AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • TAMIL NADU INDUSTRIAL ESTABLISHMENTS CONFERMENT OF PERMANENT STATUS TO WORKMEN ACT 1981
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Co-operative Societies Act, 1983 (hereinafter referred to as the Co-operative Societies Act),
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Rules, 1981,
  • Section 182 of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Co-operative Societies Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • TAMIL NADU INDUSTRIAL ESTABLISHMENTS CONFERMENT OF PERMANENT STATUS TO WORKMEN ACT 1981
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Co-operative Societies Act, 1983 (hereinafter referred to as the Co-operative Societies Act),
  • provisions of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Rules, 1981,
  • Section 182 of the Co-operative Societies Act
  • provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Co-operative Societies Act
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petition was filed by 51 temporary daily employees of the Dharmapuri District Co-operative Milk Producers Union seeking a writ of mandamus directing respondents 1 and 2 (the Government of Tamil Nadu and the Commissioner for Milk Production and Dairy Development) to direct the third respondent (the Co-operative Milk Producers Union) to confirm the petitioners in service, fix them in appropriate scales of pay and grant arrears. Some petitioners were absorbed into permanent cadre during the pendency of the petition; the litigation is confined to those not yet confirmed.

The petitioners claim they completed more than 480 days of continuous service within a 24-month period (October 1981 reference) and therefore are entitled to permanent status under the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 ("Conferment of Permanent Status Act"). The Inspector of Factories examined third respondent's accounts, issued a show-cause notice for violations (including non-conferment of permanent status to 52 labourers), and later threatened prosecution when no adequate response was received. The third respondent replied that proposals had been sent to the Commissioner and that on approval the 52 employees would be made permanent. The petitioners then approached this Court for relief.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the writ petition seeking a direction to the third respondent to confer permanent status is maintainable when the third respondent is a co-operative society, and whether the petition is effectively directed against the Government and Commissioner such that it can be entertained.
  2. Whether disputed questions of fact (as to number of days each petitioner worked) render the writ petition non-maintainable.
  3. Whether the availability of alternative remedies (under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act or the Co-operative Societies Act) bars the writ petition.
  4. Whether the Government of Tamil Nadu has power under the Co-operative Societies Act to issue directions to a co-operative society to comply with statutory obligations (specifically to confer permanent status).
  5. Whether entitlement to conferment of permanent status under Section 3 of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act depends upon existence of vacancies or cadre strength in the establishment, or arises automatically on satisfaction of statutory conditions (480 days in 24 months).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as advanced by Sri Ayyathurai, counsel)

  • The petitioners had completed more than 480 days of continuous work in a 24-month period; the factual position is clear and not disputed.
  • The Inspector of Factories' scrutiny established that the petitioners worked the requisite period; therefore respondents were obliged to confer benefits under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act.
  • The fact that 23 persons were regularised during the pendency of the petition supports that other similarly-situated persons are entitled to benefits.
  • Conferment of permanent status under the Act does not depend on the existence of vacancies or cadre strength; it is not permissible to postpone conferment until a vacancy arises.
  • The undertaking by the first respondent to consider regularisation "as and when vacancy arises" is inconsistent with the statutory right under the Act.

Respondents' Arguments (as advanced by Additional Government Pleader)

  • The writ petition is, in effect, against the third respondent (a co-operative society) and therefore not maintainable as such writs against co-operative societies are not maintainable in law (relying on earlier decisions).
  • An alternative remedy is available under the Co-operative Societies Act (and under the Act itself), so the writ petition should not be entertained.
  • There are disputed questions of fact as to the exact number of days each petitioner worked, and such disputes make the writ non-maintainable.
  • The Government of Tamil Nadu has no power to issue a direction to the third respondent to confer permanent status under the Co-operative Societies Act; consequently the writ against the Government is not maintainable.
  • There are no vacancies or approved cadre strength in the third respondent to absorb the petitioners as permanent employees.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles [1991-2-L.W. 409] Authority for the view that writ petitions filed against co-operative societies are not maintainable. The Court noted the decision but held it inapplicable to the facts of the present case because the petition seeks relief mainly against the Government and the Commissioner to direct the third respondent to comply with statutory provisions.
Philip Jayasingh v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies [1992-1-L.W. 216] Authority for the view that writ petitions directed at co-operative societies are not maintainable. The Court observed the precedent but distinguished it on the basis that the present writ was principally against Government authorities to issue directions to the co-operative society.
K. Ganesan v. Special Officer, Salem Co-operative Sugar Mills [(1994) W.L.R 509] Another authority relied upon for non-maintainability of writs against co-operative societies. The Court considered the decision but concluded it did not apply because the relief sought here was enforcement of statutory rights through directions by the Government/Commissioner to the third respondent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed each major contention raised by the respondents and analysed them against the facts and statutory scheme as follows:

