Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns the legal examination of identification parades and related evidentiary issues arising from criminal charges under Sections 148, 302, 302/149, 302/120-B, 201, and 216 of the Indian Penal Code. The procedural history references various dates of incident and investigation, including October 13, 2006, and subsequent proceedings up to 2014 and beyond. The opinion discusses the conduct and scrutiny of test identification parades held under magistrate supervision during the investigation phase, with detailed reference to timelines and evidentiary records from the case. The opinion also addresses related evidentiary matters such as the admissibility of statements under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act and the evaluation of witness identification testimony.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. What is the evidentiary value and proper judicial approach to test identification parades conducted during the investigation stage?
  2. How should courts evaluate the reliability of identification evidence, especially in relation to delays, prior exposure of witnesses to the accused, and procedural safeguards during identification parades?
  3. What are the principles governing the admissibility of statements and recoveries made under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, particularly when the place of recovery is accessible to others?
  4. What is the appropriate judicial attitude towards the memory and observational capacity of witnesses in identification cases?

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Budhsen Vs. State of U.P (1970) 2 SCC 128 Identification evidence is inherently weak; prior test identification strengthens trustworthiness; identification parades are investigative tools governed by Section 162 Cr.P.C. The court emphasized the need for corroboration of identification evidence and the role of magistrates in supervising identification parades to ensure fairness and reduce testimonial errors.
Chandra Prakash Vs. State of Rajasthan (2014 Cr.L.J.2884) Delay in conducting identification parade is not per se fatal; identification parades provide corroborative evidence. The court held that delay alone does not invalidate identification parades if properly explained and justified.
Mulla & Anr. Vs. State of U.P (2010 Cr.L.J 1440) Identification parades are primarily investigative, not substantive evidence; their purpose is to test witness memory and assist investigation. The court reiterated that identification parades corroborate in-court testimony and should be conducted promptly after arrest.
Shyamal Ghosh Vs. State of West Bengal (2012 Cr.L.J.3825) Identification parades test witness memory and veracity; identification evidence is relevant but not conclusive; witnesses are presumed truthful unless disproved. The court recognized the importance of identification parades as investigative tools and cautioned against undue skepticism of such evidence.
Ocha Vs. The State (1955 RLW 450) No fixed rule for accepting or rejecting identification evidence; courts should assess witness credibility based on case circumstances. The court noted the discretionary role of trial courts in valuing identification testimony.
State of U.P. Vs. Boota Singh (AIR 1978 SC 1770) Identification evidence is not universally weak; properly conducted parades and court identifications can be reliable. The court accepted identification evidence when procedures were properly followed and witnesses had sufficient opportunity to observe the accused.
State of Rajasthan Vs. Ranjita Ladhuram (AIR 1962 (Raj.) 78) Precautions are necessary to prevent witnesses from seeing accused prior to identification parade; prior exposure vitiates identification. The court held that identification loses value if witnesses had prior opportunity to see the accused; however, failure to explicitly state non-exposure in testimony does not automatically discredit evidence.
Prabhati & Ors. Vs. State (AIR 1966 (Raj.) 241) Human memory varies; delay in identification evidence appraisal requires prudence, avoiding rigid rules. The court advised a pragmatic, case-specific approach to evaluating identification evidence considering human variability in observation and memory.
Satrughana alias Satrughana Parida & Anr. Vs. State of Orissa (1991 Cr.L.J.846) Identification involving multiple suspects simultaneously is not inherently unreliable. The court rejected the notion that identification parades must only include one suspect with several innocents.
Sajeevan Vs. Kerala State (1994 Cr.L.J. 1316) Publication of accused's photos by press does not necessarily invalidate identification evidence; court may assess influence on witnesses. The court recognized journalistic freedom and held that prior exposure through media does not automatically discredit witness identification.
Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act Statements made by accused leading to discovery are admissible even if recovery is from places accessible to others, provided the place was not ordinarily visible. The court clarified that accessibility does not negate admissibility; focus is on visibility and concealment of the recovered object.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a detailed examination of the principles governing test identification parades, emphasizing their investigative nature and limited evidentiary status. It reiterated that identification evidence must be corroborated and carefully scrutinized, considering the conditions under which witnesses made their observations. The court highlighted the magistrate's duty to ensure fairness and prevent prejudice during identification proceedings, including recording objections and procedural safeguards.

