Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Commissioner Of Cus. & C. Ex., Kozhikode v. Ali Mohammed P.P

    S.S Sekhon, Member (T):— Revenue has filed this appeal aggrieved by the order of Commissioner who after considering the issues involved inter alia came to the following conclusion and set aside the penalty on the respondent herein

    (i) “The contention of the appellant that the investigation in the case is improper is also carefully considered. It is noticed that the investigation is not a foolproof one inasmuch as there are many missing links in the act of smuggling leaving room for defence that the accused persons are innocent and not involved in the commitment of the offence and other offenders are different. In the instant case it is required to establish the details such as who collected the Foreign Currency, from where it was collected, who transported the contraband to Airport, to whom it was entrusted for effecting the illegal act, who all actively assisted and abetted the attempted etc. From the Order-in-Original or from the case records, a clear picture of the case is not emerging. The person occupied the seat No. in question (Seat No. C-21) as shown in the baggage tag) was not interrogated. In Para 50(d) of the Order-in- Original, it is stated that Shri Saidalvai (who was imposed with a penalty of Rs. 1,00,000/-) was not apprehended and absconding.. Similarly, the appellant was also not taken into custody or interrogated. In these circumstances, the argument of the appellant is fully maintainable before law.

    (ii) It is seen that a vital document viz., the computer print out showing the telephone numbers called by Sitaram Naik from a private hospital where he was admitted was vehemently contested by the appellant. The appellant averred that the document is a concocted one not verified the entries with Telecom Department, especially the calls being trunk calls. The original authority observed that the department's case on Shri Ali Mohammed is mainly based on the statement of S/Shri J. Sitaram Naik and P. Abdul Majeed and the Telephone calls that made by Sitaram Naik to the residence of the appellant. This being so, the investigating officers ought to have established this valuable piece of evidence beyond any reasonable doubt or challenge with further corroborative evidence. Nothing prevented the investigating officers to submit a list of telephone calls duly attested by the competent authority of telecom department. The calls are made on 7th and 8th of August, 1995, and the defence of the appellant on the grounds of alibi was not properly dealt with by the original authority. He observed that in the absence of any evidence on record to disprove the entries in the passport it is extremely difficult to comment on this. He failed to record his findings on the arguments advanced by the defendant in this score.

    (iii) It is averred by the appellant that the reliance placed on a document viz., the statement of Shri P. Abdul Majeed the employee of the Cool Bar owned by Shri Saidalvai, the co-accused, which was not supplied to the defendant is illegal inasmuch as the same was not referred to in the Show cause notice. It is seen that the reference of Shri P.A Majeed is made in Para 32 of the Order-in-Original, for the first time. Thereupon, the references made on Paras 50(b)(1), 50(c), 50(d) and 52 of the Order-in-Original indicates that this evidence has a pivotal role in the formation of the findings of the original authority. But, surprisingly, no reference or mention is seen made in the SCN or in the list of relied upon documents. Such a lapse, if not deliberate, should not have occurred on the part of a prudent adjudicating officer. This undoubtedly traverse the legitimate right of defendant appellant for defence, and it is an elementary jurisprudence that the consequential findings may be challenged on the ground of perversity. This denial of natural justice render the impugned order null and void ab initio.

    (iv) Similarly the averment of the appellant that certain document called for by the appellant was not supplied by the department also give room for some grave concern. However, on a close examination of the matter, it is seen that the document in question i. e. the copy of the relevant pages of the register maintained in Baby Memorial Hospital though referred in the SCN has not taken into cognizance for corroborating the validity of the computer printout the relied upon document in the finding of original authority. Hence, I may be seen that little relevance is placed on the said document and non-supply of the same, ipso facto, does not vitiate the adjudication proceedings.

    2. And thereafter he concluded that the impugned Order-in-Original was running into 29 pages with unnecessary transcriptions of the notice and replies thereof, which did not appear to serve any meaningful purpose, since contradictions on the point of which the original authority drives at are bound to creep in such lengthy orders. He observed that allegations lacks and averments built upon feeble grounds levelled by the investigating officers would make them lethargic and the officers refrain from making fool poof investigation reports. Therefore a penalty of Rs. 5 lakhs under Section 114 of the Customs Act, 1962 imposed on the respondents herein was ordered to be set aside.

