AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Smart Summary

Summary of Opinion by Rajesh Bindal J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are employed as Data Entry Operators with the Haryana Urban Development Authority (HUDA) and have approached the court seeking a direction for regularisation of their services. They were recruited either via advertisements or campus placements and have been working for periods ranging from about 12 to 17 years. At the time of their initial appointments the petitioners met the qualifications then prescribed.

Relevant events recorded in the opinion include:

  • HUDA created 10 posts of Data Entry Operators in a meeting dated 26.11.1998 with qualification "10+2 with one year diploma in computer operators"; advertisement issued on 10.1.2000 for regular selection, but selections were not completed and the posts were abolished by government communication dated 20.9.2000.
  • Despite the abolition, petitioners continued to work on contract. In 2009 the Regulations were amended (notification dated 19.3.2009) creating 46 new posts with modified qualifications; an advertisement for these 46 regular posts was issued on 12.3.2010 but no selections were made.
  • Separately, 16 posts were advertised on 7.3.2010 to be filled on contract basis, and 12–13 persons were appointed on contract pursuant to that advertisement.

HUDA recommended the petitioners for regularisation under the State Government's regularisation policy (notified 1.10.2003, amended 10.2.2004) to the Haryana Bureau of Public Enterprises, but the recommendation was rejected on the ground that only employees appointed against sanctioned (regular) posts were eligible for regularisation; the petitioners' initial appointments were not against sanctioned posts.

The writ petition was heard and the opinion records the court's decision directing regularisation of the petitioners' services and disposing of the writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the action of the respondents in refusing to regularise the petitioners' services after long continuous contractual employment (over a decade) was unreasonable and arbitrary.
  2. Whether the petitioners are disentitled to regularisation because they were not initially appointed against sanctioned (regular) posts and/or because the qualifications subsequently prescribed for newly created posts differ from the qualifications they possessed when appointed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners had been recruited either by advertisement or campus placement and have worked for HUDA for 12–17 years, satisfying the qualifications prescribed at the time of their appointment.
  • HUDA had at times created sanctioned posts (10 posts created in 1998, later abolished; 46 posts created in 2009) and advertised for regular selection but selections were not completed — the petitioners contend this indicates continuity of work and availability of regular posts in substance.
  • Because the petitioners have performed the work continuously for more than a decade to the satisfaction of authorities, they should be regularised; denying regularisation on the technicality that no sanctioned post existed at initial appointment is unfair and amounts to an unfair labour practice.
  • Even if qualifications were modified later (in 2009), the petitioners' long experience on the posts should be treated as conferring the necessary qualification.
  • Reliance was placed on two precedents: Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod Labhu Bechar (JT 2001 (2) SC 16) and Sanjay Singh Kushwah v. Resident Commissioner, Govt. of M.P., 2008 (2) SCT 43.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The petitioners were appointed only on a contractual basis; they were not appointed against sanctioned regular vacancies.
  • Under the State Government's regularisation policy only contractual employees appointed against sanctioned posts are eligible for regularisation; because there were no sanctioned posts at the time of the petitioners' initial appointments, they are not entitled to regularisation.
  • As per the rules and the qualifications prescribed for later advertised posts, the petitioners are not qualified to be appointed to those regular posts; therefore they cannot claim regularisation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod Labhu Bechar, JT 2001 (2) SC 16

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Sanjay Singh Kushwah v. Resident Commissioner, Govt. of M.P., 2008 (2) SCT 43

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

This information was not available in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the factual matrix and framed the central enquiry as whether the respondents' refusal to regularise the petitioners' services was unreasonable and arbitrary. The court addressed the two principal contentions raised by the respondents: (i) that the petitioners were not appointed against sanctioned posts and therefore could not be regularised; and (ii) that the petitioners were not qualified for the regular posts as per later-prescribed qualifications.

The court's analysis proceeded along the following lines, as stated in the opinion:

  • The petitioners had been continuously employed for more than 12 years carrying out the same kind of work, which the court characterised as perennial/continuous in nature (Data Entry Operators work required on an ongoing basis given HUDA's responsibilities and the era of computerisation).
  • The government had, at different times, created sanctioned posts for Data Entry Operators (10 posts in 1998; 46 posts in 2009) and had issued advertisements for regular recruitment, but the selection processes were not completed and in one instance the posts were abolished (the 1998-created 10 posts were abolished on 20.9.2000 for reasons not apparent on record).
  • The pattern — creation of sanctioned posts and failure to complete regularisation or abolition of posts while continuing to engage contractual staff — led the court to view the employer's conduct skeptically, suggesting that contractual engagement was used despite the existence or need of regular posts.
  • With regard to qualifications, the court noted it was not disputed that the petitioners were qualified at the time of their initial appointment and also met the qualifications prescribed when 10 posts were created in 1998. The court observed that later-modified qualifications (in 2009) that differed from earlier criteria should not defeat the claim of employees who already had long experience on the posts.
  • On the combination of continuous nature of the work, long and uninterrupted service by the petitioners, prior creation and advertisement of sanctioned posts (even if selections were not completed), and absence of any substantive selection of regular incumbents against newly created posts, the court concluded that the respondents' refusal to regularise the petitioners was arbitrary.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court directed that the services of the petitioners be regularised.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The respondents were ordered to regularise the petitioners' services; the writ petition was disposed of.
  • The opinion does not discuss broader implications or declare a new legal principle beyond its decision in the present factual context; no further precedent-creating claim is made within the text of this opinion.