The opinion reviewed authoritative precedents underscoring that delays in conducting identification parades are not automatically fatal if justified, and that prior exposure of witnesses to the accused before the parade undermines the reliability of identification unless disproved by evidence. It recognized the variability in human memory and observation, recommending a pragmatic and case-specific approach rather than rigid rules.

Regarding statements under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, the court clarified that the admissibility of recovered articles depends on whether the place of recovery was ordinarily visible, not merely accessible to others. Concealment in places accessible but not visible to the public does not invalidate such evidence.

The court also addressed the impact of media publication of accused persons' photographs, holding that such exposure does not per se discredit witness identification, leaving room for judicial discretion based on overall circumstances.

Holding and Implications

The court upheld the evidentiary principles relating to identification parades and statements under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act as established by precedent, emphasizing the need for judicial prudence and procedural fairness.

The direct effect of this decision is to affirm the investigative and corroborative role of test identification parades, the admissibility of statements leading to discovery even from places accessible to others, and the necessity of a case-by-case evaluation of identification evidence. No new precedent was set; rather, the opinion consolidates existing legal standards and guides courts on their application to the facts of the case.

    Brij Mohan And Ors v. State Of Rajasthan Through P P

    1 , , 856/2014 374 16.07.2014 , , ( ), (.) . 83/2013

    29 , 2016 , 2 , 1, 3 9 :-( . . )

    374 , 83/2013 16.07.2014 - , 148, 302, 302 149, 302 120- 3/25 4/25, - 148, 302, 302 149, 302 120-, -201 4/25, -

    2 148, 302, 302 149, 302 120- 201 3/25 4/25, 148, 302, 302 149, 302 120-, - 302, 302 120-, 216 201, - 302, 302 120- - 148, 302, 302 149, 302 120- 4/25 (. 1) 13.10.2006 : 9.40 .. , (. 20) -1 : 8.15 15 5-6 -

    3 12 , , , ... . , 13.10.2006 : 10.30 302, 147, 148 149 698/2006 14.10.2006 1.25 13.10.2006 4 13.10.2006 : 8.15 (. 23) , , 10.16 . , 5 (. 1) (. 7) (. 2) (. 2) (. 1) (. 7) 6 , 13.10.2006 - , 13.10.2006 : 8.15 - , (. 23) 7 , , , :- (1) (. 1) -1 , (2) (. 1) - 8 (3) (. 7) (. 1) , , (4) 9 (5) , , 10 , -, (6) (. 2) (. 1) (7) - 27 11 (8) -8 -9 , - , (9) - - ... , 12 , , , (10) , - (11)

    149 120- 13 (12) , , (13) (. 18) 14 (14) 5-6 - 5-6 (15) , (. 1) (16) , , 15 (17) (18) , . 23 (19) -66 23.10.2006 12.40 23.10.2006 2

    2 "2" 12.40 2 (20) -127 16 , , (. 5), , , , 17 (. 1), -1 13.10.2006 : 9.40 .. , - (. 20) -1 , , 18 (. 1) 10-15 5-6 10-15 , , (. 1) 1. 23.10.2006 8.50 , 1091 19 -11 13.10.2006 : 8.50 (. 1) , -11 -11 -11 20

    2. -1 : 9.40 (. 1) , 16 -1 , 10-10.30 12- 12.30 11.30 12.00 -1 9.30 9.40 - 1 21 3. , 12 , -1 12 12 -1 12 12 (. 1) 12 (. 20) : 8.30 22 12 -1 4. -1 -1 4-5 5.

