Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 143, 144, 145, 147, 148 and 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
  • Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Sections 143, 144, 145, 147, 148 and 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC)
  • Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Govind Reddy was stabbed to death on the night of 12-4-1999. Srinivasa @ Raja (PW-1) lodged a complaint at Koramangala Police Station the same night, initially naming only the present appellant (Accused 1) and later adding Accused 2-6, all relatives of the appellant. A charge-sheet under Sections 143, 144, 145, 147, 148 and 302/149 IPC was filed against six accused.

During trial, eight prosecution witnesses were examined. The trial court acquitted Accused 3, 5 and 6; Accused 4 died during trial; Accused 1 and 2 were convicted under Section 302/34 IPC. On appeal, the High Court (25-3-2010) acquitted Accused 2 but upheld the conviction of Accused 1. The Supreme Court remitted the case to the High Court on 29-11-2010; after rehearing, the High Court again dismissed Accused 1’s appeal on 16-6-2011. The present Supreme Court judgment decides Accused 1’s further appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the conviction of the appellant could be sustained solely on the testimony of PW-1 when all other co-accused had been acquitted and the prosecution evidence contained material discrepancies.
  2. Whether the prosecution proved the appellant’s guilt beyond reasonable doubt in light of conflicting medical evidence, doubtful weapon recovery, and timing and lighting conditions at the scene.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • PW-1’s credibility is doubtful: he falsely implicated Accused 2-6 and introduced PW-2 as an alleged eyewitness whose testimony was later disbelieved.
  • Motivation for false implication existed because of ongoing civil disputes over land between PW-1’s group and the appellant’s family.
  • The medical expert (PW-7) twice testified that the fatal injuries could not have been caused by the alleged weapon (MO-7), contradicting PW-1’s version.
  • Unexplained delay: although the police station was only about 100 ft away, the FIR was lodged at 10 p.m., giving PW-1 time to fabricate the story.
  • Lack of lighting: site sketch (Ex. P-6) shows no lamp post; hence PW-1 could not have clearly identified the assailant at night from a distance.
  • Immediately after the incident PW-1 told both PW-6 and the Head Constable that “somebody” had killed the deceased, naming no accused, undermining his later detailed account.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found that the conviction rested exclusively on PW-1’s testimony, which was unreliable for several reasons:

  • Lighting conditions were not proved; therefore, PW-1’s ability to identify the attacker was doubtful.
  • PW-1’s initial statements to PW-6 and the Head Constable did not name the appellant, indicating possible later embellishment.
  • The medical evidence was incompatible with the prosecution narrative: PW-7 categorically stated that the injuries could not have been inflicted by MO-7, the knife allegedly used by the appellant.
  • The supposed recovery of MO-7 on the basis of the appellant’s disclosure was not proved and was not relied on by the prosecution.
  • Given these inconsistencies, the Court held that suspicion or vengeance stemming from land disputes could explain PW-1’s implication of the appellant.

Collectively, these factors created serious doubt, and the prosecution failed to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; Conviction Set Aside. The appellant is to be released forthwith unless required in any other case.

Implications: The decision affects only the parties by overturning the appellant’s conviction; it sets no new legal precedent.

    Narayana Reddy Alias Babu v. State Of Karnataka .

    Order

    1. Six persons were implicated in a trial for murder of one Govind Reddy. A complaint to this effect was lodged with Koramangala Police Station by Srinivasa alias Raja (PW 1) on 12-4-1999 at about 10 p.m. stating that Accused 1 (who is the appellant before us in this appeal) had stabbed Govind Reddy with knife (MO 7) after 8.30 p.m. between 9.15 p.m. and 9.30 p.m. FIR to this effect was registered. In his later statements, PW 1 named Accused 2 to 6 also, who are the relatives of the appellant. The matter was investigated into and ultimately a charge-sheet was filed for the offences punishable under Sections 143, 144, 145, 147, 148 and 302 read with Section 149 of the Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) against all the six accused persons.