  1. Maintainability against the Government/Commissioner and distinction from writs against co-operative societies:

    The Court accepted that while the third respondent is a co-operative society, the petition primarily seeks a direction to the third respondent from the Government and the Commissioner to comply with statutory obligations under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. Because the relief is sought from public authorities to enforce compliance, the Court concluded the earlier holdings that writs against co-operative societies are not maintainable did not apply to the facts of this case.

  2. Alleged disputed questions of fact:

    The Court relied on the Inspector of Factories — the prescribed authority under the Rules — who examined the third respondent's records, found that the petitioners had worked more than 480 days in 24 calendar months, and issued show-cause notices about contravention. The third respondent's reply to the Inspector did not deny the 480-day service but supplied lists showing periods and number of days. On that basis, and because the Inspector (a statutory authority) had already determined eligibility, the Court concluded there were no substantial disputed facts that would bar exercise of writ jurisdiction.

  3. Availability of alternative remedy:

    The Court held that the existence of an alternative remedy was not a bar because the Inspector of Factories, who is the prescribed authority under the Act, had already made the relevant determination. Given that statutory determination by the designated authority had been made, it was unnecessary to require the petitioners to resort again to the same authority; thus alternative remedy contention failed.

  4. Government's power to issue directions to a co-operative society:

    The Court examined provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act (including Section 182) and observed that the Government has power to direct the Registrar to make enquiries and take proceedings in the public interest. The Court reasoned that Acts are made for public benefit and when a co-operative society disobeys statutory provisions enacted by the State Legislature, the Government — which exercises overall control over co-operative societies — has power to issue directions to ensure compliance. The Court noted governmental practice (G.O. Ms. No. 91 dated April 13, 1984) where the Government had directed regularisation of casual labourers in district co-operative milk unions, supporting the existence of such power.

  5. Whether conferment depends on vacancies or cadre strength:

    The Court interpreted Section 3 of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act as mandatory. Once statutory conditions (480 days in 24 calendar months) are satisfied, the workman acquires an indefeasible or automatic right to permanent status. The Act does not make conferment conditional upon vacancy or cadre strength; instead conferment is not to be postponed for lack of vacancies. The Court observed the Act provides inspection and penal provisions to ensure compliance, reinforcing the mandatory nature of Section 3.

  6. Remedy and effective date of entitlement:

    Although the petitioners sought regularisation from date of joining, the Court declined that aspect: entitlement arises only on completion of the prescribed period. The Court held the petitioners are entitled to benefits from the date of issue of the direction by the Government of Tamil Nadu, not from their initial date of joining service.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITIVE RULING: The writ petition is allowed in part. The Court directed respondents 1 and 2 (the Government of Tamil Nadu and the Commissioner for Milk Production and Dairy Development) to issue necessary directions to the third respondent (Dharmapuri District Co-operative Milk Producers Union) to confer permanent status on the eligible petitioners under the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 within fifteen days from receipt of the order.

The Court rejected the respondents' contentions that (a) the writ is non-maintainable because the third respondent is a co-operative society, (b) disputed questions of fact exist (on the basis that the Inspector of Factories had already determined eligibility and the third respondent's replies did not deny that), (c) an alternative remedy bars the writ (since the statutory authority had already acted), and (d) conferment depends upon vacancy or cadre strength (the Court held Section 3 is mandatory and conferment is not contingent on vacancies).

Practical consequences for the parties:

  • The eligible petitioners (those who satisfied the 480 days condition) are to be conferred permanent status by the third respondent pursuant to directions from the Government and Commissioner within fifteen days.
  • Entitlement to benefits under the Act will be effective from the date of issue of the Government's direction, not from the petitioners' date of joining service.
  • No costs were awarded.

Broader implications: The Court construed Section 3 of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act as mandatory and held that Government has power to direct co-operative societies to comply with statutory obligations; beyond these holdings the opinion does not expressly state that it establishes a new binding precedent.