    Anand Walia And Others Petitioners v. Haryana Urban Development Authority And Others S

    Rajesh Bindal J.

    1. The petitioners, who are working as Data Entry Operators with Haryana Urban Development Authority (for short, ‘HUDA’), have approached this court seeking a direction for regularisation of their services.

    2. Learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners in the present case were recruited as Data Entry Operators by HUDA either by issuing advertisement or by way of campus placement. They are working there for the period ranging from 12 to 17 years. At the time of their appointment, whatever qualifications were prescribed, the petitioners fulfilled the same. In the meeting held on 26.11.1998, HUDA created 10 new posts of Data Entry Operators. The qualification prescribed therefor was 10+2 with one year diploma in computer operators from a recognised institution. Advertisement was issued on 10.1.2000 for selection against the newly created posts on regular basis. The petitioners also applied in response to the advertisement, however, no selections were made. Vide communication dated 20.9.2000, the government abolished the posts of Data Entry Operators and it was directed that appointments be made on contract basis depending on the requirement. Vide notification dated 19.3.2009, Haryana Urban Development Authority Service Regulations, 1989 (for short, ‘the Regulations’) were amended and 46 new posts of Data Entry Operators were created. The qualifications were also modified. Advertisement was issued for recruitment on the newly created 46 posts of Data Entry Operators on regular basis on 12.3.2010, however, no selections were made. At the same time, on 7.3.2010, 16 posts of Data Entry Operators were advertised to be filled on contract basis. As against this, 12-13 persons were selected and appointed on contract basis.

    3. The submission of learned counsel is that the petitioners are working for the last more than 12 years to the satisfaction of the authorities. They were recruited after advertisement in the newspaper or by way of campus placement and were fully qualified when they were appointed and even in the year 1999, when qualifications were prescribed for 10 newly created posts of Data Entry Operators, which were later on abolished. In terms of various policies framed by the government from time to time, which were adopted by HUDA, the services of the petitioners are required to be regularised. He further submitted that the ground on which the case of the petitioners was rejected for regularisation is totally misconceived. No regular incumbent has been appointed against the newly created 46 posts of Data Entry Operators. To state that at the time when the petitioners were appointed there were no regular posts is nothing else but unfair labour practice. Once the petitioners are working with HUDA for the last more than a decade and are being paid salary, the plea that technically there were no posts, is totally misconceived. The mere fact that the petitioners had been permitted to work for so long shows that the work is available in continuity. At one stage, even 10 posts were created in the year 1998. Even at that time, the petitioners were eligible as per the qualifications prescribed, but the same were abolished for the reasons best known to the authorities. Even if at this stage the respondents claim that the petitioners are not qualified as per the qualifications prescribed in the advertisement, as they are working on the posts for over a decade, that itself amounts to qualification. In support of the arguments, reliance was placed upon Gujarat Agricultural University v. Rathod Labhu Bechar, JT 2001 (2) SC 16 and Sanjay Singh Kushwah v. Resident Commissioner, Govt. of M.P, 2008 (2) SCT 43.

    4. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents submitted that the petitioners were merely appointed on contractual basis. In terms of the policy framed by the State Government for regularisation of services of the employees working in different categories, the case of the petitioners was recommended to Haryana Bureau of Public Enterprises, however, the same was rejected on the ground that in terms of the policy, only those employees could be regularised who had been appointed against regular vacancies. As at the time of initial appointment of the petitioners there was no regular vacancy, they were not entitled to regularisation. He further submitted that as per rules, the petitioners are not qualified to be appointed and they cannot seek regularisation.

    5. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the paper book.

    6. The dates of appointment of the petitioners on contract basis, as have been mentioned in paragraph 4 of the writ petition, which are extracted below, have not been denied by the respondents:

    “Sr. No. Name of the petitioners Date of Break Total Service appointment if any (Approx.)

