Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 504, 506 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 202 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 190(1)(a) and Section 4(1)(h) of the old Code.
  • Section 2(h) or Section 190(1)(a) of the Code. (5)
  • Section 2(d) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code
  • Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code
  • Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of Cr.P.C
  • Code. (1) Section 155(2) of the new Code
  • Sections 504 and 506 of I.P.C,
  • Section 173(2) of the new Code
  • Section 465 of the new Code,
  • Section 2(d) of the new Code.
  • Section 202 of the Code (3)
  • Section 155(4) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C7.
  • Section 202 of Cr.P.C
  • Section 2(h) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 504, 506 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 202 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred
  • Section 190(1)(a) and Section 4(1)(h) of the old Code.
  • Section 2(h) or Section 190(1)(a) of the Code. (5)
  • Section 2(d) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code
  • Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code
  • Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of Cr.P.C
  • Code. (1) Section 155(2) of the new Code
  • Sections 504 and 506 of I.P.C,
  • Section 173(2) of the new Code
  • Section 465 of the new Code,
  • Section 2(d) of the new Code.
  • Section 202 of the Code (3)
  • Section 155(4) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C7.
  • Section 202 of Cr.P.C
  • Section 2(h) of Cr.P.C
  • Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Legal Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On 14.02.2013, Kiran S/O Tarachand Jain filed a complaint before the Police Inspector, Vidyanagar, alleging that the petitioners had used abusive words, given life threats and had robbed some gold ornaments. The police registered Crime No. 28/2013 for offences punishable under Sections 504, 506 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code (I.P.C.) and carried out an investigation. After investigation the police concluded that offences under Sections 504 and 506 I.P.C. were made out and submitted a chargesheet for those offences to J.M.F.C - II, Hubli.

By order dated 05.10.2013 the Magistrate recorded: "Cognizance of offence is taken against the accused No. 1 to 2 for the offences punishable U/S. 504, 506 I.P.C" and directed registration of the case and issue of summons. The petitioners challenged that order before this Court.

After hearing, this Court set aside the Magistrate's order dated 05.10.2013 and remitted the matter to the Magistrate to pass appropriate orders after considering the rulings and observations discussed in the opinion. The petition was disposed of accordingly.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Magistrate was correct in taking cognizance for the offences punishable under Sections 504 and 506 of the I.P.C., which are non-cognizable offences, where the police had investigated without the permission of the Magistrate?
  2. What procedure should a Magistrate follow when the police file a report/chargesheet that contains only non-cognizable offences after having investigated (i.e., whether the Magistrate should treat the report as a complaint under Section 2(d) or 2(h) Cr.P.C., or order reinvestigation under Section 202 Cr.P.C., or take cognizance)?
  3. Whether a police report filed under Section 173 (after investigation) disclosing only non-cognizable offences can be treated as a complaint under Section 2(d) of the Cr.P.C., and when the Explanation to Section 2(d) applies.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Sri F. V. Patil)

  • The police are empowered to investigate matters involving cognizable offences, but if after investigation the police conclude that only non-cognizable offences are made out, they must file a report to the Magistrate rather than treat it as a chargesheet enabling automatic cognizance.
  • The Magistrate must examine such a report and determine whether cognizance can be taken or whether further investigation should be ordered under Section 202 Cr.P.C.
  • A police report that discloses only non-cognizable offences cannot be construed as a chargesheet; at best it is a complaint under Section 2(d) Cr.P.C., and the Explanation to Section 2(d) makes the police officer who files such a report the complainant.
  • The petitioners relied on two judicial rulings (a Delhi High Court decision reported at 1999 Crl.L.J 1512 — Mam Chand v. State — and a Kerala High Court decision reported at 1981 Crl. L.J 356 — P. Kunhumuhammed v. State of Kerala) to support the contention that the Magistrate must apply judicial mind before taking cognizance of offences that are non-cognizable after police investigation.

