AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 543
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 12 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 15 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • Section 15 of the Act (referring to Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948)
  • Article 14 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 79(c) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • Section 12 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • Article 309, Proviso to Article 309
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2007 INSC 543
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Article 12 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 15 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • Section 15 of the Act (referring to Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948)
  • Article 14 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 79(c) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • Section 12 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • Article 309, Proviso to Article 309
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant joined the Punjab State Electricity Board (PSEB) as a Lineman on 8 August 1964 and was promoted to Junior Engineer on 15 March 1974. He does not hold a diploma in Electrical Engineering. The Board’s pay scales and promotional avenues differ for diploma-holders and non-diploma holders. Earlier, one Ravinder Kumar (a junior non-diploma holder) successfully challenged this distinction, and the Supreme Court in Punjab SEB v. Ravinder Kumar Sharma (1986) upheld his claim.

Relying on that decision, the present appellant sued for parity in pay/promotion. The trial court accepted his claim, but the Additional District Judge (ADJ) set aside that decree on 24 April 2003, referring to the later three-Judge Bench ruling in P. Murugesan v. State of T.N. (1993) which had overruled Ravinder Kumar. The High Court of Punjab and Haryana, by judgment dated 31 March 2006 in RSA No. 4871 of 2003, affirmed the ADJ. The appellant sought relief in the Supreme Court, leading to the present decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Punjab State Electricity Board’s policy of granting higher pay scales and promotional preference to diploma-holder Linemen/Junior Engineers violates Article 14 of the Constitution when applied to non-diploma holders like the appellant.
  2. Whether the appellant can claim parity solely because his junior, Ravinder Kumar, had earlier obtained such relief under a judgment that has since been overruled by a larger Bench.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Because Ravinder Kumar (a junior non-diploma holder) received higher pay after litigating, denial of the same benefit to the appellant constitutes discrimination prohibited by Article 14.

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent’s legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19 Classification based on educational qualification for promotion is constitutionally permissible. Serves as the foundational authority supporting differential treatment between diploma-holders and non-diploma holders.
Punjab SEB v. Ravinder Kumar Sharma (1986) 4 SCC 617 Had held that quota-based discrimination between diploma and non-diploma Linemen was impermissible. Expressly noted but treated as no longer good law because it was overruled by later authority.
P. Murugesan v. State of T.N. (1993) 2 SCC 340 Overruled Ravinder Kumar; reaffirmed that educational qualifications can validly differentiate employees for promotion. Relied on as binding three-Judge Bench precedent to dismiss the appellant’s claim.
Meghalaya SEB v. Jagadindra Arjun (2001) 6 SCC 446 A statutory Board may issue executive orders regarding service conditions when no regulations exist. Cited to uphold the Board’s competence to issue the impugned circular.
State of Punjab v. Kuldip Singh (2002) 5 SCC 756 Differential pay scales based on educational qualification are not per se discriminatory. Reinforces the conclusion that the Board’s scales are constitutionally valid.
Government of W.B. v. Tarun K. Roy (2004) 1 SCC 347 Employees with distinct educational qualifications cannot demand pay parity. Used to negate the appellant’s Article 14 claim.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court emphasized that while the appellant and Ravinder Kumar were similarly placed as non-diploma holders, the legal basis on which Ravinder Kumar succeeded—Ravinder Kumar Sharma (1986)—has since been overruled by a larger Bench in P. Murugesan (1993). Under the doctrine of precedent, the later and larger Bench decision prevails.

The Court further noted:

  • The Board possesses statutory authority under Section 79(c) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 to frame regulations and, in their absence, to issue executive orders governing service conditions (Meghalaya SEB).
  • The impugned circular equalised pay only at the induction post; higher posts could legitimately carry different scales based on qualifications.
  • Consistent with Triloki Nath Khosa and subsequent cases, educational qualification is a valid ground for classification. Hence, Article 14 is not violated.
  • The fact that a junior employee earlier obtained relief under an overruled judgment does not create a vested right for others; equality cannot be claimed on the basis of an illegality or a decision no longer good law.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

Consequently, the appellant is not entitled to the higher pay scale accorded to diploma-holders. The judgment reaffirms existing precedent permitting differential treatment based on educational qualifications and does not establish any new legal principle beyond reiterating that an overruled decision cannot ground an Article 14 claim.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Sohan Singh Sodhi v. Punjab State Electricity Board, Patiala .