    6. - 9 , 23 (. 1) (. 7) 1. 2. 7.00 - 8.00 24 (. 2) 3. 4. 13.10.2006 ,

    161 - 6 13.10.2006 : 5. 25 - , 6. 2006 - - 7. 26 -6 13.10.2006 , 14.10.2006 13.10.2006 14.10.2006 , 13.10.2006 14.10.2006 , , 27 (. 7) 01.08.2009 13.10.2006 : 8.15 5-6 28 -3, -22, 23 -24 7-8 29 -6 13.10.2006 30 2006 , : , 31 -6 13.10.2006 14.10.2006 14.10.2006 13.10.2006 14.10.2006 13.10.2006 32 14.10.2006 5-6 2-3 5-6 , 33 - 12 15.10.2006 6.40 . (. . 3) -78 15.10.2006 1.45 (. 20) 15.10.2006 ( 1) (. 2) 34 -: (. 7) 35 26.10.2006 , , , 22.11.2006 19.02.2008 18.10.2006 8.10 , 15.10.2006 1.45 , 20.11.2006 3.50 , 18.10.2006 8.30 , 15.10.2006 10.30 , 07.02.2008 12.40 36 13.12.2007 6.20

    1. 161 , , 2. 37 3. 4.

    5. , , , 6. 1981 () -28 38 -3, -22, -23 -24 , , 25-30 , 39 12-13 5-6 40 (. 11) , -4 () 21.11.2006 - , 698/2006 , 21.11.2006 22.11.2006 -3 -31, -34, -35, -36 -37 11.02.2008 19.02.2008 -48 11.02.2008 41 19.02.2008 : -38, -41 - 46, -47, - 49 50 -36 - 49 - 49 42 -49 -36 (. 29) , -3 () 698/2006 , , 26.10.2006 , : 11.15 , - 22 , - 23 -168 18.10.2006, - 171, 172, 173 -174, -175 -176 -22 43 , 10 , , , -3 - 22.11.2006 (. 7) -22 26.10.2006 44 (. 7) 10 -23 (. 7) 10 -24 19.02.2008 (. 7) 10 , -

    83 - 18.10.2006 8.10 - , 45 - , 13.12.2007 -92 15.12.2007, -27, 16.12.2007 -93 16.12.2007 -25 (. 14) (. 20) (. 21) (. 7) -, 46 47 10 10 48 49 , , In the case of Budhsen Vs. State of U.P. reported in (1970) 2 SCC 128, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that: 50 Now, facts which establish the identity of an accused person are relevant under S.9 of the Indian Evidence Act. As a general rule, the substantive evidence of a witness is a statement made in court. The evidence of mere identification of the accused person at the trial for the first time is from its very nature inherently of a weak character. The evidence in order to carry conviction should ordinarily clarify as to how and under what circumstances he came to pick out the particular accused person and the details of the part which the accused played in the crime in question with reasonable particularity. The purpose of a prior test identification, therefore, seems to be to test and strengthen the trustworthiness of that evidence. It is accordingly. considered a safe rule of prudence to generally look for corroboration of the sworn testimony of witnesses in court as to the identity of the accused who are strangers to them, in the form of earlier identification proceeding. There may, however, be exceptions to this general rule, when, for example, the court is impressed by a particular witness, on whose testimony it can safely rely, without such or other corroboration. The identification parades belong to the investigation stage. They are generally held during the course of investigation with the primary object of enabling the witnesses to identify per'sons concerned in the offence, who were not previously known to them. This serves to satisfy the investigating officers of the bona fides of the prosecution witnesses and also to furnish evidence to corroborate their testimony in court. Identification proceedings in their legal effect amount simply to this: that certain persons are brought to jail or some other place and make statements either express or implied that certain individuals whom they 51 point out are persons whom they recognise as having been concerned in the crime. They do not constitute substantive evidence. These parades are essentially governed by S. 162, Cr. P.C. It is for this reason that the identification parades in this case seem to have been held under the supervision of a Magistrate. Keeping in view the purpose of identification parades the Magistrates holding them are expected to take all possible precautions to eliminate any suspicion of unfairness and to reduce the chance of testimonial error. They must, therefore, take intelligent interest in the proceedings, bearing in mind two considerations :

