AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. v. Punjab State Electricity Board

    This petition has been filed by National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. for approval of tariff for Salal Hydro Electric Project (Salal HEP) (3×115 MW + 3×115 MW) for the period from 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 based on terms and conditions of tariff notified by the Commission on 26.3.2001

    2. The revised investment approval for Salal HEP Stage I (3×115 MW) was accorded by Ministry of Power vide its letter dated 9.6.1997, according to which the generation portion of the project was completed at Rs. 621.21 crores, including IDC of Rs. 64.76 crores. Ministry of Power also accorded its approval on 3.6.1999 to the capital investment of Rs. 61.47 crores, including IDC of Rs. 6.35 crores for the renovation and modernisation of Salal HEP Stage I.

    3. The approval for capital investment of execution of Salal HEP Stage-II (3×115 MW) at an estimated cost of Rs. 193.58 crores for generation portion of the project, excluding IDC was accorded by Deptt. of Power on 12.9.1989 The approval for capital investment was subsequently revised by Ministry of Power vide its letter dated 22.10.1997 at a cost of Rs. 307.68 crores (Net), including IDC of Rs. 32.24 crores.

    4. All the three units of Salal HEP Stage I were commissioned during Novermber 1987. The units of Salal HEP Stage-II were commissioned during the period from July 1993 to April 1995 as under:

    Unit I- 1.7.1993 Unit II- 23.5.1994 Unit III- 1.4.1995

    5. Tariff for Stage I & II, for the period from 1.4.1997 to 31.3.2002 was approved by Ministry of Power vide notification dated 26.3.1999 However, consequent to notification of terms and conditions of tariff by the Commission on 26.3.2001, applicable with effect from 1.4.2001, the petitioner filed this petition for approval of tariff in respect of Salal HEP for the period from 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 based on the terms and conditions of tariff contained in the notification issued by the Commission.

    6. The replies to the petition have been filed by Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd. (respondent No. 2), Uttar Pradesh Power Corporation Ltd. (respondent No. 4) and Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd. (respondent No. 6). We propose to deal with the issues raised on behalf of the petitioner and respondents in the succeeding paragraphs while dealing with individual components of tariff.

    Capital Cost

    7. In accordance with the terms and conditions of tariff notified by the Commission, the actual expenditure incurred on completion of the project is to form the basis for fixation of tariff. It is further provided that where the actual expenditure exceeds the approved project cost, the excess expenditure as allowed by CEA or an appropriate independent agency, is to be considered for the purpose of fixation of tariff. The terms and conditions notified by the Commission further provide that the capital expenditure of the project should be financed as per the approved financial package set out in the techno-economic clearance of CEA or as approved by an appropriate independent agency. A reasonable amount of capitalised initial spares are to be included in the project cost.

    8. Ministry of Power had notified the tariff for the period 1.4.1997 to 31.3.2002 considering the gross block of Rs. 874.02 crores, excluding the initial spares of Rs. 6.24 crores as on 31.3.1997 against the claim of petitioner of Rs. 875.91 crores. The commission recognizes the gross block of Rs. 874.02 crores considered by Ministry of Power to arrive at a gross block of 31.3.2001 for the purpose of fixing tariff for the period covered by this petition. In addition, an amount of Rs. 61.47 crores was approved by Ministry of Power on 3.6.1999 for special R&M works. Considering this, the gross block as on 31.3.2001 works out as under:

    Gross block as on 31.3.1997 = Rs. 874.02 crores Addl. Capitalisation = Rs. 58.03 crores Initial spares = Rs. 6.24 crores Total as on 31.3.2001 = Rs. 938.29 crores

    9. Against this, the petitioner has claimed tariff on the gross block of Rs. 940.88 crores as on 31.3.2001 We, however, allow gross block of Rs. 938.29 crores for calculation of tariff from 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 as no justification is available for allowing Rs. 940.88 crores.

