Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order VII, Rules 10 and 10-A read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Courts Act, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Order VII, Rules 10 and 10-A read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Courts Act, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • ARTICLE 227 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This revision under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges the entertainment of suit O.S No. 186 of 1998 by the Family Court, Hyderabad. The petitioner contends that the Family Court lacked jurisdiction as the Family Courts Act, 1984 does not apply to the suit. The suit was filed by sisters against brothers and others claiming partition of property left by their father. The petitioner filed a petition under Order VII, Rules 10 and 10-A read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure to return the plaint for presentation in the proper court, which was dismissed by the Family Court on 6-5-1999.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Family Court has jurisdiction to entertain a suit for partition of property between siblings under the Family Courts Act, 1984.
  2. Whether the Family Courts Act, 1984 applies only to disputes arising between parties to a marriage and related family members.
  3. The correctness of the interpretation of the Family Courts Act in relation to the scope of "family" and the nature of disputes the Family Court can entertain.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The suit filed by the sisters against brothers is a property dispute and not a marriage-related dispute.
  • The Family Courts Act, 1984 has no application to this suit, and therefore the Family Court had no jurisdiction.
  • The petition to return the plaint to the proper court under Order VII, Rules 10 and 10-A read with Section 151 CPC was rightly filed but dismissed incorrectly.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Although the suit is not a marriage dispute, it involves family members and property, and the Act is for the benefit of ladies, so the suit is maintainable in the Family Court.
  • The term "family" is not defined in the Act, so it should be interpreted in common parlance to include siblings.
  • The Act is beneficent and should be liberally construed to include all family disputes, not just between husband and wife.
  • Cited the judgment in Smt. Izzat Sultana & Ors. v. Sabir Bin Yasrab, 1995 (3) ALT 430, where the Family Court entertained a suit involving family arrangement disputes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Smt. Izzat Sultana & Ors. v. Sabir Bin Yasrab, 1995 (3) ALT 430 : 1996 AIHC 133 Suit involving family arrangement and property dispute entertained by Family Court. The Court disagreed with this judgment, holding it did not lay down correct law as it involved parties other than husband and wife.
Mrs. Mariamma Ninan v. Mr. K.K Ninan, 1997 (2) ALT 268 Family Court jurisdiction under Section 7 of the Family Courts Act for disputes between husband and wife regarding property. The Court followed this Division Bench decision, holding it applicable and correctly limiting Family Court jurisdiction to disputes between spouses.
R. Durga Prasad v. Union of India, 1998 (1) ALT 652 : AIR 1998 AP 290 Constitutional validity of Family Courts Act provisions relating to jurisdiction over suits between parties to a marriage. Reinforced that Family Court jurisdiction applies only to parties to a marriage and related disputes; disputes about marital status must be resolved in common law courts first.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the Family Courts Act, 1984, particularly Section 7, which defines the jurisdiction of Family Courts. The Court noted that the Act's jurisdiction is limited to disputes arising between parties to a marriage and related matters such as maintenance, custody, and property between spouses. The Court emphasized that the Act is exclusionary and must be interpreted strictly according to its plain language and the Explanation under Section 7.

The Court rejected the respondents' argument that the term "family" should be liberally construed to include siblings. It held that the Act does not extend jurisdiction to disputes between brothers and sisters concerning property. The Court found that the Family Court had no jurisdiction in the present case, which involved a property partition dispute between siblings, not spouses.

The Court overruled the earlier judgment in Smt. Izzat Sultana's case, which had taken a broader view of Family Court jurisdiction, and followed the Division Bench decision in Mrs. Mariamma Ninan's case, which correctly limited Family Court jurisdiction to disputes between spouses.

Holding and Implications

The Civil Revision Petition is allowed.

The Court held that the Family Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain the suit for partition filed by sisters against brothers. Consequently, the plaint is to be returned to the respondents for presentation before the appropriate Civil Court vested with territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction. This decision clarifies that the Family Courts Act, 1984 applies strictly to disputes between parties to a marriage and does not extend to property disputes among siblings or other family members. No new precedent was set beyond affirming the existing interpretation limiting Family Court jurisdiction.

    P. Srihari v. Kum. P. Sukunda And Another

    B. Subhashan Reddy, J.:— This revision under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is directed against the entertainment of suit in O.S No. 186 of 1998 on the file of the Family Court, Hyderabad, on the premise that the said Court had no jurisdiction to try the suit and has been wrongly entertained, as the Family Courts Act, 1984 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) has got no application.

    2. Mr. Y. Vasudeva Rao, the learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the said suit has been filed by the sisters against the brothers and others claiming partition of the property left behind by their father. A petition has been filed under Order VII, Rules 10 and 10-A read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure by the petitioner herein in the Family Court to return the plaint for presentation in the proper Court, but the same has been dismissed by order dated 6-5-1999 by the Judge, Family Court, Hyderabad in I.A No. 434 of 1999 in O.S No. 186 of 1998.

