Mrs. Amareshwari, J.:— The Petitioner was appointed as a Clerk in Postal Department in Guntur Division on 10-2-1955 as against a reserved vacancy for scheduled castes and scheduled tribes. He claimed that he belonged to Konda-Kapu Community. In support of his claim, he filed and extract of the first page of the S.S.L.C Register dated 29-1-1950 showing his Page: 371community as Konda-Kapu and also a certificate of the Assistant Collector, Vizianagaram dated 7-7-1953 to the effect that he is a resident of Srungavarapukota and he belongs to Konda-Kapu Community. As per paragraph 47 of the Brochure on Reservation for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Services (hereinafter referred to as the Brochure) any one of these two certificates is enough to prove the claim of a candidate in regard to his community. He was confirmed in the said post on 1-1-1959. In 1964 he was promoted as an Inspector of Post Offices, which is selection post as against a reserved vacancy. He was also confirmed in the said post in 1170.
2. While so, during the year 1973, the petitioner was asked by the authorities to produce proof of his community as Konda-Kapu i.e, after a period of 23 years from the date of his initial appointment. The petitioner again produced the very same certificates, which he produced at the time of initial appointment, namely, the extract of the first page of his S.S.L.C Register and the certificate of the Assistant Collector, Vizianagaram dated 7-7-1953. After a period of two years, the Superintendent of Post Offices, Karinada division the third respondent herein initiated disciplinary proceedings under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 and issued a charge memo on 16-6-1975 alleging that enquiries through the Collector, Visakhapatnam as per his letter dated 10-5-1974 revealed that the petitioner belongs to Telaga Caste and that the caste certificate dated 7-7-1953 submitted by him at the time of his initial appointment in 1955 was false. The petitioner submitted his explanation. One Mr. N.L Rao was appointed as Enquiry Officer to enquire into the charges levelled against the petitioner. A full-fledged enquiry was held into the question whether the petitioner belongs to Konda-Kapu Community and whether the Certificate filed by him at the time of his initial appointment is a genuine one. Several witnesses were examined during the course of the enquiry. The Enquiry Officer found that the charge levelled against the petitioner was not proved. By a Memo No. SP/Con/7.AGR dated 23-6-1976 the petitioner was informed by the third respondent that the charges framed on 16-6-1975 are dropped. Within a year thereafter i.e on 16-6-1976, the petitioner was again asked to furnish a fresh community certificate to the effect that he belongs to Konda-Kapu Community. The petitioner once again submitted a representation on 27-9-1976 that the community certificate dated 7-7-1953 which was already submitted twice was proved genuine in the departmental enquiry and requested the authorities to intimate to him the circumstances under which he is asked to produce a fresh community certificate. It is averred by the petitioner that there was no reply for this representation. Thereafter, on 16-11-1976 the 1st respondent promoted one Ramakrishna Rao, the 4th respondent herein, to the Higher Selection Grade II, who is a junior to the petitioner against a reserved vacancy of scheduled community ignoring the seniority of the petitioner. The petitioner sent a representation protesting against the promotion of his junior to the next higher post of Selection Grade II. The petitioner also sent several reminders in this regard. On 2-8-1977 the petitioner was informed that his claim that he belongs to Konda-Kapu Community is under verification and that in the meanwhile, he will be provisionally promoted to the Cadre of Higher Selection Grade II subject to the condition that his promotion shall be terminated if his claim that he belongs to the Page: 372Scheduled Tribes Community is not established, that was followed by an order dated 4-8-1977 provisionally promoting the petitioner to the cadre of Higher Selection Grade II. The petitioner protested against this action of provisional promotion. He requested the third respondent to consider his case for promotion as per seniority in the vacancies reserved for Scheduled Tribes Community and promote him unconditionally. Since the authorities did not agree to that proposal, the petitioner expressed his unwillingness to accept the provisional promotion by his representation dated 12-10-77. Thereafter, the petitioner was served with another show-cause notice dated 7-2-1978 proposing to treat him as belonging to other community and not as belonging to Scheduled Caste, mentioning three grounds therein namely; that the petitioner did not produce the community certificate in the prescribed form and from the prescribed authority at the time of his initial appointment in 1955, that even though the charge of producing false community certificate was not proved in the departmental enquiry, the case was taken up with the concerned District Magistrate as per Paragraph 44 of the Brochure and that the Collector, Visakhapatnam by his letters dated 10-8-1974 and 7-11-77 informed that he belongs to Telaga Community and that the Director, Tribal Cultural Research and Training Institute, Hyderabad by his letter dated 28-11-1977 informed that his blood relations belong to Telaga Caste. It is this show-cause notice that is assailed in the present Writ Petition on the ground that it is illegal, arbitrary and vindictive. The petitioner also prayed for declaration that he is entitled to be promoted the next higher category on the basis that he belongs to Konda-Kapu Community with effect from the date on which that junior, the 4th respondent has been promoted to the said post.
