AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1977 INSC 195
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 417(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898
  • Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970
  • Section 238 of the old Code
  • Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution
  • Section 417(1) of the old Code
  • Section 325 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 2(a) of the Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
1977 INSC 195
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 417(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898
  • Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970
  • Section 238 of the old Code
  • Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution
  • Section 417(1) of the old Code
  • Section 325 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code
  • Section 2(a) of the Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellants, Raghubir Singh and Kishore Singh, were tried in 1969 for the murder of one Jawahar under Sections 302/34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and for the attempted murder of Pooran Singh under Sections 307/34 IPC. The Sessions Judge acquitted them of murder but convicted them under Section 325/34 IPC and sentenced each to four years’ rigorous imprisonment (alongside a concurrent five-year sentence under Sections 307/34 IPC).

The State of Madhya Pradesh appealed under Section 417(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, challenging the acquittal on the murder charge. The High Court reversed the acquittal, convicted the appellants under Sections 302/34 IPC, and imposed sentences of life imprisonment. A certificate of fitness for appeal was issued under Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution, although the Supreme Court later held that the appellants already possessed an appeal as-of-right under Section 2(a) of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970, because the High Court had reversed an acquittal and imposed a life sentence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an appeal lay to the Supreme Court as of right under Section 2(a) of the 1970 Act when the High Court reversed an acquittal on a major charge (murder) but the accused had been convicted of a lesser offence by the trial court.
  2. Whether the High Court correctly converted the conviction from Section 325/34 IPC to Section 302/34 IPC—i.e., whether the ingredients of clause “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC (murder) were proved beyond reasonable doubt.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The conviction under Sections 302/34 IPC was untenable; the facts established, at most, an offence under Section 325/34 IPC.
  • The medical evidence was inconclusive on whether the injuries were “sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death,” a necessary element under clause “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Virsa Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1958 SC 465 (1958 SCR 1495) Test for clause “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC: once intention to inflict the particular injury is proved, the Court must objectively assess whether that injury is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death; adequacy of subsequent medical treatment is irrelevant. The Court applied this test to evaluate the medical and factual evidence, ultimately concluding that the prosecution failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the injuries were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Jurisdictional Issue: The Court interpreted Section 417(1) of the 1898 Code and Section 2(a) of the 1970 Act. It held that where an accused is acquitted of a major charge (here, murder) but convicted of a minor charge, the State may still appeal the acquittal. When the High Court reverses such an acquittal and imposes a life sentence (or not less than ten years), the accused acquires an automatic right of appeal to the Supreme Court; therefore, the High Court’s certificate under Article 134(1)(c) was unnecessary.

Merits of the Conviction:

  • The Court accepted that the appellants intentionally inflicted serious injuries with dangerous weapons, satisfying the first limb of clause “thirdly” (intention to cause the injury).
  • For the second limb—whether the injury was sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death—the Court scrutinised testimony from three doctors. Their opinions were described as “somewhat hesitant” and “discrepant,” particularly because the victim died nearly one month after the assault and following surgical intervention.
  • Applying the standard from Virsa Singh, the Court found reasonable doubt on whether the injuries were sufficient to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. However, the evidence demonstrated that the injuries were “likely to cause death,” satisfying Section 299 IPC.
  • Consequently, the conviction for murder (Section 302/34 IPC) could not stand; instead, the facts met the criteria of culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 (Part I) IPC.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed with modification. The appellants’ conviction is altered from Sections 302/34 IPC to Section 304 (Part I) read with Section 34 IPC, and each is sentenced to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment. The concurrent sentence under Sections 307/34 IPC remains.

Implications: The judgment clarifies that an accused acquitted of a major charge but convicted of a minor charge may still benefit from an automatic right of appeal under Section 2(a) of the 1970 Act if the High Court later convicts on the major charge and imposes a qualifying sentence. Substantively, the decision re-affirms the stringent requirements of clause “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC; ambiguous or divided medical evidence will tilt the balance in favour of a lesser conviction under Section 304 (Part I) IPC. No new precedent is set beyond these clarifications.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Kishore Singh And Another v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .

    P.K Goswami, J.— This appeal on certificate under Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution is from the judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The certificate was granted as the High Court thought that the appellants were entitled, as of right, to a grant of certificate in view of Section 2 of the Supreme Court (Enlargement of Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction) Act, 1970 (briefly the Act).