    3. Ms. Anitha Ahuja, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents, admits that it is not a marriage dispute. But, she submits that as there is a dispute between the sister and brother regarding property, suit was filed for partition and since the plaintiffs are ladies and as the Act has been enacted for the benefit of the ladies, the suit is maintainable before the Family Court. She submits that since the word ‘family’ is not defined under the Act, the meaning in common parlance has to be taken and if so taken, the suit is maintainable. She also submits that because the Act is beneficient in nature, every dispute arising in the family, and not necessarily between the wife and husband, has to be entertained and interpretation has to be liberal in that direction. She has cited a judgment rendered by Smt. Izzat Sultana & Ors.… v. Sabir Bin Yasrab…., 1995 (3) ALT 430 : 1996 AIHC 133. No doubt, in the said case, the orders directing presentation of the plaint in the Family Court was questioned and the same was not found favour with the learned single Judge, who directed the Civil Court to number the suit and dispose of the same on merits. In the said case, the suit was filed by the wife and children against husband for injunction on the basis of the family arrangement made earlier. For the reasons mentioned infra, we do not agree with the said judgment. In fact, the decision of another Division Bench of this Court in Mrs. Mariamma Ninan v. Mr. K.K Ninan, 1997 (2) ALT 268 arising under the Act and concerning the same provision i.e Section 7 of the Act is squarely applicable to the facts of this case. In the said case, a dispute arose between wife and separate possession on the ground that her Stridhana money was used for construction of the house which was kept in the name of the husband. When the plaint was presented in the Family Court, the same was returned to be presented to the Civil Court aggrieved by which, a CRP was filed in this Court. A Division Bench of this Court in the case mentioned supra set aside the order of the Family Court holding that as the dispute was inter se husband, and wife and related to property comes within the ambit of clause (c) of Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act and that only Family Court had jurisdiction and not the Civil Court. In R. Durga Prasad v. Union of India, 1998 (1) ALT 652 : AIR 1998 AP 290, the question for consideration was the constitutional validity of clauses (a) and (b) of Explanation to Section 7(1) of the Act relating to the jurisdiction of the Family Court for trying the suits between the parties to a marriage. The proposition propounded was that the above statutory provisions are applicable only for admitted marriages and when there is a dispute with regard to their marital status, the suit is not maintainable by the Family Court and that a common law Court has to be approached firstly seeking a declaration with regard to marital status and then for consequential reliefs.

    4. The object and intendment of the Page: 171Family Courts Act is to try the family matters arising out of marriages of the parties including the maintenance and adoption of the children as also the dispute relating to property and that is so clear from the preamble of the Act itself. Even if the preamble cannot be taken to be an absolute guidance for considering the provisions of the Act, reading Section 7, as a whole, cannot leave any manner of doubt whatsoever that essentially the parties to be husband and wife and may also include children. But, if one of the spouses is absent in the litigation, then it can never be considered as a cause falling within the realm of the Family Court. The Act being exclusionary in nature and has been enacted for the purpose of resolution of disputes of a particular nature and enumerated in the Explanation, it is not for this Court to enlarge the same because of the plain language employed therein. It is a salutary principle of interpretation of statutes that when the language of the statute is plain and unambiguous and in fact made clear by the explanation, it is not for the Court to import anything not stated therein. It is apt to extract whole of Section 7 to understand such plain and unambiguous meaning of the statute:

    “7. Jurisdiction:— (1) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, a Family Court shall—

    (a) have and exercise all the jurisdiction exercisable by any District Court or any subordinate Civil Court under any law for the time being in force in respect of suits and proceedings of the nature referred to in the Explanation; and

    (b) be deemed for the purpose of exercising such jurisdiction under such law, to be a District Court or, as the case may be, such subordinate Civil Court for the area to which jurisdiction of the Family Court extends.

    Explanation: The suits and proceedings referred to in this sub-section are suits and proceedings of the following nature, namely:—

    (a) a suit or proceedings between the parties to a marriage for a decree of nullity of marriage (declaring the marriage to be null and void or, as the case may be annulling the marriage) or restitution of conjugal rights or judicial separation or dissolution of marriage;

    (b) a suit or proceeding for a declaration as to the validity of marriage or as to the matrimonial status of any person;

    (c) a suit or proceeding between the parties to a marriage with respect to the property of the parties or of either of them;

    (d) a suit or proceedings for an order or injunction in circumstances arising out of a marital relationship;

    (e) a suit or proceeding for a declaration as to the legitimacy of any person;

    (f) a suit or proceeding for maintenance;

    (g) a suit or proceeding in relation to the guardianship of the person or the custody of, or access to, any minor.

    (2) Subject to the other provisions of this Act, a Family Court shall also have and exercise—

    (a) the jurisdiction exercisable by a Magistrate of the First Class under Chapter IX (relating to order for maintenance of wife, children and parents) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974); and

    (b) such other jurisdiction as may be conferred on it by any other enactment.”

    5. In view of the above, the essential ingredient should be a dispute between the husband and the wife and the said dispute can be with regard to their marital status, divorce, restitution of conjugal rights, judicial separation, child custody, maintenance, as also property sharing. But, in no event, the Family Court can have jurisdiction if the above dispute is absent. By no stretch of imagination, can the Family Court assume jurisdiction, if there is a dispute between the brothers, sisters, mothers, fathers etc. concerning property and the case on hand being one such, the Family Court had clearly no jurisdiction.

    6. For the reasons mentioned above, the judgment rendered by the learned single Judge in Smt. Izzat Sultana's case (1 supra) cannot be said to have laid down correct law. Hence, it is overruled and the view taken by the Division Bench in Mrs. Mariamma's case (2 supra) is followed. Consequently, the Civil Revision Petition is allowed. The plaint be returned to the respondents herein for presentation before the Court of the I Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad, which Court is vested with both territorial and pecuniary jurisdiction.

    Revision allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    P. Srihari v. Kum. P. Sukunda And Another
    (Jan 24, 2001)