    ADDITIONAL CAPITALISATION

    10. In the tariff proposal submitted by the petitioner, it has taken into account the additional capitalisation since 1997–1998. The details of amount claimed by the petitioner, allowed and disallowed by us, are given hereunder year-wise:

    (Rs. in crores)

    Financial Year ACE Claimed ACE Allowed ACE Disallowed 1997–1998 11.26 11.14 0.12 1998–1999 27.18 27.11 0.07 1999–2000 15.71 15.47 0.24 2000–2001 4.58 4.31 0.27 TOTAL 58.73 58.03 0.70

    11. While allowing additional capitalisation, we have been guided by the following factors:

    (a) The expenditure falling within the scope of the R&M scheme approved by the Central Government has been allowed. A total expenditure of Rs. 50.16 crores on this count has been claimed and allowed against the sanctioned cost of Rs. 61.47 crores.

    (b) An amount of Rs. 0.35 crores claimed on account of adjustment towards compensation for land paid in earlier years has been allowed.

    (c) An amount of Rs. 3.14 crores claimed by the petitioner on account of transfer of machinery from Chamera-I HEP to Salal HEP for use during construction of the project has been allowed since capitalisation of equipment cost has been done after settlement of accounts.

    (d) Power house works of Stage I of Salal HEP and dam were commissioned in 1987. Due to heavy floods during monsoon in the year 1990, plunge pool apron had been punctured and due to heavy erosion, a cavity was created and there were heavy slides of rock mass from the right bank hill which was posing a threat to the power house and adjoining structures. The petitioner undertook restoration/rectification work of the plunge pool on the advice of a high level TAC during 1991 to 96. An amount of Rs. 8.83 crores claimed on that account has been allowed.

    (e) Additional capitalisation amounting to Rs. 6.80 crores towards replacement of vehicles, furniture, pumps, computers etc. has been allowed.

    (f) Reduction in capitalisation on account of disposal of old assets like pumps, drilling machine, vehicles, furniture items, etc, amounting to Rs. 11.25 crores has also been taken into consideration.

    12. The year-wise details of expenditure disallowed for the purpose of additional capitalisation are given hereinbelow:

    (Rs. in crores)

    1997–1998 Telephone/Telex 0.12 1998–1999 (i) Telephone/Fax Machine (ii) Others (Furniture & Fixtures/Office equipment) 0.02 0.05 1999–2000 (i) Other equipments (Plant & Machinery) (ii) Hydro Jacks (iii) Others (Misc. assets/equipment) 0.20 0.01 0.03 2000–2001 (i) Other (vehicles) (ii) Telephone/Telex (iii) Others (misc. assets/equipment) (iv) Minor assets 0.11 0.09 0.02 0.05

    13. Financing of additional capital expenditure has been considered from the term loan from LIC raised during the year 1999–2000 by the petitioner, and balance of amount has been considered from equity.

    14. It has been stated on behalf of the respondents that the petitioner has applied equity more than 50% of the capital cost. It has, therefore, been prayed that the ROE on excess equity may not be allowed. In accordance with the terms and conditions of the tariff notified by the Commission on 26.3.2001, the capital expenditure of the project should be financed as per the approved financial package set out in the techno-economic clearance of the CEA or as approved by an appropriate independent agency. Salal HEP, as already discussed in this order, was commissioned during the period 1987 (Stage I) and 1993 to 1995 (Stage II). Ministry of Power already notified the tariff for the period from 1.4.1997 to 31.3.2002 and the present tariff petition before the Commission is for the period from 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004 The respondents in this case are already paying tariff for the energy drawn from this project based on the Ministry of Power tariff notification. The Commission has, therefore, recognised the gross block as on 31.3.1997 as approved by the Ministry of Power and added additional capitalization between the period 1.4.1997 to 31.3.2001 to arrive at gross block as on 31.3.2001 The debt and equity follows from the above gross block and the additional capitalisation allowed by the Commission for which the debt and equity have also been decided by the Commission in this petition. Accordingly, the interest on loan and the return on equity shall be computed on the amount of debt and equity so arrived.

