Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges

    Kudaon v. Emperor Opposite Party.

    Prideaux, A.J.C:— This judgment disposes of Criminal Appeals Nos. 245 to 249 of 1924, the appellants being Kudaon walad Gariba, Nirpatia walad Ganesh, Halka walad Dhansingh, Girdhari walad Behari and Mujia walad Param, all residents of mauza Hura, in the Saugor district. They were committed to the Sessions Court, Saugor, on a charge of murder for killing one Damroo Chamar on the evening of the 26th June last.

    2. The learned Sessions Judge, when the case reached him, added a Charge against each accused under S. 201 of the Indian Penal Code.

    3. The Judge finds that the evidence as regards the offence of murder was insufficient to warrant the conviction of the present five appellants. But he has convicted them under S. 201 of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced each accused to 4 years' rigorous imprisonment.

    4. I am of opinion that these convictions cannot stand. It has to be remembered that the present appellants were said or believed to have committed this murder and there is authority that in such a case the accused cannot be convicted under S. 201 of the Indian Penal Code. In Empress v. Ghisia Kewat [1899] 12 C.P L.R Cr. 17. Sir Stanley Ismay, J., held that S. 201 of the Indian Penal Code does not apply to a criminal causing evidence of his own crime to disappear but to a person who screens the actual offender, and no question of abetment can possibly arise.” The section itself seems to me to make it clear that the above is the correct interpretation of the law. As stated in Torap Ali v. Queen-Empress [1895] 22 Cal. 638, quoting Reg v. Kashinath Dinkar [1871] 8 B.H.C.R Cr. 126, “S. 201 and the two following sections commence with precisely the same words thus: ‘Whoever knowing or having reason to believe that an offence has been committed.’ Now, as there is no law which obliges a criminal to give information which would convict himself, it is evident that Ss. 202 and 203 could not apply to the person who committed that offence, i.e, the offence which he knew had been committed and S. 201 should be construed in a similar manner and looking at the only illustration which follows S. 201, it would appear that the law was intended to apply exclusively to ‘another,’ and that the conviction of the accused as accessories to an offence known or believed to have been committed by themselves, is illegal.” The learned Judges who disposed of Torap Ali v. Queen-Empress [1895] 22 Cal. 638, referred to five separate rulings in support of their opinion, and their view has been followed in this Court in the case in Empress v. Ghasia Kewat [1899] 12 C.P L.R Cr. 17, already referred to.

    5. Even if I held a contrary opinion, I do not think that in the present case the convictions under S. 201 could stand. The evidence in the case certainly does not establish that Damroo was killed, and the learned standing counsel for the Crown admits that on the evidence on record he cannot say that Damroo was killed. Again, there is no reliable evidence that Damroo's body was carried to the spot said to have been pointed out by the five accused and cremated there. Here we have a case of five accused. Kudaon is first to have confessed to the police and to have agreed to point out the place where the body was burnt. Then the other accused did the same thing, and all five are said to have pointed out the exact spot. Now, in my opinion, Section 27 of the Evidence Act has to be very strictly construed. In a case like the present, where one accused has agreed to point out a place where a fact would be discovered in pursuance of his statement to point out that place, the section does not cover similar statements of the other accused in police custody. Ashes and minute fragments of bones were found on the spot pointed out. But the Chemical Examiner's report states that the fragments of bones were too small to be identified as human. Therefore, strictly speaking, it cannot be said that the pointing out of the burning-place by any of the accused would establish that a human corpse had been burnt at the spot. It is un-necessary to go into the matter further for I am distinctly of opinion that the conviction of the five appellants is not warranted either by law or by the evidence against them.

    6. The result is that I set aside the conviction and sentence in the case of each of the five appellants and direct that, unless any of them are being detained for other offences, they be set at liberty.

    7. Convictions set aside.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kudaon v. Emperor Opposite Party.
    (Dec 19, 1924)