JUDGMENT
Kohli, CJ
Based upon common questions of law, these petitions are being disposed of by this common judgment.
2. Petitioner, M/s. Unicorn Industries in W.P(C) No. 24 of 2007 was established in the State of Sikkim for manufacturing “Indian Mouth Freshner” (Pan Masala) not containing tobacco. The unit commenced commercial production of Pan Masala on 27.06.2006
3. Petitioner, M/s. Akshay Ispat and Ferro Alloys Pvt. Ltd. in W.P (C) No. 7 of 2009 was established in the State of Sikkim for manufacturing of “Ferro Silicon” and commenced its commercial production in July, 2006. On completion of all requisite formalities the petitioner claims to have invested about Rs. 5.90 crores for establishing the factory.
4. It is the common case of the petitioners that they have established their units pursuant to the Industrial Policy Resolution (IPR) of the Government of India as notified vide Central Government Office Memorandum dated 24.12.1997 followed by the State Government Notification No. G.O/2.DI/2002-2003/901 dated 17.02.2003 and the statutory Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 issued by the Central Government under Section 5A of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”) granting exemption for a period of 10 (ten) years from the date of notification or commencement of commercial production by new units set up in Sikkim from the payment of income tax and excise duty leviable under the provision of the Act, the Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and the Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles) Act, 1978 in respect to goods specified in the First Schedule and Second Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 other than goods specified in Annexure-I appended thereto and some other incentives under the aforesaid notification. This benefit was available to the goods manufactured in the units located in the Industrial Growth Centre or Industrial Infrastructure Development Centre or Export Promotion Industrial Park or Industrial Estate or Industrial Area or Commercial Estate or Scheme Area in the State of Sikkim. The goods manufactured by both the petitioners were not incorporated in Annexure-I to the aforesaid notification and being goods specified in the First Schedule/Second Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 fall within the purview of above policies and statutory notification. Undisputedly the petitioners were entitled to exemption having commenced their commercial production in accordance with the stipulations contained in the memorandum/notifications. The exemption was also available on the duty paid by utilisation CENVAT credit under the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002. Under the exemption scheme of the notification the petitioners were liable to pay duty at the time of clearance of goods from the units located in Sikkim and, thereafter, either claim refund or re-credit in accordance with the procedure prescribed in the exemption notification referred to above.
5. It is admitted case of the parties that the petitioners claimed refund/adjustment up to the month of March/April, 2007. The exemption Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 was, however, amended vide subsequent Notification No. 21/2007-Central Excise dated 25.04.2007 By virtue of the aforesaid amendment, Pan Masala falling under Chapter 21 of the First Schedule of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 was brought in the Negative List by including this item in Annexure-I to the exemption Notification dated 09.09.2003 and consequently recovery was sought from the petitioner, M/s. Unicorn Industries. The goods manufactured by both the petitioners being excisable goods were subject to payment of excise duty but for the exemption notification referred to above. However, the petitioner, M/s. Akshay Ispat & Ferro Alloys Pvt. Ltd. continued to enjoy exemption from the payment of excise duty.
6. Both the petitioners were also availing CENVAT credit under the Cenvat Credit Rules, 2002. This benefit was withdrawn vide Notification No. 23/2008-Central Excise dated 27.03.2008 and Notification No. 37/2008-Central Excise dated 10.06.2008 The petitioners challenged the aforesaid withdrawal notifications by filing W.P (C) No. 11/2008 titled Unicorn Industries v. Union of India and W.P(C) No. 27/2008 titled Akshay Ispat & Ferro Alloys Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India in this Court. Some of the industrial units who were also aggrieved of the notifications withdrawing CENVAT exemption also filed separate writ petitions. All the writ petitions were allowed by this Court vide Common Judgment dated 15.11.2010, quashing the impugned notifications with some directions.
7. In case of Unicorn Industries, the exemption from payment of excise duty granted vide notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 was withdrawn by Notification No. 21/2007-Central Excise dated 25.04.2007 by induction of Pan Masala in Annexure-I (Negative List). It filed a separate writ petition being W.P(C) No. 22 of 2007 titled Unicorn Industries v. Union of India. This writ petition has been allowed by a separate judgment of even date.
8. The petitioners were availing the exemption in terms of exemption Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 in respect to the basic excise duty payable under the Act and if leviable, the additional duties of excise under the Acts specified in the notification. At the time exemption Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 was issued, the Central Government had also levied another duty, namely, National Calamity Contingent Duty under Section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001 [Act No. 14 of 2001]. Section 136 reads as under:-
“136. National Calamity Contingent duty. - (1) In the case of goods specified in the Seventh Schedule, being goods manufactured or produced, there shall be levied and collected for the purposes of the Union, by surcharge, a duty of excise, to be called the National Calamity Contingent duty (hereinafter referred to as the National Calamity duty), at the rates specified in the said Schedule.
(2) The National Calamity duty chargeable on the goods specified in the Seventh Schedule shall be in addition to any other duties of excise chargeable on such goods under the Central Excise Act, 1941 (1 of 1944) or any other law for the time being in force.