    Repayment of Loan and Interest on Loan

    15. As provided in the Commission's Notification dated 26.3.2001, interest on loan capital is to be computed on the outstanding loan duly taking into account the schedule of repayment as per the financial package approved by CEA or an appropriate independent agency, as the case may be. The interest on loan has been computed based on actual repayment schedule and actual interest rate indicated by the petitioner in the petition. The interest on additional capitalisation has also been worked out for the debt drawn from LIC. The year-wise interest on loan payable for various years is as under:—

    (Rs. in crores)

    2001–2002 7.17 2002–2003 5.81 2003–2004 5.17

    Depreciation

    16. As per the terms and conditions of tariff notified by the Commission, the rate base for the purpose of depreciation is to be historical cost of the assets. The depreciation has to be calculated as per the straight line method. Further, the total depreciation to be recovered in the tariff during the life of the project shall not exceed 90% of the approved original cost, which shall include additional capitalisation. As per the petition, an amount of Rs. 141.24 crores had been recovered till 1996–1997 on account of depreciation. Ministry of Power in its tariff notification dated 26.3.1999 has considered gross block of Rs. 874.02 crores, excluding initial spares of Rs. 6.24 crores for the purpose of recovery of depreciation. In view of above, for the purpose of present tariff period, that is, 1.4.2001 to 31.3.2004, depreciation has been worked out on the gross block of Rs. 932.05 crores, which is based on the gross block of Rs. 938.29 crores, approved by the Commission in para 8 of this order, excluding the initial spares of Rs. 6.24 crores. Ministry of Power while notifying the tariff on 26.3.1999 considered weighted average rate of depreciation on the basis of gross block as on 31.3.1998 for the working tariff from 1.4.1997 In view of this, weighted average depreciation rate has been calculated using the asset-wise break up of the gross block as on 31.3.2001 as furnished in the petition. This rate works out to 2.34%. Based on the application of the above weighted average depreciation rate on the gross block of Rs. 932.05 crores, the depreciation payable for different years has been worked out and is indicated below:

    (Rs. in crores)

    2001–2002 21.76 2002–2003 21.76 2003–2004 21.76

    Advance Against Depreciation

    17. The Commission in the norms of tariff notified on 26.3.2001 has made a provision for advance against depreciation, in addition to allowable depreciation. Advance against depreciation is permitted wherever original scheduled loan repayment exceeds the depreciation allowable. The amount of advance against depreciation is to be worked out by applying the ceiling of 1/12th of the original loan amount less depreciation allowed. For working out advance against depreciation for the present tariff period, 1/12th of the loan amount of Rs. 438.49 crores, which includes a sum of Rs. 413.49 crores of original loan considered by Ministry of Power for the purpose of tariff and an amount of Rs. 25 crores on account of the term loan from LIC to finance additional capital expenditure has been considered. Advance Against Depreciation for different years of the tariff period is, however, “nil” in this case.

    Return on Equity

    18. As per the notification issued by the Commission on terms and conditions of tariff, return on equity is to be computed on the paid up and subscribed capital at the rate of 16%. The petitioner has claimed return on equity on account of Rs. 501.21 crores for each year during the present tariff period. However, in view of the fact that we have considered gross block of Rs. 938.29 crores as on 31.3.2001, equity of Rs. 499.80 crores has been taken and return on equity has been allowed on that amount. On these considerations, year-wise ROE works out as under:

    (Rs. in crores)

