Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 11 of the Management Rules. Rule 11 of the Management Rules
  • Rule 30(a) read with rule 11 of the Management Rules,
  • Rule 11 of the Management Rules,
  • sub-rule (2)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 11 of the Management Rules. Rule 11 of the Management Rules
  • Rule 30(a) read with rule 11 of the Management Rules,
  • Rule 11 of the Management Rules,
  • sub-rule (2)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns a writ petition challenging Memorandum No. 1676 dated 20th August 1998 issued by the District Inspector of Schools (S.E), Purulia, which appointed Sri A.K. Mukherjee as a drawing and disbursing officer for Tulin Jai Siaram High School to enable drawing of Government grants and disbursal of approved staff salaries. The school’s Managing Committee had been elected in 1995 and took charge on 19th January 1995; its term expired on 19th January 1998. A general circular from the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education dated 9th January 1998 extended the tenure (initially to 15th September 1998 and later until reconstitution). Some guardians filed a writ (registered as W.P. 8711(W)/98) seeking continuation and reconstitution in terms of that circular; an interim order dated 11th May 1998 in that writ application (granted in terms of annexure D) was made and remained in force. The headmaster informed the District Inspector that a guardian's membership (the writ petitioner) had ceased from July 1998, creating a problem concerning operation of the school's bank accounts, prompting the challenged memorandum. By consent of the parties the writ application was taken up for hearing without affidavits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petitioner’s membership of the Managing Committee (as a guardian-elected member and Secretary) automatically ceased when his ward was sent up for the Madhyamik Pariksha and ceased to be a student, in light of Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding elections and Rule 11 of the Management Rules.
  2. Whether the subsequent re-admission of the petitioner’s ward to Class XI revived the petitioner’s membership such that the petitioner should be treated as continuing member/Secretary.
  3. Whether the memorandum of the District Inspector of Schools (appointing a drawing and disbursing officer) was liable to be interfered with given the above membership questions and the interim order in the related writ.

Arguments of the Parties

Writ Petitioner’s Arguments (Mr. Bhattacharyya)

  • The petitioner argued that his membership could not have ceased because his ward was subsequently re-admitted to Class XI after having sat for the Madhyamik Examination; therefore Rule 30(a) should not be applied to deprive him of membership.
  • He also contended that Rule 30(a) concerns only the procedure for holding elections and, since the election had already been held (and he had contested as a guardian while his son was a student), Rule 30(a) was inapplicable to his situation.

Headmaster / Respondents’ Arguments (Mr. Dey)

  • Respondents contended that, under Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding elections, a guardian voter’s eligibility ceases when the ward leaves the institution, and where the ward is sent up for the Madhyamik Pariksha the eligibility ceases from 1st May of the following academic year.
  • They relied on Rule 11 of the Management Rules (casual vacancy) to argue that if the qualification in respect of which a member was elected ceases, the membership automatically ceases and the vacancy must be filled by election, co-option or nomination.
  • On that basis, the respondents justified the administrative appointment of a drawing and disbursing officer to ensure continued receipt and disbursement of Government grants and salaries.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the text of Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election and Rule 11 of the Management Rules and applied those provisions to the facts.