    M. Irudhayanathan And Others v. State Of Tamil Nadu And Others

    JUDGMENT

    1. With the consent of parties, the counter-petition is taken up for hearing.

    2. The writ petition is to issue a direction in the nature of mandamus directing respondents 1 and 2 to direct the third respondent to confirm the petitioners in service from the date of joining them in their service and fixing them in appropriate scales of pay and arrears to them.

    3. The writ petition with the above prayer was filed by 51 employees who are working as temporary daily employees in Dharmapuri District Co-operative Milk Producers Union. During the pendency of the writ petition, some of the petitioners have been absorbed in the permanent cadre and the writ petition now is confined to the rest of the persons who have not been confirmed so far.

    4. The third respondent is a milk producers' union having its milk dairy at Kanagamuthu, Krishnagiri taluk. The business of the third respondent is the manufacture and sale of milk products and it has chilling centres at Dharmapuri and Dhanganikottai. The petitioners, as stated earlier, are all temporary employees recruited through the District Employment Exchange and, according to the petitioners, they have completed more than 480 days of continuous service in October 1981. The petitioners have made several representations that they must be made permanent under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Act, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as the Conferment of Permanent Status Act). The Inspector of Factories examined the accounts of the third respondent and issued a notice to show cause why there were certain violations with reference to certain provisions of the Act conferring benefit on the labourers, one such defect that was pointed out was that 52 labourers have not been conferred permanent status even though they have worked more than 480 days during the period of 24 months. There was no response to the show-cause notice and hence, on August 5, 1992, the Inspector of Factories issued another notice to the third respondent why prosecution proceedings should not be launched against the third respondent for the alleged violation of the provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. The third respondent has informed the Inspector that with reference to the conferment of permanent status on the 52 employees, the proposals have been forwarded to the Commissioner of Milk Production and Dairy Development, Madras, and as soon as he approves the proposal, 52 employees will be made permanent. The reply was sent by the third respondent on August 14, 1992. The petitioners subsequently also made representation for the conferment of permanent status, but there was no response to the request. The writ-petitioners thus approached this Court for the relief set out in the writ petition.

    5. Sri Ayyathurai, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, submitted that there was no reason by the respondents, not granting the benefits conferred on the employees by the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. The factual position is clear that the petitioners have put in more than 480 days during the period of 24 months and the Inspector of Factories on scrutiny of the accounts has found that they have actually worked for that particular period during the particular months and hence, when the factual position is not in dispute, the respondents should have conferred the benefits under the Act to the petitioners. He also submitted that the fact that 23 persons have been conferred the benefit during the pendency of the writ petition would clearly show that the other persons are also entitled to the benefits of the Act. He assailed the averments made in the counter-affidavit filed by the first respondent on the ground that the conferment of permanent status under the, Conferment of Permanent Status Act does not depend upon the want of vacancy or want of cadre strength. Though the first respondent has given an undertaking that the question of regularisation of the services appointed during the year 1988–89 will be considered by the third respondent-union as and when vacancy arises, learned counsel submitted that the conferment of permanent status cannot be postponed till the vacancy arises in the particular post or cadre.

    6. The learned Additional Government Pleader, in reply, submitted that the writ petition is in effect filed against the third respondent which is a co-operative society and hence, the writ petition filed is not maintainable in law. He also submitted that an alternative remedy is provided under the Act, and in view of the alternative remedy available under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Co-operative Societies Act, 1983 (hereinafter referred to as the Co-operative Societies Act), the writ petition filed is not maintainable in law. He also submitted that the writ petition involves disputed questions of fact as to the number of days which each petitioner has put in service as temporary employee on the roll of the third respondent and since disputed questions of fact are involved, the writ petition is not maintainable in law. He also submitted that the writ petition filed as against the Government of Tamil Nadu is not maintainable in law as the Government of Tamil Nadu has no power to issue any direction to the third respondent as prayed for by the writ-petitioner under the relevant provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act. Hence, he submitted that the writ petition filed as against the Government of Tamil Nadu does not lie. He further submitted that there are no vacancies in the office of the third respondent to absorb the petitioners on its cadre strength.

    7. I have carefully considered the rival contentions of learned counsel for the petitioner as well as learned counsel for the respondent.

