AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 80(B) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969, the Kerala Co-operative Service Examination
  • Rule 14 of the Kerala Public Service Commission Rules of Procedure to advise W.A.No.2517 of 2015 6
  • Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1968 (hereinafter referred to as the Act for short) or the Rules
  • Rule 182(4)(vii) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 (the Rules for short)
  • Section 66A of the Co- operative Societies Act, 1969 (Kerala)
  • Examination Board. Rule 182(4) of the Rules
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 182(4)(vii) of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 80(B) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969, the Kerala Co-operative Service Examination
  • Rule 14 of the Kerala Public Service Commission Rules of Procedure to advise W.A.No.2517 of 2015 6
  • Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1968 (hereinafter referred to as the Act for short) or the Rules
  • Rule 182(4)(vii) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 (the Rules for short)
  • Section 66A of the Co- operative Societies Act, 1969 (Kerala)
  • Examination Board. Rule 182(4) of the Rules
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Rule 182(4)(vii) of the Rules
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion (W.A. No.2517 of 2015)

Factual and Procedural Background

This matter arises from W.P.(C) No.19353 of 2015 filed under Article 226 of the Constitution by Smitha T. Pillai (the writ petitioner / first respondent in the appeal) against Pannivizha Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. (the appellant / second respondent in the writ petition). The writ petitioner sought a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the bank to appoint her as Junior Clerk based on her position in the published rank list (Ext.P2).

Relevant facts recited in the opinion:

  • On 21.11.2011 the bank notified one vacancy for Junior Clerk and the Kerala Co-operative Service Examination Board conducted a written test on 16.06.2012 and forwarded eligible candidates for interview.
  • The bank conducted interviews and published Ext.P2 rank list on 02.07.2013. The writ petitioner secured the second rank; the first rank holder (Raji S.) was appointed on 05.08.2013 and joined duty.
  • A further vacancy for Junior Clerk arose on 18.02.2014. The bank's managing committee on 29.07.2014 resolved to notify and fill that vacancy by appointing persons with disability and issued a notification accordingly.
  • The writ petitioner submitted representations (Ext.P4 dated 13.05.2015 and Ext.P5 dated 26.02.2015) seeking appointment against the vacancy that arose on 18.02.2014, relying on the Division Bench decision in Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Limited v. Neena (2010(1) KLT 541).
  • The writ petition sought mandamus directing the bank to appoint the petitioner as Junior Clerk in light of her qualification and rank and, alternatively, directing the Joint Registrar to issue an order under Section 66A of the Co‑operative Societies Act, 1969 appointing her in view of the vacancy arising during the validity of the rank list.
  • The learned single Judge, by judgment dated 15.09.2015, allowed the writ petition and held that the petitioner was entitled to appointment against the vacancy which arose on 18.02.2014 based on her rank in Ext.P2. The bank (second respondent in the writ petition) filed this writ appeal (W.A. No.2517 of 2015) challenging that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petitioner is entitled to appointment to the Junior Clerk vacancy that arose on 18.02.2014 based on her rank in Ext.P2 rank list published on 02.07.2013.
  2. Whether a rank list published under the Kerala Co‑operative Societies Rules (Rule 182(4)(vii)) remains valid and operates to fill vacancies arising during its two‑year validity period, or whether the rank list ceases to operate once the originally notified vacancies are filled (in light of conflicting authority).
  3. Whether the appellant bank was permitted (or obliged) to reserve and fill the subsequently arisen vacancy for persons with disability notwithstanding the existence of a valid rank list and the petitioner's claimed entitlement.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Bank's) Arguments

  • The appellant relied on the Apex Court decision in Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Neena (2013(1) KLT 344) which reversed the earlier Division Bench decision relied upon by the petitioner; in light of that Apex Court decision, the petitioner cannot assert that the rank list remains valid to cover vacancies arising during its validity or that a rank list does not cease to operate when the notified vacancies are filled up.
  • The appellant submitted that, unlike the Kerala Public Service Commission (which has a Rule 14 obligation to advise candidates against vacancies reported during currency of a ranked list), there is no provision in the Kerala Co‑operative Societies Act or the rules framed thereunder obliging the society (bank) to fill up all vacancies that arise during the currency of the rank list in addition to the vacancies mentioned in the initial notification inviting applications.
  • The bank admitted that a vacancy arose but contended it had decided to fill that vacancy by appointing persons with disability and had taken steps to do so.
  • The appellant also relied on the decision in Jayaprakash v. Joint Registrar (2013(4) KLT 788) to contend the legal position regarding reservation for persons with disability where a society employs more than 10 employees (see further in the precedents table).