(3) The provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (1 of 1944) and the rules made thereunder, including those relating to refunds and exemptions from duties and imposition of penalty, shall, as far as may be, apply in relation to the levy and collection of the National Calamity duty leviable under this section in respect of the goods specified in the Seventh Schedule as they apply in relation to the levy and collection of the duties of excise on such goods under the Act or those rules, as the case may be.”
9. From the reading of the aforesaid Section, it appears that the National Calamity Contingent Duty, hereinafter called NCCD, was levied in respect to goods specified in the Seventh Schedule of the Finance Act, 2001. In the year 2004, another duty called as Education Cess @ 2% of the excise duty was levied vide Sections 91 and 93 in Chapter VI of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 [Act No. 23 of 2004). Sections 91 and 93, which are relevant for the purpose of present petitions, are reproduced hereunder: -
“91. Education Cess. - (1) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-section (11) of section 2, there shall be levied and collected, in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter as surcharge for purposes of the Union, a cess to be called the Education Cess, to fulfil the commitment of the Government to provide and finance universalised quality basic education.
(2) The Central Government may, after due appropriation made by Parliament by law in this behalf, utilise, such sums of money of the Education Cess levied under sub-section (11) of section 2 and this Chapter for the purposes specified in sub-section (1), as it may consider necessary.
XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX
93. Education Cess on excisable goods. - (1) The Education Cess levied under section 91, in the case of goods specified in the First Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (5 of 1986), being goods manufactured or produced, shall be a duty of excise (in his section referred to as the Education Cess on excisable goods), at the rate of two per cent, calculated on the aggregate of all duties of excise (including special duty of excise or any other duty of excise but excluding Education Cess on excisable goods) which are levied and collected by the Central Government in the Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue), under the provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (1 of 1944) or under any other law for the time being in force.
(2) The Education Cess on excisable goods shall be in addition to any other duties of excise chargeable on such goods, under the Central Excise Act, 1944 (1 of 1944) or any other law for the time being in force.
(3) The provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 (1 of 1944) and the rules made thereunder, including those relating to refunds and exemptions from duties and imposition of penalty shall, as far as may be, apply in relation to the levy and collection of the Education Cess on excisable goods as they apply in relation to the levy and collection of the duties of excise on such goods under the Central Excise Act, 1944 or the rules, as the case may be.”
10. Units established by both the petitioners were liable to pay the education cess under the Finance Act, 2004, whereas the unit of M/s. Unicorn Industries was also liable to pay NCCD under the Finance Act, 2001. It seems that both the petitioners availed refund/re-credit of the education cess and the petitioner, M/s. Unicorn Industries also availed exemption from NCCD.
11. The Central Government also introduced another component of duty called as Secondary and Higher Education Cess @ 1% of the total excise duty under Sections 126 and 128, Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2007. Sections 126 and 128 of the Finance Act, 2007 are reproduced as hereunder: -
“126. (1) Without prejudice to the provisions of sub-section (12) of section 2, there shall be levied and collected, in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter as surcharge for purposes of the Union, a cess to be called the Secondary and Higher Education Cess, to fulfil the commitment of the Government to provide and finance secondary and higher education.
(2) The Central Government may, after due appropriation made by Parliament by law in this behalf, utilize, such sums of money of the Secondary and Higher Education Cess levied under sub-section (12) of section 2 and this Chapter for the purposes specified in subsection (1) as it may consider necessary.
XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX
“128. (1) The Secondary and Higher Education Cess levied under section 126, in the case of goods specified in the First Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985, being goods manufactured or produced, shall be a duty of excise (in this section referred to as the Secondary and Higher Education Cess on excisable goods), at the rate of one per cent., calculated on the aggregate of all duties of excise (including special duty of excise or any other duty of excise but excluding Education Cess chargeable under section 93 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 2004 and Secondary and Higher Education Cess on excisable goods) which are levied and collected by the Central Government in the Ministry of Finance (Department of Revenue), under the provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 or under any other law for the time being in force.
(2) The Secondary and Higher Education Cess on excisable goods shall be in addition to any other duties of excise chargeable on such goods, under the Central Excise Act, 1944 or any other law for the time being in force and the Education Cess chargeable under section 93 of the Finance (No. 2) Act, 1944.
(3) The provisions of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and the rules made thereunder, including those relating to refunds and exemptions from duties and imposition of penalty shall, as far as may be, apply in relation to the levy and collection of the Secondary and Higher Education Cess on excisable goods as they apply in relation to the levy and collection of the duties of excise on such goods under the Central Excise Act, 1944 or the rules made thereunder, as the case may be.”
Believing that the NCCD, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess levied under the Finance Act, 2001, 2004 and 2007 respectively are components of excise duty and fall within the purview of the exemption policy of the notification, the petitioners claimed re-credit/refund of these duties on goods manufactured by them at the time of sale from their respective units in the manner and to the extent noticed above. It appears that on consideration the respondents were of the opinion that the petitioners are not entitled to the benefit of the exemption in respect to these 3 (three) kinds of duties levied under the Finance Acts as a part of incentives/exemption package under the Industrial Policies and the statutory Notification issued under Section 5A of the Act.
