AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

M/s. Sharma Fabricators & Erectors Pvt. Ltd. (“M/s. Sharma”) was registered for Service Tax under Registration No. AADCS2882AST001, engaged in Erection, Commissioning & Installation Services. They undertook dismantling of a paper plant in a foreign country and its erection in India, filing Service Tax Returns as required. During an audit from 2-2-2009 to 4-2-2009, discrepancies were found between amounts paid to M/s. Sharma as per TDS Certificates under Section 203 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and the taxable values declared in their ST-3 returns for January 2004 to March 2008. The amounts received per TDS Certificates totaled Rs. 45,94,48,238, while declared taxable value was Rs. 22,01,75,988. Consequently, a Show Cause Notice dated 20-4-2009 alleged short payment of Service Tax amounting to Rs. 2,67,78,854 under the extended proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994.

A second Show Cause Notice dated 13-10-2009 was issued after audit findings for the financial year 2008-09, alleging that M/s. Sharma declared a taxable value of Rs. 17,81,03,827 against Rs. 25,20,59,862 as per TDS Certificates, resulting in short payment of Service Tax of Rs. 91,40,965. Both notices were contested by M/s. Sharma, who argued discrepancies between TDS Certificate figures and actual consideration received, and challenged the limitation period applicability.

The Original Authority decided both notices together by Order-in-Original Nos. (S. Tax-36 & 57/09) 17 & 18 of 2010 dated 31-3-2010, confirming Service Tax demand of Rs. 1,16,64,955 and setting aside demand of Rs. 2,42,54,864, along with penalty imposition. M/s. Sharma appealed against the confirmation, and Revenue appealed against the setting aside of demand, resulting in two appeals: ST/890/2010 by M/s. Sharma and ST/949/2010 by Revenue.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Show Cause Notices issued to M/s. Sharma based on TDS Certificates without examination of their books of account are sustainable for recovery of alleged short paid Service Tax.
  2. Whether the demand of Service Tax confirmed by the Original Authority is justified, and the demand set aside is correctly decided.
  3. Whether the Show Cause Notices are barred by limitation.
  4. Whether reliance on third party TDS Certificates without verifying actual consideration received is legally valid for assessing Service Tax liability.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (M/s. Sharma) Arguments

  • The Show Cause Notices were issued without examining the books of account maintained by M/s. Sharma and were based on presumptions and third party information.
  • Clients may have booked expenses and deducted tax at source even if payments were not actually made, so TDS Certificates cannot be the sole basis for assessing consideration received.
  • The actual consideration received by M/s. Sharma during the relevant period was different from amounts reflected in TDS Certificates, which should be the basis for taxable value.
  • Elaborate explanations were provided before the Original Authority for discrepancies between TDS Certificate figures and declared taxable values.
  • The first Show Cause Notice dated 20-4-2009 was barred by limitation.
  • Reliance was placed on the Tribunal’s Final Order in Alpa Management Consultants P. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Bangalore holding that demands solely based on income-tax returns for Service Tax liability under the Finance Act, 1994, are unsustainable.
  • Regarding Revenue’s appeal, grounds raised went beyond the scope of the Show Cause Notices and were therefore unsustainable.
  • Cargo handling was introduced by Revenue as a ground of appeal but was not dealt with in the Show Cause Notices.

Respondent's (Revenue) Arguments

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Alpa Management Consultants P. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Bangalore Demands based solely on income-tax returns for Service Tax liability under the Finance Act, 1994 are not sustainable. The court relied on this precedent to support the argument that TDS Certificates and related income-tax returns cannot be the sole basis for Service Tax demands without examining the assessee's books of account.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court observed that neither of the two Show Cause Notices dated 20-4-2009 and 13-10-2009 reflected any examination of the books of account maintained by M/s. Sharma to determine the value of consideration received. The notices were primarily based on a draft audit report and third party information (TDS Certificates). The court emphasized that the purpose of an audit report is to highlight discrepancies for further examination by the executive authorities, who must then verify the facts and records before issuing a Show Cause Notice. This essential step of scrutinizing the assessee’s books of account and records was missing.

The court held that charges in a Show Cause Notice must be founded on the assessee’s books of account and other admissible evidence, not merely on presumptions or third party documents. Since the books of account were not examined, the court found the Show Cause Notices unsustainable. This absence of a proper factual basis and failure to consider the assessee’s records undermined the validity of the tax demands.

Accordingly, the court allowed M/s. Sharma’s appeal and dismissed Revenue’s appeal, disposing of associated miscellaneous applications and cross objections as well.

Holding and Implications

The court held that the Show Cause Notices issued to M/s. Sharma without examination of their books of account are not sustainable. Consequently, appeal No. ST/890/2010 filed by M/s. Sharma was allowed, and appeal No. ST/949/2010 filed by Revenue was dismissed.

