AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302, 394, 504 and 506 I.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 302, 394, 504 and 506 I.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The revision arises from an order dated 4.10.2011 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. XII, Meerut in Criminal Appeal No. 319 of 2011 and an earlier order dated 7.9.2011 of the Juvenile Justice Board, Meerut in Crime No. 431 of 2011. The revisionist had been charged under Sections 302, 394, 504 and 506 IPC (Police Station Kasna, District Gautambudh Nagar). He applied through his father/natural guardian to be declared a juvenile on the ground that his high‑school certificate recorded his date of birth as 13.9.1995, meaning he was under 18 on the date of occurrence (29.6.2011). The Juvenile Justice Board doubted the school certificate, referred the revisionist to a Medical Board, which opined he was about 19 years old (elbow and wrist joints fused). The Board therefore held he was above 18 and ordered his shift from the Juvenile Home to the District Jail. The revisionist appealed; the Sessions Court (Criminal Appeal No. 319 of 2011) dismissed the appeal on 4.10.2011, upholding the Board's disbelief of the school certificate. The present revision by the revisionist was heard by Mahendra Dayal, J., who dismissed it.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the high‑school (school) certificate and ancillary school records produced by the revisionist constituted reliable proof of his date of birth such that he should be declared a juvenile.
  2. Whether, in light of disputed documentary evidence, the opinion of the Medical Board (based on X‑rays and fusion of joints) could be relied upon to determine that the revisionist was above 18 years of age at the time of the offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Revisionist's Arguments

  • The original high‑school certificate (date of birth 13.9.1995) was filed and verified before the Juvenile Justice Board and therefore should have been accepted as reliable proof of his age.
  • The law requires that the Medical Board's report be considered only when no reliable proof of date of birth is available; here such reliable proof existed and the Board's X‑ray based opinion should have been discarded.
  • X‑ray based age estimation carries a usual variation of about two years; therefore, an X‑ray result suggesting about 19 years could allow treating the revisionist as around 17 years (giving benefit of two years), and thus he should have been declared juvenile.
  • Both courts below erred in disbelieving the school certificate on technical grounds.

Opposite Party No. 2 and Learned A.G.A.'s Arguments

  • There were material discrepancies in the records: the application dated 12.7.2011 mentioned the date of birth as 13.9.1995, yet an affidavit stated the revisionist was born in 1993, indicating inconsistent statements by the father.
  • The secondary school certificate's date of birth derived from entries in St. Josef School which, in turn, were based on a transfer certificate allegedly issued by Kisan Vaidic Junior High School; that transfer certificate was challenged as not genuine.
  • A court witness (C.W‑3), an Assistant Teacher of Kisan Vaidic Junior High School, deposed that the revisionist never studied at that school and that the transfer certificate was never issued by that school, undermining the provenance of the school records.
  • Given these discrepancies and absence of authentic documentary proof, reliance on the Medical Board's certificate (Chief Medical Officer, Meerut) which found fusion of elbow and wrist joints and opined age above 19 was appropriate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
2011 (1) JIC 710 (SC) Principle that a date of birth entered in a school certificate has no evidentiary value unless the person who made the entry or who provided that date is examined; proving the document does not automatically prove the truth of its contents. The court applied this principle to uphold disbelief of the school certificate because the foundational document (transfer certificate from Kisan Vaidic) was shown to be doubtful by evidence (C.W‑3), and the person responsible for the original entry was not effectively relied upon to prove the date recorded.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded as follows:

