AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Sanjay Karol, J. (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

The matters concern acquisition proceedings under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (the Act) culminating in Collector's Award No. 5 of 2003 dated 15.01.2003. Notification under Section 4 was published on 18.10.2000 for land in the vicinity of Kol Dam (villages referenced include Harnora and Bohat, Tehsil Sadar, District Bilaspur, Himachal Pradesh). The area taken was recorded as 669-12 bighas (reduced from an original 857-7 bighas). The acquisition was completed under Section 11 of the Act, the State took possession, and the declared purpose was construction of the Kol Dam; the acquired land ultimately became submerged.

The Collector's award fixed classification/category-wise values ranging from Rs. 1,04,416/- to Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha. Claimants filed reference petitions under Section 18 challenging the Collector's award; the Reference Court (District Judge, Bilaspur) in Reference Petition No. 37 of 2005 (Ram Rakhi v. Land Acquisition Collector, Kol Dam) by impugned award dated 26.09.2011 re-determined the market value of the entire acquired land on a uniform basis at Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha. Both claimants and the beneficiary filed appeals/cross-objections under Section 54 of the Act, which gave rise to the present proceedings before this Court. The Court heard evidence led by both sides and examined sale deeds, agreements and awards placed on record.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Reference Court was justified in re-determining the market value of the entire acquired land on a uniform basis at Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha irrespective of classification/category.
  2. Whether the claimants were precluded from seeking uniform compensation because, before the Collector, they had sought category/classification-wise compensation (i.e., whether an election before the Collector bars the claim for a uniform rate in the reference proceedings).
  3. Whether the evidence placed on record (exemplar sale deeds, agreements, awards and oral testimony) supported the Reference Court's conclusion as to market value and rejection of certain sale deeds as non-comparable.

Arguments of the Parties

Mr. Jagdish Thakur (learned counsel)

  • Contended that the Reference Court erred in permitting the claimants to obtain a uniform rate because, before the Collector, the claimants had elected compensation on a classification/category basis; that election ought to preclude re-determination on a uniform basis.

Mr. Anil Kumar God (learned counsel for private respondent)