12. Consequently, recoveries were sought from M/s. Akshay Ispat and Ferro Alloys Pvt. Ltd. on account of re-credit of Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess to the extent of exemption availed by it. These demands are also under challenge in the W.P(C) No. 7/2009, besides seeking stay against recovery. Whereas M/s. Unicorn Industries in W.P(C) No. 24/2007 has also sought a direction for the stay of recovery of amounts already received by this petitioner by way of re-credit/refund.
13. Both the petitioners challenged the Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 to the extent it restricts the exemption only in respect to the basic excise duty under the Act, additional duties under the Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and the Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles) Act, 1978. The contention raised on behalf of the petitioners is that the exemption from excise duty includes exemption from all kind of excise duties levied, imposed and recoverable as excise duty under any statute for the period of exemption, irrespective of nomenclature. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners while referring to the provisions of the Finance Act, 2001, Finance Act, 2004 and Finance Act, 2007, submit that all these duties though imposed by various Finance Acts are, in fact, recoverable as excise duty notwithstanding their nomenclature. It is further contended that sub-section (3) of Section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001, sub-Section (3) of Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004 and sub-section (3) of Section 128 of the Finance Act, 2007 clearly provide that all rules and provisions of the Act relating to refund and exemption from duties and imposition of penalties as far as may apply in relation to the levy and collection of the NCCD, the Education Cess and the Secondary and Higher Education Cess respectively. The submission is that the exemption provision of the Act, namely, Section 5A of the Act, has been made applicable to all these different categories of duties introduced under the Finance Acts, 2001, 2004 and 2007 respectively and the duties being recovered in the nature of excise duties, the petitioners are entitled to exemption thereof. Learned counsel for the petitioners further submits that the Industrial Policy Resolution (IPR) dated 24.12.1997 and the State Government Notification dated 17.02.2003 were issued to grant total exemption from income tax and excise duty for a period of 10 years and thus no duty imposed as excise duty under any law becomes recoverable from the petitioners during the exemption period. The impugned Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 in so far as it incorporates (under any of the said Acts) in paragraph 1 of the notification restricting the exemption in respect to the goods covered under three statutes only is violative of the basic IPR memorandum dated 24.12.1997 as also the State of Sikkim Notification dated 17.02.2003 being contrary to doctrines of promissory estoppel and legitimate expectation. Relevant extracts from both the resolution and notification are reproduced as hereunder: -
“New Industrial Policy and Other Concession in the North Eastern Region.
No. EA/1/2/96-IPO
Government of India
Ministry of Industry
Department of Industrial Policy & Promotion.
24th December, 1997.
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX
C. Fiscal Incentives to New Industrial Units and their Substantial Expansion:
i. Government has approved for converting the Growth Centres and IIDCs into a total tax free zones for the next 10 years. All industrial activity in these zones be free from Income Tax, Excise for a period of 10 years from the commencement of production. State Government would be requested to grant exemption in respect of Sales Tax and Municipal Tax.
XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX”
“DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE AND INDUSTRIES
GOVERNMENT OF SIKKIM
No. G.O/2.DI/2002-2003/901
Dated: 17/02/03
NOTIFICATION
The Notification/Memorandum issued by Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion, Govt. of India vide No. 14(2)/2002-SPS, dated 23rd December 2002 approving a special package of incentives for development of Industries in the State of Sikkim, is hereby reproduced for general information of the public and the entrepreneurs as under:
No. 14(2)/2002-SPS
Government of India,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry,
(Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion)
New Delhi. Dated 23 Dec. 2012.
OFFICE MEMORANDUM
Subject: New Industrial Policy and other concessions for the state of Sikkim.
XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX
3.1 Fiscal Incentives to new Industrial Units and substantial expansion of existing units:
i) New industrial units and existing industrial units on their substantial expansion as defined, set up in Growth Center, Industrial Infrastructure Development Centers (IIDCs) and other locations like Industrial Estates, Export Processing Zones, Food Parks, IT Parks, etc., as notified by the Central Government are entitled to 100% (hundred percent) income tax and excise duty exemption for a period of 10 Years from the date of commencement of commercial production. Thrust Sector Industries as mentioned in Annexure-II are entitled to similar concessions in the entire State of Sikkim without area restrictions.
XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX XXXXXX”
14. IPR dated 24.12.1997, Government of India's notification/memorandum No. 14(2)/2002-SPS dated 23.12.2002 providing special package of incentives for development of industries in the State of Sikkim and consequential notification of Department of Commerce and Industries, Government of Sikkim dated 17.02.2003 do indicate total and 100% income tax and excise duty exemption for a period of 10 years. IPR, 1997 was issued by Government of India before the Finance Act, 2001 came to be enacted by the Parliament, whereunder National Calamity Contingent Duty was levied. When the special package of incentives were formulated for the State of Sikkim vide Government of India's Memorandum dated 23.12.2002 and exemption Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 was issued granting exemption from payment of excise duty, the Finance Act, 2001 had been enacted but neither the 2002 Memorandum nor exemption Notification dated 09.09.2003 mentioned about exemption from payment of NCCD. The exemption notification issued under Section 5A of the Act granted exemption only from the payment of the excise duty under three specified statutes and not under any other law or enactment including the Finance Act, 2001. As regards the Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess levied under the Finance Acts, 2004 and 2007 respectively are concerned, neither the memorandum of 2002 nor the exemption notification could have taken note of these duties as the same were not in existence at the relevant time, both the Finance Acts having been enacted later in time.