  1. Examination of evidentiary record: The Juvenile Justice Board had found the high‑school certificate doubtful because the date of birth entry in St. Josef School rested on an alleged transfer certificate from Kisan Vaidic Junior High School.
  2. Credibility of foundational document: The Assistant Teacher of Kisan Vaidic (C.W‑3) testified that the revisionist never studied at that school and that the transfer certificate was never issued by the school, rendering the transfer certificate and the derived school entries suspect.
  3. Inconsistencies in statements: The father of the revisionist provided inconsistent dates of birth at different stages (application vs affidavit), leading to further doubt; a criminal case for giving false evidence was registered against him in this background.
  4. Application of precedent: Relying on the Supreme Court precedent (2011 (1) JIC 710 (SC)), the court noted that mere proof of a school certificate does not prove the truth of the recorded date of birth unless the maker of the entry is examined and the provenance is satisfactorily established.
  5. Absence of reliable documentary proof: Given the doubt over the foundational transfer certificate and inconsistencies in parental statements, there was no reliable documentary proof of the revisionist's date of birth.
  6. Resort to medical opinion: Because documentary proof was not reliable, the Juvenile Justice Board’s referral to, and acceptance of, the Medical Board’s report (elbow and wrist fusion; opinion that the revisionist was above 19 years) was appropriate and permissible.
  7. Conclusion on legality of lower courts' orders: The Sessions Court correctly dismissed the appeal, and this court found no illegality in the conclusions reached by the Board and the Appellate Court that the revisionist was above 18 years at the time of the occurrence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Revision dismissed. The court held that both the Juvenile Justice Board and the Appellate Court did not commit any illegality in finding that the revisionist was major (above 18 years of age) at the time of the occurrence.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The orders below are sustained; the revisionist is not to be declared a juvenile and the Board's direction (to shift the revisionist from Juvenile Home to District Jail) was supported by the courts below and not disturbed by this revision.
  • Broader legal implications: The decision applies the existing principle (as cited from the Supreme Court) that school certificates are not conclusive proof of date of birth unless corroborated by examination of the person(s) responsible for the entries; the opinion does not purport to create any new legal precedent.

    Parag Bhati (Juvenile) Petitioner v. State Of U.P & Another S

    Mahendra Dayal, J.:— Feeling aggrieved by the order dated 4.10.2011 passed by Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. XII, Meerut in Criminal Appeal No. 319 of 2011 and the order dated 7.9.2011 passed by Juvenile Justice Board, Meerut in Crime No. 431 of 2011, revisionist has filed this revision.

    2. The brief facts relevant for the disposal of this revision are that in Crime No. 431 of 2011, under Section 302, 394, 504 and 506 I.P.C relating to Police Station - Kasna, District - Gautambudh Nagar, the revisionist moved an application through his father/natural guardian praying that he may be declared as juvenile. The contention of the revisionist was that as per the high school certificate, his date of birth is 13.9.1995 and as such on the date of occurrence that is on 29.6.2011, he had not attained 18 years of age. In support of his contention, the father of the revisionist filed his affidavit and the copies of school certificate showing that the date of birth of the revisionist is 13.9.1995 The Juvenile Justice Board after considering the evidence on record came to the conclusion that the date of birth as recorded in the school certificate was doubtful and, as such, the revisionist was referred to the Medical Board for determination of age. As per the report of Medical Board, the revisionist was about 19 years of age. The learned Juvenile Justice Board held that in any case revisionist was above 18 years of age of the time of occurrence and accordingly, the application of the revisionist was rejected and he was directed to be shifted from Juvenile Home to the District Jail.

    3. Feeling aggrieved by the order of the Juvenile Justice Board, the revisionist filed Criminal Appeal No. 319 of 2011 in the Court of Sessions Judge, Meerut. The appeal was decided on 4.10.2011 and the learned Appellate Court dismissed the appeal observing that the Juvenile Justice Board rightly disbelieved the school certificate and found the revisionist major at the time of occurrence.

    4. I have heard learned counsel for the revisionist and have perused the impugned orders passed by both the courts below.