  • Relied upon the Apex Court decision in Chimanlal Hargonvinddas v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (1988) 3 SCC 751 (AIR 1988 SC 1652) and other authorities to submit that the Reference Court ought to determine market value afresh on the material produced before it and that the Reference Court's approach and conclusion were in accordance with settled principles.
  • Asserted that the beneficiary did not raise the objection (that the claimants' prior category-wise claim precludes uniform rate) before the Reference Court or in the memo of appeal; claimants in the reference petition had, in fact, claimed rates at Rs. 25 lacs per bigha on a uniform basis.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chimanlal Hargonvinddas v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona (1988) 3 SCC 751; AIR 1988 SC 1652 Detailed guidelines for reference proceedings under Section 18: treat reference as an original proceeding; Collector's award is an offer and not a judgment; material relied by Collector must be produced and proved before Court; valuation is to be as on the date of Section 4 notification; use of comparable instances and plus/minus factors, common-sense evaluation. The Court recorded that counsel for the private respondent relied on this decision and applied its guidelines in affirming that the Reference Court had to determine market value afresh and that the Reference Court's exercise was in line with these principles.
Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Karigowda (2010) 5 SCC 708 The decision was cited as supporting authority on valuation principles in acquisition references (specific principle not elaborated in the opinion beyond reliance). The Court noted reliance on this authority by the private respondent; it formed part of the body of precedent supporting the Reference Court's approach.
Viluben Jhalejar Contractor (Dead) By Lrs. v. State of Gujarat (2005) 4 SCC 789 Authority supporting the law that uniform rates may be awarded when the purpose of acquisition is common and no subsequent development activity is to be carried out. Relied upon to hold that law on award of compensation at uniform rates in such circumstances is settled and applicable to the facts where the entire land was put to the same public purpose.
Himmat Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh (2013) 16 SCC 392 Reinforces precedent for uniform compensation when justified by factual matrix. Cited as part of the line of authority establishing the principle of uniform rates where applicable.
Peerappa Hanmantha Harijan (Dead) By Lrs. v. State of Karnataka (2015) 10 SCC 469 Reinforces the settled law on uniform compensation in appropriate cases. Relied upon as part of the consistent Supreme Court position favouring uniform rate awards when the acquisition and use are common.
Land Acquisition Collector v. Jatinder Singh (R.F.A. No. 953 of 2012, decided 01.06.2016) Decision of this Court cited among authorities on uniform rate assessment. Referred to by this Court to demonstrate consistent application of uniform rates in connected matters.
Haridwar Development Authority v. Raghubir Singh (2010) 11 SCC 581 Upheld award of compensation on uniform rates; acknowledged principle of annual increase (10%–12% per year) for land near urban areas with non-agricultural potential. Used to support the proposition that uniform awards are permissible and to note recognised annual appreciation rates for certain lands (as part of the legal backdrop).
Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh (2005) 12 SCC 564 Example where the Apex Court uniformly awarded Rs.40,000 per acre across five villages irrespective of classification. Invoked to illustrate the principle that uniform valuation across different classifications may be upheld where facts warrant.
Nelson Fernandes v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (2007) 9 SCC 447 Held that no deduction by way of development charges is permissible where there is no question of development (e.g., land acquired for railway line). Cited to support the position that development-charge deductions are inappropriate where land is not to be developed by the acquiring agency.
Gulabi & v. State of H.P., AIR 1998 HP 9; H.P. Housing Board v. Ram Lal, 2003 (3) Shim. L.C 64 (SLP dismissed) State and High Court decisions reflecting the approach that uniform assessment may be appropriate; these decisions attained finality. Relied upon by this Court as local precedents in support of uniform valuation where the entire land is used for a common public purpose.
Executive Engineer v. Dilla Ram (Latest HLJ 2008 HP 1007) Local decision applying the Harinder Pal Singh principle to award compensation on uniform rates. Referenced to demonstrate consistency in local jurisprudence favoring uniform valuation in similar circumstances.
Cement Corporation of India Ltd. v. Purya (2004) 8 SCC 270 Statutory position (Section 51-A of the Act) and the principle that certain sale transactions placed on record cannot be ignored. The Court acknowledged this principle but held that the sale transactions relied upon lacked evidence of comparability and therefore could not be used to alter the Reference Court's valuation.
Trishala Jain v. State of Uttranchal (2011) 6 SCC 47 Authority considered by the beneficiary; represents a decision on different facts and circumstances. The Court held the beneficiary's reliance on this decision to be misplaced because the facts were materially different from the present case.
NTPC Ltd. (Kol Dam) v. Sukh Ram (R.F.A No. 118 of 2014, decided 15.12.2016) This Court's earlier adjudication re-determining market value of the same Collector's Award at Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha. The Court observed that the same award had already been adjudicated in that earlier RFA and the market value fixed at Rs.4,69,955/- per bigha, reinforcing the present conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded stepwise, applying settled legal principles to the admitted factual matrix and the evidence on record:

  1. Found the undisputed facts: notification under Section 4 dated 18.10.2000, Collector's Award No. 5/2003 dated 15.01.2003, acquisition for Kol Dam, State possession taken, land eventually submerged, and multiple Section 18 reference petitions were clubbed and tried on common evidence.
  2. Reiterated the settled legal burden that the onus to establish a market value higher than the Collector's award rests upon the claimants.
  3. Acknowledged the legal position that a reference under Section 18 is an original proceeding and the Collector's award is merely an offer; material relied upon by the Collector can be used only if produced and proved before the Reference Court (relying on Chimanlal and related authorities).
  4. Assessed the evidence placed before the Reference Court: claimants examined one witness and produced sale deeds (Ex.PA and Ex.PB); the beneficiary produced several witnesses and multiple sale deeds (Ex.RC to Ex.RG), earlier reference awards and other documents (Ex.R.W 3.E, Ex.R.W 5.A, Ex.RH tripartite agreement).
  5. Examined comparability and credibility of exemplar sale deeds: the Reference Court rejected the claimants' sale deeds because one pertained to a small parcel and the other post-dated the acquisition by three years; beneficiary's exemplar deeds largely pertained to other villages and lacked evidence of similarity in use, nature and potential—no ocular evidence was produced to establish comparability.
  6. Considered statutory and judicial constraints: while Section 51-A and precedent (Cement Corporation of India Ltd. v. Purya) require attention to sale transactions, the Court found no evidence on record establishing comparability of those transactions to the acquired land, and thus they could not be relied upon to upset the Reference Court's valuation.
  7. Addressed the objection that claimants had earlier elected category-wise rates before the Collector: the Court noted that such objection was not taken before the Reference Court nor pleaded in the memo of appeal and that claimants had claimed uniform rates in the reference petition itself; furthermore, the Court observed that in the present admitted factual matrix—entire land being used for a single public purpose and submerged—the law supports uniform valuation.
  8. Applied a line of Supreme Court and High Court authorities establishing that where the entire land is put to a common public use and no developmental activity is to be carried out, claimants are entitled to uniform compensation irrespective of prior categorization.
  9. Examined the assertion concerning superstructure and concluded that no credible evidence regarding superstructure was led; therefore the Reference Court's treatment was appropriate.
  10. Concluded that the Reference Court had considered the material in its entirety, applied correct principles, and arrived at a logical, reasonable and just conclusion that the market value be re-determined uniformly at Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The present appeal is DISMISSED. The Reference Court's impugned award dated 26.09.2011, re-determining the market value at Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha on a uniform basis, is upheld. All pending applications connected with the appeal are also dismissed. Cross-objections and cross-appeals are rejected.

Consequences and immediate effects:

  • The Reference Court's uniform valuation of Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha for the acquired land stands affirmed and will be binding on the parties in these proceedings.
  • The Court found no perversity, illegality or error in the Reference Court's appreciation of evidence and its application of relevant legal principles.
  • The judgment will have an automatic bearing on other connected appeals arising from the same Collector's Award; the Registrar was directed to take instructions for appropriate listing of connected appeals.

Broader doctrinal implication: The opinion rests upon existing Supreme Court and High Court authorities endorsing uniform awards where the entire land is put to a single public purpose and no development is to be carried out. The Court did not purport to create new precedent; it applied and followed the extant line of decisions to the admitted facts before it.

Sources: This summary is based exclusively on the opinion of Sanjay Karol, J., as provided. No information outside the provided text has been introduced.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ntpc Ltd., Kol Dam, Barmana, Bilaspur v. Ram Rakhi & Another S

    Sanjay Karol, J. (Oral):— The acquisition proceedings pertain to the Collector's award No. 5 of 2003, dated 15.01.2003, pertaining to village Harnora, Tehsil Sadar, District Bilaspur, H.P In terms of the said award, the market value of the acquired land stands determined, classification wise from Rs. 1,04,416/- to Rs. 4,69,955/-. In the impugned land reference petition, the same stands re-determined by the Reference Court @ Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha, on uniform basis, for the reason that: (a) The observations made by the Collector in its award itself justified such enhancement.

    2. If the claimant(s) are held legally entitled for rates, on uniform basis, irrespective of classification and category, then the increase in the amount of re-determination of the market value of the acquired land is only marginal. The rates stand increased to Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha.

    3. In terms of award No. 5 of 2003, dated 15.01.2003, Collector Land Acquisition, determined the market value of the acquired land awarding different rates, classification/category wise, ranging from Rs. 1,04,416/- to Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha.