15. The contention of the petitioners is that all the duties, namely, NCCD (Finance Act, 2001), Education Cess (Finance Act, 2004) and Secondary and Higher Education Cess (Finance Act, 2007) being in the nature of duties of excise have to be construed within the scope and ambit of exemption assured for a period of 10 (ten) years from the date of notification or commercial production. Section 2A of the Act defines certain expressions which is reproduced as under: -
“2A. References of certain expressions.- In this Act, save as otherwise expressly provided and unless the context otherwise requires, references to the expressions “duty”, “duties”, “duty of excise” and “duties of excise” shall be construed to include a reference to “Central Value Added Tax (CENVAT).”
16. Referring to the above provision it is submitted that the definition of “duty” or “duty of excise” and “duties of excise” under the Act include all kinds of duties recoverable as excise duty. It is submitted that the definition is not exhaustive and is only illustrative. It is submitted that even Central Value Added Tax (CENVAT) has been construed to be an excise duty under the Act, though regulated by separate rules. The petitioners have relied upon a judgment of this Court dated 15.11.2010 passed in bunch of petitions including the petitions filed by the petitioners herein whereunder two notifications withdrawing the benefit of CENVAT earlier granted to the petitioners under the exemption Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 have been quashed. The simple argument on behalf of the petitioners is that since the exemption from payment of the excise duty is total and 100% for a period of 10 (ten) years, the intention of the Central Government was unequivocal and unambiguous not to levy any excise duty upon the goods manufactured by the petitioners in any form for this period from the date of commercial production. It is not in dispute that IPR, 1997 and Notification dated 17.02.2003 issued by the Government of Sikkim pursuant to the Central Government's Memorandum dated 23.12.2002 promised total and 100% exemption from payment of excise duty for a period of 10 (ten) years. Both these Memorandum/Notification contain following stipulations: -
“Ministry of finance etc. are requested to amend rules/notifications etc and issue necessary instructions for giving effect to these decisions.” (IPR, 1997)
“5. The Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Department of Development of North Eastern Region, etc. are requested to amend Act/rules/notifications, etc. and issue necessary instructions for giving effect to these decisions.” (Notification dated 17.02.2003)
17. The above stipulations indicate that the concerned Departments/Ministries were required to issue formal statutory notifications for grant of exemption as proposed in IPR, 1997, Memorandum dated 23.12.2002 (special package of incentives for the State of Sikkim) and the State Government's Notification dated 17.02.2003 It is, however, seen that the statutory Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 granted exemption from payment of excise duty in respect to the goods specified in First and Second Schedule of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 in respect to the duties imposed under the Act (basic duty), the Additional Duties of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and the Additional Duties of Excise (Textiles and Textile Articles) Act, 1978 (additional duties) only and not under any other statute including the Finance Act, 2001, which was in operation when this exemption notification was issued. The petitioner, M/s. Unicorn Industries was liable to pay NCCD under the Finance Act, 2001. It goes without saying that Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess @ 2% and 1% respectively on the excise duty payable were imposed under the Finance Acts, 2004 and 2007 respectively enacted much after the IPR, 1997, IPR, 2002 for the State of Sikkim and exemption notification dated 09.09.2003 were issued.
18. To appreciate the contentions of the petitioners, it becomes necessary to examine the nature of levies imposed under the three Finance Acts. It may be noticed that NCCD, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess though not in essence the duties of excise but have been treated as excise duties for the purpose of collection. There is no abstract definition of “excise duty” under the Act, however, its definition is gatherable from the preamble of the Act and Section 3 of the Act read with entry 84 of List I (Union List) of Seventh Schedule. The Preamble and relevant extract of Section 3 and Entry 84, referred to above, are reproduced hereunder:-
Preamble
“An Act to consolidate and amend the law relating to Central duties of excise.
WHEREAS it is expedient to consolidate and amend the law relating to Central duties of excise on goods manufactured or produced in certain parts of India;”
“CHAPTER II
LEVY AND COLLECTION OF DUTY
3. Duties specified in the Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 to be levied. - (1) There shall be levied and collected in such manner as may be prescribed,-
(a) a duty of excise, to be called the Central Value Added Tax (CENVAT) on all excisable goods (excluding goods produced or manufactured in special economic zones) which are produced or manufactured in India as, and at the rates, set forth in the First Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (5 of 1986);
(b) a special duty of excise, in addition to the duty of excise specified in clause (a) above, on excisable goods (excluding goods produced or manufactured in special economic zones) specified in the Second Schedule to the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 (5 of 1986) which are produced or manufactured in India, as, and at the rates, set forth in the said Second Schedule:
Provided that the duties of excise which shall be levied and collected on any excisable goods which are produced or manufactured,-
(ii) by a hundred per cent export oriented undertaking and brought to any other place in India,
shall be an amount equal to the aggregate of the duties of customs which would be leviable under the Customs Act, 1962 (52 of 1962) or any other law for the time being in force on like goods produced or manufactured outside India if imported into India, and where the said duties of customs are chargeable by reference to their value, the value of such excisable goods shall, notwithstanding anything contained in any other provision of this Act, be determined in accordance with the provisions of the Customs Act, 1962 and the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 (51 of 1975).”
