,002 100.00 442,391,002 100.00

    6. The Standalone Quarterly Financial Results of IVL prior to, during and subsequent to the Investigation Period is provided below TABLE IV [AMOUNT IN CRORES] [SOURCE: BSE WEBSITE] Particulars Year Ended (Audited) Quarter Ended (Unaudited) 2015-16 2016-17 Dec-16 Mar-17 Jun-17 Sep-17 Dec-17 Net Sales 76.34 83.60 18.62 27.42 27.31 30.44 35.38 Other Income 28.18 67.82 5.05 22.67 13.71 28.32 13.84 Total Income 104.52 151.42 23.67 50.10 41.02 58.75 49.22 Net Profit 16.87 47.09 0.27 19.16 16.09 18.42 8.30

    7. Indiabulls Distribution Services Limited (IDSL) is a wholly owned subsidiary (WOS) of IVL. IDSL held 100% shareholding in India Land and Properties Limited (ILPL), making ILPL a wholly owned subsidiary of IDSL. Thus, ILPL was indirectly owned by IVL.

    8. Investigation observed that IVL made the following announcements with respect to sale of ILPL to Indiabulls Infrastructure Limited (IIL) (a WOS of Indiabulls Real Estate Limited [IREL]) / investment of IIL in ILPL. The price and volume data for the scrip, just before and after these announcements, is tabulated below: Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 3 of 13 TABLE V Date & Time of display on Exchange Website Particulars Price Impact Remarks

    1. NSE 20Jun 2016 12:01 hours IVL informed Exchanges that the Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) of the company will be held on 15-Jul- 2016 to inter alia transact the following special business : Sale of investment Sale of up to 100% of shares held by IDSL, a WOS of the company, in ILPL, a WOS of IDSL. 17-Jun-2016 (NSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 22.05 22.80 21.80 21.95 1268763 20-Jun-2016 (NSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 21.70 22.15 21.20 21.70 1189250 On June 20, 2016, the price of the scrip closed at 21.70 i.e. 1.14% fall against the previous day closing price. 20Jun 2016 12:07 hours 17-Jun-2016 (BSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 22.30 22.80 21.85 22.00 224613 20-Jun-2016 (BSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 21.15 22.15 21.15 21.75 373395 On June 20, 2016, the price of the scrip closed at 21.75 i.e. 1.14% fall against the previous day closing price. (June 18, 2016 and June 19, 2016 were trading holidays)

    2. NSE 15Jul2016 15:19 hours IVL informed Exchanges that members of company in EGM held on 15-Jul-2016 approved the following : Preferential Issue of an aggregate of up to 5.83 crores Convertible Warrants to Promoter group entities and CEO & Whole-time Director of the company. Sale of up to 100% of shares held by IDSL, a WOS of the company, in ILPL, a WOS of IDSL. 14-Jul-2016 (NSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 31.55 33.65 29.60 33.00 5597645 15-Jul-2016 (NSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 33.25 34.00 31.50 32.55 4004040 On July 15, 2016, the price of the scrip closed at 32.55 i.e. 1.36% fall against the previous day closing price. 15Jul2016 15:01 hours 14-Jul-2016 (BSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 31.60 33.55 30.00 33.00 1586220 15-Jul-2016 (BSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 33.80 33.90 31.55 32.70 946263 On July 15, 2016, the price of the scrip closed at 32.70 i.e. 0.91% fall against the previous day closing price.

    3. NSE 15Mar 2017 08:53 hours IVL informed Exchanges that : IDSL (a WOS of IVL) has signed a definitive agreement to sell its 100% shareholding in ILPL, at a consideration of Rs.685 crores, to IIL, a WOS of IREL and the deal is expected to be completed in the current financial year. A meeting of the Board of Directors of the Company will be held on Friday the 17th March, 2017 to consider, inter alia, declaration of interim dividend, if any, on the Equity shares of the Company, for the financial year 2016-17. 14-Mar-2017 (NSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 37.00 38.75 36.80 38.15 2495800 15-Mar-2017 (NSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 39.20 41.95 39.20 41.95 11450940 On March 15, 2017, the price of the scrip opened at 39.20 i.e. 2.75% rise against the previous day closing price and closed at 41.95

    i.e. 9.96% rise against the previous day closing price. 14-Mar- 2017 23:05 hours 14-Mar-2017 (BSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 36.50 38.70 36.50 38.15 750175 15-Mar-2017 (BSE) Open High Low Close Traded vol. 40.00 41.95 39.30 41.95 20793277 On March 15, 2017, the price of the scrip opened at 40.00 i.e. 4.85% rise against the previous day closing price and closed at 41.95

    i.e. 9.96% rise against the previous day closing price. Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 4 of 13

