AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 51 of the Madras Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act, 1961
  • Section 100 while Rule 22 was similar to Rule 69.
  • Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • Section 51. Likewise, Rule 22 of the rules
  • Section 100 read with Rule 69(7)
  • Co-operative Societies Act.
  • court.9. Rule 69(7)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 51 of the Madras Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act, 1961
  • Section 100 while Rule 22 was similar to Rule 69.
  • Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • Section 51. Likewise, Rule 22 of the rules
  • Section 100 read with Rule 69(7)
  • Co-operative Societies Act.
  • court.9. Rule 69(7)
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Second Appeal arising from O.S. No. 579 of 1971

Factual and Procedural Background

The suit (O.S. No. 579 of 1971) was filed in the District Munsif Court, Madurai, seeking a declaration and mandatory injunction. The plaintiff alleged that the suit properties originally belonged to the 3rd defendant (F. Malaya Gounder). The 2nd defendant had obtained a decree against the 3rd defendant in O.S. 359 of 1968, following which the suit properties were attached in execution (E.P. 85 of 1969) and brought to sale on 23-2-1970. The plaintiff purchased the properties at that court sale for Rs. 1300 (subject to encumbrances) and the sale was confirmed on 30-4-1970. Delivery in execution (E.A. No. 564 of 1970) was effected on 6-6-1970 and recorded on 8-6-1970; the plaintiff relied on patta and kist receipts to show possession and enjoyment.

Separately, the first defendant (a Co-operative Society) had obtained an award decree in A.R.C. 141 of 1968 and, in execution of that award, purchased the same property on 24-11-1969. When the plaintiff attempted to take possession he was obstructed by the first defendant, which led to the present suit.

The District Munsif initially decreed in favour of the plaintiff, preferring the court sale over the society's sale and holding that Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act did not oust civil jurisdiction. On appeal (A.S. No. 332 of 1972) the Subordinate Judge reversed that decree and set it aside. The present proceeding is the second appeal from that appellate decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the provisions of Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act (read with Rule 69(7)) exclude the jurisdiction of the civil courts to challenge or set aside a sale executed pursuant to an award under the Act.
  2. Between two competing sales of the same property (the Co-operative Society's earlier sale in execution of an award and the later court sale), which sale must prevail.
  3. Whether the sale in favour of the Co-operative Society can be impeached in a civil suit on grounds of fraud, illegality or irregularity.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (plaintiff who purchased at court sale)

  • Section 100's bar to civil jurisdiction should not be invoked because, relying on later Supreme Court authority (Raja Kandregula...), the statutory provisions had not been complied with; where statutory procedure is not complied with the civil court's jurisdiction remains available.
  • The Co-operative Society's sale ought not to prevail because it was vitiated by fraud and illegality; in any event the plaintiff has been in possession and enjoyment since the date of his purchase (supported by patta and kist receipts, Exhibits A.15–A.18 and A.19–A.22).

Respondent's Arguments (first defendant / Co-operative Society)

  • The society's sale is prior in point of time (24-11-1969) compared with the plaintiff's later court sale (confirmed 30-4-1970), and therefore the society's title must prevail.
  • There is no evidence to show the society's sale was vitiated by fraud or illegality.
  • The bar under Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act read with Rule 69(7) validly ousts the civil court's jurisdiction to question the award/sale.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Raja Kandregula Srinivasa Jagannadharao Panthulu Bahadur Garu v. State of Andhra Pradesh, (1969) 3 SCC 71 : AIR 1971 SC 71 Sets out grounds on which civil court jurisdiction is excluded where a statute gives finality to orders of a special tribunal; exclusion may not apply where statutory provisions are not complied with or tribunal has not followed fundamental judicial procedures. The court held the appellant's reliance on this case to be misconceived because this record did not show non-compliance with rules nor failure of the statutory tribunal to act in accordance with fundamental principles of judicial procedure; therefore the exception identified in that precedent did not apply here.
K. Satyanarayana v. Motu Industries (P) Ltd., (1963) 1 Andh WR 323 Interpreted corresponding provisions in earlier legislation (Section 48 of the old Act and Rule 22) and held that civil courts could not challenge awards/sales under the Act; procedure under the Act provides remedies and bars civil jurisdiction. The court relied on this decision by analogy to conclude that the present Act's Section 100 and Rule 69(7) also exclude civil court jurisdiction to challenge sales made in execution of awards.
Venkata Subbiah v. Perriah, 1951-2 Mad LJ 269 : AIR 1952 Mad 266 Held that sales in execution of awards of Co-operative Societies cannot be attacked in civil courts for fraud, irregularity or illegality; civil courts lack jurisdiction to entertain such challenges. The court noted that the lower court relied on this authority and treated it as supportive of the conclusion that the civil court's jurisdiction is barred in the present facts.
Ramayya v. Chittoor Dt. Co-operative Dy. Registrar, ILR (1946) Mad 330 : AIR 1945 Mad 370 Similar principle to Venkata Subbiah — sale in execution of co-operative awards cannot be impeached in civil courts; procedure under the Act provides exclusive remedies. The court treated this decision as directly on point and used it to reinforce the view that the civil court's jurisdiction was excluded and that fraud/irregularity claims could not be pursued in a civil suit under these statutory provisions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two main stages: (A) a determination on the merits as to which sale must prevail; and (B) an examination of the jurisdictional bar raised under Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act read with Rule 69(7).

