Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners (Indian citizens repatriated from Sri Lanka under Indo–Sri Lanka pacts) filed a writ petition to quash proceedings recorded as RX No. 206 of 1993.M1 dated 20 May 1993 issued by the fourth respondent (which ordered transfer of certain workers). The writ petition was admitted and an interim stay of the impugned proceedings was granted by this Court on 18 June 1993. The fifth respondent, the Administrator of North Arcot Co-operative Spinning Mills, Ariyur (the "mills"), filed Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17932 of 1993 seeking vacation of that interim stay.

Background facts (as stated in the opinion): the petitioners were repatriated from Sri Lanka in January 1983 and, on directions from the Indian High Commission at Sri Lanka and under the rehabilitation scheme, were appointed as trainees to work in the "B" Unit of the fifth respondent mills. The Government of India and the Government of Tamil Nadu provided financial assistance for establishing the "B" Unit to employ repatriates (see G.O.Ms No. 410, Industries Department, dated 25 March 1982, and the letters of the Government of India referred therein). The fourth respondent issued the impugned transfer order finding 157 Sri Lankan repatriates in the mills to be excess and ordering their transfer and re-posting to other co-operative spinning mills in the State. The petitioners challenged those transfer proceedings in this Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the impugned transfer proceedings/orders of the fourth respondent dated 20 May 1993 (transferring repatriate workers of the fifth respondent mills to other mills) are legally sustainable in view of the rehabilitation scheme and the Government of India and Government of Tamil Nadu orders that governed employment of repatriates in the "B" Unit.
  2. Whether the interim stay previously granted by this Court should be continued/made absolute pending disposal of the writ petition, or whether it should be vacated (as sought by the fifth respondent/mills).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Sri N.S. Sivam)

  • The petitioners were repatriated from Sri Lanka in January 1983 and were issued individual appointment orders by the First Secretary/Attaché (Rehabilitation) of the Indian High Commission at Sri Lanka indicating passport/family card details and appointment as trainees in the mills.
  • The Special Deputy Collector (Rehabilitation) at Mandapam Camp conveyed the petitioners to the mills; they have worked continuously in the "B" Unit of the mills from 1983 for ten years without break.
  • The Government of Tamil Nadu started the "B" Unit specifically to provide employment to repatriates; repatriates were to be appointed in such units under the rehabilitation scheme.
  • The fifth respondent/mills, allegedly in collusion with local union leaders, refused to make the petitioners permanent and persuaded the fourth respondent to issue the transfer order to deprive the petitioners of their legitimate rights.
  • The transfer order is an en masse transfer passed to "wreak vengeance" and is thus null, void and bad; it would also effectively close the "B" Unit because only repatriates can be appointed to it under the Government orders.
  • The petitioners have deep settled interests (house sites allotted by Government of Tamil Nadu, loans availed and houses built, children studying locally) that would be adversely affected by the transfer.

Fifth Respondent / Mills' Arguments (as advanced by Sri R. Krishnamurthi)

  • The mills were established in 1965 and expanded in 1974; subsequent further expansion did not occur as expected and the mills' capacity in spindles remained limited (the mills had only 30,000 spindles as at the time of argument).
  • The mills recruited 175 Sri Lankan repatriates in 1982 as per government orders, but because of limited expansion and over-commitment, the mills have excess workers and have been operating under loss for the past ten years, with net loss exceeding Rs. 12 crores.
  • A study by the South India Textiles Research Association recommended 600 workers for 30,000 spindles; considering factors like old machinery, the mills concluded 715 workers were required—therefore there was a need to transfer some workers to other co-operative spinning mills to safeguard the mills' interest.
  • The mills recommended the transfer of excess workers to the fourth respondent; the fourth respondent accepted and, after government confirmation, transferred 100 excess repatriates to other mills. The mills attempted to communicate the individual transfer orders (delivered, refused, advertised on notice board, sent by registered post but returned "refused").
  • The mills stated that the transfer order had already been given effect to and informed other co-operative mills; thus, the stay was said to have become infructuous; additionally, during the stay the mills permitted the workers to join duty though they had already been relieved.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reviewed both factual matrix and the applicable governmental orders under the rehabilitation scheme to determine whether prima facie the impugned transfer proceedings were sustainable.