Writ Petitioner / First Respondent's Arguments

  • The petitioner relied on the Division Bench decision in Kodakara Farmers Service Co‑operative Bank Limited v. Neena (2010(1) KLT 541) to contend that she was entitled to appointment to the vacancy that arose on 18.02.2014 during the currency of the rank list.
  • She contended that the decision by the bank's Managing Committee on 29.07.2014 to fill the vacancy by appointing persons with disability (after conducting a written test and interview) was illegal.
  • In reply affidavit the petitioner pointed out that after Ext.P2 was published the bank had appointed three peons and that one of those peon vacancies could have been reserved for a person with disability; she also noted that a writ petition by a person with disability (W.P.(C) No.18708 of 2014) was pending before the court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court / How It Was Used in the Opinion
Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Limited v. Neena (Division Bench) [2010(1) KLT 541] Relied upon by the writ petitioner to support the proposition that a rank list remains valid and a candidate ranked on that list is entitled to appointment to vacancies arising during the currency of the rank list. The petitioner expressly relied on this Division Bench decision in her representations (Ext.P4 and Ext.P5) and in the writ petition to assert entitlement to appointment against the vacancy of 18.02.2014. The opinion records this reliance as a central factual/legal foundation for the petitioner's claim.
Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Neena (Apex Court) [2013(1) KLT 344] The Apex Court decision reversed the earlier Division Bench decision (2010). The appellant relied on the Apex Court's ruling to argue that the petitioner cannot maintain that the rank list remains valid to cover subsequently arising vacancies in the manner asserted. The appellant's counsel relied on this Apex Court decision to contend that the petitioner's legal position (based on the Division Bench decision) is no longer tenable. The opinion records this contention as one of the principal legal points pressed by the appellant in the appeal.
Jayaprakash v. Joint Registrar [2013(4) KLT 788] Interpreted to mean that any society which employs more than 10 employees has to reserve the 11th or the 12th post for persons with disability, if the said post is identified to be filled up by appointing persons with disability. The appellant bank referenced this decision to support its position regarding the obligation to reserve posts for persons with disability in certain circumstances. The opinion records that the bank relied on this authority in its counter affidavit/defensive posture.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The provided opinion contains the following steps of reasoning and analysis (as recorded in the text):

  1. The appellate court summarized the factual matrix: notification for one Junior Clerk vacancy (21.11.2011), examination (16.06.2012), publication of the rank list (Ext.P2 on 02.07.2013), appointment of the first rank holder, and the later vacancy arising on 18.02.2014.
  2. The court recorded procedural steps taken by the petitioner (representations Ext.P4 and Ext.P5) and the filing of W.P.(C) No.19353 of 2015 seeking mandamus for appointment based on Ext.P2.
  3. The court documented the parties' primary legal contentions: petitioner relying on the Division Bench Kodakara (2010) to claim entitlement during the currency of the rank list; the bank relying on the Apex Kodakara (2013) reversal to dispute that position and also asserting a duty/decision to reserve the vacancy for persons with disability. The bank further argued the absence of any statutory obligation (in the Co‑operative Societies Act or Rules) analogous to Rule 14 of the Kerala PSC Rules that would require filling up vacancies reported during the currency of a ranked list beyond those in the initial notification.
  4. The opinion sets out, at length, the statutory and rule provisions governing recruitment under Section 80B and Rule 182(4) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969. The text reproduces the sub‑clauses of Rule 182(4) including the procedural timeline for the Examination Board, the committee's interview process, the obligation to publish a rank list within twenty days of receipt of consolidated marks, and the specific stipulation that "The list shall be valid for a period of two years from the date of publication of the same by the society." It also notes the rule's obligation that appointments be made from the select list within one month of its publication and reported to the Examination Board.
  5. The opinion records that the learned single Judge considered rival contentions and held that the petitioner was entitled to appointment against the vacancy of 18.02.2014 (the single Judge's order is described as allowing the writ petition). The appellate court noted that the bank filed the appeal challenging that impugned judgment.