    9. As observed from the table above, corporate announcements dated March 14, 2017 on BSE and March 15, 2017 on NSE made by the company had a positive impact on the price of the scrip. Unpublished Price Sensitive Information (UPSI)

    10. The term "unpublished price sensitive information" has been defined in Regulation 2(1)(n) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 as under: "unpublished price sensitive information" means any information, relating to a company or its securities, directly or indirectly, that is not generally available which upon becoming generally available, is likely to materially affect the price of the securities and shall, ordinarily including but not restricted to, information relating to the following:

    (i) financial results;

    (ii) dividends;

    (iii) change in capital structure;

    (iv) mergers, de-mergers, acquisitions, delistings, disposals and expansion of business and such other transactions;

    (v) changes in key managerial personnel; and

    (vi) material events in accordance with the listing agreement. NOTE: It is intended that information relating to a company or securities, that is not generally available would be unpublished price sensitive information if it is likely to materially affect the price upon coming into the public domain. The types of matters that would ordinarily give rise to unpublished price sensitive information have been listed above to give illustrative guidance of unpublished price sensitive information.

    11. The determination of UPSI as per investigation was made inter alia upon consideration of the following factors a. Board of Directors of IDSL in their meeting dated May 04, 2016 accorded their consent for sale of ILPL. b. Board of Directors of IVL in their meeting dated June 15, 2016 accorded approval, subject to approval of shareholders, for sale of ILPL and decided to call an EGM on July 15, 2016. c. On June 20, 2016, the company informed the exchanges that an EGM will be held on July 15, 2016 for seeking/enabling authorization for sale of investment by IDSL in the shares of ILPL and submitted the notice convening an EGM. d. The shareholders of IVL in an EGM held on July 15, 2016 approved the sale of upto 100% of shares held by IDSL in ILPL, to any prospective buyer and the same was announced on exchanges. e. On January 24, 2017 during a meeting between Mr. Divyesh Shah (CEO of IVL & Director of ILPL) and Mr. Gurbans Singh (CEO of IREL & Director of IIL) a request was made to Mr. Gurbans Singh, seeking loan facility of approximately Rs.500-550 crores against securities, from IIL to ILPL. Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 5 of 13 f. On January 25, 2017, Notice for convening Board Meeting on February 03, 2017 was issued by IIL to consider convening of an EGM. g. In IILs Board Meeting held on February 03, 2017 it was decided to convene an EGM on March 01, 2017 for seeking enabling authorization to the board to invest surplus funds, by way of loan which may inter-alia be in the form of Debentures or Non-convertible Redeemable Preference Shares of ILPL or any other security as may be offered by ILPL. Draft Notice of the proposed EGM was also placed and approved by the Board in the same Board Meeting. h. In IILs EGM held on March 01, 2017 an enabling composite authorization in terms of Section 186 of the Companies Act, 2013 was approved and following special resolution was passed: RESOLVED THAT pursuant to the provisions of Section 186 and other applicable provisions, if any, of the Companies Act, 2013, read with the Rules framed thereunder, as may be amended from time to time, consent of the members be and is hereby accorded to the Board of Directors of the Company: (a) to grant loans, give guarantee(s) or provide security, in connection with a loan made by any person to or to any person, up to an aggregate value of Rs.600,00,00,000/- (Rupees Six Hundred Crore) from time to time in one or more trenches, to India Land and Properties Limited on such terms and conditions as may be considered expedient in the interest of the Company, and (b) to invest Companys fund by way of subscription, purchase or otherwise, in the securities of India Land and Properties Limited from time to time in one or more tranches up to the aggregate of Rs.600,00,00,000/- (Rupees Six Hundred Crore) on such terms and conditions as may be considered expedient in the interest of the Company, notwithstanding that the aggregate of loans, investment already made or to be made and the guarantees or securities already provided or to be provided, may exceed the limits prescribed under the said Section.