    2. Eight witnesses were examined by the prosecution. PW 1 and PW 2 (Prakash) claimed that they were the eyewitnesses to the incident. PW 3 and PW 4 were panch witnesses to the alleged recovery of the weapon. PW 5 was the Junior Engineer who had prepared the sketch by visiting along with the police team to the place of occurrence where dead body of the deceased was found and recovered. PW 6 is the wife of the deceased. She is not an eyewitness but stated that she had come to the spot after she was informed about the murder of her husband by PW 1. PW 7 is the doctor who had conducted the post-mortem examination. PW 8 is the police officer who prepared the investigation report though he was not the investigating officer, as the investigating officer had died in the meantime. After the conclusion of the trial, statements of the accused persons were recorded under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure wherein they denied the charges or evidence against them stating that the witnesses PW 1 and PW 2 had deposed falsely in the court.

    3. After hearing the arguments, the trial court acquitted Accused 3, 5 and 6 of all the charges framed but convicted Accused 1 and 2 for the offence punishable under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC and acquitted them of other charges. Accused 4 had died during the trial and, therefore, the trial against him has abated.

    4. Being aggrieved by the judgment of the trial court, Accused 1 and 2 filed an appeal before the High Court. The High Court vide its judgment dated 25-3-2010 Criminal Appeal No. 578 of 2007 acquitted Accused 2 and dismissed the appeal of the appellant herein. The appellant challenged the said verdict of the High Court by filing special leave petition in this Court being SLP (Criminal) No. 4721 of 2001 in which leave was granted and it was converted into Criminal Appeal No. 2235 of 2010. This appeal was decided by this Court on 29-11-2010 2010 SCC OnLine SC 9 by remitting the matter to the High Court for fresh consideration. In the meantime, the appellant was ordered to be released on bail. After the remittal of the case to the High Court, the High Court heard the same afresh and has maintained its earlier decision inasmuch as the appeal of the appellant was again dismissed by the High Court vide judgment dated 16-6-2011 2011 SCC OnLine Kar 4296. It is this judgment which is impugned in the present appeal.

    5. To state the case of the prosecution in brief, Accused 4 who died during the trial was the landlord of plot bearing Sy. No. 116/8 of erstwhile Koramangala Village in Bangalore City. Accused 4 and Accused 5 are the full brothers. The Bangalore Development Authority acquired the above land for the development of Bangalore City. There was a public road to the north of the said property. Accused 4 and Accused 5 were alleged to have erected a compound and encroached upon the said public road. PW 1 (Srinivasa alias Raja) and others filed a petition before the Revenue Assistant Commissioner and got it demolished. Accused 4 filed civil suits before the City Civil Court, Bangalore City against PW 1 and others which are still pending for adjudication before the respective civil courts. In spite of it, there were petty quarrels between the two groups in connection with the said pathway as Accused 4 used to block the road by tying the cattle over the said road.

    6. It was alleged that on 12-4-1999 at about 8.30 p.m., PW 1 was called by the deceased over telephone to lay a stone slab over the gutter in front of his house adjacent to the disputed road to enable him to take his two-wheeler. Accordingly, PW 1 and the deceased have together laid a stone slab over the gutter. In the meanwhile, Accused 5 and 6 who were residing right opposite to the road came and asked PW 1 to remove the slab as it is not a public road and the same is their own property. They also abused PW 1 and the deceased in filthy language and threatened them with dire consequences. At this juncture, Accused 4 and his sons (Accused 1, 2 and 3) came to the spot armed with deadly weapons like clubs, chopper and long, formed into an unlawful assembly and proclaimed to kill them if anybody dare to come forward.

    7. It was alleged that PW 1 got scared and told the deceased to lodge complaint to the police. Both of them started proceeding in front of the house of Papaiah Reddy to go to the police station. The deceased was going ahead of PW 1 about 20 ft. While so proceeding, PW 1 slowed down to make a phone call to his another uncle by name Surendra Reddy about the incident. By then, the deceased started screaming calling “Raja, Raja”. In turn, PW 1 turned back and saw Accused 1 assaulting the deceased with a long knife on his hand and abdomen. The deceased sustained bleeding injuries and slumped on the mud road in front of the house of James Nirmal Raj. None came to the rescue of the deceased. There was severe bleeding from his stomach. Immediately, PW 1 ran towards the house of the deceased to inform the wife of the deceased. PW 1 returned to the place of assault with others and found that Govind Reddy breathed his last. Thereafter, all of them went to the police station and PW 1 lodged the complaint to the police as per Ext. P-1 on 12-4-1999 at 10 p.m. against the four accused persons and others including the petitioner for the offences under Sections 143, 144, 145, 147, 148, 302 read with Section 149 IPC.

