Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 1210
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 37 of the Act
  • Article 35(a) of the Schedule
  • Section 34, Subsection (1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898
  • Section 33, Section 38 of the Act (year not specified)
  • Section 35 of the Act
  • Section 33, Subsection (1) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957
  • Section 34, Section 39(1)(b) of the <no year mentioned> Act
  • Section 33, Section 34 of the Act
  • Section 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957
  • Section 35(a), Article of the Schedule
  • Section 58 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 36 of the Act
  • Section 33, Section 34, Section 38, Section 39 of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2018 INSC 1210
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 37 of the Act
  • Article 35(a) of the Schedule
  • Section 34, Subsection (1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898
  • Section 33, Section 38 of the Act (year not specified)
  • Section 35 of the Act
  • Section 33, Subsection (1) of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957
  • Section 34, Section 39(1)(b) of the <no year mentioned> Act
  • Section 33, Section 34 of the Act
  • Section 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957
  • Section 35(a), Article of the Schedule
  • Section 58 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 36 of the Act
  • Section 33, Section 34, Section 38, Section 39 of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant-plaintiffs entered into two agreements to sell with the respondent-defendant on 12-4-2005 and 16-5-2006, paying earnest money of Rs 1,40,000. In 2008 the appellants filed OS Nos. 863-64 of 2008 for specific performance; OS No. 327 of 2008 filed by the defendant’s sister was clubbed with the suits.

On 27-9-2010 the Principal Civil Judge impounded the agreements for being insufficiently stamped and directed payment of deficit duty and penalty. The appellants challenged that order in writ petitions, which the High Court disposed of on 14-3-2013, directing the trial court to receive written submissions. Subsequently, on 22-4-2013, the trial court admitted the agreements on payment of deficit duty (Rs 12,013 and Rs 20,320) and imposed a penalty equal to double the deficit duty in each suit.

The respondent filed a writ petition. By judgment dated 17-7-2014 the Karnataka High Court, relying on Digambar Warty v. District Registrar, directed that the penalty be levied at ten times the deficit duty. The present civil appeal challenges that High Court decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Sections 33 and 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957, a civil court admitting an insufficiently stamped instrument in evidence has discretion to impose a penalty of less than ten times the deficit duty.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The trial court rightly exercised discretion by imposing a penalty of double the deficit duty; this was “just and proper.”
  • Because the Deputy Commissioner can ultimately reduce the penalty under Section 38, the trial court should equally have discretion when initially admitting the document.
  • The High Court erred in mechanically applying a ten-times penalty.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Section 34 mandates a penalty of ten times the deficit duty; the trial court has no discretion to reduce it.
  • The Division Bench decision in Digambar Warty v. District Registrar correctly interprets Section 34 and binds the trial court.
  • The impugned High Court judgment properly applied that binding precedent.

Table of Precedents Cited

PrecedentRule or Principle Cited ForApplication by the Court
Digambar Warty v. District Registrar, Bangalore Urban District, 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776; ILR 2013 KAR 2099 Interpretation of Sections 33 & 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act: penalty on insufficiently stamped instruments admitted in evidence must be ten times the deficit duty; no discretion with the court. The Supreme Court affirmed the interpretation but, for equitable reasons, declined to apply the ten-times penalty in the present case.
K. Govinde Gowda v. Akkayamma, 2011 SCC OnLine Kar 226; ILR 2011 KAR 4719 Illustrates circumstances where imposing the maximum statutory penalty may be harsh. Cited by the trial court to justify limiting the penalty to double the deficit duty; the Supreme Court noted, but did not expressly rely on, this reasoning.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a detailed textual comparison of Sections 33, 34, 38 and 39 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957:

  • Sections 33 & 34: Any authority admitting an insufficiently stamped instrument “shall” collect duty and a penalty equal to ten times the deficit when the deficit exceeds Rs 5. The mandatory language leaves no discretion to that admitting authority.
  • Sections 38 & 39: The Deputy Commissioner, a revenue authority, is expressly granted discretion—both when initially assessing penalty (Section 39) and when considering refund (Section 38)—to impose or sustain less than the maximum ten-times penalty (“if he thinks fit”).
  • The distinction shows the legislature’s intent: field-level authorities (including courts) apply a uniform ten-times levy; discretionary mitigation is channelled through the Deputy Commissioner.
  • The Division Bench decision in Digambar Warty correctly captured this statutory scheme; the High Court’s reliance on it was legally sound.