    i. In this regard, IIL and ILPL confirmed that no amount of surplus funds were provided as loan to ILPL by IIL pursuant to above authorization. Further, IIL has submitted that on March 07, 2017 during a meeting between Mr. Gurbans Singh and Mr. Divyesh Shah pursuant to abovementioned EGM dated March 01, 2017, the loan proposal was discussed and it was agreed in principle that IIL will rather purchase shareholding of ILPL. j. IVL submitted that no buyer or acquirer approached IVL/IDSL/ILPL or gave any formal/informal proposal for purchasing ILPL prior to March 07, 2017. Further, it was observed from the replies of IVL and statement recording of CEO of IVL that real estate market was sluggish and not conducive at that time. k. On March 14, 2017, IVL informed BSE and NSE that on March 14, 2017 Indiabulls Distribution Services Limited (IDSL) (WOS of IVL) has signed a definitive agreement to sell its 100% shareholding in India Land and Properties Limited (ILPL), at a consideration of Rs.685 Crore, to Indiabulls Infrastructure Limited (IIL), a WOS of Indiabulls Real Estate Limited (IREL) and the deal is expected to be completed in the current financial year. Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 6 of 13

    l. Considering the above factors, it was noted that despite the fact that IVL had announced its intention to sell ILPL on June 20, 2016, it was crucial to find a suitable buyer and finalize the consideration to execute their intention. Hence, the information regarding identification of the buyer, finalizing the consideration and the actual event of signing of the definitive agreement to sell 100% shareholding in ILPL, to IIL, is considered to be a price sensitive information. m. Therefore, the abovementioned information relating to the sale of ILPL to IIL / investment of IIL in ILPL, prior to being announced on March 14, 2017, is considered as UPSI in terms of Regulation 2(1)(n) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. Chronology of Events:

    12. As per the information obtained from IVL, IDSL, ILPL, IIL and IREL, the chronology of events relating to the announcement of the aforesaid sale of ILPL to IIL / investment of IIL in ILPL is as under TABLE VI DATE PARTICULARS/EVENTS May 04, 2016 IDSLs Board of Directors (BOD) in the meeting held on May 04, 2016 considered sale of ILPL to improve liquidity of IDSL and decided to sell the entire investment in ILPL. June 15, 2016 IVLs BOD in the meeting held on June 15, 2016 decided to call an EGM on July 15, 2016 for seeking approval of shareholders. June 20, 2016 IVL had sent EGM Notice dated June 15, 2016 to its Shareholders, inter-alia, for seeking / enabling authorisation for sale of investment by IDSL in the shares of ILPL, subject to the approval of shareholders. Same was informed to stock exchanges. July 15, 2016 Shareholders of IVL in their EGM held on July 15, 2016, approved the sale of investment by IDSL, in the shares of ILPL, to any prospective buyer(s). Same was informed to stock exchanges. July 27, 2016 In IVLs Board Meeting, Management Committee was authorized to authorise IDSL to sell its stake in ILPL. Members of the committee were Mr. Divyesh Shah, Mr. Ashok Sharma (till Sept 28, 2016), Mr. Aishwarya Katoch and Ms. Pia Johnson (w.e.f. Sept 28, 2016) January 24, 2017 During a meeting between Mr. Divyesh Shah (CEO of IVL & Director of ILPL) and Mr. Gurbans Singh (CEO of IREL & Director of IIL) a request was made to Mr. Gurbans Singh, seeking loan facility against securities, from IIL for ILPL January 25, 2017 Notice for convening Board Meeting on February 03, 2017 was issued by IIL to consider convening of an EGM February 03, 2017 In IILs Board Meeting held on February 03, 2017 it was decided to convene an EGM on March 01, 2017 for seeking enabling authorization to the board to invest surplus funds, by way of loan which may inter-alia be in the form of Debentures or Non-convertible Redeemable Preference Shares of ILPL or any other security as may be offered by ILPL. Draft Notice of the proposed EGM was also placed and approved by the Board in the same Board Meeting March 01, 2017 In IILs EGM enabling composite authorization in terms of Section 186 of the Companies Act, 2013 was approved March 07, 2017 During a meeting between Mr. Gurbans Singh and Mr. Divyesh Shah pursuant to EGM dated March 01, 2017, the loan proposal was discussed and it was agreed in principle that IIL will rather purchase shareholding of ILPL March 07, 2017 to March 14, 2017 Discussions and finalization of the terms and conditions w.r.t. sale of ILPL to IIL. The idea of IIL purchasing IDSLs 100% shareholding in ILPL was proposed and agreed to in- principle. This was subject to the price which was to be discussed further to meet with the conditions on pricing for disinvestment as proposed by the shareholders of IVL. Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 7 of 13 TABLE VI DATE PARTICULARS/EVENTS The legal team of IREL Group prepared the documentation on behalf of IIL, as IRELs Group legal team works for IREL and all its subsidiaries. March 14, 2017 Pursuant to IDSL, ILPL & IILs BOD Meeting held on March 14, 2017, a definitive agreement among IDSL, ILPL and IIL has been executed w.r.t. sale of ILPL by IDSL to

