AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Order 26 Rule 9
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provision of Order 26 Rule 9
Smart Summary

Summary of the Opinion (B.R. Gavai, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenge an order dated 23rd February, 2007 which rejected their application for appointment of a Court Commissioner. The underlying suit is by plaintiffs for a permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with their possession of survey number 213 and from obstructing their use of the way between survey numbers 212 and 213. An earlier application for appointment of a Commissioner in that suit had previously been rejected. After the plaintiffs closed their evidence and thirteen witnesses had been examined, the petitioners filed the present application for appointment of a Commissioner; that application was rejected, giving rise to the present petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Trial Court erred in refusing to appoint a Court Commissioner for local investigation in the context of the dispute over the existence/dimensions of the road and the map.
  2. Whether Order 26 Rule 9 (CPC) mandates the appointment of a Commissioner where there is a dispute about encroachment, site dimension or map, or whether appointment is discretionary/directory.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The sole dispute concerns the existence of the road and the proper map; because there is a dispute regarding the map, it is incumbent on the Trial Court to appoint a Court Commissioner to prepare an agreed map or mark on a map.
  • Relied on the Single Judge's observation in Ramchandra Bhikaji Jagtap v. Dudharam Langruji Padvekar (2004 (1) Mh. L.J 278) that in disputes about encroachment or dimensions the first essential is to get an agreed map and, if parties cannot agree, a Commissioner must be appointed.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The application by the petitioners was in the nature of collecting evidence and not for a necessary local investigation; therefore the Trial Court rightly rejected the application.
  • Relied on the decision in Sanjay Namdo Khandare v. Sahebrao Kachru Khandare (2001 (2) Mh. L.J 959 : 2001 (1) ALL MR 653).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ramchandra Bhikaji Jagtap v. Dudharam Langruji Padvekar (2004 (1) Mh. L.J 278) Where there is a dispute about encroachment or dimension of a site, an agreed map should be obtained and if parties cannot agree, a Commissioner must be appointed to prepare the same (quoted passage). The Court treated this decision as having only persuasive value and expressly declined to follow it, stating it does not lay down the correct proposition in this Court's view.
Sanjay Namdo Khandare v. Sahebrao Kachru Khandare (2001 (2) Mh. L.J 959 : 2001 (1) ALL MR 653) Articulates a contrary view (as relied upon by respondents) concerning the exercise of discretion under Order 26 Rule 9. The Court preferred and followed this decision, holding it to be the more correct view in the circumstances of the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by reproducing the text of Order 26 Rule 9 (Civil Procedure Code) which empowers the Court to issue a commission for local investigation "in any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper" for elucidating matters in dispute, ascertaining market value, mesne profits, damages or annual net profits; and notes a proviso about State Government rules where applicable.

From the text of Order 26 Rule 9 the Court concluded that the provision is directory in nature rather than mandatory. The Court explained that appointment of a Commissioner is a matter of discretion: only when the trial court finds a local investigation necessary for deciding the matter in dispute may it exercise that discretion to appoint a Commissioner. Conversely, if the trial court does not find such an investigation necessary, nothing in the provision obliges it to appoint a Commissioner.

The Court observed there are two conflicting Single Judge decisions of this Court on the issue. It considered the decision in Ramchandra (cited by petitioners) to be of persuasive value only and stated it was not inclined to follow it. Instead, the Court found the approach in Sanjay Namdo Khandare (cited by respondents) to present the more correct view on the matter and adopted that approach.

Applying that analysis to the facts, the Court implicitly accepted the trial court's exercise of discretion in declining to appoint a Commissioner (noting the application was filed after plaintiffs' evidence had closed and after thirteen witnesses were examined, and that the trial court appeared to regard the application as effectively an attempt to collect evidence).

Holding and Implications

Petition dismissed.