    S.B Sinha, J.— Leave granted.

    2. This appeal is directed against the judgment and order dated 31-3-2006 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in RSA No. 4871 of 2003 dismissing an appeal arising from a judgment and order dated 24-4-2003 of the learned ADJ, Patiala setting aside the judgment and order of the trial Judge dated 7-2-2001.

    3. The basic facts of the case are not in dispute. The appellant was appointed as a lineman on 8-8-1964. He was promoted to the post of Junior Engineer on 15-3-1974. He was not a diploma-holder. The respondent Board which is constituted in terms of Section 15 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 and incorporated under Section 12 thereof provided for scale of pay on the basis of the qualifications held by the incumbents. One Ravinder Kumar who was a non-diploma holder filed a suit questioning the purported discrimination in promotion of lineman to Line Superintendent between diploma-holder linemen vis-à-vis non-diploma holder linemen.

    4. The matter came up before this Court in Civil Appeals Nos. 3341 and 3342 of 1983, Punjab SEB v. Ravinder Kumar Sharma (1986) 4 SCC 617, AIR 1987 SC 367 wherein this Court held:

    “8. The only issue raised in this appeal is whether Defendant 1, that is, the Punjab State Electricity Board, is competent to discriminate between diploma-holder and non-diploma holder linemen forming the common cadre of linemen having a common seniority list in promoting these linemen on the basis of quota fixed by the order of the State Electricity Board even though the requisite qualification for promotion for lineman to the post of Line Superintendent is either the holding of diploma or certificate for Electrical Engineering from a recognised institute or the non-diploma holders having passed one-and-a-half year's course in the trade of electrician/lineman/wireman from recognised Industrial Training Institute and are matriculates and have worked for four years as lineman continuously and immediately before promotion, as has been provided by Office Order No. 97.ENG/BET/G-33 dated 22-10-1968….”

    5. The only issue which was raised before this Court was as to whether, the Punjab State Electricity Board could make any discrimination for the purpose of promotion between diploma-holders and non-diploma holders on the basis of quota fixed by the order of the State Electricity Board even though the requisite qualification for promotion from lineman to the Line Superintendent is either the holding of the diploma or certificate of Electrical Engineering from a recognised institute or having passed 1½-year course in electrical trades of electrician/lineman/wireman.

    6. The claim of Ravinder Kumar was based on a circular letter issued by the respondent Board which was considered by this Court in the said decision in the following terms: (Ravinder Kumar Sharma case (1986) 4 SCC 617, AIR 1987 SC 367)

    “11. This observation applies with full force to the present case, and it has been rightly held by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana that the promotion of Defendants 3 to 7 who are junior to the plaintiff-respondent from lineman to the post of Line Superintendent is wholly bad and discriminatory and directed that the petitioner be deemed to have been promoted to the post of Line Superintendent from the date the said Defendants 3 to 7 had been promoted from lineman to Line Superintendent. In our considered opinion there is no infirmity in the judgment of the High Court affirming the judgment and decree of the courts below and we agree with the reasonings and conclusions arrived at by the courts below. The two appeals on special leave are, therefore, dismissed with costs, quantified at Rs 5000 to be paid by the appellant of CA No. 3341 of 1983 to Respondent 1.”

    7. We may, however, notice that the matter came up before a three-Judge Bench of this Court in P. Murugesan v. State of T.N (1993) 2 SCC 340, (1993) 24 ATC 149 wherein Ravinder Kumar (1986) 4 SCC 617, AIR 1987 SC 367 was specially overruled relying inter alia on a decision of a Constitution Bench of this Court in State of J&K v. Triloki Nath Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19. It was categorically held therein: (P. Murugesan case (1993) 2 SCC 340, (1993) 24 ATC 149)