    2. The High Court is not right in holding that a certificate is necessary under Article 134(1)(c) of the Constitution if the appellants have a right of appeal under Section 2 of the Act. It will therefore be necessary to consider whether the appellants are entitled, as of right, to appeal to this Court under Section 2 of the Act.

    3. Section 2 of the Act reads as follows:

    “2. Without prejudice to the powers conferred on the Supreme Court by clause (1) of Article 134 of the Constitution, an appeal shall lie to the Supreme Court from any judgment, final order or sentence in a criminal proceeding of a High Court in the territory of India if the High Court—
    (a) has on appeal reversed an order of acquittal of an accused person and sentenced him to imprisonment for life or to imprisonment for a period of not less than ten years;
    (b) has withdrawn for trial before itself any case from any court subordinate to its authority and has in such trial convicted the accused person and sentenced him to imprisonment for life or to imprisonment for a period of not less than ten years.

    It is clear that if on appeal against an order of acquittal the High Court sets aside the acquittal and convicts an accused and sentences him to imprisonment for life or to a period of not less than ten years, the accused is entitled, as of right, to appeal to this Court under Section 2(a) of the Act.

    4. In this particular case the appellants were tried under Sections 302/34 IPC for the murder of Jawahar and under Sections 307/34 IPC for attempt to murder Pooran Singh. We are not concerned with the sentence of five years under Sections 307/34 IPC in this appeal which runs concurrently with the other sentence. The Sessions Judge acquitted them of the charge of murder of Jawahar but convicted them under Section 325, read with Section 34, IPC. Indeed the Sessions Judge clearly stated that—

    “Raghubir Singh and Kishore Singh are acquitted of the charge under Section 302, read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code but they are convicted under Section 325 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code for their acts of violence against Jawahar and are sentenced to 4 (four) years' rigorous imprisonment.”

    The judgment of the trial court was delivered on August 29, 1969. The State appealed to the High Court against the acquittal of the murder charge under Section 417(1) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898 (briefly the old Code) which governs this case.

    5. The short question that arises for consideration is as to whether the appeal before the High Court under Section 417(1) of the old Code was competent since the appellants were not entirely acquitted in the trial but convicted of a minor offence after having been charged for a major offence which is permissible under Section 238 of the old Code. Being still a conviction, albeit under a minor charge, will it be a case of acquittal for the purpose of Section 417(1) of the old Code and under Section 2(a) of the Act? That is the question. The same question will also arise under Section 2 (a) of the Act since the High Court set aside the acquittal and altered the conviction under Sections 325/34 IPC to one under Sections 302/34 IPC and sentenced them to imprisonment for life.

    6. Having given our anxious consideration to the language employed both in Section 417(1) of the old Code and Section 2(a) of the Act we are of opinion that when an accused is acquitted of a major charge but convicted under a minor charge, it is still an acquittal under the major charge which can be challenged by the State before the High Court in an appeal under Section 417(1) of the old Code. The same principle will apply in the case of Section 2(a) of the Act if a person had been acquitted by the trial court under a major charge and the High Court on appeal sets aside the acquittal under the major charge and sentences the person to imprisonment for life or to a sentence of not less than ten years. The accused will then be entitled, as of right, to appeal to this Court under Section 2(a) of the Act. In this view of the matter the certificate was unnecessary in this case and we will treat this appeal as one under Section 2(a) of the Act.

    7. Mr D. Mookherjee appearing on behalf of the appellants has addressed us only on the question of untenability of the conviction under Sections 302/34 IPC. According to Counsel this is a clear case under Sections 325/34 IPC and the trial court was right in holding accordingly.