    3. Revenue has taken the grounds:—

    (i) The Commissioner's findings of missing links in this case are not called for. In view of the statements of one Shri J. Sitaram Naik, Senior loader of Indian Airlines which brings out the entire background that led to detection and eventual seizure of the brief case containing foreign currency amounting to Rs. 1,00,13,740/- on 11-9-95 by the officers of Air Intelligence Unit, Kairpur Airport, Calicut.

    (ii) In this connection it has been brought out that it was J. Sitaram Naik, Senior loader of Indian Airlines who had to take the brief case containing foreign currency from the baggage identification area to the flight bound for Sharjah. The said Naik had given a statement that it was the accused Shri Ali Mohammed who had arranged to deliver the brief case containing foreign currency to the Export Baggage Hall through a bearded man. The bearded man could not be identified, the accused Shri Ali Mohammed absconded, in spite of several summons did not appear before the investigating officer for questioning. As such because of the accused only further investigation and collection of the details of the missing links were interrupted. So also Shri Saidalvai, the owner of the Cool Bar, who had introduced Shri Ali Mohammed to Shri J. Sitaram Naik attempted to and involved in the illegal attempt to export foreign currency absconded. In this circumstances only, investigation could not be further proceeded with. Since the accused had not make themselves available to the investigating agency for questioning and fact finding they cannot later take a stand that the investigation was improper and not foolproof. It may be mentioned that accused Shri Ali Mohammed had moved the Court for anticipatory bail and on rejecting, did not face the investigating agency.”

    (iii) The abscondence of the respondent would itself come to prove his guilty mind and his involvement in the unlawful activities.

    (iv) The lacuna pointed out that the person who occupied the seat No. 21C, whose baggage tag of the briefcase was not interrogated was not factually correct. Since the officer have investigated as the Ma- hazar states that the boarding pass of the passenger indicated that a baggage identifying tag No. 5183997 and the passenger had stated that the counterfoil with him was that of a cardboard box that weighed 16 Kg, on weighting it was found 10 Kgs. and that the air ticket indicated that only one baggage of 16 Kgs, the same was checked in by passenger on seat 21C. Since there was no passenger manifest by the name of Moideenkutty, Othukkungal, Mancherry, Malappuram, as per the name and address found on the briefcase are facts with the Commissioner (Appeals) did not appreciate.

    (v) As regards the questioning of the computer print out of the telephone calls made by Shri Sitaram Naik, from the statement of Shri Sitaram Naik it could be clear that he had admitted having made calls to Shri Ali Mohammed (respondents herein on Valluvam- bram No. 2094) on 7-8-95 and 10-8-95 from Baby Memorial Hospital where Naik was hospitalized during that period, which is corroborated from the telephone calls print out maintained by the hospitals and statements from the hospital employees. Merely because the respondents had come up with an alibi that he had not in India during that period and whether he was available in the phone was only a second question, the familiarity of Naik was established.

    (vi) The Advocate of the respondents had submitted that Ali Mohammed was out of India from 27-7-95 to 14-8-95. On verification of the investigation filed it would be seen that embarkation card dated 27-7-95 shows the name of the passenger as Ali Mohammed and the Serial number allotted to the passenger manifest is 204. The name that figures against SI. No. 204 in this passenger manifest is actually Mohammed A.K The name of Ali Mohammed does not figure in the passenger manifest. If the respondent had actually travelled, his name should have been appeared between SI. No. 64 and 72 in the manifest prepared in the alphabetical order. No printed SI. Number on the disembarkation card. The name shown in the disembarkation cards are different from another. The name shown in the disembarkation card is Ali Mohammed. The signature on both the embarkation and disembarkation cards was different and intelligence was available in this indicates that Shri Ali Mohammed has not travelled from Bombay to Jeddah in flight AI-807 on 27-7-95 and the genuineness of the embarkation card was suspicious.