    IIL. Same has been Intimated to stock exchanges. The Period of UPSI

    13. From the chronology of events and the information received from the company as discussed earlier, it was observed that the proposal relating to grant of loan from IIL to ILPL against securities originated on January 24, 2017, i.e. the date when Mr. Divyesh Shah (CEO of IVL & Director of ILPL) approached Mr. Gurbans Singh (CEO of IREL & Director of IIL) for seeking loan facility against securities, from IIL for ILPL. The said proposal ultimately culminated in sale of ILPL to IIL / investment of IIL in ILPL. Thus, the date of abovementioned proposal for grant of loan against securities of ILPL (i.e. January 24, 2017) is considered as the origin point of the UPSI, which was published on BSE on March 14, 2017 at 23:05 hours and on NSE on March 15, 2017 at 08:53 hours. Thus, the period from January 24, 2017 to March 14, 2017 is determined as the UPSI period.

    14. Regulation 2(1)(g) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 defines the term insider as under: (g) "insider" means any person who is:

    i) a connected person; or ii) in possession of or having access to unpublished price sensitive information; NOTE: Since generally available information is defined, it is intended that anyone in possession of or having access to unpublished price sensitive information should be considered an insider regardless of how one came in possession of or had access to such information. Various circumstances are provided for such a person to demonstrate that he has not indulged in insider trading. Therefore, this definition is intended to bring within its reach any person who is in receipt of or has access to unpublished price sensitive information. The onus of showing that a certain person was in possession of or had access to unpublished price sensitive information at the time of trading would, therefore, be on the person leveling the charge after which the person who has traded when in possession of or having access to unpublished price sensitive information may demonstrate that he was not in such possession or that he has not traded or he could not access or that his trading when in possession of such information was squarely covered by the exonerating circumstances.

    15. As per regulation 2(1)(d) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015, connected person has been defined as:

    (i) Any person who is or has during the six months prior to the concerned act been associated with a company, directly or indirectly, in any capacity including by reason of frequent communication with its officers or by being in any contractual, fiduciary or employment relationship or by being a director, officer or an employee of the company or holds any position including a professional or business relationship between himself and the company whether temporary or permanent, that allows such person, directly or indirectly, access to unpublished price sensitive information or is reasonably expected to allow such access. Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 8 of 13

    (ii) Without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing, the persons falling with the following categories shall be deemed to be connected persons unless the contrary is established (a) an immediate relative of connected persons specified in clause (i);

    16. Further, regulation 2(1)(f) defines immediate relative as: a spouse of a person, and includes parent, sibling, and child of such person or of the spouse, any of whom is either dependent financially on such person, or consults such person in taking decision relating to trading in securities. Note: It is intended that the immediate relatives of a Connected person too become connected persons for the purposes of these Regulations.

    17. Based on the examination report of NSE and investigation conducted by SEBI and considering the abovementioned definitions, inter alia the entities viz., Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson have been identified as insiders that traded in the scrip of IVL during the UPSI period. The details of such findings are as follows: Pia Johnson:

    18. The investigation observed that Pia Johnson was the Non-Executive Director of IVL from March 10, 2015 to August 28, 2017. As per the companys reply dated May 03, 2018, being the Non-Executive Director, she was one of the entities connected to the company. Further, it was observed that Pia Johnson was a member of the Management Committee of the Board of Directors of IVL which was authorized to authorize IDSL to sell its entire investment in ILPL. Being a member of the aforesaid Management Committee of IVL, she was reasonably expected to have access to the aforesaid UPSI. In view of the same, it is noted that Pia Johnson is a connected person in terms of Regulation 2(1)(d)(i) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. Hence, she is considered to be an insider in terms of Regulation 2(1)(g) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015.

