Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Subhash Chandra v. Union Of India

    By A.K. Gaur, Judicial Member  By filing this Original Application the applicant has claimed for the following main relief: 1. to quash impugned orders dated 29.11.2005 Annexure A- 10 being contrary to record, and unreasonable,

    2. to direct the respondents to produce the entire service records of the applicant including his service roll,

    3. to direct he respondents to regularize the services of the petitioner on the post of Highly Skilled Fitter Grade I/ Stenographer Group-C,

    4. to direct the respondents to grant seniority to the applicant with effect from the date since the applicant was granted temporary status i.e. 1.1.1984.

    2. The brief facts of the case are that the applicant was initially appointed to the post of Stenographer vide order dated 18.11.1981 in the department of Railway Electrification with the respondents. At the time of initial appointment the applicant was appointed on daily wages for a period of 3 months which was further extended during the course of his services. The respondents make the appointment of stenographer through the recommendations of Railway Recruitment Board. No appointments of stenographers are made in the absence of the tests held by the recruitment board. The applicant joined the services on 23.11.1981 and he was granted the fitter grade-III on 01.11.1998. The applicant was granted the scale of fitter highly skilled grade-II on 1.5.1983 and his pay scale was enhanced to the grade of Rs. 330-480/-. Further the applicant was promoted as Highly Skilled Fitter Grade-I vide order dated 10.1.1990. His pay was fixed in the scale of Rs. 1320-2040/-. The said promotion and fixation was made effective from 5.8.1989. The applicant was granted the temporary status by the respondents on the post of highly skilled fitter/stenographer with effect from 1.1.1984. From appointment till the present date, the applicant is working as a casual worker. The applicant has put in about 25 years of service but still he is not regularized. The applicant submitted that he has been making regular efforts for his regularization of services. He is working for the department with full sincerity, honesty and dedication. For the purpose of regularization of services of the applicant the authorities of the department had been requesting the competent authorities to regularize and absorb him. Several representations were also submitted by the applicant but when the same were not decided the applicant filed an Original Application No. 705 of 2004. The Tribunal while deciding the said OA on 3.9.2004 directed the respondents to consider and decide the representation of the applicant within a period of three months. Vide order dated 29.11.2005 the respondents rejected the claim of the applicant on the ground that the applicant at no point of time was appointed on the post of Stenographer/Highly Skilled Fitter in Group-C and he was also never granted temporary status. The applicant was appointed to the post of Khalasi on Group-D post and therefore the applicant cannot be regularized on the post of Group-C but only can be regularized on a Group-D post. The respondents have passed the impugned order on baseless and immaterial grounds. Hence, this Original Application is filed.

    3. Refuting the claim of the applicant the respondents have filed their reply stating that the applicant was never appointed as stenographer but was appointed as Casual Labour in RE Project, Mathura for which post facto sanction was given by GM, RE(Core), Allahabad vide letter dated 24.2.1988. The respondents stated that there had been no post of skilled fitter/stenographer in operation. As per the records available with them i.e. the service register of the applicant, the applicant was never called for the stenography test which he had alleged to be qualified. The respondents also stated that the applicant was never appointed as stenographer on 23.11.1981 and later granted fitter grade-III on adhoc basis on 1.11.1988. There is no channel of promotion in the Railways from casual stenographer to fitter grade-III. The persons who have been appointed as stenographer will be promoted as stenographer grade-III to I and the persons appointed as casual labour may be promoted as adhoc fitter grade-III after granting temporary status in casual labour. Only after screening and regularization in group-D category, an employee has right of regular promotion in group-C as fitter according to seniority and other conditions. As per rule no promotion can be granted to the casual labour on regular basis. All the promotions granted to the applicant were purely on adhoc basis in RE project on work charge post, which were created for completion of project work and after completion of project, these posts have automatically been abolished being sporadic in nature. The respondents further submitted that the Railway Board has framed the scheme for regularization of all such project casual labour in group-D on 21.1.1997 and 5.3.1997 but the applicant refused the same and hence, he himself is responsible for delay in his regularization in group-D. The applicant at present is working against the work charge post of construction organization under Dy. CSTE Construction, Bhopal and is still to be regularized in group-D as substantive employee for seniority and promotion purposes. The applicant has not submitted any proof in support of his claim that he has qualified stenography test conducted by the railway recruitment board. The applicants monthly rated adhoc high skilled fitter post does not confer him any right that he had been regularized in railway service in the pay scale of Rs. 4500-7000/-. There is a prescribed procedure for regularization of casual labour in group-D under the provision and the applicant was called for the screening on 21.1.1997 and 5.3.1997 and on both occasion the applicant himself had submitted the refusal. Due to this fact he is continuing as temporary status casual labour for which railway administration is no way responsible as alleged by the applicant. The applicant is trying to take the advantage of his 25 years of adhoc temporary service as monthly rated fitter claiming eligibility for direct regularization in group-C for which he is not entitle. In compliance of the Tribunals judgment the respondents have passed a detailed, reasoned and speaking order. The respondents submitted that the applicant has the remedy to accept his regularization in group-D as a project casual labour as was accepted by other casual labourers but the applicant is reluctant in not accepting the departmental remedies open for him as per rule. Hence, the OA deserves to be dismissed.

