Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Indian Majority Act, 1875 (9 of 1875)
  • sub section (4) of Section 125 Cr.PC.
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Indian Majority Act, 1875 (9 of 1875)
  • sub section (4) of Section 125 Cr.PC.
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses an application challenging maintenance orders granted under Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.PC). The respondent-wife filed a petition claiming maintenance alleging maltreatment and refusal of maintenance by the petitioner-husband. The marriage was solemnized in 2001 with three children born from the wedlock. The petitioner, who is blind and disabled, was ordered by lower courts to pay maintenance. The petitioner challenged these orders on the grounds that the respondent was not compelled to leave the matrimonial home and that there was no evidence of neglect or refusal to maintain.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent-wife was entitled to maintenance under Section 125 Cr.PC despite the petitioner’s disability and presence of children and mother dependent on him.
  2. Whether the respondent proved that she was compelled to leave the matrimonial home or was neglected or refused maintenance by the petitioner.
  3. Whether the courts below erred in awarding maintenance without sufficient evidence of maltreatment or refusal to maintain by the petitioner.
  4. The applicability and interpretation of sub-section (4) of Section 125 Cr.PC regarding a wife’s entitlement to maintenance when she refuses to live with her husband without sufficient reason.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The respondent was never compelled to leave the matrimonial home; she left voluntarily.
  • No evidence was produced by the respondent to prove maltreatment or torture by the petitioner.
  • The petitioner is a 100% blind person with dependents including three sons and his mother, which limits his capacity to pay maintenance.
  • The respondent’s allegations of maltreatment under influence of liquor were unsubstantiated by any complaint or evidence.
  • The petitioner lodged a missing report when the respondent left the matrimonial home, and police inquiry confirmed she left on her own.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The respondent alleged maltreatment and torture by the petitioner after 10-11 months of marriage.
  • The respondent claimed entitlement to maintenance under Section 125 Cr.PC due to neglect by the petitioner.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Indian Majority Act, 1875 (9 of 1875) Definition of minor for purposes of maintenance claims under Section 125 Cr.PC. The court used this Act to clarify who qualifies as a minor entitled to maintenance.
Section 125 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.PC) Provision for maintenance allowance to wife, children, and parents unable to maintain themselves. The court analyzed the statutory requirements for granting maintenance and conditions under sub-section (4) regarding a wife’s refusal to live with husband without sufficient reason.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined the material on record and found no evidence that the respondent was compelled to leave the matrimonial home or that the petitioner refused or neglected to maintain her. The respondent’s allegations of maltreatment and torture were unsupported by any ocular or documentary evidence, including absence of complaints to police or Gram Panchayat. The petitioner’s disability and responsibilities towards other dependents were also considered. The court noted that the lower courts failed to appreciate these facts properly and erred in awarding maintenance. The court emphasized the legal requirement under Section 125(4) Cr.PC that no maintenance is payable if the wife refuses to live with her husband without sufficient reason. The respondent failed to prove such sufficient reason, and thus no maintenance was warranted.

Holding and Implications

The court’s final decision was to allow the petition and quash the maintenance orders of the lower courts.

DISPOSED OF

The direct effect of this decision is the cancellation of maintenance awarded to the respondent under Section 125 Cr.PC. The court found no new precedent but reaffirmed the necessity of evidence proving neglect or refusal to maintain before granting maintenance, particularly under the conditions specified in sub-section (4) of Section 125 Cr.PC.

