Aikman, J.:— This case was called for on a perusal of the Sessions Statement of the Gorakhpur District for the month of October 1905.
2. The accused Nageshwar went with six or seven other men to steal melons during the night: The men who Were watehing the field were struck by two of the thieves and one got his jaw fractured. The learned Judge finds tha the accused was not one of the two men who inflicted the injuries. But, apparently relying on the decision of this Court of Queen-Empress v. Mohabir Tevari (I.L.R, 21 All., 263), the learned Judge applied the provisions of section 397 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced Nagesh-war to seven years' rigorous imprisonment. The learned Judge was apparently not aware that the decision above referred to was overruled in the Case of Queen-Empress v. Senta (Weekly Notes, 1899, p. 187). According to this latter ruling Nageshwar was not liable to the provisions df section 397. The accused has all along admitted his guilt, and he is already guilty of an offence under section 395; But having regard to the circumstances he does not, in my opinion, deserve so severe a sentence as that which has been imposed on him. I reduce it to a term of three years rigorous imprisonment.