  1. Interpretation of Rule 30(a): The court quoted Rule 30(a), which provides that a guardian voter’s eligibility in respect of a ward ceases as soon as that ward leaves the institution, and where a ward is sent up for the Madhyamik Pariksha the eligibility ceases from 1st May of the following academic year. The court found that this plain wording showed automatic cessation of eligibility when the ward left.
  2. Interaction with Rule 11 of the Management Rules: Rule 11 deals with casual vacancies and states that if any membership ceases to fulfill the qualification in respect of which the member was elected, nominated or co-opted, he shall cease to be a member and the vacancy must be filled subject to sub-rule (2). The court read Rule 30(a) together with Rule 11 and concluded that the petitioner’s membership automatically ceased when the ward left the school to sit for the Madhyamik Examination (or, in any event, from 1st May of the following academic year).
  3. Revival by re-admission: The court rejected the petitioner’s contention that re-admission to Class XI revived membership. It held that once cessation has taken effect under the statutory scheme, it cannot be re-opened by subsequent induction of the ward; such an induction would amount to a first admission as contemplated by Clause 8(2). The statute does not postulate revival of membership after such a lapse of months.
  4. Consequence for the Secretary’s duties: The court noted Clause 28 of the procedure, under which, if a guardian member who is Secretary ceases to hold qualifying guardianship, the duties of the Secretary are to be entrusted to the Joint Secretary (the Head of the Institution) until a new Secretary is elected at a meeting conveyed by him. Thus administrative continuity is provided for.
  5. Scope of challenge to the District Inspector’s memorandum: The court observed that the District Inspector’s memorandum merely appointed a drawing and disbursing officer for administrative reasons — to ensure drawing of Government grants and disbursement of salaries at approved rates. The court found no reason to interfere with that administrative step. The existence of an interim order allowing the petitioner to continue as Secretary in the pending writ did not make the appointment of a disbursing officer impermissible; even if the petitioner were still to be considered a member for the moment, the appointment did not disturb or invalidate that limited continuation.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF — The writ petition challenging Memorandum No. 1676 dated 20th August 1998 was dismissed.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The court held that the writ petitioner’s membership of the Managing Committee (as a guardian-elected member and Secretary) automatically ceased when his ward was sent up for the Madhyamik Examination (or, in any event, from 1st May of the following academic year) under Rule 30(a) read with Rule 11 of the Management Rules.
  • The court held that subsequent re-admission of the ward to Class XI did not revive the petitioner’s membership automatically; revival was not contemplated by the statutory scheme after cessation had taken effect.
  • The appointment by the District Inspector of Schools of a drawing and disbursing officer for administrative purposes (drawing grants and disbursing approved staff salaries) was not interfered with and was upheld by the court.
  • There was no order as to costs.
  • The opinion does not announce or rely upon any new judicial precedent beyond the statutory interpretation applied; it addresses the direct effect of specific rules on the parties’ rights and the administrative action impugned.
Application dismissed.

    Bhola Nath Mahato v. The State Of West Bengal & Ors.

    T. Chatterjee, J.:—The learned Counsel for the parties appearing before me, invited me to dispose of the writ application without any direction for filing affidavits. Accordingly, by consent of parties, the writ application is taken up for hearing.

    2. There is a school in the name of Tulin Jai Siaram High School (H.S) within the jurisdiction of Jhalda Police Station in the district of Purulia (herein after referred to as “the school”). The last election of the Managing Committee of the school was held in the year 1995 and the Managing Committee took charge of the affairs of the school on 19th January, 1995. The term of the Managing Committee of the school however, expired on and from 19th January, 1998. On 9th January, 1998 the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education issued a general circular wherein the tenure of the Managing Committee of the school was extended from February, 1998 to 15th September, 1998. Subsequently, the Secretary of the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education intimated the Headmaster of the school that the tenure of the Managing Committee was extended till the completion of reconstitution of the Managing Committee of the school. According to the writ petitioner, the Headmaster of the school however, was not allowing the existing Managing Committee to run the affairs of the school on the plea that there was a vaccum of 14 days that is from 19th January, 1998 to 1st February, 1998. Some of the guardians whose wards were studying in the school, moved a writ application in this Court which was registered as W.P 8711(W)/98 in which a prayer was made for allowing the existing Managing Committee to continue and to reconstitute in terms of the general circular No. 5/12 dated 9th January, 1998. By an order dated 11th May, 1998, a learned Judge of this Court passed an interim order in the said writ application which is to the following effect:—

    “In spite of notice, none appears on behalf of the respondents.

    The matter will appear in the last one week after the Summer Vacation.

    The interim order is granted in terms of annexure ‘D’ to this petition till the disposal of this writ application.