(A) Priority of Sales and Merits

  • The court found the Co-operative Society's sale dated 24-11-1969 was prior in time to the court sale under which the plaintiff obtained title (confirmed 30-4-1970).
  • On that factual basis the court held that the prior sale in favour of the Co-operative Society had to prevail: if the civil court had been informed of the earlier sale there would have been no occasion for a subsequent court sale because the judgment debtor had already lost all rights, title and interest.
  • The court concluded that, on merits, the earlier sale prevailed irrespective of the jurisdictional issue.

(B) Jurisdiction under Section 100 and Rule 69(7)

  • The court examined the appellant's contention that the civil court's jurisdiction could not be ousted where statutory procedure had not been complied with (relying on the Supreme Court decision in Raja Kandregula).
  • After reviewing the facts and record, the court concluded there was no non-compliance with the statutory provisions and no departure from fundamental principles of judicial procedure by the statutory tribunal that would bring the case within the exception outlined in Raja Kandregula.
  • The court quoted Section 100 (which expressly bars calling in question in any court orders of award, decisions or actions under the Act) and Rule 69(7) (making orders final and not liable to be questioned in suits or legal proceedings), treating both as creating finality and ousting civil jurisdiction.
  • The court relied on prior Madras/Andhra decisions (K. Satyanarayana; Venkata Subbiah; Ramayya) interpreting analogous provisions under earlier legislation to support the proposition that sales in execution of awards under the Act cannot be attacked in civil courts, even on grounds of fraud or irregularity.
  • Turning to the specific allegations of fraud and illegality, the court found that no evidence had been led by the plaintiff to prove fraud, illegality or irregularity in the society's sale. The appellant's assertion that the society's president and the third defendant were closely related did not suffice to infer clandestine or fraudulent conduct.
  • Accordingly, even if the civil court's jurisdiction were assumed, there was no evidentiary basis to set aside the society's sale.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The second appeal is DISMISSED.

Consequences and implications drawn from the opinion (as stated by the court):

  • Direct effect: The sale in favour of the Co-operative Society (dated 24-11-1969) is upheld as valid and prevails over the later court sale obtained by the plaintiff; the plaintiff's attempt to disturb that sale in a civil suit failed for want of both jurisdiction (under Section 100 and Rule 69(7)) and evidence of fraud or irregularity.
  • Jurisdictional implication: Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act, read with Rule 69(7), operates to exclude civil court jurisdiction to call in question awards and sales made in execution of those awards, unless the exceptional circumstances identified in the Supreme Court authority (non-compliance with statutory procedure or fundamental procedural failures) are shown — which were not demonstrated here.
  • Costs and procedural note: The court ordered that there be no order as to costs and refused leave. No new legal precedent was purportedly set; the decision rests on application of existing statutory provisions and established precedents.

Disposition: Appeal dismissed. No order as to costs. No leave.

