Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 48 of the Gift Tax Act, reads as under:48. Section 21 of the Amending Act has amended section 15 of the Gift-tax Act
  • section 15(6) read with Rules 11A of the Income Tax Act.
  • section 15(6) read with Rule 11A of the Income Tax Act
  • provision of section 21 of the Amending Act
  • provisions of section 4(1)(a) of Gift-tax Act
  • provisions of sec. 4(1)(a) of the G.T> Act
  • Gift-tax Rules or Wealth-tax Rules.
  • WEALTH TAX ACT
  • sec. 16(1) of the Gift Tax Act
  • provisions of section 4(1)
  • GIFT TAX ACT
  • INCOME TAX ACT
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 48 of the Gift Tax Act, reads as under:48. Section 21 of the Amending Act has amended section 15 of the Gift-tax Act
  • section 15(6) read with Rules 11A of the Income Tax Act.
  • section 15(6) read with Rule 11A of the Income Tax Act
  • provision of section 21 of the Amending Act
  • provisions of section 4(1)(a) of Gift-tax Act
  • provisions of sec. 4(1)(a) of the G.T> Act
  • Gift-tax Rules or Wealth-tax Rules.
  • WEALTH TAX ACT
  • sec. 16(1) of the Gift Tax Act
  • provisions of section 4(1)
  • GIFT TAX ACT
  • INCOME TAX ACT

    A.C Of Gift Tax (S) v. Sarabhai Pvt. Ltd. Opponent(S)

    K.S Jhaveri, J.:— By way of this appeal, the appellant has challenged the judgment and order dated 23.9.1999 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Ahmedabad Bench ‘B’, Ahmedabad in G.T.A No. 10.Ahd/1994 for assessment year 1985-86.

    2. While admitting this appeal on 6.11.2000, this Court has framed the following substantial question of law:

    “Whether the appellate tribunal is right in law and on facts in deleting gift tax levied by invoking the provisions of section 4(1) of the Gift Tax Ac and in doing so, erred in interpreting section 15(6) read with Rule 11A of the Income Tax Act and the Rules?”

    3. The facts of the present case are that the assessee has filed return of Gift Tax on 31.5.1991 The notice under sec. 16(1) of the Gift Tax Act was issued to the assessee. In response to the said notice, the assessee has shown the value gift made during the previous year at Rs. Nil. Thereafter, after considering the material on record, the assessment order came to be passed. Against the said assessment order, an appeal before the CIT(A) has been preferred by the assessee which was allowed. Against the said order of CIT(A), the Revenue has preferred an appeal before the ITAT which was dismissed, against which, the present Tax Appeal is preferred by the Revenue before this Court.

    4. Heard the learned advocates appearing for the parties and considered the submissions. Learned advocate for the appellant has taken us through both the orders, the order passed by CIT(A) as well as Tribunal and has submitted that the Tribunal has wrongly interpreted section 15(6) read with Rules 11A of the Income Tax Act. The Rules do no specifically provide that the lesser of the two figures 50,000/- or 33% of the declared value is to be adopted, inspite of that, the Tribunal has observed contrary to the provisions. However, learned advocate for the respondent has submitted that the Tribunal has followed the decision of the Calcutta High Court in the case of GTO v. V. Foils Ltd. reported in 124 ITR 660 (Cal) and the decision of the Madras High Court in the case of CGT v. Indo Traders & Agencies (Madras) Pvt. Ltd., reported in 131 ITR 313 and now the issue is squarely covered by the decision of the Apex Court in the case of Reva Investment Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Gift-Tax, reported in 249 ITR 337. Learned advocate for the appellant has made an endeavor to take us through reasons and object as to why the provision has been introduced. Section 48 of the Gift Tax Act, reads as under:

    “48. Section 21 of the Amending Act has amended section 15 of the Gift-tax Act which a view to enabling the Gift-tax officer to refer the valuation of any property transferred by way of gift to the Valuation Officer for ascertaining the market value of such property. References under the new provision will lie only after 31st December, 1972, as the provision of section 21 of the Amending Act will come into force with effect from 1 January, 1973.

    Under the new provision, the Gift-tax Officer may refer the valuation of any property to a Valuation Officer in a case where the assessee has got the property valued by a registered valuer and the Gift-tax Officer is of opinion that the value as estimated by the registered valuer (i.e a person registered a valuer under section 34AB of the Wealth-tax Act) is less than the fair market value of the asset. Other cases in which a reference may be made to the Valuation Officer would be where the Gift tax Officer is of opinion that the fair market value of the property exceeds the value of the property as returned by more than 33 1/3rd of the value returned or by more than Rs. 50,000, whichever is less, or where, having regard to the nature of the property and other relevant circumstances, the Gift-tax Officer considers it necessary to do so.”

    5. The CIT(A) in para 2.5 and 2.6 has observed as under:

    “2.5 There is no doubt that the gift tax proceedings are different than proceedings under Income-tax Act. Even then the fact that no adverse inference has been drawn in the Income-tax proceedings during the assessment as well as acquisition proceedings it will look arbitrary to draw such inference under the Gift-tax Act. Because a person will under state the actual consideration only to save capital gains tax generally. If it is found that there has been no avoidance or evasion of capital gains tax it may not appear very logical to say that the consideration is under stated for the purpose of Gift-tax Act. For this reason also the Assessing Officer was not justified in applying the provisions of section 4(1)(a) of Gift-tax Act in this case.