Entry 84 List I Schedule Seventh
“84. Duties of excise on tobacco and other goods manufactured or produced in India except -
(a) alcoholic liquors for human consumption.
(b) opium, Indian hemp and other narcotic drugs and narcotics,
But including medicinal and toilet preparations containing alcohol or any substance included in sub-paragraph (b) of this entry.”
19. From the conjunctive reading of the above provisions, the definition of the excise duty can be extracted to mean duty on the goods manufactured or produced in India as specified in First and Second Schedule under the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985. Definition and nature of excise duty has been examined and considered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in various judgments, in AIR 1962 SC 1006: Chhotabhai Jethabhai Patel and Co. v. Union of India, a Constitution Bench defined the excise duty in the following manner: -
“(25) In our view, a duty of excise is a tax-levy on home-produced goods of a specified class or description, the duty being calculated according to the quantity or value of the goods and which is levied because of the mere fact of the goods having been produced or manufactured and unrelated to and not dependent on any commercial transaction in them. The duty in the present case satisfied this test and therefore it is unnecessary to seek other grounds for sustaining the validity of the tax.”
Drawing a distinction between a tax, a fee and the excise duty, in Har Shankar v. They Dy. Excise and Taxation Commr.: (1975) 1 SCC 737, Hon'ble Supreme Court observed as under: -
“56. The distinction which the Constitution makes for legislative purposes between a ‘tax’ and a ‘fee’ and the characteristics of these two as also of ‘excise duty’ are well-known. “A tax is a compulsory exaction of money by public authority for public purposes enforceable by law and is not a payment for services rendered”. A fee is a charge for special services rendered to individuals by some governmental agency and such a charge has an element in it of a quid pro quo. Excise duty is primarily a duty on the production or manufacture of goods produced or manufactured within the country.”
20. The duties imposed under the Finance Acts, 2001, 2004 and 2007 respectively are in the nature of surcharge. The object and purport of the National Calamity Contingent Duty is to create a fund for the calamity disaster. Similarly, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess have been levied to meet the commitment of the Central Government to finance the education including secondary and higher education in the country as is evident from the following statements contained in Section 91(1) of the Finance Act, 2004 and Section 126(1) of the Finance Act, 2007 respectively -
Finance Act, 2004
“….. there shall be levied and collected, in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter as surcharge for purposes of the Union, a cess to be called the Education Cess, to fulfil the commitment of the Government to provide and finance universalised quality basic education.”
Finance Act, 2007
“….. there shall be levied and collected, in accordance with the provisions of this Chapter as surcharge for purposes of the Union, a cess to be called the Secondary and Higher Education Cess, to fulfil the commitment of the Government to provide and finance secondary and higher education.”
It goes without saying that every legislation has a profound object and purpose. The legislative intent and purpose may be clearly, unambiguously and unequivocally evident from the preamble of the Act or any specific provision contained therein. In absence of any clear indication in this regard, the legislative intent has to be gathered from the various provisions contained in the Act. A Finance Act is a legislative measure to implement and give effect to the financial proposals of the Central Government for a particular financial year and to take within its compass various fiscal decisions which, inter alia, include imposition of new taxes proposed in the annual budget, modification/alteration of the existing taxes and budgetary allocation for different Departments and purposes/proposals. From the Budget Speech of the then Finance Minister of Union during 2001-2002 budget on 28.02.2001 (downloaded from the Lok Sabha Website), it appears that the National Calamity Contingency Fund was recommended by Eleventh Finance Commission as a special levy for the replenishment of the National Calamity Contingency Fund. The relevant extract of the Budget Speech is noticed hereunder: -
“110. The Eleventh Finance Commission has recommended a special levy for the replenishment of the National Calamity Contingency Fund. As an ad hoc measure, this was provided for in the current year through a special surcharge on corporate taxes. I propose to establish this funding on a regular basis through a special surcharge of excise on a range of products the use of which should be discouraged on health grounds. I propose to levy a surcharge of 15% on digarettes. The duty on biris would increase from Rs. 6 to Rs. 7 per thousand biris. The total duty on pan masala would be 55%/60%. Miscellaneous tobacco products like chewing tobacco would be charged to a total duty of 60%.”
21. To implement the aforesaid decision, Section 136 was enacted as a part of the Finance Act, 2001 under Chapter-IV (Indirect Taxes) to impose the National Calamity Contingency Fund to be collected as “excise duty” levied on goods specified in the Seventh Schedule. This was only an adhoc measure. From the speech of the then Finance Minister, it is evident that the intention of the legislature was not to create a new kind of excise duty but a special fund to meet the expenditure for the natural disaster by way of surcharge. It is not an excise duty in its true nature.