    (vii) As regards non-reliance of statements of P. Abdul Rasheed., an employee of Cool Bar at Kondotty has been mistakenly referred to as P. Abdul Majeed in the Order-in-Original and in the Order-in- Appeal. It is submitted that this statement dated 5-10-95 reveals that Ali Mohammed, P. Saidalvai and other gangsters were meeting in the Cool Bar and corroborate that Saidalvai, Ali Mohammed and Sitaram Naik used to visit Mecca tourist home in Kondotty and gather in room No. 105. There it is admitted as a lapse the statement was not mentioned in the show cause notice, the same has been discussed in the Order-in-Original. This corroborative evidence also confirms the fact of Naik and Saidalvai making phone calls to Ali Mohammed who used to come after some time and Ali Mohammed and Saidalvai not come to the shop for many days.

    (viii) The observations that the appellant was not supplied certain documents is not correct, since they were sent by speed post dated 24-5-96.

    4. After hearing both sides and considering the material on record, it is found:—

    (a) The Id. Advocate had advanced arguments about a criminal case being registered by Ali Mohammed and his wife at Manjeri Police Station against the Customs officers for having physically assaulted Ali Mohammed and molesting his wife. These cases have been registered prior to the present case i.e on 9-4-92 much before the alleged conspiracy to smuggle out foreign exchange was hatched between Ali Mohammed, S. Sheriff, a bearded man and J. Sitaram Naik. The police complaint made against the Customs officers may not lead to a conclusive finding that the respondent herein Ali Mohammed has been dragged out of possible departmental bias/malice. However, the police complaint do exhibits that there was a reason to believe that the Customs officers and Ali Mohammed and his wife are not at best of terms for reasons known to them. In this view it is imperative that material brought on record to implicate Ali Mohammed should be unquestionable and should be making out a water tight case.

    (b) Ali Mohammed has been penalized, based only on the statements of co-accused one J. Sitaram Naik, Senior loader at Calicut Airport who vide his statement on record is admittedly a drunkard and was in deep debts. The statement of Shri J. Sitaram Naik is therefore carefully perused and a perusal reveals the followings:—

    (i) “He took me to the main road and there was a light green ambassador car waiting there, I saw. The time was at about 7.30 PM. We went near the car and saw a man aged about 40 years, Dark complexion, he aiming at us. Saidalvai introduced us each others. He was Ali Mohammed sitting at back seat of the car. Driver was sitting at the front seat

    (ii) Accordingly we met the second day Ali Mohammed told me that whether I could do something for him. I wanted him to make it clear. He told me that he was intending to open, a new chance for his illegal business of exporting foreign currency to gulf countries. He also told me that if I could make his consignments of foreign currency reach the aircraft without being caught by any agencies. I will be left by rewarded for which I have to work out the ways. I replied that I will inform later

    (iii) …….Around July 10th as fixed earlier visited Ali Mohammed's residence situated at Valluvambrom along with Saidalvai in his white Maruthi Van. At his residence at Valluvambrom Ali Mohammed introduced me a bearded character aged around 36 years, wearing golden frame specks, medium complexion, 5’7” around height named Sherief. We went inside to one of his private room and I explained my plan. I told them that I will manage the security stickers and baggage tags, which I would deliver them well in advance. They told me that they would operate by Sharjah Flight which would be convenient for them. I told them that if the baggage is delivered at the head of the conveyor belt with the security sticker and the baggage tag when I am on duty at the check in counter, I would be able to see that the baggage is loaded in the aircraft. My idea was that baggage would be cleared from the indemnification area by affixing the identification sticker on the baggage tag which I would manage to secure from the. rack laying outside the duty officers cabin. I told them that I can speak out my duty area at the counter at a suitable time. They told me that this is enough and the other aspects of the operation such as deliver the baggage at the conveyor belt transport of the counterfoil of the tag to Sharjah, collection of the baggage at Sharjah etc. would he taken care of by them. On the same day we have decided to send the first consignment to Sharjah on 16-7-95