    1. Anand Walia 4.10.1994 Nil 15 years 5 months

    2. Piyush Verma 29.10.1993 Nil 16 years 4 months

    3. Sanjeev Kumar 22.6.1995 Nil 14 years 8 months

    4. Somesh Gupta 14.8.1992 Nil 17 years 7 months

    5. Lovekesh 31.3.1994 Nil 15 years 11 months

    6. Parveen Kumar 4.7.1996 to 5 2 years 10 24.5.1999 & months months (before 15.11.199 20 days break) 10 years till today 4 months (after break). Total 13 years 2 months

    7. Uma Joshi 18.9.1997 4 1 year 8 to months months 19.5.1999 & (before break) 24.9.1999 and 10 years 5 till today months (after break) Total: 12 years 1 month.”

    7. The fact mentioned in paragraph 3 of the writ petition that some of the candidates were selected through campus placement and some in pursuance to the advertisements issued in the newspapers on 23.9.1994 and 28.6.1996 has also not been denied. Though the work of Data Entry Operators with HUDA is of perennial nature, but the same was got done by engaging staff on contract basis. No regular posts were sanctioned. Good sense prevailed upon the authorities when the government vide communication dated 8.1.1999 informed HUDA regarding sanction for creation of 10 posts of Data Entry Operators. The qualification prescribed therefor was “10+2 with one year diploma in computer operators from a recognised institution”. An advertisement was issued on 10.1.2000 for recruitment on 10 newly created posts of Data Entry Operators on regular basis, but the process was not completed. Ultimately, the government abolished these posts on 20.9.2000, though apparently there is no reason available therefor on record. The petitioners, who were selected way back in the years 1992 to 1997, continued working on contract basis only. Again by way of amendment in the Regulations, as notified on 19.3.2009, 46 posts of Data Entry Operators were created. The qualification prescribed therefor was “at least second class Graduate with one year regular computer course, working knowledge of Stenography (Hindi/English) with speed of 30 words per minute and experience of 6 months in Government/Semi Government/Limited Organization.”

    8. The case of the petitioners was recommended by HUDA in terms of the regularisation policy notified by the State Government on 1.10.2003, as amended on 10.2.2004, to Haryana Bureau of Public Enterprises, however, as per the stand taken in the written statement filed by HUDA, the petitioners were not granted the relief as only those contractual employees could be regularised who were appointed against sanctioned posts. As at the relevant time when the petitioners were appointed, there was no sanctioned post, they were not regularised.

    9. In the aforesaid factual matrix, what is required to be considered as to whether the action of the respondents in not regularising the services of the petitioners is unreasonable and arbitrary. Two points have been raised by the respondents to negate the claim. In my opinion, both are misconceived. As far as availability of sanctioned posts is concerned, in my opinion, considering the fact that the petitioners had been working in the establishment for the last more than 12 years itself shows that the work available is of continuous nature. We are living in the era of technology. Every record is being computerised. HUDA is the only wholly controlled agency in the State for urbanisation. It has developed urban estates in almost all the cities of the State and is controlling lacs of plots. The entire record thereof pertaining to ownership, transfer or payment of instalments etc. is required to be maintained. The job is not temporary in nature. The persons are required on regular basis. The government had also realised this fact and had, in fact, created 10 posts of Data Entry Operators in the year 1998. The qualifications were also prescribed, which all the petitioners fulfilled. Even advertisement was also issued for making regular selection on the newly created posts, however, the same was abandoned. Ultimately on 20.9.2000, the posts were abolished, as if the effort was to exploit the contractual employees, who were not in a bargaining position with HUDA. Thereafter, again in 2009, 46 regular posts were created. Advertisement was also issued for recruitment on regular basis on 12.3.2010, but no selections were made. As against this, another advertisement was issued on 7.3.2010 for appointment of 16 Data Entry Operators on contractual basis and selections were made in pursuance thereto. The qualifications were also modified when 46 new posts were created in the year 2009.

    10. In the aforesaid factual matrix, it cannot be said that at present there are no sanctioned posts, though at the initial stage when the petitioners were appointed there were no sanctioned posts, but the kind of work which the petitioners were doing is of regular nature. It is also not in dispute that at the time when the petitioners were appointed they were qualified and even in terms of the qualifications prescribed when 10 new posts were created in the year 1998. They are stated to be not qualified only in terms of the qualification prescribed for the posts advertised in the year 2009 when the petitioners already have more than 12 years' experience on the posts.

    11. In view of my aforesaid discussion, in my opinion, the action of the authorities in not regularising the services of the petitioners is arbitrary. The respondents are directed to regularise the services of the petitioners.

    12. The writ petition stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Anand Walia And Others Petitioners v. Haryana Urban Development Authority And Others S
    (Jan 9, 2013)