    However, the respondents will be at liberty to apply for variation and/or vacation and/or modification of this order upon notice to the writ petitioner.”

    3. It has not been disputed by the learned Counsel, appearing for the parties that the aforesaid interim order is still now continuing. However, the Headmaster of the school sent a letter to the District Inspector of Schools (S.E) intimating him that due to cessation of guardian membership of the writ petitioner with effect from July, 1998, the question of co-option of operation of account in place of Bank account including the salary account of the staffs had arisen and as such the Headmaster of the school sought advise from the District Inspector of Schools regarding the crisis relating to the Bank account of the school. By a memorandum being Memorandum No. 1676 dated 20th August, 1998, the District Inspector of Schools (S.E), Purulia appointed Sri A.K Mukherjee, Assistant Inspector of Schools, Purulia to act as a drawing and disbursing officer of the school so that there would be no difficulty to draw the Government grants and to disburse the salary of the approved staffs of the school at the approved rates. This Memorandum being Annexure ‘H’ to the writ application is now under challenge in this writ application.

    4. Mr. Bhattacharyya, appearing on behalf of the writ petitioner firstly contended that the question of cessation of membership of the writ petitioner cannot arise at all as the ward of the writ petitioner has been re-admitted in class XI of the school after the ward had sat for Madhyamik Examination. Therefore, Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election cannot be applied to the facts of this case.

    5. This submission of Mr. Bhattacharyya was contested by Mr. Dey, appearing on behalf of the Headmaster. In order to decide whether the membership of the writ petitioner automatically ceased on the leaving of the ward of the writ petitioner from the school, it would be relevant to refer to Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election which is as under:—

    “30(a)—A guardian voter owes his/her eligibility as a voter under the category of ‘Guardian’ in respect of a particular ward or wards. As soon as that word or wards leaves the institution, the qualification of a guardian voter shall cease. In case a ward is sent up for the Madhyamik Pariksha (Secondary Examination) in a particular academic year, the eligibility of the guardian voter in respect of that ward shall cease from 1st May of the following academic year.”

    6. So far as the present writ petition is concerned, it is not in dispute that the son of the writ petitioner had sat for the Madhyamik Pariksha and, therefore, the eligibility of the guardian father in respect of the son of the writ petitioner had ceased from 1st of May of the following academic year. According to Mr. Bhattacharyya in view of the admitted fact that the son of the writ petitioner has been re-admitted in Class XI, the membership of the writ petitioner from the guardian category automatically revives, and, therefore, question of cessation of membership of the writ petitioner cannot arise at all. In my view, the submission of Mr. Bhattacharyya cannot be accepted. From a plain reading of the Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election, it is clear that as soon as the ward or wards leave the institution qualification of a guardian father shall cease.

    (Emphasis added)

    Mr. Bhattacharyya however, sought to contend that Rule 30(a) of the procedures for holding election only deals with the procedure for holding election. Therefore, he sought to contend that Rule 30(a) would be applicable only in the case of a guardian father. Since in this case that question does not arise as election was duly held and the writ petitioner contested the election from the guardian category as his son was studying in the school at that point of time, question of applicability of Rule 30(a) cannot arise at all. The argument of Mr. Bhattacharyya on the face looks attractive. But on consideration of the relevant provisions, the scheme and the object, I do not find any substance in the same. In my view, Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election must be read with Rule 11 of the Management Rules. Rule 11 of the Management Rules deals with cases of casual vacancy. Rule 11 says that if any membership of a committee ceases at any time to fulfill the qualification in respect of which he was elected, nominated or co-opted, he shall cease to be a member and the vacancy so caused shall subject to sub-rule (2) be filled up by election, co-option or nomination, as the case may be. If we read Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election and Rule 11 of the Management Rules, it would be crystal clear that the membership of the writ petitioner automatically ceased on the leaving of his ward from the school who had sat for the Madhyamik Examination. From a plain reading of Rule 11 of the Management Rules, I am clearly of the opinion that the qualification of the writ petitioner who was elected from the guardian category ceased on the leaving of his son from the school and he will cease to be a member as soon as the qualification in respect of which he was elected, ceased.

