Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts

    Krishnaji v. Mahadev Vinayak

    Ranade, J.:— There has been no decision of this Court on the point of law raised in this application, namely, whether section 310A applied to a sale in execution of a decree on a mortgage-bond, and which was governed by the Transfer of Property Act.

    This point, however, has been considered by the High Court of Allahabad, Madras and Bengal.

    The Allahabad High Court in Raja Ram Singhji v. Chunni Lal(1) remarked that, though, in the particular ease before them, they had no occasion to discuss the question of the applicability of section 310A to sales in execution of mortgage decrees, yet the matter was of sufficient importance to justify them in expressing an opinion for the guidance of the Subordinate Judges. The opinion thus exressed was to the effect that section 310A will apply to a sale held in virtue of an order absolute for sale passed under section 89 of the Transfer of Property Act, although no power is given under that Act to postpone the operation of an order under section 89. The provision's of the Civil Procedure Code, section 291 of the old Act X of 1877, as also section 310A were held to modify the concluding provisions of section 89 of the Transfer of Property Act.

    The Madras High Court took the same view first in Srinivasa Ayyangar v. Ayyathorai Pillai(2), and more expressly in Tirumal Rao v. Syed Dastaghiri Miyah(3), in which last case it was observed that this application of section 310A was in accordance with the policy which suggested the amendment of the Code.

    A Division Bench of the Calcutta High Court also in Ashruf Ali Chowdhry v. Net Lal Sahu(4) gave effect to the same view but this decision was dissented from by a Full Bench of that Court in Kedar Nath Ratu v. Kali Churn Ram(5). The chief ground on which the Full Bench decision was made to rest, appears to have been that the Calcutta High Court had made rules under section 104 of the Transfer of Property Act, subject to which rules alone could the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure be made to apply to sales under mortgage decrees. These rules have expressly made sections 304 to 319, Civil Procedure Code, to apply to sales of immovable property. The rules were made in 1892, while section 310A was incorporated in the code by act v of 1894. The High Court held that as section 310A was not included in the rules as they stand, that section could not apply to sales under mortgage decrees governed by the Transfer of Property Act. It is clear that this reasoning does not apply to the other provinces the High Courts of which have made no rules under section 104. This is the case in the Bombay Presidency, and as the Calcutta ruling has, therefore, no application outside the jurisdiction of the Bengal High Court, the Madras and Allahabad rulings seem to be more appropriate. It is true that Maclean, Chief Justice, also referred to more general considerations, such as that section 310A would, if incorporated in the rules made under section, 104, be inconsistent with the provisions of the Transfer of Property Act, and that it would lead to mischievous results. There can be no room for doubt, however, that if section 310A had been in existence before the Calcutta Rules were made in 1892, this section would have been included with the other sections 304 to 319 and sections 284 to 294. There is as more inconsistency of section 310a with the provisions of section 89 than there is of section 310 or 311, or better still section 291, which last gives great discretionary powers to the Coarts to stop or adjourn sales. As regards the alleged mischief, it is to be noted that the Madras and Allahabad High Courts appears satisfied that section 810A is in keeping with the general policy which has suggested this and other methods of relief modifying the rigidity of execution sales. The evil sought to be remedied was, (in the words of Dr. Rash Bahari Ghose, who introduced the Bill in the Supreme Counoil, which became law as act v of 1894), that lands sold in execution seldom realized a fair price, and the sales were hurtful both to honest crediors and debtors, and benefited nobody but the speculative purchasers. The power of redeeming the land even after its formal sale, but before confirmation, was, therefore, conferred on the judgment-debtor. The section was drafted on the lines of section 174 of Bengal Act VIII of 1835 which was passed in the interests of another unfortunate class, the poor tenure holders whose lands were liable to be sold for arrears of rent There is, therefore, nohing inconsistent or mischievous in the application of section 310A with a view to modify the rigours of the law of and sales in execution of mortgage decrees, any more than there is in the ease of ordinary money decrees. In the absence of any rules, the provisions of sections 304 to 319 of the Code of Civil procedure expressly apply to all sales of immoveable property. The mortgagors and persons claiming under them are the very persons who need most the relief intended to be conferred on judgment-debtors, and any other construction will defeat the main object of the legislation, which permits redemption even after sale in the case of those who are prepared to make full compensation to the creditor.

    Agreeing, therefore, with the rulings of the Madras and Allahabad High Courts, we are of opinion that the Court of first instance was right in the view it took of the applicability of section 310A to sales in execution of mortgage decrees. We, therefore, discharge the rule with costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Krishnaji v. Mahadev Vinayak
    (Jun 29, 1900)