    Krishnaswami Gounder v. A. 2190 Jambuthurai Kottai Co-Operative Society And Others

    1. O.S No. 579 of 1971 was preferred before the file of District Munsif, Madurai, for declaration and mandatory injunction and the plaintiff's allegations are briefly as follows—

    The suit properties originally belonged to F. Malaya Gounder the 3rd defendant. The second defendant had obtained a decree against the 3rd defendant in O.S 359 of 1968 on the file of the District Munsif Court, Madurai. The suit properties were attached in execution of his decree in E.P 85 of 1969 on 8-3-1969 and were brought to sale on 23-2-1970. The plaintiff purchased it for Rupees 1300 subject to the encumbrance and the sale was confirmed on 30-4-1970. E.A No. 564 of 1970 was filed for delivery of the properties and the same was effected on 6-6-1970, and the delivery was also recorded as on 8-6-1970. Ever since the date he had been in possession and enjoyment of the properties is seen from the patta and kist receipts. While that being so, the first defendant obtained an award decree in A.R.C 141 of 1968 before the Deputy Registrar of Co-operative Societies and in execution of that award he came to purchase the property on 24-11-1969 itself. When the plaintiff wanted to take delivery of the possession he was obstructed by the first defendant and his men and hence the suit.

    2. The first defendant filed a written statement stating as follows. The property has been purchased by this society on 24-11-1969 itself in execution of the award decree obtained against the 3rd defendant and that therefore any subsequent sale in favour of the plaintiff, be it a court sale, will not divest the title of the first defendant and as between the competing titles, the title of the society ought to be preferred it being earlier in point of time. It is a valid sale, by which the property had already been sold and therefore the plaintiff derived no title. The learned District Munsif of Madurai who tried the suit decreed in favour of the plaintiff holding that the court sale ought to be preferred to that for the sale in execution of the award obtained under the Co-operative Societies Act. He also held that the bar under Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act, 1961 could not oust jurisdiction of the civil court.

    3. On appeal, in A.S No. 332 of 1972, the learned Subordinate Judge of Madurai reversed the finding and set aside the decree. Against this, the present second appeal has come to be preferred.

    4. Mr. Balasubramaniam, learned counsel for the appellant, contends that the finding of the lower appellate court about the bar of jurisdiction under Section 100 is incorrect in view of the later judgments of the Supreme Court and one such is in Raja kandregula Srinivasa Jagannadharao Panthulu Bahadur Garu v. State of Andhra Pradesh, (1969) 3 SCC 71 : AIR 1971 SC 71. At page 73 their Lordships of the Supreme Court set out the grounds on which the jurisdiction of the civil court should be excluded. The first ground mentioned is:

    “1. Where the statute gives a finality to the orders of the special tribunal the civil court's jurisdiction must be held to be excluded if there is adequate remedy to do what the civil courts would normally do in a suit. Such provision, however, does not exclude those cases where the provisions of the particular Act have not been complied with or the statutory tribunal has not acted in conformity with the fundamental principles of judicial procedure.”

    5. Relying on the above principles, it is contended that the provisions of the Act have not been complied with and therefore the bar under Section 100 of the Co-operative Societies Act cannot be invoked as against the appellant. It is further submitted by the learned counsel that his sale ought to be preferred since the sale by the Society, in favour of itself, is vitiated by fraud and illegality. Lastly it is submitted that from the date of purchase, the plaintiff was alone in possession and enjoyment as seen from Exs. A. 15 to A. 18, the patta issued in his favour and Exs. A. 19 to A. 22 the kist receipts.

    6. Per contra Mr. N.S Srinivasan submits that his sale is prior in point of time, namely, 24-11-1969 while that of the plaintiff is later. There is absolutely no evidence to show that the sale is in any way vitiated by fraud or illegality. The bar under Sec. 100 read with R. 69(7) could be validly invoked in this case.

    7. On a careful consideration of the above submissions, I come to the following conclusions:

    1. The sale in favour of the Co-operative Society is dated 24-11-1969 while the sale under which the plaintiff got title is dated 30-4-1970. Undoubtedly therefore the prior sale in favour of the Co-operative Society has to prevail. If the civil court had been informed of the earlier sale there would not have been an occasion for the court sale at all because in view of the previous sale in favour of the Co-operative Society the judgment debtor namely 3rd defendant had lost all his rights, title and interest in the suit property and therefore the court sale could not convey any right in favour of the plaintiff. So on merits, there is no difficulty in concluding that the first sale has to prevail, irrespective of the fact whether the civil court has jurisdiction or not.