Important limitation: The portion of the opinion provided does not contain the appellate court's full, final analysis or the ultimate disposition of W.A. No.2517 of 2015. The text records the arguments, the statutory framework, and the fact that the single Judge allowed the writ petition, but the appellate court's concluding reasoning and final order in the appeal are not included in the provided excerpt.

Holding and Implications

Holding: By the impugned judgment (single Judge dated 15.09.2015) the writ petition was allowed. The single Judge held that the writ petitioner was entitled to be appointed to the vacancy that arose on 18.02.2014 based on her rank in Ext.P2 rank list (the judgment mistakenly referred to the date as 08.02.2014).

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: As recorded in the provided opinion, the single Judge's decision directed (or effectively required) appointment of the petitioner as Junior Clerk against the vacancy of 18.02.2014; the bank has challenged that order by filing the present writ appeal (W.A. No.2517 of 2015).
  • Broader legal implications: The provided excerpt does not set out any new, authoritative appellate holding resolving the conflict between the earlier Division Bench decision in Kodakara (2010) and the Apex Court's reversal (Kodakara 2013), nor does it record an appellate pronouncement establishing a fresh precedent. The appellate court's final determination on these broader legal questions is not present in the supplied text.

If further parts of the judgment (the appellate court's complete reasoning and final order in W.A. No.2517 of 2015) are available, they would be necessary to state conclusively whether the single Judge's allowance of the writ petition was upheld, modified or set aside on appeal and to explain any precedential effect arising from the appellate court's ruling.

    Pannivizha Service Co-Operaive Bank Ltd. v. Smitha T. Pillai

    OF HIGH COURT OF KERALA, DATED 15-09-2015) APPELLANT/2ND RESPONDENT: PANNIVIZHA SERVICE CO-OPERAIVE BANK LTD. NO.891, ADOOR, REPRESENTED BY SECRETARY, PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT-689 645. BY ADV.SRI.P.N.MOHANAN RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS 1 & 3:

    1. SMITHA T. PILLAI, AGED 36 YEARS, W/O. KRISHNAKUMAR, MANGALATH HOUSE, THEKKUMMURI, PERINGANADU P.O., PATHANAMTHITTA DISTRICT-689 645.

    2. JOINT REGISTRAR (GENERAL), CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES, MINI CIVIL STATION, PATHANAMTHITTA-689 645.

    3. KERALA CO-OPERATIVE SERVICE EXAMINATION BOARD, 2ND FLOOR, KERALA STATE CO-OPERATIVE BANK BUILDING, OVER BRIDGE JUNCTION, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY/CHAIRMAN, PIN-695 001. R1 BY ADV. SRI.RAJU JOSEPH (SR.) SRI.J.JULIAN XAVIER R3 BY ADV. SMT.S.L.SYLAJA, SC, CO-OPERATIVE SERVICE EXAMINATION BOARD R2 BY SMT. K.R.DEEPA, GOVERNMENT PLEADER THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 11-01-2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: P.N.RAVINDRAN, J & [C.R.] R.NARAYANA PISHARADI, J

    -------------------------------------------------------- W.A.No.2517 of 2015

    --------------------------------------------------------- Dated this the 11th day of January, 2018 JUDGMENT P.N.Ravindran, J The appellant is the second respondent in W.P.(C) No.19353 of 2015, a writ petition filed by the first respondent herein under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying for a writ in the nature of mandamus commanding the appellant bank to appoint her as Junior Clerk based on her rank in Ext.P2 rank list. By judgment delivered on 15.09.2015, the learned single judge allowed the writ petition. The appellant has, aggrieved thereby, filed this writ appeal. The brief facts of the case as follows:

    2. By a notification dated 21.11.2011, the appellant bank invited applications from eligible persons for appointment by direct recruitment to the post of Junior Clerk. The number of vacancies notified was 01. In terms of the stipulations contained in Section 80(B) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969, the Kerala Co-operative Service Examination Board, joined as the third respondent in the writ petition and in the writ appeal, conducted a written test on 16.06.2012 and forwarded a list of eligible candidates to the appellant bank for the purpose of conducting the interview. The appellant bank thereafter conducted an interview W.A.No.2517 of 2015 and published Ext.P2 rank list on 02.07.2013. The writ petitioner secured the second rank in the selection. From Ext.P2 rank list, Raji. S, the first rank holder was appointed as Junior Clerk by order passed on 05.08.2013 and she joined duty.

