Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Registration Act, 1908 of the Tamil Nadu Registration Rules, 1983
  • Section 81 or 82 of the Registration Act, 1908
  • SECTION 71 REGISTRATION ACT
  • Registration Act, 1908 and the Rules
  • Rule 55 of the Registration Rules
  • Section 5 of Patta Pass Book Act,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Registration Act, 1908 of the Tamil Nadu Registration Rules, 1983
  • Section 81 or 82 of the Registration Act, 1908
  • SECTION 71 REGISTRATION ACT
  • Registration Act, 1908 and the Rules
  • Rule 55 of the Registration Rules
  • Section 5 of Patta Pass Book Act,
Smart Summary

Legal Opinion Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to quash Check Slip No.3 of 2018 dated 09.05.2018 issued by the Sub Registrar and to direct registration and delivery of a sale deed dated 09.05.2018 in the petitioner's favour.

Relevant facts (as stated in the opinion): the petitioner intended to purchase a property of 2970 square feet (S.F.No.3/1) in Kanchanayakkanpatti Village, Aruppukottai Taluk, Virudhunagar District from one S. Selvi (wife of Late Shanmugasubramanian). The vendor had mortgaged the property to R.S. Ashok for Rs.4,80,000/-, and the original parent document of title (the sale deed by which the vendor acquired title) had been handed over to the mortgagee. The petitioner obtained a sale deed dated 09.05.2018 from S. Selvi; that deed recorded that part of the sale consideration (an amount equivalent to the mortgage with interest) was retained by the petitioner to enable redemption of the mortgage.

When the petitioner presented the 09.05.2018 sale deed for registration, the Sub Registrar initially accepted the document but returned the original sale deed with the impugned check slip dated 09.05.2018, on the ground that the petitioner had not produced the original parent document (a sale deed dated 02.12.2009). The petitioner challenged that direction by filing the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Registering Officer (Sub Registrar) has the statutory power under the Registration Act, 1908 and the Rules framed thereunder to refuse or return a document for registration on the sole ground of non-production of the original parental (earlier) document.
  2. Whether executive instructions/circulars (specifically the Inspector General of Registration circular dated 25.04.2012) can lawfully compel production of original parent documents for registration when the Registration Act and Rules do not expressly require such production.
  3. Whether, on the facts of this case (where the original parent document is with a mortgagee and part consideration is retained to redeem the mortgage), the Sub Registrar's direction to resubmit with the original parent document was sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Registering Officer has no power under the Registration Act, 1908 or the Rules to return or refuse registration on the ground that the original parental document has not been produced.
  • The original title document is in the custody of the mortgagee and cannot be produced unless the mortgage is redeemed; the sale deed dated 09.05.2018 itself records that the petitioner retained an amount to enable redemption.
  • The circular of the Inspector General of Registration (dated 25.04.2012) is only a guideline and has no force of law to expand the Registering Officer's statutory jurisdiction; reliance was placed on earlier decisions of the Court (Lakshmi Ammal and K.S. Vijayendran) supporting this proposition.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent relied on the circular dated 25.04.2012 which directs Sub Registrars to verify and, where appropriate, insist on production of previous original deeds to prevent fraudulent registration.
  • However, the respondent's counsel conceded before the Court that the legal position reiterated by this Court in previous judgments was not followed by the Registering Officer, and that the Registering Officer in this case had no authority to return the document for production of the original title deed based solely on the circular.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lakshmi Ammal Vs. The Sub Registrar, Chennai and another (CDJ 2015 MCH 5710) Held that the Registrar cannot refuse to register a document solely because the original parental deed was not produced; a circular cannot impose a requirement not found in the Registration Act. The Court relied on this authority to conclude that the circular of 25.04.2012 cannot be used to insist on production of original parent documents where the Act and Rules do not require it, and thus the check slip was unsustainable.
K.S. Vijayendran Vs. The Inspector General of Registration and another (2011 (2) LW 648) Held that none of the provisions of the Registration Act or Rules contemplate the Registrar requiring production of original title deeds; the scope of the Registering Officer's enquiry is limited to the statutory provisions and cannot be expanded to conduct a roving inquiry into title. The Court applied the principles in this case to hold the Registering Officer exceeded jurisdiction by returning the deed for want of the parent document and reiterated that the authority to refuse registration must be found in the Act or Rules, not in administrative circulars.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by examining the statutory scope of the Registering Officer's powers under the Registration Act, 1908 and the Rules (including the Tamil Nadu Registration Rules, 1983). The Court observed:

  1. The Registration Act and Rules do not contemplate or confer power on the Registering Officer to insist on production of the original parent document as a condition precedent for registering a subsequent deed; therefore, returning the document on that ground was without statutory authority.
  2. Administrative circulars, such as the Inspector General's circular dated 25.04.2012, are only guidelines and cannot override or expand the statutory scheme established by the Act and the Rules. The circular cannot, by itself, create a legal requirement to produce original parental documents when none exists in the statute or Rules.
  3. The scope of inquiry by the Registering Officer is limited by statute. A broader, roving inquiry into title would adversely affect parties' rights to deal with property as provided by law. Only in exceptional cases—for example, where fraud or public policy concerns arise, or where proceedings are initiated under specific statutory provisions such as Sections 81 or 82—might the officer entertain extended verification. The Court found that this case did not present such exceptional circumstances.
  4. On the facts, the sale deed was executed by a person who had the recorded title and the patta stood in the vendor's name (and Section 5 of the Patta Pass Book Act requires production of the patta). The petitioner had produced xerox copies of the mortgage deed and previous sale deeds, and had retained part of the consideration to redeem the mortgage; thereby production of the original parent document was not possible without redemption.
  5. The Court characterized the impugned check slip and the Sub Registrar's direction—based on the circular—as arbitrary and unsustainable because they lacked any foundation in the Registration Act or Rules. The Court noted that the circular itself contained exceptions (for example, dispensing with production where original is lost or permitting registration on certified copies in certain cases), which further indicated that the circular could not supply an independent statutory power to refuse registration.
  6. Applying the legal principles from earlier decisions of this Court (as cited), the Court concluded that the Sub Registrar had acted beyond his statutory authority in returning the deed for want of the original parent document and that the check slip must be quashed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The impugned check slip dated 09.05.2018 (Check Slip No.3 of 2018) issued by the Sub Registrar, Aruppukkottai, is quashed. The respondent is directed to accept the sale deed dated 09.05.2018 from the petitioner and register the same without insisting on production of the original parent document (sale deed dated 02.12.2009). Connected miscellaneous petitions are closed. No costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The Sub Registrar must register the sale deed dated 09.05.2018 and release it to the petitioner notwithstanding non-production of the earlier parent document that is in possession of the mortgagee.
  • The opinion reiterates the court's prior view that administrative circulars cannot expand the statutory powers of Registering Officers under the Registration Act and Rules; however, the opinion does not purport to authoritatively state that it establishes a new, distinct precedent beyond the principles already relied upon from earlier decisions mentioned in the judgment.

This summary is based exclusively on the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add facts or inferences beyond that text.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    C. Moorthy v. Sub Registrar, Aruppukkottai .

    This writ petition has been filed for issuance of a Writ of Certiorarified Mandamus to quash the Check Slip bearing No.3 of 2018, dated 09.05.2018, issued by respondent and to direct the respondent to register the sale deed dated 09.05.2018 and release the same to the petitioner. 2.The brief facts that are necessary for disposal of the writ petition, are as follows: 2.1. The petitioner wanted to purchase some property measuring to an extent of 2970 square feet in S.F.No.3/1 in Kanchanayakkanpatti Village Aruppukottai Taluk, Virudhunagar District, which belong to one S.Selvi wife of Late.Shanmugasubramanian. After verifiying the fact that the petitioner's vendor had mortgaged the property to one R.S.Ashok, Son of R.Sankara Raja for a sum of Rs.4,80,000/-, the petitioner obtained sale deed from the said Selvi on 09.05.2018. 2.2.It is pertinent to mention that the original sale deed, by which the petitioner's vendor got title (sale deed dated 17.09.2012) was handed over to the mortgagee. After referring to the fact that the mortgage deed had already been executed in favour of the said R.S.Ashok and that the original parent document of title of his vendor was with to the mortgagee, the petitioner obtained the sale deed from his vendor on 09.05.2018. The sale deed dated 09.05.2018 also refers to the fact that the sum equivalent to the mortgage amount with interest accrued is retained by the petitioner for the redemption of the mortgage by the petitioner. 2.3.The petitioner presented the sale dated 09.05.2018 for registration. After accepting the document for registration, the Sub Registrar, Aruppukkottai returned the original sale deed along with the impugned check slip dated 09.05.2018, for the reason that the petitioner had not produced the original parent document. The order of the Sub Registrar, Aruppukkottai, directing the petitioner to resubmit the document with the original document of sale dated 02.12.2009, is challenged in the present writ petition. 3.The learned Counsel for the petitioner submitted that the Registering Officer has no power to return the document for non production of parental document, as the Registration Act, 1908 and the Rules framed thereunder do not contemplate production of original parent documents for registering any subsequent deed of conveyance. The learned Counsel for the petitioner further submitted that the original document of title is available with the mortgagee and the petitioner can get the document only after redemption of the mortgage. This is revealed even from the recitals of the sale deed dated 09.05.2018 executed in favour of the petitioner.