However, the Supreme Court observed that: (a) the trial court had already imposed and the appellants had presumably paid double the deficit duty more than five years earlier; (b) the plaintiffs were agriculturists with limited knowledge of stamp requirements; and (c) insisting on a fresh ten-times payment followed by Section 38 proceedings would cause further delay and expense. To “meet the ends of justice,” the Court therefore chose to validate the trial court’s lesser penalty, effectively short-circuiting the need for a separate refund application.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF. The appeal is allowed to the limited extent that the Supreme Court confirms the trial court’s order directing payment of the full deficit duty plus a penalty equal to double that duty. The High Court’s directive to impose a ten-times penalty is set aside for pragmatic reasons, although its legal interpretation of Section 34 is upheld.

Implications: The decision reaffirms that, as a matter of law, courts have no discretion to levy less than a ten-times penalty under Section 34. Nonetheless, it highlights that equitable considerations and the remedial powers of higher courts (or the Deputy Commissioner under Section 38) may temper harsh outcomes in individual cases. No new legal precedent is created on the statutory interpretation, which remains as previously articulated in Digambar Warty.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Gangappa And Another v. Fakkirappa .

    Ashok Bhushan, J.— This appeal has been filed against the judgment of the Karnataka High Court, Dharwad Bench dated 17-7-2014 2014 SCC OnLine Kar 12775 disposing of the writ petition filed by the respondent herein.

    2. Brief facts of the case necessary to be noticed for deciding this appeal are: the appellant-plaintiffs entered into agreements to sell with the respondent-defendant dated 12-4-2005 and 16-5-2006 and earnest money of Rs 1,40,000 was paid. The appellants filed Suits Nos. 863-64 of 2008 praying for specific performance of contract. Another suit filed by the sister of the defendant being OS No. 327 of 2008 was also clubbed. The Principal Civil Judge impounded agreements to sell filed by the plaintiffs in Suits Nos. 863-64 of 2008 with direction to the plaintiff to pay deficit duty and penalty vide order dated 27-9-2010. The plaintiffs challenged the order by means of Writ Petitions Nos. 69264-65 and 69263 of 2010 which were disposed of by the High Court vide its judgment dated 14-3-2013 2013 SCC OnLine Kar 1103 directing the Principal Civil Judge to permit the plaintiffs to place written submissions. After the order of the High Court, the Principal Civil Judge passed an order dated 22-4-2013 by which agreements to sell in question were admitted in evidence and marked for the plaintiffs in OSs Nos. 863-64 of 2008 on payment of deficit duty and penalty. Deficit duty in both the suits was determined as Rs 12,013 and Rs 20,320 respectively and the penalty imposed was double of the deficit duty in both the suits.

    3. Aggrieved by the judgment of the Principal Civil Judge, the respondent-defendant filed a writ petition in the High Court. The High Court disposed of the writ petition relying on a Division Bench judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Digambar Warty v. Bangalore Urban District 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776, ILR 2013 KAR 2099. The High Court directed the courts below to levy the penalty at 10 times of the deficit duty as per the judgment of the Karnataka High Court in Digambar Warty v. Bangalore Urban District 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776, ILR 2013 KAR 2099. Aggrieved by the judgment of the High Court this appeal has been filed by the appellants.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellant submits that the High Court committed an error in directing payment of penalty at 10 times. The trial court has rightly directed for payment of deficit duty and penalty at the rate of 2 times which was a just and proper order. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that when the Deputy Commissioner can reduce levy of penalty not exceeding 10 times of the amount of duty, the trial court while determining the deficiency and penalty shall also have such discretion. The trial court has rightly exercised the discretion by imposing the penalty of two times.

    5. The learned counsel appearing for the respondent submits that the instruments were not duly stamped. While admitting the insufficiently stamped documents the trial court has no discretion while levying the penalty. The statute i.e. Section 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957 mandates penalty at the rate of 10 times. The Division Bench of the High Court in Digambar Warty 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776, ILR 2013 KAR 2099 has correctly interpreted Section 34 while holding that the Court has no discretion to reduce the penalty from 10 times. The High Court has rightly followed the above Division Bench judgment.

