AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges

    Shri Iqbal Singh & Anr. v. Canara Bank & Anr.

    R.A Mehta, Presiding Officer:— Refusal to vacate the interim injunction has given rise to this appeal preferred by the original defendant Nos. 2 and 3 who are admittedly the Guarantors to defendant No. 1 who had obtained the loan facilities from the applicant Bank for carrying on the business of export of readymade garments.

    2. Defendant No. 1 had approached the Bank for obtaining the loan facilities for carrying on his business of readymade garments. The loan was sanctioned on 16.3.1993 The additional facilities were also granted thereafter. The defendant Nos. 2 and 3 (appellants) stood surety and executed the guarantee deeds on 16.3.1993 itself in favour of the applicant Bank.

    3. It was alleged by the Bank that the outstanding balance in four different accounts was Rs. 23,05,138.17. The defendants did not pay the dues in spite of legal notice and hence the application was filed before the Tribunal for the recovery of the dues on 14.3.1996

    4. The claim was resisted by all the defendants by their common reply filed on 16.12.96 The defendants denied their liability to pay any dues.

    5. Apprehending the transfer of the properties the Bank applied for the injunction against defendant Nos. 2 and 3 who are hereinafter referred to as defendants restraining them from transferring their properties in any manner till the disposal of the suit. The ex parte injunction order was issued against the defendants on 26.3.96

    6. The defendants initially challenged the injunction order on the ground that it was illegal and in violation of section 60 of cpc. The said applications were already rejected by the order dated 23.8.96 (page 126 of the paper book compilation) on the ground that the provisions of section 60 of cpc relating to attachment and sell of the properties in execution of the decree are not applicable when the defendants are simply restrained from transferring their properties till further orders or till the disposal of suit.

    7. Thereafter the defendants applied on 9.5.97 (page 72) for vacating the injunction order on the ground that the injunction order is causing constant worries to them and is creating tension in their minds (vide para 6 of the application). Alternatively they showed their willingness to give the Bank Guarantee or to deposit Rs. 5 lacs jointly which was the amount of surety as mentioned in the guarantee deed.

    8. The claim was resisted on behalf of the Bank on the ground that the application is not bona fide.

    9. The learned Presiding Officer rejected the application for vacating the injunction order on the ground that the amount of guarantee is itself in dispute and that, therefore, it would not be appropriate at that stage to vacate the injunction order.

    10. It is against this order of refusal to vacate the injunction order the defendant have preferred this appeal.

    11. Heard Mrs. Masurkar, the learned Advocate on behalf of the appellants.

    Perused the written submissions made on behalf of the respondent Bank. The only point which arises for consideration is whether the impugned order calls for any interference.

    12. It is true that the defendants had given their personal guarantees. Their properties are consequently liable to be attached and sold in execution, if any, for realisation of the dues due to the Bank. It was alleged by the defendants in their application that the injunction order was causing tension and worry to them. This can hardly be a ground for claiming vacation of the injunction order. In para 11 of the Appeal Memo it has been averred and contended that defendant No. 2 atleast wants to dispose of his share in the house property. In that case the applicant Bank was justified in applying for the injunction order. Looking to the nature of facts and apprehending transfer, the Presiding Officer was justified in issuing ex parte injunction order.

    13. In the same application filed by the defendants it was alleged that the defendants are willing to give the Bank Guarantee or willing to deposit Rs. 5 lacs for the discharge of their liability under the guarantee deed. Mrs. Masurkar the learned Advocate for the defendants tried to rely upon the clauses in the guarantee deed which purport to show that the liability was limited to the extent of Rs. 5 lacs only. The question of interpreting the clauses of the guarantee deed will have to be considered on merits. The Presiding Officer has not applied its mind about the extent of the liability or the clauses in the guarantee deed. It would not be expedient to record any specific finding for the first time in appeal about extent of liability.

    14. The defendant No. 1 within a short time from the sanctioning of the loan adjusted Rs. 2 lacs by negotiating some bills. Thereafter the defendant No. 1 had availed of the additional facilities from the Bank. The consequences of adjustment and the consequences arising out of the additional facilities are again the factors to be read along with the guarantee deed and the provisions of law. From this point of view also the learned Presiding Officer was justified in rejecting the application filed by the defendants.

    15. The main application, in fact, was already fixed for hearing. The hearing by this time would have been completed. If not, the Presiding Officer is hereby directed to dispose of the main application within three months from the receipt of the papers. With these observations the impugned order does not call for any interference. The Appeal is devoid of any substance.

    Appeal is dismissed. No order as to costs. Hearing of the main application under Section 19 of the Act shall be expedited.

    Appeal dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Iqbal Singh & Anr. v. Canara Bank & Anr.
    (Jan 21, 1998)