    4. When the petitioner obtained sale deed on 09.05.2018, he has retained a part of the sale consideration for the purpose of discharge of mortgage loan. Hence, it is not possible for the petitioner to get the original document and the impugned order and the direction of the Registering Officer in the impugned order, cannot be complied with by the petitioner. In this regard, the learned Counsel for the petitioner also relied upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Lakshmi Ammal Vs.The Sub Registrar, Chennai and another, reported in CDJ 2015 MCH 5710, wherein a Hon'ble single Judge of this Court has held as follows: ?7.Now, the question that arises for consideration is, whether the first respondent can refuse to register the document on the ground that the original parental deed has not been produced before him. Section 71 of the Registration Act, 1998 (herein after called as the Act), contemplates that the Registrar can refuse to register the document giving reasons for refusal. Nowhere in the Registration Act, it contemplates that the Registrar can insist for production of the original parental document. When the Act does not contemplate so, the first respondent cannot insist the petitioner to produce the same. However, the first respondent seems to have relied on the circular of the Inspector General of Registration dated 25.04.2012, in and by which the Inspector General of Registration has given several instructions to the Sub Registrar and one of the instructions is that he shall require the parties to produce he original parental documents. The circular can only be a guideline and it has no force in law. Unless otherwise, such requirement is made under the Registration Act, the guideline alone, without any provisions in the Act, has any role to play. In fact, the said view was taken by this Court in the judgment reported in 2011-2-L.W.648, K.S.Vijayendran Vs.The Inspector General of Registration and another.? 5.The learned Counsel for the petitioner also relied upon the judgment of this Court dated 18.03.2011, in the case of K.S.Vijayendran Vs. The Inspector General of Registration and another, reported in 2011 (2) LW 648, wherein this Court has held that none of the provisions of the Act or the Rules contemplate the Registrar to require the production of original title deeds. Further, it has been held as follows: ? 11. A close reading of the Act as well as the Rules, elicited above, shows that the reason which has been made out by the registering authority for refusing the registration does not find place either under the Act or the Rules. The scope of enquiry by the registering authority is restricted only as per the statutory provisions enunciated under the Act as well as the Rules framed thereunder and the authority cannot do anything which is contrary to the provisions of the Statute. 12.On the facts of the present case, when the petitioner, being the husband, seeks to execute settlement deed in favour of his wife, it is not for the registering authority to satisfy himself about the ownership and right of the petitioner over the property to enable him to execute the settlement deed. Such power can never be construed to be vested on the registering authority either under the Act or the Rules or even as per the circular of the first respondent dated 12.09.2010, which only clarifies about the power of enquiry under Rule 55 of the Registration Rules in order to avoid registration of bogus documents. Thus, looking from any angle, I am of the considered view that the reasons given by the second respondent for not registering the document are untenable under any of the provisions of the Act. There is absolutely no reason for not registering the document which has been presented by the petitioner.? 6.The learned Counsel for the respondent fairly conceded that the legal position reiterated by this Court in several judgments have not been followed and that the Registering Officer in this case has no authority to return the document for production of original document of title based on the circular, as the same circular was earlier considered by this Court in the judgment cited by the learned Counsel for the petitioner. As held by this Court earlier, there is no provision in the Registration Act, 1908 of the Tamil Nadu Registration Rules, 1983 which confers power to the Registering Officers to insist production of original parental document. The Executive orders cannot be issued contrary to Rules framed in exercise of power conferred any Statute. In this case production of parent document is not possible without redemption of mortgage. 7.Having regard to the scope of enquiry that is contemplated under Registration Act, Registrar cannot conduct any roving enquiry to the title, as that would lead to unwanted situations affecting the rights of parties to deal with their party in the manner prescribed in law. It may be open to the Registering Officer to insist in certain exceptional or peculiar circumstances, where an objection is raised on the ground that the particular transaction is fraudulent or opposed to public policy. This is not a case where a proceeding is initiated either under Section 81 or 82 of the Registration Act, 1908 or the transaction can be termed as one against public policy. 8.Having regard to the fact that the sale deed is executed by the person who has valid title and patta stands in the name of the petitioner's vendor, which is required to be produced before the Registrar in terms of Section 5 of Patta Pass Book Act, the impugned check slip is arbitrary, unwanted and unsustainable. 9.The Sub Registrar has passed an order without an authority or power under the Registration Act, under the guise of the Circular. The scope of enquiry by the Sub Registrar for the purpose of registering a document can not be expanded. The respondent relied upon the circular dated 25.04.2012 which is reproduced as under: ?The object and purpose of the Registration Act is to provide information to public regarding the transaction that had taken place in a property. 2.In order to fulfil the objects of the act, several circulars as cited in the reference were issued. Through, these circulars, instructions were given to Sub Registrars that they ought to verify the previous original documents/patta and other revenue records to ascertain the right over the property by the persons who executed the documents. However, it is brought to my knowledge that documents are being registered without proper verification of the title deeds and other original relevant documents which leads to fraudulent registration. Hence, in order to safeguard the public interest by preventing bogus or fraudulent registration of documents, following instructions are reiterated for strict adherence in letter and spirits. (A) In respect of deeds involving transfer of immovable property, such as sale, gift, settlement, exchange or creating charge over the property such as Mortgage or Power of Attorney, the registering officer should insist presentation of previous original deed/deeds by which the executants acquired right over the said property before registering the document and then verify the previous documents to satisfy himself that the executants have right over the property. (B) In case previous document are not available as the property may be ancestral, the executants should produce revenue records such as Patta copy issued by the Revenue Department and tax receipt in original along with attested/notarizsed Xeros copies to prove that the properties are owned by them. The Registering officer should verify the original and return them to the party concerned and preserve the attested xerox copy as part of the document by scanning and numbering it. (C) In case the previous original document is lost, the party should produce certified copy of the document, copy of complaints recorded in Police Station and copy of advertisement published in local dailies regarding loss of documents. In such case, party has to produce patta/property tax receipt in original.