    Manohar Lal v. Jayawanti

    (1) If any person having sufficient means neglects or refuses to maintain.- (a) his wife, unable to maintain herself, or rt o (b) his legitimate or illegitimate minor child, whether married or not, unable to maintain itself, or (c ) his legitimate or illegitimate child (not being a married daughter) who has attained majority, where such child is, by reason of any physical or mental abnormality or injury unable to maintain itself, or (d) his father or mother, unable to maintain himself or herself, A Magistrate of the first class may, upon proof of such neglect or refusal, order such person to make a monthly allowance for the maintenance of his wife or such child, father or mother, at such monthly rate as such magistrate thinks fit, and to pay the same to such person as the Magistrate may from time to time direct: Provided that the Magistrate may order the father of a minor female child referred to in clause (b) to make such allowance, until she attains her majority, if the Magistrate is satisfied that the husband of such minor female child, if married, is not possessed of sufficient means. Provided further that the Magistrate may, during the pendency of the proceeding regarding monthly allowance for the maintenance under this Sub-Section, order such person to make a monthly allowance for the interim maintenance of his wife or such child, father or mother, and the expenses of such proceeding which the Magistrate considers reasonable, and to pay the same to such person as the Magistrate may from time to time direct: Provided also that an application for the monthly allowance for the interim maintenance and expenses of proceeding under the second proviso shall, as far as possible, be disposed of within sixty days from the date of the service of notice of the application to such person. rt o Explanation For the purposes of this Chapter-

    a) minor means a person who, under the provisions of the Indian Majority Act, 1875 (9 of 1875) is deemed not to have attained his majority;

    b) wife includes a woman who has been divorced by, or has obtained a divorce from, her husband and has not remarried. (2) Any such allowance for the maintenance or interim maintenance and expenses of proceeding shall be payable from the date of the order, or, if so ordered, from the date of the application for maintenance or interim maintenance and expenses of proceeding, as the case may be.; (3) If any person so ordered fails without sufficient cause to comply with the order, any such Magistrate may, for every breach of the order, issue a warrant for levying the amount due in the manner provided for levying fines, and may sentence such person, for the whole, or any port of each months allowance allowance for the maintenance or the interim maintenance and expenses of proceeding, as the case may be remaining unpaid after the execution of the warrant, to imprisonment for a term which may extend to one month or until payment if sooner made: Provided that no warrant shall be issued for the recovery of any amount due under this section unless application be made to the Court to levy such amount within a period of one year from the date on which it became due: Provided further that if such person offers to maintain his wife on condition of her living with him, and she refuses to live rt o with him, such Magistrate may consider any grounds of refusal stated by her, and may make an order under this section notwithstanding such offer, if he is satisfied that there is just ground for so doing. Explanation If a husband has contracted marriage with another woman or keeps a mistress, it shall be considered to be just ground for his wifes refusal to live with him. (4) No wife shall be entitled to receive an allowance for the maintenance or the interim maintenance and expenses of proceeding, as the case may be from her husband under this section if she is living in adultery, or if, without any sufficient reason, she refuses to live with her, husband, or if they are living separately by mutual consent. (5) On proof that any wife in whose favour an order has been made under this section is living in adultery, or that without sufficient reason she refuses to live with her husband, or that they are living separately by mutual consent, the Magistrate shall cancel the order.

    6. Perusal of aforesaid provisions of law clearly suggests that wife, legitimate or illegitimate minor child, whether married or not, unable to maintain herself or himself can file petition for maintenance under Section

    125 Cr.PC, if husband/father neglects or refuse to maintain wife/son. However, Section 125 (4) Cr.PC specifically provides that no wife would be entitled to claim maintenance allowance from her husband if she lives in adultery or she leaves the house of her husband without any sufficient rt o reason or if they are living separately by mutual consent. It clearly emerge from the aforesaid provisions of law that wife while claiming maintenance, if any, under Section 125 Cr.PC is required to prove on record that she is neglected by her husband or there is refusal on the part of husband to maintain her.