The direct effect of this decision is the quashing of the Service Tax demands based solely on TDS Certificates without proper audit of the assessee’s records. No new precedent was established beyond reinforcing the principle that tax demands must be supported by examination of the assessee’s books of account and admissible evidence rather than presumptions or third party documents.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sharma Fabricators & Erectors Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise

    [Order per : Anil G. Shakkarwar, Member (T)]. - Above stated two appeals are arising out of common impugned Order-in-Original No. (S. Tax-36 & 57/09)17 & 18 of 2010, dated 31-3-2010 passed by Commissioner of Central Excise & Service Tax, Allahabad.

    2. The brief facts of the case are that M/s. Sharma Fabricators & Erectors Pvt. Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “M/s. Sharma”) were registered with the Department for payment of Service Tax under Registration No. AADCS2882AST001 and were engaged in the service category of Erection, Commissioning & Installation Services. M/s. Sharma used to undertake dismantling of paper plant in foreign country and Erection, Commissioning & Installation of the same in the taxable territory [of] India. They used to file their Service Tax Returns as provided by law. During the course of audit of the records conducted from 2-2-2009 to 4-2-2009, the audit team noticed that taking into account the amounts as indicated to have been paid to M/s. Sharma by the customers/clients as per the certificate of deduction of charts at source under Section 203 of Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short “TDS Certificate”) the amount received by M/s. Sharma during the period from January, 2004 to March, 2008 amounted to Rs. 45,94,48,238/- whereas total taxable value declared by M/s. Sharma during the said period was totalling up to Rs. 22,01,75,988/-. Therefore, M/s. Sharma were issued with a Show Cause Notice dated 20-4-2009 wherein it was alleged that M/s. Sharma short paid Service Tax as reflected in ST-3 returns to the tune of Rs. 2,67,78,854/-. Therefore, M/s. Sharma were called upon to show cause as to why Service Tax amounting to Rs. 2,67,78,854/- should not be recovered from them under the extended proviso to sub-section (1) of Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994. The said Show Cause Notice has listed the documents relied upon for issue of Show Cause Notice as (1) copy of the draft Audit Report for the period January, 2004 to March, 2008, (2) letter dated 25-3-2009 of M/s. Sharma along with enclosures & (3) Annexure - ‘A’ which was as follows :-

    Period (TDS Income) payment received (Rs.) Taxable value realized as per ST-3 (Rs.) Difference (Rs.) S. Tax (Rs.) Ed. Cess (Rs.) S. H. E. Cess (Rs.)
    Jan, 04 to Mar, 04 2,92,70,667 --- (-) 2,92,70,667 23,41,652 --- ---
    2004-05 1,68,38,247 7,73,850 (-) 1,60,64,397 6,36,459 8,10,866 16,217 ---
    2005-06 10,05,45,110 1,93,53,397 (+) 3,93,28,089 (5,86,81,486) (-) 4,18,63,624 41,86,362 83,727 ---
    2006-07 13,35,38,417 2,01,15,033 (+) 3,60,79,515 (5,61,94,548) (-) 7,73,43,869 92,81,264 1,85,625 ---
    2007-08 17,92,55,797 5,70,30,582 (+) 4,74,94,792 (10,45,25,374) (-) 7,47,30,423 89,67,651 1,79,353 89,677
    Total 45,94,48,238 22,01,75,258 23,92,72,980 2,62,24,255 4,64,922 89,677