3. The main contention advanced on behalf of the petitioner was that the show-cause notice dated 7-2-1978 is illegal and without jurisdiction and is contrary to Paragraphs 47 and 49 of the Brochure. He further contends that the action of the respondents is arbitrary and the authorities have no jurisdiction to conduct successive enquiries in respect of the matter which has been investigated fully, in the absence of any fresh material. On the other hand, it is contended by Mr. Upendralal Wagharay the standing Counsel for the Central Government, that at any time after appointment if the authorities consider it necessary to verify the claim of the candidate regarding his community, they can do so and that at each stage of promotion, the matter can be enquired into as per paragraphs 47 and 49 of the Brochure. It is further submitted that the petitioner cannot as a matter of right ask for promotion to the next higher grade and that in fact, a provisional promotion was offered to him which was refused by the petitioner and therefore, he is not correct in contending that he has not been considered for promotion to the next higher category of Higher Selection Grade II.
4. The sole question for consideration is whether the action of the respondents in issuing the show-cause notice dated 7-2-1978 proposing to treat the petitioner as belonging to other community is justified in law. The second relief claimed by the petitioner namely, that his promotion to the next higher post as against a reserved vacancy would depend upon the answer to the first question. Hence, it is necessary to determine whether the show-cause notice dated 7-2-1978 is justified.
5. The petitioner was originally appointed in the year 1955 as a Clerk as against a reserved vacancy for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Under paragraph 47 of the Brochure, the candidate claiming to be belonging to a Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe has to produce either a Matriculation or School Leaving Certification in support of his claim or a certificate in the Form given in Appendix 15 issued by one of the authorities listed in Appendix 16. The petitioner produced an extract of the first page of the S.S.L.C register wherein it was mentioned that he belongs to Konda-Kapu Community. There is no column in the S.S.L.C register with regard to the place of residence. Hence, there was no mention of the same in the said register. He also filed a certificate of the Assistant Collector, Vizianagaram dated 7-7-1953 to the effect that he belongs to Koda-Kapu Community. In the said certificate, it was mentioned that he was residing at Srungavarapukota. It is on the basis of these two certificates that he was appointed as a Clerk initially. He was confirmed in the said post. He was promoted as the Inspector of Post Offices as against a reserved vacancy in the 1964. Apparently the authorities were satisfied about the genuineness of these certificates and not only accepted the same, but acted upon the same for over a period of 20 years. On 16-6-1975 the petitioner was served with a charge sheet that the Enquiries from the District Collector, Visakhapatnam revealed that he belongs to Telaga Community and that he produced a false certificate regarding his community. Even at that time, there was no reference to the S.S.L.C certificate which was filed by him. In the counter affidavit, it is admitted that the petitioner filed an extract of S.S.L.C Register showing his community as Konda-Kapu.