    19. The summary of trading activity of Pia Johnson in the scrip of IVL is as under: TABLE VII Period Trade date Quantity Buy Value (Rs.) Sell Quantity Sell Value (Rs.) Pre-UPSI Period (April 01, 2015 to January 23, 2017) 20/06/2016 135000 2916252 0 0 21/06/2016 170000 3669603 0 0 05/07/2016 0 0 25000 803412 Total 305000 6585855 25000 803412 During UPSI Period (January 24, 2017 to March 14, 2017) 16/02/2017 275000 9401223 0 0 17/02/2017 80000 2744461 0 0 22/02/2017 150000 5528327 0 0 Total 505000 17674011 0 0 Post-UPSI Period (March 15, 2017 to March 31, 2018) Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 9 of 13

    20. The summary of trading activity of Pia Johnson in the scrip of IVL visvis gross trading across the market is as under: TABLE VIII Period Buy Value Sell Value Gross Traded Value Total IVL % Total IVL % Total IVL % Pre-UPSI Period (April 01, 2015 to January 23, 2017) 40911634 6585855 16.10% 25121501 803412 3.20% 66033135 7389267 11.19% During UPSI Period (January 24, 2017 to March 14, 2017) 17674011 17674011 100.00% 1142774 0 0.00% 18816785 17674011 93.93% Post-UPSI Period (March 15, 2017 to March 31, 2018) 12452980 0 0.00% 24981504 0 0.00% 37434485 0 0.00% Total 71038625 24259866 34.15% 51245780 803412 1.57% 122284404 25063278 20.50%

    21. As seen from the tables above, during UPSI period, Pia Johnson had bought in total 505000 shares of IVL. Her trade concentration in IVL scrip was 11.19%, 93.93% and 0.00% respectively during pre-UPSI period from April 01, 2015, during UPSI period and post-UPSI period till March 31, 2018. Mehul Johnson:

    22. From the KYC documents received from broker, UCC details received from exchanges and Mehul Johnsons reply, it was observed that Mehul Johnson is husband of Pia Johnson. They share common address i.e. Flat no. 2502, 25th Floor, Tower B, Raheja Vivarea, Jacobs circle, Mahalaxmi station, Mumbai. Both are registered with the same broker i.e. IVL. Also, they jointly hold HDFC bank account no. 00011000083619. As per his replies, he is a senior official equivalent to the grade of President and is designated as Director (although not a member of the Board) of a subsidiary of IREL and is associated with the Indiabulls Group companies since April 2006.

    23. As per the provisions of regulation 2(1)(d)(ii)(a) read with regulation 2(1)(f) of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015, the spouse (immediate relative) of a connected person is also deemed to be a connected person, unless the contrary is established. In view of the same, since Mehul Johnson is husband (immediate relative) of Pia Johnson (i.e. the connected person), he is deemed to be a connected person in terms of Regulation 2(1)(d)(ii)(a) r/w Regulation 2(1)(f) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. There is nothing on record which indicates to the contrary. Hence, Mehul Johnson is considered to be an insider in terms of Regulation 2(1)(g) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 10 of 13

    24. The summary of trading activity of Mehul Johnson in the scrip of IVL is as under: TABLE IX Period Trade date Buy Quantity Buy Value (Rs.) Sell Quantity Sell Value (Rs.) Pre-UPSI Period (April 01, 2015 to January 23, 2017) 20/06/2016 45000 978245 0 0 Total 45000 978245 0 0 During UPSI Period (January 24, 2017 to March 14, 2017) 14/02/2017 166000 4973249 0 0 16/02/2017 122970 4030835 0 0 09/03/2017 50000 1817209 0 0 Total 338970 10821293 0 0 Post-UPSI Period (March 15, 2017 to March 31, 2018) - 0 0 0 0