    5. The submission on the behalf of the revisionist is that the Original High School Certificate was filed before the Juvenile Justice Board and the same was also verified but even then both the courts below disbelieved the same on technical grounds. The law in respect of determination of age of the juvenile is that in case no reliable proof of date of birth is available only then the report of Medical Board would be considered. Since in this case there was reliable evidence of date of birth, the Juvenile Justice Board ought to have believed the High School Certificate and should have discarded the report of the Medical Board which is based on X-ray of various joints. It is also submitted that there is always variation of two years on either side in the age determined on the basis of X-ray. Since the revisionist was found to be around 19 years of age, he could have been treated to be around 17 years of age giving benefits of two years relaxation. Both the courts below have adopted erroneous approach which is not sustainable in the eyes of law.

    6. Learned A.G.A as well as learned counsel for the opposite party no. 2 have argued that the application for declaring the revisionist as juvenile was moved on 12.7.2011 in which the date of birth of the revisionist was mentioned as 13.9.1995 However, in the affidavit, the revisionist was said to have born in the year 1993. It is further submitted that in the Secondary School Examination Certificate, the date of birth as mentioned therein is 13.9.1995 but this date of birth is not correct. It has come in the evidence that the revisionist studied from class 1st to 5th in St. Josef School, Grater Noida. Thereafter he studied in Kisan Vaidic Junior School. After leaving this school, the revisionist again took admission in St. Josef School. A report from St. Josef School was also produced before the Juvenile Justice Board in which it was mentioned that his date of birth was recorded in the register on the basis of transfer certificate issued by Kisan Vaidic Junior High School. The court witness C.W-3 was examined before the Juvenile Justice Board who stated on oath that the revisionist never studied in Kisan Vaidic Junior High School and the alleged transfer certificate was never issued by the School. The submission of learned counsel for the opposite party no. 2 is that since the transfer certificate on the basis of which entries were made in St. Josef School, was not found genuine, the date of birth as mentioned in the secondary school certificate was not at all reliable.

    7. The learned Juvenile Justice Board on the basis of aforesaid discrepancy, discarded the evidence produced by the revisionist in support of his age. Since there was no other reliable evidence with regard to the date of birth of the revisionist, the board had no other option except to believe the opinion of the Medical Board according to which the revisionist was about 19 years of age. A copy of aforesaid certificate issued by the Office of Chief Medical Officer, Meerut is on record according to which the elbow and wrist joints were found fused. On the basis of the fusion of joints, the Chief Medical Officer recorded his opinion that the revisionist was above 19 years of age.

    8. In a recent decision of the Supreme Court reported in 2011 (1) JIC 710 (SC), it has been held that the date of birth mentioned in the School Certificate has no evidenciary value unless the person who made the entry or who gave the date of birth is examined. Merely because the transfer certificate or school certificate is proved, it would not mean that the contents of the documents are also proved. In this case, the Assistant Teacher of Kisan Vaidic Junior High School has clearly stated on oath before the court that the transfer certificate filed on behalf of the revisionist was never issued by the school. Even the revisionist never studied in his school. The date of birth recorded in the register of St. Josef School is on the basis of transfer certificate issued by Kisan Vaidic Junior High School. Since the basic document on the basis of which the date of birth was entered, was doubtful, the date of birth as mentioned in the High School Certificate cannot be believed. Moreover, the father of the revisionist has stated different dates of birth of the revisionist at different stages of the case. It was in this background that a criminal case of giving false evidence was registered against him.

    9. The submission of learned counsel for the opposite party no. 2 is that both the courts below rightly disbelieved the school certificate and since there was no authentic proof of the age of the revisionist, the court had no other option except to rely upon the certificate issued by the Chief Medical Officer, Meerut.

    10. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and considering the facts that there is no reliable proof of date of birth of the revisionist and according to the certificate issued by the Chief Medical Officer, the revisionist was above 19 years of age, both the courts below have not committed any illegality in holding that the revisionist was major and above 18 years of age at the time of occurrence. I, therefore, do not find any illegality in both the orders and, as such, revision has no force and is liable to be dismissed.

    11. With the above observations, the revision is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Parag Bhati (Juvenile) Petitioner v. State Of U.P & Another S
    (May 24, 2013)