Key factual and documentary foundations relied upon by the Court (as stated in the opinion):

  • G.O.Ms No. 410, Industries Department, dated 25 March 1982 (Government of Tamil Nadu) approving the proposal for setting up the "B" Unit by the mills under expansion programme with financial assistance from the National Co-operative Development Corporation and the Government of India under the rehabilitation scheme.
  • Letters of the Government of India (Ministry of Supply and Rehabilitation, Department of Rehabilitation) referred to in that Government Order, which (the Court noted) sanctioned among other things a straight loan of Rs. 26.25 lakhs to the State Government for investment in the mills' share capital for providing employment to 175 repatriates from Sri Lanka; the State accepted the loan subject to stipulated terms and conditions.
  • The Court also set out (quoting the opinion) the terms and conditions specified by the Government of India for the loan assistance (at one point referring to the amount as Rs. 26.15 lakhs in the formulation of those terms and conditions). Those conditions included (inter alia) obligations that repatriates must be provided employment within 12 months, that a specific agreement be signed prior to release of funds with refund/interest consequences if commitments were not met, and staged terms of training, stipend/minimum wage, and confirmation after 24 months.
  • The appointment order issued by the Indian High Commission (Rehabilitation Cell, Kandy) dated 14 March 1983 explicitly indicated selection for employment in the mills and directions to report to the Special Deputy Collector (Rehabilitation), Mandapam Camp.

Applying those documents to the facts, the Court reasoned as follows:

  1. The petitioners were specifically appointed under the rehabilitation scheme and by virtue of appointment orders and the terms of the rehabilitation scheme (as reflected in G.O.Ms No. 410 and the Government of India letters), their rights to work in the "B" Unit of the mills are protected by those governmental orders.
  2. Clause (iii) of the terms and conditions (as quoted) required repatriates to undergo a six-month training period, then to receive a minimum wage (or equivalent stipend/grant) during the next 18 months, with confirmation after 24 months and parity of wages with other permanent workers thereafter—establishing a framework for eventual permanency for repatriates appointed under the scheme.
  3. The Government of Tamil Nadu's order limited appointment to repatriates for the "B" Units started with repatriation scheme funds; thus, transferring repatriates out of the "B" Unit would undermine that mandate and could effectively close the "B" Unit because non-repatriates cannot be appointed there.
  4. The fourth respondent's transfer of repatriates—on the recommendation of the mills—was found to be in disregard of the specific Government of India and Government of Tamil Nadu orders and the terms and conditions of the rehabilitation scheme. On a prima facie view, the impugned proceedings were therefore not sustainable in law.
  5. The Court also noted the petitioners' settled domestic and financial ties (allotment of house sites by the State, loans taken for house construction that are yet to be fully repaid, children studying locally), which contributed to the balance of convenience favouring continuation of the interim stay.

Based on the foregoing analysis, the Court concluded that a prima facie case had been made out by the petitioners for their retention at the fifth respondent/mills and for making the interim stay absolute (subject to the limited exception described below).

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: The interim stay previously granted is made absolute (with a limited qualification). Specifically, the Court ordered that the interim stay is made absolute in respect of those petitioners who have not already joined the places to which they were transferred by respondents 4 and 5.

Outcome in the pleadings: Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17055 of 1993 is ordered and Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17932 of 1993 (filed by the fifth respondent/mills to vacate the stay) is dismissed.

Direct consequences and practical implications (as stated in the opinion):

  • The transfer proceedings dated 20 May 1993 and consequential orders of the fifth respondent are stayed as to those employees who have not yet joined the transferred stations—i.e., those persons remain in their existing employment at the fifth respondent mills pending final disposal of the writ petition.
  • The stay was not made absolute in favour of 13 workers who had already joined the transferred places (the Court declined to make the stay absolute in respect of those 13 persons).
  • The Court's decision was expressed as a prima facie view and was grounded on the particular terms of the rehabilitation scheme and the governmental orders; the opinion does not claim to establish any new binding precedent beyond the decision in the present proceedings.