    4. In terms of the impugned award dated 26.09.2011, passed by District Judge, Bilaspur, H.P, in Reference Petition No. 37 of 2005, titled as Ram Rakhi v. Land Acquisition Collector, Kol Dam, Bilaspur, the Reference Court re-determined the market value of the entire acquired land, irrespective of its category/classification, by uniformly awarding a sum of Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha.

    5. Certain facts are not in dispute: (i) 669-12 bighas of land (reduced from original area 857-7 bighas) came to be acquired in village Bohat, Tehsil Sadar, District Bilaspur, H.P, with the publication of notification in the official gazette on 18.10.2000, so issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as the Act); (ii) The acquisition proceedings concluded with the passing of Collector's award No. 5 of 2003, dated 15.01.2003, under Section 11 of the Act and the State taking over possession of the land; (iii) The purpose of acquisition being construction of Dam, commonly known as Kol Dam; (iv) Dissatisfied with the offer made by the Collector, claimants filed petitions under Section 18 of the Act, which came to be clubbed (with Reference Petition No. 33 of 2005) and on the basis of common evidence led by the parties, disposed of in terms of impugned award; (v) Both the claimants and the beneficiary have preferred the present appeal(s) under Section 54 of the Act/cross-objections; (vi) It is the common case of parties that the entire acquired land came to be submerged with the construction of Dam by the beneficiary. Also there is no evidence on record of either any requirement or any developmental activity carried out on the spot.

    6. With these admitted/undisputed facts, material placed on record by the parties is being appreciated for just decision of the case.

    7. It is a settled principle of law that onus of establishing true market value of the acquired land, higher than the one which stands determined by the Collector, is always upon the claimants.

    8. Perusal of the Collector's award reveals that claimants themselves claimed compensation @ Rs. 25 lacs per bigha. But then it was category/classification wise.

    9. It is a settled principle of law that Collector's award is a mere offer and in the proceedings under Section 18 of the Act, Court is duty bound to determine the market value, which is just, fair and reasonable, on the basis of material placed on record by the parties. The conclusion with respect to re-determination of the market value, in the instant case, is clearly based on the evidence led by the claimants, which cannot be said to have been appreciated erroneously. Material, in its entirety, stands considered by the Court below.

    10. With vehemence, Mr. Jagdish Thakur, learned counsel, contends that Reference Court erred in considering the fact that before the Collector, claimants had themselves elected for award of compensation on the basis of classification/category, hence they were precluded from seeking re-determination of the market value of the acquired land on uniform basis.

    11. To rebut the same, Mr. Anil Kumar God, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the private respondent, seeks reliance on the decision rendered by the Apex Court in Chimanlal Hargonvinddas v. Special Land Acquisition Officer, Poona, (1988) 3 SCC 751 : AIR 1988 SC 1652, wherein the Court made the following observations:—

    “4 The following factors must be etched on the mental screen:

    (1) A reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act is not an appeal against the award and the Court cannot take into account the material relied upon by the Land Acquisition Officer in his Award unless the same material is produced and proved before the Court.

    (2) So also the Award of the Land Acquisition Officer is not to be treated as a judgment of the trial Court open or exposed to challenge before the court hearing the Reference. It is merely an offer made by the Land Acquisition Officer and the material utilised by him for making his valuation cannot be utilised by the Court unless produced and proved before it. It is not the function of the court to sit in appeal against the Award, approve or disapprove its reasoning, or correct its error or affirm, modify or reverse the conclusion reached by the Land Acquisition Officer, as if it were an appellate Court.

    (3) The Court has to treat the reference as an original proceeding before it and determine the market value afresh on the basis of the material produced before it.

    (4) The claimant is in the position of a plaintiff who has to show that the price offered for his land in the award is inadequate on the basis of the materials produced in the Court. Of course the materials placed and proved by the other side can also be taken into account for this purpose.

    (5) The market value of land under acquisition has to be determined as on the crucial date of publication of the notification under S. 4 of the Land Acquisition Act (dates of Notifications under Ss. 6 and 9 are irrelevant).