State's Argument (as advanced by the Additional State Public Prosecutor)

  • The Additional State Public Prosecutor relied upon the Supreme Court decision in State of Orissa v. Sharat Chandra Sahu (1996 SCC (Cri) 1387), which laid down principles under Section 155(4) Cr.P.C. including that when offences alleged comprise both cognizable and non-cognizable offences, the entire matter is to be treated as cognizable and the police must investigate the whole case.
  • The respondent sought to persuade the Court that the Supreme Court ruling supported the police and Magistrate action in treating the matter as cognizable and proceeding with investigation and process.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
1999 Crl.L.J 1512 (Delhi) — Mam Chand v. State Where there is doubt as to whether a cognizable offence is made out, the police should report to the Magistrate and obtain appropriate orders rather than proceed to investigate a matter that on facts may disclose only non-cognizable offences; adopting the safer course avoids misuse of police power and accords with the spirit of Section 155 Cr.P.C. The Court relied on this observation to support the proposition that if circumstances at the relevant time do not plainly disclose a cognizable offence, the police should consult the Magistrate rather than carry out an investigation that may later be held to be improper.
1981 Crl. L.J 356 — P. Kunhumuhammed v. State of Kerala Under the new Code (Cr.P.C.), the police report under Section 173(2) cannot be treated as a complaint except within the restricted scope of the Explanation to Section 2(d). Propositions extracted include: (1) Section 155(2) prohibits police investigation into non-cognizable offences without Magistrate order; (2) defect may be cured by Magistrate ordering investigation under Section 202; (3) when at commencement police believed cognizable or doubtful and investigation discloses only non-cognizable, the police report may be treated as a complaint under Section 2(d); (4) if at commencement it was apparent only non-cognizable offence, the report cannot be treated as complaint; (5) Magistrate must apply judicial mind to decide whether to order reinvestigation, treat as complaint, or take cognizance; (6) Section 465 may cure defects unless failure of justice caused. The Court gave particular weight to this Kerala High Court judgment, emphasizing that a Magistrate must apply judicial mind to decide whether a police report disclosing only non-cognizable offences should be treated as a complaint, sent for reinvestigation under Section 202, or whether cognizance can be taken. The Court found that the Magistrate in the present case failed to do so.
1996 SCC (Cri) 1387 — State of Orissa v. Sharat Chandra Sahu (Supreme Court) When offences alleged comprise both cognizable and non-cognizable offences, the entire matter should be treated as cognizable and the police should investigate the whole case (subject to satisfaction that offences are prima facie made out). The Additional State Public Prosecutor relied on this ruling. The Court in the present opinion observed that this Supreme Court decision did not consider the proviso/Explanation to Section 2(d) Cr.P.C. and did not address what should happen after the police files a report disclosing only non-cognizable offences; therefore the Court concluded that the Supreme Court ruling was not directly applicable in a "straight jacket" manner to the facts here.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded from a careful reading of the cited rulings, with particular emphasis on the Kerala High Court decision (P. Kunhumuhammed). The Court identified the following legal and procedural principles from the authorities and applied them to the facts of the present case:

  1. If at the commencement of investigation the police honestly believe a cognizable offence is made out, or if there is doubt whether the offence is cognizable, the police may investigate; if after investigation only non-cognizable offences appear to have been committed, the police report may fall within the Explanation to Section 2(d) and be treated as a complaint (i.e., the reporting police officer being the complainant).
  2. Section 155(2) prohibits police investigation into non-cognizable offences without the Magistrate's order; a breach of that provision would render the investigation illegal, but certain defects may be cured by the Magistrate ordering reinvestigation under Section 202 or by other provisions such as Section 465 if no failure of justice results.
  3. The Magistrate has an obligation to apply judicial mind when a police report/chargesheet discloses only non-cognizable offences: the Magistrate must decide whether (a) to treat the report as a complaint under Section 2(d) and take cognizance, (b) to order reinvestigation under Section 202, or (c) to decide that the report cannot be treated as a complaint and decline to take cognizance. This obligation arises from the restricted scope of the Explanation to Section 2(d) under the current Cr.P.C.
  4. Applying these principles to the present matter, the Court found that the police had submitted a chargesheet for Sections 504 and 506 (non-cognizable) and that the Magistrate had not perused the chargesheet papers or applied judicial mind to determine whether the report should be treated as a complaint, or whether reinvestigation under Section 202 was required, or whether cognizance could properly be taken.
  5. Although the State relied upon the Supreme Court decision in State of Orissa v. Sharat Chandra Sahu, the Court noted that that decision did not address the Explanation to Section 2(d) and did not specify what a Magistrate should do after the police files a report disclosing only non-cognizable offences; therefore that precedent could not be applied without regard to the procedural framework established by Section 2(d) and the authorities construing it.
  6. Because the Magistrate failed to apply the required judicial scrutiny when taking cognizance under Sections 504 and 506, the Magistrate's order taking cognizance was set aside and the matter remitted for the Magistrate to reconsider and pass appropriate orders in light of the authorities discussed.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court SET ASIDE the Magistrate's order dated 05.10.2013 that had taken cognizance for offences under Sections 504 and 506 I.P.C., and REMITTED the matter to the Magistrate to pass appropriate orders after considering the rulings and observations cited in the opinion.

