Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff manufactures television sets marketed under the trademark "CHOICE." In 1986, the defendants were appointed as dealers for the plaintiff's television sets but this agency has since been terminated. The plaintiff alleges that the defendants are now selling other domestic appliances such as sewing machines, fans, electric irons, geysers, washing machines, water filters, hot plates, and room coolers under the same trade name "Choice," using a logo similar to that of the plaintiff. The plaintiff contends that these goods belong to the same trading channel and that the defendants' use of the name and logo is likely to cause confusion and passing off. The plaintiff applied under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 for an injunction restraining the defendants from using the name "CHOICE" in relation to these goods.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the defendants' use of the trade name "Choice" and a similar logo for domestic appliances constitutes passing off, given that the plaintiff's mark is unregistered.
  2. Whether the goods sold by the defendants (various domestic appliances) and the plaintiff's televisions fall within the same or allied trading channels such that an injunction can be granted.
  3. Whether the plaintiff's relatively short period of use (approximately three years) and unregistered status precludes it from obtaining an injunction.
  4. Whether an interim injunction should be granted restraining the defendants from using the trade name and logo pending disposal of the suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The plaintiff manufactures and markets television sets under the trademark "CHOICE" and has acquired reputation and goodwill in the mark within three years, supported by sales and advertising.
  • The defendants, after termination of their agency, have begun selling other domestic appliances under the same trade name and a similar logo, likely causing confusion and passing off.
  • The goods sold by the defendants belong to the same or allied trading channel as the plaintiff's televisions, justifying an injunction.
  • Precedents show that goods not obviously similar may still be in the same trade channel, supporting the plaintiff's claim.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The use of the logo similar to the plaintiff's was a mistake by the advertising agent and has been corrected; defendants have no intention to use the similar logo further.
  • The goods sold by the defendants (sewing machines, fans, irons, etc.) are not allied or cognate to the plaintiff's televisions and fall under different trademark classes, thus no confusion is likely.
  • The plaintiff's trademark is unregistered and the plaintiff has only been in business for three years, which is insufficient to claim exclusive rights or an injunction beyond the class of goods (class 9) it manufactures.
  • Precedents cited by defendants support that injunctions require goods to be of the same category or nature.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(1979) R.P.C. 19; AIR 1983 Punjab & Haryana 418; AIR 1985 Allahabad 242; (1973) R.P.C. 560; (1975) R.P.C. 171 Goods not apparently similar may still fall under the same trade channel for passing off purposes. Supported the plaintiff's contention that the goods sold by defendants and plaintiff are allied in trading channel despite different classes.
United Brothers v. United Traders, I.A. No. 3927 of 1981 (Order dated 28 Jan 1982) Goods must be allied or of the same category for injunction against passing off. Defendants relied on this to argue that goods (aluminium utensils vs spoons/forks) were not allied; court considered relevance.
1988 P.T.C. 98 Distinctness of goods (fluorescent tube vs choke) for passing off. Defendants cited to support non-allied nature of goods.
Hindustan Pencils Private Ltd. v. Prem Chand Gupta, 1985 P.T.C. 33 Different goods (pencils, sharpeners vs mathematical instruments) not same description. Defendants cited to support argument goods are not allied.
Nestle Products Ltd. v. Durex Products Milk Made Corpn., AIR 1947 Delhi 43 Requirement that goods be of the same category or nature for injunction. Defendants relied on to argue no injunction for different goods.
London Rubber Co. Ltd. v. Durex Products Incorporated and another, AIR 1963 S.C. 188 Same as above: importance of goods being in same category for injunction. Defendants cited to support their submissions.
M/s. Parry and Co. Ltd. Madras v. M/s Perry and Co. Usilampati Madurai, AIR 1963 Madras 460 Goods must be of the same category or nature for injunction. Defendants relied on this precedent.
M/s Jugmug Electric and Radio Co. v. M/s Telerad Private Ltd., 1 JLR (1978) I Delhi 667 Goods in different classes but same trade channel and customer confusion justify injunction in passing off. Key precedent relied on by the court to hold that televisions and domestic appliances can be in the same trading channel causing confusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the case under the law of passing off since the plaintiff's trademark "CHOICE" was unregistered and thus Section 9 of the Trade Marks Act was inapplicable. The central inquiry was whether the goods sold by the defendants (various domestic appliances) and the plaintiff's televisions belong to the same or allied trading channels such that confusion or deception is likely.