22. The Education Cess and the Secondary and Higher Education Cess are a part of the Central Government's proposal to discharge its constitutional obligation under Articles 39(f), 45 and 21A of the Constitution of India.
23. Article 39(f) was introduced in the Constitution vide the Constitution (Forty-Second) Amendment Act, 1976 to incorporate provisions for the welfare and protection of the children and youth in this Country by providing opportunities and facilities to develop in conditions of freedom and dignity and protection against exploitation etc. Article 45 was substituted to make provision for childhood care and education to the children below the age of 6 years. Similarly, Article 21A was enacted creating right to free and compulsory education to all children of the age of 6 to 14 years. Both these provisions were introduced by Eighty-Sixth Amendment Act, 2002, even though Article 51A(k) introduced by the same Amendment cast a duty upon the parent or guardian to provide opportunities for education to his child between the age of 6 and 14 years. However by virtue of Articles 45 and 21A, the State took upon itself the duty to provide free education to children.
24. To discharge these constitutional obligations obviously the finances were required to undertake the exercise for providing free education. India has about 40% population below the age of 18 years. To discharge the constitutional obligation the Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess have been levied under the Finance Acts, 2004 and 2007 respectively. The statements contained in Section 91 of the Finance Act, 2004 and Section 136 of the Finance Act, 2007 noticed hereinabove indicate the purpose of the levy (Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess) by way of surcharge to be collected as excise duty. It may also be noticed here that the Parliament has recently enacted “The Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009” to carry out the constitutional mandate.
25. Admittedly, these are indirect taxes levied for particular purposes. It seems that the Central Government instead of enacting special statutes to levy or create funds for the above purposes in its wisdom created these funds by levying surcharge/excise duty under the Finance Acts notwithstanding the fact that these duties are not in essence in the nature of duties on the manufacture and production of goods in India. It seems that to facilitate the collection of funds, these Cesses were brought within the purview of the excise duty by fiction of law. Otherwise the National Calamity Contingent Duty, the Education Cess and the Secondary and Higher Education Cess have no relation with the manufacture and production of the goods. Assumption or creation of a non-existent situation or thing by fiction of law is not unknown to legislative field and practices. However, the scope of such fiction cannot be enlarged. Hon'ble Supreme Court in Commissioner Of Sales Tax, U.P v. Modi Sugar Mills Ltd. : AIR 1961 SC 1047 held as hereunder: -
“(13) ………………………………………………………………………………. ………………………………………………… A legal fiction must be limited to the purposes for which it has been created and cannot be extended beyond its legitimate field. …………………………………………………..”
26. It thus emerges that the Cesses imposed under the Finance Acts referred to above are for limited purpose of collection as excise duty and no further meaning can be given to these Cesses so as to grant benefit to the petitioners as the real object and purpose of these levies are not to impose a tax or a duty on the manufacture and production of the goods. Thus both the levies being not the excise duties in the real sense of definition, the petitioners are not entitled to exemption in terms of the IPR, 1997, Memorandum dated 23.12.2002 and the exemption Notification dated 09.09.2003
27. It may also be noticed that by virtue of sub-section 3 of Section 136 (Finance Act, 2001), sub-section 3 of Section 93 (Finance Act, 2004) and sub-section 3 of Section 128 (Finance Act, 2007), the provision of the Central Excise Act, 1944 and the rules made thereunder have been made applicable as regards the refunds, exemption and imposition of penalty in respect to these duties. This clearly signifies that these Cesses and duties can also be exempted by the Central Government in the same manner as the exemption is granted in respect of the basic excise duty and additional excise duties imposed under various enactments including those specified in exemption Notification dated 09.09.2003 Indisputably, neither the exemption notification nor the IPRs specifically grant exemption in respect to the levies as discussed hereinabove. At the first place the Finance Acts, 2004 and 2007 were not in operation when these exemptions were granted and thus the Central Government could not have intended or even conceived to grant exemption in respect to the duties which could not have been visualised at the relevant time. As regard the NCCD is concerned, the duty had already been imposed under 2001 Finance Act when the exemption notification was issued but no exemption was granted in respect to this duty. The intention has to be gathered and inferred from the exemption notification itself. The only inference is that the Central Government had no intention to exempt the NCCD as far as industries established in the State of Sikkim are concerned. This fact is evident from the reply filed by the respondents. In the counter affidavit filed by the respondents, it is stated that the goods manufactured by the petitioner attracts various excise duties viz. CENVAT known as Basic Excise Duty @ 37.5% (of the first schedule of the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985), National Calamity Contingent Duty (NCCD) @ 23% (as per Seventh Schedule of Finance Act, 2001), Additional Duty @5.5% (as per Seventh Schedule of Finance Act, 2005) and the Education Cess @ 2% on the aggregate of the excise duty as per the Finance Act, 2004. It is, further, stated that the total excise duty excluding Education Cess was 66% and including the Education Cess 67.32%. However, with effect from March, 2007 the total duty was modified from 66% to 45% wherein the Basic Excise Duty was @16%, National Calamity Contingent Duty (NCCD) @ 23%, Additional Duty @6% with the usual rate of Education Cess @ 2%, Secondary and Higher Education Cess @ 1% (imposed vide Finance Act, 2007) and thus, total excise duties excluding Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess was 45% and including Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess comes to 46.35%. In so far as the question of exemption is concerned, the respondents have stated that the NCCD was levied by Notification No. 32/99-CE and Notification No. 33/99-CE both dated 08.07.1999 upon the industries set up in North-Eastern States. However, the Central Government vide Notification No. 27/2001-CE dated 11.05.2001 in public interest exempted the industries from paying NCCD on Pan Masala for industries set up in other North-Eastern States except the State of Sikkim and there is no notification for exemption of NCCD for industries set up in the State of Sikkim. It is alleged that petitioners were claiming re-credit of NCCD by referring to Notification No. 27/2001-CE dated 11.05.2001, even though the notification was not applicable in the State of Sikkim. It is further case of the respondents that even though general industrial policy was issued, however the policy could only be implemented through statutory notification to grant exemption. The Central Government had no intention to grant exemption from payment of NCCD, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess. It is further stated that Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess were not in existence when the industrial policy was formulated and exemption notification was issued. The petitioners are not entitled to exemption from payment of these dues in absence of any exemption notification under law.
