AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2004 INSC 231
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Regulation 32 of the Reserve Bank of India (Staff) Regulations, 1948
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2004 INSC 231
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Article 136 of the Constitution
  • Regulation 32 of the Reserve Bank of India (Staff) Regulations, 1948
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Respondent 1, an Assistant Currency Officer (Grade C) with the Reserve Bank of India (“RBI”), was directed on 1-10-1988 to perform the vault-related duties of a Grade B officer who had proceeded on sudden leave. Respondent 1 declined to open and close the vault, asserting lack of prior experience, though he undertook the remaining duties of the Claims Department on 3-10-1988. RBI treated the refusal as insubordination and, on 1-12-1989, issued a charge-sheet under Regulation 32 of the Reserve Bank of India (Staff) Regulations, 1948. While disciplinary proceedings were pending, RBI conducted its 1989 all-India promotion exercise from Grade C to Grade D before a high-power Selection Board chaired by a retired Judge of the Bombay High Court. Under the governing 1983 policy, candidates needed 170/300 aggregate marks (200 for service record and 100 for interview). Respondent 1 scored 162 and was not empanelled.

He filed Writ Petition No. 5483 of 1990 challenging both the charge-sheet and his non-selection. During the writ’s pendency, RBI imposed the minor penalty of permanent reduction of his substantive pay by one stage; his departmental appeal failed on 4-8-1994. He amended the writ petition to assail the enquiry and punishment. On 12-12-2001, the Rajasthan High Court (Jaipur Bench) allowed the petition: it set aside the disciplinary penalty, annulled the entire 1989 selection process, and directed RBI to re-frame the selection so as to promote Respondent 1 to Grade D with effect from 1989. RBI obtained special-leave and appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the disciplinary penalty of permanently lowering Respondent 1’s substantive pay by one stage was justified on the charge of insubordination.
  2. Whether the High Court erred in setting aside the entire 1989 promotion process and directing RBI to promote Respondent 1 to Grade D with retrospective effect.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Reserve Bank of India)

  • Respondent 1 was duly interviewed on 29-5-1990 and four subsequent occasions (8-6-1990, 3-9-1991, 6-4-1992, 5-2-1993) but consistently found unsuitable.
  • The Selection Board, chaired by a retired High Court Judge, was impartial and empowered to set its own assessment procedure, including allotting 100/300 marks for interview.
  • The Board’s record, including a forwarding letter signed by all members, showed no irregularity or extraneous influence; the High Court therefore exceeded its jurisdiction by questioning the award of marks.

Respondent 1

  • The marksheet did not disclose individual marks by Board members; instead identical marks were allotted, indicating a flawed procedure.
  • The marksheet itself lacked individual signatures, though the covering letter was signed, casting doubt on authenticity.
  • No merit list or underlying promotion policy was produced before the High Court, suggesting arbitrariness; extraneous factors caused his low performance-appraisal score despite success in the interview.
  • Findings of fact by the High Court should not be disturbed under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Issue 1 – Disciplinary Penalty: The Supreme Court affirmed the High Court’s view that Respondent 1’s conduct did not constitute insubordination under Regulation 32. His contemporaneous explanation—lack of vault experience and completion of all other tasks—showed bona fide refusal limited to a specific unfamiliar function. Consequently, the factual foundation for misconduct was absent, rendering the penalty unsustainable.

Issue 2 – Setting Aside the Selection Process: The Court disagreed with the High Court. It emphasised that:

  • The Selection Board was high-powered, nationwide, and chaired by a retired Judge, ensuring impartiality.
  • The Board allotted 200 marks for service record and 100 for interview in conformity with the 1983 executive policy; candidates needed 170 aggregate marks.
  • The Court examined the original records and found the marksheets genuine, duly forwarded and signed; there was no interpolation or evidence of extraneous considerations.
  • The Board was entitled to prescribe its own evaluation procedure; judicial interference is limited where no mala fides or procedural illegality is demonstrated.

The High Court therefore erred in invalidating the entire selection and mandating Respondent 1’s promotion.

Holding and Implications

PARTLY ALLOWED: The disciplinary penalty imposed on Respondent 1 is quashed; however, the High Court’s direction to set aside the 1989 promotion process and promote Respondent 1 is reversed. Each party bears its own costs.