    8. Inasmuch as the point relating to the jurisdiction has been elaborately argued I also think it necessary to deal with the same. The reliance placed in Sree Raja Kandregula Srinivasa Jagannadharao Pantulu Bahadur Garu v. State of Andhra Pradesh, (1969) 3 SCC 71 : AIR 1971 SC 71, by the learned counsel for the appellant is misconceived. This is not a case in which there is any non-compliance with provisions of rule nor again is this the cast where statutory tribunal has not acted in conformity with the fundamental principles of judicial procedure. In fact, the first half of the provision extracted above will clearly govern this case. It is stated there—

    “Where the statute gives a finality to the orders of the special tribunal the civil courts' jurisdiction must be held to be excluded if there is adequate remedy to do what the civil courts would normally do in a suit…… “In this connection, I find the reliance placed on Section 100 read with Rule 69(7) by the learned counsel for the respondent is well founded. Section 100 states as follows—

    “No order of award passed, decision or action taken or direction issued under this Act by an arbitrator, a liquidator, the Registrar or an officer authorised or empowered by him, the Tribunal or the Government or any officer subordinate to them, shall be liable to be called in question in any court.”

    9. Rule 69(7) is to the following effect—

    “All orders made under the rule shall subject only to the provisions of Section 97 be final and shall not be liable to be questioned in any suit or other legal proceeding.”

    10. Apart from there being a finality, there is an ouster of the jurisdiction of the civil court. In a case reported in K. Satyanarayana v. Motu Industries, (P) Ltd., (1963) 1 Andh WR 323, the provisions of the previous Act came up for interpretation. Section 48 of the old Act corresponded to the present Section 100 while Rule 22 was similar to Rule 69. In such a case, after referring to various decisions regarding exclusion of the jurisdiction of the civil court it was held as follows—

    “It is not open to the plaintiff to challenge the correctness of the award passed by the Deputy Registrar under Section 51 of the Madras Co-operative Societies Act, or the sale held pursuant to the said award. The Act has, under Section 57 empowered the Registrar and the State Government to correct the decisions embodied in awards under Section 51. Section 51(6) expressly bars the jurisdiction of civil and revenue courts to call in question the decision under Section 51. Likewise, Rule 22 of the rules made under the Act provides the procedure to be followed in execution of an award passed under Section 51, and also for setting aside the sales on the ground of material irregularity or fraud. The jurisdiction of the civil courts to set aside the sale is also barred. Therefore, suit for declaration that the sale is void and not binding on the plaintiff and other creditors is barred by the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act.”

    11. It may be noted that the learned Judge who decided the case relied on the decision of this court in Venkata Subbiah v. Perriah, 1951-2 Mad LJ 269 : (AIR 1952 Mad 266) wherein Panchapagesa Sastri, J. following the earlier decision in Ramayya v. Chittoor Dt. Co-operative Dy. Registrar, ILR (1946) Mad 330 : (AIR 1945 Mad 370) held—

    “that a sale in execution of awards of Co-operative Societies cannot be attacked by a suit in a civil court either on the ground of fraud or irregularity in the conduct of the sale or even illegality, and the civil court has no jurisdiction to go into such matters.” I find the court below has relied upon the last of the decisions namely Ramabakthula Ramayya v. Chittoor Dt. Co-operative Registrar, ILR (1946) Mad 330 : (AIR 1945 Mad 370) which is also on point. In this view I have no hesitation in holding that the jurisdiction of the civil court is excluded in the present case. Assuming that the civil court has jurisdiction I find that no evidence whatsoever has been let in on behalf of the plaintiff to prove that the sale in favour of the Co-operative Society was vitiated by fraud, illegality or irregularity. On this aspect of this matter I am in entire agreement with the finding of the lower appellate court which states in paragraph 8 of its judgment:

    “In the first place I may point out that there is absolutely no evidence worth the name on the side of the plaintiffs to show that the sale was vitiated by any fraud, illegality or irregularity.”

    12. Further it is contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the president of the first defendant Society and the third defendant are close relations and therefore it can easily be inferred that the sale was done in a clandestine way and fraudulent manner. This is too tall a statement and I cannot accept the same.

    13. In the absence of evidence regarding fraud, illegality or irregularity it must be held that the sale in favour of the Co-operative Society is valid one.

    14. For the above reasons I hold that the second appeal is liable to be dismissed. Accordingly the same is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs. No leave.

    15. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishnaswami Gounder v. A. 2190 Jambuthurai Kottai Co-Operative Society And Others
    (Jul 18, 1975)