    M/s. Sharma were issued with another Show Cause Notice dated 13-10-2009 wherein it was mentioned that on examination of records during the course of audit of the unit conducted by the Officers of Central Excise Commissionerate, Allahabad it was noticed that as per certificate of deduction of Service Tax under Section 203 of Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short “TDS Certificate”) issued by the clients during the financial year, M/s. Sharma were paid the amount which were more than the taxable value declared to have been received by M/s. Sharma in the ST-3 returns submitted. It was further alleged that M/s. Sharma mis-declared the taxable value in the ST-3 returns and they did not pay Service Tax that duty to be paid by them on the basis of actual amount received by them. The said Show Cause Notice dated 13-10-2009 stated that computation of amount from the details submitted by M/s. Sharma through letter dated 10-9-2009 it appeared to Revenue that M/s. Sharma had received total taxable amount of Rs. 25,20,59,862/- during the financial year 2008-09 but declared the taxable value as Rs. 17,81,03,827/- in the ST-3 returns filed during the year. Therefore, it was alleged that on the basis of TDS Certificate issued by the clients of M/s. Sharma, the taxable amount that M/s. Sharma received was Rs. 25,20,59,862/- but they have declared less value and short paid Service Tax. Therefore, through the said Show Cause Notice dated 13-10-2009 M/s. Sharma were called upon to show cause as to why Service Tax amounting to Rs. 91,40,965/- should not be recovered from them. The relied upon documents for issue of said Show Cause Notice were stated to be (1) Letter dated 29-5-2009 & 16-7-2009 issued by the Range Superintendent, (2) Letter dated 10-9-2009 & details dated 21/22-9-2009 submitted by M/s. Sharma & (3) Sample copy of the invoice issued by M/s. Sharma & the corresponding TDS Certificate issued by clients of M/s. Sharma. Both the said Show Cause Notices were contested by M/s. Sharma. M/s. Sharma elaborately explained the reasons for difference in the taxable value arrived at on the basis of TDS Certificate issued by the third party and actual consideration received by them. They further contested that the first Show Cause Notice dated 20-4-2009 was hit by limitation. The Original Authority decided the said two Show Cause Notices together through Order-in-Original Nos. (S. Tax-36 & 57/09) 17 & 18 of 2010, dated 31-3-2010. The Original Authority confirmed the demand of Service Tax of Rs. 1,16,64,955/- and set aside the demand of Service Tax amounting to Rs. 2,42,54,864/-. The Original Authority also imposed penalty. M/s. Sharma was aggrieved by the said confirmation of demand of Service Tax of Rs. 1,16,64,955/- and Revenue was aggrieved by setting aside the demand of Service Tax amounting to Rs. 2,42,54,864/-. Therefore, M/s. Sharma filed appeal bearing No. ST/890/2010 and Revenue filed appeal bearing No. ST/949/2010.

    3. Heard the ld. Counsel for M/s. Sharma he has basically argued that the said Show Cause Notices were not issued by examining the books of account maintained by M/s. Sharma. The Show Cause Notices were based on the presumptions and third party information. He has argued that even when the payments were not made by the clients but the clients booked the expenditure in their books of account they were required to pay the related tax deducted at source to the exchequer and issue a certificate of TDS and incorporate the same in the return called 26AS filed with the Income Tax Authorities and such information cannot be the basis for arrival of the consideration received by the service provider. He has submitted that both the Show Cause Notices were issued without examining the books of account maintained by M/s. Sharma and were issued on the basis of presumptions about the consideration received by M/s. Sharma. The considerations taken into account for issue of Show Cause Notices was in no way near to the actual consideration received by M/s. Sharma during the relevant period which should be the basis for arriving at the assessable value. He has stated that they had elaborated before the Original Authority various reasons for discrepancies in the figures arrived at presuming the considerations received by M/s. Sharma on the basis of such TDS Certificates and the figures in the returns. He has further relied upon this Tribunal’s Final Order in the case of Alpa Management Consultants P. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Service Tax, Bangalore reported in (Tri. - Bangalore). He submitted that this Tribunal in the said case has held that demands, solely based on the income-tax returns for liability of Service Tax under Finance Act, 1994 is not sustainable. In respect of appeal filed by Revenue ld. counsel for M/s. Sharma has contended that the grounds of appeal are travelling beyond the Show Cause Notice and therefore that is not sustainable. He has further elaborated that cargo handling was brought in as ground by Revenue in the appeal filed by Revenue whereas that issue was not at all dealt with in the Show Cause Notices dated 20-4-2009 & 13-10-2009.

    4. Heard the ld. DR, who has presented the grounds of appeal in appeal filed by Revenue.

    5. Having considered the rival contentions and on perusal of record, we find that in the cases of both the Show Cause Notices dated 20-4-2009 & 13-10-2009 there is no whisper of examination of books of account maintained by M/s. Sharma to arrive at the value of consideration received by them. Surprisingly the draft audit report was the relied upon document. It may be worth mentioning here that the purpose of audit report is to point out any discrepancy to the notice for examination by the executive and it is the duty of executive to examine the records and examine the objection raised with reference to the records and facts of the case and take a view whether there is a sustainable case for issue of Show Cause Notice. Such vital aspects of framing of charges have been missing in the present case. The charges in the Show Cause Notice have to be on the basis of books of account and records maintained by the assessee and other admissible evidence. The books of account maintained by M/s. Sharma were not looked into for issue of abovestated two Show Cause Notices. Therefore, the transactions recorded in the books of account cannot be held to be contrary to the facts. Therefore, we hold that the said Show Cause Notices are not sustainable. Since the said Show Cause Notices are not sustainable, appeal bearing No. ST/890/2010 filed by M/s. Sharma is allowed and appeal bearing No. ST/949/2010 filed by Revenue is dismissed. Miscellaneous Applications also stand disposed of. Cross Objection also disposed of.

    (Dictated and pronounced in Court)

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sharma Fabricators & Erectors Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Central Excise
    (Jun 14, 2017)