    8. It was alleged that PW 1 asserts in his complaint that the incident had taken place on 12-4-1999 between 9.15 p.m. and 9.30 p.m. and the motive for the commission of the offence was in connection with the civil disputes between the deceased and Accused 4.

    9. From the aforesaid narration of the facts, how the trial proceeded and culminated into the conviction and thereafter from the results of the appeals, it is clear that out of the six accused persons, one died and other four stood acquitted. It is only the appellant who is convicted for committing the offence under Section 302 IPC. It may also be mentioned at this stage itself that though PW 2 (he is brother of PW 1) also deposed to the effect that he was an eyewitness to the incident, the High Court disbelieved his testimony and discarded the same as unworthy of any credit. It means that he is not considered as an eyewitness to the incident. It may also be pertinent to mention at this stage itself that though the weapon of the crime i.e. long knife (MO 7) was allegedly recovered on the basis of disclosure statement made by the appellant, that discovery is also not believed by the courts below. The conviction against the appellant, thus, is recorded primarily on the basis of testimony of PW 1 who is believed to be the eyewitness of the incident and the courts have gone by the proposition that once his testimony is to be believed, this ocular evidence may be singular now, which is sufficient to convict the appellant.

    10. In view of the aforesaid circumstances, the endeavour of Mr R. Basanth, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant, was that no credence could have been given to the testimony of even PW 1 and there were various circumstances to show that he had deposed falsely and had implicated not only the appellant but his entire family out of vengeance or because of suspicion nurtured by him having regard to some previous animosity between the parties because of some civil disputes pending between the parties. In this behalf, he pointed out the following circumstances which according to him were sufficient to doubt the creditworthiness of PW 1:

    10.1. PW 1 claimed that he was the eyewitness to the incident and he had implicated not only the appellant but Accused 2 to 6 as well. His version qua Accused 2 to 6 has not been believed by the courts below holding that these accused were falsely implicated. Mr Basanth, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, submitted that under the given circumstances, the testimony of the particular witness can be partly believed but the aforesaid circumstances, coupled with other circumstances, would show that the intention of PW 1 was to falsely implicate not only the appellant but his other family members also.

    10.2. In taking this argument further, Mr Basanth pointed out that PW 2 who was the brother of PW 1 was introduced as eyewitness and this attempt of the prosecution stood exposed as the testimony of PW 2 could not stand after he was cross-examined and, therefore, even the courts disbelieved him.

    10.3. There was a clear motive to implicate the appellant because of previous civil disputes between the parties which was accepted by PW 1 himself in cross-examination.

    10.4. Another very significant circumstance which was pointed out by Mr Basanth was the evidence of the doctor (PW 7) who had conducted the post-mortem examination. The learned Senior Counsel pointed out that as per the prosecution, the appellant had struck the deceased with a long knife (MO 7) which according to PW 1 was in the hands of the appellant. In his statement, he very categorically stated that he had seen the said knife in the hands of the appellant with which he had stabbed the deceased. On the other hand, the doctor in his deposition had categorically opined that the stab and incised wounds shown in the post-mortem report cannot be caused by MO 7 long knife.

    10.5. It was pointed out that the aforesaid statement of PW 7 was recorded on 22-7-2005 and immediately after the aforesaid statement, further examination-in-chief of PW 7 was deferred at the request of the Public Prosecutor. He was, thereafter, recalled for further examination on 19-8-2005. However, even on that date, PW 7 categorically reiterated that the injuries mentioned in the post-mortem report cannot be caused by MO 7 long knife. The statement in this behalf along with opinion or other incidental aspect is as under:

    “It is true that MO 7 has got flat tip. It is true that the cutting edge of MO 7 is not sharp. It is true that the width of the weapon is 4 cm. The injuries mentioned in post-mortem report cannot be caused by MO 7. It is true that except Injuries 1, 4 and 12 other injuries are piercing injuries as it has no pointed tip, since it has got flat tip it cannot pierce the skin of the body. The injuries mentioned in the post-mortem report cannot be caused by MOs 9 and 10 (clubs). It is true that MOs 9 and 10 are heavy blunt objects.”