This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion. No external facts, case law, or inferences beyond the opinion text have been added.

    K. Maylvaganan And Others v. Government Of India And Others

    JUDGMENT

    1. The petitioners abovenamed filed the writ petition to quash the proceedings in RX No. 206 of 1993.M1, dated 20 May 1993, of the fourth respondent. The writ petition was admitted by this Court on 18 June 1993 and in Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17057 of 1993, K.S Bakthavatsalam, J., was pleased to grant interim slay of operation of the impugned proceedings of the fourth respondent pending disposal of the writ petition. The fifth respondent, viz., The Administrator, North Arcot Co-operative Spinning Mills, Ariyur (hereinafter referred to as the mills) has filed Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17932 of 1993 to vacate the interim stay.

    2. The petitioners, who are Indian citizens, were repatriated from Sri Lanka under Indo Sri Lanka Pacts signed by the two countries. Under the rehabilitation scheme, the Government of India has directed the petitioner to work at the mills. The rights of the petitioners to work in the mills are protected by the various orders issued by the Government of India and the Government of Tamil Nadu. The fourth respondent issued the impugned order of transfer of the petitioners working in the mills from 1983 onwards, to the other District Co-operative Spinning Mills in the State. The petitioners have, therefore, come before this Court challenging the impugned proceedings of the fourth respondent.

    3. I have heard Sri N.S Sivam for the petitioners and Sri R. Krishnamurthi, learned Senior Counsel for the contesting fifth respondent mills.

    4. According to Sri N.S Sivam, the petitioners, who were staying at Sri Lanka, were directed by the Indian High Commission at Sri Lanka to return back to India. In January 1983, they were repatriated from Sri Lanka and brought to Mandapam Campt in Tamil Nadu. While repatriating the petitioners, the First Secretary/Attache (Rehabilitation) of the Indian High Commission at Sri Lanka, served individual orders to the petitioners indicating the Indian passport and the family card issued to them and their families and individual appointment orders giving appointment to the petitioners as trainees in the mills. The Special Deputy Collector (Rehabilitation) stationed at Mandapam Camp, after perusing the appointment orders, transported the petitioners and their families to the place of destination. The petitioners are now working in the “B” Unit of the Mills from 1983 continuously for ten years without any break.

    4A. According to Sri N.S Sivam, the Government of Tamil Nadu started the “B” Unit in the mills to provide employment to the repatriates. Joining hands with the local union leaders, the fifth respondent/mills refused to make the petitioners and other repatriates as permanent workers and that the mills had made the fourth respondent to pass the impugned proceedings depriving the legitimate rights of the petitioners. The Administrator of the fifth respondent nulls, in order to help the local labourers has requested the fourth respondent that the Sri Lankan repatriates working in the mills are in excess and hence they have to be transferred to various other mills in the State. The fourth respondent by the impugned proceedings has Ordered that the 157 Sri Lankan repatriates working in the mills are found to be excess and so they have to be transferred and posted in other co-operative mills in the State and posted them in other co-operative mills in the State. The fourth respondent has also ordered that the petitioners, who were working in the mills from 1983 onwards for more than ten years, will be placed as juniormnst in the transferred co-operative mills and the seniority among them will be fixed as indicated in the proceedings. According to the learned counsel for the petitioners, this en masse transfer order has been passed in order to wreak vengeance and hence the impugned proceedings are null and void and also bad.