6. After receiving the explanation from the petitioner, an enquiry officer was appointed and an enquiry was conducted in accordance with the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 and witnesses were examined. In the said enquiry, it was proved that his claim that he belongs to Konda-Kapu Community was not false. It may be noted here that the said charge-sheet was issued on the basis of a report sent by the Collector, Visakhapatnam that the petitioner does not belong to Konda-Kapu Community. The authorities accepted the report of the Enquiry Officer and dropped the charges by its order dated 23-6-1976. The order dated 23-6-1976 has concluded the matter so far as the community of the petitioner is concerned. It is not a summary enquiry that was held. A full-fledged enquiry as contemplated by the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965 was conducted and it was proved that the certificate filed by him was not a false certificate and that the finding was that none of the witnesses were able to show that he does not belong to Konda-Kapu Community. When once that enquiry was over and the charges were dropped, it is not open to the authorities to reopen the issue again and issue another show-cause notice asking the petitioner to show-cause why he should not be treated as belonging to other caste. It may be relevant here to note the grounds mentioned in the show-cause notice dated 7-2-1978. The first ground is that the petitioner did not produce the community certificate in the prescribed form and from the prescribed authority at the time of initial appointment in 1955. It is not the case of the authorities that the certificate produced was not in the prescribed form at the time when the enquiry was conducted in respect Page: 374of his community. They have acted on the said certificate for a period of 23 years by giving him promotion. The only ground on which the charges have framed was that the certificate was a false one and not that it was not in accordance with the form prescribed. Even this allegation does not appear to be correct because even though the certificate was not in the prescribed form, it gives all the necessary information as required in the form. The petitioner's place of residence was mentioned as Srungavarapukota. Further, under paragraph 49 of the Brochure, on verification, the appointing authority feels that the claim is false, his service may be terminated. Such an enquiry was conducted and it was found that the claim was not a false one. The issuance of another show-cause notice on the ground that the certificate was not in the prescribed form and therefore it is proposed to treat the petitioner as a person belonging to other communities and not scheduled tribe is nothing but an arbitrary exercise of power Further, there was no reference to the S.S.L.C register filed by the petitioner showing his caste as Konda-Kapu which it self is enough to prove his community, as provided under paragraph 47 of the Brochure. When once a candidate has been appointed as against a reserved vacancy, the appointing authority can terminate his services only if his claim is false. Having conducted a full-fledged enquiry regarding the community of the petitioner and having dropped the charges in view of the enquiry officer's report, the validity or the genuineness of the certificate dated 7-7-1953 cannot be reopened.
7. The second ground mentioned in the impugned show-cause notice is that the Collector. Visakhapatnam by his letters dated 10-5-1974 and 7-11-1977 informed that the petitioner belongs to Telaga Community. These letters cannot form the basis for issuing the show-cause notice. It was the letter dated 10-5-1974, that was the basis for conducting the earlier enquiry. In the charge-sheet dated 16-6-1975 it was clearly mentioned that action was initiated on the letter written by the Collector, Visakhapatnam on 10-5-1974 in answer to the enquiries made. The earlier charges which were based on the same report were dropped. It is not open to authorities to issue another charge-sheet on the very same report of the Collector, Visakhapatnam. From a perusal of the file, I find that the second letter dated 7-11-1977 of the Collector, Visakhapatnam is to the effect that he has already informed by his letter dated 10-5-1974 that the petitioner belongs to Telaga Community and that it is not known why further references are made. Therefore, by the letter dated 7-11-1977 no further material was furnished by the Collector, Visakhapatnam entitling the authorities to issue another show-cause notice.
8. The third ground mentioned in the impugned show-cause notice, that the Director, Tribal Cultural Research and Training Institute, Hyderabad has stated in his letter dated 29-11-1977 that the blood relations of the petitioner belong to Telaga caste cannot equally be a valid ground for forming the basis for the issue of the impugned show-cause notice. As I am of the opinion that successive enquiries cannot be conducted in respect of the very same matter on the basis of some bagues information. Paragraph 49 of the Brochure contemplates that the claim can be verified through the District Magistrate of the place where the candidate or his family ordinarily resides. In the instant case, the claim was verified through the Magistrate and it is on the basis of the report sent Page: 375by the District Magistrate an enquiry was conducted and in the enquiry, it was proved that the petitioner belongs to Konda-Kaou Community. Any further enquiry into the very same matter on the ground that some other authority has written a letter expressing a doubt about the community is unwarranted. If enquiry after enquiry has to be conducted with reference to the same matter, there will be no end and it results in great prejudice to the parties and unwarrants harrassment. I cannot also accept the contention of the learned Counsel for the respondents that at each stage of promotion, the question regarding the community can be verified when once it was already adjudicated. Once an enquiry was conducted and it was found that the claim of the candidate was genuine, it cannot be re-opened again at the time of promotion to the next higher grade Having regard to the fact that the earlier enquiry conducted in accordance with the Rules ended in favour of the petitioner and charges were dropped, a farther enquiry cannot be conducted. That in my opinion, certainly amounts to arbitrary exercise of power. In these circumstances, the impugned show-cause notice dated 7-2-1978 is quashed. The authorities shall consider the case of the petitioner for promotion to the next higher category treating him as a member belonging to the scheduled Tribe and promote him, if he is qualified, from the date when his junior, the 4th respondent is promoted and give him the seniority on the basis of such promotion.
9. The writ petition is allowed. There will be no order as to costs.
10. Petition allowed.