    10.6. The incident occurred, as per PW 1, after 8.30 p.m. PW 1 accepted that the police station is hardly at a distance of 100 ft which is a 2 minutes' walk. PW 1 further stated that immediately after the incident, he had gone to the house of the deceased where he informed PW 6 (wife of the deceased) about the incident and thereafter he went to the police station. However, the FIR was lodged only at 10 p.m. It was thus argued that there was sufficient time for PW 1 between the incident and the lodging of the report to cook up the story and during this period, he tried to rope in accused persons.

    10.7. It was also argued by Mr Basant that since the time of the incident was after 8.30 p.m., it was night/dark. According to him, there was no light and from distance, PW 1 could not have seen/identified the appellant. He submitted that though PW 1 tried to explain that he could see the accused persons as there was street light but, on the other hand, Junior Engineer (PW 5) who had prepared the sketch of the site and which is produced as Ext. P-6 does not show any lamp post in that area. From this, it is sought to be argued that PW 1 was not narrating the facts correctly.

    10.8. Another very significant aspect which needs to be noted, as pointed out by the learned Senior Counsel, was that when PW 1 rushed towards the house of the deceased and informed PW 6 about the incident, he stated that “somebody had killed the deceased”. He did not name the accused persons. This was admitted by PW 6 in her statement. Further PW 1 himself stated in his deposition that when he went to the police station, there was Head Constable and he had told the Head Constable that “somebody had killed the deceased” and did not name the accused persons. It is further stated that the Head Constable did not record his statement. Submission of Mr Basanth was that all the aforesaid circumstances were pressed into service only to demonstrate that the testimony of PW 1 was not believable.

    11. We find sufficient force and merit in these submissions of the learned Senior Counsel. As already pointed out above, the conviction is recorded on the basis of the testimony of PW 1. To recapitulate in brief the significant circumstances which are explained by Mr Basant, it is a case where the incident happened after 8.30 p.m. i.e. between 9.15 and 9.30 p.m. and there was dark in that area. The prosecution has not been able to establish that there was sufficient light in which PW 1 could see the persons who had attacked the deceased. It is possible that PW 1 reached the spot immediately after the incident but was not there at the time of incident or if he was at a distance, he could not see who were the persons who had attacked the deceased. This becomes clear from the fact that when he disclosed the information about the murder of deceased to the deceased's wife, he did not name anybody and on the contrary said that somebody had killed. This is what is repeated by PW 1 himself when he went to the police station and disclosed to the Head Constable present there about the incident. Thereafter in the complaint made to SHO (Ext. P-1), he mentioned the name of the appellant only. He improved upon the statement and in his subsequent statement, he implicated five more persons i.e. Accused 2 to 6.

    12. The prosecution story and, in particular, the testimony of PW 1, is totally untrustworthy when we examine the medical evidence that is the post-mortem report which is produced and the opinion of the doctor who conducted the said post-mortem examination thereupon. He has categorically stated that the wounds and injuries on the person of the deceased could not have been inflicted by knife (MO 7) whereas as per PW 1, the appellant was having MO 7 knife in his hands with which he attacked.

    13. In the chain of these loopholes, what becomes important is that though recovery of MO 7 is done at the disclosure statement allegedly made by the appellant, that has not been proved at all and, therefore, the prosecution did not rely thereupon.

    14. We, thus, find that the entire prosecution allegation is shrouded in mystery which does not inspire any confidence. Even PW 1 cannot be believed and it appears that either out of suspicion or out of vengeance PW 1 had implicated the appellant along with the other accused persons. It is, thus, a case where the alleged guilt of the appellant is not proved beyond reasonable doubt.

    15. Resultantly, we allow this appeal and set aside the conviction of the appellant. He shall be released forthwith unless he is wanted in some other case.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Narayana Reddy Alias Babu v. State Of Karnataka .
    (May 12, 2016)