    2.6 Coming to the legal aspect of the case it is seen that the obitery by the Hon'ble High Court in the case of Venesta Foils Ltd. (supra) makes it very clear that when a transfer is between a holding and subsidiary company there is no gift. It will be pertinent to reproduce the obitery of the Hon'ble Court- “Gift basically is a transfer by one person to another person. In this case there was really no such transfer since the V.G Ltd, the alleged donor owned all dhstr of the Ltd. the alleged dones. Viewed in this light also there was no gift in respect of impugned transaction as defined in Sec.2 clause (xii).” I would therefore hold that the addition made by the Assessing Officer in this case is neither sustainable on facts not in law. I would therefore, delete the addition of Rs. 34,99,000/-.”

    6. The Tribunal, in paras 6, 7, and 8 has observed as under:

    “6. We have carefully considered the facts and circumstances of the case as well as the rival contentions made before us. It is well settled that provisions of sec. 4(1)(a) of the G.T> Act cannot be invoked in for case of transactions which are bonafide and no attempt of evasion of tax is discernible. If the consideration which passed between the parties can be considered to be reasonable or fair, it cannot be considered to be inadequate. Adequate consideration is not necessarily that is ultimately determined by someone else as market value. Their lordship of the Madras High Court observed in CGT v. India Traders and Agencies 131 ITR 313 that unless the price realised for transfer was such as to shock the conscious of the Court, if would not be possible to hold that the transaction is otherwise than for adequate consideration. Rule 11A of the GT Rules as well as rule 3B of the WT Rules fairly bring out the legislative intention for accepting the declared value of an asset for the purposes of wealth tax and gift assessments if the difference between the declared value and the fair market value is less than 33 1/3% or Rs. 50,000/-. In the instant case, the market value as determined by the DVO under the W.T Act as on 31.3.84 is Rs. 178.49 lakhs whereas the realised value shown by the assessee is Rs. 143.50 lakhs. The difference being merely Rs. 35 lakhs which is much less than the percentage prescribed in Gift-tax Rules or Wealth-tax Rules. The Ld. Dr. made a valiant effect to support the department's case by pointing out that since the difference is more than 50,000/- in the instant case, rule 11A of the GT Rules is attracted.

    7. We are not impressed with this argument. Rules do not specifically provide that the lesser of the two figures 50,000 or 1/3% of the declared value is to be adopted. There is therefore, no justification for rewriting the rule by adding the words “whichever is less”. The well accepted rules of interpretation of statutes expressly negate any such construction. It appears to us that the amount of Rs. 50,000 is mentioned in the aforesaid rules under the statutes so as to obviate the possibility of references of small cases by the AO to the valuation cell. The percentage of 33 1/3% indicated in the rules appears to lay down the standard of acceptability of the declared value for the purposes of wealth-tax and gift tax assessments. In our opinion the transaction in question involving sale of Kashmir House by the assessee to its 100% subsidiary is a bonafide transaction and does not reflect any attempt of tax evasion on the part of the assessee company. It is further to be noted that the valuation being relied upon by the Ao for treating the transfer as a deemed gift has been made under the WT Act estimating the market value as on 31.3.84 We find merit in the contention of the ld. counsel that the property in question was partly occupied by legal tenants and the comparable transactions replied upon by the DVO in respect of vacant properties do not afford a fair and reasonable basis for estimating the market value in assessee's case.

    8. Regarding the reliance placed by the ld. Counsel on the decision of Calcutta High Court in the case of V. Foils Ltd. we find that the ld. Judges observed at page 673 that gift is basically a transfer by one person to another person and no such transfer is involved if the donor viz. V. Foils Ltd. owns all the share of the alleged dones viz. India Foils Ltd. However, the decision of the High Court has not been based on this premise as specifically pointed out by their Lordships. This decision may therefore render no direct support to the assessee's case. However, the circumstance that the transderee in the instant case is a 100% subsidiary company and the difference in the sale consideration and the market value estimated by the DVO is much less than the prescribed percentage of 33 1/3% as per rule 11A of the GT Rules support the bonafide of transaction. In our opinion, this is not a fit case for invoking the provisions of sec. 4(1)(a) of the GT Act for treating the sale transaction as a deemed gift. For the reasons as discussed above we uphold the order of CGT(A) and dismiss the appeal of the revenue.”

    7. In view of concurrent finding, and more particularly, the finding recorded by CIT(A) in para 2.5 and 2.6 and the finding recorded by Tribunal in paras no. 6, 7 and 8, as well as the decision of the Calcutta High Court in the case of GTO v. V. Foils Ltd. reported in 124 ITR 660 (Cal) as reproduced hereinabove, the appeal deserves to be dismissed. We are in complete agreement with the view taken by the Tribunal. The question is answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. The present Tax Appeal is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    A.C Of Gift Tax (S) v. Sarabhai Pvt. Ltd. Opponent(S)
    (Nov 24, 2014)