Implications: Respondent 1 is relieved from the penalty but gains no automatic promotion; the validity of the 1989 selection stands restored. The judgment reiterates judicial restraint in reviewing expert selection bodies absent demonstrable illegality or mala fides.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Reserve Bank Of India And Another v. C.L Toora And Others

    S.H Kapadia, J.— This appeal by special leave is filed by Reserve Bank of India against the judgment and order of the High Court of Rajasthan, Bench at Jaipur dated 12-12-2001 directing the appellant to consider Respondent 1 for promotion to Grade D ignoring the fact that a high-power Selection Board presided by a retired Judge of the Bombay High Court had found the respondent unsuitable for selection to the said grade.

    2. The facts giving rise to this appeal are as follows:

    On 1-10-1988, the Currency Officer of the appellant asked Respondent 1 who was Assistant Currency Officer in Grade C to look after, on 3-10-1988, the duties of M.S Janagal, Assistant Currency Officer (Grade B), who had proceeded suddenly on casual leave. It is the case of the appellant that Respondent 1 herein refused to comply with the orders of the Currency Officer stating that he cannot be asked to discharge the functions of a Grade B officer. Accordingly, the said respondent was charge-sheeted on 1-12-1989 for insubordination under Regulation 32 of the Reserve Bank of India (Staff) Regulations, 1948 (hereinafter referred to as “the said Regulations”). In the preliminary enquiry preceding the charge-sheet, the said respondent in reply to show-cause notice stated that on 1-10-1988, seven Grade B officers were present on duty and only one of them, Mr M.S Janagal had applied for casual leave; that he had never operated the vault in the past; that vault duties were entrusted to Grade B officers and as such, except in emergency, a Grade C officer was entrusted with such duties and, therefore, he did not intend insubordination. In fact, he pointed out that on 3-10-1988, he did all the work of the Claims Department except opening and closing of vault. By his reply to the show-cause notice, he further pointed out that he was under mental agony on that day in the background enumerated in para 2 of his reply to the show-cause notice. The appellant, however, did not accept the explanation of the respondent. In the meantime, the appellant undertook selection process in the matter of promotions of officers from Grade C to Grade D. Respondent 1 herein was one of the candidates. The appellant constituted a high-power Selection Board presided by Mr Justice A.S Ginwala, a retired Judge of the Bombay High Court. The Selection Board held several meetings at Calcutta, New Delhi, Bombay and Bangalore, as promotions were to be made at all-India level. The Selection Board recommended candidates for promotion in terms of the executive policy formulated by the management in 1983 and which was in existence in 1989. Under the said policy, a candidate had to secure in all 170 marks out of 300 for empanelment for promotion to Grade D. Respondent 1 herein secured 162 marks and consequently he failed to qualify. At this stage, it may be mentioned that the said respondent was interviewed at New Delhi centre on 2-6-1989, wherein he was successful but overall he did not secure 170 marks, hence not found suitable for the panel year 1989. On 23-10-1990, he filed Writ Petition No. 5483 of 1990 challenging the charge-sheet and his non-selection. During the pendency of the writ petition, disciplinary enquiry was completed and the competent authority imposed the minor penalty of lowering his substantive pay by one stage permanently, against which he filed departmental appeal, which was also rejected on 4-8-1994. Respondent 1 filed an amendment application to the writ petition challenging the enquiry proceedings as well as the order of punishment. By impugned judgment, the writ petition was allowed on the ground that the charge of insubordination was not proved. The High Court also found fault with the non-selection of Respondent 1 on the ground that the procedure and the criteria adopted by the Selection Board were improper. It doubted the decision of the Selection Board in awarding only 162 marks on the ground that the said respondent had obtained the requisite 32 marks in the interview but he was given only 130 marks on performance appraisal. In the circumstances, the entire selection was set aside and the appellants were directed to reframe selection and consider the said respondent for promotion to Scale D from 1989. Aggrieved, Reserve Bank of India has come to this Court by way of this appeal.

    3. Two issues arise for determination, firstly, whether the appellant was justified in imposing the above penalty of lowering the substantive pay of the respondent by one stage permanently; and secondly, whether the High Court was right in setting aside the entire selection and directing the appellant to promote Respondent 1 to Scale D w.e.f 1989.