    2001–2002 79.97 2002–2003 79.97 2003–2004 79.97

    O&M Expenses

    19. The Commission has prescribed the procedure for arriving at base O&M expenses for the year 1999–2000 in the notification issued on 26.3.2001 The average of actual O&M expenses including insurance but excluding abnormal O&M expenses for years 1995–1996 to 1999–2000 gives the O&M expenses for the year 1997–1998. This average of O&M expenses for the year 1997–1998 is escalated twice at the rate of 10% per annum to arrive at the base expenses for the year 1999–2000. The base O&M expenses of 1999–2000 are further escalated at the rate of 6% per annum to arrive at permissible O&M expenses for the relevant year. Where increase in the O&M expenses in a year is more than 20% over the O&M expenses of previous years, such expenses are to be explained. The O&M expenses wherever was more than 20% over the previous year, was supported by explanation by the petitioner in the form of an affidavit filed on 13.3.2002 Year-wise O&M expenses as furnished by the petitioner and percentage increase are as under:

    Year O&M expenses (Rs. in crores) % increase 1995–1996 26.9 − 1996–1997 36.9 37.3 1997–1998 64.8 75.9 1998–1999 72.3 11.5 1999–2000 56.7 -ive

    20. O&M expenses during 1996–1997 exceed the O&M expenses of the previous year by more than 20%. Similarly, there is an increase of 75.9% during 1997–1998 over the previous year. The petitioner has submitted an affidavit to explain the expenses for 1996–1997 and 1997–1998. It has been stated that CISF personnel are deployed at Salal HEP for security purposes. With the implementation of recommendations of Fifth Pay Commission with effect from 1.1.1996, the entitlement of pay and allowances of CISF personnel has increased by 23.9% over the previous year's expenses on that account. It is further explained that some of the NHPC employees at Salal HEP are governed by Central DA pattern. As a result of implementation of Fifth Pay Commission, their pay and allowances have also increased. It has been submitted that the total increase on account of these two factors is Rs. 7.4 crores. After exclusion of these expenses, O&M expenses are within the normal permissible range. It is further explained that during 1997–1998 there was pay revision of other NHPC employees at Salal HEP governed by Industrial DA pattern, which has resulted in an increase of Rs. 21.8 crores on account of pay and allowances, etc. It has also been seen that insurance expenditure has increased from Rs. 0.03 crores during 1996–1997 to Rs. 4.5 crores during 1997–1998 and thereafter the trend is steady. According to the petitioner, increase in insurance expenses during 1997–1998 and onwards is on account of corporate policy of providing insurance coverage to all fixed assets of the project viz. generating plant machinery, Civil and hydro-mechanical works etc as also the employees located in remote areas of J&K, inflicted with insurgency. The total increase of O&M expenses during 1997–1998 on account of insurance and employee cost is Rs. 26.3 crores.

    21. We have considered the explanation furnished by the petitioner to justify O&M expenses during 1996–1997 and 1997–1998. The increases in O&M expenses during these years is on account of mandatory and obligatory expenses over which the petitioner had no control. We, therefore, allow actual expenses for the years 1995–1996 to 1999–2000 to be considered for the purpose of calculation of O&M base for the base year of 1999–2000, except that expenses on account of Incentive under the category Staff Welfare Expenses, as per the following details:

    (in Rupees)

    1995–1996 38,39,222 1996–1997 54,04,776 1997–1998 2,00,05,208 1998–1999 2,87,09,947 1999–2000 1,35,86,321

    22. Accordingly, O&M expenses for different years of the tariff period allowed by us are summarised hereinbelow:

    (Rs. in crores)

    2001–2002 54.18 2002–2003 57.43 2003–2004 60.88

    Interest on Working Capital

    23. As per the Commission's notification 26.3.2001, interest on working capital covers the following:

    (a) Operation and Maintenance expenses for one month;

    (b) Maintenance spares at actuals but not exceeding one year's requirements less value of one fifth of initial spares already capitalized for the first five years;

    (c) Receivables equivalent to two months of average billing for sale of electricity.