    5. Per contra, Sri R. Krishnamurthi, learned senior counsel for the contesting fifth respondent, submits that the mills was established in the year 1965 with 12,000 spindles and subsequently, it was expanded during 1974 for 65,000 spindles. After 1974, there was a proposal for further expansion for 50,000 spindles. During 1982, the mills recruited 175 Sri Lankan repatriates as per the orders of the Government. But, due to over-commitment by the State, the mills could not be expanded to their expectation and it was expanded only to the extent of 5,000 spindles and in all, as on date, there are only 30,000 spindles and there is excess of workers in the mills. Consequently, the mill is working under loss for the past ten years. He further submits that the net loss is more than Rs. 12 crores and the main cause for the loss is due to the excess workers employed in the mills. According to the learned senior counsel, a study was conducted by the South India Textiles Research Association and as per their report, they allowed 600 workers for the 30,000 spindles, but, in view of the old machinery and other factors, the mills arrived at 715 workers for its requirements. Therefore, after a careful survey, the mills decided to transfer some workers to other co-operative spinning mills in order to safeguard the interest of the mills. Hence, they recommended to the fourth respondent for transfer of the excess workers to other co-operative spinning mills and after accepting the same, the fourth respondent by the impugned proceedings, after confirmation from the Government, has transferred 100 excess Sri Lankan repatriates to other co-operative spinning mills. On the basis of the orders of the fourth respondent, the mills issued orders, to be communicated to the individuals, as per the direction, on 7 June 1993 and also handed over the copies to the individuals but they refused to receive the same. Therefore, an advertisement was made in the notice board of the mills. Since the employees refused to receive the copies, the same was sent to the workers by registered post, which have been returned with the endorsement refused. It is further stated that the transfer order has already been given effect to and communication has already been given to all the individuals and other co-operative spinning mills have been informed to that effect. Therefore, the stay petition has become infructuous and hence it is liable to be dismissed. It is also stated in Para. 6 of the counter-affidavit that in view of the stay granted, the Mills has now permitted the workers to join duty though they have already been relieved.

    6. I am unable to accept the contention of the learned senior counsel for the mills for more than one reason. As stated earlier, the rights of the petitioners to work in the mills are protected by the various orders issued by the Government of India. It is seen from G.O.Ms No. 410, Industries Department, dated 25 March 1982, that the Government of Tamil Nadu have approved the proposal of the fourth respondent for setting up of “B” Unit by the mills under its expansion programme with the financial assistance from the National Co-operative Development Corporation and also from the Government of India under the rehabilitation scheme for the purpose of State Government's contribution towards the share capital of the mills. The Government of India, Ministry of Supply and Rehabilitation, Department of Rehabilitation, in their letters referred to in that Government order, have sanctioned among others, a straight loan of Rs. 26.25 lakhs to the State Government for investment in the share capital of the mills for providing employment to 175 repatriates from Sri Lanka under their rehabilitation scheme, subject to certain terms and conditions specified in the said Government order. The Government of Tamil Nadu have also accepted the Government of India's loan assistance subject to their terms and conditions.

    7. The following are the important terms and conditions stipulated by the Government of India, Ministry of Supply and rehabilitation. Department of Rehabilitation, for the sanction of straight loan assistance of Rs. 26.15 lakhs under the rehabilitation scheme for employment of 175 repatriates from Sri Lanka in the “B” Unit of the mills:

    (ii) The mills will provide employment to repatriates from Sri Lanka from the families who have not been granted any rehabilitation assistance earlier, within a period of 12 months from the date of release of the loan amount. Before the amount is released to the mill authorities, they should sign an agreement with the State Government. The agreement should provide inter alia that if the mills default in providing employment as stipulated, the mills will refund the entire amount along with interest or repay that portion of loan along with interest as is worked out in relation to unsatisfied part of the commitment where the number of repatriates employed falls short of the committed number failing which penal rate of interest at 2½ per cent will be charged from the date after the expiry of period of one year till the amount is refunded.

    (iii) During the first six months of training period in the mills, the repatriates employed would be paid stipend and other members of the family (excluding the repatriates) ad hoc grant under the pattern scheme sanctioned by the Government of India. During the next 18 months the mill will pay a minimum wage of Rs. 250 per month or the amount equivalent to the stipend and ad hoc grant as in the first six months training period whichever is beneficial. The repatriates will be confirmed after 24 months and will be given wages, as would be payable to other permanent workers of the mills.

    (iv) In the event of desertion, the mill will absorb fresh repatriates in the vacancies and such repatriates would be paid stipend and ad hoc grant and wages as indicated in item (iii) above.”