    8. The petitioners have filed the writ petition against the Government of Tamil Nadu, Commissioner for Milk Production, Madras, and the management of Dharmapuri District Co-operative Milk Producers Union. It may be true that the third respondent is a co-operative society formed under the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act, but, however, the relief that has been sought for by the petitioner is mainly against the Government of Tamil Nadu and the Commissioner for Milk Production to issue a direction to the third respondent to confer on the petitioners the status of permanent employees. Hence, it is not possible to accept the contention of learned counsel for the respondents that the writ petition filed is directed against the third respondent and hence, the writ petition does not lie. No doubt, the learned Additional Government Pleader placed reliance on the decisions in R. Tamilarasan v. Director of Handlooms and Textiles [1991-2-L.W. 409], Philip Jayasingh v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies [1992-1-L.W. 216] and K. Ganesan v. Special Officer, Salem Co-operative Sugar Mills [(1994) W.L.R 509], wherein this Court has taken the view that the writ petition filed against the co-operative society is not maintainable in law. But, the said decisions are not applicable to the facts of the case on the ground, the writ petition has been filed against the Government of Tamil Nadu and the Commissioner for Milk Production and Dairy Development for a direction to the third respondent to comply with statutory provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. Hence, I am not able to accept the contention of the learned Additional Government Pleader that the writ filed against the respondents is not maintainable in law.

    9. The next contention that has been urged by the learned Additional Government Pleader is that the issues involve disputed questions of fact, and hence, the writ petition is not entertainable by this Court. The question is also bereft of force because the Inspector of Factories, who is the prescribed authority under the relevant provisions of the Tamil Nadu Industrial Establishments (Conferment of Permanent Status to Workmen) Rules, 1981, has gone into the matter in detail on the basis of the information furnished by the third respondent itself and after satisfying himself on the basis of the particulars furnished by the third respondent, the Inspector has determined that the petitioners have put in continuous service of work for a period exceeding 480 days in a period of 24 calender months in that particular industrial establishment. The Inspector of Factories has brought to the attention of the third respondent that the third respondent has violated the provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act and sought for its explanation as regards the violation of the provisions of the said Act. That apart, the Inspector of Factories also informed the third respondent that the prosecution proceedings would be initiated against the third respondent as it failed to comply with the provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act with reference to the 52 employees. The third respondent, when it submitted its reply to the Inspector of Factories has not denied that the petitioners have not put in 480 days of continuous work as contemplated under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act, but has really admitted that position by enclosing along with the letter, list of the persons snowing the period of service and the number of days which each of those persons have put in more than 480 days during the relevant period and when it is not disputed by the third respondent, it is not now open to the respondents to contend that the questions raised in the writ petitions involve disputed questions of fact. Therefore, I am not able to accept this contention of the learned Additional Government Pleader on this point.

    10. The third contention that has been raised by the learned Additional Government Pleader is that an alternative remedy is available under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act and hence, the writ petition does not lie. This contention is also not acceptable for the simple reason that the Inspector of Factories, who is the prescribed authority, has already determined that the petitioners have put in 480 days and they are eligible to be conferred the benefit under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. Therefore, this Court feels that it is not necessary for the petitioners to approach again the said Inspector of Factories with a prayer that the petitioners should be granted the permanent status. Hence, the prayer of alternative remedy cannot be put against the petitioners in filing the present writ petition.

    11. The fourth contention that has been raised is that the Government of Tamil Nadu has no power to issue any direction to the third respondent to confer the benefit of permanent status to the petitioners under the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. The learned Additional Government Pleader brought to my notice the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act and contended that under the said provisions, the Government has no power to issue any direction to the co-operative society to confer the permanent status to its employees. Section 182 of the Co-operative Societies Act empowers the Government to direct the Registrar in public interest to make an enquiry or take appropriate proceedings under the provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act and on such direction being issued, the Registrar shall report to the Government the result of the enquiry made. It is seen from the said provisions of the Co-operative Societies Act, the Government has the necessary power to issue direction to the Registrar to take appropriate proceedings under the Co-operative Societies Act in public interest. The claim of the petitioners is that they should be granted statutory benefit conferred on them by the provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act and that the third respondent has not obeyed the mandate of the relevant provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act. It is thus seen what the petitioners now seek from the Government to issue a direction to the third respondent to comply with the provisions of the Act. The Acts made by the Central or other State Governments are for the public benefit and made in public interest and if there is any violation or disobedience or disregard of the relevant provisions of the Act, any direction for obeying the provisions or complying with the mandate of the Act would be in the public interest. I, therefore, hold that the Government which exercises overall control over the co-operative societies has the necessary power to issue a direction to the third respondent to comply with the provisions of the Act made by the State Legislature. The third respondent is functioning under the administrative control of the Government of Tamil Nadu and if it is brought to the notice of the Government of Tamil Nadu and there is a violation of the provisions of the Act, the Government has the necessary power to issue appropriate direction to the erring society which fails to comply with the provisions of the Act. As a matter of fact, it is seen that the Government of Tamil Nadu has issued similar direction which is clear from G.O Ms. No. 91, dated April 13, 1984, wherein the Government has directed regularisation of services of certain casual labourers in 14 Districts Co-operative Milk Producers' Union who are appointed irregularly without reference to Employment Exchange. When the Government has been issuing such a notification, the contention raised by the learned Additional Government Pleader that the Government has no power to issue such a direction is not acceptable to this Court. Hence, I reject the contention of the learned Additional Government Pleader that the Government has no power to issue such a direction is not acceptable to this Court. Hence, I reject the contention of the learned Additional Government Pleader that the Government has no power to issue the direction to the third respondent.