    Therefore, after reading the aforesaid two provisions, there cannot be any doubt in my mind that on the leaving of the son of the writ petitioner, the membership of the writ petitioner automatically ceased. Therefore, I am of the view that the right to continue of the writ petitioner as a Secretary of the Managing Committee ceased on the ground that the ward has left the school. There is no doubt in the present case that the ward of the writ petitioner had left the school to sit for the Madhyamik Examination. In terms of Rule 30(a), the writ petitioner cannot be permitted to come within the guardian category to contest the election procedure. As Rule 11 clearly says that the qualification of a person in respect of which he was elected shall cease automatically, there cannot be any doubt that on the leaving of the son of the writ petitioner, the membership of the writ petitioner from the guardian category shall automatically cease.

    7. Now the other submission of Mr. Bhattacharyya may be considered. He submitted that even assuming that the membership of the writ petitioner ceased on the leaving of his son from the school to sit for Madhyamik Examination, even then in view of the subsequent event that the son of the writ petitioner was re-admitted in Class XI of the school, question of cessation of membership of the writ petitioner cannot arise at all. In view of the clear mandatory provision as made in Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election read with Rule 11 of the Management Rules, I am of the firm opinion that Mr. Dey was justified in submitting that in view of the clear provision as made in Rule 30(a) read with Rule 11 of the Management Rules, the membership of the writ petitioner from guardian category shall immediately cease. From a plain reading of Rule 30(a) read with Rule 11 of the Management Rules, it is clear that once cessation has taken effect, it cannot be re-opened by subsequent induction of the ward in the school. In that case, in my view such induction would be a first admission in the school which would be evident from Clause 8(2). In any view of the matter the statute does not postulate revival of membership after a lapse of few months (in this case from May 1998 to August, 1998 when the first admission of the hearing of the writ petition was made in the month of August, 1998). Therefore, relying on Rule 30(a) of the procedure for holding election read with Rule 11 of the Management Rules, I am of the view that the writ petitioner cannot automatically continue to be a member of the Managing Committee on the ground that his ward has been re-admitted in Class XI of the same school. Accordingly, I hold that the membership of the writ petitioner from the guardian category in the school has automatically ceased when his ward was sent up for Madhyamik Examination or even from 1st of May of the following academic year. Accordingly, I do not find any reason to hold that the Authorities were wrong in holding on the leaving of the son of the writ petitioner, the membership of the writ petitioner from the guardian category had ceased. Furthermore, in my view, if a guardian member is the Secretary of the school whose guardianship ceases as his ward had left the school, in that event, the duties of the Secretary shall be entrusted upon the Joint Secretary of the school (the Head of the Institution) as per Clause 28 of the procedure. The Head of the Institution in that case shall act as the Secretary of the school until a new Secretary is elected at a meeting conveyed by him. In any view of the matter, there is no scope to entertain the writ application against the memorandum of the District Inspector of Schools (S.E), Purulia which is under challenge in this writ application. By this order, the District Inspector of Schools for administrative reasons has only appointed a drawing and disbursing officer for drawing Government grants and to disburse the salaries of the approved staffs of the school at the approved rates. There is no dispute that in view of an interim order passed by this Court in a pending writ application, the writ petitioner has been continuing as a Secretary of the school. Therefore, even assuming that the writ petitioner can be considered to be a member of the Managing Committee, even then in my view such membership is not disturbed by appointing a disbursing officer who has been appointed only for the purpose of drawing and disbursing Government grants and payment of salaries to the approved teachers. That being the position, I do not find any reason to interfere with the memorandum issued by the District Inspector of Schools which is under challenge in this writ application.

    8. Accordingly, the writ petition fails.

    9. There will be no order as to costs.

    Application dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhola Nath Mahato v. The State Of West Bengal & Ors.
    (Nov 10, 1998)