The court noted that although the goods fall under different classes in the Trade Mark Rules Schedule IV, this classification alone is not decisive. The court emphasized that the relevant test is whether the goods are in the same category or trading channel and whether the use of the mark by the defendants is likely to cause confusion among ordinary consumers.

Relying heavily on the Division Bench decision in M/s Jugmug Electric and Radio Co. v. M/s Telerad Private Ltd., the court observed that it is common for reputed firms to manufacture both televisions and other domestic appliances, and customers generally associate such firms with a range of electrical goods. This commonality in manufacturing and marketing channels creates a likelihood of confusion.

The court also considered that the defendants were previously dealers of the plaintiff's televisions and continued to sell televisions of other brands alongside the domestic appliances under the "Choice" name, reinforcing the proximity in the trade channel.

Regarding the plaintiff's short period of use (three years), the court held that this does not preclude acquiring reputation or entitlement to relief, especially given the volume of sales and advertising demonstrated. The court found it significant that the defendants adopted the "Choice" name for domestic appliances after dealing in the plaintiff's televisions, suggesting intent to benefit from the plaintiff's goodwill.

Consequently, the court granted an interim injunction restraining the defendants from selling the specified goods under the name "Choice," except for sewing machines, pressure cookers, and water filters (non-electrical items), and prohibited use of a similar logo for those three items pending final disposal of the suit. The court clarified that its opinion was tentative and did not prejudice the defendants' case at trial.

Holding and Implications

The court granted an interim injunction restraining the defendants from using the trade name "Choice" and a similar logo for all the specified domestic appliances except sewing machines, pressure cookers, and water filters pending final disposal of the suit.

The direct effect is that the defendants are temporarily prohibited from passing off their goods as those of the plaintiff in respect of most domestic appliances. The court’s order is cautious and does not set a final precedent, expressly reserving the defendants’ rights at trial. No absolute monopoly was granted given the unregistered status of the plaintiff's mark and the limited scope of the injunction.

    Creative Handicrafts v. Sedana Electric Company

    B.N. Kirpal, J:

    This order will dispose of plaintiff's application under Order 39 rules1 and 2 for an injunction restraining the defendants from using the name CHOICE in respect of the articles which are being sold by the defendants.

    Briefly stated, the allegations of the plaintiff are that the plaintiff is manufacturing television sets and marketing them under the trade mark of CHOICE. It is further alleged that sometime in 1986 the defendants were appointed as dealer of the plaintiff and the defendants were also selling those sets. This agency now seems to have been terminated.

    The grievance of the plaintiff is that the defendants have advertised and are selling some other appliances under the trade name of “Choice”. These appliances are sewing machine, fans and electric iron, geysers, washing machine, water filter, hot plates and room coolers. According to the plaintiff the said goods which are being sold by the defendants belong to the same trading channel as that of the plaintiff and, therefore, an injunction should be issued as the defendants are likely to pass off the said goods as the goods manufactured by the plaintiff. It is further the case of the plaintiff that an advertisement has been inserted by the defendants using an identical logo to that of the plaintiff. In that advertisement the letter 'O' is represented by a somewhat round. T.V. Screen and this is stated to be a letter which has been devised by the plaintiff and is one which the defendants cannot use.

    The defendants have contended that the use of the logo, similar to the one of the plaintiff, was a mistake of the advertising agent and this mistake has been corrected and the defendants have no intention of using the logo similar to that of the plaintiff. The defendants, therefore, do not object to an injunction being issued restraining the defendants from using the logo of Choice similar to that of the plaintiff.

    It is, however, contented on behalf of the defendants that this is not a case where an interim injunction can be granted. It is submitted by Shri Mangla that two sets of goods in the present case, namely, the televisions manufactured by the plaintiff and the appliances, which are being sold by the defendants cannot be regarded as allied or cognate. The second submission of the learned counsel for the defendants is that the plaintiff has been in business only for 3 years and its user is not sufficiently long as to give it an exclusive use. It is further submitted that the television, which is manufactured by the plaintiff, falls under class 9 of the Trade Mark Rules, Schedule IV while sewing machine falls under class 7, hot plates etc. under class II and other domestic appliances fall under class 21. According to the learned counsel for the defendants, the trade mark of the plaintiff is not registered and it cannot get an absolute monopoly of the said mark. It is further submitted that at best it can get a monopoly or a restraint order only with regard to the class of goods which fall in class 9.