    12. The next contention that has been raised by the learned Additional Government Pleader is that there are no vacancies or there are no approved cadre to absorb the petitioners as permanent employees of the third respondent co-operative society. The object with which the Conferment of Permanent Status Act enacted is that the Government found that many workers in industrial establishments are kept under temporary rolls and they were denied various statutory benefits which are given to the permanent employees. In order to curb the serious unfair labour practice and in view of the recommendation of the 25th Meeting of the State Labour Advisory Board, the Government of Tamil Nadu enacted the Act conferring permanent status to workmen in various industrial establishments in the State of Tamil Nadu who have put in service for a period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in such industrial establishments. It is beneficial legislation enacted in favour of the workmen and the Act should be construed to achieve the object of the provisions of the Act. Section 3 of the Act confers the benefits of permanent status to workmen and once the statutory conditions prescribed under S. 3 of the Act are satisfied or complied with, the workmen concerned acquire, an indefeasible right to become a permanent employee in that particular industrial establishment. The conferment of permanent status to the particular employee does not depend upon the want of vacancy or want of cadre strength. The only question that has to be asked for the conferment of permanent status is, whether the workman was in continuous service for a period of 480 days in a period of 24 calendar months in that particular establishment and if that answer to the question is in the affirmative, the workman concerned acquires a statutory right to become a permanent employee under the provisions of S. 3 of the said Act. He need not wait for the next vacancy that might arise and his permanent status does not depend upon the want of cadre strength. The Act provides sufficient safeguards, for the protection of rights of the employees and the Government is empowered to appoint Inspectors to inspect, to enter the industrial establishment, to make examination of the records and registers of the industrial establishment to find out whether there has been a compliance with the provisions of the Act. The Act also provides that if there is any contravention of the provisions of the Act, the concerned employer shall be punishable with fine and also for the continuous offence a further fine is also imposed. A fair reading of the provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act clearly shows that S. 3 of the Act is mandatory in nature and once the statutory conditions prescribed under S. 3 are fulfilled, the workman concerned acquires an automatic right of being conferred the permanent status. Further, the third respondent is a Government organisation and it has been repeatedly held that the Government organisations should be model employers for other private organisations to follow. The contention raised on behalf of the learned Additional Government Pleader that the question of granting permanent status will be considered as and when the vacancy or the cadre strength is increased does not deserve acceptance. Though the anxiety of the Government Pleader that there should be a curb on the spending by the Government or Government expenditure is appreciated, but, the remedy for such a curb on such a spending or for adopting an austerity measure lies elsewhere, but not in not granting the statutory benefits due to the employees.

    13. There is no dispute that the petitioners have put in more than 480 days of service in a period of 24 calendar months and they are entitled to be conferred a permanent status in the third respondent establishment. Hence, the first and second respondents are directed to issue necessary direction to the third respondent to confer the eligible petitioners the status due to them under the provisions of the Conferment of Permanent Status Act within fifteen days from the date of receipt of this order. The further prayer that the petitioners must be given a permanent status from the date of joining the service is not acceptable because only on completion of the prescribed period the petitioner's would be entitled to the benefits of the Act. Hence, the petitioner's would be entitled to the benefits of permanent status from the date of issue of the direction by the Government of Tamil Nadu.

    14. In this view of the matter, the writ petition is allowed as indicated above. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M. Irudhayanathan And Others v. State Of Tamil Nadu And Others
    (Nov 29, 1996)