AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 33, Section 33-A of the Industrial Disputes Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Section 33, Section 33-A of the Industrial Disputes Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

C.A. Rodrick was employed by Karam Chand Thapar & Bros. (P) Ltd. as a storekeeper. An inventory conducted on 7 December 1956 revealed shortages in several stock items. On 3 January 1957 he was served with a charge-sheet and suspended, and on 19 February 1957 he was dismissed after a domestic enquiry.

Rodrick filed an application on 10 March 1957 before the Industrial Tribunal under Section 33-A of the Industrial Disputes Act, asserting that his dismissal contravened Section 33 and seeking reinstatement. The respondent contended that Rodrick was not a “workman,” and thus Section 33 was inapplicable.

The Tribunal held that Rodrick was a workman concerned in a pending industrial dispute, found Section 33 had been violated, but—after examining evidence led by the employer—upheld the dismissal on merits for misappropriation and dismissed the application. Rodrick obtained special leave and appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Industrial Tribunal erred in upholding the dismissal of the appellant on the ground of misappropriation despite an initial finding that Section 33 of the Industrial Disputes Act had been contravened.
  2. Whether the Supreme Court should interfere with the Tribunal’s factual findings supporting the charge of misappropriation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments

  • Managing the stores was difficult; the mere fact that items were missing did not establish the appellant’s sole responsibility.
  • The appellant handed over the keys every evening to a superior officer, suggesting others had access.
  • The appellant had been discharged in a related criminal case, undermining the allegation of misappropriation.
  • Other individuals, such as a coolie or assistant, could have removed the goods.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The appellant was guilty of misappropriating stock, as evidenced by admissions in his written explanation and the shortages discovered.
  • As storekeeper, the appellant bore primary responsibility for safeguarding the goods; absence of proof implicating others strengthened the case against him.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted that, although the Tribunal found a technical violation of Section 33, an employer may nevertheless justify a dismissal on merits under Section 33-A proceedings. The Tribunal had accepted the respondent’s evidence that:

  • The appellant admitted taking two Primus stoves for repair, retaining one for personal use.
  • He acknowledged that ten liquid soap dispensers and thirty-three brass nozzles were missing without satisfactorily identifying another culprit.
  • He later withdrew allegations implicating colleagues, weakening his defence.

The Court emphasized that factual determinations by the Tribunal—especially credibility assessments and admissions—are ordinarily not interfered with in special leave jurisdiction. Given the appellant’s own admissions and lack of evidence incriminating others, the finding of misappropriation was held neither incorrect nor improper.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed.

The Tribunal’s award upholding the dismissal stands; the appellant is not entitled to reinstatement or relief. No costs were awarded, and the appellant, permitted to appeal as a pauper, is exempted from paying court-fees. The decision resolves the dispute between the parties but sets no new legal precedent.

    C.A Rodrick v. Karam Chand Thapar And Bros. (P) Ltd.,) Calcutta-1 And Another

    Gajendragadkar, J.— The appellant C.A Rodrick was appointed by the respondent Karam Chand Thapar & Bros. (P) Ltd. as a storekeeper. On 7-12-1956, Mr Sen Gupta took account of the stock which was in charge of the appellant and discovered that the stock was deficient in respect of many items. On 3-1-1957, the appellant was served with a charge-sheet and on the same date, he was suspended from service. Thereafter, an enquiry was held and as a result of the enquiry, he was dismissed from service on 19-2-1957. On 10-3-1957, he made the present application to the Industrial Tribunal under Section 33-A of the Industrial Disputes Act. He alleged that his dismissal had contravened Section 33 of the Act and that he was entitled to reinstatement.

    2. The respondent disputed the appellant's status as a workman and pleaded that Section 33 was inapplicable and so the respondent case was that since Section 33 had not been contravened, the appellant's application under Section 33-A was incompetent.

    3. The Tribunal has upheld the appellant case that he was a workman employed by the respondent; it has also accepted his argument that he was a workman concerned in an industrial dispute which was then pending adjudication and so, Section 33 was applicable and had been contravened by the respondent. That is why the Tribunal rejected the preliminary objection of the respondent that the application made by the appellant under Section 33-A was not competent. Having reached this conclusion, the Tribunal proceeded to examine the dispute between the parties on its merits. It is well settled that if an application is made by an employee under Section 33-A and it is shown that the impugned dismissal of the employee has contravened Section 33, it is open to the employer to justify the dismissal on the merits by adducing satisfactory evidence before the Tribunal. The respondent has adopted that course in the present proceedings.

    4. On the merits, the Tribunal has believed the evidence led by the respondent and held that the appellant was guilty of misappropriation. In the result, the application made by the appellant under Section 33-A has been dismissed, and it has been held that the dismissal of the appellant was fully justified. It is against this award that Mr Gopalakrishnan has come to this Court by special leave on behalf of the appellant.

    5. Mr Gopalakrishnan does not dispute the fact that when Mr Sen Gupta checked the stores, he found that many items of the stores were missing. He however argues that the management of the stores was such a difficult job that it is impossible to hold that just because some goods were missing, that the appellant alone could be fixed with the criminal responsibility in that behalf. Mr Gopalakrishnan further contends that the appellant used to give the keys every evening to his superior officer and he relies on the fact that in a criminal case started against the appellant, he has been discharged. There may be some force in the argument that some others besides the appellant may have been responsible for the loss of the goods; but in any case, in respect of some items, the appellant has clearly admitted that he is guilty. After inspection of the go down was made, the appellant was called to give his explanation and in his explanation on 27-12-1956, he admitted that two primus stoves belonging to tents supply were lying in the godowns and required repaiRs He added that he took both the stoves to a repair shop and got one stove repaired and left the other with the repairer and that the repaired stove he took to his house and was using it. This clearly is an admission that the appellant took one of the two stoves belonging to the respondent, got one repaired and was using it.

    6. Similarly, the appellant admitted that ten liquid soap metal dispenser and 33 brass nozzles were missing, but he added that he could not say who had taken them away. Then he seemed to suggest that his assistant, Mr Bose may be responsible. But on second thought, he withdrew that allegation and stated that Mr Bose was an honest man. Mr Gopalakrishnan no doubt relied on a complaint made by the appellant against the coolie Basan Kahar, but as the Tribunal has pointed out, it is easy for the appellant to suggest that some others may have a hand in removing some of the goods; but if the appellant was appointed as storekeeper, it was his primary responsibility to look after the stores and see that no pilfering took place. Admittedly, some stores are missing and admittedly, there is no other evidence to show that anybody else could have taken them away. Besides, the items we have already indicated are shown to have been taken by the appellant. Under these circumstances, if the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the charges framed against the appellant by the respondent were fully established before it, we do not see how the appellant could successfully challenge the correctness or the propriety of that conclusion. It is a question of fact which the Tribunal had to consider and decide and ordinarily, this Court does not interfere with questions of fact.

    7. The result is, the appeal fails and is dismissed. There will be no order as to costs. In this appeal, it is ordered that the appellant who was allowed to appeal as a pauper need not pay the court-fees.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    C.A Rodrick v. Karam Chand Thapar And Bros. (P) Ltd.,) Calcutta-1 And Another
    (Aug 13, 1962)