    8. We may very briefly advert to the material facts necessary to appreciate this submission. Appellant Kishore Singh was armed with a “sabbal” and Raghubir Singh with an axe. We are not concerned with their father Bhaiyalal who was said to be in their company with a stick but has since been acquitted. On the date of occurrence which was on July 28, 1968, at 3.30 p.m, both the appellants attacked Jawahar and caused grievous injuries on his person using the “sabbal” and the blunt side of the axe. Jawahar died in the hospital on August 27, 1968, after recovering from a surgical operation for his head injuries. Dr D.N Malviya (PW 6) who first examined the deceased could not say whether the injuries were such as were likely to cause death in the ordinary course of nature. Dr P.K Jain (PW 12) performed the operation on Jawahar on July 30, 1968, on the third day of the occurrence. He found depressed fracture of the temporal bone. Four pieces of bone were removed during the operation as these were causing compression to the brain. He opined that the injuries to the skull were likely to cause death in the ordinary course of nature without any treatment. The deceased recovered from the operation but unfortunately died after a month of the occurrence on August 27, 1968, as stated earlier. Dr C.N Dafal (PW 13) who held the post-mortem examination was of opinion that death was due to injury to scalp and chest and its complications which were due to the same. He also opined that the injuries found on the dead body were sufficient in his opinion to cause death in the ordinary course of nature.

    9. Relying on the above medical evidence Mr Mookherjee submits that the charge under Section 302 IPC has not been made out against the appellants. According to Counsel the medical evidence is not definite as to whether the injuries caused by the appellants were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. In other words, he submits that the present case does not come under the clause “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC to warrant a charge of murder.

    10. We may, therefore, read that clause:

    “300. Except in the cases hereinafter excepted, culpable homicide is murder....
    ... Thirdly — if it (if the act by which the death is caused) is done, with the intention of causing bodily injury to any person and the bodily injury intended to be inflicted is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death.”

    11. The distinction between culpable homicide (Section 299, IPC) and murder (Section 300 IPC) has always to be carefully borne in mind while dealing with a charge under Section 302 IPC. Under the category of unlawful homicides fall both cases of culpable homicide amounting to murder and those not amounting to murder. Culpable homicide is not murder when the case is brought within the five exceptions to Section 300 IPC. But even though none of the said five exceptions are pleaded or prima facie established on the evidence on record, the prosecution must still be required under the law to bring the case under any of the four clauses of Section 300 IPC to sustain the charge of murder. If the prosecution fails to discharge this onus in establishing any one of the four clauses of Section 300 IPC, namely, firstly to fourthly, the charge of murder would not be made out and the case may be one of culpable homicide not amounting to murder as described under Section 299 IPC.

    12. On the facts and circumstances of the present case in order to sustain the charge under Section 302 IPC the prosecution has to establish the ingredients of the clause “thirdly” under Section 300 IPC.

    13. That both the appellants caused injuries on the vital parts of the body of the deceased with dangerous weapons has been fully established. It is absolutely clear on the evidence that both the appellants intended to cause the bodily injuries to the deceased. Thus the first part of “thirdly” is established.

    14. With regard to the second part of “thirdly”, namely, whether the bodily injury is sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, the Court's enquiry is not confined to the intention of the accused at that stage of judicial evaluation, once the intention of the accused to cause the injuries has already been established (see Virsa Singh v. State of Punjab AIR 1958 SC 465, 1958 SCR 1495, 1958 Cri LJ 818). The Court will have to judge objectively from the nature of the injuries and other evidence, including the medical opinion, as to whether the injuries intentionally inflicted by the appellants on the deceased were sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death. In judging whether the injuries inflicted are sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death, the possibility that skilful and efficient medical treatment might prevent the fatal result is wholly irrelevant.

    15. Having regard to the entire evidence and the circumstances of the case and in view of the somewhat hesitant medical opinion with regard to the cause of death given by the three doctors and the further fact that the deceased died a month after the occurrence, we think that clause “thirdly” of Section 300 IPC has not been established beyond reasonable doubt in this case. The evidence fulfils one of the ingredients of Section 299, namely, that the appellants caused the death by doing an act with the intention of causing such bodily injury as is likely to cause death as deposed to by the Surgeon (PW 12).

    16. The distinction between the expression “likely to cause death” and “sufficient in the ordinary course of nature to cause death” is significant, although rather fine, and sometimes deceptive. At any rate in view of the somewhat discrepant medical opinion the appellants are entitled to the benefit and we hold that it is a fit case where the conviction of the appellants should be under Section 304 (Part 1) IPC. Both the appellants are, therefore, convicted under Section 304 (Part 1) read with Section 34, IPC and sentenced to ten years' rigorous imprisonment. The sentence of the appellants under Sections 307/34, IPC will rule concurrently with this sentence. The appeal is dismissed with the above modification of the conviction and sentence.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kishore Singh And Another v. State Of Madhya Pradesh .
    (Oct 10, 1977)