    3. Shortly after Ext.P2 rank list came into force, yet another vacancy of Junior Clerk arose in the appellant bank on 18.02.2014. The managing committee of the appellant bank that met on 29.07.2014 resolved to notify that vacancy and fill it up by appointing persons with disability. A notification inviting applications was also issued. On coming to know of the fact that a vacancy of Junior Clerk has arisen on 18.02.2014, the writ petitioner submitted Ext.P4 representation dated 13.05.2015 to the Joint Registrar of Co- operative Societies (General), Pathanamthitta (the first respondent in the writ petition), wherein, relying on the decision of the Division Bench of this court in Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Limited v. Neena (2010(1) KLT 541), she contended that she is entitled to be appointed as Junior Clerk in the vacancy that arose on 18.02.2014. She also contended that the decision taken by the Managing Committee on 29.07.2014 to fill up the vacancy by appointing persons with disability, after conducting a written test W.A.No.2517 of 2015 and interview is illegal. She thereafter submitted Ext.P5 representation dated 26.02.2015 to the Secretary and President of the appellant bank, wherein, relying on the decision of the Division Bench of this court in Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Limited v. Neena (supra) she requested that she may be appointed as Junior Clerk. She thereafter filed W.P.(C)No.19353 2015 in this court, seeking the following reliefs:

    i. To issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order or direction directing the 2 nd respondent to forthwith appoint the petitioner as junior clerk under the 2nd respondent in the light of her qualification and rank in the ranked list.

    ii. To issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ, order or direction directing the 1 st respondent to issue an order under Section 66A of the Co- operative Societies Act, 1969 (Kerala) appointing the petitioner as junior clerk under the 2nd respondent bank in the light of availability of the vacancy that has arisen during the validity of the ranked list.

    4. She contended that as a vacancy of Junior Clerk has come into existence on 18.02.2014, during the currency of the rank list, she is entitled to be appointed as Junior Clerk. The appellant bank resisted the writ petition by filing a counter affidavit dated 15.07.2015. Though the appellant bank admitted the fact that a W.A.No.2517 of 2015 vacancy of Junior Clerk has come into existence, it contended that it has taken a decision to fill up that vacancy by appointing persons with disability and has also taken steps to fill up that vacancy. The appellant bank also contended that this court has in Jayaprakash

    v. Joint Registrar (2013(4) KLT 788) declared that any society which employs more than 10 employees has to reserve the 11 th or the 12th post for persons with disability, if the said post is a post identified to be filled up by appointing persons with disability.

    5. The petitioner filed a reply affidavit dated 30.08.2015 wherein she contended that after Ext.P2 rank list was published, the appellant bank had taken steps to appoint 03 Peons and that it could have very well reserved one among the 03 vacancies of Peons to be filled up with a person having disability. She also referred to the fact that a person with disability has filed W.P.(C) No.18708 of 2014 and that the said writ petition is pending before this court.

    6. The learned single Judge considered the rival contentions and held by the impugned judgment that the petitioner is entitled to be appointed against the vacancy which arose on 18.02.2014 (wrongly referred to as 08.02.2014 in the impugned judgment) based on the rank assigned to her in Ext.P2 rank list. W.A.No.2517 of 2015 The second respondent in the writ petition has, as stated earlier, filed this writ appeal, aggrieved by the said judgment.

    7. We heard Sri.P.N.Mohanan, learned counsel for the appellant, Sri.Raju Joseph, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the first respondent/writ petitioner, Smt.Sri.K.R.Deepa, learned Senior Government Pleader appearing for the Joint Registrar of Co- operative Societies and Smt.S.L.Shylaja, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the third respondent. Sri.P.N.Mohanan, learned counsel for the appellant raised two main contentions. The first is that in the light of the decision of the Apex Court in Kodakara Farmers Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Neena [2013(1) KLT 344] whereby the decision of the Division Bench of this court in Kodakara Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Neena [2010(1) KLT 541] was reversed, the writ petitioner cannot contend for the position that the rank list is valid and current for a period of two years or that it does not cease to operate when the notified vacancies are filled up. The second contention raised is that unlike the Kerala Public Service Commission (hereinafter referred to as the Commission for short) which is mandated by Rule 14 of the Kerala Public Service Commission Rules of Procedure to advise W.A.No.2517 of 2015 candidates against the vacancies reported during the currency of the ranked list, there is no provision in the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1968 (hereinafter referred to as the Act for short) or the Rules framed thereunder, which obliges the appellant bank to fill up all the vacancies that arise during the currency of the rank list, in addition to the vacancies mentioned in the notification inviting applications.