    6. We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the parties and perused the records.

    7. The issue which needs to be answered in the present case is as to whether the trial court which had admitted the agreements to sell in evidence could have exercised its discretion in imposing penalty at the rate of 2 times of deficient amount of stamp duty or it was obligatory for the trial court to impose the penalty at the rate of 10 times.

    8. Before we proceed to consider the respective submissions of the parties, it is relevant to notice the statutory provisions of the Karnataka Stamp Act, 1957. Section 33 requires every person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence, is obliged to impound any instrument which according to him is not duly stamped. Section 33 sub-section (1) is as follows:

    “33. Examination and impounding of instruments.—(1) Every person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence, and every person in charge of a public office, except an officer of police, before whom any instrument, chargeable in his opinion, with duty, is produced or comes in the performance of his functions, shall, if it appears to him that such instrument is not duly stamped, impound the same.”

    9. Section 34 provides that instruments not duly stamped are inadmissible in evidence. Section 34 sub-section (1) which is relevant for the present case is as follows:

    “34. Instruments not duly stamped inadmissible in evidence, etc.—No instrument chargeable with duty shall be admitted in evidence for any purpose by any person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence, or shall be acted upon, registered or authenticated by any such person or by any public officer, unless such instrument is duly stamped:
    Provided that—
    (a) nothing herein contained shall be deemed to require any Magistrate or Judge of a criminal court to examine or impound, if he does not think fit so to do, any instrument coming before him in the course of any proceeding other than a proceeding under Chapter XII or Chapter XXXVI of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898;”

    10. Section 38 empowers the Deputy Commissioner to refund penalty paid under sub-section (1) of Section 37. Section 39 relates to the Deputy Commissioner's power to stamp instruments impounded. Section 38 and Section 39(1) are as follows:

    “38. Deputy Commissioner's power to refund penalty paid under sub-section (1) of Section 37.—(1) When a copy of an instrument is sent to the Deputy Commissioner under sub-section (1) of Section 37, he may, if he thinks fit, refund any portion of the penalty in excess of five rupees which has been paid in respect of such instrument.
    (2) When such instrument has been impounded only because it has been written in contravention of Section 13 or Section 14, the Deputy Commissioner may refund the whole penalty so paid.
    39. Deputy Commissioner's power to stamp instruments impounded.—(1) When the Deputy Commissioner impounds any instrument under Section 33, or receives any instrument sent to him under sub-section (2) of Section 37, not being an instrument chargeable with a duty not exceeding fifteen paise only or a mortgage of crop Article 35(a) of the Schedule chargeable under clause (a) or (b) of Section 3 with a duty of twenty-five paise, he shall adopt the following procedure—
    (a) if he is of opinion that such instrument is duly stamped, or is not chargeable with duty, he shall certify by endorsement thereon that it is duly stamped, or that it is not so chargeable, as the case may be;
    (b) if he is of opinion that such instrument is chargeable with duty and is not duly stamped he shall require the payment of the proper duty or the amount required to make up the same, together with a penalty of five rupees; or if he thinks fit an amount not exceeding ten times the amount of the proper duty or of the deficient portion thereof, whether such amount exceeds or falls short of five rupees:
    Provided that, when such instrument has been impounded only because it has been written in contravention of Section 13 or Section 14, the Deputy Commissioner may, if he thinks fit, remit the whole penalty prescribed by this section.”

    11. Section 34 proviso provides for admitting in evidence an instrument not duly stamped on payment of duty and penalty. With regard to penalty the statute provides:

    “34. (a) … in the case of an instrument insufficiently stamped, of the amount required to make up such duty, together with a penalty of five rupees, or, when ten times the amount of the proper duty or deficient portion thereof exceeds five rupees, of a sum equal to ten times such duty or portion;”

    12. The statute envisages that when the 10 times of the amount of the proper duty or deficient portion thereof exceeds five rupees, a sum equal to 10 times of such duty or portion is the penalty.

