DATED 18-01-2018 AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN WP(C) 4589/2015 of HIGH COURT OF KERALA DATED 13-02-2015 APPELLANT/ FIRST PETITIONER IN THE W.P(C) : BHAGAVAN KANI,
65 YEARS, S/O. ERAYIMANKANI, RESIDING AT MANPURATHU VEEDU, 320, MUKKOTHIVAYAL, KANI SETTLEMENT, KOTTOOR P.O., MANNOORKARA VILLAGE, KATTAKKADA TALUK, TRIVANDRUM DISTRICT, PIN - 695 574 BY ADVS.SRI.JOHNSON GOMEZ SRI.S.BIJU (KIZHAKKANELA) RESPONDENTS/ RESPONDENTS/ PETITIONERS 2 TO 6 IN THE W.P(C) :
1. THE STATE OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY, FOREST AND WILD LIFE DEPARTMENT, TRIVANDRUM - 695 001
2. THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS(WILD LIFE), OFFICE OF THE PRINCIPAL CHIEF CONSERVATOR OF FORESTS WILD (WILD LIFE), THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695 001
3. SRI.R. JAYAKUMARAN NAIR, PRESIDENT SREE AGASTYAR KSHETRAYOGAM, ATHIRUMALA, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, AGED 45 YEARS, S/O. RADHAKRISHNAN NAIR, RESIDING AT DEEPTHI BHAVAN, MEENANGAL, ARYANADU VILLAGE, NEDUMANGAD TALUK, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695 542 ---2--- WA.No. 374 of 2018 IN RP. 62/2018
----------------------------------
4. KUTTIMATHAN KANI, AGED 55 YEARS, S/O. ADICHANKANI, THADATHARIKATHU VEEDU, CHONAMPARA, KOTTOOR P.O, PIN 695 574
5. ADICHANKANI, AGED 36 YEARS, S/O. AYYAPPANKANI, MANPURATHU VEEDU, 333, MUKKOTHIVAYAL, KANI SETTLEMENT, KOTTOOR P.O, MANNOOR KARA VILLAGE, KATTAKKADA TALUK, TRIVANDRUM DISTRICT, PIN - 695 574
6. SURESH KUMAR, AGED 32 YEARS, S/O. MILLAN KANI, RESIDING AT RAHUL BHAVAN, PLAVILA KOTTOORKANI SETTLEMENT, MANNOORKKARA VILLAGE, PEPPARA WILD LIFE SANTURY, KATTAKKADA TALUK, TRIVANDRUM DISTRICT, PIN - 695 574
7. NARAYANAN KANI, AGED 39 YEARS, S/O. MILLAN KANI, RESIDING AT ASWATHY BHAVAN, MULAMOODU, KOTTOOR P.O, PIN - 695 574
8. MOHANAN TERIVENI
9. STATE PRESIDENT, ADIVASI MAHASABHA, CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE OFFICE, VITHURA P.O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695 551, KERALA. R1 & R2 BY SPL. GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI.K.SANDESH RAJA R3 BY ADVS. SRI.MATHEWS K.UTHUPPACHAN SRI. SHARAN SHAHIER THIS WRIT APPEAL HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON 09-02-2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING: WA.No. 374 of 2018 IN RP. 62/2018
---------------------------------- APPELLANT'S ANNEXURES :
--------------------- ANNEXURE A1 : COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 29.01.2018 ISSUED BY THE THIRD RESPONDENT ALONG WITH ENGLISH TRANSLATION. RESPONDENTS' ANNEXURES : NIL
---------------------- TRUE COPY PA TO JUDGE K. SURENDRA MOHAN & ANNIE JOHN, JJ. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= W.A.No. 374 of 2018 =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= Dated this the 9th day of February, 2018 JUDGMENT Surendra Mohan, J. The first petitioner in W.P.(C).No.4589 of 2018 is before us challenging the order of the learned Single Judge dated 18.01.2018 in R.P.No.62 of 2018. The writ petition was filed by the appellant and others seeking the following reliefs :- a. To issue a writ of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ order of directions calling for the records leading to Ex.P3 issued by the first respondent and to quash the same. b. To issue a writ of mandamus or any other appropriate writ order or direction compelling and commanding first respondent to consider Ext.P5 representation in accordance with law within a time limit that this Hon'ble Court may consider reasonable. c. Issue such other Writ, Order or Direction that this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the nature and circumstances of the case.
2. The appellant and the other writ petitioners belong to the 'Kani Tribe'. They claimed that only the 'Moothakani' of that Tribe was entitled to perform the poojas and rituals of the 'Sree Agastyar Temple' at Agastyarkoodam peak.
3. When the Writ Petition came up for admission, the Special Government Pleader submitted that no permission was W.A.No. 374 of 2018 granted to the general public to enter the area and that nobody was permitted to conduct poojas. The writ petition was disposed of on 13.02.2015 recording the said submission. Later on, a review petition was filed in 2018 by the 3 rd respondent in the writ petition, who is the 3 rd respondent in this appeal also. According to him, the observations of this Court in the judgment sought to be reviewed was causing prejudice to his attempts to have entry to the Agastyarkoodam temple and to conduct poojas there. The Review Petition was considered by the learned Single Judge and disposed of by the order against which, this writ appeal is filed.