Implications:

  • The direct effect of the decision is that the Magistrate's cognizance order is vacated and the Magistrate must reconsider the police report/chargesheet with reference to the legal principles discussed (in particular the proper application of the Explanation to Section 2(d) Cr.P.C., the possibilities of ordering reinvestigation under Section 202 Cr.P.C., and the need to apply judicial mind before taking cognizance of offences that are non-cognizable after investigation).
  • The Court emphasized procedural safeguards: where police investigation results in a report disclosing only non-cognizable offences, the Magistrate cannot mechanically take cognizance but must assess whether to treat the report as a complaint or order further investigation; failure to do so requires setting aside the Magistrate's order.
  • The opinion did not announce any novel legal doctrine beyond applying and reconciling existing case law; the Court remitted the matter for reconsideration rather than establishing a new binding precedent in the text of this order.

Note: This summary is limited to and based exclusively upon the content of the provided opinion. No information has been added that does not appear in the original text.

    Gururaj v. State Of Karnataka

    ORDER:

    The short question involved in this Particular case is that-

    “Whether the Magistrate is right in taking cognizance for the offences punishable under Sections 504 and 506 of I.P.C, which are non-cognizable offences as investigated by the police without the permission of Magistrate?

    2. The brief factual aspects that emanate from the records are that a person by name Kiran S/O Tarachand Jain filed a complaint on 14.02.2013 before Police Inspector, Vidyanagar, alleging the abusive words used and life threat given by petitioners and also about robbery of some gold ornaments. On these allegations, police have registered a case in Crime No. 28/2013 for the offences punishable under Sections 504, 506 and 392 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as ‘I.P.C’ for brevity) and investigated the matter. After thorough investigation police found that offences punishable under Sections 504 and 506 of I.P.C are made out. Accordingly, they have submitted a chargesheet for the above said offences before J.M.F.C - II, Hubli. The Magistrate has passed the following order dated 05.10.2013-

    “The PI Vidyanagar PS Hubli has submitted splitup charge sheet against the accused No: 1 to 2 for the offences punishable U/S 504, 506 I.P.C

    Hence submitted for Order -

    ORDER:

    Perused the records.

    Cognizance of offence is taken against the accused No. 1 to 2 for the offences punishable U/S. 504, 506 I.P.C

    Office to register the case.

    Issue SS to accused, call on 30/10/2013”

    3. Sri. F.V Patil, learned counsel for the petitioners strenuously contends before this Court that the police are empowered to investigate the matter involving cognizable offences, but if the police comes to the conclusion that only non-cognizable offences are made out then they can file a report to Magistrate. The Magistrate has to look into the matter and find out wherher cognizance can be taken for the non-cognizable offences or whether it requires any further investigation by referring the matter to police to reinvestigate under Section 202 of Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (hereinafter referred to as ‘Cr.P.C’ for brevity).