28. The petitioners have also relied upon a Circular issued vide Order No. 60/1/2006-CX (Annexure-P25) under Section 37B of the Central Excise Act, 1944, rendering explanation in respect to the exemption from payment of duties on goods exported under bond under rule 13 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, rule 19 of the Central Excise Rules, 2001 and rule 19 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002. It is argued that this Circular which is of explanatory character issued by the Government of India clearly provides that duties including the NCCD, Education Cess and various other kinds of duties imposed in the nature of excise duty are not payable under rule 19 of the Central Excise Rules, 2002 and rule 19 of the Central Excise Rules, 2001 and rule 13 of the Central Excise Rules, 1994. These rules exempt the payment of excise duty on the export of excisable goods outside India except few countries.
29. From the perusal of the aforesaid Circular and the Rules, it seems that the Government of India had clarified that the duties payable under the Central Excise Tariff Act, 1985 for which exemption has been granted in respect to export of excisable goods, include the duties like NCCD and Education Cess etc. The argument is that all excise duties irrespective of enactments under which these are levied, are in fact excise duties and by virtue of the IPR, 1997 and Notification dated 17.02.2003, the petitioners are entitled to total exemption of payment thereof.
30. I have perused the rule 13 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 and rule 19 of the Central Excise Rules, 2001. These rules deal with the export of goods in bond on which duty has not been paid. Goods manufactured purely for export purposes altogether fall in a different category and no duty is payable on such goods in terms of the aforesaid rules when these are removed from the factory/bond. The clarification made vide the Circular No. 60/1/2006-CX dated 13.01.2006 is confined to the benefit to be granted for export purposes. If the intention of the Central Government was to grant the similar benefit for the industries established in Sikkim, a similar action would have been taken, particularly, when there is specific provision for grant of exemption under the Finance Acts, referred to above. No such intention is deducible from any of the notifications or circular relied upon by the respondents.
31. It is also pertinent to note that the duty is also defined under Rule 2(e) of the Central Excise Rules, 2002, which reads as hereunder: -
“Rule 2. Definitions. - In these rules, unless the context otherwise requires, -
…………………………………………………………………………………….………………
(e) “duty” means the duty payable under Section 3 of the Act;”
This definition of duty further signifies that the duty envisaged is the basic duty levied under charging Section 3 of the Act. Any other special duty imposed by any special act does not fall within the purview of the duty for purposes of the Act.
32. Apart from the fact that the Central Government never expressed its intention nor such intention is apparent from any of the notifications, cesses imposed under Finance Acts, 2001, 2004 and 2007 are not in essence the duties of excise. The later two duties were imposed after the grant of exemption and incentives by the Central Government, it could not have visualised by the Central Government at the time of framing the IPR, 1997 and IPR, 2002 in regard to the State of Sikkim or even the exemption Notification No. 71/2003-C.E. to grant exemption from any duty which may be imposed in future. Exemption could only be granted in respect of the duties which were levied or had been imposed at the time of grant of incentives.