    (i) that the life and liberty of an accused may depend on their vigilance and caution and (ii) that justice should be done in the identification Those proceedings should not make it impossible for the identifiers who, after all, have, as a rule, only fleeting glimpses of the person they are supposed to identify. Generally speaking, the Magistrate must make a note of every objection raised by an accused at the time of identification and the steps taken by them to ensure fairness to the accused, so that the court which is to judge the value of the identification evidence may take them into consideration in the appreciation of that evidence. The power to identify, it may be kept in view, varies according to the power of observation and memory of the person identifying and each case depends on its own facts, but there are two factors which seems to be of basic importance in the evaluation of identification. The persons required to identify an accused should have had no opportunity of seeing him after the commission of the crime and before identification and secondly that no mistakes are made by them or the mistakes made are negligible. 52 The identification to be of value should also be held without much delay. The number of persons mixed up with the accused should be reasonably large and their bearing and general appearance not glaringly dissimilar. The evidence as to identification deserves, therefore, to be subjected to a close and careful scrutiny by the Court. In the case of Chandra Prakash Vs. State of Rajasthan reported in 2014 Cr.L.J.2884 with regard to delay in conducting test identification parade Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that the delay per se cannot be fatal to the validity of holding an identification parade, in all cases, without exception. The purpose of the identification parade is to provide corroborative evidence and is more confirmatory in its nature. In the case of Mulla & Anr. Vs. State of U.P. reported in 2010 Cr.L.J 1440, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that the identification parades are not primarily meant for the Court. They are meant for investigation purposes. The object of conducting test identification parade is two fold. First is to enable the witnesses to satisfy themselves that the accused whom they suspect is really the one who was seen by them in connection with the commission of the crime. Second is to satisfy the investigating authority that the suspect is the real person whom the witnesses had seen in connection with the said occurrence. Identification test do not constitute substantive evidence and they can only be used as corroborative of the statement in Court. The necessity for holding an identification parade can arise only when the accused persons are not previously known to the witnesses. The whole idea of a test identification parade is that witnesses who claim to have seen the culprits at the time of 53 occurrence are to identify them from the midst of other persons without any aid or any other source. The test is done to check upon their veracity. In other words, the main object of holding an identification parade, during the investigation stage, is to test the memory of the witnesses based upon first impression and also to enable the prosecution to decide whether all or any of them could be cited as eyewitnesses of the crime. The identification proceedings are in the nature of tests and significantly, therefore, there is no provision for it in the Code and the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. It is desirable that a test identification parade should be conducted as soon as possible after the arrest of the accused. This becomes necessary to eliminate the possibility of the accused being shown to the witnesses prior to the test identification parade. This is a very common plea of the accused and, therefore, the prosecution has to be cautious to ensure that there is no scope for making such allegation. If, however, circumstances are beyond control and there is some delay, it cannot be said to be fatal to the prosecution. In this case Hon'ble Supreme Court laid down following principles regarding identification parades- (i) an identification parade ideally must be conducted as soon as possible to avoid any mistake on the part of witnesses, (2) this condition can be revoked if proper explanation justifying the delay is provided; and (3) the authorities must make sure that the delay does not result in exposure of the accused which may lead to mistake on the part of the witnesses. In the case of Shyamal Ghosh Vs. State of West Bengal reported in 2012 Cr.L.J.3825, Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that: The whole idea of a Test Identification Parade is that witnesses who claim to have seen the culprits at the time of occurrence are to identify them from the midst 54 of other persons without any aid or any other source. The test is done to check upon their veracity. In other words, the main object of holding an identification parade, during the investigation stage, is to test the memory of the witnesses based upon first impression and also to enable the prosecution to decide whether all or any of them could be cited as eyewitnesses of the crime. Identification Parade is a tool of investigation and is used primarily to strengthen the case of the prosecution on the one hand and to make doubly sure that persons named accused in the case are actually the culprits. The Identification Parade primarily belongs to the stage of investigation by the police. The fact that a particular witness has been able to identify the accused at an identification parade is only a circumstance corroborative of the identification in court. Thus, it is only a relevant consideration which may be examined by the court in view of other attendant circumstances and corroborative evidence with reference to the facts of a given case. The legal position is also that law presumes that witnesses giving evidence under solemns are witnesses of truth unless the contrary is proved. It can not be presumed that witnesses in identification parades are coached by police or that the suspects are shown to them. Facial recognition of a human being is dependant on the particular quality of memory. Detailed observations, clarity of image, its retention and recall are the obvious steps in the process. They differ from person to person and from occasion to occasion. A Single Bench of the Rajasthan High Court in the case of Ocha Vs. The State reported in 1955 RLW 450 has held that no hard 55 and fast rule can be laid down for believing or disbelieving the evidence of a particular witness regarding identity of the accused and it is always open to a Court which tries the case to attach such value to the statement of the witness as it deserves under the circumstances of the case. Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of U.P. Vs. Boota Singh reported in AIR 1978 SC 1770 has held that the rule that identification evidence is a very weak type of evidence is not a rule of universal application. Where the witness correctly identifies the accused at a T.I.parade held by a Magistrate after observing all the essential formalities and taking the necessary precautions and then identifies the accused also in Court, the evidence of identification can be believed unless the evidence of the witness suffers from some other infirmity. Moreover, the evidence of identification becomes stronger if the witness has an opportunity of seeing the accused for some length of time, in broad daylight, when he would be able to note the features of the accused more carefully than on seeing the accused in dark night for few minutes. In the case of State of Rajasthan Vs. Ranjita Ladhuram reported in AIR 1962 (Raj.) 78, Full Bench of the Rajasthan High Court has held that No one doubts the position that where the accused are put up for identification by witnesses to whom they are strangers, every precaution should be taken against the witnesses having an opportunity of seeing the accused prior to the stage of the test identification parade. If an accused has been shown to the witnesses or the witnesses have had the opportunity of 56 seeing him prior to the test identification, the identification becomes meaningless and loses all its significance. In that event, the witnesses would easily pick out the accused from a number of other persons in the test identification parade. Therefore, precautions are necessary against any such opportunity being given to the witnesses, either at the instance of the witnesses themselves or at the instance of the police. It was further held that:

    I also fail to understand why the mere failure of an identifying witness to state in his deposition that he had not seen the accused prior to the stage of identification, should discredit his testimony. To throw out the sworn and valuable testimony of the witness on that ground alone, is as bad as accepting his testimony on the bare statement that he had not seen the accused prior to the identification parade. It was also held by the learned Full Bench that: It would be wrong to start with a suspicion of the evidence given on oath and insist that unless the witness adhered to some kind of a formula in stating that he had not actually seen the accused, who was a stranger to him, after the occurrence and before the test identification parade, his evidence must be rejected. It was further held that: In our opinion, therefore, it would be going too far to suggest that all that precaution of Ba Parda with corresponding routine entries in the police diary or in the jail warrant are absolutely essential. All that is necessary is to see whether there is anything on the record to indicate that the accused had been either deliberately shown to the witnesses prior to the test 57 identification parade or that the witnesses had an opportunity of seeing the accused and being pointed out their identity before the test identification. If there is any such indication on the record and the investigating authorities have taken no precaution against it, then alone no value should be attached to the test identification otherwise there can be no justification for insisting that the identifying witnesses should unnecessarily go on repeating in their evidence that they had not seen the accused before the test identification parade and if they failed to do so all the value of their evidence in Court should be lost merely on that account. As we said, if we insist on any such formula, there is nothing to prevent the witnesses, if they are dishonest enough to do so, to go on repeating this formula in their examination in chief. It is always open to the defence to bring out any such facts in cross-examination of the witnesses which may lead to the inference that the witnesses had already an opportunity of seeing the accused and, therefore, no reliance should be placed upon their test identification. Normally, it is expected that the police, before they place the accused for identification at a test identification parade, will take every precaution to see that the witnesses have not already seen the accused, unless it appears that they had some personal motive of reward or revenge or undue professional enthusiasm in having a person identified as an accused at any cost by even winning over the identifying witnesses to act according to their desire. These are undoubtedly far- fetched assumptions, though in some cases the evidence might justify an inference of this kind. It is also erroneous, in my opinion, to attach too much weight to the assertion of the accused, unsupported by 58 any cogent material, that he or they had been shown to the witnesses prior to the test identification parade. Experience shows that almost invariably this defence is taken in order to destroy the value of the test identification and if the Courts were to act merely on the ipse dixit of the accused and thereby throw an unnecessary burden on the prosecution to make the identifying witnesses repeat in each case that they had not seen the accused earlier, they would be, in my opinion, adopting a meaningless formula which is neither warranted by logic or law. In the case of Prabhati & Ors. Vs. State reported in AIR 1966 (Raj.) 241, a learned Single Bench of the Rajasthan High Court has held that: It is true that human memory is fail-able and that impressions as to identify of offenders have tendency to fade out with the lapse of time. It is also true that there have been cases in which the identification evidence has been discarded on account of delay under certain circumstances. At the same time it must be pointed out that the circumstances and the manner in which witnesses form and register impressions as to identity of the offenders are bound to differ widely. It must also be recognised that individuals have varying powers of observations and registering impressions as to identity; their capacity to retain memories of the impressions also differ. Human experience and common sense considerations, therefore, warrant that it will be dangerous and risky to