Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules, 1957
  • Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972
  • Rule 38 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules, 1957
  • Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972
  • Rule 38 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.

    Bhagwan Singh Rathor v. Union Of India

    By virtue of this OA applicants impugn order dated 9.10.1998 whereby request of applicant No.2 for compassionate appointment has been rejected.

    2. The facts in brief are that applicant No.1 was retired on medically grounds from service,e w.e.f. 10.10.2002 on the recommendation made by the Medical Board on 29.11.2002. After retirement of applicant No.1, he nominated applicant No.2, his elder son for compassionate appointment. This was submitted to the Chief PMG, UP, Lucknow (CPMG) for consideration by the Circle Relaxation Committee (CRC). On 14.11.2003, a communication was received by applicant No.1 that this case for compassionate appointment was rejected on the ground that applicant No.1 retired as invalid after attaining the age of 55 years while compassionate appointment is available to Group C employees up to the age of 55 years and 57 years in the case of Group D employees as per the scheme dated 9.10.1998. In view of this matter, applicant submits that as the age for Group A, B and C employees has not been raised from 55 years to 57 years, the same is discriminatory and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution.

    3. Applicants had earlier also filed OA No.471/2005, which was dismissed as withdrawn, vide order dated 9.12.2005.

    4. In view of these facts, it is prayed that the OA be allowed.

    5. Respondents, while denying the contentions raised by the applicants, submit that compassionate appointment is applicable to a dependent family member of a Government servant, who dies while in service or is retired on medical grounds under Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules, 1957 on the corresponding provision in the Central Civil Service Regulation before attaining the age of 55 years in respect of Group C and 57 years in respect of Group D or is retired under Rule 38 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972.

    6. Respondents also contended that compassionate appointment cases are considered by the CRC constituted in accordance with orders of Directorate issued vide letter dated 29.9.1989. In accordance with the scheme of compassionate appointment issued by DOP&T on 9.10.1998, it has been clearly mentioned in para No.7 (b) that compassionate appointment can be made up to 5% vacancies fallen under direct recruitment quota in any Group C and Group D posts. The ground, which can justify compassionate appointment, is primarily financial condition of the family and it should be offered as relief against destitution in an emergent situation. The object of the scheme is to help the family to get out of an emergency and allows for immediate assistance for those deserving such relief. In order of the Apex Court in the case of U.K. Nagpal Vs. State of Haryana and Others, JT 1994 (3) SC 525 it has been clearly held as under:- Compassionate appointment cannot be granted after lapse of reasonable time and it is not a vested right which can be exercised at any time in future.

    7. The respondents have also relied on the judgment in the case of Himachal Road Transport Corporation Vs. Dinesh Kumar (JT 1996 (5) SC on 7.5.1996 and Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd. Vs. A. Radhika Thirumalai, JT 1996 (9) SC 97 on 9.10.1996, wherein it has been ruled out that the appointment on compassionate ground can be made only if a vacancy is available for that purpose. In the case of LIC of India Vs. Mrs. Asha Ramachandran Ambedkar and Others, JT 1994 92) SC 183 it has been held as follows:- That the High Court and Administrative Tribunals cannot give direction for appointment of a person on compassionate ground but can merely direct consideration of the claim for such an appointment

    8. Heard both the learned counsels of the parties on this case and perused the quoted judgments and available file records.

    9. Shri D.P. Sharma, the learned counsel of applicants has acknowledges that though the applicant retired at the age of 55 years and as per Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 vide order dated 9.10.1998 of the Department of Posts his family is not entitled to compassionate appointment, yet he makes a plea for the same. His arguments are based primarily on the fact that the applicant had to retire at the age of 55 years due to medical reasons as his eyesight had become so bad that he was unable to work. This was confirmed by a Medical Board examination. He has prayed for compassionate appointment as available to Group D appointees as the difference in the scale of pay between Group C and Group D is a small one and prays that his claim be considered.

    10. Another limb of the argument advanced by him is that the case of the applicant no. 2 for compassionate appointment had not been properly considered by CRC. He acknowledges that in the meeting held on 29.9.1989 his case had certainly come up for consideration and rejected on the basis of the above order dated 9.10.1998 of the DOP&T wherein it is stated that Group C appointees if they reach the age of 55 on retirement are not to be considered for compassionate appointment.

    11. Replying to the above contentions, Shri S.M. Arif, learned counsel for the respondents, has strongly pleaded that an appointment on compassionate ground cannot be offered as a matter of course. It is not a right to be availed of by a Government servant. It is clear from various judgments of Apex Court and High Court that a balance be maintained, taking into consideration various factors of each case and the appointment is to be provided to give immediate relief to the family, who is in distress and there should be no delay in such appointments. He has also argued that such appointments are only 5% of the overall vacancies, which are earmarked for compassionate appointments, and the same is to be considered strictly according to merits and the Committee has to give specific reasons and grounds in each case. It is further argued that the object of granting compassionate appointment in this case is no longer valid since 5 years have already elapsed. Compassionate appointments cannot be granted after lapse of a reasonable period since it is not a vested right that can be exercised at any time, in future.

    12. Moreover, the main ground for rejecting this compassionate appointment is on the basis of Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules 1957 and the OM dated 9.10.1998, which clearly states that after attaining 55 years, no appointment can be offered to Group C employees. For applicant no. 2 to claim that since there is a small difference in pay scale between Group C and Group D, he ought to have been considered, is a totally fallacious argument. It is also not correct to state that his case was not fully considered by the CRC. His case had been taken up in the meeting held on 29.9.1989 of the CRC and, after seeing the prevailing rules and orders on the subject, an order was had been passed. Learned counsel of the respondents also refutes the argument of the applicant that right of natural justice under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution have been denied to him since it is clear that this right of compassionate appointment is not a vested right. This is substantiated in the judgment of U.K. Nagpal (supra). To advance his case and buttress the above arguments, the learned counsel of the respondents has relied upon a large number of Apex Court and High Court judgments in Sushma Gosain Vs. Union of India, AIR 1989 SC 1976, LIC of India Vs. Mrs. Asha Ramachandra Ambedkar and Another, JT 1994 (2) SC 183. Umesh Kumar Nagpal Vs. State of Haryana and Others, JT 1994 (3) SC 525.

    13. On hearing both parties, I am inclined to support the arguments advanced by the counsel for the respondents. Since it is clear that prevailing rules and orders within the department did not support granting of compassionate appointment to the family members of Group C employees if they had retired after attaining the age of 55 years, this OA cannot be maintained.

    14. In view of the above, OA is dismissed. No costs. (Mrs. Neena Ranjan) MEMBER (A) Rakesh

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhagwan Singh Rathor v. Union Of India
    (Apr 26, 2007)