    24. The interest rate for this purpose shall be the cash-credit rates prevailing at the time of tariff filing.

    25. The actual details of maintenance spares would be available on completion of the tariff period. In view of this, average of 5 years spares consumed, (including repairs and maintenance of machinery) as furnished by the petitioner has been considered for the purpose of calculating working capital. This is, however, subject to adjustment between the parties, once the actual spares consumed during different years of the tariff period is known. The Commission could be approached in the event of any disputes. The annual average prime lending rate of State Bank of India of 11.5% as applicable at the beginning of the tariff period, that is, 1.4.2001, has been taken for the purpose of calculating interest on working capital. The interest on working capital to be recovered from the respondents is as per the following details:

    (Rs. in crores)

    2001–2002 5.14 2002–2003 5.30 2003–2004 5.47

    26. The revised fixed charges payable by the respondents to the petitioner year-wise are as under:

    (Rs. in crores)

    Particulars 2001–2002 2002–2003 2003–2004 1 Interest on Loan 7.17 5.81 5.17 2 Interest on Working Capital 5.14 5.30 5.47 3 Depreciation 21.76 21.76 21.76 4 Advance Against Depreciation 0.00 0.00 0.00 5 Return on Equity 79.97 79.97 79.97 6 O&M Expenses 54.18 57.43 60.88 Total 168.22 170.27 173.25

    27. In accordance with the Commission's Notification dated 26.3.2001, the annual fixed charges are to be divided into capacity charge and primary energy charge. The annual fixed charges are indicated in para 26 of this order. The primary energy charge is to be computed in accordance with clause 3.5.3 of the Commission's notification. The capacity charge shall then be computed as indicated below:

    Capacity Charge = (Annual fixed charge-primary energy charge)

    Primary Energy Charges

    28. As per the notification dated 26.3.2001, the primary Energy Charges are to be worked out on the basis of paise per kWh rate ex-bus energy scheduled to be sent out from the Generating Station after adjusting for the free power delivered to the home state.

    29. Rate of Primary Energy, is to be taken as 90% of the lowest variable charges of the central sector thermal power station of the Northern region. The primary energy charge are computed based on the primary energy rate and saleable energy of the project. This rate is also the rate to be used in merit order despatch of the plants. Secondary Energy Rate are to be equal to Primary Energy Rate.

    30. The lowest variable charge of Central Sector Thermal Stations of northern Region was found to be varying on a month to month basis. The petitioner has calculated the primary energy rate of the hydro stations for the first year of tariff period namely 2001–2002 as 90% of average of preceding 12 months (i.e the year 2000–2001) lowest variable charge of Central Sector Thermal Power Stations of Northern Region. We agree with the methodology adopted by the petitioner for calculation of the rate of primary energy which is reproduced below. The lowest variable charge for the year 2000–2001 has been worked out to 60.66 paise per kWh. The primary energy rate applicable during 2001–2002 for the energy supplied from Salal HE Project shall be 54.59 paise per kWh (90% of 60.66 paise per kWh). The details in support of primary energy rate arrived at are given in the Table below:

    SALAL H.E PROJECT VARIABLE CHARGES OF THE CENTRAL SECTOR THERMAL POWER STATIONS OF NORTHERN REGION FOR THE YEAR 2000–2001 (Paise/Kwh) STATION APR. MAY JUNE JULY AUG. SEPT. OCT. NOV. DEC. JAN. FEB. MAR. Avg. Rate for the Year SINGRAULI 63.44 59.31 61.14 62.26 61.01 60.09 61.06 61.76 60.92 63.60 69.74 68.79 62.76 RIHAND 65.49 60.15 60.50 62.27 59.39 63.87 59.03 58.67 59.90 58.08 61.54 65.67 61.21 FGUPTS 94.56 94.84 92.86 94.82 100.24 100.75 97.22 91.54 96.60 96.52 99.58 105.71 97.10 NCTPS 143.66 147.76 140.56 134.90 134.26 134.93 133.23 133.50 128.58 142.64 147.37 152.99 139.53 ANTA GPS 93.42 93.87 93.85 93.30 93.30 93.30 92.87 92.87 92.87 93.40 93.40 93.54 93.33 AURAIYA GPS 96.51 96.86 97.10 96.15 96.15 96.12 95.62 95.63 95.61 96.26 96.28 96.27 96.21 DADRI GAS 95.48 95.94 95.71 95.01 95.01 95.01 94.48 94.48 94.48 94.14 95.14 95.14 95.00 FGUPTS-II 217.94 216.36 213.99 215.96 219.73 221.67 218.6 212.92 218.08 219.98 220.63 222.77 218.22 Average Lowest Rate for the year (P/Kwh) = (63.44 + 59.31+ 60.50 + 62.26 + 59.39 + 60.09 + 59.03 + 58.67 + 59.90 + 58.08 + 61.54+ 65.67) = 727.88/12 = 60.66 P/Kwh 90% of Average lowest rate for the year 2000–2001 = 54.59 p/kwh