    4. Learned counsel for petitioners strenuously contends that if the police report is filed for the offences involving only non-cognizable offences then that cannot be construed as a chargesheet, so as to enable the Magistrate to take cognizance. Looking into the contents of records, at the most it can be treated as a complaint under Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C The learned counsel argues before this Court that the Explanation appended to Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C makes it abundantly clear that whenever a report is filed by the Police Officer in a case which discloses, after the investigation, the commission of a non-cognizable offence shall be deemed to be a complaint; and the Police Officer by whom such report is made shall be deemed to be the complainant. The learned counsel also relied upon two rulings. In this regard a case reported in - 1999 Crl.L.J 1512 Delhi High Court between Mam Chand v. State. It has been observed by Delhi High Court at Paragraph 10 as follows-

    “10. I do not find much substance in the contention urged on behalf of the State that since the FIR was registered under S. 324, I.P.C and the said offence being cognizable, there was no bar in the police investigating the case. Once, on the circumstances prevalent at the time of registration of the case, it is evident that a non-cognizable offence is not made out, permitting the police to first register a cognizable offence, carry out investigations and ultimately if it is found that a cognizable offence was not made out, would be giving a long rope to the police. The nature of the offence is to be gathered from the facts available at the relevant time and if there is a doubt as to whether a cognizable offence is made out or not, the police can report it to the Magistrate concerned and obtain appropriate orders. On the one hand, no prejudice will be caused to the prosecution by adopting a safer course and on the other it will eliminate the possibility of misuse of power by the police. This approach will also be in consonance with the spirit and intention of S. 155 of the Code.

    5. The learned counsel for petitioners has also relied upon another ruling which is reported in - 1981 Crl. L.J 356 between P. Kunhumuhammed v. State of Kerala. Wherein, the relevant Paragraphs at 15 to 17 read thus -

    15. It is made clear under the new Code that the police report, that is a report under Section 173(2) of the new Code cannot he treated as a complaint The decisions referred to above arising under the old Code, made it clear that the report of a police officer in a non-cognizable offence following any investigation made without in order of the Magistrate can be treated as a complaint for the purposes of Section 190(1)(a) and Section 4(1)(h) of the old Code. This position can no longer continue to the same extent and in the same manner under the new Code. That is because of the restricted scope of the Explanation to Section 2(d) of the new Code. If the Legislature wanted to follow the judicial precedents under the old Code, the Explanation could merely have stated that the report made by a police officer in a case relating to commission of a non-cognizable offence shall be deemed to be a complaint. Instead, the Explanation states that the report made by a police officer in a case which discloses, after investigation, the commission of a non-cognizable offence shall be deemed to be a complaint. In other words, it is clear that a case where commission of a non-cognizable offence alone (is alleged or disclosed) at the commencement of the investigation cannot and does not fall within the scope of the Explanation. The Explanation takes within its scope only a case at the beginning of the investigation of which commission of a cognizable offence is alleged or disclosed or where it is doubtful if it relates to commission of a cognizable offence or a non-cognizabie offence and investigation discloses only the commission of a non-cognizable offence. Other categories are excluded from the purview of the Explanation.

    16. It is therefore clear that there is only minor change introduced by the provisions of the new Code. A consideration of the judicial precedents referred to above in the light of the changes made in the new Code, would suggest the following propositions as being applicable under the new Code. (1) Section 155(2) of the new Code prohibits investigation by a police officer into a non-cognizable offence without the order of a Magistrate. A violation of this provision would stamp the investigation with illegality. (2) This defect in the investigation can be obviated and prejudice to the accused avoided by the Magistrate ordering investigation under Section 202 of the Code (3) The report of a police officer following an investigation contrary to Section 155(2) could be treated as a complaint under Section 2(d) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code if at the commencement of the investigation the police officer is led to believe that the case involved commission of a cognizable offence or if there is doubt about it and investigation establishes only commission of a non-cognizable offence. (4). If at the commencement of the investigation it is apparent that the case involved only commission of a non-cognizable offence, the report followed by investigation cannot be treated as a complaint under Section 2(h) or Section 190(1)(a) of the Code. (5) Whenever a report of a police officer relating to a non-cognizable offence is brought to the notice of a Magistrate he has to look into the matter and apply his judicial mind and find out whether, (a) it is a case where reinvestigation has to be ordered under Section 202 of the Code, or (b) whether it could be treated as a complaint under Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code and if so cognizance could be taken, (c) or whether it is case where the report cannot be treated as a complaint under Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of the Code or, (d) it is a fit case for taking cognizance taking into consideration all the attendant circumstances. (6) If these aspects are not brought to the notice of or adverted to by the Magistrate at that stage and trial is concluded, the trial cannot be said to be vitiated on account of the defect as the defect in the investigation precedent to trial could be cured by Section 465 of the new Code, unless failure of justice has been occasioned thereby.