    (6) The determination has to be made standing on the date line of valuation (date of publication of notification under S. 4) as if the valuer is a hypothetical purchaser willing to purchase land from the open market and is prepared to pay a reasonable price as on that day. It has also to be assumed that the vendor is willing to sell the land at a reasonable price.

    (7) In doing so by the instances method, the Court has to correlate the market value reflected in the most comparable instance which provides the index of market value.

    (8) Only genuine instances have to be taken into account. (Sometimes instances are rigged up in anticipation of Acquisition of land.)

    (9) Even post-notification instances can be taken into account (1) if they are very proximate, (2) genuine and (3) the acquisition itself has not motivated the purchaser to pay a higher price on account of the resultant improvement in development prospects.

    (10) The most comparable instances out of the genuine instances have to be identified on the following considerations:

    (i) proximity from time angle;

    (ii) proximity from situation angle.

    (11) Having identified the instances which provide the index of market value the price reflected therein may be taken as the norm and the market value of the land under acquisition may be deduced by making suitable adjustments for the plus and minus factors vis-a-vis land under acquisition by placing the two in juxtaposition.

    (12) A balance-sheet of plus and minus factors may be drawn for this purpose and the relevant factors may beevaluated interms of price variation as a prudent purchaser would do.

    (13) The market value of the land under acquisition has thereafter to be deduced by loading the price reflected in the instance taken as norm for plus factors and unloading it for minus factors.

    (14) The exercise indicated in clauses (11) to (13) has to be undertaken in a common sense manner as a prudent man of the world of business would do. We may illustrate some such illustrative (not exhaustive) factors:—

    (For table see below)

    Plus factorsMinus factors1. Smallness of size.1. largeness of area.2. Proximity to a road.2. situation in the interior at a distance from the road.3. frontage on a road.3. narrow strip of land with very small frontage compared to depth.4. nearness to developed area.4. lower level requiring the depressed portion to be filled up.5. regular shape.5. remoteness from developed locality.6. level vis-a-vis land under acquisition.6. some special disadvantageous factor which would deter a purchaser.7. special value for an owner of an adjoining property to whom it may have some very special advantage.

    (15) The evaluation of these factors of course depends on the facts of each case. There cannot be any hard and fast or rigid rule. Common sense is the best and most reliable guide. For instance, take the factor regarding the size. A building plot of land say 500 to 1000 sq. yds cannot be compared with a large tract or block of land of say 10000 eq. yds. or more. Firstly while a smaller plot is within the reach of many, a large block of land will have to be developed by preparing a lay out, carving out roads, leaving open space, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers (meanwhile the invested money will be blocked up) and the hazards of an entrepreneur. The factor can be discounted by making a deduction byway of an allowance at an appropriate rate ranging approx. between 20% to 50% to account for land required to be set apart for carving out lands and plotting out small plots. The discounting will to some extent also depend on whether it is a rural area or urban area, whether building activity is picking up, and whether waiting period during which the capital of the entrepreneur would be locked up, will be longer or shorter and the attendant hazards.

    (16) Every case must be dealt with on its own fact pattern bearing in mind all these factors as a prudent purchaser of land in which position the Judge must place himself.

    (17) These are general guidelines to be applied with understanding informed with common sense.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    12. Reliance is also sought on the decision rendered by the Apex Court in Special Land Acquisition Officer v. Karigowda, (2010) 5 SCC 708.

    13. Significantly while responding to the reference petition or at the time of recording evidence, such objection never came to be taken by the beneficiary. Even before this Court, it is not a pleaded ground in the memo of appeal. In fact, as is evident from the reference petition, claimants had claimed rates @ Rs. 25 lacs per bigha, on uniform basis.