formulate and act upon any rule of thumb in the matter of appraising the effects of delay in identification. The proper course is that Judges and Magistrates in dealing with such a question should avoid uncritical over-credulity as also 59 unnecessary scepticism and should bring to bear judicial maturity and consider and weigh the circumstances and facts of individual cases and proceed to decide them on a consideration of the individual peculiarities of the cases in the light of experience as to human affairs and the guiding rules of prudence enunciated in the leading cases but without treating them as rigid, mathematical formula. To put it differently, their approach to the cases should be prudent, intelligent and pragmatic and not mechanical, wooden or unnecessary doctrinaire. It was further held that: Men differ very largely in their powers of observation. One man will remember a face for a very long period though he has only seen its possessor once, and for a very short time. Other men, who are unobservant may not be able to identify persons whom they had a good opportunity or identifying even a short time afterwards. The power to identify varies according to the power of observation and the observation may be based upon small minutes which a witness cannot describe himself or explain. It has no necessary connexion with education or mental attainments. An illiterate villager may and frequently is much more observant than an educated man." In the case of Satrughana alias Satrughana Parida & Anr. etc. Vs. State of Orissa reported in 1991 Cr.L.J.846, a learned Single of Hon'ble Orissa High Court has held that it is not correct to say that where identification is held simultaneously of many suspects, the identification is totally unworthy of credit. It is wrong to hold that test identification parade should be held only with one suspect mixed up, with 60 nine or ten innocent persons. A Division Bench of Kerala High Court in the case of Sajeevan and etc.etc. Vs. Kerala State reported in 1994 Cr.L.J. 1316 has held that: If the idea of conducting a test identification parade is to test the ability of a witness to identify a particular person, then photograph of the suspect should not be shown to him in advance. Otherwise the parade becomes only a farce. But that is different from the Press publishing photos of the accused in newspapers. It is not the work of the investigating agency, but the exercise of journalistic calibre. Investigating agency has, normally, no control over such journalistic adventures. Hence such publication cannot be prevented by the police in a society where freedom of press is guaranteed. It has become very usual that in sensational criminal cases newspapers would display enthusiasm to publish photos of different facets including photos of the accused. It is not necessary that witnesses should see such photos in the newspapers. Even if a witness happens to see the photo of a particular accused in a newspaper we are not inclined to sideline his evidence regarding identification on that score alone. It must be remembered that Kerala is a State where there is preliferation of newspapers. How can a witness be made responsible if newspapers publish the photoghraphs of the accused? If we are to lay down a proposition that identification evidence of a witness is liable to be thrown overboard in cases where newspapers published the photo of the accused, a good number of witnesses in Kerala would be exposed to the peril of being disbelieved on account of the 61 journalistic adventure and high density of print media in this state. Of course, it is open to the court to decide whether a witnesses evidence regarding identification was really influenced by such publication.
    It was further held that: Evidence of identification of witnesses cannot be rejected merely because they did not enumerate the features or marks of the accused. Persons possessing special identification features are far and few between. One is able to remember another man's face not always because of any special mark or features. The image of an assailant or a thief or a burglar can leave the impression in the mind of the viewer or the victim which can remain in the mind without fading out for a reasonable period. There are untranslatable factors by which such retention is possible. The viewer need not count or notice any special mark or feature for retaining the image of the assailant in his mind. (. 7) - , , , , , (. 2) , 62