    A large number of cases have been cited by the plaintiff and the defendants in respect of their rival contentions. The plaintiff has cited cases to show that goods which do not, in the first flush, appear to be similar have been held to fall under the same trade channel. Some of the cases are (1979) R.P.C. 19, AIR 1983 Punjab & Haryana 418, AIR 1985 Allahabad 242, (1973) R.P.C. 560 and (1975) R.P.C. 171.

    On behalf of the defendants, my attention has been drawn to some of the orders passed by this Court in an effort to show that the goods in question do not fall in the same trading channel. The learned counsel has relied upon the order of R.N. Aggarwal, J.(as he then was) passed in suit No. 1310 of 1981 decided on 28th January, 1982. United Brothers v. United Traders. I.A. No. 3927 of 1981. In that case the plaintiff's were manufacturing aluminium hollow-ware utensils like tiffin boxes etc., while the defendants were manufacturing spoons, forks and knives and this Court held that the goods manufactured by the two parties were not allied goods. Reliance was also placed on 1988 P.T.C. 98 were a single Judge of this Court held that the fluorescent tube or lamp was a distinct commodity from choke which was used. In Hindustan Pencils Private Ltd. v. Prem Chand Gupta, 1985 P.T.C. 33, this court had held that pencils, sharpeners, erasers, etc. which were the products of the petitioner therein and the respondent's products, namely, mathematical instruments and water colours were not goods of the same description. Reliance was also placed by the learned counsel on Nestle's Products Ltd. v. Durex Products Milk made Corpn. and another, AIR 1947 Delhi – 43. London Rubber Co. Ltd. v. Durex Products Incorporated and another, AIR 1963 S.C. 188 and M/s. Parry and Co. Ltd. Madras v. M/s Perry and Co. Usilampati Madurai AIR 1963 Madras 460, and it was contended that it was necessary that the goods in question should be of the same category or of the same nature before any injunction can be issued.

    This is a case where the mark of the plaintiff is not registered under the Trade Marks Act. The plaintiff, therefore, is unable to invoke the provisions of Section 9 of the Trade Marks Act. The action which has been initiated by the plaintiff has to be dealt with under the head of passing off. If the goods manufactured by the defendants are likely to cause confusion and deception and are likely to be regarded as the goods which have been manufactured by the plaintiff then in an action under the head

    "passing off, the plaintiff would be entitled to an injunction against the defendant. In order to maintain an action for passing off it is not relevant, and it has been so, held in 6 R.P.C. 318, as to be seen is whether the respective goods fall under the same or different classes. What is whether the types of goods which are sold belong to the same category or are in the same trading channel or are allied products? In the present case what is being manufactured by the defendants are domestic appliances. These domestic appliances are non-electrical as well as electrical. Sewing machine, water filters, pressure cookers are non-electrical appliances while geysers, washing machines, hot plates etc. are electrical appliances. While sewing machine falls under a class different from hot plate under Schedule IV of the Trade Mark Rules, nevertheless goods belonging to different classes are being manufactured and sold by the defendant under the same trade name, namely, Choice. This trend to lend support to the contention of the plaintiff that even though goods may fall under different classes but they are in same trading channel and can cause confusion and deception to pass off as the goods of the plaintiff. In this connection reference has to be made, in some detail, to a Division Bench decision of this Court in the case of M/s Jugmug Electric and Radio Co. v. M/s Telerad Private Ltd. 1. JLR (1978) I Delhi 667. In that case the respondent-therein was manufacturing television sets while the petitioner was manufacturing domestic appliances. The television sets which were manufactured were covered by class 9 while domestic appliances which were being manufactured by the petitioner therein fell under class 11. The question arose whether the trade mark authorities were right in cancelling the registration of the petitioner's trade mark Telerad. It was not in dispute that the respondent therein was the registered owner of the trade mark Telerad in respect of televisions. The contention of the respondent in that case was that confusion or deception in the minds of the customers was likely to be caused because the goods of the appellant and those of the respondent have the same trade channel and were even sold in the same shops. This Court accepted the contentions of the respondent and observed as under :"