    (iv) As decided earlier that day evening itself I went Kon- dotty. Sherief whom I had met at Ali Mohammed's residence who was waiting for me in front of the Bombay restaurant there along with Saidalvai at around 8 P.M as planned. They showed me an ash coloured brief case on which “sigma” sticker was pasted. They told me that they would be sending the consignment in such brief case

    (v) After three days I met Ali Mohammed at his residence at Valluvambrom and told him that I require some more time to carry out the operation properly. Due to low back pain I was admitted in Baby Memorial Hospital on 20-7-95 far about 5 days and on 4-8-95 for 7 days. During this period occasionally I used to contact Ali Mohammed over phone

    (vi) Therefore, 1 contacted Ali Mohammed on 7-8-95 and 10-8-95 for financial assistance and assuring him that I would be helping him for his operation of sending the foreign currency illegal

    (vii) That day evening itself 1 went to Kondotty and handed over the same to Sherief in the presence of Saidalvai

    (viii) That day evening I went to Kondotty and received the amount of Rs. 15,000/- from Saidalvai in the presence of Sherief and Ali Mohammed

    (ix) After one week as requested by Saidalvai I went to Kondotty and meet him near the Bombay Restaurant and he asked me to arrange for sending another consignment as already done

    (x) We went near the Cool Bar where I saw Ali Mohammed, Sherief and the man with bearded sitting in a car which was parked near the Cool Bar. Ali Mohammed asked me what happened

    (xi) Ali Mohammed patted on my bag and told me not to worry and assured me that he would take care of everything and also repeatedly told me not to say anything about this issue to anybody at any cost

    (xii) While I was an inpatient in hospital from 4-8-95 onwards I also admit that on 7-8-95 I made a telephone call to Vallu, vambrom 2094. On 10-8-95 I made another call to the same number the telephone belongs to Ali Mohammed”

    (c) The implications, as brought out by Shri J. Sitaram Naik are now dealt as follows

    (i) The implications (i) to (iv) do indicate the presence of Ali Mohammed at stage, and for having met Sitaram Naik at his house or in an Ambassador car outside the main road at Kondotty and at his house and again at Kondotty at an undetermined site, somewhere near Bombay Restaurant. The case as made out goes to propose that Ali Mohammed, a Kingpin of the entire smuggling operations, along with Sherief, P. Saidalvai and the bearded man who were other persons assisting Ali Mohammed. Therefore, once Saidalvai has recruited Sitaram Naik to abet in the conspiracy, by rendering the alleged assistance inside the airport, there was no purpose in having to introduce Sitaram Naik to Ali Mohammed 444 the King pin. Since a Kingpin, smuggler would never like to come forward and expose himself to others and be who known and identified by smaller fries in the Operations at the operating level. There was no reason for Ali Mohammed to have come in a green Ambassador car for an introduction to Sitaram Naik and thereafter to have made a proposal to Sitaram Naik after inviting Sitaram Naik to his house. When P. Saidalvai his close friend never invited him home since Naik does not know his house and location. A Kingpin smuggler will like to keep his identity, movements and locations secret, Naiks version do not inspire confidence for accepting the presence of Ali Mohammed.

    (ii) As regards the implications at SI. Nos. (v) and (vi), Ali Mohammed's passport is an alibi to disprove the entire story brought on record by the Revenue. How Sitaram Naik could have contacted Ali Mohammed on 7-8-95 and 10-8-95 for financial assistance assuring him that he would be helping Ali Mohammed in the operation of sending foreign currency illegally to India when Ali Mohammed was not in India as per the passport details placed on record by him. From the grounds taken by the Revenue, it appears that inquiries on this alibi of Ali Mohammed not in India during the relevant period were got made. Both the lower authorities declining with this matter appear to be convinced that Ali Mohammed's presence and availability on the dates as alleged on telephone number at Valluvambrom could not be established. The alibi is so strong that Ali Mohammed involvement and pre-contact knowledge with smuggling conspiracy cannot be established.