    7. After having carefully perused the application having been filed by the respondent under Section 125 Cr.PC, this Court sees considerable force in the arguments of Mr. Shivank Singh Panta, learned counsel representing the petitioner that there is nothing on record from where it could be inferred that the respondent was ever compelled to leave the company of her husband. It is admitted case of the parties that the marriage was solemnized in the year 2001 and three children were born out of their wedlock. Though respondent has stated that her husband kept her nicely for about 10 to 11 months after marriage and thereafter started maltreating and torturing her under the influence of liquor, but unfortunately there is no evidence adduced on record by the respondent to substantiate her aforesaid allegation. It is not understood on what basis the Courts below proceeded to hold that the petitioner refused to maintain the respondent. Similarly, this Court finds no evidence on record suggestive of the fact that the respondent was ever compelled to leave her matrimonial house. Apart from her own statement, the respondent has not adduced any evidence on record, be it, ocular or documentary to substantiate her allegations with regard to maltreatment and torture, if any, by the petitioner. Otherwise also, it is not understood that if rt o the petitioner had started maltreating respondent after 10-11 months of the marriage, then where was the occasion for her to remain in the company of petitioner for almost 9 to 10 years. Neither any complaint, if any, lodged by the respondent with the police or Gram Panchayat, nor any oral evidence to prove maltreatment and torture, if any, by the petitioner has been adduced on record by the respondent. Petitioner while refuting the averments made in the petition has specifically stated that the respondent left her matrimonial house in the month of July 2010, whereafter he lodged missing report in Police Station, Reckong Peo on 08.08.2010. It has also come in his statement that the police after inquiry reported that the respondent has left the matrimonial house of her own. Interestingly, no suggestion was put to the petitioner with regard to lodging of missing report and thereafter correctness of report, if any, submitted by the police. Similarly, it stands proved beyond doubt that the petitioner is 100% disabled person and is blind from both eyes. Though the respondent disputed the aforesaid fact, but no document/evidence, if any, is placed on record by her to dispute the disability certificate, which was duly proved by the Doctor, who had issued that certificate.

    8. This Court after having carefully perused the material available on record has no hesitation to conclude that both the Courts below have failed to appreciate the evidence in its right perspective, as a result of which erroneous findings have come on record. Both the Courts below, while awarding maintenance to the respondent failed to take note of the fact that rt o the petitioner, who is completely a blind person, has three sons and one mother to maintain. Leaving everything aside, as has been discussed hereinabove, no maintenance, if any, could be awarded under Section 125 Cr.PC by the Courts below, if the respondent/applicant was unable to prove that she was compelled to leave her matrimonial house. In the instant case, as has been taken note above there is no evidence led on record by the petitioner to prove that she was thrown out of her matrimonial house by her husband. Rather there is ample material on record suggestive of the fact that respondent herself withdrew the company of her husband.

    9. Perusal of impugned order dated 23.04.2015 passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Kullu, suggests that suggestion put by learned counsel representing the petitioner that Rs.25,000/- were given to the respondent by the person, namely, Babu Ram, weighed heavily while coming to the conclusion that the character of respondent was being suspected by the petitioner, but aforesaid reasoning given by learned Sessions Judge, while upholding the order of maintenance awarded by the Court below, is not sustainable, especially in view of the fact that there is no evidence led on record by the respondent to prove that her husband used to suspect her character. Mere allegation, if any, in the petition was not sufficient for the Courts below to accept the aforesaid contention of the respondent.

    10. Consequently, in view of detailed discussion made hereinabove, this Court has no hesitation to conclude that respondent/applicant has not been able to prove on record that she had valid reason for leaving the rt o company of her husband or she was compelled to leave her matrimonial house by her husband and, as such, no maintenance could be awarded under Section 125 Cr.PC by Courts below, more particularly in light of sub section (4) of Section 125 Cr.PC.

    11. In view of above, present petition is allowed and the order dated 23.04.2015 passed by learned Sessions Judge, Kullu, Distt. Kullu (H.P.), in Criminal Revision No.26/2013 and order dated 04.04.2013 passed by learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kullu, in Application No.387-IV of 2010, are quashed and set-aside. Present petition stands disposed of accordingly, so also pending application(s) if any. July 31, 2017 (Sandeep Sharma), (rana) Judge.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Manohar Lal v. Jayawanti
    (Jul 31, 2017)