    1. 4-5 2. 3. 63 3-4 , (. 5) : 1997 64 4-5 (. 18), - , 65 4-5 (. 5) , - (. 9) , 3-4 1995 66 (. 9) 120- , 67 18.10.2006 8.10 (. 21) -83 - 24.10.2006 4.45 ,

    27 , - 99 24.10.2006 5.05 (. 14) (. 15) , -55 "" , "" "" 15.10.2006 1.45 (. 20) -78 6 ,

    27 15.10.2006 1.50 -80 - 68 15.10.2006 3.40 (. 17) , -70 "" "" 20.11.2006 3.50 (. 28) -89 (. 21) 27.11.2006 : 11.45 , 27 -95 -96 28.11.2006 "" (. 21) 18.10.2006 8.30 -84 23.10.2006 : 8.00 69

    27 -97 23.10.2006 : 11.30 (. 12) (. 2) -9 "" "" 24.10.2006 12.15

    27 -98 24.10.2006 1.30 (. 14) (..15) -53 "" "" 07.02.2008 12.40 -101 09.02.2008 5.00

    27 102 70 09.02.2008 6.15 -103 "" 13.12.2007 6.20 -91 15.12.2007 : 11.30 , 27 -92 15.12.2007 1.20 . 9 -27 "" 16.12.2007 1.25 , 27 -93 16.12.2007 5.10 . 9 71 -25 "" , -130 "" - 128 "" -130 - 128 "" -128 -128 - 72 "" -130 -129 - -132 - -132 -131 -128 73 :- 1. 2.

    3. ,

    4. , , , 5. 74 27 1999 (1) () - 195 (2001) 1 -652 75 (. 14), (. 15), (. 17), (. 2), (. 12) (. 9) (. 14) (. 15) 76

    There is nothing in Section 27 of the Evidence Act which renders the statement of the accused inadmissible if recovery of the articles was made from any place which is "open or accessible to others". It is a fallacious notion that when recovery of any incriminating article was made from a place which is open or accessible to others. It would vitiate the evidence under Section

    27 of the Evidence Act. Any object can be concealed in places which are open or accessible to others. For Example, if the article is buried on the main roadside or if it is concealed beneath dry leaves lying on public places or kept hidden in a public office, the article would remain out of the visibility of others in normal circumstances. Until such article is disinterred its hidden state would remain unhampered. The person who hid it alone knows were it is until he discloses that fact to any other person. Hence 77 the crucial question is not whether the place was accessible to others or not but whether it was ordinarily visible to others. If it is not, then it is immaterial that the concealed place is accessible to others.

    , -

    6 , - - , - 78

    12 - 12 16.04.2007 - 127 , , 79 - - (. 23), 23.10.2006 , , (. 23) 20.10.2006 -59 - , - , 352, 347, 387 80 165/2006 -149 164 -147 30.10.2006 (. 22) (. 22) (. 23) 164 20.07.2006 -59 - - , , , , , 81 (. 7) -11, . (. 3) , 29 , , , , 82 (. 30) 15.10.2006 14-2--0123 207 -11 11.12.2006 5.30 (. 21) -86 14.12.2006 3.25

    27 -27 14.12.2006 4.40 -109 , , 15.10.2006 (. 30) 83 15.12.2006 -88 27 15.10.2006

    1. - , , , , 13.10.2006 : 8.15 84

    148 302 149 2. 120-

    3. 201 216

    4. , 3/25 4/25, 4/25, - 3/25 4/25 - 4/25 85

    1. , , ,, , 148 302/149 , 120- , 302 302 120-

    2. , , 3/25 4/25, - 4/25, - 3/25 4/25 4/25

    3. -

    4. -

    5. 148, 302/149 4/25 3/25 437- () 20000/- , : 86 ( . ) ( 0 ) All corrections made in the judgement/order have been incorporated in the judgement/order being emailed. B.L. Jain, PS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Brij Mohan And Ors v. State Of Rajasthan Through P P
    (Mar 29, 2016)