    (iii) As regards the successful attempts of sending out a bag, on the retracted statements of Sitaram Naik that he was paid Rs. 15,000/’- for that successful attempt by Saidalvai on 28-8-95 evening at Kondotty, an apparent conflict arises. If Ali Mohammed and Naik were to deal directly, then why Sai- dalvi should be brought into the picture for payments is not explained by Naik nor is he questioned by the officers on that.

    (iv) As regards implications at SI. No. (ix), it is apparent that the proposal to smuggle out the foreign currency came from Saidalvai and from implications (x) and (xi) it would appear that these implications have been got at, if Sitaram Naik was in direct touch control of the respondent herein i.e Ali Mohammed, then he would have definitely called up Ali Mohammed on his telephone No. 2094 at Valluvambrom, whom he is used to calling from Baby Hospital as per the version and he would have informed Ali Mohammed about the failed attempt to smuggle out the currency on 11-9-95. Why for such a serious matter, there is no attempt made by Sitaram Naik, as per his statement to have informed Ali Mohammed, is not explained. He only informs Saidalvai. Saidalvai, as it appears brings Ali Mohammed, Sherief, the bearded man to Kondotty, near the Cool Bar. This stay cannot be accepted. If Ali Mohammed, Sheriff and the bearded man who came at Cool Bar were part of the smuggling syndicate involved in the Custom Seizure of a baggage containing Rs. 1 crore and above in foreign currency, then only reaction of a Kingpin Smuggler and other smugglers assisting him would be to abscond from that area and not go on an audit visit for stock taking and reassuring a small fry Naik in the entire smuggling racket. Alternately if Ali Mohammed, Shrief, bearded man, who were part of the smuggling conspiracy, they could have as well asked Saidalvai to bring Sitaram Naik to the residence Ali Mohammed, as at introduction stage as alleged, or to any other safe house for questioning. The appearance of entire cabal of conspirators, as alleged by Naik near Cool Bar at Kondotty, to ascertain the facts of the seizure and to assure him, cannot be accepted to have happened in the natural flow of reactions to events.

    The statement of Sitaram Naik have been retracted, they cannot be accepted by any prudent person especially when the respondent have raised a case of animus by the departmental officers.

    5. There are many points in the statements of Sitaram Naik which could have been corroborated e.g white car number of Saidalvai could have been got ascertained the same could have been intercepted and located the alleged green ambassador car of Ali Mohammed could also be located and intercepted. No investigation to these effect appear to have been done. The only corroboration is by the statement of one Abdul Rasheed an employee of Cool Bar at Kondotty. This statement dated 5-10-95 has been, admitted as made out in the ground being mistakenly referred. The grounds as filed by the Revenue al SI. No. (iv) admit that there is a lapse of having not mentioned this statement as a relied upon document in the show cause notice. If a statement has been recorded and the department wants it to be relied upon as a crucial piece of corroborative evidence, then non-mention of the same in relied upon documents would be more than an innocent mistake or lapse. Care and diligence was required on the part of investigators. In any case if a statement or a documents has not been mentioned in the relied upon list, by the original authority, the Revenue appeal now made based on that document cannot be upheld. Consequences would be, that the material, as relied upon, is not corroborated. Without corroboration statements of a co-accused cannot be accepted, to bring in the severe consequences of a penalty amounting to Rs. 5 lakhs as found by the original authority on the respondents herein.

    6. There have been admitted lapses and lacuna in the investigation. The finding of the Commissioner that an uncalled for order running into 29 pages of unnecessary transcriptions and replies thereof will not serve of any meaningful purpose is to be upheld. The alibi of Ali Mohammed and the contradictions in the uncorroborated statement of co-accused Sitaram Naik lead to only conclusion that there are no grounds to upset the findings as arrived at by the Commissioner. Consequently, the Commissioner's order is upheld and the Revenue appeal is required to be dismissed. Ordered accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner Of Cus. & C. Ex., Kozhikode v. Ali Mohammed P.P
    (Dec 11, 2003)