    4. The applicant has also filed a rejoinder contesting the averments contained in the reply filed by the respondents. Nothing new has been stated in the rejoinder.

    5. A reply to the rejoinder has also been filed by the respondents reiterating the same facts as has been stated in the counter reply filed by the respondents.

    6. Heard the learned counsel for the applicant and the respondents and carefully perused the pleadings and records of the case. In this matter the sole controversy involved is whether a person appointed in a Railway Electrification project/Construction project has any right for regularization on the post on which he is appointed? The Railway Board after the judgment of the Honble Supreme Court in Inder Pal Yadav & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors.  1985 SCC (L&S) 526, framed a scheme for regularization of all such project casual labourers in group-D posts only. Thus, in the present case the respondents have called the applicant for screening on 21.1.1997 and 5.3.1997 and on both the occasion the applicant himself had submitted his refusal for his regularization in group-D post. The applicant was engaged purely on casual basis as per requirement of work and not against any regular vacant post of stenographer. As per the respondents the applicant at present is working against the work charge post in Construction organization under Dy. CSTE Construction, Bhopal and is still to be regularized in group-D post as substantive employee for seniority and promotion purposes. The respondents stated that there had been no post of skilled fitter/stenographer in operation. As per the records available with them i.e. the service register of the applicant he was never called for any stenography test as alleged by the applicant. The respondents also stated that the applicant was never appointed as stenographer on 23.11.1981 and later granted fitter grade-III on adhoc basis on 1.11.1988. There is no channel of promotion in the Railways from casual stenographer to fitter grade-III. The persons who are appointed as stenographer will be promoted as stenographer grade-III to I and the persons who are appointed as casual labour may be promoted as adhoc fitter grade-III after granting temporary status in casual labour. Only after screening and regularization in group-D category, an employee has right of regular promotion in group-C as fitter according to seniority and other conditions. All the promotions granted to the applicant were purely on adhoc basis in RE project, which were created for completion of project work and after completion of the project, these posts are automatically abolished being sporadic in nature.

    7. The Honble Supreme Court in the matter of Secretary, State of Karnataka and Others Vs. Umadevi(3) and others, 2006 (4) SCC 1 and in the matter of State of U.P. Vs. Neeraj Awasthi and others, 2006 (1) SCC 667 held that regularization cannot be a mode of appointment by any state under Article 162. There is no power to the state to make appointment and even if there is any such power no appointment could be made in violation of statutory rules. Thus, we find that the respondents have rightly rejected the case of the applicant for regularization in a group-C post.

    8. However, we find that the respondents in their reply to paragraph 8 have stated that the applicant has the remedy to accept his regularization in group-D as a project casual labour as was accepted by other casual labourers but since the applicant is reluctant and not accepting the departmental remedy open for him as per rule, we direct the respondents to re-consider the case of the applicant for regularization in group-D post, within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.

    9. In view of the aforesaid observation, the Original Application is disposed of. No order as to costs. Sd/- Sd/- (A.K. Gaur) (Dr. G.C. Srivastava) Judicial Member Vice Chairman

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Subhash Chandra v. Union Of India
    (Sep 28, 2007)