    “19. The learned counsel for the respondents relied upon the decision in Punjab SEB v. Ravinder Kumar Sharma (1986) 4 SCC 617, AIR 1987 SC 367, a decision rendered by a Bench comprising A.P Sen and B.C Ray, JJ. The category of linemen in the service of the Punjab State Electricity Board comprised both diploma-holders and others who may be referred to as non-diploma holders. They constituted one single category having a common seniority list. By means of the rules issued under the proviso to Article 309, a quota was prescribed for diploma-holders, the result of which was that diploma-holders who were far junior to the non-diploma holders were promoted ignoring the non-diploma holders. The rule was held to be bad by the learned Subordinate Judge, Patiala. On appeal, the Additional District Judge, Patiala affirmed the judgment. It was affirmed by the High Court as well. The matter was brought to this Court. This Court affirmed the judgment of the High Court. A perusal of the judgment shows that the attention of the Bench was not drawn either to T.N Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19 or to other decisions. Reference was made only to the observations in Mohd. Shujat Ali v. Union of India (1975) 3 SCC 76 quoted hereinbefore and it was held that the distinction made between the diploma-holders and non-diploma holders was discriminatory and bad. Apart from the distinction on facts between that case and the case before us, it is evident that non-consideration of T.N Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19 and other decisions relevant under the subject has led to the laying down of a proposition which seems to run counter to T.N Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19. With great respect to the learned Judges who decided that case, we are unable to accept the broad proposition flowing from the case.”

    8. The learned trial Judge relied on the decision of Ravinder Kumar (1986) 4 SCC 617, AIR 1987 SC 367 in holding that as both the plaintiff-appellant and Ravinder Kumar are non-diploma holders and belong to the same cadre, the appellant could not have been discriminated against. The first appellate court, however, relied on the decision of the three-Judge Bench of this Court in P. Murugesan (1993) 2 SCC 340, (1993) 24 ATC 149.

    9. Mr Gurnam Singh, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant would inter alia contend that as the said Ravinder Kumar Sharma is junior to the appellant, the action on the part of the respondent, which is a State within the meaning of Article 12 of the Constitution of India, not to grant the same scale of pay is violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.

    10. The power of the State Electricity Board to issue circulars in exercise of its powers under Section 79(c) of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 is not in dispute. It has the power to frame regulations. If it can frame regulations, in absence of any regulations, issuance of executive orders is permissible in law. The power of framing regulations prescribing conditions of service of its employees appointed by the Board in terms of Section 15 of the Act cannot be disputed. Thus, in absence of any rules or regulations governing the service conditions of its employees, issuance of administrative order is permissible in law vide Meghalaya SEB v. Jagadindra Arjun (2001) 6 SCC 446.

    11. The circular issued by the Board provided for parity in the scale of pay in the induction post and not on a higher post. The said circular, therefore, has no application in this case. The jurisdiction of the Board to lay down different scales of pay for the employees on the basis of educational qualification per se is not discrimination. (See Triloki Nath Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19, see also State of Punjab v. Kuldip Singh (2002) 5 SCC 756.)

    12. In P. Murugesan (1993) 2 SCC 340, (1993) 24 ATC 149 it was clearly held:

    “Looked at from this broad angle, it may appear there is some force in what the respondents contend viz. that once the graduate engineers and diploma-holder engineers constitute one class, perform same duties and discharge same responsibilities, placing a restriction on the diploma-holders alone (limiting their chances of promotion to one out of four promotions, as has been done by the impugned amendment) is not justified but this may be a too simplistic way of looking at the issue. We cannot fail to take note of the fact that right from 1974 i.e since the decision of the Constitution Bench in Triloki Nath Khosa (1974) 1 SCC 19 this Court has been holding uniformly that even where direct recruits and promotees are integrated into a common class, they could for purposes of promotion to the higher cadre be classified on the basis of educational qualifications.”
    (emphasis in original)

    13. No doubt Ravinder Kumar was junior to the appellant but his case has become final due to the decision in Ravinder Kumar (1986) 4 SCC 617, AIR 1987 SC 367. However, that decision has been overruled by a larger Bench of this Court, and hence the appellant before us can get no benefit from the fact that his junior has been promoted. Article 14 will have no application in such a case.

    14. In Govt. of W.B v. Tarun K. Roy (2004) 1 SCC 347, a three-Judge Bench of this Court, noticing several other decisions opined that parity in the pay cannot be claimed when the educational qualification is different.

    15. There is no merit in this appeal, which is dismissed accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sohan Singh Sodhi v. Punjab State Electricity Board, Patiala .
    (May 9, 2007)