    (i) In case if the property is Government land/poramboke land or belonging to religious institution as per revenue records/other records and the party has not produced any patta prove his right the Registering Officer should return the document with check slip stating the facts.

    (ii) In the above mentioned case, it the party produces patta, then the Registering Officer should keep the document pending for ascertaining the facts and genuineness of patta from concerned department /revenue officials. 5.In case of cancellation of settlement deed, if the settler is unable to produce the original settlement deed as it may be with settlee then the settler should produce certified copy of the statement deed. The Registering Officer, after verifying the certified copy for identity, then register the cancellation deed without insisting for original deed. The above instructions should be strictly adhered along with other instruction already issued in this regard.? 10.Even the circular, dispenses with the production of original in case it is lost. In this case a xerox copy of mortgage deed and the previous sale deeds are produced. Though, unilateral cancellation of settlement is illegal and held to be void, the circular provides for cancellation of settlement deed on production of certified copy of settlement deed. 11.Hence, this Court is of the view that the circular dated 25.04.2012 is not the one which is in tune with the provisions of the Registrations Act and the Rules framed there under. 12.In view of the above discussion the impugned check slip is quashed and the respondent is directed to accept the document namely sale deed dated 09.05.2018, from the petitioner and Register the same without insisting the production of original parent document, namely, sale deed dated 02.12.2009.

    13. With the above direction, the Writ petition is allowed. Consequently, connected Miscellaneous petitions are closed. No costs. The Sub Registrar, Aruppukkottai, Virudhunagar District.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C. Moorthy v. Sub Registrar, Aruppukkottai .
    (Jul 2, 2018)