4. According to the appellant, the observations in the review petition has adversely affected the rights of the 'Kani Tribe', who are the only persons, who are entitled to enter the Agastyarkoodam and to worship there. Therefore, it is contended that, the order in the review petition requires to be interfered with and set aside.
5. According to the learned Special Government Pleader, Forests, the Principal Secretary, Forest and Wild Life W.A.No. 374 of 2018 Department, Government of Kerala has received a request dated 29.01.2018 from the 3rd respondent for permission to conduct poojas in connection with the Shivarathri festival, that is approaching. The Principal Chief Conservator of Forests (Wild Life) and Chief Wild Life Warden has forwarded the representation of the 3rd respondent to the Principal Secretary, Forest and Wild Life Department, Government of Kerala requesting that the permission already accorded to the 3rd respondent and his society be withdrawn since it was necessary to preserve the ecology and biodiversity of the area. It is contended that, though permission had been granted in the year 2015 as evidenced from Ext.P3 produced in the writ petition, the same does not confer any right on the 3 rd respondent to seek permission for entry into the restricted area, year after year. We have heard Adv. Sharan Shahier, who appears for the 3rd respondent. According to the learned counsel, the 3rd respondent is a worshiper and the president of a registered organisation of worshipers by name 'Sree Agasthyar Kshetra Yogam'. They only want to offer prayers and poojas at the temple there. W.A.No. 374 of 2018
6. The learned counsel for the appellant responds to the above submissions by pointing out that there is no temple at the Agastyarkoodam and what is available is only an idol. The learned Special Government Pleader also supports the said contention.
7. Heard. We have perused the judgment of the learned Single Judge disposing of W.P.(C).No.4589 of 2015. What has been recorded therein is only the submissions made by the learned Special Government Pleader, that absolutely no right has been conferred on the 3 rd respondent by Ext.P3 order and that neither the said person nor any member of the general public has been permitted to conduct any poojas or rituals at the place. The above aspect has been clarified and reiterated in Paragraph 6 of the order in the review petition which reads as under :-
6. The first writ petitioner approached this Court pointing out that under the guise of implementing Ext.P3, the third respondent, who is the review petitioner, was taking steps to perform some poojas/ rituals and in the said circumstance, Ext.P3 was sought to be challenged stating that the right to conduct poojas was exclusively upon the said writ petitioner belonging to the 'Kani Tribe'. Reliance was also sought to be placed on Ext.P4 in this regard. When the matter was taken up W.A.No. 374 of 2018 for consideration, it was submitted by the learned Government Pleader that, as per Ext.P3, no general public including the third respondent was intended to be permitted to conduct any pooja. This was recorded and the matter was disposed of. In other words, this Court did not decide the merit of the case, particularly with regard to the right, if at all any, of the writ petitioner in W.P.(C).No.4589/2015 or anybody else. Admittedly, the review petitioner has not challenged Ext.P3, where the right stands restricted, I.e.only with regard to have right of entry and worship and no right to perform pooja is allowed therein. In the said circumstance, whatever right that flows from Ext.P3 could be entertained and enjoyed by the review petitioner, so long as Ext.P3 stands.
8. The above being the position, we are not satisfied that there is any substance in the contentions of the counsel for the appellant that the appellant and the members of the 'Kani Tribe' have been prejudiced by the observations in the review petition.
9. The learned Special Government Pleader assures us that the ecology as well as the biodiversity of the area would be preserved and that all steps are being pursued by them to ensure that entry of persons either as tourists or as worshipers is restricted. Carrying plastic and other articles that destroy the environment is strictly prohibited. Even the persons, who are permitted entry are accompanied by the W.A.No. 374 of 2018 officials of the forest department. It is further submitted by the learned Special Government Pleader that the members of the 'Kani Tribe' go there only for the purpose of collecting medicinal plants and that they only offer worship at the place. According to the Chief Wild Life Warden, the Government Order Ext.P3 produced in the writ petition on the basis of which the 3rd respondent is asserting a right of entry to the place was obtained by misrepresenting facts and misguiding the Government and that the order was being misused and utilized for private gain.
10. We are sure that the Government shall take into account the above observations of the Chief Wild Life Warden and issue necessary orders restricting the entry of the 3rd respondent and the members of the society to the Agastyarkoodam. We have perused Ext.P3 order. We do not find any permission therein for entry of the 3 rd respondent and his followers to the Agastyarkoodam, year after year. We are of the firm view that, the activities like that of the 3 rd respondent of commercializing the idol that is there by conducting poojas and other rituals at the place, when there W.A.No. 374 of 2018 has never been any such practice in the past should not be permitted. We find from the letter dated 06.02.2018 of the Chief Wild Life Warden forwarding the printed notices of the previous year that elaborate poojas including a 'Radhayathra' were part of the functions organized by the 3 rd respondent. Any permission to conduct such activities in the restricted area would ruin the ecology and the biodiversity that are required to be preserved at any cost. It would also give a handle to the 3rd respondent to commercially exploit the idol that is there. The Principal Secretary, Forest and Wild Life Department, Government of Kerala shall look into the above aspects and ensure that the Agastyarkoodam is protected and preserved for the benefit of the posterity. With the above observation, this appeal is disposed of. Sd/- K. SURENDRA MOHAN JUDGE Sd/- ANNIE JOHN JUDGE True Copy PA to Judge