    31. The primary energy rate of 54.59 paise per kWh which pertains to the year 2001–2002 shall remain constant throughout the tariff period for the purpose of payment of incentive/disincentive relating to the capacity index.

    Secondary Energy

    32. Secondary energy relates to the quantum of energy generated in excess of the design energy on an annual basis in the station. For the computation of monthly secondary energy and secondary energy charge, month wise details of design energy are indicated in the table given below:

    MONTHWISE DESIGN ENERGY

    Month Design Energy (GwH) April 189.52 May 324.94 June 471.90 July 487.70 August 487.70 September 424.30 October 229.61 November 128.63 December 94.57 January 60.69 February 68.97 March 113.47 Total 3082.00

    33. The rate of secondary energy shall be the same as rate of primary energy in the respective years.

    34. The primary energy rates for the years 2002–2003 and 2003–2004 shall be determined based on 90% of average of the 12 months' lowest variable charges of Central Sector Thermal Stations of Northern Region for the years 2001–2002 and 2002–2003 respectively by the petitioner in consultation with the respondents. No petition for this purpose is required to be filed. However, in case the parties are unable to agree to primary energy rates for these years, any one of them may approach the Commission for a decision by filing an appropriate petition.

    Filing Fee

    35. The petitioner has remitted a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs on account filing fee for the present tariff petition. The petitioner has prayed that the filing fee be made a “pass through” in the tariff. HVPNL has submitted that the filing fee should not be made a “pass through” in tariff but should be borne by the petitioner itself. On the contrary, UPPCL has submitted that filing fee should be charged on O&M expenses. We have considered the submissions made on behalf of the parties. We are satisfied that the filing fee is an obligatory statutory expense on the petitioner and is to be made “pass through” in the tariff, like other taxes, duties, cess and levies. We have also considered the implications of allowing filing fee in O&M expenses. We feel that filing fee should be allowed to be reimbursed as a separate item and not made a part of O&M expenses since by including the filing fee in O&M expenses will put additional burden on the consumers for a longer term. We, therefore, direct that filing fee of the main tariff petition only shall be recovered by the petitioner in 10 monthly installments in the tariff. We make it clear that all other charges like advocate's fee or filing fee for interlocutory applications shall not be allowed as “pass through” and these expenses shall be borne by the petitioner itself.

    36. In addition to the above charges, the petitioner shall be entitled to incentive/disincentive, tax on income etc. as prescribed in the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001

    37. The matters not specifically covered in this order, but for which provisions are made in the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001, shall be governed by that notification. This is, however, subject to the directions of the superior courts on these matters.

    38. The tariff approved by us shall be borne by the respondents in proportion of energy supplied from Salal HEP until Availability Based Tariff (ABT) is introduced in the region and as per the Commission's notification dated 26.3.2001 after the ABT is introduced in the Northern region.

    39. This order disposes of petition No. 64/2001.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Ltd. v. Punjab State Electricity Board
    (Jul 27, 2002)