    25. The summary of trading activity of Mehul Johnson in the scrip of IVL visvis gross trading across the market is as under: TABLE X Period Buy Value Sell Value Gross Traded Value Total IVL % Total IVL % Total IVL % Pre-UPSI Period (April 01, 2015 to January 23, 2017) 11580765 978245 8.45% 9696605 0 0.00% 21277370 978245 4.60% During UPSI Period (January 24, 2017 to March 14, 2017) 10821293 10821293 100.00% 6106696 0 0.00% 16927989 10821293 63.93% Post-UPSI Period (March 15, 2017 to March 31, 2018) 11547435 0 0.00% 89382556 0 0.00% 100929991 0 0.00% Total 33949493 11799539 34.76% 105185857 0 0.00% 139135350 11799539 8.48%

    26. As seen from the tables above, during UPSI period, Mehul Johnson had bought in total 338970 shares of IVL. His trade concentration in IVL scrip was 4.60%, 63.93% and 0.00% respectively during pre-UPSI period from April 01, 2015, during UPSI period and post-UPSI period till March 31, 2018. Charges of Insider Trading:

    27. Based on the close family relation between Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson and their trading in the scrip during the period of UPSI, it is prima facie established that Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson, both being insiders to the company, had traded in the scrip of the company while in possession of the UPSI, thereby indulging in insider trading, in terms of regulation 4(1) of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015. There is a prima facie case that Pia Johnson had communicated the UPSI to her husband, Mehul Johnson, who executed his trades while in possession of the same.

    28. Therefore, Pia Johnson has prima facie violated Section 12A (d) & (e) of SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(1) and 4(1) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 by communicating UPSI to her Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 11 of 13 husband Mehul Johnson and by trading in the scrip of the company while being in possession of UPSI, thereby indulging in insider trading. Mehul Johnson has prima facie violated Section 12A (d) & (e) of SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(2) and 4(1) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 by procuring UPSI from his spouse, Pia Johnson (an insider) and by trading in the scrip of the company while being in possession of UPSI, thereby indulging in insider trading. Wrongful gains made by Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson

    29. Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson bought shares of IVL during the UPSI period and the gains made by them is calculated as under: TABLE XI Name No. of shares bought Total Buy Value (Rs.) Average Buy Price (Rs.) Closing Price on March 15, 2017 (Rs.)** Wrongful gain (Rs.)# A B C=B/A D E = A x (D-C) Pia Johnson 505000 17674011 35.00 41.95 35,10,739.00 Mehul Johnson 338970 10821293 31.92 41.95 33,98,498.50 #Note: Wrongful gain has been calculated as per the following method: Wrongful gain = (Closing price on the next day of announcement** - Average buy price) X No. of shares bought during UPSI period ** The announcement was made on March 14, 2017 on BSE at 23:05 and on March 15, 2017 on NSE at 08:53. Therefore, the closing price of scrip on March 15, 2017 i.e. Rs.41.95 at BSE and NSE is considered for computation of wrongful gains.

    30. In view of the above, it is observed on the basis of investigation that Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson traded in the scrip of IVL when in possession of UPSI pertaining to sale of ILPL to IIL / investment of IIL in ILPL and have collectively made wrongful gains of Rs.69.09 Lakhs.

    31. As the alleged gains were made during January 24, 2017 to March 14, 2017 (i.e. the period of UPSI), it becomes reasonable and necessary to levy an interest at the rate of 12% simple interest per annum. The total alleged wrongful gains made by Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson, through trading in the scrip of IVL during the UPSI period, including interest thereon, amounted to Rs. 87,21,918.55. A summary of the same is provided hereunder: TABLE XII Entity Name Gain (Rs.) Interest 12% per annum* Total (Rs.) Pia Johnson 35,10,739.00 9,21,064.02 44,31,803.02 Mehul Johnson 33,98,498.50 8,91,617.03 42,90,115.53 Total 69,09,237.50 18,12,681.05 87,21,918.55 *Interest calculated on wrongful gains from March 15, 2017 to May 21, 2019)

    32. With the initiation of quasi-judicial proceedings, it is possible that the Noticees may divert the unlawful gains (subject to the adjudication of the allegation on the merits in the final order), which may result in defeating the effective implementation of the direction of disgorgement, if any to be passed after adjudication on merits. Non-interference by the Regulator at this stage would therefore result in irreparable injury to interests of the securities market and the investors. It Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 12 of 13 therefore becomes necessary for SEBI to take urgent steps of impounding and retaining the proceeds (wrongful gains) allegedly made by Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson, by way of an interim measure. Considering the facts and circumstances of the case, the balance of convenience lies in favour of SEBI.