    8. The appointment order issued by the Indian High Commission at Sri Lanka, Rehabiliation Cell, P.O Box No. 47, Kandy, Sri Lanka, dated 14 March 1983, also specifically mentions that the workers have been selected for employment in the mills. It further states that they have been directed to bay tickets up to Mandaparu Camp Railway Station and approach the Special Deputy Collector (Rehabilitation), Mandapam Camp, for guidance and necessary action. It is not in dispute that the petitioners, who are repatriates from Sri Lanka, are now working in the “B” unit of the fifth respondent Mills from 1983 onwards continuously for ten years without any break. Government of Tamil Nadu have issued G.O.Ms No. 410, Industries Department, dated 25 March 1982, regulating the employment of the repatriates in the mills that have received Government aid. Under Cl. (iii) of the terms and conditions it is clearly stated that the repatriates employed have to work for six months as trainees and during the next 18 months, they will be paid a minimum wage of Rs. 250 per month and after 24 months, they will be made permanent workers of the mills. Since the petitioners had been issued specific appointment orders by the First Secretary of the Indian High Commission at Sri Lanka, they had been appointed in the mills.

    9. In this connection, it is also relevant to notice that in the Government order, the Government of Tamil Nadu have specifically ordered that only repatriates can be appointed in the “B” Units that are started with the financial assistance offered under the repatriation scheme. But, the fourth respondent, on the recommendations of the fifth respondent mills, have, in disregard to the orders of the Government of India and the Government of Tamil Nadu referred to above, transferred the workers to other units when they were specifically appointed to work in the fifth respondent mills under the rehabilitation scheme. It is also stated that the issue of conferring permanent status to the petitioners is sub judice before this Court in Writ Petition No. 12707 of 1992. Further, it is pertinent to notice that the petitioners who have put in more than ten years experience in the mills, will be placed as juniormost in the transferred co-operative spinning mills and the seniority among them will be fixed as indicated in the impugned proceedings. Prima facie, I am of the view, that the impugned proceeding is not sustainable in law. It is also to be noticed that the transfer of the repatriates working in the “B” unit of the mills would render the “B” unit being closed since non-repatriates cannot be appointed. This glaring infirmity also, in my view, renders the impugned proceedings of transfer passed by the fourth respondent, as void and is violative of the terms and conditions of the rehabilitation scheme and the orders of the Government of India and the Government of Tamil Nadu. It is further slated that as soon as the petitioners landed in India, they were sent to Vellore to join as workers in the “B” unit of the fifth respondent mills and for the past ten years, they are working in the said unit, and the Government of Tamil Nadu, taking sympathy on them, allotted house sites at Ariyur village and other places and the petitioners, availing the house loan given by the Government of India and the Government of Tamil Nadu, have also built small houses and are living there with their families. The loans obtained for construction of houses arc to be paid in instalments and the petitioners are yet to discharge the house loans fully. Further, it is submitted, that their children are also studying in the local schools.

    10. For the foregoing reasons, I am of the prima facie view that the impugned proceedings of the fourth respondent, dated 20 May 1993, and the consequential orders of the fifth respondent/mills have to be stayed pending disposal of the writ petition. Balance of convenience is in favour of continuing the interim stay already granted. A prima facie case has been made out by the petitioners for their retention at the fifth respondent/mills and for making the interim stay absolute.

    11. At the time of argument, it was represented by Sri R. Krishnamurthi, learned senior counsel for the fifth respondent/mills, that 13 workers have already joined in the transferred places and since the order of transfer has been implemented there is no question of making the stay absolute at least in so far as those 13 persons are concerned. I make it clear that the interim stay in made absolute only in so far as it relates to the persons who have not joined the new stations pursuant to the orders of respondents 4 and 5.

    12. In the result, the interim stay already granted is made absolute as indicated above. Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17055 of 1993 is ordered and Writ Miscellaneous Petition No. 17932 of 1993 is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K. Maylvaganan And Others v. Government Of India And Others
    (Jul 23, 1993)