    14. In any event, Reference Court is duty bound to determine such market value, which is just, fair and reasonable.

    15. The law for award of compensation at uniform rates, when the purpose of acquisition is common and no developmental activity is required to be carried out is no longer res integra and stands settled by Hon'ble the Supreme Court in Viluben Jhalejar Contractor (Dead) By Lrs. v. State Of Gujarat, (2005) 4 SCC 789; Himmat Singh v. State of Madhya Pradesh, (2013) 16 SCC 392; Peerappa Hanmantha Harijan (Dead) By Legal Representatives v. State of Karnataka, (2015) 10 SCC 469; as also this Court in R.F.A No. 953 of 2012, titled as Land Acquisition Collector v. Jatinder Singh, decided on 01.06.2016 and other connected matters. As such, at this point in time, in view of admitted/undisputed factual matrix, as noticed earlier, it would not be permissible for the beneficiary to raise such objections.

    16. Now it is a settled principle of law that if the entire land is put for a public use and no area is left out for carrying out any developmental activity, then the claimants are entitled for compensation for the entire acquired land, at uniform rates, regardless of its categorization.

    17. The apex Court in Haridwar Development Authority v. Raghubir Singh, (2010) 11 SCC 581 has upheld the award of compensation on uniform rates. Also it has acknowledged the principle of providing increase in the market value up to 10% to 12% per year for the land situated near urban areas having potential for non-agricultural development.

    18. In Union of India v. Harinder Pal Singh (2005) 12 SCC 564, while determining the compensation for acquisition of land pertaining to five different villages, the apex Court uniformly awarded a sum of Rs. 40,000/- per acre, irrespective of the classification and the category of land.

    19. Further, in Nelson Fernades v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (2007) 9 SCC 447 while dealing with the case where the land was acquired for laying a Railway line, the Court held that no deduction by way of development charges was permissible as there was no question of any development thereof.

    20. Similar view stands taken by this Court in Gulabi and v. State of H.P, AIR 1998 HP 9 and later on in H.P Housing oard v. Ram Lal 2003 (3) Shim. L.C 64, which judgment has attained finality as S.L.P (Civil) No. 15674-15675 of 2004 titled as Himachal Pradesh Housing Board v. Ram Lal (D) by LRs, filed by the H.P Housing Board came to be dismissed by the Apex Court on 16.8.2004

    21. This judgment was subsequently referred to and relied upon by this Court in Executive Engineer v. Dilla Ram (Latest HLJ 2008 HP 1007) and relying upon the decision of the Apex Court in Harinder Pal Singh (supra), wherein the market value of the land under acquisition situated in five different villages was assessed uniformly irrespective of its nature and quality, also awarded compensation on uniform rates.

    22. It is a matter of fact that the entire land was put to public purpose. Dam stood constructed thereupon. It was used for only one purpose and as such there cannot be any error in uniform determination of the market value of the acquired land.

    23. It is a matter of record that claimants examined one witness, namely, Gurbax Singh (P.W 1) and proved on record sale deeds (Ex. PA and Ex. PB) and beneficiary examined five witnesses, namely, R.R Kaul (R.W 1), Renu Ranaut (R.W 2), Rajinder Singh (R.W 3), Yashwant Singh (R.W 4), Om Prakash (R.W 5), and placed on record sale deeds (Ex.RC to Ex.RG); awards passed by Reference Court (dated 31.05.2008 Ex.R.W 3.F; 30.04.2009 Ex.R.W 3.G; 21.03.2011 Ex.RA and 21.03.2011 Ex.RB); and copies of statements (Ex.R.W 3.E and Ex.R.W 5.A); as also agreement (Ex.RH).

    24. Sale deeds produced by the claimants stand rejected by the Reference Court for the reason that they do not reflect true market value of the acquired land. Land sold in terms of sale deed (Ex. PA) was a small parcel of land and cannot be considered to be an exemplar sale deed and sale deed (Ex. PB) was executed much after i.e 3 years of the commencement of acquisition proceedings.

