AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Royal Twinkle Star Club Private Ltd. v. Securities & Exchange Board Of India

    33. When we apply the ratio of the aforesaid judgment to the facts of the present case, it becomes difficult to accept the argument of the learned ASG. In the first instance, we may point out that no such case was set up by the respondents that by omitting to state the proposed action of blacklisting, the appellant in the show cause notice has not caused any prejudice to the appellant. Moreover, had the action of black listing being specifically proposed in the show cause notice, the appellant could have mentioned as to why such extreme penalty is not justified. It could have come out with extenuating circumstances defending such an action even if the defaults were there and the Department was not satisfied with the explanation qua the defaults. It could have even pleaded with the Department not to blacklist the appellant or do it for a lesser period in case the Department still wanted to black list the appellant. Therefore, it is not at all acceptable that non mentioning of proposed blacklisting in the show cause notice has not caused any prejudice to the appellant. This apart, the extreme nature of such a harsh penalty like blacklisting with severe consequences, would itself amount to causing prejudice to the appellant.

    17. The above analysis of Gorkha Security Services Ltd. clearly reveals that the ratio of the said judgment is an advancement on existing jurisprudence relating of the principles of natural justice. The concept of principles of natural justice in the matter of granting effective and proper opportunity to an entity against whom an extreme order of blacklisting or debarment, as in the case in hand, is likely to be passed for a specific period. After a detailed analysis of the jurisprudence on the subject, the Honble Supreme Court has categorically held that to fulfill the requirement of principles of natural justice, a show-cause notice should meet the following:-

    (i) The material/grounds to be stated which according to the department necessitates an action;

    (ii) Particular penalty/action which is proposed to be taken. It is this second requirement which the High Court has failed to omit. -15- We may hasten to add that even if it is not specifically mentioned in the show- cause notice but it can clearly and safely be discerned from the reading thereof, that would be sufficient to meet this requirement.

    18. Undoubtedly, there is power vested in the Respondent by Regulation

    65 of CIS Regulations to, inter alia, debar an entity from entering the market. No period is prescribed. Therefore, in all fairness, while issuing the SCN, the Respondent should have mentioned the maximum period for which entity could also be debarred, in case the charge was proved. However, applicability of the judgment of Honble Supreme Court in the case of Gorkha to the facts of present case need not be gone into because, Counsel for the Appellants in order to put an end to the controversy, fairly stated before us, that even if the schemes operated by the Appellants are held to be CIS, in view of the fact that the Appellants have stopped enrolling new members from 31/3/2012 and the directors of RTSCL have already undergone debarment from the date of impugned order till date, in the facts of present case, where, except for registration the schemes were carried on in accordance with law, this Tribunal be pleased to restrict the debarment till date, so that the directors of RTSCL who are also directors of CCIL can continue with the schemes operated by CCIL by seeking registration from SEBI under the CIS Regulations.

    19. Thus, the time sharing schemes initiated by RTSCL on 6/5/2008 had already been closed on 31/3/2012 long before issuance of the show-cause notice dated 7th March, 2014. Appellant has not enrolled a single new member after 31/3/2012 in any of the erstwhile schemes run by RTSCL. However, we also note that the Appellants went on collecting equated monthly installments from the members enrolled prior to 31/3/2012 and on 9/6/2014 -16- addressed a letter to that effect to SEBI. Admittedly, this letter remained unanswered by the Respondent. Further, during the course of hearing we directed the Appellant to submit to SEBI a complete list of its members as also the balance amount refundable to the members. The same was promptly done by the Appellant with various details of its members/customers. SEBI selected about 500 members and verified from them about the conduct of the Appellant in the matter of repayment to them. Learned Senor Counsel Shri Sen fairly submitted before us that no negative comments were received from the people which could be contacted by the SEBI. Therefore, the conduct of the Appellants seems to be good. Similarly, the Appellants have filed an affidavit before the Court categorically stating that the remaining likely contractual liability to repay to those customers who dont want to avail of the holiday facility in their resorts, hotels and restaurants, etc., an amount of Rs.786 crore is due to be paid to such customers. Whereas, the Appellant, as on the date of affidavit, has got assets worth Rs.1421 crore.

    20. Considering the above facts and respective submissions of the parties, we are inclined to extend the time to the Appellant to repay the dues to its members on account of its contractual obligations for a period of 24 months from the date of this order. In the meanwhile, the Appellant shall not encumber or dispose of its assets except for the purpose of making payment of dues to its members and/or running its routine business. During this period of 24 months, the Appellant shall be entitled to continue to receive EMIs from the willing members as per the contract for availing facility of time sharing schemes in question. -17-

    21. To sum up, the decision of SEBI that the schemes floated and operated by the Appellants constituted CIS and operating such schemes without seeking registration was in violation of CIS Regulations cannot be faulted. Admittedly, the said schemes have been closed with effect from 31/3/2012. No doubt that the Appellants while not admitting new subscribers were not justified in collecting the equated monthly installment from the members who had subscribed to the schemes prior to 31/3/2012. However, it is on record that in reply to the ex-parte order cum show-cause notice dated 7/3/2014 the Appellants by letter dated 9/6/2014 had intimated the same to SEBI, but SEBI did not consider it necessary to stop the Appellants from collecting the subscription amount from the members who had subscribed to the schemes prior to 31/3/2012. Instead of directing the Appellants to stop collecting equated monthly installments, the WTM of SEBI, by the impugned order dated 21/8/2015 had directed SEBI to look into the matter. Be that as it may. It must be told to the credit of the Appellants that on our pointing out that the collection of subscription amount after the ex-parte interim order was improper, the Appellants have immediately stopped collecting the subscription amount from the subscribers who has subscribed to the schemes prior to 31/3/2012. Therefore, we rest this matter here itself. Further, it is relevant to note that apart from the fact that the CIS schemes were floated and operated without seeking registration under the CIS Regulations, there is nothing on record to suggest that the schemes operated by the Appellants were detrimental to the interests of the investors. Moreover, it is a matter of record that after 31/3/2012, the Appellants have refunded substantial amounts to the investors and the Appellants have submitted that the balance amount -18- of (approx) Rs.786 crore (subject to redeeming the points under the holiday plans) would be refunded to the investors within a period of two years.

    22. In these circumstances, while upholding the decision of SEBI that the Appellants have floated and operated CIS without registering with SEBI and hence in violation of CIS Regulations, since the schemes are closed by the Appellants voluntarily and substantial amount is refunded to the investors, we grant extension of two years time from the date of this order to the Appellants to enable them to pay the balance amount refundable to the investors. Looking to the conduct of the Appellants before and after 31/3/2012 which is fair, we restrict the debarment imposed against the directors from the date of the impugned order i.e. from 21st August, 2015 till the date of present order.

    23. Both the Appeals are disposed of in the above terms with no order as to costs. Sd/- Justice J.P. Devadhar Presiding Officer Sd/- Jog Singh Member 03/02/2016 Prepared & compared by-ddg

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Royal Twinkle Star Club Private Ltd. v. Securities & Exchange Board Of India
    (Feb 3, 2016)