Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963 (Rules, 1963) and R. 12
  • 5 of Limitation Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963 (Rules, 1963) and R. 12
  • 5 of Limitation Act

    State Of Rajasthan Through Principal Secretary, Medical & Health Department, Secretariat, Jaipur v. The Director (Public Health), Medical & Health Services, Swasthya Bhawan, Jaipur

    1. Instant appeal is directed against order of the Ld. Single Judge impugned dt. 9-9-2016.

    2. However, office has pointed out delay of 253 days in filing present appeal in support thereof separate application has been filed seeking condonation of delay u/S 5 of Limitation Act.

    3. After taking note of the submissions made, we find that the delay has been satisfactorily explained and deserves to be condoned.

    4. Accordingly, application seeking condonation of delay u/S 5 of Limitation Act stands allowed and the delay is condoned.

    5. The respondent (writ petitioner) submitted application & participated in the selection process held by the appellant for various posts including the post of Laboratory Assistant in reference to the advertisement dt. 10-7-2013.

    6. At the outset it may be noticed that its not a case of concealment on the part of the applicant while submitting his online application and participated in the selection process conducted by the respondent.

    7. After going through the process of selection placed in the select list and appointment order was sent to him dt. 11-12-2015 which was subject to police verification. When he reported to join duty in pursuance to the order of his appointment dt. 11-12-2015 & in the police verification report it came that a criminal case no. 136/2002 was registered against him for offence u/S 341, 323 & 504 IPC in which after being convicted he was granted benefit of probation and another was registered during the process of selection bearing criminal case no. 14/2015 for offence u/Ss. 448 & 453 IPC which as informed is still pending before the competent court of jurisdiction. Taking that report to be a basis the respondent applicant was not permitted to join & that compelled him to approach this Court by filing writ petition.

    8. The Ld. Single Judge after taking into consideration the material on record in its order impugned dt. 9-9-2016 observed that there was no concealment on the part of the applicant respondent and mere pendency of criminal case or in a case in which he was granted benefit of probation in itself will not hold him ineligible/unsuitable for being considered for appointment and that apart we are of the view that the post of Laboratory Assistant is included in the Schedule appended to Rajasthan Medical & Health Service Rules, 1963 (“Rules, 1963”) and R. 12 provides regarding character of candidate to be considered for direct recruitment to the service and Note-1 appended thereto clearly indicates that a conviction by a court of law need not of itself involve the refusal of a certificate of good character and in adjudging overall suitability of the applicant it is to keep in view the circumstances of conviction & if it involves no mortal turpitude or association with crimes of violence or with a movement which has as its object the overthrow by violent means of the government as by law established and a mere conviction need not be regarded as a disqualification. R. 12 & Note-1 appended thereto in particular of the Rules, 1963 being relevant for the present purpose reads ad infra:—

    “12. Character:- The character of a candidate for direct recruitment to the service must be such as to qualify him for employment in the service. He must produce a certificate of good character from the Principal/Academic Officer of the University of College in which he was last educated and two such certificate written not more than six months prior to the date of application from two responsible persons not connected with the College or University and not related to him.

    Note:(1) A conviction by a court of law need not of itself involve the refusal of a certificate of good character. The circumstances of the conviction should be taken into account and if they involve no moral turpitude or association with crimes of violence or with a movement which has as its object the overthrow by violent means of the government as by law established, the mere conviction need not be regarded as a disqualification.

    9. The information which was made available to the department on police verification regarding criminal case being registered during the process of selection in the year 2015 & also in 2002 even if taken at its face value, may not fall in any of the considerations which the rule making authority has taken note of in R. 12 & Note-I in particular of which we have made a reference and that apart in the given facts & circumstances since the criminal case registered in the year 2015 is still pending consideration no adverse inference can be drawn regarding his suitability to join the post pursuant to order of appointment dt. 11-12-2015 and in the given facts & circumstances not permitting the respondent to join pursuant to order of appointment was certainly not justified and this what the Ld. Single Judge observed in its order impugned dt. 9-9-2016.

    10. After we have heard counsel for the parties, we find no error in the order of the Ld. Single Judge impugned dt. 9-9-2016 which may call for our interference.

    11. Consequently, the appeal fails and is hereby dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Rajasthan T... v. The Director (Public...
    (Sep 1, 2017)