    17. In the present case, at the stage of taking cognizance, the learned Magistrate did not apply his judicial mind to these questions involved in this case and now discussed by me. He has taken cognizance without considering any of these questions and when this matter was brought to his notice later, he rejected the contentions and this order has been approved by the learned Sessions Judge. Both the courts have seriously erred in proceeding as they did. The orders passed by them and the cognizance taken by the Magistrate are hereby quashed.”

    6. On meticulous reading and meaningful understanding of the above said rulings, Particularly, after going through the judgment of Kerala High Court, it is clear that whenever the police have filed the chargesheet only containing non-cognizable offence though they have investigated the matter under the guise that there was a cognizable offence disclosed at the threshold of the investigation, if the police are of the view that the allegations made in the complaint creates a doubt that whether the allegations constitute only non-cognizable offences or cognizable offence also, then the police have to invariably approach the Magistrate seeking permission to investigate the non-cognizable offences. But if the police are of the view that both cognizable and non-cognizable offences are made out on reading of the FIR then the police can proceed with the investigation and file a report for non-cognizable offences only. But after the completion of investigation if the Police Officer files such report then it definitely falls under Explanation - II of Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C

    7. The procedure, the Magistrate has to adopt is in crystal clear manner enunciated in the above said Kerala High Court judgment quoted above. In the said case also, on facts, the police have filed the chargesheet for the offences involving non-cognizable offences the Magistrate did not apply his judicial mind to ascertain whether report of Police Officer relating to a non-cognizable offence can be taken note of and cognizance can be taken on that report itself or whether re-investigation has to be ordered under Section 202 of Cr.P.C or whether it could be treated as a complaint under Section 2(h) and Section 190(1)(a) of Cr.P.C and cognizance could be taken.

    8. In this Particular case also the similar set of facts are involved. The police have submitted chargesheet under Sections 504 and 50C of I.P.C The Magistrate, it appears, has not at all perused the contents of chargesheet papers. He has not applied his judicial mind in order to ascertain whether the said report submitted by police has to be treated as a complaint under Section 2(h) of Cr.P.C or whether under Section 202 of Cr.P.C further investigation is required, by treating the Police Officer as a complainant or whether on the basis of said report treating it as a complaint under Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C whether the Magistrate can take cognizance of the offence and issue summons to the accused persons. These matters appear to have not been observed by the Magistrate as rightly contended by learned counsel for the petitioner.

    9. The learned Additional State Public Prosecutor tried to persuade this Court by producing a ruling of Hon'ble Supreme Court reported in - 1996 SCC (Cri) 1387, between State of Orissa v. Sharat Chandra Sahu.

    10. In the above judgment the Hon'ble Supreme Court while dealing with Section 155(4) of Cr.P.C has laid down certain principles at Paragraph 11 and 12. In the said case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has nevertheless observed that when the offences alleged comprising of both cognizable and non-cognizable offences the entire matter has to be treated as cognizable only and the police have no option, but to investigate the whole case and submit a chargesheet in respect of all the offences, both cognizable or non-cognizable. Provided, it is found by the police during investigation that the offences prima facie appear to have been committed.

    11. But in this Particular case Section 2(d) of Cr.P.C and proviso attached to that has not been considered by Hon'ble Supreme Court and it is also not narrated in the said judgment that what should happen after filing of the report by police and whether the Magistrate can directly issue process against the accused persons. Therefore, the said ruling cited by learned Additional State Public Prosecutor in a straight jacket manner not applicable to the present facts and circumstances of the case, wherein the Kerala High Court judgment makes it clear that what the Magistrate has to do after a chargesheet comprising of only non-cognizable offences is filed by police.

    12. Under the above said circumstances, I am of the opinion that the matter requires to be reconsidered by Magistrate after going through the above said rulings cited in the body of this order. In view of the above, the order passed by Magistrate dated 05.10.2013 requires to be set aside, accordingly, the said order is set aside and matter stands remitted to Magistrate to pass appropriate orders after going through the rulings cited in the body of this order and the observations made by this Court. Accordingly, petition is disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Gururaj v. State Of Karnataka
    (Jan 22, 2014)