    8. It is not in dispute that the rank list has a validity period of two years. Rule 182(4)(vii) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 (the Rules for short) stipulates that the list shall be valid for a period of two years from the date of its publication by the society. The very same rule also mandates the publication of the rank list within twenty days from the date of receipt of the consolidated mark list. Rule 182(4)(vii) of the Rules also obliges the society to make appointments from the rank list so published, within one month from the date of such publication and report to the Examination Board. Rule 182(4) of the Rules reads as follows:- (4) In respect of recruitment to societies covered by Section 80B of the Act, the following procedure shall be followed:-

    (i) The Society shall report the vacancy to the Co-operative Service Examination Board and the applications for appointment shall be invited by the Co-operative Service Examination Board, by notification in two vernacular dailies, W.A.No.2517 of 2015 having wide circulation in the area. The notification shall include the details of number of vacancies, qualifications required for the post, age and reservation, if any, the mode of application, method of appointment and other required details. The Co-operative Service Examination Board may collect application fee along with the application at the rate fixed by the Registrar of Co-operative Societies from time to time. The Examination Board shall process the applications and prepare the list of candidates to be called for the written test. One copy of the prepared list shall be published in the notice board of the Examination Board and one copy shall be sent to the society for publication in its notice board. The society shall publish it in the notice board and copies thereof in the branch offices of the society. The arrangements for the written test shall be made by the Examination Board.

    (ii) The Examination Board shall conduct the written examination of the candidates and furnish a list of eligible candidates to be interviewed to the committee of the society within a period of three months from the date of requisition by the society. The list so furnished shall not contain the mark secured by the candidates;

    (iii) The maximum marks for written examination shall be

    80 and those who secure 40% of the marks shall only be eligible to be included in the list for interview; Provided that in case of candidates belonging to Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe, those who secure 30% of marks and above shall be included in the list. Provided further that the total number of candidates to be called for interview shall be ten times the number of posts W.A.No.2517 of 2015 advertised to be filled up in each category. If there are more candidates who secure not less than forty per cent marks in the written examination and if the candidate who secured forty per cent or above marks are less than ten times as above, all of the candidates shall be called for interview.

    (iv) The maximum marks for interview shall be 15; Provided that the minimum marks for interview shall be 3. (iv A) Candidates of home district shall be awarded 5 marks over and above the marks for interview as grace marks. Explanation.- For the purpose of this item, candidates of home district means the candidates belonging to the district or districts to which the area of operation of the society extends.

    (v) On receipt of the list from the Examination Board, the committee shall conduct interview of the candidates within two months from the date of such receipt and return the list to the Examination Board noting the marks secured by each candidates, in the interview within a period of two weeks;

    (vi) On receipt of the list from the society, the Examination Board shall note down the marks secured by each of the candidate in written examination and return consolidated list with the total marks obtained by each candidate. This shall be done within a period of one week.

    (vii) On the basis of the consolidated list so received from the Examination Board, the committee shall prepare the rank list of candidates and publish the same in the notice board of the society within a period of twenty days from the date of receipt of such consolidated mark list. The society shall send one copy of the rank list so published to the Examination Board also. The Board shall examine the correctness of such rank list and W.A.No.2517 of 2015 report to the Registrar, the irregularities, if any. The list shall be valid for a period of two years from the date of publication of the same by the society.

    (viii) All appointments to the vacancies shall be made by the committee from the select list so published; within one month from the date of such publication and shall be reported to the Examination Board.

    (ix) Expenses, if any, incurred over and above the fees collected by the Examination Board, shall be borne by the society concerned.b

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pannivizha Service Co-Operaive Bank Ltd. v. Smitha T. Pillai
    (Jan 11, 2018)