    4. On the first point, we are of the view that the High Court was right in coming to the conclusion that the conduct of Respondent 1 was not such as to warrant disciplinary action. As stated above, in the preliminary enquiry, Respondent 1 has given his explanation vide letter dated 12-6-1989. We have gone through the letter, as discussed above. Regulation 32 states that every employee shall obey directions given to him from time to time by his superiors. In the present case, we do not find any insubordination or disobedience as alleged. He has stated in his reply that he has no experience of opening and closing the vault and that he did all the work of the Claims Department on 3-10-1988, except opening and closing of vault. In the circumstances, we are in agreement with the view taken by the High Court in the matter of disciplinary proceedings that there was no foundation for alleged misconduct.

    5. The second issue is whether the High Court was right in setting aside the entire selection with the direction to the appellant to consider the said respondent for promotion to Scale D from 1989. Mr Harish N. Salve, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant submitted that Respondent 1 was interviewed along with other candidates by the Selection Board. On 29-5-1990, Respondent 1 was advised about his non-selection and thereafter he had appeared in interview four times i.e on 8-6-1990, 3-9-1991, 6-4-1992 and 5-2-1993 but was found unsuitable. It was submitted that the Selection Board was presided by a retired Judge of the High Court of unquestionable impartiality who had no axe to grind. He contended that it was open to the Selection Board to formulate its own procedure in the matter of allotment of marks for interview, written test and performance appraisal and that the High Court had erred in fixing qualifying marks for interview. In this connection, it was pointed out that the Selection Board had prescribed 100 marks out of 300 for interview which the High Court has held to be on the higher side. He submitted that the High Court had erred in coming to the conclusion that non-selection of Respondent 1 was on account of extraneous factors. He submitted that the covering letter enclosing the marksheet has been signed by all the members of the Selection Board. Mr Salve produced before us the entire record. Per contra, Mr A.B Rohtagi, learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of Respondent 1 submitted that the individual members of the Selection Board have not assigned individual marks in the marksheet and that all the members have allotted equal marks and, therefore, the procedure was faulty. He submitted that the mark list did not bear the signatures of the members of the Board though all the members have signed the forwarding letter. It was urged that no merit list was prepared and no policy was produced before the High Court on the basis of which marks came to be given. He submitted that the respondent was successful in the interview and for extraneous reasons, he was given less marks for his performance and consequently he could not obtain 170 marks. It was submitted that the High Court had examined the entire record and has given finding of fact and, therefore, this Court should not interfere in this matter under Article 136 of the Constitution.

    6. We are of the view that the High Court had erred in setting aside the selection and in directing the appellant Bank to consider Respondent 1 for promotion from 1989. The appellant had constituted high-power Selection Board presided by a retired Judge of the Bombay High Court. The Selection Board, as stated above, held interviews of candidates from various centres at all-India level. The Selection Board held its sitting at Calcutta, New Delhi, Bombay and Bangalore. It provided for 200 marks for service records and 100 marks for interview in terms of the policy formulated by the management as far back as July 1983. Under that policy, the candidates were required to obtain aggregate qualifying marks of 170 out of 300. The Board was entitled to formulate its own procedure. Moreover, we have perused the records and proceedings of the Selection Board produced before us. The forwarding letter enclosing the marksheets has been signed by all the members of the Board. There is no interpolation in the marks given to the candidates as alleged. On facts it cannot be said, as held by the High Court, that the Board had taken into account extraneous factors. Hence, the High Court erred in setting aside the selection and directing the appellant Bank to consider the case of Respondent 1 for promotion to Grade D from 1989.

    7. For the aforestated reasons, we hold that there was no misconduct committed by Respondent 1 and the appellant had erred in imposing the penalty on Respondent 1 of lowering his substantive pay by one stage permanently. However, we hold that the High Court had erred in setting aside the selection made by the Selection Board and directing the appellant to reframe selection and consider Respondent 1 for promotion to Scale D from 1989.

    8. Accordingly, the appeal stands partly allowed, with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Reserve Bank Of India And Another v. C.L Toora And Others
    (Apr 5, 2004)