    25. Insofar as exemplar sale deeds produced by the beneficiary are concerned, save and except for one sale deed all pertain to other villages. Insofar as sale deed (Ex.RC) is concerned, though it pertains to village Harnora, but then there is no evidence of similarity of the acquired land with that of exemplar land. Also it pertains to small chunk of land i.e 4 biswas.

    26. Insofar as sale deeds placed on record by the beneficiary are concerned, no doubt, in view of the statutory provisions (Section 51-A of the Act) and the law laid down by the Apex Court in Cement Corpn. of India Ltd. v. Purya, (2004) 8 SCC 270, these sale transactions cannot be ignored, but however, there is no evidence on record, establishing comparability of the acquired land with these exemplar sale transactions. No ocular evidence was led by the beneficiary. In this view of the matter, these sale transactions cannot be accounted for, for just determination of a fair market value of the acquired land.

    27. Insofar as the tripartite agreement (Ex.RH) is concerned, it also has no bearing in the outcome of the case.

    28. Also it cannot be said that the awards passed by the Reference Court i.e awards passed by Reference Court (Ex.R.W 3.F, Ex.R.W 3.G, Ex.RA and Ex.RB) have any bearing for want of any evidence of similarity with regard to the use, nature and potential.

    29. On the other hand, one finds that the evidence led by the claimants stands considered and discussed by the Reference Court. Discussion is based on correct and complete appreciation of material on record (paragraphs No. 11, 21, 23, 24 and 25). Reasoning adopted is logical and reasonable. Conclusion is just, fair and reasonable.

    30. Insofar as the claim with regard to the superstructure is concerned, one finds the Reference Court to have aptly dealt with the issue in paragraph 37 of the impugned Award. From bare perusal of paragraph 37, it is quite apparent that no evidence with regard to superstructure, worthy of credence was led by the parties. Hence in the absence of any other evidence on record, it cannot be said that the Reference Court erred in re-determining the market value of the acquired land and awarding rates on uniform basis irrespective of its classification.

    31. Noticeably appeals arising out of land reference petitions pertain to the very same award i.e award No. 5 of 2003, dated 15.01.2003, which already stands adjudicated by this Court in R.F.A No. 118 of 2014, titled as NTPC Ltd. (Kol Dam) v. Sukh Ram, decided on 15.12.2016, wherein market value of the acquired land stands re-determined @ Rs. 4,69,955/- per bigha.

    32. Reliance by the beneficiary on the decision rendered by the Apex Court in Trishala Jain v. State of Uttranchal, (2011) 6 SCC 47, is also misplaced for the decision is rendered in the attending facts and circumstances totally different from the one in hand. Also this Court has otherwise dealt with the issue in the earlier part of the judgment.

    33. No other point urged or proved.

    34. Hence in the given facts and circumstances, no interference is warranted. It cannot be said that the findings returned by the Reference Court are perverse, illegal or erroneous. As such, present appeal stands dismissed, so also pending application(s), if any.

    35. Cross-objection/cross-appeals stand rejected in view of the aforesaid discussion, more so, for the reason that no evidence other than the one discussed hereinabove, was brought to the notice of the Court.

    36. Quite evidently, in terms of award No. 5 of 2003, so passed by the Collector, several land reference petitions came to be clubbed and disposed of by the common impugned award dated 26.09.2011, passed by District Judge, Bilaspur, H.P, in Reference Petition No. 37 of 2005 titled as Ram Rakhi v. Land Acquisition Collector, Kol Dam, Bilaspur. Common evidence was led by the parties in land Reference Petition No. 33 of 2005. Learned counsel for the parties jointly submit that decision rendered in the present appeal would have an automatic bearing on the other connected appeals, arising out of the very same impugned award, pending before this Court. Registrar (Judicial) to take appropriate instructions from Hon'ble the Chief Justice for listing of such connected appeals, before the appropriate Court particulars whereof shall also be supplied by learned counsel for the parties.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ntpc Ltd., Kol Dam, Barmana, Bilaspur v. Ram Rakhi & Another S
    (Jan 11, 2017)