    13. The language of Section 34 provides a flat rate of penalty when the amount of proper duty exceeds five rupees i.e. 10 times of such duty or portion. There is a clear contrast in the language of Section 34 and Section 39. Section 39 sub-section (1) clause (b) is extracted for ready reference:

    “39. (1)(b) if he is of opinion that such instrument is chargeable with duty and is not duly stamped he shall require the payment of the proper duty or the amount required to make up the same, together with a penalty of five rupees; or if he thinks fit an amount not exceeding ten times the amount of the proper duty or of the deficient portion thereof, whether such amount exceeds or falls short of five rupees:”

    14. The above provision indicated that if the Deputy Commissioner is of opinion that such instrument is chargeable with duty and is not duly stamped shall require the payment of the proper duty with a penalty of five rupees. The latter part of the provision states “or if he thinks fit an amount not exceeding ten times the amount of the proper duty or of the deficient portion thereof, whether such amount exceeds or falls short of five rupees:”. Thus, discretion has been conferred on the Deputy Commissioner which is apparent from the words “if he thinks fit”. The Deputy Commissioner has discretion of imposing penalty of 10 times or lesser of the amount of duty or portion thereof. There is clear contradistinction between the power under Sections 33 and 39. The object and purpose for such contradistinction in the provision and power is not far to seek. Section 33 applies to every person having by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence, and every person in charge of a public office. Thus, Section 33 covers a host of authorities, persons before whom instruments are filed. The legislative scheme does not indicate any distinction between a court receiving an insufficiently stamped instrument in evidence and other authorities. All have to impose penalty of 10 times of the duty or deficit portion, if it exceeds rupees five. This provision is for purpose of maintaining a uniformity in imposing a fixed penalty of 10 times without adverting to any adjudicatory process regarding quantifying the quantum of penalty. The statute gives discretion to the Deputy Commissioner who is the authority envisaged by the Act in-charge of the revenue administration of a district. The definition of “Deputy Commissioner” is given in Section 2(dd) which is to the following effect:

    “2. (1)(dd) “Deputy Commissioner” means the Chief Officer-in-charge of the revenue administration of a district and includes in respect of such provisions of this Act or Rules made thereunder such officer in such area as the State Government may by notification in the Official Gazette specify;”

    15. The amount of duty and penalty is required to be sent to the Deputy Commissioner under Section 37. Section 37 is quoted below:

    “37. Instruments impounded how dealt with.—(1) When the person impounding an instrument under Section 33 has by law or consent of parties authority to receive evidence and admits such instrument in evidence upon payment of a penalty as provided by Section 34 or of duty as provided by Section 36, he shall send to the Deputy Commissioner an authenticated copy of such instrument, together with a certificate in writing, stating the amount of duty and penalty levied in respect thereof, and shall send such amount to the Deputy Commissioner or to such person as he may appoint in this behalf.
    (2) In every other case, the person so impounding an instrument shall send it in original to the Deputy Commissioner.”

    16. The Deputy Commissioner under Section 38 is empowered to refund any portion of the penalty in excess of five rupees which has been paid in respect of such instrument. Section 38 sub-section (1) again uses the expression “if he thinks fit”. Thus, in cases where penalty of 10 times has been imposed, the Deputy Commissioner has discretion to direct the refund of the penalty in facts of a particular case. The power to refund the penalty under Section 38 clearly indicates that the legislature has never contemplated that in all cases penalty to the extent of 10 times should be ultimately realised. Although the procedural part which provides for impounding and realisation of duty and penalty does not give any discretion under Section 33 for imposing any lesser penalty than 10 times, however, when provision of Section 38 is read, the discretion given to the Deputy Commissioner to refund the penalty is akin to exercise of the jurisdiction under Section 39 where while determining the penalty he can impose the penalty lesser than 10 times.