33. A similar question came up for consideration before the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India v. Modi Rubber Ltd.: (1986) 4 SCC 66. In this case, the manufacture of tyres was subject to duty of excise levied under Section 3 of the Act. Rule 8 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 framed under the Act contained provision for exemption of duty wholly or in part on excisable goods by a notification to be issued by the Central Government. A notification bearing No. 123/74-C.E. dated 01.08.1974 was issued by the Central Government exempting tyres for motor vehicles from a portion of the excise duty levied thereon. This was followed by another notification bearing No. 27/81-C.E. dated 01.03.1981 issued by the Central Government exempting part of the duty in respect of tyres for some other categories of motor vehicles etc. Vide Section 32 of the Finance Act, 1979, a special duty of excise was levied. Section 32 also contained a similar provision relating to refund and exemption from duties as contained under sub-section (3) of Section 136 of the Finance Act, 2001, sub-Section (3) of Section 93 of the Finance Act, 2004 and sub-section (3) of Section 128 of the Finance Act, 2007. The assessee, Modi Rubber Ltd., who was availing the exemption in terms of the notification of 01.08.1974 and 01.03.1981, claimed exemption from the special duty imposed under the Finance Act, 1979. The Hon'ble Supreme Court at the outset noticed the question for consideration with the following observation: -
“These appeals and writ petition raise a short question of the construction of the expression ‘duty of excise’ employed in two notifications issued by the Government of India under sub-rule (1) of Rule 8 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944, one bearing No. 123/74-C.E. dated August 1, 1974 and the other bearing No. 27/81-C.E. dated March 1, 1981. The question is whether this expression is limited in its connotation only to basic duty of excise levied under the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 or it also covers special duty of excise levied under various Finance Bills and Acts, additional duty of excise levied under the Additional Duty of Excise (Goods of Special Importance) Act, 1957 and any other kind of duty of excise levied under a Central enactment. ……………”
34. Answering this question, the Hon'ble Court held as under: -
“8. ………, at the date when the first notification was issued, namely, August 1, 1974, there was no special duty of excise leviable on tyres. It came to be levied on tyres with effect from the financial year 1978 under various Finance Acts enacted from year to year. It is therefore difficult to understand how the expression ‘duty of excise’ in the notification dated August 1, 1974 could possibly be read as comprehending special duty of excise which did not exist at the date of this notification and came to be levied almost four years later. When special duty of excise was not in existence at the date of this notification, how could the Central Government, in issuing this notification, have intended to grant exemption from payment of special excise duty? The presumption is that when a notification granting exemption from payment of excise duty is issued by the Central Government under Rule 8(1), the Central Government would have applied its mind to the question whether exemption should be granted and if so, to what extent. And obviously that can only be with reference to the duty of excise which is then leviable. The Central Government could not be presumed to have projected its mind into the future and granted exemption in respect of excise duty which may be levied in the future, without considering the nature and extent of such duty and the object and purpose for which such levy may be made and without taking into account the situation which may be prevailing then. It is only when a new duty of excise is levied, whether special duty of excise or auxiliary duty of excise or any other kind of duty of excise, that a question could arise whether any particular article should be exempted from payment of such duty of excise and the Central Government would then have to apply its mind to this question and having regard to the nature and extent of such duty of excise and the object and purpose for which it is levied and the economic situation including supply and demand position then prevailing, decide whether exemption from payment of such excise duty should be granted and if so, to what extent. It would be absurd to suggest that by issuing the notification dated August 1, 1974 the Central Government intended to grant exemption not only in respect of excise duty then prevailing but also in respect of all future duties of excise which may be levied from time to time.”
35. The Hon'ble Supreme Court also considered similar arguments as raised in this case that by virtue of the provisions contained in the Finance Acts, referred to above, the exemption provisions contained in Section 5A of the Act are applicable mutatis mutandis and thus, the exemptions from all kinds of excise duties leviable under the Finance Acts being excise duties are exempt. It has been observed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court that definitely the source for exemption is contained in Rule 8(1) read with the provisions of the Finance Act. However, in view of the definition of ‘duty’ under Rule 2 clause (v) as was at the relevant time (presently Rule 2(e), the exemption would be confined only to the duty envisaged under Section 3 and not any other special or auxiliary duty imposed after the exemption notifications were issued. The Hon'ble Supreme Court thus observed: -
“9. ………………………………………………………………. ………………………………………….. It is, therefore, clear that where a notification granting exemption is issued only under sub-rule (1) of Rule 8 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 without reference to any other statute making the provisions of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 and the Rules made thereunder applicable to the levy and collection of special, auxiliary or any other kind of excise duty levied under such statute, the exemption must be read as limited to the duty of excise payable under the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 and cannot cover such special, auxiliary or other kind of duty of excise. The notifications in the present case were issued under sub-rule (1) of Rule 8 of the Central Excise Rules, 1944 simpliciter without reference to any other statute and hence the exemption granted under these two notifications must be construed as limited only to the duty of excise payable under the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944.”
36. The position in the present case is no different. The respondents have placed on record various notifications regarding grant of exemption from the NCCD or Education Cess levied under the Finance Acts, in question. This further clarifies that the excise duty envisaged under the exemption Notification No. 71/2003-Central Excise dated 09.09.2003 as also under IPR, 1997 and Notification dated 17.02.2003 could not be expanded to include the duties that may be levied, subsequently under any finance act or special duty levied by the Parliament for a different purpose. The petitioners are availing the benefit in respect to the exemption under the impugned notification itself since 2003. They illegally availed the benefit of exemption in respect to NCCD, Education Cess and Secondary and Higher Education Cess levied under the Finance Acts, 2001, 2004 and 2007 respectively without any exemption notification having been issued pursuant to these Finance Acts meaning thereby that the benefits secured by them was without any sanction of law. The respondents rightly raised demand of duties levied under the Finance Acts.
37. In view of the factual and legal aspects noticed hereinabove, the challenge to the impugned notification fails. The petitioners are not entitled to avail the exemption in respect to the duties imposed under the Finance Acts, 2001, 2004 and 2007 respectively.
38. These Writ Petitions are without merit, hence dismissed without any order as to costs.