    “Firstly, the affidavit of Mr. Todi filed in favour of the respondent shows that many well known firms like GEC, TELEFUNKEN, PHILIPS, SIEMENS, HGEC, NATIONAL, GE , and REMCO manufacture not only radios but other domestic appliances like heaters, irons, toasters, etc. This fact is so well known over the years that even judicial notice can be taken of them. There is absolutely no rebuttal of it by the appellant. It is true that the respondent has not extended its manufacturing activity beyond the radios and television sets to include domestic appliances. But the respondent is also a well known firm of Sarabhais. If the above mentioned well known firms could manufacture both the radios as well as domestic appliances, the impression carried by customers would be that such big firms are capable of manufacturing both the kinds of goods. The respondent being such a firm, the customers can have the same impression about it as they have about the above-mentioned firms. The first source of confusion or deception which is, therefore, not only likely but very probably springs from the fact that manufacture of both these types of goods is often done by the same firms. The reason is oblivious. They both involve electric engineering and technology. ”It is true that wireless is one branch of the said technology while the domestic appliances which use electric wires is another branch of it. Such theoretical difference however, is not shown to be material by the very fact that in practice most of the reputed electrical manufacturer in India have chosen to manufacture both kinds of goods. Obiviously, the theoretical difference between the two types of goods is no barrier for one firm to manufacture both of them. On the contrary, there must be similarities and other economies and conveniences which have persuaded these firms to manufacture both the kinds of goods instead of sticking only to one kind of them”.

    "Another circumstance which was taken into consideration by the Division Bench was that the electrical goods shop will sell not only domestic appliances falling under class 11 but also sell radios and television sets falling under class 9. It, therefore, came to conclusion that there was proximity of goods of both the parties in respect of the trade channel. Similar is the case here. It is an admitted fact that the respondent herein was not only selling domestic appliances but was also selling the televisions manufactured by the plaintiff. Even now as per the documents produced on record by the defendants show that they are still selling televisions manufactured by Weston, Beltek and Telerad. After considering the decisions which were cited before it, the Division Bench in Jugmug's case (supra) finally concluded as under :"

    "We have considered the strong relevance of the nature of the trade marks in the relevant case. The class of customers are ordinary people who are not well versed in the specific information as to what is manufactured by the respondent and what is not manufactured by it. These customers go by the general impression that electrical manufacturer often manufacture both the types of goods and dealers sell both of them together. This leads to the impression which is formed by the customers by a confusion or deception taking place in their minds. We have also considered the trade channel and how it is common to both these types of goods. We have shown that the connection between the two is both at the manufacturing and at the marketing stages. Almost all the factors which are relevant for consideration under Section 11(a) are, therefore, present in this case."

    The aforesaid circumstance is present in the present case also. The goods which are manufactured by the defendants are both electrical and non-electrical but they are domestic appliances and they are sold along side television sets. It is not unknown, and in fact it is quite common, for firms and companies manufacturing television sets to also manufacture other domestic appliances like heaters, iron, toasters etc. This is an example which has been given by the Division Bench and which has been quoted herein above. A television has now become as much a domestic appliance as a cooler. It is true that some of the goods manufactured and sold by the defendants under the name and style of 'Choice' are not electrical goods meant for domestic use.

    It is true that the plaintiff has been in business possibly only for three years but that by itself, cannot be a ground for disentitling it to the relief if it was otherwise entitled to. Even according to the counsel for the defendant the plaintiff had sold, in the last three years, about 12,000 television sets the price of those would be more than Rs. 1 crore. It is further the case of the plaintiff, and it has produced documents in support thereof, that it has widely advertised its television sets in the market. Even in a period of three years, it can be safely inferred, the plaintiff has acquired a reputation in the market which is reflected in its sales. The defendant was a dealer of the plaintiff and it does not appear to be an accident that the defendant has chosen to adopt the trade name “Choice” with respect to the domestic appliances after it had started selling the television sets hearing the brand name “Choice”.

    Following the ratio of the Division Bench in Jugmug's case (Supra). I therefore, issue an injunction restraining the defendants from selling the aforesaid goods except sewing machines, pressure cookers and water filters (which are all non-electrical items) under the name and style of “Choice” pending disposal of the suit. The defendants are further restrained from using the logo “Choice” similar to one of the plaintiff with respect to the aforesaid three items, namely, sewing machines, water filters and pressure cookers. Any opinion expressed in this order is only tentative and will not in any way prejudice the defendants at any stage.

    I.A. stands disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Creative Handicrafts v. Sedana Electric Company
    (Jul 19, 1988)