    17. In the Division Bench judgment of the Karnataka High Court relied on by the High Court in Digambar Warty 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776, ILR 2013 KAR 2099, after noticing the provisions of Sections 33 and 34 the Division Bench laid down the following in para 36: (SCC OnLine Kar)

    “36. This provision refers to the power of the civil court which admits the documents in evidence. The main section is couched in the negative. Unless the instrument is duly stamped, it is inadmissible in evidence. As an exception, the proviso provides for payment of duty and penalty. In the matter of collection of duty and penalty no discretion is vested with the authority admitting such an instrument in evidence. The duty payable on the instrument is prescribed by statute. Therefore, there is no question of any discretion being vested with the authority impounding the document in the matter of collecting the duty. Once the duty payable is ascertained from the statute, no discretion is vested with the authority admitting the document in evidence, in the matter of imposition of duty and penalty. The word used in the said proviso is “shall”. It is mandatory. However, Section 35 makes it clear, that where an instrument has been admitted in evidence without there being objection at the time of admitting the said instrument in evidence, then such admission shall not, except as provided in Section 58, be called in question at any stage of the same suit or proceeding on the ground that the instrument has not been duly stamped. Section 58 deals with the power of the appellate court to review the finding recorded by the original court under Section 34 of the Act, either suo motu or on the application of the Deputy Commissioner. Section 36 of the Act deals with admission of improperly stamped instrument. The State Government may make rules providing that, where an instrument bears a stamp of sufficient amount but of improper description, it may, on payment of the duty with which the same is chargeable, be certified to be duly stamped, and any instrument so certified shall then be deemed to have been duly stamped as from the date of its execution.”

    18. The above view of the Karnataka High Court that there is no discretion vested with the authority impounding the document in the matter of collecting duty under Section 33, is correct. The word used in the said proviso is “shall”. Sections 33 and 34 clearly indicate that penalty imposed has to be 10 times. The Division Bench of the Karnataka High Court in Digambar Warty 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776, ILR 2013 KAR 2099 has rightly interpreted the provisions of Sections 33 and 34 of the Act. We, thus, are of the view that the High Court in the impugned judgment 2014 SCC OnLine Kar 12775 did not commit any error in relying on the judgment of the Division Bench in Digambar Warty 2012 SCC OnLine Kar 8776, ILR 2013 KAR 2099. We thus have to uphold the above view expressed in the impugned judgment 2014 SCC OnLine Kar 12775.

    19. There is one more aspect which needs to be noted in the present case. We have seen that even though 10 times penalty has to be collected and imposed by the person impounding the document under Section 37, Section 38 empowers the Deputy Collector to refund the duty. The learned trial court while imposing penalty at the rate of two times has given the following reason:

    “The plaintiffs of OS Nos. 863-64 of 2008 are stated to be agriculturists and are residing at Sherewad Village. The said fact is not denied by the defendants therein. It appears that the agreements were prepared by local villagers who are not experienced in the documentation. Looking to the status of the plaintiffs, their standard of having qualification of the document writers, I am of the opinion that the ratio laid down by our Hon'ble High Court in K. Govinde Gowda v. Akkayamma 2011 SCC OnLine Kar 226, ILR 2011 KAR 4719 can be applied to the present facts and circumstances levying 10 times penalty in respect of the said agreement will be harsh on the plaintiffs. Therefore I am of the opinion that levying double the amount of deficit duty as penalty will meet the ends of justice.”

    20. The order of the trial court was passed as early as on 22-4-2013, that is, more than five years ago. In view of impounding the documents and imposition of penalty, we are sure that the suit must not have been proceeded further, and it must be at the threshold stage; asking the appellant to deposit 10 times of penalty and thereafter to invoke the jurisdiction of the Deputy Collector under Section 38 to refund penalty shall be a proceeding again taking considerable time. In the facts of the present case, we are of the view that ends of justice will be served in closing the matter by confirming the payment of deficit duty with the double penalty as imposed by the trial court which shall obviate the proceeding of approaching the Deputy Commissioner for reduction of penalty under Section 38, which in the facts of the present case and for the reasons noted by the trial court was a relevant consideration for refund/reduction of the penalty.

    21. In view of the foregoing discussion, we are, therefore, of the view that the High Court has correctly interpreted the provisions of Section 33 in the impugned judgment 2014 SCC OnLine Kar 12775 but instead of prolonging the matter permitting the appellant to deposit 10 times of penalty and thereafter to take recourse under Section 38, we in the facts of the present case close the proceedings regarding penalty on the agreements to sell by approving the direction of the trial court for payment of entire deficit duty and double the penalty.

    22. The appeal is disposed of accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gangappa And Another v. Fakkirappa .
    (Dec 14, 2018)