AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges

    Cajiton Santan Carneiro v. Aphali Pharmaceuticals Ltd., Ahmednagar

    The facts leading to the filing of the present writ petition, briefly stated, are as under:

    2.The petitioner was employed by respondent as Junior Office Assistant from 12.8.1977 till 21.1.1987. There was domestic inquiry held against petitioner by respondent employer and his services came to be terminated. The industrial dispute was referred to the Labour Court by the Deputy Commissioner of Labour and learned Judge of the Labour Court by Order dated 19.11.1993 allowed the Reference and directed reinstatement of the petitioner with back wages to the petitioner from the date of his termination till 7.6.1990, the date of enrolment of the petitioner as an Advocate. The petitioner is aggrieved with this order inasmuch as, according to him, he should have been paid until the date of his reinstatement i.e. 19.11.1993. Hence this writ petition.

    3. have heard Shri Prabhakaran, learned Counsel for the petitioner and I have gone through judgment and order of the Presiding Officer of the I st Labour Court, Ahmednagar dated 19.11.1993.

    4.Admittedly, there is no challenge raised to the reinstatement order and the order for back wages by the employer. Thus, the order with regard to reinstatement and arrears of wages has not been challenged. It is stated at the Bar that the petitioner has been reinstated in service.

    5.The only point which has been raised in this petition and which has been argued by Shri Prabhakaran, learned counsel for the petitioner, is that the Court was not justified in refusing the back wages on the sole ground of enrolment of the petitioner as an Advocate. Admittedly, there was no evidence adduced by employer suggesting income earned by the petitioner after the petitioner's enrolment as an Advocate. The petitioner stated in his evidence that he did not get any income and despite his efforts, he could not get any employment.

    6.On perusal of the reasonings adopted by learned Judge of the Labour Court, it would be seen that relying on the two cases of the Supreme Court, i.e. Om Prakash Goel vs. The Himachal Pradesh Tourism Development Corpn. Ltd., Shimla and Anr. 1991 II CLR 350 and S.M. Saiyed v. Baroda Municipal Corporation, Baroda 1985 I CLR 153 S.C., learned Judge chose not to grant back wages after the date of enrolment of the petitioner as an Advocate. Normally, this Court would not have interfered in the discretion exercised in this regard by the Judge of the Labour Court. Since, however, it has come in the evidence in this case that the present petitioner has been trying to secure a job after his termination and did not succeed in securing any job, he got himself enrolled as an advocate. It has been rightly argued by Shri Prabhakaran that if petitioner had been earning, there was no reason for him to have accepted the job with the respondent over again. There is waiting period in legal profession and the person is not expected to start earning immediately on his enrolment. It would, therefore, be reasonable to hold that the petitioner was not gainfully employed even though enrolled as an Advocate at least for one year after his enrolment. It is for this reason that I partly allow this writ petition.

    The order with regard to the back wages is modified as follows:

    The petitioner is entitled to back wages from the date of his termination till after expiry of one year from the date of his enrolment i.e. till 7.6.1991. Petitioner succeeds to this limited extent only. Rule made absolute with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Cajiton Santan Carneiro v. Aphali Pharmaceuticals Ltd., Ahmednagar
    (Nov 3, 2004)