Implications:

  • The Trial Court's order rejecting the application for appointment of a Court Commissioner (dated 23rd February, 2007) is upheld and stands.
  • The Court held that Order 26 Rule 9 is directory and confers a discretionary power on the trial court to appoint a Commissioner only when it deems a local investigation necessary; there is no absolute mandate to appoint a Commissioner merely because there is a dispute over a map or existence of a way.
  • The Court preferred the earlier Single Judge decision in Sanjay Namdo Khandare over the decision in Ramchandra Bhikaji Jagtap v. Dudharam; the opinion does not purport to create a binding precedent beyond resolving the matter before it, and it characterizes Ramchandra as having only persuasive value.


Source: Opinion of B.R. Gavai, J., as provided.

    Pandurang Nandlal Chandak And Another v. Sandip Mukundrao Pensalwar And Another

    B.R Gavai, J.:— By way of present petition, the petitioners challenge the order dated 23rd Feb., 2007 vide which the application filed by the petitioner for appointment of Commissioner came to be rejected.

    2. The plaintiffs have filed the suit for permanent injunction restraining the defendants from interfering with their possession in Sr. No. 213 and from obstructing them from using the way between Sr. No. 212 and 213. In the said suit on an earlier occasion also, an application for appointment of Court Commissioner came to be filed and the same was rejected. Thereafter, after the closure of evidence of the plaintiff and after the thirteen witness were examined, the present application came to be filed. The same is rejected hence the present petition.

    3. Shri Chandak, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners submit that the only dispute is regarding the existence of the road. He submits that since there is a dispute regarding the map, it is incumbent upon the Trial Court to appoint Court Commissioner.

    4. He refers to the observation of the learned Single Judge in the case of Ramchandra Bhikaji Jagtap v. Dudharam Langruji Padvekar dead through L.Rs Bulkabai Padvekar, 2004 (1) Mh. L.J 278 which reads thus:

    “In any case, in which there is a dispute about encroachment or dimension of a site, the first essential is to get an agreed map and if the parties cannot agree on one, a Commissioner must be appointed to prepare the same and/or subsequent reference in the pleadings or judgment to place the mark on a map should be referred to this map which must be attached to the decree and signed by the Judge.”

    5. Shri Chapalgaonkar, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondents on the contrary submits that the application filed by the present petitioner was in the nature of collecting evidence and as such the learned trial Court has rightly rejected the application.

    6. He relies on the judgment of Single Judge of this Court in the case of Sanjay Namdo Khandare v. Sahebrao Kachru Khandare, 2001 (2) Mh. L.J 959 : 2001 (1) ALL MR 653.

    7. The provision of Order 26 Rule 9 reads thus:

    “In any suit in which the Court deems a local investigation to be requisite or proper for the purpose of elucidating any matter in dispute, or of ascertaining the market value of any property, or the amount of any mesne profits or damages or annual net profits, the Court may issue a Commission to such person as it thinks fit directing him to make such investigation and to report thereon to the Court.

    Provided that, where the State Government has made rules as to the persons to whom such Commission shall be issued, the Court shall be bound by such rules.”

    8. From perusal of the said Rule it would thus be clear that the provisions are directory in nature. Only when the trial Court finds a local investigation necessary for the purpose of deciding the matter in dispute, it may exercise the discretion for appointment of Court Commissioner. It would also be seen that when the Court does not find it necessary, there is nothing which mandates the Court to appoint Court Commissioner.

    9. Insofar as the judgment rendered by the learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Ramchandra v. Dudharam (cited supra) is concerned, it is only having a persuasive value on this Court.

    10. In the present case it could be seen that there are two conflicting judgments rendered by the two Single Judges of this Court. I am of the considered view that the Judgment rendered by the Single Judge in the case of Ramchandra v. Dudharam (cited supra) does not lay the correct proposition, as such I am not inclined to follow the same. On the contrary, I am of the view that the view taken by the learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Sanjay Namdo Khandare v. Sahebrao Kachru Khandare, 2001 (2) Mh. L.J 959 : 2001 (1) ALL MR 653 is more correct view and therefore I am inclined to follow the same.

    11. In the result the petition is dismissed.

    Petition dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pandurang Nandlal Chandak And Another v. Sandip Mukundrao Pensalwar And Another
    (Nov 27, 2008)