    33. Accordingly, as an interim measure, an AdInterim ExParte Order for impounding such alleged profits under Section 11(1) read with 11(4)(d) and Section 11B of the SEBI Act read with Regulation 10 of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015 needs to be issued against Pia Johnson and Mehul Johnson. Order

    34. In view of the foregoing, I, in exercise of the powers conferred upon me in terms of Section

    19 read with Sections 11(1),11(4)(d)and Section 11B of the SEBI Act read with Regulation 10 of the Insider Trading Regulations, 2015, hereby issue the following directions: (a) I hereby impound the alleged unlawful gains of a sum of Rs. 87,21,918.55 (alleged gains of Rs.69,09,237.50 + interest of Rs. 18,12,681.05 from March 15, 2017 to May 21, 2019), jointly and severally, from the following persons/entities- ENTITY PAN

    1. PIA JOHNSON AGVPJ6093M

    2. MEHUL JOHNSON ABBPJ3414H (b) The Banks are directed that no debits shall be made, without permission of SEBI, in respect of the bank accounts held by all the persons/entities tabulated in paragraph 34(a) above. Further, the Depositories are also directed that no debit shall be made, without permission of SEBI, in respect of the demat accounts held by the above said persons. However, credits, if any, into the accounts maybe allowed. The Banks and the Depositories are directed to ensure that all the above directions are strictly enforced. Further, debits may also be allowed for amounts available in the account in excess of the amount to be impounded. Banks are allowed to debit the accounts for the purpose of complying with this Order. (c) The persons/ entities tabulated at paragraph 34(a) above are also directed not to dispose of or alienate any of their assets/properties/securities, till such time the amount mentioned in paragraph 34(a) is credited to an interest bearing Escrow Account [Escrow Account in Compliance with SEBI Order dated May 24, 2019 A/c (in the name of the respective persons/entities)] created specifically for the purpose in a Nationalized Bank. The Escrow Account(s) shall create a lien in favour of SEBI and the monies kept therein shall not be released without permission from SEBI. On production of proof by any of the persons mentioned at paragraph 34(a) that the said money is deposited in the Escrow Account, SEBI shall communicate to the Banks and Depositories to defreeze the accounts. (d) Further, the persons/entities tabulated in paragraph 34(a) above are directed to provide, within 7 days of this Order, a full inventory of all their assets and properties and details of Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited Page 13 of 13 all their bank accounts, demat accounts and holdings of shares/securities, if held in physical form and details of companies in which they hold substantial or controlling interest.

    35. The observations/findings contained in this Order are made on the basis of Investigation concluded by SEBI in the matter. The findings in this order may be treated as allegations against the respective entities for the purpose of show cause against them. Accordingly, the persons mentioned at paragraph 34(a) are advised to show cause as to why suitable directions, including the following, should not be issued/imposed against them under Sections 11(1), 11(4) and 11B of the SEBI Act, 1992 for the alleged violations of the provisions of Sections 12A(d) & (e) of the SEBI Act, 1992 and regulations 3(1) / 3(2) & 4(1) of Insider Trading Regulations, 2015: (a) Directing them to disgorge an amount equivalent to the total gains made on account of insider trading in the scrip of IVL along with interest,

    (ii) Directing them to refrain from accessing the securities market and prohibiting them from buying, selling or otherwise dealing in securities for an appropriate period.

    36. The persons mentioned at paragraph 34(a) may file their replies to SEBI within 30 days from the date of receipt of this Order. They may also indicate in their replies whether they wish to avail an opportunity of personal hearing in the matter.

    37. This Order shall come into force with immediate effect and shall be in force till further Orders.

    38. This Order shall be served on all Recognized Stock Exchanges, Depositories and Registrar and Share Transfer Agents and Banks to ensure necessary compliance. Place: Mumbai G.MAHALINGAM Date: May 24, 2019 WHOLE TIME MEMBER SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Order in the matter of Indiabulls Ventures Limited
    (May 24, 2019)